Main Topic: The FBI investigation into Tom Homan, the border czar under the Trump administration, and the $50,000 in cash that was delivered to him as part of an undercover operation.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
For the past few weeks, Trump officials have repeatedly dodged questions about an undercover F.B.I. investigation of the border czar, Tom Homan, and what became of $50,000 in cash that was delivered to him.
Devlin Barret, who covers the F.B.I. for The New York Times, discusses the inquiry, which was closed after President Trump came to office.
Guest: Devlin Barrett, a New York Times reporter covering the Justice Department and the F.B.I.
Background reading:
Photo: Doug Mills/The New York Times
For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.
Theme music fades out
Natalie Kitroeff
From The New York Times, I'm Natalie Kitroeff. This is The Daily. The White House Borders are Tom Homan was recorded on an F.B.I. surveillance tape in September 2024, accepting $50,000 in cash. Did he keep that money or give it back?
Pause
For the past few weeks, Trump officials have been asked repeatedly about an undercover F.B.I. investigation of border czar Tom Homan. What became of the $50,000 in cash that the F.B.I. delivered to Mr. Homan? And consistently, they've sidestepped... Did he accept that $50,000 or not?
George
I don't know what you're talking about.
Natalie Kitroeff
Did he accept $50,000 for what? ...or refuse to answer key questions... Did the F.B.I. get it back?
Senator Whitehouse
You're welcome to talk to the F.B.I.
Natalie Kitroeff
Senator Whitehouse, you're welcome to talk to the F.B.I. ...about whether one of Trump's top immigration officials brazenly broke the law and what's being done about it. The White House and the president stand by Tom Homan 100 percent because he did absolutely nothing wrong.
Pause
Today, my colleague Devlin Barrett on the story behind those questions and why the Tom Homan scandal hasn't faded away. It's Wednesday, October 15th. Devlin, I've been watching this story of these allegations surrounding Tom Homan unfold over the past several weeks. And as I've watched, I keep thinking about this interview I did with Homan on the show in June.
Devlin Barrett
One thing that really stuck with me from that interview was just how uncompromising Homan was in the way he presented his view of the law and what should happen to people who break it. That they should be punished.
Natalie Kitroeff
And I want to just play you a little bit of tape about how he represented himself and that mission.
Devlin Barrett
We're nice from laws, right? We've got to enforce the laws. Entering this country legal is a crime. We don't pick and choose what we enforce. We're here to enforce the law.
Natalie Kitroeff
And then recently, we got some new information about Holman.
Devlin Barrett
Tell us when you first learned about this story.
Natalie Kitroeff
So I cover the Justice Department and the F.B.I. And months ago, I had started hearing rumblings that there had been some kind of bribery investigation related to Tom Holman. But I couldn't quite figure out what it was about or where it was.
Devlin Barrett
And for a while, it just was a puzzle I couldn't solve. You had a lot of other stories you were covering. It's pretty busy at the D.O.J. and the F.B.I. most days.
Natalie Kitroeff
Then sometime in September, I got a little more information where someone knew some of the answers to these questions and said, you know, oh, you mean the case with a bag of cash?
Devlin Barrett
Whoa, bag of cash. That's a pretty big tip.
Natalie Kitroeff
Well, right. That's not, you know, what you think of as like, let's call it regular business practice, right? It's almost the stereotypical way that people think of corruption cases.
Devlin Barrett
Yeah. So from that point, I started putting more pieces together and figuring more things out. I wasn't the only reporter chasing this. MSNBC also figured it out.
Natalie Kitroeff
And so what I eventually came to understand was that there had been, beginning really in 2023, but stretching all the way into this year, a really fascinating investigation that came to include Tom Homan.
Devlin Barrett
As it's been described to me by sources, if you go back to the spring of 2023, the F.B.I. in Texas was conducting an undercover investigation related to a particular businessman.
Natalie Kitroeff
And the investigation, my sources were adamant, was not looking at Tom Holman at all.
