Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics in the tech and business world, including the new version of ChatGPT, Facebook's advertising policies, the streaming wars, and the beauty industry.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
Host
A lot of people do not like the new version of ChatGPT. They hate it so much that OpenAI brought back the old version to please them. This week on The Vergecast, we give our take now that we've had a week to try GPT-5 in the wild. And we tried vibe coding, and it did not go very well. Plus, Gen 2E talked to a man whose smart home products stopped working. So he did what anybody would do: bought the company that made them. That's this week on The Vergecast.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
And Cara, this is very exciting. Kara has gone Hollywood.
Scott Galloway
That's right. Kara made her TV appearance, and you guessed it. She was the Baby Yoda on The Mandalorian.
Kara Swisher
No, no, no, no. It's my third appearance on the TV show Silicon Valley. And again, once again, I suspect I probably should win the Emmy for it. But I was again on stage for Silicon Valley, the TV show. Do we have a clip? I think we do. Go ahead.
[Clip from Silicon Valley plays]:
Character
I'm now using the touch as a means to communicate friendship.
Hey, is that Kara Swisher? What are you guys doing in there?
We are uplifting each other while we plan our annual Women in Tech Empowerment Panel. Kara's moderating.
Oh, my God. Is that Susan? Susan Wojcicki from YouTube. Don't point. It's unseemly.
Kara Swisher
That is... you know what? So I got to be honest. Most of the time, when you tell me about the stuff you do, I have serious Jomo. Do you know what Jomo is?
Scott Galloway
No.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God. Who do I want to know? Joy of missing out. Most of the shit you do, I think, "Oh, my God, I feel so much better about my life that I don't have to do that shit." This was serious FOMO, though. This was very cool. They gave you a... I mean, you were actually in the show. You had lines. There's another scene later where I'm actually interviewing her about her company. It was all about sex-positive feminism. It was really funny.
Scott Galloway
Sex-positive feminism? What the fuck is that? Sex-positive feminism? Well, it's sex... it's an app for women. Is there anything a sex negativism? What is that?
Kara Swisher
Oh, no. But it was funny. You'll see. It's very fun. It's adorable. It was nice. It's well done. It was nice. And what? I am on another episode. I'm sorry to tell you. I'm not going to tell you.
Scott Galloway
You're on another episode? So in terms of expectations around those of us who've never been on an HBO show, did it meet, not meet, exceed your expectations?
Kara Swisher
It was fantastic. I love Alex Berg and Mike Judge, and I like the whole team there. And also, the food is great, let me just say. And I had a trailer. That's the key. I had a really nice trailer. Eric Anderson went with me.
Scott Galloway
Did she?
Kara Swisher
And we hung in the trailer with all the other celebrities. It was fun.
Scott Galloway
And who's the nicest? Give me the most. I want some, like, Page Six gossip here. Who is the least like their character and the most like their character based on your limited impressions?
Kara Swisher
Well, Susan Cryer, who plays Lori Bream, is not like that. She's just delightful and witty and funny. And she does a perfect job channeling either it's Marissa Mayer mixed with Mark Zuckerberg mixed with all of them. And I think she's really... they're all great. I've interviewed... I've actually... every year that they've had a premiere, I've done an interview with the cast, a lot of the cast. And so I think they're all wonderful. The particular one is the guy... I can't... I'm blanking on his name. He plays the assistant, Jared. He's amazing. He's very good. He's amazing as a person. And in person, he's so funny.
But they're all great. He was in Veep. The other... the best-written show on TV. He was in Veep. He played... I forget. He played the boyfriend of... he's been in a bunch of stuff. In any case, they're all great. I think they're all great. I don't think there's anyone on it... I don't think that I've met that it hasn't been great. They're every one of them. Listen, this episode was actually written by Daisy Gardner. It was actually an all-female directing cast. Everything else was great there. Who told Eric America that she listened to Rico Dico to inspire her scripts. So shout out to you, Daisy.
Thanks for writing this hilarious episode.
Scott Galloway
Maybe you'll get on a show someday. You want to be on The Mandalorian, but like...
Kara Swisher
Don't even say that. Don't even say that.
Scott Galloway
We might get you on a Mandalorian.
Kara Swisher
There you go again. Promise me stuff. You're literally like a 60-year-old man trying to seduce some 30-year-old impressionable person with all these false promises. I just don't buy it. I just don't buy it. Yes. Anyway, let's get down to business. There's so much news happening. There's a lot going on here, Carol. So much news.
Scott Galloway
Now, all my colleagues at Recode were at Code Media in L.A. this week. A ton of information from Tig Notaro to John Stanky of AT&T took the stage. And there was one particular interview with Carolyn Everson. She's the vice president of Global Marketing Solutions, whatever that is, at Facebook. And she told them that the government should regulate ads and not companies. And she said that Facebook was probably not going to do anything from their stance and then walked it back 12 minutes later in another interview. But let's play this tape.
[Clip of Carolyn Everson plays]:
Carolyn Everson
We really believe that Washington, D.C. needs to put regulation. As a citizen, and I'm sure you want this too, probably everybody in this audience, we'd like to know that the ads we see from our political candidates are truthful. That's really important for democracy.
Interviewer
You want the government deciding what's truthful and not you guys.
Carolyn Everson
We think there should be regulation. We do not think Facebook should be choosing what is true or not.
Kara Swisher
All right. So in the interim of that, Google, following in Twitter's steps, decided to put in some more less targeting, no targeting, and will take out really egregiously false ads. Not sort of bloviating ads, but anyway. So Google's now moving in what you call... what do you call it, Mr. Galloway, Professor Galloway?
