Main Topic: The episode discusses the career of Greg Gutfeld, a conservative late-night host, and his thoughts on the current state of late-night TV, comedy, and politics.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
The pugnacious conservative late-night host on his "hierarchy of smears" and the risks of being a scold.
Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.
David Marchese
From the New York Times, this is The Interview. I'm David Marchese.
Music fades
Why can't conservatives break through on late-night TV? For years, that was an open cultural question. The left had The Daily Show and Last Week Tonight with John Oliver, not to mention other liberal-leaning hosts like David Letterman, Stephen Colbert, and Jimmy Kimmel. The right had no one. That is, until Greg Gutfeld.
Formerly a health and men's magazine editor, Gutfeld joined Fox News in 2007 to host a later-than-late-night chat show called Red Eye. Then he worked his way up the schedule until 2023, when his new show, called Gutfeld—it's got an exclamation mark at the end—moved to weekday nights at 10 on the East Coast and started dominating.
Its format is a little different from traditional host-driven late-night shows, because rather than chat with celebrity guests, Gutfeld presides over a roundtable of regular panelists, Kat Timpf and Tyrus chief among them. The overall vibe is insult-heavy, defiantly anti-woke, and relentlessly pro-conservative. It's a highly successful formula. The show averages over 3 million viewers a night, numbers that dwarf its competitors.
But if Gutfeld, who also hosts Fox's daytime show The Five, can now credibly call himself the king of late night, his kingdom is in turmoil. Earlier this year, CBS announced it was canceling The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. And as you probably know, Jimmy Kimmel's show was briefly suspended after comments he made related to Charlie Kirk's murder. Both decisions were viewed by many as politically motivated and also as possible threats to free speech.
This is coming at a time when questions about the future of late night, as well as censorship and comedy, are thick in the air. All of which Gutfeld, in highly provocative fashion, had plenty to say about. Here's my conversation with Greg Gutfeld.
Interview begins
Greg.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes.
David Marchese
Thank you for being here.
Greg Gutfeld
My pleasure.
David Marchese
I want to start with the biggest story in late night this year, or biggest stories, I should say, which are the impending cancellation of Colbert and Kimmel's suspension.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah.
David Marchese
Do you remember what your immediate reaction to the news of both was?
Greg Gutfeld
I guess... Why did it take so long? Because I crushed them like bugs, David. I crushed them and threw them into the wind, and they were still here. I call it entertainment welfare. The only reason they were around for so long, despite the fact that their numbers were dropping, was that they toed the line. So when I heard that they were gone, it really didn't surprise me because the numbers were saying it.
I don't think it was political. I know a lot of liberal friends who watched them. And I think it's because it wasn't entertainment anymore. It was more like a therapy session for people that were upset at the world.
David Marchese
So you don't give any credence to the notion that there were larger corporate political considerations that went into what happened with both Colbert and Kimmel?
Greg Gutfeld
I think people understand that there's never been anybody who's ever really folded because of Trump saying you suck. If the numbers were there, it wouldn't make any difference. Was it extra noise in the story? Probably. But I honestly think the grumbling was already there.
David Marchese
You described both their shows as being akin to therapy sessions for people who are mad at the world.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes.
David Marchese
Is there not a way in which your show functions similarly?
Greg Gutfeld
Oh, no. Our show is fun.
David Marchese
But you can be fun and mad at the same time.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, you can. But generally, I like to be at least part of the punching bag. And I encourage that among the guests. If I come off as petty about something, they have to come after me for being equally as absurd and stupid. I enjoy that. The teasing makes it fun. And also, I genuinely like people that I tease. In fact, if you want to know the people I don't like, it's the people I don't tease.
David Marchese
So you must love the women on The View then?
Greg Gutfeld
Yes. I adore Whoopi. And I like the other lady.
David Marchese
Rosie O'Donnell, you must be a big fan.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, Rosie, I love her. But personally—and I guess I put people I don't know in a different kind of room—but I make fun of everybody that I love. Relentlessly. There are a lot of conservative commentators who will not be teased. This is a very serious vocation. I think the success of my show and the success of The Five is based on the ability to tease. People try to replicate The Five and they don't understand. The secret sauce is that we make fun of each other. And I think that is something that you don't see on the left at all. I think we're the only people doing it.
You asked me something else. I forgot what it was.
I do think there are issues that upset me, but I have to always step back and go, this thing cannot take over my life. Trump derangement syndrome is now an addiction. It's moved into something that creates a filter, where everything you look at—the people you know, your coworkers, your relationships—are all seen through this. If you don't see this my way, we're going to have a problem. So I try to always, no matter what the story is, put it back in its box so it doesn't become something that I think about and change the way I view people.
