No summary for this episode yet.
I spent 12 years at NPR covering mostly viruses, and they would send me around the world. What was really surprising to me and why I went on this journey to learn this other way of parenting was when I came back to San Francisco and I tried some of these techniques and methods, they worked amazing on my little girl. So what are some of these tips? I mean, you summed it up with an acronym of TEAM. Yes. What is TEAM? And let's make them practical for people. So the first thing, T, is like this idea of like a lot of the Western relationship, parent-child relationship is based on control. But E is a different way.
E is. And the next one is autonomy. Yeah, this one's huge. If you could just change like one thing in your child's life, that would be. M, I guess. We've sort of talked about this a little bit. Yeah, it kind of puts it all together. The M is like. So praising is a really interesting topic that's very unique in Western society. In my entire travels, I've never seen a parent raise a child. Like, it's not necessary. Okay, we do video games. It's like seven, eight. Every day? If you have your homework done. I would cut out every day. Oh, I can't. Yeah, no. But they don't need it. I don't. I don't.
Well, you know, if parents are listening to this and they have a 16-year-old addicted to their phone, what are the tangible things they can do in the next one month to sort of like help? So here's how it works. Welcome to The Knowledge Project, a bi-weekly podcast exploring the powerful ideas, practical insights, and mental models of others. In a world where knowledge is power, this podcast is your toolkit for mastering the best of what other people have already figured out. I'm your host, Shane Parrish. Before we dive in, I have a quick favor to ask. If you're enjoying the show and listening on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or another platform, please take a moment and hit the follow button.
The more followers we have, the better guests we can bring on to share their knowledge with you. If you want to take your learning to the next level, consider joining the membership program at fs.blog.com. As a member, you'll get my personal reflections at the end of every episode, early access to episodes, no ads, exclusive content, hand-edited transcripts, and so much more. Check out the show notes for a link. Today, my guest is Michaelene Ducluff, author of Hunt, Gather, Parent, and a global explorer of parenting practices. Her work takes us on a journey across cultures, revealing profound insights that challenge our modern assumptions, I guess, about raising children.
At the heart of her discoveries lies the acronym TEAM, TOGATHER, Encourage, Autonomy, and Minimal Intervention. These four principles draw from the wisdom of indigenous communities around the world, offering a roadmap for fostering resilience, independence, and emotional well-being in our children. She shares her observations on how different cultures approach parenting and how their practices can help alleviate the burdens we place on ourselves and our children. We also explore the role of technology in modern parenting and its impact on our children's development. She offers practical strategies for navigating this digital landscape and fostering meaningful connections within our families.
It's surprising how often we give our kids orders. Do this. Don't do that. And in this conversation, you'll learn a better approach that encourages critical thinking, empathy, and problem-solving skills that works on toddlers and teens. I tried to make this episode as practical as possible so while we learn insights from other cultures, how do we put them into practice in our culture? Michaelene shares insights on how we can create an environment that allows our children to take appropriate risks, learn from their mistakes, and grow into confident, capable individuals in a world that sometimes pushes back.
Listening to this episode will give you another perspective on parenting that draws from the collective wisdom of cultures around the world. As with anything, take what works and ignore the rest. It's time to listen and learn. I want to start with Our parent. Have we collectively lost our way as parents? Western society has kind of veered off the path, you know, and kind of gone into this valley of strange parenting valley where we've kind of, yeah, we've kind of lost sight of like what kids actually need, what the parent-child relationship actually needs to really function. What's different?
So there's so many things that are different. One anthropologist said that there's about 40 to 50 things that we do as parents that you can't really find anywhere else except in places that have westernized. And then there's like four or five things that we are really missing that are really key to raising a child that you enjoy being with, raising a child that's helpful and respectful and confident. I mean, that's really if you look at our data, right, in Western society, we have this epidemic of children who are anxious, who have kind of lost confidence. And then for sure, we have children that like we struggle to get them to help.
Right. And be helpful around the house and kind of work together as a team. And so there's a couple of things that we're not doing that really support that. How did we get here? It's a big question, but it dates back to like probably the 1500s in Europe. It actually, one scientist thinks and has this whole theory and book about how it dates back to the Catholic Church. We could talk about that. But in general, what's happened is we've lost the parenting teachers. That's, I think, a really key aspect of it. That traditionally, you have a child, often very young, you know, in your 20s. And your parents or aunt or neighbor would teach you how to raise that baby.
And then by the time you have your second or third baby, you kind of know, right? But now, like me, when I had my daughter, basically handed me this baby, sent me home, and it was like me by myself. Good luck. Good luck. Exactly. You know, my husband always says, like, we took all these birthing classes. But he was like, why didn't we take all these parenting classes? Like, now what do we do? Now that it's, you know. So that, I think, around the 1700s is when that really started to get going, losing this kind of the teachers. And then parents started turning to the medical industry and parenting experts.
And you can see the progression of like, what do we do? We don't really know what to do. And so parents are hungry for these pamphlets. They were pamphlets, basically, from orphanages that doctors had made just to say, how do you raise like 40 kids? Right. And they turned into these like parenting manuals and books that were very popular because parents stopped really knowing what to do. Parenting books today, you can trace all the way back to those pamphlets. It's really incredible. And of course, they weren't the way you raise children in a home, you know, in a family. They were for these institutions, basically.
I think I remember listening to one of your interviews and you mentioned like the number one sleep book is by some dude in the 1800s who didn't even have kids. Yeah, he was like a sports writer. And he wrote about golf, I think. And he was also super into guns. And he actually like blew his hand off and stuff. And he like, I think he saw like there was like this market for parenting advice. And he wrote, yeah, like he was one of the first ones to really write about sleep training, which is totally crazy, like around the world, like leaving a baby to cry. And it's a very unique style. And he was kind of one of the first people to suggest it and recommend it.
Can we come back to like the Catholic church and sort of like we're not taught how to be parents anymore? Is that a byproduct of like all of us working more and living in a busier society or is it? The theory is, and it's really fascinating, was that before the 1500s, people in Europe lived like people everywhere in the world in these big kind of clans or groups of like family, like big and not like all one house, but kind of in the same neighborhood. And it was, you know, we was like communal living. Right. And this is how children were raised for hundreds, thousands of years in these kind of big groups.
And there's a lot of data to support that. And that's how Europeans were doing it. And then the Catholic Church came along about the 1500s and started having these laws to prevent close cousins from marrying and having children, which is totally legitimate, like biologically. You don't want to marry your first cousin and have a child. But over time, they started extending it out to like second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth cousins. I mean, you and I are sixth cousins, right? But we're not related at all. And whether this was intentional or not, what it did was it broke up this big family living, right?
Because you couldn't marry anymore into these groups. And it really took intergenerational living and squashed it down slowly and slowly to what we now think of as the nuclear family. So you go from living in an environment where, you know, as a mom, I would have clearly an older sibling. I'd have an aunt, an uncle. I'd have a cousin. I'd have this, all these people that are like helping me. And I would be watching as I grew up other children being raised. Right. That's a big element too. Right. Like by the time I was 16, I probably had seen like five children get raised from somebody in this big group.
