No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to The Knowledge Project. I'm your host, Shane Parrish, curator behind Farnham Street, which is an online intellectual hub of interestingness covering topics like human misjudgment, decision-making, strategy, and philosophy. But today we're going to be talking about wine, one of my favorite subjects. The Knowledge Project allows me to interview amazing people from around the world to deconstruct why they're good at what they do. It's more conversation than prescription. On this episode, I have Veronique Rivet, one of the most respected sommeliers in the world. She's been working in restaurants since she was 16.
She's entirely self-taught and has an amazing passion for wine. After placing twice in the top 12 in 2007 and 2010, she became the first woman to make the podium by taking second place at the world's best Sommelier competition in Tokyo in March 2013. She's the owner of Suave and Hall, which is quickly becoming one of my favorite wine bars. We explore the fascinating world of wine, how to taste, including an on-air tasting, tips and tricks for serving wine, and so much more. I'll apologize in advance for the audio. We had a goof with the recorder. This is definitely worth listening to. With that said, I hope you enjoy the conversation.
Welcome. Thanks for coming on. I've never interviewed a sommelier before, and you're one of the world's best, so this is incredibly exciting for me. Tell me how you got started with your love of wine. How many hours do we have? You know what? I never had a real... It's not as if I woke up one day and I decided I wanted to become a sommelier. it's really something that happened through different jobs, experiences, trips, people I met. I actually started working in the restaurant industry at about 16 years old as a student job. And my studies have been completely non-wine related. I did a BA in modern literature and languages, studying languages, and then an MBA in international trade.
But all that time I was working in restaurants. I ended up going to France for a year of study, turned into a seven-year stay, and looking for a job there. I found a job with a winemaker. And I thought, oh, this sounds cool. And I had been in restaurants for a while. I basically fell in love with the restaurant industry, with the service industry, the restaurant industry as a whole, and with wine and food. But every time I say that, I'm like, Who wouldn't, right? So it's really just all these, you know, a combination of jobs I held, of people I met, and all of a sudden I kind of realized, okay, this could actually become a real job.
I wasn't very glorious in my family when, you know, I wanted to be a waitress. Today it's well seen. They're kind of happy about it, right? So there's no elimination. It just kind of happened. Okay. Yeah. And what was it like living in France for seven years in terms of culture between here and there and the differences? And is that what really started your passion? No, it really fed it in a way, I guess. I always thought I was a citizen of the world. My mom's German. My father's French-Canadian. We've always traveled a lot as kids. It's something my parents instilled in all of us. My brothers are still great travelers.
and I thought I had no particular attachment to Canada and it takes that. You have to live elsewhere to realize how good you have it at home, right? And it did, that time I spent, so there was always this opening onto the world and European culture in particular, so it's not as if it was something new, it felt kind of natural, And in Quebec, there is this strong, you know, these strong links, cultural links to France. So it wasn't like, you know, a big shock or anything. But I really, really appreciated the food and wine culture. And being in Alsace, that's where I was for seven years, one of the best places to eat and drink.
It was, I really felt in my element. I just loved being around the winemakers. When I was working at this winery, I was constantly, you know, had my nose into the winemaker's lab, asking everybody questions down the cellar. You know, just really, really curious. Outside of the winery. Outside of the winery, so you were going to the actual vineyards and spending time there with the winemakers. Exactly. When did you start your process of becoming a sommelier? In France or did you do that when you came back? That's a good question. Again, there's such a kind of a seamless flow to everything I did that there's no real defining moment.
I think it all kind of falls together. But after those seven years in France, when I came back to Canada, I was seriously, the obvious choice was a restaurant job Because, again, the good thing about it is that there's always work when you work in the restaurant industry, right? So it was an easy thing to fall back onto. But I was starting to think, okay, maybe I could, you know, become a wine buyer for the SAQ or the LCBO. I didn't know how things worked back then. It's not as simple as that. So I started thinking of wine as more of a possible career choice. and when I came back, I was working in restaurants in France.
I came back here. I went directly to restaurants. It was kind of my comfort zone, and just kept evolving in restaurants. I think that it's an industry I really liked and that I felt comfortable in and I felt good in. And it's the first time. I didn't even know what a sommelier competition was. I didn't give myself the title of sommelier. And I am, I mean, even though I took every class I could during my whole life, I followed every class I could on wine, but at the base, I'm self-taught. Okay. Again, as I said, curiosity is something that really defines me, and so I would read everything. Just like when I was at the winemaker in France, I was always asking questions about everything.
I would read everything I could get my hands on. And so when I came back from France, I was in 94, went back to the restaurant industry, got a job also at the LCDO. started working quickly became a product consultant and uh i saw an ad go by for somebody competition and i thought huh i had just been back six months and in the country and i thought what better way to find out who's who who's doing what you know what's going on i had been away for so long and i had heard great things about the restaurant and the sommelier scene in quebec but was disconnected from it all um and so i signed up for that competition i thought you know if I'm going to go, I might as well do it, right?
There was 60 people doing the semifinals and six finalists, and I was expecting to watch the final, but I was called as one of the finalists. So two questions. I mean, what is involved in the path to becoming an official sommelier, and then what happens at a sommelier competition? Okay. Oh, there's two big questions. So how the path has evolved? I mean, there's still, in France, in Europe in general, they've had, I mean, it's a known trade, and they've had sommelier schools. There's a sommelier program in every hotel, restaurant, school throughout Europe. So it's something, it was actually difficult when I first went to France and thought, oh, I'll find a job as a student.
