No summary for this episode yet.
You look back and I don't think about the things that were really hard, the injuries. I really don't think back like that. I think of how great it was to live that life and play the game. Hello and welcome. I'm Shane Parrish and this is The Knowledge Project, a podcast exploring the ideas, methods, and mental models that help you learn from the best of what other people have already figured out. To learn more about the show and past guests, go to fs.blog.com. My guest today is former professional hockey player Brent Gilchrist. Brent spent 15 years in the NHL playing 792 games with the Montreal Canadiens, Edmonton Oilers, Dallas Stars, Detroit Red Wings, and Nashville Predators.
He won a Stanley Cup with the Red Wings in 1998. In his post-playing career, he's become a mining executive with JDS Energy and Mining. In this conversation, we explore what it's like to play in the NHL and the habits that allowed him to have such a long playing career. We talk about the difference between good coaches and bad coaches. We also talk about how he transitioned from hockey to investing and then venture capital and mining. Let's get started. Take me to the Stanley Cup final. You're a professional hockey player at this point. This is before we get into mining and post-playing career.
What is that like? I was fortunate enough to play in two Stanley Cup finals. And fortunate and probably misled a little bit. My first year in the NHL, I played with the Montreal Canadiens. And we had a great team. We finished second that year in the standings. and in 1989 we ended up playing the Calgary Flames in the Stanley Cup final. And we lost in six games, obviously really devastating, but as a 21-year-old kid to play in a Stanley Cup final your first year. And one story I remember after we eliminated Philadelphia in the Spectrum in the conference final, I remember sitting next to Bob Gainey on the bus and the bus ride from the Spectrum to the airport.
And he said to me, you know, when you get here, when you have a kick at the can, you have to win it because you never know when you're going to be back. And as a 21-year-old with no experience, I thought, well. This is easy. And I also thought Bob was 36 or 37. He was our captain. But I think we all knew that Bob was probably going to retire that year or the next year. And I thought to myself, well, you're probably not going to be back here. you're, you know, but I will be, you know, like this seems like we're the best team in the league or close to it. Well, that was a rude awakening that I, it took me 10 years as a player to get back to the finals with a completely different team.
And I had a few stops in between and getting back to the finals with Detroit. It was, it was not bittersweet for me, but I, I played most of the playoffs seriously injured and and so the finals was not not in my in my cards I was not going to be able to play in the finals I played the last game against Dallas the team that I had just left and we beat them in six which was a great series they were a great team so for me on a personal standpoint outside the team there was a lot of risk in me moving from Dallas to Detroit, which Dallas, we had a real strong team. And then of course, um, as, uh, as the car, the chips would fall here, I am playing against him in the, in the conference final.
So we eliminated him, but I was, um, I was unable to continue. So I didn't play the last four games. I think I read something, maybe it was a Steve Iserman interview where he said that he's never seen somebody go through as much pain as you were in playing. Well, I think, um, you know, Steve being the person he is and the friend he is, obviously meant a lot for him to say that. But he actually has done the same himself in a couple different playoff seasons. I watched him do it. But it was great of him to say that. He's a great person, obviously a great player, and a great captain. But, yeah, that was great to hear him say that.
said it publicly many times and some of the other players on our team said that um because it was very hush-hush during the um during the playoffs obviously and um and it was it was an experience that um I look back on and boy I'm not tough enough anymore to take that sort of pain uh but as a player and as the in the moment in the moment I did not think one minute about that um it's just what you did and today I'm I'm just you know I'm a big wimp I I don't want to go in anywhere near the pain that we used to go through. You said he was a great captain. What's the role of an NHL captain of a team?
Yeah, so it's very different part of leadership than I face today as a leader in business and working with other leaders and decision makers. The captain of a hockey team, you know, typically they're your best player. Not always. I think we have a hard time. Society always want our society leadership and business and sports we want to talk about leaders and we you know talk about the characteristics they have and for sure that's there's a truth to that but in hockey like the captain's not making decisions so he's not the leader of the team he's the he may be the emotional leader or the best player leader on the ice and in the locker room but but he's beyond the leader the leadership of decision making which I think well as I learn in business, everything about leadership is decision-making.