Devlin Barrett
But in the course of that investigation, that businessman told the undercover agents that if those agents were posing as businessmen looking for government contracts, if they were willing to pay Tom Holman a million dollars, he could steer government contracts to them.
Natalie Kitroeff
Whoa. So these agents weren't initially fishing for anything related to Tom Holman. They weren't looking at him at that time.
Devlin Barrett
My sources are adamant that no one had asked about Tom Homan. That was brought up unprompted.
Natalie Kitroeff
And Tom Homan just sort of wanders into the picture, wanders into the frame of what the F.B.I. agents are already doing.
Devlin Barrett
Just to put us in time here, we're in 2023. We know Tom Homan as the former I.C.E. director in the first Trump administration, this longtime border official. He actually served in the Obama administration.
Natalie Kitroeff
But he's not in government at this point, right? Right. He's just a private citizen and he runs a consulting business for companies that are seeking contracts.
Devlin Barrett
So it's not completely out of the blue that he would have some interest in government contracts. But again, he's not in government at that time.
Natalie Kitroeff
And he's known mostly as a former Trump official who is what they sometimes call a campaign surrogate. He often would appear, you know, speaking publicly in support of another Trump administration.
Devlin Barrett
And there's a lot of general expectation that if Trump wins reelection, Homan will rejoin the government.
Natalie Kitroeff
And in November of 2023, he out and out says it. He says, you know, I promised President Trump that if he goes back, I go back.
Devlin Barrett
And then he added to that and I going to run the biggest deportation operation this country ever seen.
Natalie Kitroeff
He widely seen as a likely member of a future Trump administration.
Devlin Barrett
He saying he going to be there. And there's this sense that a lot of money is going to be thrown at the area that he's going to be involved in in border enforcement.
Natalie Kitroeff
Well, right. That that whole time period, the Trump campaign is talking about deporting millions of people. It is a very expensive prospect.
Devlin Barrett
So there's a natural expectation that there will be significant government contracts related to both border security work and deportation work.
Natalie Kitroeff
Okay. So back to the investigation. What happens next?
Devlin Barrett
So once that businessman just sort of proposes this notion that the undercover agents could pay Tom Homan to get government contracts, a series of conversations follow.
Natalie Kitroeff
This investigation goes on for a long time, but eventually a meeting is set up for September 20th, 2024.
Devlin Barrett
And at that meeting, my sources tell me the undercover agents bring $50,000 in cash.
Natalie Kitroeff
And that cash is put in a takeout food bag, a bag from the chain Kava.
Devlin Barrett
So what has been described to me is at that meeting, Homan both accepts the cash and seems to convey that he's willing to help them get contracts in the future.
Natalie Kitroeff
Do we know exactly what he says?
Devlin Barrett
We don't know exactly what he says, and that's obviously a big question in this whole process.
Natalie Kitroeff
But we do know that the F.B.I. agents made an audio recording of the meeting.
Devlin Barrett
So somewhere in government files, there exists, I am told, an audio recording of this discussion.
Natalie Kitroeff
And what's been described to me is that Homan accepts the cash and leaves.
Devlin Barrett
And that's a great start to an investigation. You've got a lot to work with there, right?
Natalie Kitroeff
Because the person you're investigating has taken the money and appears to have agreed to do things in exchange for the money.
Devlin Barrett
But that's not really the end of the investigation. Why not?
Natalie Kitroeff
For a couple of reasons. One, because there was no very specific act that he agreed to do in exchange for that money.
Devlin Barrett
And two, it's important to remember, at the time he takes the money, Tom Homan is still not a government official.
Natalie Kitroeff
He certainly can't make the Biden administration, which was running the government at that time, award contracts.
Devlin Barrett
So in the moment the cash is handed over, Homan really can't deliver even if he wants to.
Natalie Kitroeff
I guess the assumption here is that this is like a down payment for future services that he could potentially render, correct?
Devlin Barrett
Right. The investigators thought of it as this is the start of the relationship. This is the start of the process.
Natalie Kitroeff
Devlin, does that help explain a question I've had about all this, which is $50,000 is a lot of money, but it also doesn't feel like enough for someone like Homan to do something this risky that could really jeopardize his career?
