Main Topic: The podcast episode revolves around the tech industry, focusing on the recent announcements and developments from major players like Facebook, Twitter, and Google.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk. Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC. Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC-insured or SIPC-protected. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPC, a registered broker-dealer.
This episode is brought to you by Amazon Prime. From streaming to shopping, Prime helps you get more out of your passions. So whether you're a fan of true crime or prefer a nail-biting novel from time to time, with services like Prime Video, Amazon Music, and fast, free delivery, Prime makes it easy to get more out of whatever you're into or getting into. Visit Amazon.com slash Prime to learn more.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Rebecca, cue the bad 80s music.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no.
Kara Swisher
That's right, you nose-ringed, bearded, yoga-babble bitch, Jack Dorsey. You take my breath away. I hate Twitter, but I hate it less today. Oh, my God.
Scott Galloway
OMG. Did you see last night? Talk about the massive bitch move. He announces they're no longer doing political advertising.
Kara Swisher
All right, okay. Can we find another one? When I say bitch, I say it in sort of a Jack Dorsey kind of way.
Scott Galloway
I know that, but the ladies don't like it. Let's try to find it. Say gangster. Just call him a gangster.
Kara Swisher
No, no, no, no. Anyways, so he announces this. All right. Literally five minutes into the Facebook earnings call.
Scott Galloway
I know. It was before. It was just before.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, talk about waving your little bird finger in the face of Facebook. He announced it five minutes into their earnings call.
Scott Galloway
I think it was right before. It was enough that they had a chance. So they had a chance they're going to ask about it, right?
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah. Oh, it was perfect. This is a big deal. It was like, I said, coincidence? I hope not. Of course it wasn't a coincidence. Have you? So has anyone called you or have you heard anything?
Scott Galloway
Yes.
Kara Swisher
And be like, what's going on? So say more. Say more.
Scott Galloway
All right. So first of all, happy Halloween. I love Halloween. Do you love Halloween?
Kara Swisher
I do not. I hate it.
Scott Galloway
You hate Halloween?
Kara Swisher
I hate dressing up. I hate costumes. I hate the whole nine frigging yards of it. I hate the whole thing.
Scott Galloway
Wow. I don't get it. I just find it fascinating what people pick to wear. I always found it interesting.
Kara Swisher
I only wear one thing, hair.
Scott Galloway
Hair. Okay. What do you really do? You put on a wig?
Kara Swisher
Oh, God. Any chance to put on hair.
Scott Galloway
You put on a wig?
Kara Swisher
It's awesome.
Scott Galloway
What are you going as?
Kara Swisher
I went as Elvis.
Scott Galloway
What should we go as if we were going?
Kara Swisher
I went as the king.
Scott Galloway
What would be our couple's costume? That's an interesting one.
Kara Swisher
I think we're Cagney and Lacey.
Scott Galloway
Cagney and Lacey. Really? Interesting.
Kara Swisher
I think we should go as Jerry and Ronan on Succession. Anyways, where are we? Okay, Twitter. What happened?
Scott Galloway
Twitter. Okay. All right. So here's the deal. So the people know what exactly happened. Yesterday in the afternoon, in the late afternoon, Jack Dorsey suddenly started tweeting that he was going to stop all political advertising on Twitter. Obviously, Facebook has been dealing, and not so graciously, with the same issues around false political advertising, and in fact, encouraging false political advertising. And last week, in the last two weeks, Mark has been making pretty much a fool of himself in Washington discussing this issue. Earlier this month, Joe Biden's 2020 presidential campaign wrote letters to Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube asking that they don't run false or misleading political ads.
And among other things, Jack pointed out that, quote, "Some might argue our actions today could favor incumbents, but we have witnessed many social movements reach massive scale without any political advertising." They're putting more details out on November 15th, although Vijay Gade, their chief counsel, I suspect, is quite behind this in a big way. It'll start on November 22nd. So here we are. They're just not going to take political advertising. Now, they don't have a lot. They're not the big player in this. Facebook is. But it's a big stake in the sand. And so he did it right then. And I think it came as a shock, I think, to Facebook people.
Well, it's interesting because first you had one of – a key component of Facebook and the Zuck's Kevlar is they were like, OK, we can't all be evil. It was sort of big tech is evil. And then Tim Cook said, I want off this evil train and purposely said actually in an interview with you that I wouldn't put myself in this position and began to disarticulate himself, remove himself, extricate himself. Removing Alex Jones. They were – Apple was the first mover on Alex Jones. And also said we're doubling down on privacy. And be clear, there's big tech and there's Apple, and we're off. We're out. We're no longer having lunch with the mean girls here. And now Jack Dorsey is doing the same thing. He's like, I want out. I want off this big tech train. So it kind of isolates uniquely Facebook. And to a lesser extent, Google is the bad guy. And the argument that Facebook has that's just so indispensable is that letting false ads run rampant creates more discourse, that you should – we should have the opportunity to see who lies to us, recognizing that makes – We're doing you a favor.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But at the same time, two days later – and by the way, we're a platform. And then Campbell Brown, who is kind of the less well-paid, less effective beard to all this bullshit, goes on – She's the head of news.
