Main Topic: The succession drama surrounding Rupert Murdoch's media empire, specifically the battle over control of the Murdoch Family Trust.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ryan Knutson
Few succession dramas have been watched more closely than the ones surrounding Rupert Murdoch's media empire. It was a long-running question. I mean, for the past 20 years or so, people have been wondering who would succeed Rupert, and each of his sons seemed like the heir apparent at various points.
Amol Sharma
That's our colleague Amol Sharma. When Rupert retired from the boards of his companies last year, Amol said it felt like the world finally had an answer. What's really at stake here is succession. So it was a really big moment. He was stepping back and it was symbolically was sort of transitioning power to his oldest son, Lachlan.
Ryan Knutson
Breaking news this morning, a new line of succession at Fox News. Lachlan Murdoch will become News Corp's sole chairman and continue as Fox's chair and CEO. This is a historic day. I mean, what a time of transition for this news network.
Amol Sharma
Lachlan was the chosen son. He was now the head of the multi-billion dollar family business, which includes Fox News, Fox Sports and News Corp, the parent company of the Wall Street Journal.
Ryan Knutson
And did it seem at that moment like it was over, like the decision had been made? it's Lachlan.
Sound of a pause
I think on its face, you looked at it and said, wow, clearly Lachlan is his favored leader. But people who follow this stuff closely and have paid attention to the companies know that the real power in the Murdoch empire is in this family trust.
Amol Sharma
The Murdoch family trust controls about 40% of the voting shares for both Fox and News Corp. And right now, Rupert alone has that control. But that changes when the 93-year-old dies. According to the trust, Rupert's voting control will be split evenly between Lachlan and three of his siblings.
Ryan Knutson
And so the trust itself didn't change last fall. So we were looking at each other and I was calling around and asking folks I know close to the companies, are they changing the trust? Is Lachlan getting control of that?
Amol Sharma
It turns out, Rupert is trying to give Lachlan control of that trust. But those three other siblings are fighting back. This is about who's going to control a sprawling business empire. And this is basically the series finale of this long-running succession battle.
Ryan Knutson
Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Ryan Knutson. It's Tuesday, September 17th.
Coming up on the show, the legal fight over who will control the Murdoch empire. We'll be right back.
Deals, brands, wow. Tuesday on NBC, Jimmy Fallon and Bozema St. John host a highly anticipated new competition show.
I hired 10 creatives from all walks of life. They will be battling it out to see who can impress the world's biggest brands. This is a huge opportunity. This is the battle for the next big idea. This is not play play. We're spending millions of dollars.
I'm so excited to embark on this adventure with all of you. Make the best idea win! On brand with Jimmy Fallon. Series premiere Tuesday on NBC.
While the Murdochs have said nothing publicly about this case, Amol and his team of reporters spoke to a number of people familiar with the conflict to piece together the years of tensions that led to this court battle.
Amol Sharma
The trust at the heart of this legal dispute dates back to Rupert's 1999 divorce with his second wife. Basically she wanted to make sure that her children Lachlan, James, and Elizabeth would have an ownership stake in the Murdoch businesses in the future.
And so an irrevocable trust was created that gave them some authority in the future once Rupert dies. And what does it mean when a trust is irrevocable? It just means that it's somewhat challenging to alter the trust plan.
There's some bar that you have to meet. In this case, there's a term in this trust that would allow Rupert to make some changes if he can show it's in the best interest of all stakeholders.
Ryan Knutson
So is this kind of irrevocable trust unusual? It's not unusual to have a trust like this, nor is it that unusual to try to change a trust. It's just that usually those changes are minor.
It's usually not a change to determine who controls the multi-billion dollar media empire. So this is definitely unusual as far as trusts and estate cases go.
Amol Sharma
Rupert has a total of six children from different marriages. But the trust says that only the oldest four will inherit voting power and therefore control of their father's businesses.
Basically, as it's worded now, if Rupert were to die, his four oldest children would each have an equal voting share in the trust.
So that would mean they would have to vote on any major strategic decision. Major strategic decisions include things like whether to sell the company or buy a competitor and who gets to sit on the company's board.
Ryan Knutson
The true power in the Murdoch empire is in this family trust. That's where the holdings in Fox and News Corp lie.
