Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the California home insurance crisis, focusing on State Farm's decision to drop thousands of homeowners, including Sandra Kaler, in high-risk areas, and the subsequent impact on the state's insurance market.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Music plays, then fades out
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business and power. I'm Jessica Mendoza.
Pause
It's Wednesday, February 19th. Today, we're talking about State Farm, the L.A. fires, and California's home insurance crisis.
Pause
Our guest, Sandra Kaler, is a 74-year-old woman who lived in the Pacific Palisades neighborhood in Los Angeles for 38 years. She's here to share her story.
Sandra Kaler
I can tell you about my house in L.A. It was homey. It had a view of the ocean. It had a deck on top. It was home.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
Sandra, you must have so many memories of the place. Do you have a favorite memory?
Sandra Kaler
It's hard to say. But one thing that stands out is when the kids would have friends over. They didn't think I noticed, but it was pretty special that they would do that.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
That sounds lovely. But I understand that your home was recently destroyed in the L.A. fires. Can you tell us about that?
Sandra Kaler
Yes. We were contacted by State Farm, and they told us they were dropping us from their insurance policy. We had to find a new policy, and it ended up being much more expensive.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
I see. And what about the California Fair Plan? Did you end up using that to insure your home?
Sandra Kaler
Yes, we did. But the coverage was much more limited, and the rates were much higher.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
I'm so sorry to hear that, Sandra. It's clear that this has been a very difficult experience for you.
Pause
Now, let's talk about State Farm. Our colleague, Jean Eaglesham, has been investigating the company's decision to drop thousands of homeowners from their policy.
Jean Eaglesham
Yes. State Farm was the biggest home and auto insurer in the country, with over 90 million customers. But in California, they had a unique situation. They were expanding into high-risk areas, while other companies were pulling back.
Pause
And it turned out that State Farm couldn't afford to be there. They were taking on too much risk, and they needed to dramatically raise their rates, but they couldn't. In California, insurance companies can only increase rates with the approval of state regulators.
Pause
So, State Farm kept asking for small rate increases, but they knew they needed to do more. And then, in 2023, they changed leadership, and the new CEO, Denise Harden, decided to play hardball.
Pause
She went to the California regulators and asked for a rate increase of 28%. It was a shockingly high level in the context of the California market.
Pause
And then, in May 2023, State Farm pulled back on new home insurance policies. The move put more pressure on regulators, and it ultimately led to a decision to approve much bigger rate increases for the state's insurance companies.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
That's fascinating. And what about the California Fair Plan? How did it get into this situation?
Jean Eaglesham
The Fair Plan was created by the state to make sure all California homeowners have access to basic fire insurance. But it's been getting into increasingly perilous financial situation.
Pause
And because of the way it operates, it essentially has to take all comers. So it's skewed towards the highest risks. And that's why it's in trouble.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
I see. And what about State Farm's decision to drop thousands of homeowners from their policy? How did that affect the Fair Plan?
Jean Eaglesham
Well, it forced many more homeowners onto the Fair Plan. And because of the way it operates, it's now in an even more precarious situation.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
I'm so sorry to hear that, Sandra. It's clear that this has been a very difficult experience for you.
Sandra Kaler
Yes, it has. But I'm just glad to be safe, and I'm grateful for the support of my community.
Pause
Host (Jessica Mendoza)
That's all for today, Wednesday, February 19th. The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. Thanks for listening.
Music plays, then fades out
And don't forget to check out our show merch at wsjshop.com/collections/clothing.
Music continues to play
And if you want to learn more about this story, check out our further reading and listening links.
Music continues to play
Thanks again for listening, and we'll see you tomorrow.
Music continues to play