Scott Galloway
Head of news, former journalist, totally throwing her reputation out the window in exchange for options that are more in the money today because as per our prediction, the stock is up on earnings. But basically said, you don't want a tech platform making these decisions in the midst of announcing that they're launching a new service that they will curate where they're announcing what we will get to see. So when they pay for content, they get to decide what we see and edit it and show some journalistic or editorial discretion. But if you pay, there's no journalistic discretion. As long as you're paying, we'll put anything up. But when it comes to us putting news out, we're going to have that same editorial coverage. I mean, it just, it literally makes absolutely, their position is literally the definition of indefensible and they're now in a corner totally alone.
Kara Swisher
What was interesting is Cheryl Sandberg put out a video, it was on Bloomberg's TikTok. She was talking about, we believe in free speech, the same thing that Mark was spouting, the same stuff. And one of the things they were talking about is we, and Mark talked about it in the earnings call. We're going to double down on transparency, like saying what things are and where the political ads come from and everything else. And we believe more speech is better speech. That's essentially what you said. And one of the things is these very elaborate transparency – I don't know what they are. They're like desktops where you can look at things, which nobody looks at.
Like they – one of the things was really – it just – what they're doing is offering all these really complicated ways to figure out who's doing what. But it's completely, utterly impossible to use. And someone from Facebook – I sent them this. And what she was saying is we believe in free expression. We believe in political speech and ads can be an important part of that. Said Sheryl Sandberg when asked why Facebook decided not to ban political ads. What the person said is it's so – as usual, the company is being astonishingly confusing about what they're doing instead of doing something easy to do.
Not to cut out – and this is what someone from a former Facebook person told me. They love complexity. It's amazing. Not to cut out political ads but create all kinds of difficult-to-understand rules. It's classic.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're just more attractive versions of Rudy Giuliani. They have a 750-person corporate communications department, which is bigger than the newsroom of Washington Post, which tries to craft this bullshit narrative and talking points, whether it's we want to give voice to the unheard. I mean it's just all narratives, all earnest, thoughtful commentary is always about an excuse to cash anybody's check. And it's just so ridiculous that they've decided not to take this cycle off. And what's great, the Twitter thing isn't that big a deal. They weren't getting that much money from it. What it is is it now puts Facebook in a corner alone, and it puts more pressure on Facebook. And actually, I'd like to think, and this is, I don't know, I'll come up with another prediction, but by Thanksgiving, Facebook succumbs.
Kara Swisher
All right, you said that. You said that. Tell me about that.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay, so under the cover of darkness, right, in the midst of the earnings call, under the barrage of cloud cover and flack from other news, Susan Desmond-Hellmann left the board. Now, what have we had here? We had anyone who has a conscience that isn't a venture capitalist or corrupt has decided to get the hell out of Dodge. I'm not sure why she left. But, OK, all right.
Kara Swisher
Well, she claims – and I want to be fair. She claims that some of it was health reasons and obviously we hope that she's doing fine. She's a terrific person.
Scott Galloway
My guess is she's like Erskine Bowles or Reed Hastings choking on the corruption and bullshit of Facebook. You just don't have this many people running for the hills on a board this prestigious and probably this well-paying. And so essentially you have board members who are like, okay, let's be honest. I'm kind of done with this 34-year-old Jesus Christ total control fucking up the world and humanity train. I'm off. And people who are worried about the reputation, people who are supposed to be curing malaria as the CEO of the Gates Foundation is supposed to be doing are just all quietly saying, I'm out, which leaves us with the Zuck, Peter Thiel, and Sheryl Sandberg. What could go wrong?
Kara Swisher
Mark Andreessen is there too.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, okay. I feel so much safer. So it's literally, okay, this is arguably – I mean this thing is turning into the Pollard Bureau, the board of directors there.
Kara Swisher
But I thought it was telling that she decided to leave under the cover of darkness. It feels like all the people he would point to and say this is a high-integrity person. She was quite active on the board too. Is that right?
Scott Galloway
Oh, she was the lead director, right? She was one of them, yeah.
Kara Swisher
So one of the things that was interesting that I liked about Jack's announcement – and I'm not going to slather Jack with it because I think they still have massive problems of bullying and everything else. And this is the lowest hanging fruit. I wrote a column in the Times that appeared this morning about this. I did a quick take on it.
Scott Galloway
You write for the New York Times?
Kara Swisher
Yes I do, thank you.
Scott Galloway
I didn't know that.
Kara Swisher
Hush up.
Scott Galloway
What did you want to say?
Kara Swisher
That where you can find it.
Scott Galloway
Oh good god. You so jealous. You were once on that board.
Kara Swisher
I have a blog. I have a blog.
Scott Galloway
You have hot takes. You have lots of fans Scott.