David Marchese
You don't think there's a way in which your show also sits behind a Trump filter? And if people don't agree fundamentally with the positions that are sympathetic to Trump, that's upsetting for people?
Greg Gutfeld
I look at it—
David Marchese
It's like you're saying it only works one way. And to my mind, watching the show, it seems like clearly—
Greg Gutfeld
I think the difference is—Trump influences in both directions.
David Marchese
Yeah, but there's a key difference here—
Greg Gutfeld
Let's say I may think you're wrong. You might think I'm evil. That's where the difference is. The teasing and the ridicule is not "you're Hitler" or "you're a fascist" or "an authoritarian." If I insult you over the top, it's because it's obviously a joke. But I don't put a target on your back.
David Marchese
To be clear, I think you're being a little disingenuous.
Greg Gutfeld
Am I really?
David Marchese
In some of your—I read all your books, you know.
Greg Gutfeld
Really?
David Marchese
Yeah. I would go through and mark it. The most blatant counterexample to what you're talking about is you literally use the phrase, "the left are dumb fascist mother effers."
Greg Gutfeld
Ah, what book was that?
David Marchese
I want to say it was in your most recent one, The King of Late Night. I could be wrong, but it's in one of your books.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. I'll have to look back at that. What was the context? The left?
David Marchese
Yeah.
Greg Gutfeld
Who was I talking about?
David Marchese
The left.
Greg Gutfeld
No, but I mean—I don't remember the specific context. And was it part of some kind of amplifying narrative where it's like these people are a threat to democracy? It's going to lead to World War Three? This is the most damaging thing that has happened in the United States, I believe, because if you look at everything from the Palisades fire to Charlie Kirk getting shot, these are all the product of amplified narratives. The repetition, the brainwashing, the persuasion of being told over and over again.
I'd have to look at that and see what I said. I imagine that it was in some kind of paragraph of hyperbole where I was having fun. Because if it was in all caps, especially, or I could have been mocking the actual language. I don't know. I'd have to trust you on that. You seem like a nice guy for now, anyway.
David Marchese
Well, anyway, go ahead.
Greg Gutfeld
I know where you're going.
David Marchese
Where do you think I'm going?
Greg Gutfeld
I was going somewhere else.
David Marchese
Oh, good, good. Then go somewhere else. But where did you think I was going?
Greg Gutfeld
I thought you were going to bring up the world of insults and ridicule, because you were talking about insults.
David Marchese
Oh, that was not where I was going. That might come up later.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes.
David Marchese
But you've been the top-rated host in late night for a minute now. And you sort of, kind of like you did right at the top of our conversation, you hold that up as a triumph over—
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, but I'm having fun.
David Marchese
You're having fun.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, it's kind of like the same thing that Trump does where he says, "I got the biggest crowd." It's just something fun to say. But more people say it to me than I say it to anybody else.
David Marchese
A lot of people, when they have commented on your success, they fold it in with this idea that prior to Gutfeld, there hasn't been a hit conservative late night show. Do you think there's something that you cracked the code with? Or do you think it's just right time, right place because of changes in the culture? Why hasn't there been?
Greg Gutfeld
I think it's a little of both. One is that late night shows were not political and then they became political. Half of the population doesn't share those politics, so they're for the taking. They don't want Kimmel or Colbert in their living room telling them they're stupid for voting for Trump. So there are all those people.
But then the other thing is what you said about the change in the culture. Everybody was walking around going, "Am I going to get canceled? Do I have to be scared of not just what I'm saying, but what I'm thinking? Do I actually change my behavior?" And I had always been about sharing the risk. Somebody's got to do it. Like J.K. Rowling in the trans debate—she's a billionaire, she can share the risk. She has F-you money. But I thought somebody has to break the ice and say, "I'm here and I'm going to do this."
Whether it's Rogan or Tim Dillon or Theo Vaughn—Shane Gillis is a great example. He was a guy that was shoved off to the side because he didn't fit the right formula for SNL, and then he comes back four years later and is hosting it.
David Marchese
But do you actually see Kimmel, Colbert, and Fallon as competition?
Greg Gutfeld
Not really, because you do very different things. But you do seem to use them in a way as foils.
David Marchese
Yes, absolutely. In fact, I know myself enough that I do need foils.
Greg Gutfeld
Why?