Those aren't student jobs. People train to become servers, to occupy every position in the restaurant industry. But it's much more recent that we have official sommelier training in schools in North America. We see it now more and more. I think we've had it again in Quebec for a certain time because of our links with France, because of many ways we have more resemblances. So it's slowly starting. I'd say in the last 10 or 20 years, we've seen more official programs for training sommeliers in North America. But there's also a lot still to be, well, I was going to say like every other training, I hope there's not a lot of surgeons that learn, you know, that are self-taught.
There's some professions where you don't want that, like pilots, surgeons. But in this industry, I think there's probably still a lot, and more so in North America, Yeah, because we're not as, you know, it's not as all compartmented into, you know, strict academic programs. And when you go to a competition, you have all these varying backgrounds competing for what's involved in the competition. That's a, we could talk hours about just that, but I love talking about it because for so many people, so many competitions are strictly tasting contests, right? The number of times, and I hate that, that I'm in public events and I have people walk up to me and stick a glass under my nose and say, what's that?
And I always say, I'm not a circus animal, you know? It's not. So I guess it's what people remember the most because it's the most impressive. People are always very impressed by somebody who, you know, does a blind tasting and says, okay, this is a Pinot Maw from Burgundy from such village from that year. I remember watching Somme and they were trying to do that. Have you seen the movie? And they're trying to do that. And it just blew my mind that you were even capable of doing something like that. So I think that's why people remember that because there is something impressive about it but what's really important, two things it's not just a guessing game there's really really serious knowledge needed to back up a tasting like that.
Oh of course. First of all in the tasting as such you're not going to get that many points from guessing what it is. It's kind of fun. We all love to do it. Right. And it's very showy and Exactly, right? But the most talented people in this business also learn humility very quickly, and we're the first to recognize that, you know, no, it's not easy. No, we don't guess it right every time. People going around bragging, oh, I always get blind tasting. They're usually not very knowledgeable. So the guessing what it is part is fun, but it's not the finality. I'd say the analytical tasting. it's analyzing the level of acidity, of sugar, of alcohol, of tannins, being able to qualify the tannins.
Are they ripe, unripe? Does it come from a hot year, from a moderate year, from a cool year? What kind of soil type might it come from? Has it seen oak or stainless steel or clay amphoras? If it's been in oak, was it new oak? So these are all things that take years and years of tasting training. and basically blind tasting is deductive reasoning so you just gather a whole bunch of and the tasting so that's how complex a tasting can be and the tasting is still just one part of the competition I'd say competitions are always threefold there's the tasting, there's obviously service because we are service people even though the world the word samargi has become very very trendy a bit like the chefs, there's all this kind of almost rock star status celebrity.
You would be one of those people, right? Yeah, I hate that kind of the sommeliers are servers. First and foremost. So somebody who calls themselves a sommelier and has never worked in the restaurant business in their life is not really a sommelier. A sommelier is a server. It's a wine specialized server. I always tell when I'm training young people that are starting, I say, if you find serving the slightest bit degrading, change business right away. Right? This is not, you should thrive on serving people. That's the basic, basic thing to start. So service as part of the competitions can be anything from how do you serve an old bottle of Bordeaux, how do you open a double magnum of champagne and serve it to how do you deal with difficult guests, right?
So it's a lot of tact and diplomacy. Wine and food matching is a huge part of our work, right? So being familiar with not only French cuisine, Italian, Spanish, Japanese, Mexican, you know, knowing the great cuisines of this world and being able to do wine and beverage matches, because it's not only wines. Somebody should be familiar with every beverage alcohol, spirits, liqueurs, beers, sakes, as much in terms of wine tasting as production, elaboration, different styles, and pairing. And then the biggest part, the third part, other than tasting and service, is theory. we're basically supposed to know everything and the theory is just so vast and continuously expanding.
I mean, we're way past the days where there was France and Italy as wine producers. China is the sixth or seventh world's largest producer of wine today. Brazil makes wine. Thailand makes wine. So knowing everything about great growing, so geology, climate questions, winemaking, which is essentially chemistry, all the grape varieties of the world, all the wine appellations of the world. So the theory is immensely vast. Nobody will ever know anything, but they can ask us anything. It's all for our game. Sounds like the only job better than mine, walking around tasting wine all day. Speaking of which, they dropped off two glasses here.
Can you walk me through a tasting and what we have? A wine tasting? Yeah. Well, wine for me, you know what it is. I'll tell you exactly what this is. So I don't even know. I sit down in a restaurant. They pour wine. Am I supposed to swirl? How do I actually go through it? You're supposed to enjoy it. Okay. That's the most important thing, and that's what anybody serving you should worry about the most, right? That's it. We're there to make sure people have a good time. So enjoying it is the basic thing. Then you can completely geek out about it, and we love to do that, right? And people are more and more into wine.
And I truly believe that pleasure increases with knowledge. And the more we know about wine, about the people who make it, the region it comes from, it really adds to the pleasure of tasting. Can you walk me through how you would taste this? How we do a tasting? Yeah, okay. So first of all, we're looking at three things, eyes, nose, and palate. And the visual examination of a wine is something a lot of people overlook, but it's full of clues to what the wine could possibly be. So we have, obviously, first is the color. So we have a slightly salmon pinkish wine. So it's a rosé wine. In certain wines, there will be variations of color.
When wines age, their color changes. Oak aging can impart color to wine. If it's the same grape from a super cool or a super hot climate, it's not going to have the same... It'll be a different color. It'll be a different color. So very, very slight differences, nuances, hues in the wine that can tell you a lot about what the wine is or where it comes from. Of course, you're never going to jump to a conclusion from just one clue. Right. Again, deductive reasoning. So we're combining all these clues together to come to a logical conclusion. The other thing that's obvious about this wine is... It's bubbly.