Right. And so that's, I mean, if you look around the world, that's how people learn to parent. That's how this skill, the craft is like passed down through watching. And then when you have your own teaching, but if you live, if you squash down the family into like mother and father only, and you're right, one parent is out of the home a lot or two parents are out of the home, then you've no longer have, you never, no longer watch people being raised. Maybe you get one kid, one sibling, right? And then you don't have any helpers. And this professor at Harvard has tracked down the rise of the nuclear family correlates with how long ago the Catholic Church was brought into a society.
And so Europe is the longest and you see this very strong nuclear family. And then other parts of the world, you know, it's been introduced more recently and you still see intergenerational living and these big family units. But it's not the only factor, I think. Lots of other things have come about to kind of support the creation of the nuclear family and the reduction of the people in our lives raising children. And we have this saying, right? Like it takes a village to raise kids, but it sounds like we don't actually create the village anymore. That's right. And it's funny because I always say like it doesn't take a village.
It takes like five extra people. Like, you know, because if you look in some societies, so they're called alloparents. This is what scientists call them. They're people in children's lives that are just as close to the child and just as important to the child as the mother and the father. They're other parents, basically. And if you look, in most societies, children have like four or five of these. Very close. In some societies, they have like 12 or 15, but they're not very close. but there's amazing studies in some societies where like a babe they'll track like how many times a baby is passed around to a different person in like an hour or two hours and it's like something like 10 or 11 people in like an hour like just regularly think about that like when you had your kids like if you had 10 people like constantly helping you hold the baby feed the baby like how much different your life would have been i'd have a lot more kids you'd you right you'd have a little work it and you'd have a lot like less stress right you know when i was traveling with rosie um my little girl we were in tanzania and we were with these women raising they had the little ones the babies and the toddlers because the other ones were at school and they were it was a group of like six women and they would spend all day long together helping each other with the baby the toddlers and the baby like all day long i'm talking like 10, 12 hours a day.
It was amazing, right? From a standpoint of like social support, right? And then I got back home and it was just me like in this condo with a kid. And it was, it was, the difference was so stark. So before we sort of cover how we undo all of this, like what did you learn? You traveled around the world. You found four different tribes that all taught in a sort of different way. What are the key lessons that came out of that? Why is that important? I'm a reporter and I spent 13, 12 years at NPR covering mostly viruses and they would send me around the world. And I started to notice while I was traveling that parents didn't seem to have the same struggles as we did.
You know, there were clearly struggles. There's struggles everywhere. I don't want to romanticize it. But what was really surprising to me and why I went on this journey to like learn this other way of parenting was when I came back to San Francisco and I tried some of these techniques and methods, because that's really what they are. They worked like amazing on my little girl in urban San Francisco. It really surprised me how quickly our relationship improved. She was like two at the time when I really started to try this. So what are some of these tips? I mean, you summed it up with an acronym of team.
Yes. But let's make them what is team and like, let's make them practical for people. So the first thing T is like this idea of like together that humans, homo sapiens are these incredibly social creatures. We that's what separates us from like other homo species is that we are social. And not only that we want to be with people, we want to help people. And children are born wanting to help everyone knows this in our society. And so the first thing is really is let your children help you, even when they can't do it. Right. So we have this, there's, there's studies that show this, like American parents are asked this question of like, you're doing the laundry and your little two-year-old comes over and starts throwing the clothes like all over the place.
Like, what do you do? And the American mom says something, the European American mom says something like, I get mad because she's making a mess and I tell her to go play. Right. Or I tell her to go watch cartoons. Right. And then they ask the same question to a Maya mom. And the Maya moms say something like, I get kind of mad because she's making a mess, right? It starts off kind of similar. And then she says, but I'm really excited that she wants to help with the laundry. And so the Maya mom sees the little toddler's mess as this like sign of interest in helping, right? It's a very different view of the child, right?
It's a very pro-social view. And then she says, so I start teaching her how to do the laundry. And one of the moms even says, The little girl sometimes balls up the laundry and she says, I can see she's trying to fold it. I would just say she's balling up the laundry and making a ball. The other view is that she wants to help. We are these social creatures and we have this huge desire to help. Starting off just really from day one. In many, many parts of the world, parents immediately say, yes, come help. and keep the child there and have the child at least watch or give the child a very small task to do.
And so that's really the T never turned down a child's request to help. Like when I was getting ready for this podcast, like Rosie wanted to do my hair, she wanted to do my makeup. And it was like, yes, my job as a parent, I see is to find a way that she can actually help. And the my families have some saying about it, like it's your job to find the purpose in the child's life. to find the opportunities for the child to have purpose. Don't push them away because if you keep pushing them away by the time they're seven or eight and they actually can start kind of helping, they're not stupid. They're like, that's not my job.
You know, like you've pushed me away for six years. Why would I help you now? You know, and there's data that show that that's kind of what happens. That kids, they learn their place in the home. Is my place playing and watching video games, playing video games, watching TV, or to my place, like helping with dinner, helping with the laundry, helping. And unlearning that is hard. I don't think it's as hard as we think it is. But again, I think you have to change your view of the child, right? You have to, instead of just saying, oh, he doesn't want to help. He never helps. He's never going to help.
Don't ask, right? Can you imagine, right? If somebody said that at work, don't ask him. He's never, he's no good at this. Like how bad that would make you feel, right? So it's like actually starting to see there's a little flame inside the child that actually really does want to help. I think you can turn it around. Well, let's E for inquiry. Oh, E. So E is this idea that like a lot of the Western relationship, parent-child relationship is based on control. That the parent tells the child what to do and they're supposed to listen because they're the child. And you're the authority. And you're the authority.
Right. And that's kind of just set. But E is a different way. The E is we're going to encourage children to do the right thing. And really, we're going to get them to figure out what the right thing is themselves. And every time you try to control a child, you create conflict, you risk creating conflict because either the child's going to get mad because they don't want to be told what to do, or you're going to get mad because they're not doing it, right? And so another way of doing it is like, okay, I'm going to guide you. I'm going to encourage you to do the right thing. And you know what? It's okay if like nine, sometimes you don't, because this is the long game, but I'm going to use all these tools I have in my toolbox to get you to learn, to figure out what the right thing is, to learn, to think.
When I went traveling, I knew there were like tools that cultures use to get children to figure things out. And instead of just telling them what to do, but I had no clue how many there were. There's so many, it's amazing. And they're very subtle, But they can really change the whole dynamic between the parent and the child. What the E does, the encouragement, is it gets the child to feel like, I'm making decisions for myself. I'm in charge of my life. My mom has confidence that I can do it. And so there's this ease that starts to happen with the parent and the child. So what are those tools?