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I'm drawing a blank. What have I said?
Kara Swisher
White hat.
Scott Galloway
Oh, they're starching their hat white. Yeah. But it's kind of like you said, they've starched it kind of an off-white here. It's not the full starch. It's not Twitter. It's not a ban.
Kara Swisher
That's right. But still, you know, the best thing that happened to Google was Facebook providing cloud cover because all of a sudden they're no longer the bad kid. I mean, it's literally Facebook's kind of... you know, most wanted number one kind of in that statement. I mean, you know, you had when you said, "Well, I'm sure people here would like to see truthful ads, but want the government to regulate it." And I would bet the majority of people in the office... well, no, actually, media companies, probably if they can screen out blatantly false content, we'd probably be down with that, too. So they're in a corner because what they're saying is inconsistent. It makes no sense. And they're kind of isolated and alone and basically trying to... it's difficult. It's difficult to put lipstick on this pig because it just makes no sense what their stated policy is.
Scott Galloway
And you've predicted that they're not going to ban them, but they're going to alter it.
Kara Swisher
Alter it, which is what I thought Google was going to do, which is what they do, because now I'm the prediction queen here.
Scott Galloway
You're just the queen. You are just the queen.
Kara Swisher
What's interesting about Google is, look, they've got YouTube, which is more like a TV business, right? It's more akin to a TV business than anything else. And then they've got search, which you've got to search on things to get them. So they're not in the micro-targeting business the way Facebook is. That said, Google compared to Twitter is a big player here. And the question is how much pressure it's going to put on Facebook to do something else besides nothing. And what's interesting is that then the Trump people tweeted lobbying Facebook against changing the way it's targeting because the Trump campaign loves it. And so Brad Parcell is probably sweating in his Levi's about this situation. But it's going to be really problematic because they're being buffeted by the Trump campaign on one hand and by what Google and Twitter have done on the other.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's... the weird thing though is that we are in sort of our... a little bit of our bubble and we read the media every day and we say, "OK, there's a lot of pressure on Facebook." But it's difficult to bring pressure to bear on a monopoly because there's very little downside. And if you look at some of the things that Facebook's done and then what's happened to them, if you look at their stock price, if you look at the fact that the CEO and the COO still have their jobs, I mean, they're really at the end of the day, we think there's pressure on them. But none of this pressure has resulted in anything tangibly bad happening to the company. There's been some fines that are like parking tickets.
Kara Swisher
What's that? I think they're going to change. I think they're going to do something different. I think they're keeping their options open. What Facebook has to do is there's got to be 26 disasters and then they move. And I think that's really what it is. But I don't think they like being in this position. That said, Mark was at dinner with Trump as there just was revealed because they don't keep logs in the White House anymore that Mark had dinner with Peter Thiel and Trump when he was here. That time he gave his idiotic free speech speech. And so he's... you know, they're trying to play it both ways in that regard.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's... in the tech executives, Tim Cook got a lot of grief, and I know that... I don't know how you feel about Tim Cook's role in it, but these corporate leaders...
Kara Swisher
Bad leaders.
Scott Galloway
But they're sort of in an impossible position because if they in any way... what Tim Cook, in my opinion, has done that's been incredible is his ability to somehow thread the needle between she and Trump and not offend people and figure out a way to still remain, in my view, a principled person who appears to want to do the right thing and does the right thing. And still maintain anything resembling a productive working relationship with the president. And when you're the most valuable company in the world and you're a U.S.-based company, you want to maintain a good relationship with the administration. I thought the media was kind of unfairly harsh on Tim Cook.
Kara Swisher
You feel like he should have behaved differently?
Scott Galloway
No, not this one. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Look, this is what I tweeted. Trump tweeted out, "Today, I opened a major Apple manufacturing plant in Texas that will bring high-paying jobs back to America. Today. Nancy Pelosi closed Congress because she doesn't care about American workers." This is a lie. This is a major lie. There's no opening of a major Apple manufacturing plant in Texas. This is what's happening. They toured a plant that's been in operation making Macs since 2013. They toured that plant. It's not even an Apple company, by the way. It's a company called Flex. It used to be called Flextronics. So they didn't open anything.
Apple is working on expanding its campus in Austin to a larger campus. Yes, they are. It will have no manufacturing. And obviously there's going to be more jobs there, but it's not even close to this tweet. And then the Trump campaign turned it into a campaign ad with a lie, and Tim said nothing. This is just... look, when he gets called Tim Apple, I get it. And this is what I wrote. This is completely false. I get that Tim Cook did not correct the Tim Apple thing, pointing out someone being addled is awkward, but this is different. It's a plant run by a company called Flex. It's been manufacturing since 2013.
If Apple will not say so, I will. This is a lie. And I don't know what deal he's getting in response, but it's pretty much of a shocker to a lot of people to do this. I get the idea of having dinner with him. I get having to be nice to him. But to be part and parcel to a lie that becomes a lying campaign ad that I guess you then run on Facebook is gross. It's just gross.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know what he wants. What he wants is exemption from tariffs that are going to take his stock price tangibly down. But, look, the good news is that Carolyn Everson believes that Apple shouldn't be responsible for checking its own lies. It should be the government regulating them. That was a joke, Cara. That was good humor.
Kara Swisher
Anyways. In any case, it's a mess. I just think there's a point where you kiss up to people and then there's a point where you don't kiss up to people. I think people who use Apple, I was surprised at this level of lying. And you know silence is annoying enough, but allowing this kind of lie to go on under the corporate name is... I'm surprised, I have to say.