David Marchese
Like I talk about this with Jessica Tarloff a lot. When I'm writing my notes for The Five, I have her in my head. She's my muse. Like, "Okay, what is she reading? How is she going to respond to this?" It's very helpful to have that rather than just writing for myself. When I was in men's magazines, my foils were Esquire, GQ, Details. I just made fun of them all the time. I think it helps sharpen my identity. It reminds me of what I am, which is not them. I know that's circular.
Is there any kind of actual animosity there? Because I was looking up stuff you said about Colbert. You call him a "smug loser" or something like that. The one that stood out for me about Kimmel was—let me make sure I get this right—"If that man was any more full of shit, he'd be a colostomy bag." Does it not tip over into personal animosity?
Greg Gutfeld
This is where I thought you were going to go earlier. I have this thing called the hierarchy of smears. If you, at the top of the hierarchy of smears, call somebody a fascist who's going to destroy the world, I can call you anything. I made this point in an article by the New York Times, but they didn't include it, which bummed me out.
The writer had asked me—she was in the audience watching the show—and she said, "During the show, you made all of these fat jokes. There were so many of them. And I'm sitting in your audience and I'm thinking, there's some overweight people here." And I said, "Yeah, but they didn't call me Hitler." And that's the difference.
It goes back to the framing. I think you're wrong. You think I'm evil. And I'm never going to call somebody fat because they're fat. I'm going to call you fat if you called me Hitler. In the hierarchy of smears, that's way down here. And the best part about it is it hurts them. It hurts them more than if they were to call me Hitler, because they have to look in the mirror every day. I know I'm not Hitler. They know they're fat.
David Marchese
It's charming.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, what?
David Marchese
That's a charming way of looking at things.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes. Kat makes fun of me over this. She says, "Greg, you're trying to turn calling people fat into a heroic endeavor." And it's like, yeah, pretty much. But again, just stop calling me a Nazi or Hitler or a fascist, and I'll lay off the physical stuff. The physical stuff doesn't come close to ascribing this moral evil to somebody that then generates animosity among people who might do something to you, who might come to your house. That's what I think. When I call somebody a name, I go, "This fucker deserves this shit." Does that make sense?
David Marchese
I understand what you're saying. That's not the same as saying I think it makes sense, but I understand what you're saying.
Greg Gutfeld
I'll take "I understand what you're saying" as making sense.
David Marchese
If you were to consult Colbert and Kimmel's writers about how they could make fun of you, what would you tell them?
Greg Gutfeld
Ooh. Okay, so height doesn't work because a lot of people make fun of my physical stuff, but I do that too. So I guess you could probably—
David Marchese
Where's your soft spot?
Greg Gutfeld
Where is my soft spot? I don't know. That's funny. I would like to think that you could make fun of me about everything. But I guess it's weird because I just explained that this is the thing—my hierarchy of smears. Maybe that is what it is. Maybe what gets me is when you call me Hitler. That might be my soft spot. That's the line. I guess.
David Marchese
There's the idea that you're willing to take risks in things you say and push against various orthodoxies. What would be the risky thing to say to your audience?
Greg Gutfeld
Hmm.
David Marchese
And are those risks you're willing to take?
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. What I don't say, Kat says. Kat and I disagree on a lot of stuff. She's more in the "live and let live" mode on the trans stuff. I am not. I believe in live and let live, but I think there's a compelling pressure behind this kind of preferential treatment that is disturbing and can lead to other things.
I'm always trying to figure shit out when it comes to spirituality, but I have offended my audience if I'm too flippant on religion. But I think my audience is pretty generous because they didn't exist until I got there. They're aligning with me in a way. So it would be surprising if there was something we disagreed on. For example, I say I'm pro-life. Most of those people are pro-life. Maybe that's why they came to me.
David Marchese
Do you remember what it was about religion that you said that offended your audience?
Greg Gutfeld
God. Might have just been using the Lord's name in vain. That will always piss people off. Also, religious people are such nice people. They make you feel bad when they don't write angry letters. They know—well, New York Times, product of the devil, David, let's be honest.
David Marchese
[Makes skeptical face]
Greg Gutfeld
Because this is gonna be in audio too, I just need to make it clear that I made an extremely skeptical face when you said religious people don't write letters.
David Marchese
No, no, I said—no, they write letters, but they're so polite.
Greg Gutfeld
Though, the ones I get—I'm telling you, man—it's like, "Greg, we always respect your opinions, but I must ask you, please refrain from using the Lord's name in vain." And then they will try to—it's like Penn Jillette said to me, he's an atheist. He's like—
David Marchese
Someone who works at Planned Parenthood might have a different opinion about how polite the religious—
Greg Gutfeld
Well, I mean, they are killing children, so.