And I think two things that I would say about, not just one thing I would say about an NHL captain or a leader in business, we just can't seem to put our finger exactly on what a leader should do or look like or his characteristics or her. But what I will say is a great leader, people follow. Why they do that, charisma the way they lead by example i think one thing for me a leader is believable do you believe when people believe a leader they follow and that's the best way i can describe it in hockey the captain has to be believable he has to lead by example he has to do the things that that um the sacrifice that every every player is expected or or even to a higher degree but also they have to be great teammates and I think we miss that that that being on an NHL hockey team you're the leader but the reason you're the leader is you're you might be the best teammate you might be such a great team player and care about not just the the wins and losses the goals and assists but the other players on the team and I think that's really it we just miss that a great leader in hockey is a great teammate who picks the leader is it the GM the coach the players I don't even know how that's selected is it written in contracts yeah so it's absolutely I don't think it's uh there's any rules um I've you know played 15 years in NHL I voted for my captain once one time that happened um when Bob Ganey retired from the Montreal Canadiens the next season here we were we were a great team we just lost in the finals and um and here we were not rudderless but this was a big hole because Bob Ganey was you know this iconic captain of a team that was a dynasty won one cup in the 80s we lost a cup in in 89 and you're going to replace somebody that was for us as young players just working on a different level and and somebody we watched as real young kids so we voted for the captain Serge Savard was our general manager who was one of the best hockey men and people that I ever worked with.
Just so well respected, just a great person. And he came in the locker room, said, we're going to vote for the captain. And so we voted and the first round came out. And I think there was only three candidates. There might've been four, but I remember Chris Chelios and Guy Carboneau. And I think Brian Scruton got a few votes, but, and there might've been one more, but I'm not too sure. But the fact was, is Guy Carbino and Chris Chelios tied and so okay that was a tie that's fine now we throw everybody out and we say okay guys um or Serge said we're gonna between these two guys who had the most votes we voted again and they tied and so I was like wow what what what's you know what's what's Serge gonna do and he said he made a very quick decision he said okay we're gonna have two captains that was it so one war I think the C1 game and I think they just switched on and off I can't remember how how we did it and he made a fast decision which was interesting I think you know Serge was a great leader of that organization and I think his decision was was good because it wouldn't create any controversy and there was you know there's no question amongst the players there was no rivalry between French and English players but certainly in the Montreal media there was always a rivalry if a French player, I think the way we felt as English players anyway, if a French player was as good as you, he was probably going to get the spot from a media standpoint, not from a Serge Savard or Pat Burns standpoint.
But, you know, they were always looking for, you know, a bias to French Canadian players, which is fine. You know, it never affected us as players. A follow-up on that is at the time you had Patrick Waugh on the team as well, who's probably the best goalie in the NHL. Absolutely. Why are goalies never team captains? Well, we had one instance of it in Vancouver. Roberto Luongo was the captain for a couple of years. I think in the past there has been some, and I'm going to mess up my history, but I want to say like George Besner or something was the captain. It's pretty rare though. Very rare, and it hasn't happened other than Roberto for probably 50, 67 years.
I'm not too sure. I'd have to look that up. But I think from the standpoint that I look at it, and I'm not sure that the rest of the hockey world would think that, but the goalie has this position that's unique. It's, they're not, everybody says they're weird, and sometimes they are, and sometimes they're not. But they have a, there's a solitude to their position that's somewhat different than the rest of the players. Not that they're not part of the team, but their position has some solitude to it. and we sort of always players and coaches and I think management I think you try to leave your goalie alone a little more than you do other players from their preparation and their and their work um they have many coaches now I wasn't so much like that when I played there was a goalie coach but he wasn't maybe so was involved so I think they have a they have a position that that they have enough to deal with and you sort of just let them it's it's a big mental game and they they they have a solitude like i said before so i think we leave them alone and i think to to to put the captaincy on somebody in that position as another layer that may you don't want anything to affect your goalie you know preparation and mental ability you want them thinking about one thing stopping the puck right and if you overlay the leadership of the team on i think it could be a problem i would say that patrick was one that could handle that great leader great guy great player and um so competitive you just you know just even shooting on patrick in practice it was a competition you didn't come down and just shoot you really tried to score because you knew he would not want you to score a goal in practice um was that different from other teams you played You know, I think everybody's competitive and the goalies are super competitive, but I just saw their goalies preparing.