Amol Sharma
So the question of succession has always been, who will control that trust? Although Rupert formally gave his oldest children equal power in the trust, it didn't end up preventing competition between siblings.
Specifically, when it came to the question of who would call the shots at his companies once he retired. For years, that competition seemed to be between Rupert's two sons, Lachlan and James.
Both of them had a lot of experience and also had their own, you know, individual dramas or trouble points along the way.
Ryan Knutson
So Lachlan Murdoch, the older one, he started in the company in 1994. He rose through the ranks to a fairly senior executive position.
And then in 2005, when he was feeling somewhat undercut by his father on some business decisions and wasn't happy at the company, he left and went back to Australia to live there, got involved in other business ventures.
Amol Sharma
Meanwhile, younger brother James started a hip-hop label after dropping out of Harvard. But by the mid-1990s, he'd also made his way over to News Corp.
He also rose through the ranks of News Corp and had different positions in Europe and Asia over the years rising to a pretty high level.
He was overseeing the UK publishing division when this big phone hacking scandal was erupting more than a decade ago.
Ryan Knutson
There were building tensions between James and Rupert for years, but they really started to accelerate around the time when Rupert sold a big chunk of Fox to Disney in 2019.
Amol Sharma
The Walt Disney Company is buying a large portion of 21st Century Fox. That includes its movie and TV studios, the Hulu streaming service, and a number of hit franchises.
The deal was announced this morning by Disney CEO, Bob Iger. The expected value is about $52 billion.
Ryan Knutson
And when that happened, James had designs on getting a senior role at Disney. That didn't happen, and I think he was disappointed at that.
Amol Sharma
Tensions deepened when Rupert asked each of his four oldest children to give him part of their roughly billion payouts from the Disney deal.
Lachlan, Elizabeth, and Prudence did so as a sign of respect. But James refused.
James tenure as the CEO of Fox ended after the Disney deal. And a year later, he resigned from the board of News Corp.
He was critical of his father's businesses in his resignation letter, and even more pointed in private.
Ryan Knutson
One major piece of tension was Fox News. James has been critical of Fox. He's told people he's disturbed by what he sees as this extreme right turn at Fox, particularly since the 2020 election.
Amol Sharma
When Rupert proposed merging the two companies, News Corp and Fox, together in 2022, James actually lobbied against the deal.
He wrote letters to the boards of the companies laying out his objections, saying that it didn't make sense, saying it would contaminate brands in the company like the Journal.
Ryan Knutson
and that was just another reason for the strains in this relationship.
Amol Sharma
So what is James' relationship with his father like now? Well, it's really distant. They're not on speaking terms, is what we're told.
Ryan Knutson
But I think there's a sadness, you know, certainly from Rupert's side, by all accounts, even though they don't speak.
Amol Sharma
He's sort of sad about the way this has played out. James didn't come to his 90th birthday party a few years ago.
Ryan Knutson
So yeah, I think there's some sadness too.
Amol Sharma
As James grew more distant from Rupert, Lachlan was getting closer.
The older brother had returned to the business years earlier. After the Disney deal in 2019, he was named CEO of Fox and co-chair alongside his father.
And then last fall, Rupert solidified Lachlan's leadership position when he stepped back, leaving Lachlan the sole chairman of his companies.
Ryan Knutson
But to make sure Lachlan actually controls the companies after he dies, Rupert needed to make changes to that irrevocable Murdoch trust. That's next.
Only murders in the buildings, he said five. The hit Hulu original is back.
The night Luster died. He was talking with his mobster. Was he killed in a hit? We need to go face-to-face with the mob.
Get ready for a season. Buongiorno, signore! This is how I die. You can't refuse. You're gonna save the day like you always do by being smart, sharp, and almost always find mistake.
The Hulu original series. Only murders in the building. Premieres September 9th. Streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+. For bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
New episodes Tuesdays.
it's pro savings days at Lowe's get up to 35% off select major appliances and save an additional $1,000 when you buy four select lg major appliances plus get a free dewalt 20 volt max 5 amp hour battery when you buy a select dewalt 20 volt max tool get the job done for less at Lowe's we help you save valid through 926 selection varies by location while supplies last see associate or Lowe's.com for more details and qualifying items.