So one of the amazing tools with smaller children is stories. like we are there's good evidence that humans are really made to learn through story and when we were actually with the hadzabe this hunter gatherer community in tanzania they were using stories to teach me the rules so when we got to the camp they didn't just list off you know very like american be like here are the rules and like you know like this is what you can do and you can't do no around the fire they would tell these stories and um some of them were about where you went to the bathroom and they would say things like this isn't about you though like this even though it's clearly about me you know are they they sing songs that had stories in them for children um and so this is a way of like putting the ideas into the child's mind in a way that one they can really understand because they don't let young children don't understand logic but also like a way of like again they're gonna figure it out through these stories so that's a huge one for younger children.
Even for younger children, there's all these ways of asking questions, telling them consequences, these little puzzles that you set up for them. Another big one is the environment, just setting up the environment so they can't get themselves in trouble or they're less likely to. The list goes on and on. There's some beautiful examples. When we were up in the Arctic, Rosie was throwing these rocks up in the air like this, and the little nine-year-old, Rosie was three at the time, and the little nine-year-old comes over and says, you're going to hurt somebody with those rocks. And Rosie kind of sat there and looked and then dropped the rocks.
And the nine-year-old walked away. Like it wasn't a... No, and that's what the parents do. It's like, I mean, I think if Rosie was throwing rocks at kids, then it would be different. But it's like if you really stop and look at most of the situations, you don't need... And one of the stories that would probably resonate with people you told in the book is how Rosie was keeping the fridge door open. Yes. So when I first traveled up to the Arctic, the moms would tell me these stories, like to get kids to wear their hats in the winter because they would get frostbite on their ears. And they would tell them that like if they didn't, like that their heads would get chopped off and the northern lights would use their heads as soccer balls.
All these very kind of scary stories. And I was like, no, I'm never doing that. That's one of the things readers write into me about. like one of the things are like, I could never do this, you know? And then when I got back, Rosie had the refrigerator door open and I was sitting there, close the refrigerator door, close, you know, just kind of nagging her, which is the big tool we use over and over again. And then I was like trying logic, you know, the electricity, dah, dah, dah, dah. And I was very frustrated with her. And then I turned to her and I said, there's a monster in that refrigerator.
And he, when he warms up, he's coming, oh my gosh, she's coming out. And I kind of made it very dramatic and kind of fun. And like these stories are often kind of a wink in the eye. Like the kid kind of knows it's a story. And she like slammed the refrigerator door and was like, looked at me and she was like, tell me more mama, tell me more about this monster. And it, she was, I think three and three and a half at the time, three. And, um, it like changed our whole relationship. We just started using stories for everything. Cause the way we could communicate like with her, like we weren't communicating with her.
Otherwise, oh, we had so many stories. And like when she's, now she's eight and like around six or seven, she kind of knew the stories were fake and she kind of didn't want to hear them for a while. And then she wanted to again. Like it was like, because even as an adult, you like stories. I mean, we still use stories as a society, right? Absolutely. We use them as warnings. We use them as fairy tales. We use them as... I mean, we use them as entertainment, right? Like one of the scientists I talked to, because again, parents are very... Like I was, like, this is too scary, you know? But then one of the scientists I was talking to said, yeah, but look at a Disney movie.
Like, it's way scarier, like, you know, than, you know, because also I'm there, I can see. The point is not to scare her to death, it's to communicate. Parenting is about transmitting values. Is there a difference between encouraging and sort of praising? Because we seem really good at praising kids. It's like, oh, wow, you picked the green pen. You're amazing. My child's a genius. now? So praising is a really interesting topic that's very unique in Western society. You don't, in my entire travels, I've never seen a parent praise a child. Like it's not necessary. Is it more subtle or they just don't do it at all?
I think that there is some that's more subtle. Like you think the parent's not doing anything, but then you look and there is like these subtle signals that are happening, which also speaks to the fact that we could be a lot more subtle with children, you know? Like a smile. Yeah, or like a pat on the shoulder. Or one of the moms said I would hug the child, you know, to thank them. But praise really just came about in the last like 30 years. Like, I'm 47. And like, my mom was really into praise and my dad wasn't. So I'm kind of right at the generation where the praise kind of... And there's this whole backstory to it about why it happened.
But praise is a tricky beast. Praise can motivate children, but it can also demotivate. It depends on how it's done, what context it is, the child. Does the praise actually kind of fit with what you're doing? And I mean, we have the sense that all praise is good and it's not. I tell parents, you can just stop. Before we get to autonomy, let's double click on that. What's the difference between good praise and bad praise? I mean, I don't think psychologists know. And I think that's one of the problems. I think this over-the-top praise that you're talking about, I don't think kids know it's fake.
And in some ways it's manipulative. I think the problem is we don't know. We don't know how much praise helps kids because it's an experiment. It's brand new. How do we get in this experiment? Maybe it was the 80s. There was this whole push from the California government. There was this idea that like the reason why kids started to use drugs and misbehave is because they had poor self-esteem. and that the way to help kids was to have, was to praise them, that gives them good self-esteem. But there was, the data don't support it at all. There was no data. It's just, again, like these myths that kind of bubble up, but you don't need to do it.
I mean, I think I come from a privileged position in the sense that like I've seen many, many families not praise children and like the kids are like amazing and have enormous amounts of confidence and self-esteem. So it's Like, it's just not required. I think what's more important and what motivates kids, and there's a lot of data to support this, what motivates kids is having them actually contribute to your life. You know, having them be part of your life and contribute in it. I mean, you know, as a person who works, that you feel good and motivated when you help and you do something and you accomplish something.
And that, I mean, there's tons of data in psychology. That's what motivates kids. Not when somebody goes on and on about, oh, my God, amazing. So just to orient us where we are, you have the acronym TEAM, Togetherness, and we've talked about encouraging. And the next one is autonomy. Yeah, this one's huge. If you could just change like one thing in your child's life, that would be to give them two hours, an hour a week of autonomy. If you look at hunter-gatherer communities around the world, so humans spent 200,000 years as hunter-gatherers. That's where our brains evolved. That's where we evolved in this context.
And so looking at hunter-gatherer communities around the world offers some clues kind of to how the conditions in which we're involved in. It doesn't say it exactly, but kind of gives you some clues. And if you look in lots of different continents, children have enormous amounts of autonomy in these communities, which implies that's how the child evolved, right? The child's brain evolved. We used to have a lot of autonomy. I mean, I was walking to school at seven. I was walking like two kilometers almost. Exactly. Like it wasn't that long ago in Western society that we had it. The evolutionary perspective kind of says that like we need it.