Kara Swisher
I have a blog. All right, listen. This is what Jack wrote, which I thought was the best. He wrote a very smart thread, which was very in contrast to having heard Mark's speech, which was very lightweight. It was sort of free speech, good. China, bad. That was essentially Mark's speech.
Scott Galloway
You said there was no nuance.
Kara Swisher
There was no nuance. There was no complexity. Complexity was what I'm looking for. I thought this was highly complex. "Internet political ads present entirely new challenges to civic discourse. Machine learning-based optimization of messaging and micro-targeting, unchecked misleading information, and deep fakes, all at an increasing velocity, sophistication, and overwhelming scale. These challenges will affect all internet communication, not just political ads. Best to focus our efforts on the root problems without the additional burden and complexity that taking money brings. Trying to fix both means fixing neither well and harms our credibility."
It was just so smart and it went on one smart comment that also wasn't ducking the difficulty. Look, we haven't fixed it. And you know, so he also said for instance, you know, we're well aware we're a small part of a much larger political advertising ecosystem. Some might argue our actions today could favor incumbents. Talking about all these things that were like hard and I was like and he didn't say we haven't really fixed it. You know, we haven't really fixed it, and we know that. And it was so refreshing to, like, get an actual – it's not letting him off the hook for the other stuff, but at least it addresses it in a complicated way that this is a complex issue that nobody has good answers for.
Scott Galloway
I give him – Smart move. Great for shareholders. But although let's talk very quickly. They had a terrible earnings. There was some issue around ads and stuff like that, but they've been doing really well. The stock had been up to 40. Now it's down much lower. It's come back. It's come back down. You had talked about it going up higher. But Facebook, killer earnings. Killer earnings. Everything up into the right. So what was our prediction? That Facebook was going to blow away earnings and go over $200 a share. It touched $198 this morning. I think it's going over $200 the next few days. But here's the thing. Just as Trump has his base of loyalists regardless of how corrupt or how much he lies, Facebook has their base of people who are totally loyal to them regardless of how corrupt or how much they lie. And it's called the global advertising market.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they own everything. You have no option. Someone asked me if I had a small business. How do you say monopoly? Yeah, someone asked me if I had a small business, would I advertise on Facebook? And I said I'd have to on Google. There's no choice.
Scott Galloway
You have no choice, no options.
Kara Swisher
That's exactly right, Kara.
Scott Galloway
And here it is. When you have no choice, it's not a tool. It's a tax. Facebook and Google have become taxes. The greatest – the biggest tax cut to small business in America would be if you banned Facebook and Google. Because what they are now is they're not means of differentiation. There's something everyone has to do. You have to own the right rail. You have to own those first two spots up top, two-thirds of all social media. So everybody doesn't use it as a point of differentiation. One of my colleagues at L2, quite frankly, is responsible for the success there, a woman named Maureen Mullen, who's like this incredible blue flame thinker, highlighted to me, she said, name a single company that has established competitive advantage over the long term using Google or Facebook. And that just blew me away. Because if you said TV, you'd go, oh, well, Nike. If you said catalog, you'd say, oh, Williams-Sonoma. No one has been able to establish long-term competitive advantage.
Kara Swisher
No, they can't.
Scott Galloway
And their genius is they've made the tools so egalitarian and the best practices so porous, everybody figures out how to buy more words and how to catch up. So it's really – anyways, I hope at some point the CMOs do it.
Kara Swisher
You're probably right. They can't do it because everyone would laud them for their efforts and then their stock would go down the next day. They can't. Yeah. It's the only game in town. My prediction is Facebook. The only, it's the company store.
Scott Galloway
A hundred percent. It's a tax. It's the company store. You cannot buy, that's how much potatoes are going to cost.
Kara Swisher
Right. It's the one railway, right? I called it Mother Russia the other day.
Scott Galloway
Mother Russia, nice. Speaking of Mother Russia, let's talk about your interview.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I interviewed Edward Snowden. It was fascinating. He was in Moscow. So we were talking about the idea of whether he's a whistleblower, a traitor, a leaker, an activist. You know, and he's written this book.
Scott Galloway
Broadway dancer.
Kara Swisher
Broadway dancer. He's a cat. He says he's an indoor cat. That's what he told me. He's an indoor cat. I said, how is it in Moscow? He's like, well, it doesn't really matter where I am. I'm an indoor cat, and I like to look at the screen. So it doesn't matter where I am.
Scott Galloway
And what came out? What was the most surprising thing about your interview?
Kara Swisher
That he was so thoughtful. I think one of the things – look, there's all these – whether he's a Russian asset or not. I don't believe he is. I think a lot of the intelligence points that way. I think the question is what he will become someday. As long as it continues to be established that he acted on his own, what is he? What did he do? Because he did reveal the US government doing unconstitutional legal actions. That said, the way he did it was illegal. And they later passed laws to stop the government from doing what he pointed out was illegal. But him pointing it out was illegal. So it's really complicated.