Devlin Barrett
Right. It wasn't necessarily that you give him this $50,000 and then he immediately starts doing things for you.
Natalie Kitroeff
One source described it as, you know, they paid money to make a friend in a regular corruption investigation.
Devlin Barrett
There would naturally be follow-up meetings, maybe follow-up payments.
Natalie Kitroeff
That's certainly a possibility in such an investigation.
Devlin Barrett
They're playing the long game here.
Natalie Kitroeff
Exactly. They have a very strong start to a case. They have very good evidence and they have a very good basis to proceed with their investigation.
Devlin Barrett
And then Trump wins the election.
Natalie Kitroeff
Right. And within days of Trump winning the election, the president-elect announces that Tom Homan will become his border czar.
Devlin Barrett
And not many people know the ins and outs of these czar positions that government and White Houses sometimes announce.
Natalie Kitroeff
Yeah, I've always wondered, is that a real long-term position in the U.S. government, czar?
Devlin Barrett
It's not something you're nominated for. It's not something that the Senate confirms you for.
Natalie Kitroeff
It's very much sort of a point person for an administration on a particular subject.
Devlin Barrett
But what matters in this instance is that because there's no Senate confirmation, there's not the same kind of background check scrubbing that goes on for a czar position as there is for a cabinet official or a deputy cabinet official.
Natalie Kitroeff
And that's important in Holman's situation because there is this underlying outstanding case.
Devlin Barrett
Are you saying basically that this might have been intentional, that the Trump administration might have nominated Holman to the czar position in order to avoid a background check?
Natalie Kitroeff
It's really unclear.
Devlin Barrett
But we do know, however, that during the transition, after Trump is elected, but before he is sworn into office, federal law enforcement officials notify and essentially warn the incoming administration that this investigation exists into Tom Holman.
Natalie Kitroeff
And the Trump Justice Department then does inherit this investigation.
Devlin Barrett
The short answer is they don't do much of anything with it.
Natalie Kitroeff
The senior officials of that administration look at the case and they don't like it.
Devlin Barrett
They're very skeptical that this is anything worth pursuing.
Natalie Kitroeff
And this case that the agents and investigators thought was a very solid case a very promising start it just gets closed.
Pause
So Devlin, once this story breaks about the investigation and about the ending of the investigation, what happens? How does the Trump administration respond?
John Doe
They explain their decision to drop this case.
Natalie Kitroeff
So when we asked the Justice Department to explain, you know, why was this case closed, the F.B.I. Director, Kash Patel, and the Deputy Attorney General, Todd Blanche, said that, you know, it was reviewed by agents and prosecutors.
John Doe
And they said those agents and prosecutors found no credible evidence of any criminal wrongdoing.
Natalie Kitroeff
They basically called it a baseless investigation.
John Doe
And that's why they say they closed it.
Natalie Kitroeff
They don't mention the bag of cash specifically?
John Doe
They don't mention the bag of cash, and that becomes a real focal point of all the questions that follow about what the administration did here and why they did it.
Natalie Kitroeff
One of the first very public comments about all this is the White House press secretary, Carolyn Leavitt.
Carolyn Leavitt
Does Holman have to return the $50,000?
Natalie Kitroeff
Well, Mr. Homan never took the $50,000 that you're referring to, so you should get your facts straight, number one.
Devlin Barrett
Denying that he took the money at all.
Natalie Kitroeff
Hours after that. Tom, I want to give you a chance to address this article that came out over the weekend.
Tom Homan
Tom Homan goes on Fox News, and he's given an opportunity to just respond to the reporting, respond to these allegations.
Natalie Kitroeff
And his answer is very telling in one way, in that he never denies taking the money.
Tom Homan
Look, I did nothing criminal. I did nothing illegal.
Natalie Kitroeff
And this hit piece after hit piece after hit piece.
Tom Homan
He repeats very emphatically that he didn't commit any crime.