It's bubbly. See? I feel like a pro now. So it's got bubbles. bubbles could also be, it's not necessarily a sparkling wine. From the amount of bubbles here and they're continuous. It's not a lot. But still, it's more than if it was wine with just a little bit of CO2 trapped in it. Right. Because that could also be the case. Okay. Think of Vino Verde, certain wines that are bottled very young or can be bottled with a little CO2 in them sometime voluntarily to give them a bit more of that freshness of that spritz to it. But this looks like it is a fully sparkling wine. We can look at the, you know when people swirl their glass around, we talk about legs on a wine, so the tears that come down.
So when you swirl it around and you see the wine coming down on the inside of the glass, it can tell you about viscosity of the wine. So a combination of sugar, of alcohol, of body, usually the thicker the tears, the slower they are to form and to come down, the more full-bodied the wine will be. It could be in alcohol, it could be in sugar, it could be a combination thereof. I wish that people did that to aerate the wine. We swirl it around definitely to aerate it, but as the wine is coming down, you will watch the tears. It's something I didn't pay attention to for many years because you need glass in a perfect state, right?
There shouldn't be any residue of soap. So it's not the most trustable source of information. But it's something you can look at. Then, of course, we know it's rosé. We know it's sparkling. That's about all we know for now. It's a very light hue. Some rosés tend to be much darker. So it could be different grape varieties. It could be different styles of winemaking. Then we're going to smell it. And ideally, you want to smell it once before swirling it around. Okay. What time? First thing you're going to look at is, is the wine clean? Looking for faults. Are there any faults? Is the wine corked?
Is it oxidized? Is there something wrong with it? How do you tell a corked wine? By smelling a lot of corked wine. Okay. In the wine bar I have, every time we stumble, or wherever I am, if I'm doing an event, and there's lots of people help. If I have a bottle of corked wine, I always keep it and make people smell it. Okay. Because so many people don't know what a corked wine smells like. Some people confuse cork and oak. So it's a very distinctive smell, and you just need to smell it quite a few times to kind of memorize that smell, and then you'll instantly pick it up when it happens. Because it can be very, just a corked wine can vary tremendously in the intensity of its faults.
Some wines are so badly corked, you open the bottle and people 10 feet away will smell it. They say, oh my God, that's corked. others we're going to be there's going to be three of us you know pouring over the glass like is this it's not it's not perfectly clean something's wrong something's off but it's not so the intensity of the court smell can vary it's not always the same so sometimes and see we have a sparkling wine a lot of people I don't know why I think sparkling wine can not be corked oh okay I don't know why any wine can be corked port can be corked sparkling wine can be corked but there's this every time I have a corked sparkling wine, people so often, oh, I didn't know sparkling wine could be corked.
Yeah, of course. Any wine can, anything that's closed with a cork, a natural cork closure can be corked. So the wine is clean. It doesn't have any faults. And then we're looking at intensity. The intensity of the aromatics, because some grapes are much more aromatic than others. There's some highly aromatic grape varieties like Gewildströminer, Musca, Viognier. So when you have a very intensely aromatic wine, Already you've eliminated a whole bunch of others. Right. You know it's going to be. In sparkling wines, there's usually a limited number of grapes that are used to make sparkling wines worldwide.
There's probably lots, and there's always somebody somewhere doing something weird with an unheard of grape variety. But a lot of sparkling wines are either made with the champagne grapes, so Chardonnay, Pinot Noir mostly. Then you have the sparkling wines of Spain, the Cava, which have their own grape varieties, Prosecco in Italy. So there's these pockets of a few sparkling wines, specialty sparkling wines made in certain countries that have their own grapes. And then there are the ones that are made according to the Champagne model, which are made in Champagne but all over the world, in Canada and the United States and Germany, everywhere.
So at least we're not dealing with 2000 grape varieties. Usually when we're dealing with sparkling wines, right? Right now we're taking it down somewhere. So something we're going to look at when we're doing a sparkling wine is from the aromas and the taste and the quality of the bubbles, trying to define is it a wine that's been made in the champagne tradition or is it something else? So when we're smelling it, you look at the intensity. Sparkling wines are usually, unless it's made with an aromatic variety, are usually more discreet. They're not super big on the nose, right? They don't jump out of the glass at you.
There's always a certain finesse in the sparkling wines. This smells amazing. You like it? And, you know, the other thing is people are so afraid to say when you ask them, okay, what are you smelling? Everybody is so... There's been so much intimidation throughout the years with wine that people feel incompetent when you... And I always say, if I give you a plate of food, you know, I give you a dish, and most people will say if they like it or if they don't. Right. And if you ask them why, they'll probably be able to say why they like it or they don't. Give them a glass of wine and ask them their opinion, they're totally scared.
The vocabulary around it seems so impenetrable to... And yet it's not that different from food, right? We're dealing with taste, so there's obviously a lot of, you know, subjective personal preferences. but it's you know first of it just okay do you like it or not why do you like it okay yes the vocabulary is not there but like for you know not everybody has a chef's vocabulary for food either right um and and you develop that as you go but you have to to start to jump in to say what you think it's by expressing your thoughts and and tasting with others that can help you kind of you know put the right words on what you're thinking right um that that you'll get there But there's unfortunately been, over the years, so many people that have positioned themselves, you know, be it winemakers or wine writers or so-called experts, sommeliers, right?