And I think the only issue is proving whether or not he's a Russian asset or a Chinese asset or a spy of some sort. But again, if he is not, then he's a whistleblower. He's a whistleblower who whistleblowed classified information, which you're not allowed to do. Although that's sort of what the whistleblower did, went through the right chain of command in this recent Ukraine thing. Although it wouldn't have come out had not someone leaked to the press that there was a whistleblower. So, you know, it was a great conversation about what he is and where he's going. And then we talked a lot about Facebook and the big tech companies and how he feels, you know, whether government is more dangerous to people and stuff.
So let's listen to him talking about that, Facebook and data collection, internet privacy.
Audio clip plays
Edward Snowden
Facebook's internal purpose, whether they state it publicly or not, is to compile perfect records of private lives to the maximum extent of their capability and then exploit that for their own corporate enrichment and damn the consequences. This is actually precisely the same as what the NSA does. Google has a very similar model. And they go, oh, we're connecting people. They go, oh, we're organizing data. But we can see privately what they're doing, right? You open your weather app, and it's communicating with Facebook because someone baked the Facebook SDK into it. And you didn't even realize that. You don't see it. It's intentionally kept invisible to you, and yet it's collecting material on you.
End of audio clip
Scott Galloway
There you go. Sounds like Scott Galloway in Moscow.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, me and Edward Snowden.
Scott Galloway
I think you're right. I actually think he will probably go down in history as someone who served a certain utility. And this is going to sound very hawkish and Republican. I agree with Hillary Clinton. I would have liked to see us drone his ass. I think when you, I don't know, subject this many people in our national security apparatus to this kind of danger, which I think he subjected them to, there's no doubt about it.
Kara Swisher
Well, no. He makes the case that there hasn't been – they have not revealed any instance where he did. So they're just saying that but then don't provide any proof to it. And his contention is that if he had actually damaged people's lives, they would have said, look what he did. And they haven't once. So he's contending, one, that he leaked – I'll just give you his argument.
Scott Galloway
Sure.
Kara Swisher
He says he gave it only to journalists. He made sure they didn't – the stuff that they – that he gave them, that they didn't write stories that would put – and contact the government about if there were people in danger's way. Revealing that we spied on Angela Merkel doesn't put anyone in danger. It just doesn't. And he's correct about that. It makes – it embarrasses us for sure that we did that and not – probably not a surprise that we did that. But his contention was that he made sure the journalists agreed that there was nothing and they would check with the government on anything that was even slightly. That he never released anything publicly himself. So he didn't do a data dump. He's, you know, differentiating himself from WikiLeaks and Julian Assange. And he said that none of this stuff has been proven to hurt anybody. So it's really – it's interesting. So how do you – I'm not a fan of – but like how do you show that the government is cheating and doing illegal things that they were never supposed to do, which is mass surveillance, without breaking the law?
Scott Galloway
Well, look. So I don't know. If he wants to be a martyr and a whistleblower, then come back and face the consequences and maybe he's right.
Kara Swisher
Well, actually, the Espionage Act –
Scott Galloway
You don't take off for China and Russia with a thumb drive up your ass.
Kara Swisher
Well, he didn't. He says he didn't. He says he didn't.
Scott Galloway
Oh, come on.
Kara Swisher
Well, I don't know. And Russia's looking after him.
Scott Galloway
Well, no, they're not. He doesn't work for it. He doesn't work. He lives in a small apartment in Russia.
Kara Swisher
In Russia. Yes, but he got stuck there because we pulled his passport. He wasn't traveling there. He was traveling to Ecuador. He wants to live in Europe. He wants to live here.
Scott Galloway
Well, I want to live in Europe. That doesn't give you permission to, like, be a spy.
Kara Swisher
No, I get it. But I'm just saying it's a lot – I think it's a lot more – it's a very interesting, complex issue of what you do. Let's put aside – say he isn't a Russian asset. Okay. Or a Chinese asset because he went through Hong Kong. He picked Hong Kong because it was an area that was at the time not Chinese territory, but it was a free area. What would you do if you were sitting there? What I found most intriguing about this interview was that he had a vision of the internet as a young man, and he's very typical of a lot of people I cover, where the internet was a safe place. It was a great place.
It's where he lived, where it was his world. And then it perverted into not just – it perverted by the government and mass surveillance and it was perverted by big tech by mass surveillance. And I think he was in love with the internet as he conceived it and he had the arrogance to think I can stop them. And that's the best case scenario for him. And he still broke the law. And under the Estimation of Justice, he can't have an actual trial where he can give a reason for doing it, which is they were doing something illegal and I was pointing it out. That's not a defense actually. He just goes to jail.
He just goes to jail. That's it. There's no other thing but go to jail.
Scott Galloway
I think your voiceover is a romantic script on some – a young man who is probably very thoughtful, very intelligent. It was a great interview. I get it. I get it. History will judge this man. And if things come out in Russia that it was indeed a Russian asset that could happen like it happened before.
Kara Swisher
You don't think he negotiated safe haven in Russia in exchange for something?
Scott Galloway
No.
Kara Swisher
Why would they want him? They tried to go everywhere else and he still trying to get out of Russia. He's trying to get—
Scott Galloway
Why did Russia agree to host him, other than to make us look stupid?