David Marchese
That's part of the game.
Greg Gutfeld
In your face.
David Marchese
There's a book of yours from 2015 called How to Be Right.
Greg Gutfeld
Oh, yeah.
David Marchese
And in there, you wrote that ideological purity on the right creeps you out. Where do you see that ideological purity on the right today?
Greg Gutfeld
You know, it's funny. You notice that it's kind of been destroyed. That's weird. I haven't reread that book because I'm afraid there will be things in there that I have changed my mind on. And I should, because I've learned more in the last 10 years than I have in my entire life.
Ideological purity would be like drugs. This also shows you how you can flip so many times. I went for decriminalization. I believed that all drugs should be legalized. Basically the libertarian position.
David Marchese
Yes, the libertarian position.
Greg Gutfeld
In a weird way, people like me who make decriminalization arguments have the safety net. If I end up getting super high tonight, I'm not going to end up on the street tomorrow. So I have that luxury.
David Marchese
What about everybody else?
Greg Gutfeld
Right. It was an easy argument for me to make. It's almost like a cool virtue signal. But then you look around and go, "Wow, there's a lot of people here that are fucked up."
David Marchese
But you're bringing this up as an example of an ideological position you held that has changed.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes.
David Marchese
And I'm more curious about ideological positions that you might hold today that don't seem in line with contemporary conservative orthodoxy.
Greg Gutfeld
Oh, okay. Like you're saying the purity test thing is kind of outdated. Give me an example. I think foreign policy is a good one. I'm definitely America first. I had to be sold on that. I'm still wait and see on tariffs. Tariffs was an ideology. Anti-tariffs was an ideology. I just thought they were bad.
David Marchese
And also a libertarian position.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. Anti-free trade. And yet did that keep me from wondering if it might work or not? I don't know what happens. I still don't know. I know that it's a tool that you can modulate, but I don't know.
David Marchese
You gave two examples—drug decriminalization and tariffs—that are in line with a libertarian slant to your thinking. And it's clear from reading your books that there has been a libertarian thrust to your political thinking. And it's very easy to make the argument that President Trump's policies are problematic when it comes to libertarian politics.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, I don't think he fits any label. That's the thing.
David Marchese
So my question is, knowing that you do have this libertarian slant, are there aspects of what President Trump is doing that give you pause or cause for concern?
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, I guess the flag thing does.
David Marchese
What's the flag thing?
Greg Gutfeld
Going to jail if you burn a flag. I get it if it's somebody else's property, but if it's your flag, you can do whatever you want. That to me is a mistake. It's funny—I still don't really see Trump in any political party. I see him as the way Trump was before he was in politics: "Do whatever you want, just don't bother me."
David Marchese
Are there things that President Trump does that infringe on people's freedoms?
Greg Gutfeld
Let me think. I'd say the flag thing is a potential thing. I think sometimes, when he cleans up a mess, it can look like it is. But it's like, who else is going to do it? We're cleaning up a mess that was five years in the making. Illegal immigration is a good example. You can't make this mess and then stand off on the side and criticize the way we're cleaning it. Is there a softer approach? Maybe. But you've got to build credibility back to be able to criticize that.
David Marchese
You worked for a long time at Men's Health magazine. And also at Prevention magazine. I'm curious to know, given that experience and being familiar with health fads coming and going, what you make of the MAHA movement—Make America Healthy Again.
Greg Gutfeld
Well, it's weird. When I was working at Prevention and Men's Health, there were all sorts of movements. The anti-vax movement was very tough. It was always focused around this Lancet study that made a tie between vaccines and autism. It's been completely debunked, but it still existed. That used to drive me crazy. But I talked to people and I understand the concern about grouping. My wife is like this—she worries about the grouping of vaccines. And there are questions about other vaccines, whether it's COVID or Hep B or Hep C.
But I have a fairly skeptical eye. There was some weird shit working in health magazines. You'd come into the reverse circumcision movement—guys who wanted their foreskin back. There was a woman who once tried to convince me she could use sound waves to cure AIDS. I would run into the weirdest stuff.
David Marchese
Given your skepticism about that, doesn't it seem like there's a lot that's ripe to be made fun of with the MAHA movement and anti-vax stuff? And why don't you do it?
Greg Gutfeld
I do. I actually do.
David Marchese
You give a comment every now and then, like you let one slip, but you don't consistently make fun of it.
Greg Gutfeld
I've always said I'm critical. The autism thing I'm really worried about, but I'm waiting to see what happens.
David Marchese
What would you need to see happen?