I mean, this old image of the arrogant French sommelier. So many people have positioned themselves as having the ultimate truth. And we're going to, you know, we're going to teach you, poor, ignorant consumer, what good wine is. Right. Everybody's equipped to decide if they like the wine or not. What they like themselves. Exactly. Right? I disgress a lot. Oh, this is amazing. I love this. So this is, I know what it is, right? So it's a Cava. Okay. Well, actually, it's not a Cava, but it's from that region in Spain. Okay. Cava's a big, big, big industry. I love Cava. So a lot of really good, affordable sparkling wines are made under that denomination.
And they work with local grape varieties. Xarello, Macabeo, and Tarelada. three white grapes. There's a few others also, but those are the three main grapes used for Cava. So it's not champagne-like. It's not a champagne look-alike. They're using different grapes. It is made, though, in the traditional method. We're not supposed to say champagne method anymore, but so in the same way as champagne is made, which is considered the best production method for giving the better quality sparkling wines. But Cava is a huge Appellation with millions and millions of bottles made. And this producer is a producer I like a lot called Ravento Ciblant.
And they've been working really hard to try and get the standards for Cava higher. Because they thought there was too much low quality, a lot of really cheap supermarket wines in the category. Anybody can just label it Cava. Well, you have a certain cahier des charges, a certain protocol to follow in terms of elaboration. The grapes you're allowed to use, you have to make it a méthode traditionnaire, right? The whole elaboration is all, but still it wasn't sufficient to ensure the level of quality they wanted for the product. And there's a lot of really low quality Cava produced. So the standards of the Appalachian are not sufficient to distinguish between them.
Exactly, the more ordinary. And so they actually pulled out these guys. They don't call their wines Cava. So it's made in Catalonia, in Penedes, in the region. They're actually in the heart of the Cava production region with Cava grapes. But they pulled out of the Appalachian. They don't call their wines Cava anymore because they don't want to be associated with a brand that also has a lot of really low-quality products. So that's the long story on these guys, Ramento. So they now call their wines Conca del Rio d'Anoia, which is actually a geographical designation. Okay. It's the land where they are, where they grow their grapes and make the wines.
When do we finally get to taste? Go ahead, taste. So on the nose, we're looking for aromatics. We're looking for oak influence. We're looking for minerality. In the aromatics, what kind? Is it more fruit? Is it floral? Is it spicy? Is there a lot of non-fruit aromas, or is it just a big fruit bomb? And does your ability to distinguish those different smells come from smelling them and then smelling wine, and just over time again, kind of like the corked one? Our nose is like a muscle. It's one of our most, it's an amazing sense we have. It's the one we use the least. We're so dependent on our eyes that we completely underuse our nose.
we think we all can smell we know we can smell we think we're good at oh yeah i know what coffee smells like i know what basil smells like but try smelling those things blind not knowing what it is and you'll be surprised at how very common smells everyday smells people won't recognize once you're blindfolded because we're not used to developing our smell memory and that's anybody can do it. It's just an exercise. I've been doing it my whole life and I still do it. I'm far from being... How do you do that? You smell everything. Here in the kitchen, they're always laughing at me because I always go put my nose in everything.
I smell, I train my nose. I smell it. I smell when I'm gardening. I smell when I'm walking. I smell when I'm in traffic. Good smells and bad. It's just a question of training your nose. And yes, trying to sometimes I'll do it on purpose, right? Put out certain herbs certain vegetables whatever when I'm grocery shopping yes and and but the difficult part is again with your eyes closed or you are blindfolded to be able to remember the smells so those kind of instant recognition of aromas those exercises are are hugely important and they help in developing your your memory of smell and then we finally get to the tasting after the smell yeah and so So what do you do when you, and this is going to sound maybe ridiculous, but when you put it in your mouth, do you swirl it around, do you swallow it?
Do you have that gargling noise we made? Yeah. It's exactly the same thing you were talking about how we're swirling it in the glass. I said smell it the first time before swirling it, and then swirl it around, because it's basically oxygenating the wine to help release more aromatics. Some wines, there won't be much difference between not swirling it and swirling it. Some wines you'll smell much more once you swirl it around, right? Some wines are a little bit shy and the aromas need to be coaxed out. What we're doing in the mouth is exactly the same. It's just you take a little bit of wine in your mouth and you let some air in.
And you gargle the air through the wine. So once again, it's oxygenating it to smell it better. Because that's another important thing we talk about the palate. But in the mouth, we're talking about taste and smell. When you say a wine taste of strawberries or chocolate or vanilla, it actually smells of those things, right? There's only four, five, or six basic tastes. Oh, that's interesting. Sweetness, sourness. I always thought it was crazy when people are like, it tastes like chocolate. And I'm like, it doesn't taste like chocolate. Yeah. That's why you don't taste anything when you have a cold.
Right. Because you can't smell. So tastes are basically those things. acidity, sugar, bitterness, and salt. Those are the four basic. You can throw in umami. We won't go into that because people can look it up. It's a fascinating subject. And fat is also starting to be considered as a taste. So that's taste. And you can still taste when your nose is blocked. You can still taste when you have a cold. You'll taste sweetness and saltiness, But you won't smell. And so our palate and our nose are linked through the back of the throat, retronasal passages. And so that's it. When you have something in your mouth and you say, oh, it tastes of strawberries, it actually smells of strawberries.
You're smelling it, but from inside your mouth. Exactly, exactly. So that's why that putting the air through the wine in your palate helps you taste or smell it better, right, through the back passages. Okay, and then you swallow. And then are you looking for, I mean, I want to geek out on this for a second. Are you looking for, like this wine that we have here, I feel it on the front of my tongue more so than anywhere else, but that could be because I just aerated it. Okay, and that can be personal too. There's this other kind of slightly ridiculous notion out there that was vehiculated for years of a tongue map, whereas we taste this sweetness on the front of the tongue, acidity on the side, bitterness on the back.