Kara Swisher
Make us look stupid. Or they got something in exchange.
Scott Galloway
Or make us look stupid. Yeah, okay.
Kara Swisher
He doesn't have a visa there right now. He gets extended year after year, I think, or something like that. So he's trying to get somewhere else right now. But he doesn't have a passport. He can't go anywhere. He's a man with a money. And by the way, the U.S. clamps down anybody that offers him anything.
Scott Galloway
As they should.
Kara Swisher
If you want to listen to the full interview, it's out now on my other podcast, Recode Decode.
Scott Galloway
All right. All right. Last quick story. Very quick story. HBO Max makes its debut.
Kara Swisher
Oh, the streaming wars, Kara.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, streaming wars. They're now white hot. They've been heating up. White hot. They're literally. It's coming in May, $14.99 per month.
Kara Swisher
That's what we need, another streaming service. It's more expensive. I'm just sitting around waiting for Peacock.
Scott Galloway
If you like HBO but don't want to buy HBO. But that's what HBO costs, I think, monthly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, what is it? It costs that much if you have cable. But anyway, you can get it by yourself.
Scott Galloway
Carol, last week you said that the streaming wars are going to be won by whoever has the best content.
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
And, you know, HBO Max is trying to get in there. It's the only place you can stream Friends. They also bought the entire run of South Park for over $500 million out from under Disney Hulu. So they're trying to get in there. Who has the very – and that will matter. The most interesting thing here, and I'm parroting a Vox article, which by all measures is probably going to launch their own streaming network. We are not. This will test net neutrality because the only thing – so Netflix and Disney+, what they don't have relative to HBO Max, relative to the Peacock network from Comcast, is they don't have vertical distribution.
And that is basically what HBO Max has with AT&T as a parent is you could flip on your TV or your direct TV channel and they could start promoting it or they could make it more expensive to stream Netflix. And that will be a real test of the banishment or the banning of these net neutrality laws. So I've always contended that if you look at companies that have been able to get over $100 billion in market capitalization, they all have one thing in common, and that is they're vertically distributed. They go from creation to they control the end unit phrase. So Apple TV Plus could be pre-installed on a billion devices.
When they sell their 110 million phones a year, and I don't know if that's the right number, they can pre-install it with Apple TV Plus and give you a free year. So vertical distribution is an unbelievable competitive advantage, and the biggest player doesn't have it, and that's Netflix. That's why I've always thought that Netflix should probably at this point merge with someone who's vertical and can control the distribution.
Kara Swisher
Apple.
Scott Galloway
That would be an interesting one.
Kara Swisher
Amazon.
Scott Galloway
Or Google, you know, pre-installed on more. It's actually more kind of from a brand positioning standpoint, I think, congruent with Android, pre-installed on 2.5 billion devices. But when you don't control the distribution, you are subject to someone else's decision to say, you know, we're going to make it almost impossible for distribution. That's what's happened to Spotify. They don't control their distribution, so they're at the whims. So interesting.
Kara Swisher
They're both still the best products, too.
Scott Galloway
100%.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, Netflix is the best product. Let's see how good these products are. I think it does depend on the content. It's a lot of them, though. I mean, every one of them are coming out. And people say it's going to be bad for Netflix. Netflix needs distribution. My prediction or my thought was they should buy Sony because they would get some distribution on handsets or on PlayStation and also great content.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's interesting.
Kara Swisher
And Sony is kind of cheap. It's kind of a shadow of its former self.
Scott Galloway
That was considered the most innovative company in the world.
Kara Swisher
Yes, it was. That was the Apple of the 80s. It was.
Scott Galloway
But without vertical distribution, I don't know if they can bust through from wherever they are, 100-plus billion to 200-plus billion.
Kara Swisher
I like it, Scott. That's an excellent prediction. We'll see. But we're going to get more when we get back. We're going to take a quick break. We'll be right back with more Pivot.
Advertisement
Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max Bundle. Plans starting at $16.99 a month. All these and more streaming soon. Visit DisneyPlusHuluHBOMaxBundle.com for details.
Advertisement
Nearly home. Isn't home where we all want to be? Reba here for Realtor.com, the pro's number one most trusted app. A dream home isn't a dream home if it comes with a nightmare commute. That's why Realtor.com has Real Commute, so you can search by drive time. Download the Realtor.com app today because you're nearly home. Make it real with Realtor.com. Pro's number one most trusted app based on August 2024 proprietary survey.
Welcome back to Pivot. We're going to dig into some listener mail before we get to wins and fails, but you went to the Apple premiere. You went to a premiere I didn't go to.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Morning News. Stephen Carell, Jennifer Aniston, Reese Witherspoon, a story. It's basically what I'd call the Diet Coke version of the Matt Lauer story.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And it was actually – I thought what's interesting – I think it will be quite controversial because at least in the first episode, it treats the serial or the harasser, the guy with very much kid gloves. It portrays him as a bit of a victim. So I don't know if there's a twist coming. But it felt very aptly in the sense that they spent – they must have spent literally –
Scott Galloway
Everyone said the money. I have a friend who went. Game of Thrones like money on this thing. I have a friend who's a doc who has a show with Netflix actually and was like the money was insane.