You know, and then there's this data that shows that kids that don't have it are more anxious, more prone to depression. Like so there's just tons of data that's like we need autonomy. Children need autonomy. But I think parents don't know what it looks like. So what does autonomy look like? The best way to figure it out is to put your stopwatch on when you're with a child in the morning, at the grocery store, just somewhere, and give no commands to the child. No verbal instruction to the child for 20 minutes. And see if you can do it. I mean, because scientists have done this analysis. I did this analysis in different communities and in places where children have autonomy.
parents give children like two to three verbal inputs in an hour and i've done it on myself i've done it with parents in san francisco and we are talking about like 120 verbal inputs per hour just a constant stream do this do that don't do this say this say thank you like i mean you can just you can see it like it's just a constant praise because it is a form of like kind of manipulating their behavior right which creates a power struggle in some ways oh can create for some some children are fine. Some children appear fine with it, right? They just kind of go, I call them like turtles. They kind of go down into a little shell and kind of, okay, you know, and some children it's horrible.
When, when I was writing the book and Rosie and I's relationship was really changing. If we were in a hard time and we were arguing a lot, I would do this. I've put my stopwatch on and my phone and I would say, okay, I'm going to be quiet. I'm not going to, I can give her physical, physical input, right? Like you're talking about more subtle, like some eye movement some I can move her you know if she's doing something bad I can take something right I can do physical things but I can no talking to her and it was amazing Shane like how quickly that improves our relationship what can I do I have two teenagers for to encourage autonomy like what does that look like well it depends on where they're at how much they're already doing on their own well I used to like send them to grocery stores on their own when they were like seven and eight and you know i i got a lot of pushback for that from society yes yes i used to let them walk to school and i get a lot of pushback from society one one aside from this it's so cute um my youngest came home one day and i had asked him to get a red pepper and he got a green pepper and i was like we'll go back to the store and he was like i think eight or nine at the time and he goes back to the store and then he comes home and i was like well what was the difference in price and he's like huh and i was like what did you do he's like i put the green pepper on the shelf and i took the red pepper because why would it be any different he's like i paid for it the first time right just a pepper exactly it's a funny story it seems like society i guess is has uh maybe it's just my feeling i know like it's pushed back on those things oh it's not just your feeling there's huge data on this and one david lancey one of the anthropologists that I cite a lot in the book, calls it like the shrink wrapping of children, where we're just so afraid of their safety.
I'm not afraid of their safety as much as afraid of other parents. Right, right. The police showing up at my door and taking away my kids because I sent them on an errand. Society as a whole is afraid of their safety. And there are parents that are. I think we're kind of probably in the minority right now. So Rosie's eight. She started going to the store. We live in that right now, a 6,000 person town, you know, America, I don't know about Canada, but I bet it's the same as the safest it's ever been. Like then when we were kids and, um, she got, she's gotten pulled over by the cops twice. One time they brought her home in the back of the car.
So, I mean, we've gotten pushed. There's absolutely a huge pushback. I've had to just be like, this is what we value. You know, my husband and I sat down. We like, what do we do? You know, we've, we've thought about going to the police. So we dealt with the police and we told them like, And the police actually admitted, like, she's fine. But other parents are calling us. It's the neighbors that we're calling. And so we've also made her look better, like the optics of it. She's on the bike now, and she looks more like she's in charge. There's a great organization called Let Grow. I don't know if you know about it.
but it's it's all about empowering parents and children to give their to have more autonomy and they have these little licenses that you can print out that say like i'm rosie ducluff and my parents allow me to go to these places and i'm allowed to talk to strangers i'm talking to you right now and like so we printed that out for her and but it's hard but it's worth it well i don't know like what can i do like so okay so they're 13 they're one 13 one's 14 i mean autonomy is also like what does the child want to do that they can't because they feel afraid or they feel like they you know they can't do it because of parents or society or whatever and then helping them kind of achieve those goals so i guess like maybe an example like what comes to mind with uh with my kids would be like, do I give complete autonomy, which is they come home, you know, this is dinner time, you help out with chores and you're, you contribute to the household, but I don't talk to them about homework.
I don't talk to them about schoolwork. Or do I provide like a structure around this where it's like, let's go over what's due tomorrow and tell them what to do. You know, like, how do you think about that between structure and autonomy? I think at 13 and 14, I would not help them structure their time. But if they don't have the ability. Do you see what I'm saying? If they're capable of doing it, let them do it. And if they're not, give the structure, but not the instructions. Give the encouragement. Right? Like go back to the E. So what would that look like? I'm happy exposing all my poor parenting.
I mean, I'm just it's really fascinating, right? Because like we have this sense in our this is another weird thing we do is that like we think, OK, they're at this age they need to do this you know and i would ask parents like well what what age can they use a knife and the parent would just be like it depends on the child yeah you know and so i that's why i'm like kind of like well where are they with it right because one of the one of the publishers said to me well i my my child's 11 and i opened up the back door and said you're free now you have autonomy now and she just stood there yes exactly i'm telling you like chickens will just stand there too if they've been inside a cage for life.
You know, and she was like, but she didn't want autonomy. And I was like, well, she's 11. She's never had that. So she can't just like, you can't just tell her to go run and play outside after 11 years of not, right? So that's why I'm asking you, like, where are they? But I think the idea is like, don't do things for them. Like ever, like ever. You don't need to, especially 13, 14. It's like if they can't manage their time or they can't figure out, okay, what's next? Because that's a skill. There's actually a study looking at this in Guadalajara. It's a fascinating study. It looks at parents that are more westernized who manage the child's time.
Okay, now you're doing dinner. Now you're doing chores. Now you're doing this. Now you're doing that. And then a little more like team parenting, like my book, where the children manage their own time. In the study, these are like nine, 10 year olds. In the study, they show that the kids that are in that kind of more flexible environment take initiation. They start their homework themselves. But it takes time. That's a skill. I mean, that's one of the things that I tell parents. When you're kind of their personal assistant and you're managing their time, like blocked hour by hour, you're kind of doing them a disservice because they're not able to learn this skill of like, what do I do next?
And you know, like at your job, like my job, I sit down in the morning, it's like, well, what do I do? That's a big part of the job. It's like, okay, I got to interview this person. I got to send this email. I got to read this part. I got to write this part, right? And that's a skill that takes time. So I would start, I don't know, I'm not trying to say your child doesn't have that, but if I felt like my child didn't have that, I would start trying to teach them that. you know like what do you what do you have on your plate tonight yeah you know what would you do questions questions exactly like you know that was one of my favorite part questions not command so we actually now have a little school and so i love it because i get to say i tried these things on lots of kids you know like as time has gone on i've gotten more confident because i've tried them on all these kids at this little school we have and like the questions work on every kid and the questions are designed to get them to think about the next step instead of you giving the instruction that's telling them what to do that's right we have one little boy who he's 11 he's very smart great reader great math but he cannot do anything that i don't tell him kind of the next step like we were just making um valentine's day carts and then hanging him on a tree for the teacher and he was literally standing there with the two pieces of yarn and was like what do i do next and i was like what do you think you do next and it took about five minutes for him to figure out that he needs to tie it and put it on the tree.