If they were practicing, they were practicing some things and they weren't going to kill themselves to stop a puck in practice. I don't say that it's right or wrong. You know, a practice is practice. I just remember that when Patrick was in the net during warm-up practice, he really was focused on stopping the puck and he was real competitive. It was a lot of fun, but not, not to a, not to a, he wasn't, he wasn't overdone or, or nasty about it. He just, he was really competitive. To the outside world. I mean, it often seems like you're living the dream, right? You're a professional hockey player.
You get paid to play hockey. What behind the scenes don't we see in terms of preparation? Is it a full year round job? Is it a nine to five on a daily basis? Are you just going for a morning warmup? Walk me through a little bit of what goes into how you excel and how you become a professional hockey player. Yeah, so I don't have the secret, and I don't think any of us do. As a kid, all I wanted to do was play hockey, and I think my teammates and my colleagues were probably very similar to me. More Canadians when I came up in the league, and now as my career progressed, obviously lots of Europeans, lots of Russians, all the best players in the world the league just kept getting better so what we what fans don't see I think it's you can be fairly typical on what they don't see the travel stuff the work you know the the the toll on your body um how hard it is every day and probably what one doesn't think about as much as just the stress and the emotional um toll and so it's very very competitive the league's competitive but also your team is very competitive so you're fighting for your job every day maybe not the superstars or maybe not in sort of the prime of your career you're not thinking about that as much but when you're younger and older you're trying to keep your job and that is a daily exercise that you have to work very hard at and um and you're always trying to play your best and we all you know when as players i think that we all think of ourselves as the best game we ever played or the best season we ever had played that was how good we are that's the standard and that that's how good we were or i was but you know you you don't sort of couple it all up with the bad season the bad games and so it's always a struggle to play at your at your best and i think the best players in the game the best players in the world and the historically the the hall of famers i don't think their skills are that much better than everybody else they are better in circumstances sure they may be faster better shots or better pop candlers but i think it's their ability to to make their you know to achieve the highest level of their abilities consistently and that's the hardest thing to do the competitiveness of playing your best um as well as you can yeah and you just can't maintain it i think that's the i think that's A lot of times the difference between the great, great players is they maintain their highest level at a very consistent basis.
And the rest of us struggle to do that. So, you know, we all grew up being the best players on our team or in our community. And, you know, the air gets thinner up there. But it's great. It's such a great life. And you look back and I don't think about the things that were really hard, the injuries. and sometimes the stress of being a player and trying to maintain your position in the travel. I really don't think of back like that. I think of how great it was to live that life and play the game. How hard is it to go from being the best player on every team you've probably played on to the NHL where you might have to accept a role that's what you've never done before in order to make the team or in order to contribute?
you? Yeah. I don't know that it was tough. I think it was a progression. And I don't know if acceptance is the right word, but when I came up in Montreal, I was not a regular player in my rookie season. I think I played 49 games. And you're always trying to get in the lineup. I don't think it was difficult. I think you're fighting so hard to find that position and find that role, I think that's more what it is. So Pat Burns was my coach and he coached me the year before in the American League. And all of a sudden, what I realized that I was, I might not be a centerman in the NHL and I was always a centerman.
I never played anything else as a kid. You know, when you're always really, really young, you played other positions, but always played center. So all of a sudden I found myself on the left wing. I thought, well, this is interesting. and then I found myself on the right wing and I would bounce back and forth between center right wing and left wing and what I didn't realize it was going to be such a blessing for me that we had four incredible centers in Montreal in the late 80s and that it was going to be tough for me to play center regular but when somebody was hurt I got I typically got the chance to play center so what the blessing was is I became a player that could play in could play all three positions.