Greg Gutfeld
That they say that it's not vaccine related, which I don't think it is. But I do think at least the dude's fit.
David Marchese
You're talking about RFK.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. And they're talking about exercise and they're talking about diet. It's this whole weird world from the Rogan sphere to RFK Jr. and Pete Hegseth. It's a renewed sense that taking care of yourself is not a bad thing.
David Marchese
From your book, The Bible of Unspeakable Truths: "I don't know shit when it comes to medicine, but that shit is still more than people like Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and everyone else who thought that vaccines cause autism."
Greg Gutfeld
Yes.
David Marchese
And now you're saying "at least he's fit."
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah.
David Marchese
This feels like a good trade-off to you?
Greg Gutfeld
You can have two thoughts in your head. I'm still critical of that. And I wonder if he is too. I think he has pulled back from that. But I felt like that was a really serious issue because it was feeding into people's beliefs about vaccines. If he's willing to pull out of that, which I think he kind of is, at least they're investigating it. But I still feel the same way. I would be shocked if they find a link. So I stand by that.
David Marchese
Nice job, though.
I hate to keep going back to your books, but there was something that was particularly interesting to me in a book you wrote a couple years ago called The Plus. Where you sort of lamented a problem that you called the "opposition toxin"—the inclination of the media to always see two groups in conflict. Could Gutfeld the show, or your career, be possible without the opposition toxin?
Greg Gutfeld
Yes. As long as it's funny. There are so many stories that you can cover without being either/or. I think I do plenty of them. It's the thing where you have to always be a party pooper with nuance. It's not exactly this way. I call it the prison of two ideas. Almost everything can be placed in that prison. Everything—foreign policy, feminism, gay rights, you name it. Either you're for or you're against.
We can't help but view the world through our personal context, particularly our personal emotional context. Emotions are where all ideas come from.
David Marchese
So I have some questions about your formative years. I know that when you were growing up, your dad was sick with cancer for most of your adolescence. And I think you wrote about how you would come home and help clean his wounds and do physical therapy with him when he was yelling in pain.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah.
David Marchese
How does that shape someone?
Greg Gutfeld
I think it probably kept me from having kids for a while. On a personal level, you never know what's going to happen with your family. I don't want to be—maybe I had done my child care when I was young.
David Marchese
For your dad.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. And maybe that was it. I don't know if it steered me into health journalism, but I was definitely interested in health and fitness. And that might have been because of my dad's illness. I had a curiosity. I remember taking genetics at Berkeley and it was fairly new, because of that. So I think it made me curious about medicine. And it probably made me reticent about starting families because you never know, which is a really stupid reason not to do it.
David Marchese
And so you have a one-year-old now?
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, well, she's 10 months.
David Marchese
10 months?
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah.
David Marchese
Are there ways in which being a father has changed your disposition to the world or what you would like the world to look like?
Greg Gutfeld
I don't think it can make me more anti-crime than I already was. When I'm walking around, I go, "Is this—do we have to move out of the city? What happens if we get this new mayor?" But it makes you forgive everything bad you did prior to that. Because you can't have a regret. You can't have a regret for something if you were to change that, this person wouldn't be here. Obviously, I wouldn't even know that Mira existed, and I would have Joey and Geronimo. But the thing is, I don't. I have this. And I'm like, "Fuck, I wouldn't change anything." Which is great, because if you spent decades being a reprobate, I can now say to myself, "Well, I was an asshole for these four years. These other years I was vacant. But it all led to this."
By the way, it's 12:15, dude. I got to go to work.
David Marchese
I know we're scheduled for another 15 minutes.
Greg Gutfeld
Oh, really? Those bastards didn't tell me that. Sorry to interrupt.
David Marchese
Also, just so you know, then we talk a second time.
Greg Gutfeld
Oh, well, it's fact checking.
David Marchese
Nope. No, it's a whole second part of the interview.
Greg Gutfeld
No, it's not.
David Marchese
Yep. It's shorter. Don't worry.
Greg Gutfeld
I'm not joking either.
David Marchese
I don't believe you.
Greg Gutfeld
It's true.
David Marchese
So I just want to—there were two stories in a book you wrote called Be Cool. Or Not Cool. Not Cool. I'm sorry. I have the specific title because the whole title really is important.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes, yes. Not Cool: The Hipster Elite and Their War on You.
David Marchese
In that book, there are two anecdotes that you mention still sort of linger with you. One involved a group of kids in the fifth grade.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes. The Sharks.
David Marchese
Do you want to quickly tell that story?