Yesterday, Rupert Murdoch arrived at a court in Nevada, where the Murdoch Family Trust is based, to kick off legal proceedings over his family empire.
Mr. Murdoch, are you confident of victory? Any comments?
After he stepped down as chair of Fox and News Corp last year, Rupert filed a proposed amendment to his trust.
It said, when I die, voting control of this trust should pass to Lachlan instead of passing to all four of my oldest children.
Amol Sharma
James, Elizabeth, and Prudence, the other siblings, how did they all feel about Lachlan being chosen? They basically feel like if they are part of the family, this has been part of their inheritance all along.
And if Lachlan is going to wind up being the one in control, at the very least, there should be some kind of economic transaction, some financial deal to buy them out of the trust.
They shouldn't just get written out of the trust which is what Rupert is proposing to do.
Ryan Knutson
Why would Rupert want James and Elizabeth and Prudence the other siblings, not to have control over the company?
Amol Sharma
Well, for one, he was concerned that there would be paralysis in making any major decisions if you had four people essentially making the big decisions about the future of the Murdoch business empire.
He's also afraid that if James and his sisters were aligned with one another, that they could sort of gang up on Lachlan three-on-one and prevent him from running the company, or they could push for big changes at Fox News, try to make it more centrist, try to make it, you know, maybe that would undermine its appeal to conservatives.
Ryan Knutson
At least that's what Rupert's fear was.
Amol Sharma
Why doesn't Rupert just pay them out and buy out their stakes? They've looked over the years at doing some kind of buyout of the other siblings.
Most recently, I'm told that was in 2020. But it's pretty expensive. The value of the Murdoch business empire is around $6 billion for the family.
So this wouldn't be cheap. And you'd probably have to raise a lot of money. And that's been difficult.
Ryan Knutson
Didn't Rupert see this moment possibly coming? I mean, he put this framework that all four kids would have an equal vote into an irrevocable trust.
Amol Sharma
Like, did he not anticipate that this might create some infighting or that he might want to have only one of them have all the power?
Ryan Knutson
This is really puzzling to people around the companies because it looks like a recipe for a big problem.
Amol Sharma
But I guess, you know, parents might not be able to imagine that their kids would be unable to agree on how to run a family business.
Ryan Knutson
It seems like, well, we all love each other and we're all related. That won't be a problem.
Amol Sharma
And then as the time went on, as years went on, it just became clearer and clearer. Actually, this is going to be a huge problem, particularly in the last maybe five or six years.
Ryan Knutson
And how big of an impact do you think the result of this trial will have on the Murdoch media empire itself?
Amol Sharma
I think if Lachlan prevails and Rupert is successful in giving him control, I do think that when Rupert Murdoch dies, there could be more swift decision-making and clarity over strategy one way or another because one person would be in control.
Ryan Knutson
It would be much more like the kind of authority that Rupert himself has had all these years.
Amol Sharma
So that's probably the biggest implication.
Ryan Knutson
There's a lot of strategic questions that will be facing these companies right now on the television and Fox side.
So that would all fall to Lachlan.
Amol Sharma
And I think if this trial plays out where Rupert's successful, you'll see Lachlan Murdoch start to put his imprint on the empire in a much more definitive way.
Ryan Knutson
The trial is closed to the public, although several news organizations have been trying to get it opened up.
Amol Sharma
Meanwhile, Amol and our colleagues will be talking to their sources to try and figure out what happens.
Ryan Knutson
So what are you going to be watching for as this trial plays out?
Amol Sharma
I think we're going to be watching for whether Rupert Murdoch's wishes are fulfilled here.
Ryan Knutson
This is towards the latter stages of his life. He's 93. He's decided to get his affairs in order in this particular way.
Amol Sharma
And will that happen? And however this case plays out, we're going to find out when Rupert Murdoch leaves the stage, who's going to be in charge.
Ryan Knutson
That's all for today, Tuesday, September 17th.
The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and the Wall Street Journal.
Additional reporting in this episode by Jessica Tunkul, Alex Frangos, Catherine Sayre, and Keech Hage.
Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.