Scott Galloway
But if they ran the ad on Facebook, then the government... it... Trump that should be regulating the lies of his own making.
Kara Swisher
I know, I know. It's a mess, it's a mess. But the whole point is that we've gotten used to these lies, like lies are okay. And arguing... and I've got all these imbeciles on Twitter going, "They're investing a billion dollars, Trump is right." I'm like, no, he's not. And by the way, if you want to give credit, give it to Rick Perry or whoever was governor of Texas at the time and Obama because it was 2013. It's just... and by the way, politicians don't matter in these decisions these companies make. If they need to manufacture in China, they will. If they need to do it here for some political reason, they'll do it. It has nothing to do with these politicians. Most of this stuff has nothing to do with politicians.
Scott Galloway
I agree, except for AOC and state senator Gianaris that saved New York taxpayers $3 billion by telling the wealthiest man in the world to put his hand back in his pocket. I think actually they did have an impact. And also, you talk a little bit about code media. Code media was a lot. A lot happened. And John Stanky, the CEO of Warner Media, he says HBO Max wants to be the next cable bundle, not the next Netflix. Let's listen to his tape.
[Clip of John Stanky plays]:
John Stanky
I would fully expect that the platform at some point in time is a platform that we allow others to bring content into. I don't think, from my point of view, we're ever going to have a lock or a monopoly on creativity. And I think there's been a number of articles actually written the last couple weeks about the frustration and the fragmentation of the bundle and what's going to happen. We're basically unbundling to rebundle. At some point, there will be platforms that re-aggregate and rebundle. And we'd like the platform ultimately to be a place where re-aggregation occurs. And that doesn't just mean our content.
Kara Swisher
Scott, your Rundle idea is catching on with John Stanky, who has a very deep voice, by the way, CEO of WarnerMedia. The Rundle, Scott, what do you think? There's too many things out there? What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Well, I actually think this will be the brand disaster move of 2020. And I think what Mr. Stanky...
Kara Swisher
Explain yourself.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay. So HBO has 23% of their shows rated higher than 7.5 on IMDb versus just 6% for Amazon Prime or 10% for Netflix. If you look at the amount of Emmys that HBO has won, it won 34 last year, which is more than Netflix and Amazon almost combined. And what you have here is an incredible culture that has created the equivalent of a luxury brand. And I mean, it's some more data here. So if you were to take the monthly fee of these bundles and then divide it by the billions of dollars we're spending on original content, basically what HBO has been able to do is nothing short of remarkable. And that is that for basically for $7.
50, HBO gives you a billion dollars worth of original content. And despite charging you more, in other words, it's the worst value versus Apple TV, you only have to spend 80 cents a month as a consumer to get a billion dollars in original content. With Netflix, you have to spend 90 cents, Prime Video, $1.30. HBO charges you $7.50. Despite this, HBO continues to produce the best content. So HBO is the equivalent of a Birkin bag. And what Stanky's deciding to do by trying to go more mass and layer in all this kind of mediocre content from Warner is he said, "I know we're Birkin. We're a luxury brand.
We have the best highest margin company or creative machine in the world. We have artisans in the form of content creators. And we're going to turn it into fucking Coach and then Walmart." This is literally... what other brand has done that? Can you recall a brand that's gone...
Kara Swisher
That's a great... there's a bunch of brands that have done that, gone too cheap, right?
Scott Galloway
Well, I mean...
Kara Swisher
Tiffany, I guess.
Scott Galloway
There's a lot... I mean, Cartier, when they started putting their names on Lincoln Town Cars, but then they got it back and have made an incredible brand. It's much easier to go downhill, but then there's no going back. And the bottom line is they can't compete with the deep pockets of Netflix or Apple TV. So this is literally John Stanky taking a Birkin bag down to a Coach bag down to a Brooklyn Messenger bag. It's just the worst strategy in the world. They can't compete with the deep pockets of Netflix and Apple TV+. They only have about 200 original shows or 200 shows on their platform versus 2,000 on Netflix and Amazon. So they can't go toe-to-toe with these guys. They had to stay... they shouldn't.
Kara Swisher
And they shouldn't. And Disney, too. 100%. And don't you, when you hear a show that's from HBO, don't you naturally assume in the back of your mind, it's probably going to be better and you're more willing to trial it. Except now... it was interesting. I was on an airplane yesterday and, you know, Fleabag is from what, Amazon?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Amazon.
Kara Swisher
I forget. I don't even know. Fleabag is from Amazon. Maisel is from Amazon, which I watch. I'm trying to think of the things I watch. Homeland is from Showtime.
Scott Galloway
Showtime, yeah.
Kara Swisher
I don't think of HBO as the only place for great stuff, although there's great stuff on it, right? Let me just be clear. There's tons of great stuff on there. But others have started to make great stuff.
Scott Galloway
100 percent. Like HBO-worthy stuff.
Kara Swisher
So I don't know if they have the market on that anymore. But they don't have any choice. And with Richard Plepler gone.
Scott Galloway
They don't have any choice. They have to have fewer programs but better programs, and they have to maintain. The only asset they have, they can't go toe-to-toe in terms of capital and armaments and spending against these deeper-pocketed players. The only strategy they have is to maintain 100% succession. Think about it. Oh, my God. Sopranos, Six Feet Under. The best show that nobody ever watched, The Wire. Hank on Larry Sanders. This company has the secret sauce of being able to produce amazing content on a fraction of the budget. They're a luxury brand, and they've decided, "Oh, no, we're not going to be a luxury brand. We're going to be Walmart and Target." And by the way, that market is covered like crazy with cheap tackle. So the worst brand decision of 2020 was the decision for AT&T to basically trash their positioning as a luxury brand in the content arena and move into the mass market. It is not going to work. It's going to result in one of the largest corporate write-downs.