I'm not saying that guys can't, but maybe in those days it was a little more structured and almost had a utility to my game that helped me play a long career. Playing 15 years is not easy at my size. And, you know, my offensive output was not always stellar. So you're right, you find the role and my role actually was not singular. And I was able to play power play through my career, more penalty killing, lots of times in a defensive role, but other times, you know, I got the opportunity to play on a more offensive line and being able to play those three positions, um, without really any, any, any difference to my game helped me a lot.
So, so that was a blessing. The versatility makes it harder to like, to get rid of you in a way, right? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think that you can be plugged in and, um, there's, there's always the intangibles how does that affect your mind though like do you come into that going i'm a center iceman and now they're asking me to do something i'm not and i'm not going to be at my best and yeah i again i don't think i rationalized it or or really gave many thoughts about it maybe early on yeah just like okay i'm in the lineup tonight that's number one and okay i'm playing left wing and on that team there wasn't a bad position to be in if you got in the lineup Every player around you, for me at that point, certainly was, wow, this player's fantastic, that player's fantastic.
And we had a very deep team, so all our lines were very good. We may have lines that were scoring or more defensive, but all the players could, they were great players. What's the wear and tear on the body? I think they play 80 game seasons at that point? It's 82 now. It's been, through my career, it had been 80 and then 82 and then 84 and then back to 82. So it's, you know, for a player my size, it was always a challenge to maintain your health. What do you mean your size? Well, I'm small for a pro. I played at about 180 pounds, maybe a little less. Okay. A little heavier now, unfortunately.
And so that's the strength and the size that you're up against. It can be grueling, or it is grueling. And I think it's harder for smaller players when they do get hurt to withstand continuing to play injured. And the bigger guys are just stronger. They're more able, in my opinion, to accept more punishment. And that's just a simple fact. So does that mean, in a way, as a fan, we should have more respect for people like Sidney Crosby and Connor McDavid are on the smaller size? I don't think we have to respect them more because they're smaller. They're just so good. I mean, definitely. They're amazing.
Yeah, I think. But we probably don't appreciate the word and terror. I think it's harder for them. I think Sidney, I mean, those players are so strong. Physically, they're just very gifted, not only in their talent, but they're very, very strong athletes. So, no, it's just, it's a bit harder, but it, you know, it doesn't mean, you know, people, I remember I was too small to play in the NHL. I was, it was told, you know, I heard that many, many times. Did that motivate you? Sure. And I don't think it mattered to me. Like, I don't think I, you know, if somebody said, because, because I think not just small players, but, you know, a big player, you know, they're probably saying, well, he's too slow to play in the National League.
And so, you know, it wasn't something I was worried about. But when I hear somebody say he's too small to play, he's not. Nobody is. Everybody has skills and then they have, you know, they have things that are going to hold them back. Now, there's just not perfect players out there typically. Maybe, you know, maybe there's a few. But, you know, you're too slow. You're not tough enough. Everybody's fighting against something that's, you know, their weaknesses. and you're small or you're big or you're slow or you're you know or you're not that tough so they say you either can play and help a team win or you can't there's no there's no attribute that's going to say you can't do this if you're small and you can't play it means you're not good enough to play and so everybody's judged on whether you help a team win or not whether you can score whether you can stop a team from scoring whatever it is do you help the team win or not and if you're five feet tall but you help your team win you're gonna be in the lineup you were traded a few times right from montreal to edmonton edmonton to dallas yes and then dallas to detroit yeah so dallas to detroit i left as a free agent okay yeah the other the other yeah the trades are interesting um what's that like as a player coming up to the trade deadline no do you have a sense that you might be traded do people talk to you yeah no no no sense of that one so it was in the summer and I just had the best season of my career.