And you just let him sort of struggle with it. Yeah. Yeah. That's really interesting. And that M, I guess we've sort of talked about this a little bit. Yeah. It kind of puts all together. The M is like minimal interference. That's kind of a little bit what we're getting at. It's like, we think that good parenting, I thought that good parenting was maximal interference. Like I was always trying to figure out, okay, what do I tell Rosie next? Okay. I'm always looking out for like the next thing to say. And like one parent even told me, I forgot who it was, but she told me sometimes I have to really hold myself back from interfering to see if they can do it.
You know, there's this like magic moment where you want to jump in and that's when they were like, but if they need your help, you jump in. How do we learn that as parents? Because you've done it for so long. And then the temptation is obviously. I tell parents, and this is kind of how I started it, was I would take Rosie to the beach. I would take her to an environment where she had a lot of autonomy. I know the beach doesn't sound like that to a lot of parents, but like I had taught her like not to go into the water. And then I would just sit there like hours and I would read and work and just let her live.
And that was how I practiced it. You get the confidence that like, oh, the kid, I don't need to interfere so much. And when I don't interfere, she does. She's so happy and she's, you know, I can work and I can do my life. And like, I think you just have to try it. And she didn't want to play with you? She did want to play. She didn't want to play with me. I mean, especially if there was like, not other kids around or something. I would just say, no, I'm reading right now. You know? I mean, that's another thing is like, most society's parents don't play with children. Yeah. Like at all. Babies a little bit, but...
Otherwise, sort of like, figure it out. Use your imagination. Be bored. Yeah, or there's other kids. A lot of times there's other kids around. And now we're in a nonstop. I feel like I have to entertain you. So that is another huge one. Huge, huge difference in our, this is one I think the most stressful things is like this feeling of what do you do with your time with your kids? Kids do not need to be entertained. They have not been entertained for like hundreds of thousands of years, 200,000 years. They do not need it. Like I said, like you can welcome them into your world and teach them how to be in your world.
But when they're in their world, you can be there, T for together, but you don't have to do anything. There's a lot of differences between the worlds of these tribes and our world. Yes, there are. Some of those differences are food. Yes. Technology. Well, both of those are changing. Culture. Culture. In terms of women's roles and whether they work or not and how they contribute. How do you think that affected how they're raising kids? Is that specific to that environment? How does it affect our environment? What's the same? What's different? In the Maya community, in the Inuit community, which is, you know, just north of us right now in Canada, there was lots of technology and lots of processed foods.
Interesting. Yeah. I mean, the Maya community less, but... Like they're eating Froot Loops for breakfast sort of thing? The Inuit, yes. A lot of them, yes. A lot of them. But I mean, the Maya, the more, there was more traditional foods kind of made every day. and every day, but they had, you know, the hadzabe, it was no technology, very little westernized processed food. So it was very different. So I think the food is an interesting question because like these really control children and control us kind of in ways. What do you mean by that? Like, I think both, I think technology is probably easier to talk about.
I mean, it's designed to make the child use it. Right. So it's not a secret, right, to shape the child's behavior and their activities. And so it's it's hard to be as a parent to just let that go. So how is it impacting these kids, though? Like kids today? I mean, my kids are maybe an exception, but most kids long before they hit 13, 14 have iPhones or iPads. Right. So the Maya is very fascinating. The Maya, Yeah, many of the parents told me that they don't get a phone until they can pay for it. But you can do that when everybody's in that. When it's collective. When you're the only great, you know, in my grade.
So how did you do it? You know, well, I just did what my parents did. I was like, I don't care about Johnny down the street. Yes, yes, yes. I care about you, but like, I feel that pressure in grade seven. You know, that he was the there's two kids in his class who didn't have a phone in grade eight. He was the only one who didn't have a phone. and he feels it because he feels sort of like left out right these guys or these you know my classmates are doing something and i'm not i can't be a part of it the way that we've talked about this inside our house is like okay going into grade nine you can have a phone but you can't take your phone to school with you uh and you have to wait at least a year before you have to show me that you can be responsible with it before you can have other apps on your phone that aren't sort of like games, right?
Like so before you can have Instagram, my whole path with this is like, I'm hoping schools ban phones. By the time that like, by the time. And they probably will. Well, Ontario came out yesterday and said they banned phones in all schools up until the end of grade 12, which I think is a great idea personally. And I'm hoping we get to this place with sort of like Snapchat and social media and some of that stuff before he gets there. So I'm like all about delaying, right? Right. I mean, yeah, I think that is the word. Also, like they're growing up in a world where they have to coexist with technology.
And we know how addictive it is. So, you know, all of a sudden you're 18 and giving them a phone is also probably not the best strategy. It's interesting because all the data show that when they get the phone, it makes them more lonely. Yeah. It makes them more isolated. It was my conversation with Jonathan that actually totally I was like adamant, no phone. I don't care what the pushback is. Like, I'm going to slow roll this as long as I can. And he told me every year you can delay it. It makes a huge difference. Absolutely. Because they have like a prefrontal cortex, right? The Inuit were really interesting because they have tons of video games, tons of TV.
Like the grandmother we were with was like, she spent like a week out in the land hunting caribou. And then she comes back. She's like, I got so much CSI to catch up on. Like there's this like very like the technology and never like completely squeezed out the other life. Right. How is that possible? Because it's designed, and I say this as, you know, it's designed to make it. It is. It's designed to squeeze it out. There's no doubt. If you have a 16 year old boy or girl and they're on technology, like how do you limit, how do they limit that as parents? I mean, I think some of it is like, and I'm not saying that you wouldn't know how to do this at all, because I don't want to give that impression.
But I think delay is absolutely the right word for many reasons. But also, it's about making sure that it is like you're talking about, like it is not the way it works in the brain is it narrows your desires and wants to this to this one thing. That's that's what happens over time. I mean, you see it with kids, right? It's like all they do is on their phone, right? They do nothing else. and i think that to me is like the key and it's what you're talking about it's like having these spaces and time and valuing of other things and and i mean we could talk about this for like an hour we can like go on and on about this um and i feel like we've kind of gone on a tangent but no let's double click on this for a second what are sort of the big points here because this is something when i talk to other parents it's a hot topic to talk about yeah when i talk to schools it's a hot topic yes people want to know uh more about it they also want to know sort of like where where they can take strides right so if if parents are listening to this and they have a 16 year old addicted to their phone yeah what are the tangible things they can do in the next one month or you know today the next month the next three months to sort of like help okay so here's how it works and this is what i'm just writing about right now our brains are these little prediction devices, right?