Kara Swisher
That's a good prediction. I think you're 100% right on that. And I think other people are moving into the luxury space and they're taking their eye off the ball. But, you know, AT&T is a mass brand and they don't know how to own something that's fancy. People want to see Kara Swisher on Silicon Valley. They don't want to see the dog on a bunch of like Big Bang Theory on HBO. They want the high-end stuff. Anyways, I'm joining on.
Scott Galloway
Okay, Scott, we're going to take a quick break. We'll be right back after this with Friends of Pivot. We've got listener mail. We've got predictions. We've got wins and losses. We've got a lot to go. We'll be back in a minute.
[Ad Break]:
Kara Swisher
All right. So here's the deal. Take a Steelers captain who's been bleeding black and gold and playing for the Steelers for over a decade. That's me. Cam Hayward. Add in football minds who live and breathe this game. And you get Not Just Football with Cam Hayward, a weekly podcast where we break down the sport we all live for. We talk about what's really happening in the league. Sit down with players you know and respect and shine a light on the moments that don't make the highlight reels. Whether it's the season predictions, sharing what it's really like in the locker room, or diving into the real stories behind the headlines, we've got it all. This podcast is about having fun and giving fans an inside look at what makes football incredible. Catch Not Just Football with Cam Hayward on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Like, subscribe, follow, all that good stuff. Let's get after it.
Scott Galloway
Welcome back to Pivot. All right, Scott, we're going to hear from a friend. We have a friend of Pivot. That's a new thing. FOP. FOP. FOP. Okay, FOP. She's Arielle Duhaime-Ross, the host of Vox's podcast Reset, where she covers stories for people who want to hear what's behind new tech developments and policies. So go to tape.
[Clip of Arielle Duhaime-Ross plays]:
Arielle Duhaime-Ross
This week on Reset, we're doing an episode on sharenting, which is basically what happens when parents share information about their kids online. So while I was working on this episode, one of the things that I learned was that even when parents announce the birth of their child online, they tend to give the specific date. And that can actually be a problem because that makes it more likely that your kid's identity will be stolen. I know both of you like to talk about your kids on the show and on social media. And Kara, you just had a baby. Congrats on that, by the way. So I'm curious, especially going into the holiday season and when parents are posting lots of pictures of their kids online, how do you decide what to share on the Internet about your children? Thanks, guys.
Kara Swisher
It's a really thoughtful question. You go first.
Scott Galloway
Am I in trouble? I got in trouble this week with my 14-year-old because I sharent it. I'm a sharent. There's no way around it. I'm terrible. I am a terrible.
Kara Swisher
And do they get upset? They don't like it?
Scott Galloway
Well, the older one doesn't care.
Kara Swisher
Is he about to get upset with what you're about to say?
Scott Galloway
Well, no. Yeah, the older one doesn't care. It doesn't seem to care. It seems fine when he doesn't care. But the other one, he was furious at me because I shared a picture of him holding his new sister. He doesn't mind. It was fascinating. He doesn't mind me necessarily sharing, but now I have to check with him if the pictures are good, which is totally fair. And secondly, he wanted me to tag him, but not always. And so I realize I am a sharent, and I'm doing the same thing. I don't know. It's a good debate to have, and it's a really important topic because I just... I don't have anything to stand on. What do you think, Scott?
I'm just a bad sharent. No, you know what? I have what I'll call no moral clarity around this issue. And that is initially I turned my Instagram account private and I don't accept new users because I have pictures of my kids. And it feels... it just feels private. And it feels like that should be one area of your life that is just that, is private and you keep it sort of precious and special and unique. But I also write a lot about my children in my blog post numbers, malice, but I try to refer to them in the generic of my oldest and my youngest. I did publish a picture of my youngest. And then afterwards I thought I probably shouldn't be publishing pictures of them until their age of consent. And I talk about them on this podcast a lot, but sometimes I think, is that performative? Am I trying to be more likable by showing these incredibly... we all think our kids are special and wonderful and they are. And I wonder, am I doing that to make a point or because I want to be more likable? So my kind of move right now is I've decided I'm going to be performative and pimp my dogs. I'm going to not try and talk less about my kids and talk more about the dogs.
Kara Swisher
Did those dogs give consent? I'm not sure.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. Such joy. Zoe the Vichla, and now we have the Puerto Rican rescue hound gangster. And he's doing very well. He's doing very well.
Kara Swisher
You and George Conway with your dogs. What the hell? It's a really interesting topic. You should listen to this show. So, but I think it's something you have to think about a lot. Again, my son Louie, I've talked about their names, has been on the podcast, and he's very voluble and likes to do it. And the other one, I'm not going to say his name because he doesn't want me to. Or maybe he does. I don't know. Things change every day. But it's a really big issue, and people should listen to this topic because it's a big issue. Between being called a sharent, screenager, that's the other name my kid has for me, and an okay boomer. It's been a great time at home. Anyway, let's take a listener question now about another topic sort of related to kids. It's a topic that I think about a lot. Juul gets sued. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
This week's Pivot listener mail comes from Owen Libby. He's from Manhattan, New York. He's wondering, is Altria's investment in Juul the worst corporate investment of all time? A little background. California and New York formally sued Juul earlier this week for allegedly targeting teens toward flavored nicotine with their marketing. So he's wondering because you both have kids whether you have any vaping testimony yourself, whether you have any thoughts on this area in general. Thanks, Owen.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I have thoughts. What are your thoughts, Kara?