That was the Montreal to Edmonton. Yeah. And I was here in Montreal. I spent the summer in Montreal with my soon to be wife at the time, Carolyn. And that was devastating to say the least. I'd never been traded as a junior or as a pro. And I don't have any tattoos, but if I did have one at that time, it would be the CH. was drafted by them and loved living in the city loved playing for the team we're a good team and you know my teammates were we were so close and to get traded was really difficult did never thought I'd leave Montreal of course that's a young player that that doesn't quite have a reality on the business and once it happened you know you you sort through it and you pick yourself up and how did you find out would you read the newspaper did they call you no so they were trying to call me apparently it was the afternoon it was august 27th you remember the day yeah absolutely um i was actually at the forum in the gym working out and i want to say that the rolling stones were in town and uh carolyn and i were on our way with friends to see the rolling stones at olympic stadium yeah i'm pretty sure it was the same night um and so i was working out having an afternoon workout uh the forum was always open to us and i spent the summer here so i was working out and and they service of art i apparently was trying to call me and and jacques demer said just taking over from pat burns as our coach and i hadn't played for jacques yet and he walked into the gym because somebody told them upstairs that i was in the gym he walked in and he said bren i gotta talk he pulled me in his office he says this is very difficult for me because I you know we don't know each other well and you haven't played for me yet but um you've been traded to the Edmonton Oilers for Vincent Danfus he says you and Shane Corson and yeah it was a it was a tough one and one of the toughest things was my wife was working she just finished her law degree and she was working downtown here articling at a law firm and that was going to be a tough one born and raised French Canadian girl born and raised here in Montreal.
So I went to her office and she knew something was wrong because I'd never been to her office before. So yeah, that was a tough one to tell her that that I'd been traded. And in effect, we've been traded. So how did that change your relationship to the team after you were traded? I mean, you just said you would have a tattoo of like the Montreal Canadiens logo on your heart, sort of. How does that change going to Edmonton at that point where you're still a player you still want to play you love the game but does your relationship to the team change I think so so playing for Montreal in those days and I'm not I don't know the modern day you know it was the New York Yankees it was all those things and you believed in everything that was happening here and you just didn't think there was another place to play like this was the place you know and I'm sure there was other players feeling about that about their own team and then as my career you know as you as you get more experience what i think great teams become is and in today's modern game where you have a team in las vegas that has no history but lots of success all these different teams so i do believe this that the front of the jersey uh the logo does mean less and i think what means the same is your teammates right i think the great teams play for each other they play for their team sure they play for their fans they want they want to make their fans proud but if it's not about the 20 guys in the locker room that you're that you'll you'll you'll go to bat for you'll go to war for you'll fight for all those things that's what maintains the team and the the logo has to mean less today with 31 teams and probably 32 shortly versus six and then 12.
And then when I came in the league, it was probably 21. But there was still those franchises that were the original six. And I was fortunate to play for two original six teams and have lots of success, obviously, in Montreal and in Detroit. And I think that the logo, the jersey, meant something more because there was so much history to it. But at the end of the day, it's your teammates. You played for some great coaches. I mean, Pat Burns, Scotty Bowman. I'm probably leaving out a few here. What was different about great coaches to average coaches? That's probably hard to describe. So I'll just go through those two.
But Pat was a great coach. But he was, I think Pat and I had a good relationship because he coached me when I was playing in the American League. And he definitely was, you know, I had more rapport with him. I could speak to him more than a lot of the other coaches I didn't know as well. And he was a real fiery guy, real passionate. lose his temper a lot, but you knew his bark was way worse than his bite. So the players trusted him, and I think that was Pat. And he wore everything on his sleeve, right? So you knew where you stood with him, and you knew when he was probably going overboard because he was just such an emotional guy, but really, really great person.
Scotty, so I'll skip right to Scotty because, you know, he fascinates everybody. one thing I think I recognize with Scotty is he would make any decision that he thought was right and you might think that was crazy you know like he he would do things that that other coaches I don't think would do I think part of that was his success where he was in his career because I played for him when he was in his 60s or even his mid-60s and he could make a decision and never worry once about his job if it was the wrong decision that's a hard thing for any leader coaches, you know, business managers is when you make a decision, it's I've got this decision nailed, but it's going to be viewed in the public like a bit, you know, a bit off the wall.