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. It was almost the first real experience I had with groupthink. I think it was after an episode of Happy Days or something where there was a gang in it. Everybody the next day wanted to be in a gang. They just decided they were the Sharks. But I wasn't going to be one. And I think I was mad because I wasn't even included in it. It was the first time I ever felt that.
David Marchese
You were being excluded.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes. Being excluded. And also how stupid they were acting as a mob. I think that has always been following me around a little bit.
David Marchese
In that book, you say your experience with this gang of kids was that you were banished, and you've sort of been banished ever since. And then you also tell a story about a kid named James. Do you want to tell me about James in kindergarten?
Greg Gutfeld
Oh, yeah. Boy, you're pulling shit out. That black kid?
David Marchese
Yeah.
Greg Gutfeld
It was weird because we were like best friends. Then I run into him, I don't know, maybe seven years later. And he saw me as a completely different person. Like I didn't exist. And it was just like, what happened?
David Marchese
And what do you think happened there?
Greg Gutfeld
I think that he realized we were two different races and that he had no need for me. That was basically it.
David Marchese
When I read those two stories—and again, it's because you single both of them out as being formative in the book—I thought these stories are about resentment at being rejected.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah.
David Marchese
I wonder how much resentment and also a desire to preemptively reject before you're rejected drives what you do now and formed your identity. Because the subtext of all your work—I've really immersed myself in it for a while—it's all "fuck you" to this other group. All of it.
Greg Gutfeld
I think that's simplistic, but there is a kernel of truth. I do think that almost all resentments have your role in it.
David Marchese
Right. I think it's fair to say. It takes two to tango.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. And I do think that—okay. Why do you get mad when somebody gets a promotion over you or you get fired and you get resentful?
End of Part 1
It's usually self-doubt. Maybe I may never be good enough. So I do think there's always going to be that feeling.
David Marchese
No, I'm saying that's what I would say in that example. Like, let's say somebody gets a promotion over me. I would ask, is that person better than me? I think that's a normal human thing. And I think I can feel that. I don't think I feel that anymore, but I'm sure back in the day I did. It's like, why is this person... When I would get fired, I would be pissed off. And I would forget the fact that when I got into my next role, it would be better. I didn't have faith in myself to actually do better.
Greg Gutfeld
Do you have long-term ambitions beyond what you're doing now? Is this what you want to be doing five years from now?
David Marchese
God, I'm 61. There are no long-term ambitions. I'm happy doing this. And I imagine that the vehicles might change. It feels like things are always going to be changing. But I have a feeling this is kind of what I'm doing for now. And now could be until I'm, I don't know, 75. I think 75 is a good year. I mean, I look great for 61. Let's be honest. I mean, look at this.
Greg Gutfeld
Debatable.
David Marchese
Thank you for taking the time today. We are speaking a second time. That's part of the deal. You can get mad at your publicist.
Greg Gutfeld
I am. I'm going to get mad.
David Marchese
It'll be next week. So you have a little time. The walk back to the office is going to be very, very cold with sharp looks back and forth. But thank you again for taking the time. And I'm looking forward to talking with you again.
Greg Gutfeld
You got it, buddy. Good to see you. Don't forget my pen.
After the break, we do indeed talk again. This time I call Greg up at home, and he makes his case for how the right got cool.
David Marchese
What is considered, I don't know, fun, is whatever upsets your teacher. This is where I think the real Trump fandom came into play among young people, was how much it pissed off their teachers.
Greg Gutfeld
Thank you.
David Marchese
My pleasure. So this is something that's been nagging at me. Earlier, you expressed this idea that a lot of damage has been done in the country as a result of what you called amplified narratives, politically oriented repetition, persuasion, kind of like brainwashing. And the thing that's been nagging at me is, help me understand how it's not at least a little bit hypocritical to say that, because even if it's nominally comedy that you're doing on *Gutfeld*, you're repeating the same ideas over and over again with slight variations. And those ideas basically being, the idiots on the left are ruining the country. So how are you not part of the problem that you're diagnosing?
Greg Gutfeld
I do my best not to call people Nazis. I do my best not to put targets on people's backs. Now, there might be times that I violate that, but I pretty much try to hold myself to that standard. So I don't think it's hypocritical. And when you call somebody Hitler, if I believe that you are Hitler, I would be morally wrong not to do something. And by the way, this is not an uncommon thing. Everything from the Democrats when it comes to trying to persuade is always fear. It's a threat to the planet. It's a threat to democracy. It's a threat to your children. If you do not agree with our beliefs on trans, this child will commit suicide. What would you rather have, a live daughter or a dead son? That's the rhetoric that I hear all the time. I try my best not to use it.