I think they're just the worst. The worst. The worst. If you have teens, I don't think your kids are a little younger. It's just completely targeted toward them. It's as bad as old cigarette marketing. I own so many Juuls. Like I've taken them from my oldest kid and I just think it's awful. I think the way they're doing this, I think it's dangerous. I think some of these – I think probably the dangers are probably slightly overhyped by the media. But nonetheless, it's just like smoking as far as I'm concerned. And I think the marketing is what really drives me crazy. The flavor, the – it's so aimed at young people. And I do think it's the worst investment from Altria. And I think those people walked out with a whole bunch of – they're sort of like the WeWork people, just walked out after perpetrating what is essentially a really dangerous product.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. Yeah. So I have, again, no moral clarity here. Full disclosure, I'm an investor in the space. Tobacco had a strangle-like hold on my household, took my mother's life. And I think that the fast – and I'm not making in any way a health claim here. This is just a pure thesis or opinion of my view. But if we were to give an e-cigarette to every smoker over the age of 25 and reduce the number of tobacco smokers 10 percent a year, I think we would save more lives or we could save five to seven million lives. And at the same time, the outrage over the youth problem, I think, is justified.
I think your concerns are justified. The question around whether or not it was the biggest kind of corporate blunder from just a purely financial standpoint, it's not even close. The Altria invested $13 billion for a one-third stake, valuing the company at about $40 billion. It rose to $50 billion. Let's say that's been cut in half or even say they've lost $6 to $10 billion. Time Warner bought AOL for about $163 billion. And then, you know, fast forward 15 years later, AOL and Yahoo got sold for $5 billion. Google bought Motorola for, I think, $12 or $13 billion and then sold it, I think, for $2 or $3 billion to Lenovo.
Daimler bought Chrysler for $38 billion and then ended up selling it back to private equity after a failed integration for 7 to 10. So this doesn't even make the top 10. There have been a lot more disastrous acquisitions that have been written down by much more than this.
Kara Swisher
Okay, that's true. Fair point, but it's still not a good one. And secondly, let me just say, look, look, the Center for Disease Control has reported over 2,000 lung injury cases and 43 deaths linked to vaping. More than 120 of those people were kids or minors. Altria is a tobacco company, and so they are just trying to keep their nicotine addicts with them. And I just – as a parent, I just – when I see this marketing, it's like mass – and the coolness factor and everything else. It's just – you know, they could – if older people want to ruin their lives by smoking and that's what you do, just so you know, it's – you're sucking on a death stick. You don't point them at kids who are so – at such a point in their lives where, you know, they think they're cool doing them. And then when celebrities – it's like the old cigarette days. And I'm sorry even if they're even slightly healthier. It's just – I just think they acted incredibly badly just on every aspect of them and then tried to put themselves off. Another company that pretended they were a tech company. They're not a tech company. They're a smoking company. So, sorry.
Scott Galloway
Agreed.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. Anyway, we'll move on from that on that note. We need to take one more quick break and we'll be back with wins and fails and predictions.
Ad Break
Okay, we're back. Let's talk about wins and fails. Come on, Scott. What are your wins and fails this week?
Scott Galloway
So my win is, who is my win? My win is Ambassador Yovanovitch.
Kara Swisher
Ah, nice.
Scott Galloway
And I just thought this was, you know, this last week, what the media has been reporting on, that the impact of this was a series of drumbeats that have, in fact, continued to link the president with the criminality that is, you know, the president. But what I found especially encouraging or rewarding about Ambassador Yovanovitch's testimony is that I think it, I don't want to say restores a lot of faith, but I've always felt that we give people in uniform or people in the government who are in what I'd call kind of macho jobs the credit they deserve, but we have a tendency to mock or be somewhat cynical about the people in government who don't carry an M-16 or aren't working as spies, right?
And the reality is we have an incredible army of people who decide to spend their life working for something bigger than themselves to advance our interests overseas and domestically. And Ambassador Yovanovitch, I thought, was on full display in terms of how impressive many of these people are and how fortunate we have. So this is the daughter of parents who fled Nazi Germany, and then the Russians figured out a way to get to Princeton. Then she studied at the Pushkin Institute. Then she received an MS from the National Defense University's National War College. She rose to become the ambassador of Kyrgyzstan and then Armenia.
And then while in Armenia, she was given an award. She went to huge lengths and was hugely successful convincing the Armenian government to release protesters from prison. She was given the Secretary's Diplomacy and Human Rights Award, a department award honoring ambassadors who demonstrate extraordinary commitment to defending human rights. She's been given all sorts of awards. I mean, this is just an incredibly impressive person who had so many options, who didn't go to work for Goldman, didn't go to work for MySpace or a tech company, and decided to serve her country. And then to have, you know, soon-to-be cellmate to Michael Cohen, Rudy Giuliani, show up and basically, you know, disparage her.
It just really—it not only highlighted how corrupt this administration is, but I thought in a very positive way. Incredible people. It demonstrated just how incredibly impressive this army of people overseas are.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they were fantastic. So she's—anyways, Ambassador Yovanovitch— My friend was at the jazz club in D.C. called the Blues Alley, and she did a tape of people giving her a standing ovation. She's a jazz fan. And she was there, and when she walked in, everyone gave her a standing ovation. I think people really want to feel proud of their country, and the attacks on her are reprehensible by the Trump administration. They're reprehensible. And they're backfiring. They're just backfiring. You listen to these people, and the truth has a nice ring to it, and it's just ringing so loud. Everything they say sounds so true.