And if it goes wrong, you're risking. And we see that every day, whether it's the prime minister of the country or the leader of the, you know, Royal Bank, they make decisions. And sometimes we know their decisions are affected by what what the public is going to going to see and I don't think Scottie was at a point in his career that it mattered that he could make any decision I remember him sitting out Sergei Fedorov like one of the best players in the world and Sergei had probably had a couple bad games which is not uncommon for anybody in the league and I think Scottie decided to sit him out and that was like well that's a that's a scary decision for most coaches and um of course it worked because you know everybody stood up and went wow like you said if he can get benched exactly so of course you know the team reacted very well and Sergey came back in the lineup the next game or whatever but um those are things that most coaches and certainly a young coach I doubt would sit on a superstar you kind of grew up in the NHL as it was becoming this huge business right I mean I don't know what the average salary was when you started but when you ended your career it was much different absolutely that's one thing i look at all the time because people ask me man the players make so much money now and i said we were very well paid we were there's no grudge here of the because we were paid a lot more than the generation before us and that's just that's just what it is and the players today they deserve the money they're making and um and and they're probably not going to make it as long as we did because i I see that the couriers are shorter.
Yeah, a guy loses a step, boy, he's not long for the NHL. It happens faster now. They train harder. They're in better shape. They're bigger and faster. And when you stumble a little bit, you know, I think your career ends faster. But anyway, you know, I was in a – I think every era is a great era. And, you know, I certainly wouldn't change the era I played. And things did change a lot from 1988 to 2003. Maybe one of the biggest changes from start to finish in terms of money and business that the game has seen. Walk me through the first, when does training camp start in the NHL? August? September?
September. So walk me through the first September after you've retired. Yeah. Well. What are you doing? I was feeling pretty good. You know, obviously there was some anxiousness. But it was, you know, I'm not that anxious, certainly on the outside. But, you know, you're second guessing yourself. I think one of the things that helped me transition is I had a real focus. I knew exactly what I wanted to do probably five or ten years before I retired. And I wanted to be in the investment business. I've always been, was always fascinated with capital allocation. I was, you know, learning self-taught and I self is maybe the wrong word, but in terms of, um, you know, formal education, self-taught, but would hang around a lot of people that did that for a living, that allocated capital, that managed money and, um, you know, learned a lot through osmosis and being around it and doing it with my own money.
And so I had a real focus that I wanted to start on an investment practice right away when I retired. So immediately I went into all the licensing, you know, from the securities exams to options trading. Everything I was, you know, getting all the licenses behind me. Did you come back to Canada or were you still in Detroit at that time? I did. And that was a decision. So my last season we played in Nashville and we left Detroit and it probably broke us away from the city of Detroit, which was a great place to live and we enjoyed it there. We could have stayed and lived. We had lots of friends there, lots of contacts, and we really liked the community, believe it or not.
And for a lot of Canadians, that's like, really, Detroit? Yes, a really good place to live, a real good community, good schools, and where we lived anyway. Obviously, the city of Detroit has its own challenges, which is getting better. So the decision was we were in Nashville, which was not a place that we really had any attachment to. And it was a very nice city. We really enjoyed the season we played there. And I obviously wasn't going to play. I retired, but I was going to be told I was going to retire too. I maybe could have went to Europe, but I was not going to get another contract in the NHL when I was 36.
And you knew that? Yeah, I knew. You felt it? Oh, yeah, I knew that. Or people were very direct about it, like this is your last year? Yeah, not really, because I really didn't seek out that direction because I knew that, well, two things. I knew that there wasn't a team out there that was looking for a 36-year-old, 178-pound, slowing forward. Stanley Cup winner. Yeah, that scored one goal the previous season. And secondly, I knew I was done. I knew that the speed and the size of the players was starting to look like I wasn't feeling, I was feeling out of place. So there was a total reality to that.