Kara Swisher
Incredible. And that's what's become so interesting about content is it no longer needs to be self-sustaining. It becomes something, as you said it aptly once you said, well, we can sell more paper towels if we have the marvelous Mrs. Maisel.
Scott Galloway
And what it all – it all leads to one point and that is it's a great time to be in the business of creating content. You know, young kids or a lot of kids meet with me, and I'm like, you want to get close to processing power? You want to get to a city?
You also, if you have the ability to be in the business of creating mass-consumable, differentiated content, it is a great time to be. I don't know if you're a gaffer. I don't know if you cater movie sets. But, you know, you and I have been approached about doing TV shows. And when they're coming after Kara and the dog, it means there's too much capital swashing around original scripted television.
Kara Swisher
Did you get to meet Jennifer Aniston? Was she there?
Scott Galloway
I didn't. I saw her and I saw Reese Witherspoon. I was too intimidated. Tim Cook was there. Yeah. But it was, you know, they screamed it. Tim Cook in an environment like that is weird. You could just tell he's uncomfortable. He's way too... He's so uncomfortable. He likes to talk about football and... He's not having a midlife crisis. Bezos wanted to be there smiling and laughing. He really just wants to talk about football, really.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Whenever I meet him. Yeah. He's so damn likable. He's got good hair and he seems nice. Anyways, but I saw him. That was my celebrity sighting. So you were at a premiere. I was at a premiere. I put on a tie. Did you?
Scott Galloway
The dog was looking good.
Kara Swisher
Were you? I was looking good. Yeah, I showered. I'd love to see you at these premieres. You're very shy. People don't realize you're quite shy.
Scott Galloway
Well, I'm paid to be an extrovert, but the reality is when I'm off mic, I don't want to talk to anybody.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true. You are. It's interesting. I will talk to anybody. I'm complex. I'm quite an extrovert.
Scott Galloway
So many layers to the dog cake.
Kara Swisher
All right. In any case, listener mail. So we got an email question from the listener, Michael Swain, about an article that was written on our sister's site, The Verge. The article looked at a new bill introduced by some big Silicon Valley critics this month that's meant to undercut social media monopolies. The Augmenting Compatibility and Competition by Enabling Service Switching Act, ACCESS, is designed to make large communications platforms loosen their hold on user data. Senator Mark Warner introduced the bill last week as part of an effort to rein in big platform monopolies. We reached out to the writer of this article, Addie Robertson, to sum up the bill and how it might play out.
Audio clip plays: Addie Robertson explains the ACCESS Act and its implications for data portability and security.
That's interesting.
Scott Galloway
That wasn't that interesting. That was boring.
Kara Swisher
No, it was not. You're wrong. Listen to me. Listen to me. It is interesting.
Scott Galloway
No, data portability is really important, the ability to move services. But these big companies have already amassed so much data, there's no way rivals can compete.
Kara Swisher
It's actually critically important. It's a very fascinating bill. You're absolutely wrong. So can people tap into what Facebook or Google has already compiled and create new businesses? So it could potentially be a font of innovation so that you don't – there's no way these companies can compete or create what you were saying, different choices in online advertising without access to this data. And so how do you do it right is a really important thing. And secondly, the ability to do it is a big deal. Thank you.
Scott Galloway
And not only that, it's legislation that's difficult and hard. And you can imagine writing this thing took a ton. I'm a big fan of Senator Warner. Depending on how you categorize or qualify the statement, somewhere between 4 and 9 percent of our elected officials have a background in engineering or technology. And Senator Warner is one of them. And he's very thoughtful. I got the opportunity to spend some time with him. His questions are right on. He seems very interested, really wants to understand this stuff. And I think a lot of our elected officials who are clearly very smart, clearly have good instincts, clearly have resources, quite frankly, they don't want to take the time to write this kind of legislation because it's hard. I mean it's really difficult.
Kara Swisher
You're already saying this, but it's actually really important.
Scott Galloway
It is important. A bill like this is critically important to allowing competitors. And we do have to safeguard against privacy issues of moving this data around. But it's not – Mark Zuckerberg talks only about data portability, not that he has to turn over the data he collects to competitors to let them build businesses. I get it. This is important. Kudos to you. At the end of the day, though, it solves a fraction of the problem. We need to break these companies up because right now it's, I'm pissed off at Facebook. I'm taking my data to Instagram. I mean, it's just—
Kara Swisher
It not taking your data. It actually letting rivals build businesses off this data that never will be compiled again. Such you own your data and you can begin when you fire up another service you would have your friends fire up and your contacts would be there. No, that's data portability. Data – this is talking about the ability of some company X decides to make an actual competitive search service. They can use data from Google. They can use Google's data in a way that they can create a new business. I think it's a great idea. I think it's a great bill.