And by the way, Ambassador Sondland clearly, his lawyer, you know what happened there. His lawyer clearly sat him down and said, I just have one question for you. Do you want to go to jail? And if the answer is no, get your shit straight and tell the truth. Because everybody that's gotten up there thinking that in some perverted source of patriotism and loyalty to the president, lies, misleads, it's like Lady Justice kind of, we thought she might have left the building. She was just grabbing coffee and she is back with a vengeance and it is working. These people, when they now stand in front of Congress, are like, OK, best I tell the truth because people are going to prison.
And it's good to see. It's good to see that our system is working. And people, when they get in front of these committees, are now saying, OK, the best advice you can get is to tell the truth. And he revised his testimony, I think, twice. But it feels like the system – We'll see. It's just like – it feels like we're in an ongoing episode of Star Wars. Like, oh, God, the Empire.
Scott Galloway
Did you say that like it's a bad thing?
Kara Swisher
No, because – Like last episode, there's like seven people from the resistance left. It's like, ah, Jesus. Like, God, these people. They keep on coming. Like, honestly, I just – just from like – even just doing this tweet about Apple. They were like, oh, you're a – you wanted Hillary to post. I'm like, no, I don't want the president to lie and use Apple as an ad. Like, thank you. Just like I'm sorry you have so little – like you have so few abilities not to think lying is OK. I just – I agree with you. I think it was very heartening to listen to that and to listen to all these people. And, you know, Lieutenant Colonel Vindman I thought was great. Weirdly, he looks – my dad was also in the military and he looks a little like my dad and my dad died when I was young. And so I was like so proud of like the idea of – like he wasn't having any of it. You know what I mean? Like he's an immigrant. He came from the former Soviet Union. Just – I thought he was great too. I know we revere military more than other things, but I thought he was exactly what was right about the military. Who's your win?
Scott Galloway
My win. I'm going to go to someone who's not like Ms. Ambassador, the ambassador. Kylie Jenner's cosmetics company being bought by Coty for $600 million.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my gosh.
Scott Galloway
They also own makeup brands, CoverGirl, Max Factor. I think, you know, this was really interesting. The question is what's going to happen to it, but Coty's shares rose 2.6% this week. These independent beauty brands, like not just from Kylie Jenner, but from Rihanna with Fenty, which apparently is very good because people really make up. People always tell me it's really fantastic. I think it's really interesting. And I do think it shows that, look, this is real money. This is real money. The Kardashians, as much as people make fun of them. Kylie Jenner is obviously daughter of Kris Jenner and part of the Kardashian empire. I think it's really interesting that these brands are just being created like this. And I thought that was fascinating. I'm curious what you think. You can bash the Kardashians all you want if you feel like, but I thought it was, it puts some lipstick on this, whatever.
Kara Swisher
So. No, I think, like, I agree with you. I think the Kardashian women or daughters are impressive people, and I think it's easy to be cynical about them, but they've built great businesses. And, like, this was a, it's doing $200 million in revenues. It was actually purchased 51% of the company for $600 million, valuing the company at $1.2 billion. And to a certain extent, it's a victory for social media because the primary asset here wasn't a proprietary skincare line or even a great brand, but her ability to sell $200 million of cosmetics through primarily the Ulta channel using her 160 million followers on Instagram or Twitter. So this notion, what are these independent... You have a few trends, one in the beauty space, which is a wonderful space that is high margin, great for e-commerce, and it's one of the few spaces that hasn't been disrupted by technology or Amazon because brand's important and there's a certain kind of – similar to HBO, there's a culture of creativity at places like Estee Lauder and L'Oreal that continues – Those are the big ones.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. P&G, L'Oreal, Estee Lauder are the big ones. And then you have Clarins. And then P&G looks like the smart company because they sold all their cosmetics line to Coty. And quite frankly, it looks like Coty overpaid for it. Coty's stock was down dramatically. It's come back. But Coty is largely kind of a fragrance and licensing company of celebrity-driven fragrances. But anyways, what this shows is the power of these long-tail brands has incredible power across beauty, hair, hair cosmetics, and skin. And when you have a $200 million company largely built on the back of social media and then distribution through Ulta, valuation of $1.2 billion. I mean, it's just kind of impressive all around and plays on a lot of trends. But I think the big winner here is it shows just how important Instagram is in terms of building a high-margin aspirational product. If Conde Nast had been reinvented or reimagined for a digital age remember how powerful the Conde Nast media company was with Vogue it would look something like Instagram. So Instagram, my thesis is that in 24 months and this is another indication, Instagram will be worth more than the core platform of Facebook.
Kara Swisher
I agree. That's like a prediction. We'll get to that in a minute. But I agree. I agree. I think this is a big win. And I think people like to make – I got a lot of pushback when I said this was fascinating because they love to just keep talking about Kim Kardashian's sex tape years to come. But, look, these people have created a lot of stuff, whether you think the messages about girls are wrong or not. They've done a lot of things that are really interesting. You know, and a lot of these celebrities are using these social media platforms for really interesting stuff. And I think this is one of them in terms of Kylie Jenner. And, you know, someone like The Rock, who I have just been tweeting with back and forth with. I'm trying to get a chance to code.
Scott Galloway
I saw that. The Rock's all over you.