David Marchese
When people talk to me about the right, clearly there are people on the right that do this stuff. There's no question. There are crackpots. But they're almost... the crackpottery on the right is usually driven from an internal paranoia, an internal conspiracy. It's not welcome. It might be welcome in some chat rooms, but it's not welcomed in the media. In fact, we have a pretty good track record of distancing ourselves from crazy people.
Greg Gutfeld
Well, the Dominion lawsuit would suggest otherwise.
David Marchese
Well, I don't know. That's above my pay grade. I had nothing to do with that.
Greg Gutfeld
Why did you bring that up? I mean, it's kind of like... you score a point with that, but you know that has nothing to do with me.
David Marchese
Well, I think—
Greg Gutfeld
It's not a cheap shot. You can ask any questions that you want. You thought it was an unfair comparison. What does that have to do with me? I thought we were talking in a larger context about messages on the right and the left.
David Marchese
But I mean, I'm trying to figure out. I'm confused by that example, because what's the Dominion lawsuit involving people saying we need to kill people? I'm talking about a narrative that causes people to act violently.
Greg Gutfeld
I'm sorry, I have a little dog here that is driving me crazy.
David Marchese
That's OK. I understand the narrative you're bringing up. And I thought—
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, sorry, can I just finish? Since you get to bring up something, I get to bring up something, right?
David Marchese
OK, sure.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. So when we were leaving, this is the only thing that stuck with me. You said that you have a hard time getting people from the right on your shows. And you said it's probably because they feel that they don't need to do it or they know that there's a risk involved. And I understand that because I encountered the same thing with my show. There are people that will want to do my show, but they won't do it because there's a risk involved. But we still do, like I still did this interview with you, even though I felt that there was a risk involved and because of that I didn't want to do it. But you know who persuaded me to do it?
David Marchese
Who?
Greg Gutfeld
Fox. Fox wanted me to do this because anytime there is something like this, Fox will say, this is a great thing to get out in front of people and let them hear you. And I'm like, what's the point? I don't see the point. So I think people have to understand that we put ourselves out there when almost from my personal experience, nobody ever does. By the way, are you OK with me talking about this? I don't know the answer. I apologize. It's just that it stuck with me because I was thinking, you know what? I didn't want to do this interview because I was weighing the risk benefits and I couldn't see the benefits, but I could see the risks. I think I said to you, like, why walk a tightrope between two buildings when you could just cross the street?
David Marchese
No, sorry, Greg, I understand that. I appreciate you taking the risk. And again, I just want to say perhaps my comparison was not a fair one. The reason I brought it up, and maybe I was misunderstanding the point you were making, but the reason I brought it up is because I interpreted what you were saying as being that we, being Fox, doesn't have a place for conspiratorial thinking. And then when I heard that, I thought, well, there's evidence, the evidence being the Dominion lawsuit, that no, Fox did have a place for conspiratorial thinking.
Greg Gutfeld
Gotcha. Yeah, I was focusing on things that put my life or your life at risk, those kinds of things. That other stuff, the conspiracy type stuff. To me... I'm holding a dog toy. I can't see myself, so I have no idea what I'm doing. But right, G? Sorry. I want to move on from this subject. I'm sorry, but he's driving me nuts. And I'm alone, so I can't really put him anywhere.
David Marchese
No, it's nice to get a glimpse of what Greg Gutfeld's life is like when he's on his computer. If anything, it helps create a sympathetic portrait of you.
Greg Gutfeld
I got this from reading a book on power. Have a dog show up in the middle of an interview.
David Marchese
This is not even your dog. It turns out it's a prop dog. There's a whole company that rents out prop dogs for contentious interviews with the liberal media. This is a conservative organization. And get this. These are strays. These are strays. And after we use them in the industry, put them back on the street.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah, they're back on the street. But they get a good meal. Go away. Go away.
David Marchese
There's an idea that I've heard you express. It's one that I've heard other comedians express too. Andrew Schultz has said it. And that idea is that the right is now the cool side and the left are the scolds, the wet blankets. And you wrote a whole book about it called *Not Cool*, defining yourself in opposition to being cool. And I just want to know, how do you think about what cool is now and what benefits it confers on you and also what flaws it might conceal?
Greg Gutfeld
It's a good question. So I wrote, it must have been like 20 years ago, it was called the Dean Wormer Effect. And it was about how as... Is that the *Animal House* dean?