That was a mistake from the start. It's hard to believe that it's been vehiculated. Sorry, there must be a better word for that. For so long because it was an error from the beginning. I mean, no such thing exists as a tongue map. We are all very, very individual once again as tasters. We don't perceive things the same way. You know that scientists say that there's actually not two people on the planet that will perceive the same food or the same beverage exactly in the same way. That's fascinating. That does not surprise me at all. But it also makes it difficult. That's why we establish these kind of protocols.
We have to talk common language. I love acidity. A wine that's super high in acidity will be just fine for me. For somebody who doesn't like acidity, that wine will be way too sour. So that person will say, that's super high acidity, and I'll say, no, it's just right. So we have to kind of calibrate ourselves, and that's also something you learn as you're tasting a lot. So what would be the acidity in this? In our technical jargon, we quantify everything precisely, so I'd say it's medium plus acidity. We'll go from high to medium plus to medium to medium minus to low. It's delicious, by the way.
Glad you like it for a Napa Cab drinker. That's quite a different style of wine. But so on the palate, when we talked about the aromas and the tastes, because acidity helps you define, right, the level of acidity in the wine, we're looking at aromas, tastes, but also structure, you know, kind of the mouthfeel. On top of letting the air through and kind of garnering with the wine, you're carrying it through your mouth, right? And to get a feel of the wine, of the weight, of how it coats your mouth, right? Some wines go down like water. Others have almost a creamy feel to them, right? So there's textural qualities that are different that can also tell you about a grape variety, about a climate, about winemaking methods, right?
so it's all these things combined that help you come to a conclusion that makes sense an educated guess based on really elimination it sounds like you're walking through what isn't and how do you know I always tell people how you become a taster well you just drink a lot so you taste a lot but that's it it just comes through years and years of training of tasting and rigorous tasting not sitting alone in front of the TV and chugging down bottles There has to be a method Almost like a deliberate practice Exactly And the necessity of doing it together One Foremost because wine to me Is about bringing people together That's the most important thing Is you have to enjoy it Hopefully you're not enjoying it alone It brings people together But for learning about wine also The exchange is necessary There's just so much you can learn from books At one point you have to confront your ideas with somebody else's.
I was talking about calibrating, right? You know, my high acidity, what is it for you and where do we meet? What's considered medium acidity and high acidity by the community at large, right? We kind of have to agree. So the importance of tasting with others to make sure you're on the right track and you're calibrating. And what books would you say recommend for not only the beginner, but the person who wants to get into not necessarily becoming a professional sommelier, but an educated consumer. To me, there's two Bibles, and they're pretty much everybody's. The Wine Atlas from Jancis Robinson and Hugh Johnson, which is wonderful because it covers the winemaking world.
It's got great maps. It's got a general presentation of each country, each region. So it's really a solid, solid basis for wine knowledge, right? And again, understanding about the region, about the topography, about all of that helps you better understand the wines. And it's all linked. Of course, there are wines today that are completely cut off from where they come from. There are industrial wines that you can have an Australian wine, a wine from the Languedoc, and a wine from Chile that tastes exactly the same. Those are fabricated wines. And there's nothing wrong with them. I mean, they're not going to kill you.
What do you mean by fabricated wine? Because you can very much, you can come and, you know, you could hire a consultant winemaker today and say, okay, I've got this vineyard, wherever it is. I want my wine to be this color, to taste the chocolate and blackberries and be a little bit sweet and super round and creamy and not aggressive and to sell it around that price point. And he'll make it to order. Technology allows that, both in the vineyards and especially in the winery. Through the processes or through additives? Through the processes, both. There's many, many allowed additives and many allowed processes that allow you to manipulate a wine to make it what you want.
There's still this very romantic notion out there in the consumer world that wine is fermented grape juice. And, of course, the industry just loves that and totally exploits it. And you read all these nice back labels. that tell you about the vineyard and the vigneron and this bucolic image of wine, whereas a lot of wines out there actually resemble more Coca-Cola, a soft drink or processed cheese in terms of how they're made. Is that because... So disconnected from nature. It's very fragmented, but there's becoming to be a few large players who are striving for almost like McDonald's consistency.
Yeah, there's a bit of that. And some consumers actually want that also. They want the reassurance of having the same product year in, year out. No matter where they go, they know they're going to drink the same thing. Most true wine lovers, for most wine lovers, the variance from one year to another, from one region to another, the fact that the same wine grower grows the same grapes on two different plots with different soils and different slopes are different, that's fascinating to us. That's what we love. I always say what really turns me on, in French we say avant qu'il y a de la gueule.
Avant de la gueule means a wine that has character and a wine that tastes like it tastes because it comes from a specific place and it wouldn't taste the same if it came from another place. That's what really turns wine lovers on. but again there are people who drink wine they like a glass of wine and they don't really care about the story and they don't they prefer something, they grew up on soft drinks and sweet foods and they like something sweet and soft and simple and that's fine right and so there's a lot of the industry that caters to that, to the mass market make wine as a real consumer product with all the marketing gimmicks and everything that goes with it Coming back to the service aspect of being a sommelier, what do you wish more people knew when they came into a restaurant and talked to a sommelier?
Oh, it's very simple. I mean, the first thing I wish people had was more confidence and be less intimidated. Just, you know, there's so many people out there that are just waiting to talk wine with you, right? We want to share their passion. And if anybody gives you attitude, if anybody's arrogant, if anybody tries to recommend a wine, be it in a store or in a restaurant, without asking you a single question first, steer clear away from them. It just means this is what I like. Exactly. They'll sell you what they love without caring about what you like. But, yeah, just be confident. Don't be afraid to ask questions.