Natalie Kitroeff
And I'm glad the F.B.I. and D.O.J. came out and said, and, you know, said that nothing illegal happened, nothing, you know, no criminal activity.
Tom Homan
Yeah, suddenly we're talking not about whether this happened or not, but about whether it was legal.
Natalie Kitroeff
And obviously those two things are very different.
Tom Homan
Right.
Natalie Kitroeff
And so the administration ends up getting very adamant about the point that Homan makes in his interview on this, which is just to say there was no crime here.
Devlin Barrett
And that becomes a kind of mantra throughout the administration as the questions keep coming up.
Natalie Kitroeff
You know, sitting here, all I know is that Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche and F.B.I. Director Patel said there was no case.
Pause
Last week, there's a hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee in which Attorney General Pam Bondi is very confrontational.
Pam Bondi
If you worked for me, you would have been fired.
Natalie Kitroeff
She is adamant that no crime was committed.
Pam Bondi
And she basically goes on the attack and just criticizes the lawmakers who are even asking the question.
Natalie Kitroeff
In the same vein, just this past weekend, the vice president, J.D. Vance, is interviewed by ABC's George Stephanopoulos.
George Stephanopoulos
and he's asked again about Tom Holman and the bag of cash.
J.D. Vance
Are you saying that he did not accept the $50,000?
Natalie Kitroeff
Vance's answer is very similar to Bondi's.
J.D. Vance
The question is, did he do something illegal?
Natalie Kitroeff
And there's absolutely no evidence that Tom Holman has ever taken a bribe of anything illegal, which is why he's working in the administration.
J.D. Vance
He insists no crime was committed and, again, goes on the attack for even asking the question.
Natalie Kitroeff
Of course, this administration dropped the investigation before they could actually prove whether or not a crime was being committed.
Devlin Barrett
So, on a political level, their argument is very simple. This was a partisan witch hunt generated by the last Democratic administration.
Natalie Kitroeff
The legal argument is actually a little more complicated. and it touches on a lot of things.
Devlin Barrett
First, I would just say, not everyone inside the Justice Department has the exact same view about this case.
Natalie Kitroeff
I have talked to people who feel very strongly that it was a very strong case, a chargeable case, a pursuable case, and it's frustrating to those people that the case was dropped.
Devlin Barrett
I have talked to other people inside the department who have made the argument, look, this was a great beginning of a case.
Natalie Kitroeff
We had not finished the case, and it's not a terrific case without more evidence.
Devlin Barrett
So there aren't universal views about this, even inside the department.
Natalie Kitroeff
But it also, this case speaks to what's really a long-running disagreement about whether or not the Justice Department is overusing and stretching corruption laws beyond what they were intended to do.
Devlin Barrett
And over a number of years, the Supreme Court has basically whittled away at how federal corruption laws can be used.
Natalie Kitroeff
And has repeatedly sent a signal to the Justice Department that certainly the conservatives on the court believe that the Justice Department is in many cases misusing or overusing corruption statutes to go after politicians.
Devlin Barrett
Meaning there's a disagreement within the legal community about what actually constitutes corruption, or at least what's the threshold for proving it in court.
Natalie Kitroeff
Well, exactly.
Devlin Barrett
And one of the ways that this case gets argued about among lawyers is there's something called stream of benefits corruption, which makes the argument that you don't need a very explicit quid pro quo.
Natalie Kitroeff
You need a very explicit you give me X dollars and I will do Y for you Soprano style.
Devlin Barrett
That what you can have is a sort of corrupt flow relationship where I do the following things for you, like cash, and you in exchange do the following things for me, like official favors, like getting contracts.
Natalie Kitroeff
But the court has to believe that it's explicit. It can't just be a vague set of actions.
Devlin Barrett
That's the argument for how you could charge a case like this.
Natalie Kitroeff
So there are obviously a lot of open legal questions here, and maybe what the F.B.I. had in its hands wasn't an open and shut case yet.
Devlin Barrett
But Homan taking this money as a lawman, as the chief spokesman of this administration's immigration policy, it does raise all sorts of questions.