And when I walk into an environment, my brain does this quick calculation of where am I going to get my rewards in this environment? I'm going to maximize the rewards. And kids are even more this way because their brains are, their prefrontal cortex is less developed. If a child walks into the living room and every time they've walked into that living room for the last like five years of their life, they've played on the video game, they've looked at their phone, their brain is just lighting up like firecrackers they're going to use the phone it's gonna it's gonna exclude out everything else they're never gonna pick up a book because the phone is designed to do that so the only way you can bring back these other things into their life is to create environments where their brain knows they can't have it you have to so does that mean like a technology free weekend does it mean like flip it around so that's like the kind of the desire or like the way we talk about now like sabbath is and hours where we're not it's the other way around life is without it and these are the times we have it oh interesting okay because then your brain relaxes i can't because again your brain is just it's just it's a prediction device it just is predicting where do i get these things and if it knows like i never get it if it's variable reinforcement than you're oh just just all there's there's very more reinforcement it's just the tip of the iceberg of the of the the tools they use to create this to know but i mean like if you're like oh i can get video games some days at four i can get it at some days at six oh if you move it around if you move it around as a parent you create this sort of like i i don't know it's interesting because you could think of the moving that that's a very interesting question to me i've read both in these books like you should do it at the same time so if you do it at the same time the brain will know the brain will know and if you don't do it at that time you'll get like so this is what we currently do and and like give me the best practices here because i'm making this shit up as i go but it's like okay we do video games it's like seven eight every day have your homework done i would cut out every day oh i can't yeah no they learn a lot from video i mean i would argue they actually learn a lot from video well i mean that's another thing it's like screens are not screens, right?
It depends on what they're actually playing, right? But they don't need it. I don't... Well, you know, there's an element of, you're right, they don't need it. There's an element of all their friends are doing it. Playing those video games. Yeah. But, I mean, they don't need it every day. Oh, God. I think, you know, if you were to survey parents, the fact that I give them, like, eight hours of screen time a week is probably on the extremely low end. Is eight hours of screen time gonna hurt them in the long run? Probably. This is what I worry about. I mean, again, it depends on what they're doing.
Depends on the kid. Depends on their reward center. There's all these genetics involved. I have this incredibly addictive personality. I'm basically addicted to Gmail. Me and Tristan Harris. I can get, we'll play Hey Man, and I'll be like, play it again. So for me, an hour a day playing videos wouldn't be good. Okay. You know, I think for some kids, it wouldn't be good. Well, I do change what they play. So if they're mean to each other after. Yeah, there you go. Consistently. So we've talked about this, right? Like we took away a certain video game a while ago because I was like, hey, and I warned them, right?
I'm like, I noticed how you guys interact after you play this. I don't like it. Right. That's not what we do. And that's not how we treat anybody, let alone our family. And then it kept going. And I was like, okay, you just can't play this video game anymore. So I think that. And then it came back two years later. The game? Yeah. I was like, do you want to try again? Like, you know, they're like, we want to play. And I'm like, okay, but you know why we lost it, right? So if it has the same impact, we're going to have the same results. So I think you said like the key thing here, we always talk about time, hours of whatever screen, but it's like that, like, I think we need new recommendations from AAP, from all the societies, because an hour of screen time today can be so different.
First of all, what you're doing. Oh, totally. Yeah. And then it's so different than like an hour screen time when I was a kid. Yeah. Right. It's just not the same. So I think you have to like do exactly what you're saying. You have to like, what happens during that hour of screen time? How does the kid behave? What do they behave like afterwards, right? Like how does it make them feel? Like why do we need to do things? Why do kids need to do things where they feel worse afterwards, right? Tell me more about this feeling worse. Is that like when I try to end it and they won't let me end it? Is it how they treat people?
Like what does it mean to feel worse after? I think it's a lot. I mean, I think you're doing exactly what I'm saying. It's like assessing like... I'm really just making this stuff up. Like this is... I have no idea what I'm doing. I'm just trying to think like, okay, maybe let's figure this out. One thing is that just because the child wants it doesn't mean it's actually like pleasurable. Of course. Right? And so I think a lot of parents think that, oh, they want it so much that they like it. Right? And that's just wrong. That's based off like 50 year old neuroscience. So I'm going to push back on this slightly because when I intuitively hear that, I think in a different way, which is probably completely wrong, but I think something they care about, a currency that I can use to manipulate at worst behavior.
Yes. Yes. Right. And I think lots of parents feel that. Positively reward behavior at best, maybe. Right. And so it's like the one thing in their lives where I'm like, okay, I have something that I know they want. Yes, I think that's the common. That's very common. And I think I felt that way too about it at first. But then I was like, is it worth it? Go deeper on that. Like, okay, so we had like Rosie, maybe like when she was six, it was like starting like with, you know, Netflix, right? Which is insane, right? And if you watch it, like it makes me feel insane to watch some of it. It's like so fast and it's so like psychedelic and it's just like, ah.
And we would every night she would get some time and it would like you say, it was like this currency, right? This like, oh, reward, this like manipulative device. But then at the end of it, she'd be so crazy. And every night would be like a struggle and a fight and like she'd be like a different child. And it was just like, I don't think this is worth it. I don't need this. I can, I don't, first of all, I can motivate her in other ways, ways that don't make her scream at me and ways that don't feel like this struggle and don't make her hyper and don't. And it just feels like a waste of her time.
I think I come at it more from the perspective of it's not hurting her, but actually she's going to feel better and have. If she does something else. Yeah. And it like lifelong better, you know, because what you're doing is you're building habits. Oh, totally. Right. When I'm bored, when I want to relax, and I would even question whether it's relaxing for kids a lot, especially video games, I do this. I can build that habit. I can build that habit in Rosie like that. But maybe better in her life would be like, when I'm bored, I play them a piano. I read a book. And she's never going to pick those things if she knows the other is available.
I have one kid who probably reads too much. If that's even possible. I think most kids are not like that. I take away books as a consequence. He's like, you know... Books, like paper books? And Kindle. He's on the Kindle all the time. It's attached to my account. So, A, I get these crazy Amazon recommendations. It's based on your reading. I'm like, man, you don't know me. I'm not worried about AI taking over at all. Then I open the Kindle and I'm like, now I know where I get it from. But like it's it's a currency coming back to technology. It's like I know something that motivates him. I know that, hey, I'm going to, you know, this is a natural consequence to your behavior.
And then he's like, oh, you're the dad that takes away reading from his child. But that currency to me is more valuable than like watching Netflix. Does it matter if they're if it's sort of like the same thing? If they're reading a book about the same show they'd be watching, do you think? I mean, I think it just again, it depends on what you value. What do you think? For a while, Rosie was kind of addicted to audiobooks. Okay. Like hours and hours and hours, like six, seven hours on the weekends, you know, of just listening. And to some parents, that would be like amazing. And I mean, I think that's better than watching cartoons in the sense that like she learned narrative structure.
She learned an incredible vocabulary, right? Like, so that's what I'm saying. Like I had to like figure out, but then it was, I could see it was like squeezing out other things and it was like creating conflict. Right. Like, so it's like, what do I value? takes over so this value thing is super interesting because it's it makes me wonder if a lot of our parenting is driven by like we're trying to succeed through our children instead of putting our children in a position where they can succeed i think that we don't oh you get into yale that's my success as much as your success and you're transmitting the value of that right i don't think we stop and think enough about like how our actions and what we say and what we the currency we use with children transmits values so for instance like i'm sitting there talking to one of my friends about jonathan's book and about literally about this topic and i have with with the mom of two children and the 13 year old comes over and shows us look mom look at this video of this gerbil like while we're talking about this topic and what does the mom do stops looks at the video stops our face-to-face conversation to look at this like tiktok video and like engage with it and i just left there and i was like what is that transmitting to the children in the room that they're the the vip right you're the and this tiktok video is more important yeah than a face-to- face conversation with a friend and it's not something you're actively communicating but is something they're receiving through.