Scott Galloway
I think theoretically it is. Do you think all of a sudden across America venture capitalists are going to start funding competitors?
Kara Swisher
Well, at least it gives them like literally I've interviewed just today Alexis Ohanian, Ben Horowitz, never going to invest in a social media company again because of Facebook. And do you think that changes as well?
Scott Galloway
Yes, it does. If people have more stuff and right now these big companies are hoarding all the data. Let's use their data to create competitors and maybe we don't have to break them up. I don't know. I think it's a great bill. It's complicated, which is why it's difficult. But I think it's great.
Kara Swisher
Agreed. All right. So wins and fails. Wins and fails. What's your win, Cara?
Scott Galloway
What's my win? Oh, God. Jack Dorsey. Just Jack Dorsey. Jack. Yeah, well done. That was a good one.
Kara Swisher
My win is Claudia Lopez.
Scott Galloway
Okay. Who this week, do you know who Claudia is? No. Please explain.
Kara Swisher
She was elected as the first female mayor of Bogota, Colombia, and she's also a member of the LGBTQ community. Okay. And after decades of abuse, it was especially difficult as most civil wars are on women. There's a wonderful story. Women have decided, have turned to political activism. And the second most important office in Colombia, the mayor of their largest city, is now a 49-year-old gay woman. And it's a huge – I think it's a really nice victory. And her speech was wonderful. It says a lot about the progress of a country that's been war-torn, and she's now one of the two most powerful lesbians in the Americas, the first, of course, being the senior senator from South Carolina, Lindsey Graham. Anyways, my win is Claudia Lopez. I think that this is a victory for Columbia, a victory for her, and a victory for women.
Scott Galloway
And by the way, what is the number one source of news on lesbian leadership? The dog! The dog. Don't call. Don't impugn lesbians by calling Lindsey Graham one. Don't do that.
Kara Swisher
No, that's okay. We are not going to take him. He's not tough enough anyway. Anyway, actually, I do have another win. Casey Newton for taking down horrific contract Facebook content moderators. Cognizant is shutting down its moderation business. A few months ago, Casey published a couple of blockbuster stories about contract workers moderating the grimmest Facebook content. This week, two of the companies doing that work said they'd stop working with Facebook. Facebook's got to do this biz wax themselves. If they make a mess, they have to clean it up. I get it. I like it.
Scott Galloway
So, all right. What is your fail?
Kara Swisher
So it's not so much as a fail. I just wanted to recognize a guy I went to college with and was actually my attorney at UCLA. A guy named Keith Boski passed away at the age of 53.
Scott Galloway
That's very sad. I know Keith.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you know Keith?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, not well, but. And we had lost touch and reconnected. He was the president at DLD in Germany. He was the president of a video game company and a thought leader on robotics and drones. And the thing that struck me about him, I've never had a chance to meet his wife or his son, Sarah and Kevin, but within 30 seconds, he would begin talking about it. So, oh, I'm a mess.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, I'm sorry. Anyways, Keith Boski, dead at 53. Oh. Very upsetting.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no. He was a lovely guy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he was a lovely guy. That's why I would see him every year at DLD.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he was a fascinating guy, always interesting, sent me interesting ideas and stuff like that. Nice man.
Kara Swisher
I'm so sorry. That is sad, right?
Scott Galloway
Yes. Short carrot. We got to enjoy it. It's all very short. You know I'm death-obsessed.
Kara Swisher
Not obsessed. I'm death-focused.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so am I. You know that. It's motivating, though. It's nice.
Kara Swisher
It is motivating. I think it can be a source of energy and power. People always think I'm crazy, but I'm like, no, no, no. It makes me happier when you recognize that we have very short time on this planet. Very little time. And everywhere we go, we're going to hit this, whether we like it or not. And so I think it's very touching, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Faster than we think, right?
Kara Swisher
Scott, I'm so excited. All right, let's go to predictions. Predictions. Let's get you out of this.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so there's this artificial – the unicorn industrial complex is all about pumping and dumping and trying to create a ridiculously artificial high stock price until the VCs and the institutional investors can sell. And we saw that with Beyond Meat, and that is they only had about 16% of their float. So the idea is only put a small percentage of your ownership out there, and then it creates artificial demand, more demand than supply. And then the moment additional shares come out, Beyond Meat goes public at $25, rockets to $250. Ridiculous valuation. I mean, just insane valuation. They do a secondary. The stock goes down 20%. The lockup comes off last week. Stock goes down again. And now the stock has lost two-thirds of its value. We're about to see the same thing happen at Uber next week.
Kara Swisher
It seems like Uber is your next thing to talk about.