I would say those in the business that are judgmental, that will look down on you, they're not the good ones anyhow. You shouldn't care about them. We couldn't care less if they like you or not, right? Real professionals and real wine lovers will just be more than happy to take you on at any level you are and try to guide you through discovery and pleasure. So that probably leads to suboptimal outcomes, right? Hiding or being intimidated by speaking about what you like and your preferences. what would be other mistakes that people make that are easily correctable or that would offer a better experience from a consuming point of view?
There's very simple things, you know, like just service temperature. We still, you know, drink a lot of wines way too cold and a lot of other wines way too warm. There's not a red wine that's good above 17, 18 degrees, right? the whole notion of room temperature. I don't know, that goes back to the Middle Ages, but when houses are heated at 22, 23, there's not one wine that's good at that temperature. The white wine straight, or rosé, summer coming around, rosé season, so many people drink their rosés ice cold, and that just mutes the wine. The better rosés, a lot of the better rosés are much better, like at 10, 12 degrees.
A fridge is at 4 or 5. So when they warm up, they really, rosés are not usually very aromatic wines or more textural wines, but you kind of kill that texture when you serve it ice cold. And it really, you know, comes into its own when you let it warm up a little bit. So, yeah, temperature is another. So do you recommend people touch the bottle? Like if I ordered a bottle of red at a restaurant, when it comes and it's presented, right? Yeah, they'll let you try it. And if it's too warm for a red, which still often happens, don't hesitate to ask for an ice bucket and put the red bottle of wine in the ice bucket for five or ten minutes.
If they're idiots, excuse me, it still happens, they'll look at you as if you're from Mars. Okay? But if it's anybody who knows anything, they'll totally understand. First of all, they shouldn't serve it to you too warm. Is that an indication about how serious the restaurant you're in takes their wine as well? Totally, totally. If anybody serves you a red wine that tastes lukewarm, they're really not serious about their wine service. That's good to know. And so flipping it around a bit from the consumer perspective, how do I tell the difference between a good or bad sommelier? I think in the rapport you establish with them, right, from the start, their ease of approach, their willingness to really try to understand you and what you want.
And you'll see if their main goal is for you to have a good time or if it's for them to shine, right, or if they couldn't care less because they have another important table next to you, whatever. But those things, I think. It's a regular kind of service aspect. Yeah. So you're in the business of wine now. You operate this amazing restaurant we're in right now. Wine bar. Wine bar, sorry. Which is gorgeous, by the way. Tell me about what it was like to start a business in wine in an industry that is notorious for a high failure rate. Yeah. Well, I think like most people who spend a lot of their time working in the industry, we all kind of play with the dream of having your own place one day.
Although I remember for years I said, I will never have a restaurant. I don't want to be a slave. I don't want to have a life. But, you know, people in this industry, it is a difficult industry. Financially, it's almost impossible to get finance, right, because there's such a high failure rate. It's really hard to get banks and other institutions on board. it is stupid crazy hours for not a lot of pay you know once again this whole celebrity I think it's really great what's happening with chefs and sommeliers because it's bringing light to the profession making it known, better appreciated but the downside effect is that it's giving young people starting the business a really, not necessarily the right image I see kids coming out of cooking school and they want to have their TV show and their cooking book.
And it's like, no, no, you're going to sweat for years behind an oven before we even call you a chef, right? So it's really hard. And those that really succeed, I think, are people that are truly, truly passionate. Yeah, I work like crazy. I work crazy hours, but I don't care. I'm having fun as long as I'm having fun. So it doesn't seem like work. Exactly. But what is, so the behind the scenes, though, you're constantly traveling, trying to find new bottles that you can bring to people. What's involved in the behind the scenes that people wouldn't necessarily think about from a sommelier's point of view?
Well, first of all, from an owner, I think one of the reasons why the industry has such a bad rap is because too many people go into the restaurant industry because they're great cooks. They have friends, oh, you're a really good cook, you should open up a restaurant. You need a manager to open up a restaurant because the profit margins are so, so, so tiny. If you're not constantly checking your numbers, constantly, constantly, constantly, you can make loads of money and, well, revenues and close down because you're just going bankrupt. So you need solid management experience, I think, is the first thing before even having a, right?
and then from a semi-perspective yeah it's just what people see is the service people on the floor serving people but then like you said there's all building up a wine program so ordering the wines buying wines, managing inventories are you going to have a buy the glass program what's going to be your pricing and then constantly working with the kitchen for wine and food matching right so you know what's good So for us, it's different in Canada. I know importing wine can be a bit tricky. You can't just go over and import a case, can you? What's the process for that? Well, you have to work in your province of operation.
So this wine bar is in Quebec, so I can only deal with the SAQ. I cannot deal with the LCBO, even though we're right across the river from Ottawa. I cannot buy directly from Ontario wine producers, which is ridiculous. This, I've always said, my ultimate fight once I'm retired, whenever that happens, I will get on that case. It'll be very, very hard to make our wine laws change across the country. A lot of people are already working on it, but there's a tremendous amount of work to be done. I mean, all of our liquor laws are based on, you know, our early 20th century. They're from the Prohibition era, right?
So it seems to me as a consumer of wine, I'm limited to the LCBO selection. and what they've chosen for me, and then getting anything outside of that becomes difficult. And then it's almost like books, right? Like what they're choosing for me is high-volume, crowd-pleasers, not necessarily a variety of flavors or small. Well, there's one thing consumers should know and people into wine is that we're actually in a pretty great market in terms of what's on offer because there's a whole, beyond the LCBO and the SAQ and the state monopolies, there's ways to get wine also. It's not illegal. It's completely, it goes through.