David Marchese
Yes.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes. It's like the way people view conservatives versus liberals is Dean Wormer in *Animal House*. The liberals are Animal House. The conservatives are always Dean Wormer. And my goal was to flip that. And it had to come down to humor, how people take a joke. So I think what is considered, I don't know, fun, is whatever upsets your teacher. And when you saw an overwhelming number... this is where I think the real Trump fandom came into play among young people, was how much it pissed off their teachers. And you saw this growth of people recording their teachers that showed up on Twitter and Instagram of a teacher talking about, if you vote for Trump, I'm going to fail you, stuff like that, where they think they're not being recorded.
They say something funny, then they get in trouble. So I think what happened was teachers represent the scold, the adult symbol of you can't do that. And that creates a whole thing of, oh, yes, we can. And that's kind of the flip. And in comedy, you're supposed to be the one that... I mean, that's where the class clown probably originates, is the comic is there to make the teacher crazy. Once the left got too comfortable, got into power, they realized they didn't have to have a sense of humor anymore. And that's why you saw a lot of people getting canceled and stuff.
David Marchese
Let's take that diagnosis to be true. Now that you are the cool one, does that carry any risks? Arguments you made in the past were that the people who are cool end up being condescending, dismissive, exclusionary?
Greg Gutfeld
I think there's two points to make. I am the last person to think that I'm cool.
David Marchese
We can agree on that.
Greg Gutfeld
Yeah. Well, thank you, David. Thank you. And I mean, I'm 61. And you make Dean Wormer references. I got a Frenchie sleeping at my foot. This is not cool. But there is a danger of when you ascend, and you replicate the very practices that you hate. That is a concern. I think that is a concern in every... I try, for example, I try never to say "that's not funny" because that shouldn't matter. Like if Kathy Griffin makes a joke about Donald Trump, if my first instinct is to go, "well, that's not funny," it doesn't matter whether it's funny or not. That's just what she says. That's fine. Not my cup of tea. But I'm not going to go and say, you know what the problem is? That's not funny. Funny is subjective. I'm telling you, as you probably know, there's an equal number of people who find me unfunny. And that's fine. I'm an acquired taste. So I have to remind myself that whether I find something funny or not is irrelevant.
David Marchese
Just the last question because I know you have to run. But what are you most idealistic about?
Greg Gutfeld
God, that's a schmaltzy question, but it has a schmaltzy answer. I really love life. And I used to be somebody that expected things to go my way. So when things went well, I just expected it. And when things didn't go well, I was pissed off. And it's a very simple filter flip. And now it's like, I expect everything to be difficult. And then when it goes well, I'm incredibly grateful. And that one little switch, it's literally a flip, has changed my life. I don't know if that's... I guess that's it. I should shut up because that's it.
David Marchese
You probably expected this to go badly and then it went well.
Greg Gutfeld
Yes, exactly right. If I expected coming into this interview that this thing was going to somehow change my life and I was going to own the libs, then I would be a cranky, cantankerous asshole. But in this case, I'm like, we'll see what happens. He'll probably have some penetrating questions. He'll probably try to psychoanalyze me. He might even bring up Dominion. But knowing that ahead of time, I'm pleasantly surprised. David is not a bad guy. He doesn't mind my dog.
David Marchese
That's Greg Gutfeld. To watch this interview and many others, you can subscribe to our YouTube channel at youtube.com slash at symbol the interview podcast. This conversation was produced by Wyatt Orm. It was edited by Annabelle Bacon. Mixing by Sonia Herrero. Original music by Dan Powell, Rowan Nemisto, and Marian Lozano. Photography by Philip Montgomery. Our senior booker is Priya Matthew, and Seth Kelly is our senior producer. Our executive producer is Alison Benedict. Video of this interview was produced by Paola Neudorf. Cinematography by Zebediah Smith, with additional camera work by Andrew Smith and Thomas Trudeau.
Audio by Nick Pittman. It was edited by Caroline Kim. Brooke Minters is the executive producer of podcast video. Special thanks to Rory Walsh, Renan Borelli, Jeffrey Miranda, Nick Pittman, Maddie Macielo, Jake Silverstein, Paula Schumann, and Sam Dolnik. Next week, Lulu talks with journalist Tina Brown about the Royals, Jeffrey Epstein, and how the magazine world has changed since her days editing *Vanity Fair* and *The New Yorker* in the 80s and 90s. This was when work was so much fun. It's like all the fun has come out of work. This was a period that I lived through where it was this hell for leather pursuit of great stuff.
And the offices of *Vanity Fair* were just the HQ of interesting, adventurous talent. I'm David Marchese, and this is *The Interview* from *The New York Times*.