Oh, I think it is active. I mean, yes, in the sense that like- Like not directive. I'm not saying, oh, the TikTok video is more important. But that's not how kids learn. Kids don't learn from what you say is important. Kids learn through practice and modeling. That is how kids learn everything. What would be an alternative way to handle that situation? I would say, I'm talking to, this is important. I'm having a conversation with Mike Lane right now. You know, let's discuss this later. And then I would tell the child later. You know, number one, that's really rude to, you know, it's a 13 year old kid.
Like they should know at that point. That's rude to, you know, interrupt in the middle of a conversation. Like I would tell Rosie that nicely, not maybe not as mean as I just said it. You would do that after, not in the moment. I wouldn't do it in the moment. You would embarrass the child. You'd make a big scene. In the moment, it's more of a performative parenting device, which is, again, what do you value? Me looking good as a parent. They're less likely to learn, but you feel better. That's right. You're basically shaming them, right? But I would tell them in the moment, like, this conversation is important.
And there, I'm transmitting the value of, I value a face-to-face interaction more than some gerbil video on TikTok. But if you look around, Gene, you will see this everywhere. You will see parents actively valuing and modeling the love of technology. The reward system is really a value system. Yeah. The reward system in the brain is made in animals. So to make sure they get food, sex, water, safety. Right. But in humans, it can be it can be hooked up to anything that seems valuable. And that's what children are learning. They're learning that the screen, these videos, this video game. This is what our society, this is what my family values.
It's so hard. Like, I leave my phone in a different room when we eat dinner. Yeah. Yeah, we have one phone and it's in a drawer. And I feel it, right? You want to go over there? I do. I definitely feel a pull towards it, right? Yeah, they call it motivational magnets. Well, it's like, where's my phone? You know, like, you don't have this thing on you. Yeah, that's your brain. But it's interesting because a couple of weeks ago, my youngest came up to me and he's like, I like that you never have your phone. at dinner. I love that. And I was like, I didn't even think you noticed. And it's like, yeah.
Like it was just this moment of like, oh, I was like, I, so I was doing it because I wanted to pay attention to them. And my motivation was like less of a, you know, it's sort of communicating values, which is like, we need to chat face to face, but it was also about avoiding regret. I didn't want them. I always think about like, well, they're going to move out one day. yeah i hope eventually and when they move out i'm gonna wish i was having dinner yeah and what was more important checking your email for the under time or like and so all of these thoughts lead to like i'm just gonna leave and i'm not uh i usually am but like i'm not 100 confident that i can just like leave it in my pocket and then you can't but the other thing that i've started doing recently is i just when i'm with them i put it on silent mode for sure and the only people that can get through silent mode are them.
Right. I mean, all these things that you're doing are transmitting the value of like, you care about interacting with them more than the phone. Yeah, I didn't think they paid attention. Oh, at least one of them pays attention. I think it's a fascinating observation. I've been, I'm writing a chapter now about how actually kids don't like technology as much as you think they do. Oh, tell me more about this. Because I just asked them. But can they answer that? I mean, if you ask us what kind of car you want, you end up with Homer Simpson. It's not that blatant. And you can actually find it in these conversations or in books.
People will say what you just said. Kids will say things like, oh, I really like this night because we're not on the screens. That's what I'm saying. But you can ask them. You can say, what do you do on the iPad after school? I do this, I do that. And then one little girl said, without even me saying anything, was like, but I would do something more fun and more fun. more fun and more better if my parents let me oh you don't want to actually be on that bit no i don't really want to be like that actually and rosie one day said to me like not that long ago she said i thought you wanted me on the netflix oh interesting because i kind of did in the sense that like what you're talking about using it as currency right so i was like pushing it at her right you need to find something you don't need it it was really weird like again it's this question of wanting it, wanting to pick up your phone and actually enjoying it and actually valuing it.
And actually like, I think most kids would rather you do something else, but they are like, especially teenagers that have been on technology for so long. I mean, their brains are so wired to want it. They call them motivational magnets. The cues turn into these like magnets that pull you there, not the actual software, the cues. Yeah. And you actually transfer the value onto the cues. And it's this very, very, very strong pull. To get away from that, you have to protect the child from the cues. What do you tell your, I don't know, like I'm picking random ages here, but like your 16-year-old or your 12-year-old that they can't watch a show on Netflix or that's not what our family does or values, but then they go to school and everybody's talking about it.
Now they feel left out. They feel like they're not a part of something. Right, right. And isn't it interesting how it's all about fear? Because we think it's about reward, but it's actually about fear. And the fear and the reward system are all enmeshed. Yeah. So I think at the teenage years, they really need to start to understand how it affects their brain. Right. And how it's manipulating their brain, kind of wiring up their reward system to prioritize it over everything else. Teenagers don't like to be manipulated. So I think you start there. You start with this conversation of how this actually works.
One of the neuroscientists said to me, he has a 12 year old boy, just gave him a phone. He gave him this like hour long PowerPoint on what the phone does to his brain and how it works and how this thing called sign tracking and all this stuff. And then they sat down and they said, okay, he said, how much of your day do you want the phone to take up? Let's write it down. How much do you want? And I think the kid says that like 45 minutes a day, which sounds about what you're doing, right? Yeah. And he said, okay. And they wrote it out. And he said, now it's my job as the parent to hold him to that.
It becomes more of this cooperation thing where they're like working together. Well, that's what it is, right? You're effectively trying to come up with something with them, but you're still the parental authority. Oh, I think absolutely you are. But you move from parenting to coaching. Yeah, it's more guidance. But then I think that there's these rules that make sense just neurologically. you know like no no screens in the bedroom yeah i mean like we got rid of right now we have no screens after seven and i try to hold it to myself i can't do that just because of homework too like that they do all their homework on technology sure i mean like yeah i'm not like they leave their phones in the living room they're not letting their phones in their bedroom at this point you know this all changes but try try it in the sense that like if you can one of the neuroscientist who studies dopamine in the eyes told me three hours before bedtime yeah and so i started doing i mean it's crazy right that's like seven o'clock right yeah um and i started doing it like maybe in november and i shane i sleep like i've never slept before i mean i'm not kidding you i'm like i mean i and i think i think kids will feel the same i mean it really affects your the sleep there's no doubt is there a book you came across in your research that like parents of teens you know, sort of 12, 13 can be like, hey, before you get a phone, before we talk about technology, I want you to read this and let's have a conversation about it.