In Ontario, they call it consignment. In Quebec, we call it importation privée. It's basically the same thing. Most wineries here are represented by an agent who does the importation, who does all the paperwork, but it's sold through the SAQ. But they have an agent, so there's agencies in every province that represent the different wineries present on our market that work here. They're the ones who will bring me samples or invite me to a tasting or send me information on that product. They're the ones making sure it's where they want it to be on the shelves in the stores and so on. And so those agents also have wines that are not distributed through the Monopoly stores.
and frankly one of the reasons why in the region here I wanted to be on the Quebec side and not on the Ontario side was because I wanted to work on the wines with the wines we have on offer in Quebec I have nothing to envy from cities like New York or London I can basically get anything I want in this market through private importation and private import is not only for restaurant owners, it's for everybody and it's I was just going to ask, as a consumer can I use it And for years, it was thought it was reserved to restaurants. And unfortunately, actually, some unscripted agents did that. They didn't make the prices known to the public so that the restaurateurs could make horrific margins on those wines, right?
Sell you a $10 bottle of wine for $60 because the price was not known from the public. But now, as consumers are more and more into wine, consumption is increasing. The whole wine scene is just very dynamic right now. There's more individuals that don't have restaurants that buy wines through these channels. The only inconvenience is because it doesn't transit through the stores. It goes directly from the monopoly warehouses to the consumer. It's by the case. They don't open the cases. You have to buy a case of six or a case of 12. But as I normally say, that's not really a problem, right? Just get yourself some friends.
Exactly. Exactly. And like you said, wine's for bringing people together. Exactly. You touched on something I want to talk about just briefly. People associate price and value. Is that true in wine? To what extent? It's like everything else, right? Like everything else. You get what you pay for up to a certain extent. Just like watches, like clothing, like cars, at one point you get into the luxury market. there's no single bottle of wine in the world that costs more than about $30 or $40 to produce so why are there bottles selling for $1,500 a bottle or $2,000 you get into that luxury segment where you're starting to pay for rarity for reputation for all the marketing that goes around it there's supply and demand and wine just like anything else.
We do pay in our markets, in Canada in general. What we don't get is the dirt cheap wine, is the wines you pay like 2, 3, 4 euros in a supermarket in France. Right, or 2-Bout Chuck in the U.S. Exactly, that we don't get. But frankly, not usually the best wines anyhow, right? And from, you know, $20 to $50, I think our pricing can actually be quite competitive. of regularly I see wines that I can buy here for cheaper than what I see them, you know, at the producer in Italy or in France or when we're in that, especially that kind of $30 to $50 range. And then, yeah, of course, there's wines that are $2,000 a bottle or more, but that's, again, we've crossed over to the luxury good department.
It's not wine as food anymore, right? It's wine as a collector's item. Have you ever tasted something that changed you? Changed you as a person and like the world didn't look the same after having it? I've tasted a lot of things that made me feel really good. The more you taste, the better you feel, right? But no, even without going into that factor of the effects of alcohol. But there's just wines that, yeah, they just move you. And that's, I think, what I look for the most in wines. I used to, and it was all part of the learning process, right? so many people see me, oh yeah, you were the one taking the, I filled up, I don't know how many notebooks during my life, taking notes on every single wine I would taste, I would go to a wine fair, I was writing, writing, writing, writing, now my tasting techniques, sometimes it's that precise, it has to be when I'm training for competitions or things like that, but But for buying purposes or for more simple evaluation purposes, I just taste the wine and pay attention to how it makes me feel.
I look for liveliness in wine, for something. I often say of a wine, this wine's just dead. It's not speaking to me. And that's often very manipulated wines. Again, there's nothing wrong with them. Technically, they're perfectly sound. But they don't have a soul. They don't move you. They don't speak to you. And a lot of wine, I mean, the consumption would also be with the romance. I would imagine, like, the winemaker and the craftsmanship that goes into it. And when you start thinking about the mechanics of mass-produced wine or wine that is manufactured to taste a certain way, you lose that.
Yeah, exactly. And we could go on for hours and hours about the values or not of blind tasting, right? because knowing the story behind changes. Yes, it can influence you, right? Just like, you know, when you're tasting an expensive wine, you might rate it higher because it's expensive and prestigious, although we try really, really hard not to do that. So blind tasting in those cases is good. But sometimes I've, you know, evaluated certain wines quite poorly, tasting them blind because they were kind of out of context and not in the right place, and had I known what they were, what the winemaker was trying to do, I would have had a better understanding, right?
So much of our understanding comes from context. Exactly, right? And again, that's what I think is great about wine. It's all those, you know, and I love imperfections. I always say perfection is boring, right? When something is so, almost asepticized, is that a right word? something that's so clean that it's soulless it's too technically perfect right I think in wine in people beauty lies in the faults I have to be careful saying that I don't want to I don't want to say that a wine is good because it's faulty no, a wine should not be faulty it should be good it should have character and that's one of the ways that you get character.
Yeah, by not having this perfectly technical, ascepticized wine that, you know, all the processes you've used have basically stripped all the character and the life out of it. So how do you look at a wine menu when you go into a restaurant that's not a wine bar, that's not known for their wine, but you want to have a bottle because you're there with your friends? Yeah. How do you go about evaluating that from, you know it's not going to be served chilled, you know it's... But I scroll through the list and right away, you see somebody who's from the trade knows right away. You go through it and you look at the producers.