Kara Swisher
The Rock is all over. I love The Rock. What did he call you? He called himself Rock Bundle from you. Did you see that? A rundle, a rock bundle, yeah. I said I'd buy a rock bundle last week. By the way, Dwayne Rock, I'd love someone to compare Dwayne the Rock Johnson to George Clooney. First off, the Rock graduated from college. The Rock has been in all these incredible movies. Basically, we're comparing him to George Clooney about how much more impressive he is than Clooney. The Rock is very impressive. I love The Rock. If I could get The Rock on a podcast or a code, literally, it would be a dream. Someone was like, who's my— You know, by the way, years ago when I was talking to Facebook about who was a real up-and-comer on social media, they said two names, the Kardashians and The Rock. And that was – they said he is just something else on social media. And so I think he's – I can't believe he responded to me. I literally screamed when I saw that. And I just watched Hobbs and Shaw, which I loved, of course. And they – I was really thrilled. And he was great about it. He wants to have a drink. You may come with me to that because I don't drink. So you'll get to drink.
Scott Galloway
Again, more hollow promises. If I get drinks at The Rock, you are coming. And literally you cannot embarrass yourself with me and The Rock. Do you understand? Because I am deeply— This takes me to the ugly place of my dad constantly holding out that rabbit coat. He was going to get my mom that never came. I'm just saying. We never got the rabbit coat. We got a two-bedroom apartment in Encino and mediocre child support. That's where you take me with these hollow promises.
Kara Swisher
The Rock. The Rock. Listen, Dwayne. I love you. You need to come to code or whatever. I will do a podcast with you anywhere, anyplace, anytime. It will be so much fun. We will laugh and laugh and laugh, and then we'll have tequila afterwards.
Scott Galloway
Can you use the rock to put us both on a workout program and let's just see what happens?
Kara Swisher
No. Let's not even try to bother. Okay, your fail. Very quickly. We've got to go because we've got to get to your prediction. You like that?
Scott Galloway
I like that. Oh, my fail is easy. My fail is just the brand strategy blunder, and it will result in what is the erosion. I've had companies that have been acquired, and what you realize is the culture is just so important. And one of the great cultures in all of corporate America and media is the culture at HBO. And you have just an incredibly poor judgment right now that is going to erode the culture that has produced some of the most, for me, some of the most moving content in history. And it's not only the wrong thing to do just in terms of destroying art. It's the stupid thing to do. They can't be Walmart. So my fail is just poor decision-making at HBO going to HBO Max. No one wants Big Bang Theory to junk up The Wire, Six Feet Under, Girls. Richard Plepler is probably just choking.
Kara Swisher
Well, did you hear? Supposedly Apple is eyeing him.
Scott Galloway
Yes, they are.
Kara Swisher
And the deep pockets of Apple, the original content there. They're not eyeing him. He's going to do a deal with them. It makes sense.
Scott Galloway
You think? I mean, that's going to be a formidable. We're talking. We definitely want to know that guy because that's our invite to the Emmys because that guy is going to be accepting a lot.
Kara Swisher
Well, of course you do. Well, Plepler was the PR guy for HBO for years before he became the head of it, and he was in my book. I love that Plepler guy. He's a fantastic, amazing person.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but him on top of a limitless capital and the Apple brand, watch out.
Kara Swisher
I love the Plepler. He's very funny. He's a funny guy. You know Plepler, don't you? I got an email from him asking if we could have lunch, and similar to you, Hollow Promises, another rabid coach. He likes to go—I forget which restaurant he goes to.
Scott Galloway
You've got to go to lunch. I'm going to hook you up with a plepler. I will do that.
Kara Swisher
Here we go again. I love pleplers. More promises. Jesus, you can't help yourself.
Scott Galloway
I'm just telling you, plepler is great. You and a plepler would get along well. He loves to meet interesting people, and you're an interesting—he has dinner parties.
Kara Swisher
And also me.
Scott Galloway
And also me. Yeah. No, but he likes to have interesting people dinner parties in New York, you know, those things where you're sort of on display like a zebra. You'd be perfect. You'd be perfect for that.
Kara Swisher
Huh. I guess. You're like a zebra. Thanks for that. Okay. All right. We're going to get to predictions. My fail, obviously, is Tim Cook and Trump this week. And I don't blame Trump because he lies like he breathes, but Tim Cook should know better. Thank you. Okay, your prediction, and then we got to go.
Scott Galloway
My prediction. So a name you're going to hear more about in 2020, and it's about to become a player in the ecosystem between the intersection of tech and the streaming wars, which I'm just fascinated right now, is Roku.
Kara Swisher
Oh.
Scott Galloway
And Roku now, I believe, has a 38% share of devices for streaming ahead of Amazon, whose Fire Stick, I think, has about a 30% share. And when you look at one of the keys, one of the missing links to Netflix and to Disney Plus is they don't control their distribution. Okay. So their ability to go toe-to-toe with Amazon and Apple streaming offerings that control their own distribution will be their ability to either acquire distribution or build it or the other way, and Roku offers that, or the other way because Roku's stock has skyrocketed. And now as sports, I think about a $15 or $16 billion market cap, you could see a Roku, you could see a man dog bites dog, and you could see Roku go out and start to acquire content. Maybe even a CBS that I think sports about a $13 billion market cap right now. But a bigger name that we're not talking a lot about now in 2020 and a new player in the space, if you will, is Roku.
Kara Swisher
Roku. Okay, that's interesting. You're pulling them out of nowhere. God, not Netflix or anything like that?
Scott Galloway
Well, they either get acquired. They could get acquired by Netflix or potentially Disney that need distribution. Or they, if their stock keeps going up, will use their currency to go acquire a content company. But Roku is going to be in the news either as a seminal acquirer or acquisition in 2020.