Scott Galloway
Well, Uber doesn't go to zero. There's real value there. Right. But it's going to – I think my prediction is I think Uber gets cut 20 to 40 percent in the next 30, 60 days as the artificially low float goes away and the lockup comes off and people realize this company is not worth more than Ford. It's a nice company worth $10 to $20 billion, not $55 billion. Anyway, so the artificial demand and the artificially high stock prices created by a minimal float that the investment bankers and the companies manage, at some point you got to pay the piper. It's happened with Beyond Meat. And by the way, what Uber was to WeWork, so Uber breached the firewall and everyone said, all right, we're not going to be fooled again and killed the WeIPO. That is what Beyond Meat is to Impossible. Impossible has lined up its IPO. That's not going to happen because now that Beyond Meat is crashing to something that reasonably reflects its value, the bankers and the folks at Impossible are going, oh, fuck. We're not going to get out.
Kara Swisher
So what happens to the businesses then?
Scott Galloway
They're nice businesses. They're good businesses. They're worth perhaps billions of dollars, but they're not worth more than the entire agri-food business.
Kara Swisher
Do they get bought?
Scott Galloway
I don't know. Not for a long time. They're way too expensive. I mean I find a decent strategy. I only buy chicken and beef stocks because, Cara, I want to be a billionaire. Get it? A billionaire. That's good comedy.
Kara Swisher
And he's recovered from his moment of sweet, kind, poignant. That's good comedy. Bullionaire? That was just I'm very hungover.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, okay. But anyway, so my prediction is Uber gets cut 20% to 40% as the lockup comes off and some sort of reasonable valuation. Everyone realizes this thing is not going up. It's going way down, and they head for the doors.
Kara Swisher
Okay. What does that mean then for IPOs going forward? I'm going to push this.
Scott Galloway
We're just going to have a massive recalibration of value in the public markets. It's happening in the private markets. The public markets have been the rational ones. It's usually – supposedly usually the retail investors in the public markets are the stupid ones, and the private markets are supposed to be the smart guys, and it's actually been reversed. Next year will be a very interesting year for IPOs, and we have all these companies delaying their IPOs.
Kara Swisher
Like Palantir will be the most interesting because they benefit from this kind of black box. Oh, they're so mysterious. That would be just a fascinating S1 to see.
Scott Galloway
All right, let's enjoy that.
Kara Swisher
We will read that together.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that would be. Together by the fire.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I like it. Reading S1s. That's our Sunday. Actually, the rumors that Alphabet, Google's parent company, might be buying Fitbit was interesting. We'll talk about that next week, the wearable space.
Scott Galloway
That's right. I thought that was bullshit, and it ended up I got that wrong. I thought that was a lie released by Fitbit, but it looks like, in fact, Google is, in fact, in talks to acquire them.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, interesting. We will talk about the wearable space next week and so much more. Scott, I'm so sorry about your friend dying. I really am.
Scott Galloway
You know, it's a stretch to say we were friends.
Kara Swisher
I know, but still. It still affects you all. Very sad, right?
Scott Galloway
I keep – I don't know if you know this. I use the WeCroke app constantly so I can hear death quotes all the time. And so I get five of them a day, which everyone makes fun of me. But there's a really good one I got today, which was oddly enough. Liz, live as if you were to die tomorrow. Learn as if you were to live forever. Mahatma Gandhi.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's Gandhi?
Scott Galloway
That's Gandhi, my friend. With the flowing robes?
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Benjamin Franklin, death takes no bribes.
Kara Swisher
That's right, isn't it? And on that note, on Halloween. That's right. Let's go out. Let's dress up our kids. Let's dress up our kids. My new rescue dog from Puerto Rico is going as a little wiener dog. It's going to be hilarious.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God. God. My 12-year-old wants to go as an archer, a medieval archer. He's way too thoughtful last year. He went as an artist. I wanted to do Star Wars as a family, and he said no.
Kara Swisher
Okay. And you're going as Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
No, every year I go as Starship Commander Jean-Luc Picard. Huge crowd pleaser. Anyway, everybody. Thank you so much. We will be back next week. It's time to go. But if listeners have a question or an idea of a company, Pivot should mercilessly take down over the next couple months. Shoot us an email at pivot at voxmedia.com.
Kara Swisher
We're not limited to anything. We love new ideas and companies and different things. I know we talk a lot about Facebook and Uber and stuff like that, but we were definitely willing to talk about lots of different companies. Also, we're hiring a new producer for Pivot. Scott, give the pitch, please.
Scott Galloway
Come work for the jungle cat and the big dog. All right. And for the rest of your life, be angry. You're not skill and sell it.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, please apply at voxmedia.com slash careers. We have snacks. If you need the right person.
Scott Galloway
We do have snacks. We do have snacks to join the team.
Kara Swisher
Scott, please read the credits.
Scott Galloway
Oh, good. I'm sorry. Oh, my God. Find the script, Scott. Do you want me to start? Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanes. Try to get there. Erica Anderson is Pivot's executive producer. Thanks also to Rebecca Castro, Drew Burrows, and Yashat Kerouac. Make sure you've subscribed to the show on Apple Podcasts. And if you like this week's episode, leave us a review. Thanks for living to pivot from Vox Media.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. What did I say? Living. I got that wrong?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's listening. Dude, if you were as hungover as me right now, you would be seriously impressed.
Kara Swisher
Thanks for listening to pivot. To pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.