And is it all only industrial, big producers, or is there some interesting stuff in there? And nobody knows everything. You can be a specialist of a certain region. There's so many producers. Even if you're a Burgundy specialist or a Chianti specialist, you never know everybody that's making wine in that area. So that's fascinating. That's great, right? We're never done discovering. So did you try something new or do you go with what you know? Like is there any hacks for the consumer going in? Well, I will try something. I don't know if I see it's mainly industrial, right? Right. If I see a few interesting producers, well, then I'll start talking.
First thing, ask the staff there. They know, right? That's one way for the consumer to make good use of the staff and the rest. Do you ever ask them if the wine is good or do you ask them different questions? Different questions. I mean, asking if the wine is good, I always thought that was a bit weird and almost insulting when consumers go in restaurants. But that's probably the most popular question you get, right? I know, I know. But who will honestly tell you, no, it sucks. Exactly. Oh, that's horrible. I know I just recommended it. Yeah. No, but again, if it's all industrial producers, I know it's not really worth talking to anyone because nobody has put any heart into making this wine list because it's probably been made by the rep of one of those big producers.
And sometimes still, I shouldn't say that, because sometimes there's staff working in restaurants that, okay, that's the place they found a job. They don't necessarily agree with the wine list, but that's where they're working. And so just chat with them and find out quickly from their attitude, because it could be little gems in the making, you know, in terms of staff and in terms of wine. So always scouting. If I'm at home and I don't have a wine fridge, I think I just want to make sure I understand this. You would recommend taking a red and putting it in almost like an ice bath for five or ten minutes and then serving it?
There's a super simple rule, the 20-minute rule. What is the 20-minute rule? Take your whites out of the fridge 20 minutes before serving them and put your reds in the fridge 20 minutes before serving them. In case of doubt, just do that. That's awesome. It's a very basic thing and it will work for most, right? And in the summertime when it's super hot and it's 30 degrees outside, you're always better to have the wines a bit more chill, too cold and too warm. Because they'll heat up as you're... Exactly. They'll heat up. They'll take a degree per minute once they're in the glass, right? So they heat up pretty quickly.
If the wine's too warm, you know, other than putting ice cubes into it, which isn't great, there's not much you can do. I'm cognizant of your time. I just want to circle back to the Wine Atlas again. Yeah. Do you recommend going through that and learning about the regions by then going to the LCBO or the liquor store and then getting bottles from that region? There's nothing I like more than reading a book on a certain wine region and sitting with a glass of a wine. When I read about a certain wine or region, it actually makes me want to try it. Reading in wine, it's like a match made in heaven.
Exactly. So you're reading on Burgundy, go grab a bottle of Burgundy, right? And will you grab the same producer in different years and taste them at the same time, like in 2012, 2013, 2013? Yeah, I mean, those kind of tastings are super educational, right? But it's not always easy to do because usually there's one vintage out on the market. So that's something you can do when you visit producers, right? So take a book, pick a region, whatever, read on Burgundy, go buy a Burgundy, but then organize a tasting with friends, right? Again, it's all about coming together, and it's going to be fun when you're sitting there with your book and geeking out all alone, but it'll be even more fun when you can, okay, let's, okay, today, get a little group together.
People are just making up tasting groups. Right. And you don't need to have any great knowledge. You're all going to learn together, right? But, you know, pick a region and ask everybody to bring a wine from that region, and, okay, that day you're going to be presented. Oh, that's a great idea. read up on it and give us like a 10-15 minute I love that overrun of what the region is and let's taste these wines together how do I become a member at all of these little tasting groups you can be your own it's easy, just get some friends last question, is there anything that I can do if I do start a wine tasting group that would make a big difference that probably would take a while to figure out that's different about how you approach it in terms of stay away from certain things yeah, well see, if you really want to learn Again, I can't stress enough the importance of having rigor and the methodology and a certain discipline, right?
Because, of course, alcohol comes into play at one point, you know. The learning goes out the window. Everybody's just too happy to make any sense, right? Which is also a good outcome. Yeah, exactly. Spitting is not a bad thing, right? It's one of the first things we learn how to do, spit wine. It allows you to taste 50 wines in one sitting in a second. I just can't do that. I have this aversion to it. You have, what's important to stress is that the learning process is different. You will get everything exactly the same out of the wine except for the effect of the alcohol. Right. Your appreciation of it, the evaluation of the body, of the structure, of the acidity, the tannins, everything.
The aromas, the taste. Spit it out or swallow it, same thing except for the effects of the alcohol, right? So when you're doing your official tasting with your friends, it doesn't have to be, don't, you know, make it. okay, next time you're having a dinner party, just say, okay, we'll start half an hour earlier. Everybody brings a bottle. Let's make it a theme. Like, let's just do Pinot Noir. Let's just do Burgundy. Let's just do Argentina, whatever. Everybody brings a wine. And okay, so we're tasting them. We're learning. We're trying to, and again, get some help from, you'll find sommeliers.
You'll find wine consultants in stores that are super talented and more than happy to share and give you a few pointers on, okay, here's what you should do. You need a tasting grid. Okay, here's a good one. Okay. Something to go by. But that's super easy to find if you do a little bit of research and have it validated by somebody who knows what they're talking about. Because like everything else, there's a lot of, you know, useless information out there. Yeah. So that's it. Well, thank you so much. This has been absolutely fascinating. Thank you. Hey, guys, this is Shane again. Just a few more things before we wrap up.
You can find show notes at farnamstreetblog.com slash podcast. That's F-A-R-N-A-M-S-T-R-E-E-T-B-L-O-G.com slash podcast. You can also find information there on how to get a transcript. And if you'd like to receive a weekly email from me filled with all sorts of brain food, go to farnamstreetblog.com slash newsletter. This is all the good stuff I've found on the web that week that I've read and shared with close friends, books I'm reading, and so much more. Thank you for listening.