Kara Swisher
I think that's really smart. I never even thought about Roku, but you're right.
Scott Galloway
Well, I heard Richard's listening, so I'm trying to impress him.
Kara Swisher
I like that. I like that a lot. I like that concept a lot. But it's interesting, Netflix, I still think, despite the fact that Disney's done a great job with this thing and HBO Max is coming, I still think Netflix got a lot of kick left in it in terms of its programming. I watched, if you can believe it, Let It Snow, which is their Christmas movie. It's trying to sort of be Booksmart but not quite as smart. And I thought I can see why they're doing really well. It was really well done even though it was ridiculous and empty for a rom-com. But it was sort of a mix between Booksmart and Love Actually. So I still think they're really canny as programmers. And so it'll take a lot for others to keep up with how good they are.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know who winners are just based on that is content creators. As evidenced by just an anecdotal or a small data point, Netflix is expanding their creative community and their producers in their content hub in Madrid, Spain from 13,000 people to 25,000 people. So think about Netflix is going to have 20,000, 25,000 people in Madrid producing European content. And it gives you a sense of really it's a wonderful time for kids coming out of college right now if they can be any part of the ecosystem that manages to figure out a way to produce creative, differentiated content. That is a really good wrap right now. The cost of producing a show in the last 12 months, according to Netflix, has gone up 30 to 40 percent, which indicates that everyone from the gaffers to the caterers to the people moving your trailer around are making a lot more money. So this is a growth part of the economy. Get to content. Get to content.
Kara Swisher
Yep, you're right. And speaking of content, I'm going to have a prediction. Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is going to be a huge hit. And Cats is not, even though it's weird looking.
Scott Galloway
Why, you're really going out on a limb there.
Kara Swisher
I know. Listen to me. You and I are going to go see both in a double feature.
Scott Galloway
There we go again. There we go again. Try on this rabbit coat. It's coming.
Kara Swisher
Yes, it's coming. You and I are going to go see Cats and sing along to it.
Scott Galloway
You're literally taking me back to Sears. My dad pulls out his diner's club card. I'm sorry.
Kara Swisher
We're going to go see Cats together. We're going to hold hands. It's going to be great.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. That's what you call Jomo. Joy of missing out.
Kara Swisher
Joy of missing out. Taylor Swift is in Cats. Wendy Leshko gave me that term. Oh, my God. We didn't even talk about Taylor Swift kicking Scott Borchetta or whatever. And Scooter Braun in the place where it hurts. Taylor Swift. Nice. Taylor. What do you got going on this week, Kara? This week? What's the big cat up to? I've got a lot of interviews. I've got a lot of interviews. I'm going up to Boston for Thanksgiving. What are you doing for Thanksgiving?
Scott Galloway
My sister and her family, who I will not be posting on social media or Instagram, will be coming down. Okay. My dad's third wife, my wonderful stepmother, was the first person to ever spoil me. She's Linda, first person. She, like, first person to spoil me, buy me things. She used to send me cookies. And you always love for the rest of your life the first person who spoiled you. I didn't have grandparents, but I had my dad's third wife. Third wife. Thought she couldn't have children. He's on number four, but we think this one's going to stick there.
Kara Swisher
That is a heartwarming family Thanksgiving. Isn't that nice? Isn't that nice? My dad's third wife. She's coming. She's wonderful. What are you thankful for? We've got to go. First person who's spoiled. We've got to go. What are you thankful for?
Scott Galloway
I'm thankful we live in a country that attracts some of the best and brightest that continue to want to serve for us silently and quietly and competently. I'm thankful for ambassadors, the Secret Service, the DMV, and the University of California. I'm thankful for all the wonderful people who've made this incredible experiment as robust as it is.
Kara Swisher
Oh, Scott, that's so good. And your father's third wife.
Scott Galloway
And my dad's third wife. Listen to me. I'm thankful for you, Scott Galloway. Linda, I can't wait to see her. What are you thankful for?
Kara Swisher
I'm thankful for you because you make me look good. Go on. Go on. You make me look good. Someone the other day goes, you know, Scott's really offensive. And I'm like, uh-huh. Well, no shit. And they go, well, do you think that's okay? I'm like, I love it. It's fantastic. It's my favorite part because I can kick him in the teeth. There you go. And then he says something really smart. That's how it works. And then he says something else. But I am thankful for you, and I'd be more thankful if the next time we meet you were dressed in drag. That's what I would be thankful for.
Scott Galloway
That's nice. I'm in.
Kara Swisher
All right. We're going to go see Cats, and you're going to dress like a cat. Rebecca Newman.
Scott Galloway
All right. I'm dressing as Rebecca.
Kara Swisher
All right. Anyway, Scott, we've got to go now. We'll be back next week. We do have to go. With more things. Before we go, I want to big thank you, actually, to all the amazing listener questions and feedback on Twitter in our inbox. Thank you all to Pivot. We love our fans. We have great fans. We've gotten great notes from Mexico, from everywhere around the world who want us to come there. And we are going to go everywhere as long as you buy our drinks. That's how it works for us. Hottest city in the world, Mexico City, hottest city in the world right now. We're going for Formula One. Erica is on it.
She's going to figure it out. They're all going to, and Rebecca, they're going to figure it out for us. Anyway, please keep your questions, requests, suggestions coming into our inbox. Keep telling Scott he's the best on Twitter. We can be reached at pivot at voxmedia.com. Also tweeted us using hashtag pivot podcast. Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Gautam Shrikashen engineered this episode. Eric Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro and Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. And if you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend.
Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.