I would recommend watching Social Dilemma. Okay. Have you watched that? Have you guys watched that? No. Definitely watch that. I've heard of some teenagers tell me they've had to watch it in school. Like it's- Oh, interesting. Yeah, it's good. The same schools that don't ban phones. I'm not sure. I haven't done the cross correlation data on that. But the problem is, is that parents don't know these things. Like parents, it's not, like I say, like it's not an even playing field right now the tech industry has all this knowledge and tools and goals about technology and how it affects your brain and it affects children's brain more that way because of you know they're not as developed and parents have none of it right now it's a really really uneven playing field and we're playing with these old rules of two hours of screen time a night and i try to be i mean personally i just try it like the rules are interesting.
We're trying to get away from rules into more like autonomy, if you will, within certain limits of how that goes. But I mean, it's just a nonstop struggle. And I have great kids, so I can imagine if you had more difficult children, I can like some nights I go to bed and I'm like, man, I just won the Olympics, right? Nobody died today. Everybody ate food. This is a win. And they were on the screen for an hour. And some days I'm like, I just don't care. I need a break. I mean, it really is about setting up your environment. I mean, I said that earlier. I said you set up an environment where the child can be autonomous and it's about doing that with the screens.
It's just going to be harder because they are magnets. I want to come back to this just before we end, but what have you learned about in not these tribes, but in sort of Western culture, what can we do for our environment that sort of at least adds friction to things, if not removes them as a possibility? You mean for technology? Well, for technology or anything. Like what can we do to encourage autonomy in our kids through the environment? I'm a big fan of the environment is like the hidden hand. It is. I think James Clear said that, the hidden hand that shapes your... Yeah. I mean, like we said, like a prediction machine.
I come into an environment and it's like, I know, like I'm predicting everything that I've done here in the past, especially with younger children. I mean, older children, too. It's about empowering them so you don't have to say anything to them. Right. It's teaching them the skills they need so that they can be autonomous in your environment. So you can either change the environment and get rid of everything, which is what we kind of tend to do with kids. But then you just leave them unempowered. Right. Or you slowly teach them, you know. So does that make sense? A little bit. Yeah, I think it's just I'm trying to make it practical for.
Right. So give me an example of something that you like a house environment. Like what are the things like one thing that you mentioned that I picked up on, which I mean, we don't do other people may or may not. And I really try not to judge other people. Everybody's doing their best. I really. And every kid is different. That's the thing, too. So but like having a TV in your room or having something like that's an environmental choice, right? where you put the tv and so if you put the tv and sort of the main floor you end up with one sort of you're you're exemplifying one thing right and if you put it in the basement you're you're sort of like putting it out of the way it's not a showpiece uh and then the kids get more autonomy in a way because they have to go downstairs and like figure it out themselves and hang out with their friends if they want to watch tv and so like i'm just thinking are there any other environmental i would love to learn some i'm sure everybody else listening would i think one of the things that maybe we haven't said explicitly that should be said is like i don't think children can be autonomous with technology some technology oh that's interesting okay right i don't think that they're capable i don't even think adults are capable right i mean i'm not so use the environment to shape the technologies is like screen time limits or app limits or something that's right so like let's take like inuit hunting a lot of one of the big goals in is to teach boys but now girls too it's very mixed um to seal hunt okay they have to do many families have to do it and like you know this is a skill you have to learn right well the seal hunt is crazy it is a crazy skill you have to go out on the ice poke a hole in the middle of nowhere and then they put a little tiny like feather in the hole and you sit there and you stare at it for six hours until the feather moves.
And then you stab the ice. Okay, this is a very difficult task. Well, you can't just take a six-year-old and tell him to go seal hunt, right? Well, what do they do? The dad explained it to me. He's like, when the kid can stay outside for six hours, then we'll take him with us, but we'll park him like way out because if they make noise, you're going to mess it all up. And then if the kid still wants to do it, then we'll bring, you know, slowly bring them closer. And it's like, I mean, I think that's how we think of technology is a little bit like seal hunting. So a little bit at a time, demonstrate responsibility.
And then. Yeah, you delay it until they show a lot of interest and really want it. And then it's like, OK, well, where can you go in the seal hunt? You're going to be way out there. Right. And then you show me you can do that. And then I'll pull you in a little bit closer. I guess that's kind of like what I've done intuitively, personally, which is like, OK, well, show me you can be responsible. before we start adding more things to your phone. It's exactly what you like and delaying it, you know, because the kid's not capable of standing over the hole. I'm not capable. Except six hours, right?
And it's like the parent's not gonna stick them in that situation and have them fail. Well, I think if you put a phone, give the child a phone and stick them in their bedroom or the video game, you're putting them at the seal hole to fail, right? And so it's not new that this idea, I just think that we have to treat this thing is this tool that's like kids can't learn yet. They don't have the mental capacity to sit over the hole for six hours. They don't have the mental capacity to carry a phone into their room and not go to bed. It's a slow process. Oh, yeah. And like everybody's doing the best they can.
Every child is different. Every sort of like environment's different, but then like every broader environment's different too. Actually, the community, the school, absolutely. A lot of schools are all technology now. There's iPads and computers and laptops. Oh, and the school is crazy, which I think actually means at home, it's more important to switch it around. Oh, to go the other way. That's interesting. They need to build these other skills. I mean, like I'm a big fan of Cal Newport and he talks a lot about how like concentrating and these, and, you know, doing this kind of deep thinking and stuff is, it takes practice.
We always end with the same question, but I'm going to use a slightly different version of it for you, which is what is success as a parent for you? So when I first, before I wrote the book, it was like what you're talking about, like Yale, you know, it's like Rosie speaking Mandarin and going to Yale was, you know, like, I don't, I don't even. But then when I wrote the book, I was like, success for me is Rosie feeling growing up mentally healthy. What does that mean? Mentally healthy? Not having tons of anxiety and depression and like feeling suicidal and like, you know, like, like enjoying life.
life, you know, like really enjoying life and enjoying our relationship, enjoying being part of the family, which I think is important for like mentally healthy kids. You know, that means working, having a job. That means having a family. That means whatever that means for her. But like, you know, waking up and being excited about the things she's doing in that day. It's a beautiful way to end this conversation. Thank you so much for taking the time. Thanks for listening and learning with us. For a complete list of episodes, show notes, transcripts, and more, go to fs.blog slash podcast, or just Google The Knowledge Project.
Recently, I've started to record my reflections and thoughts about the interview after the interview. I sit down, highlight the key moments that stood out for me, and I also talk about other connections to episodes and sort of what's got me pondering that I maybe haven't quite figured out. This is available to supporting members of The Knowledge Project. You can go to fs.blog slash membership, check out the show notes for a link and you can sign up today. And my reflections will just be available in your private podcast feed. You'll also skip all the ads at the front of the episode. The Farnham Street blog is also where you can learn more about my new book, Clear Thinking, turning ordinary moments into extraordinary results.
It's a transformative guide that hands you the tools to master your fate, sharpen your decision making, and set yourself up for unparalleled success. Learn more at fs.blog.com. Until next time.