Natalie Kitroeff
And the administration not following up also raises questions.
Devlin Barrett
I guess what I'm wondering, Devlin, is there's been so many similar scandals swirling around the Trump administration at this point, allegations of corruption from crypto to the free airplane.
Natalie Kitroeff
A lot of those have kind of faded away in the fire hose of news that we are all experiencing on a day to day basis.
Devlin Barrett
But this one has kind of outlived the Trump news cycle. Why?
Natalie Kitroeff
I mean, look, as someone who covers the Justice Department and the F.B.I.
Devlin Barrett
I will tell you that there are many corruption cases that are hard to follow, hard to explain, hard to just unravel and unpack.
Natalie Kitroeff
Crypto isn't an easy thing to explain.
Devlin Barrett
You know what is easy to explain? A cab a bag full of cash.
Natalie Kitroeff
That's pretty simple.
Devlin Barrett
Why did he take a bag of cash? What did he do with the cash?
Natalie Kitroeff
And in addition to how simple a bag of cash is, we know from the reporting that an audio tape exists somewhere.
Devlin Barrett
Right. And that tape could be released.
Natalie Kitroeff
People could start demanding its release.
Devlin Barrett
Right. So if you think for a minute about the Jeffrey Epstein case, obviously the Tom Homan case is not the Jeffrey Epstein case.
Natalie Kitroeff
Epstein is a completely different type of case with a completely different history.
Devlin Barrett
But the demand to release the Tom Homan tape is in some ways very similar to the demands to release the Epstein files because it's a simple, straightforward question.
Natalie Kitroeff
And it's sort of when you are told no, it begs the question, well, why is the answer no?
Devlin Barrett
Can I just ask, do we know what happened to the money, the $50,000?
Natalie Kitroeff
We really don't.
Devlin Barrett
A lot of what you've seen since the initial reporting is people trying to figure out the answer to that question, but the administration really won't tell us and Homan so far hasn't told us.
Natalie Kitroeff
So the case may be dead, but I think what hasn't died is people's desire to know the answer to that question.
Devlin Barrett
So I think for the foreseeable future, wherever Tom Homan goes, he's going to be asked that question.
Natalie Kitroeff
What did you do with the money?
Theme music starts
Well, Devlin, thanks so much for coming on the show.
Devlin Barrett
Thanks for having me on the show.
Natalie Kitroeff
We'll be right back.
Theme music continues
Here's what else you should know today. On Tuesday, President Trump announced that the U.S. had killed six men aboard a boat off the coast of Venezuela, the fifth known strike on a boat in the Caribbean Sea since September.
He said the men had been transporting drugs, but provided no evidence to support that claim.
And while he posted a video of the attack, the president offered no details about the nationality of the suspects and didn't identify them as belonging to any particular criminal group.
The U.S. military has now killed 27 people in these boat attacks, treating them as if they were enemy soldiers in the middle of a war zone, rather than criminal suspects.
It's a great honor to have the leader of Argentina, a place that I love, I've been to, and one of the most beautiful places in the world, president.
I really want to thank you very much.
Trump hosted Argentinian President Javier Malay at the White House on Tuesday, just days after the U.S. agreed to move ahead with a $20 billion bailout of Argentina.
We think he's going to win. He should win.
And if he does win, we're going to be very helpful.
And if he doesn't win, we're not going to waste our time because you have somebody whose philosophy has no chance of making Argentina great again.
Trump explicitly tied U.S. economic support for the country to the political fortunes of Malay, who's trying to stave off a financial meltdown at home and whose party is facing tough midterm elections this month.
Trump acknowledged that the bailout was intended to support the Argentinian leader's fiscally conservative policies and wouldn't make a big difference for the U.S.
Today's episode was produced by Caitlin O'Keefe and Carlos Piretto.
It was edited by Lizzo Balin and Michael Benoit and contains original music by Marion Lozano, Will Reed, and Dan Powell, and was engineered by Alyssa Moxley.
That's it for The Daily. I'm Natalie Kitroeff. See you tomorrow.