I was not kidding myself. Was it one year too many? No, I don't think so. I think, I think I had a, I think I wouldn't say I had a good season, like I played really well, but I think I was a useful player for the Predators in terms of some experience and filled in when, when they needed. We didn't make the playoffs that year. And I think, I think we could have, they made the playoffs the next year. So I don't think it was one year too many, but I think it was, that was it. I was, I was done I knew it and it was time to move on so did you think about that during that last season yes and did that change how you you enjoyed that last season well so I think I was very conscious of where I was and I was very conscious that I didn't want to hate my last season I wasn't physically um you know that healthy and so it was a grind it was grueling even only playing 41 games and I also didn't want to hate what I was doing.
I was trying to be conscious of where I was, how great a life I'd led in the National League and I was still playing in the NHL and so I did not want to regret one minute of it and so I was conscious to be careful of that. So I didn't, I just, I enjoyed, I accepted the role. Not every day, maybe the role frustrated me a few times that, you know, Barry Trotz would come and say, Brent, you're not playing. I really respected Barry. He'd come to me every day and say, you're not going to play today. But I felt like he had a real respect for me as a player, and he was a real good guy to play for. So I think your question back to what was that September like, I think the transition was pretty good because I immediately jumped into something.
It wasn't overwhelming. And you had planned it beforehand. So the decision was to move back to Canada. We had a summer home in my hometown or close to my hometown. We had a summer home in Kelowna, but really the same thing, same community that I grew up in and played junior around there. And it was a bit of a natural to just say, okay, the kids are pretty comfortable here. The decision would have been to go back to Detroit, which was sort of reestablished. We had sold our home. And so we said, let's give this a try. and you know i had friends in the business in the investment business just said hey your office is ready when you're ready so it was a natural um i had a good friend um running a ds office in the okanagan and he said no let's uh rbc and so i started an investment practice at dominion securities how did you go about learning about this while you're playing hockey what was that process like it's all about reading you know i was i i today i'm less of an avid reader because it's it's easier to get information quickly so i read less books than i want to right now but i do get the sort of the gist of books by your podcast you know by by freakonomics by you know revisionist history whatever it is um so i i was so passionate and still am about capital allocation, you know, how the history of the stock market, you know, what Buffett writes, what, or says what Munger has written in, in the Almanac.
I'm sure Charlie Munger is not a household name amongst NHL players. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, some of the ones I hung out with for sure, but not, probably not as many. So it was, I mean, I don't think you ever really understand, or think you can get good at something that you don't love. And I have a great passion for it, the history of the capital markets. And that's the view I take, the actual management from a day-to-day basis because I still do quite a bit of that. It's not day-to-day. It's more big-picture thinking. And I don't know how I got here, but it's where I want to be and it's what I'm passionate about.
And then you moved from investment management to mining. Yeah. So I obviously had a very good friend, Jeff Stibbert, who has built an incredible business called JDS Energy and Mining. And we were, you know, we ended up sort of in Kelowna at the same time. He'd retired from running a big oil sands project, mining engineer and really good leader. and we ended up there and we became friends through, I think, our kids playing hockey together. And so we did some business together from an investment standpoint. And basically the businesses that I started and he started were sort of kicked off at the same time.
His business grew really fast and he was interested in just more. He's always interested more. He's a serial entrepreneur and just a guy who just wants to do a lot. So he approached me about leaving my investment business and starting what we call today JDS Resources, which is really just a company that doesn't hold a lot, but we look for our own opportunities. And that's sort of how he approached me. Only in mining? Yeah, pretty much. I mean, in natural resources, I mean, we'll look at other investments that we don't have something to do with. If it looks attractive, we look at everything. But from a standpoint of us starting something, it really has to fall within our expertise.
And it really is mining at this point. So we didn't know how we were going to do this or what we were going to do. um so at the end of 2011 i i sold my investment business and um and started at this company that jeff and i said this is what we're going to do jds resources and again our strategy was it didn't exist we just knew that we had a team at energy at jds that could evaluate could design could build We could do anything from cradle to grave in the right project. And something that was probably unloved and uncared about by the public market because we were going to stay private. And there is lots of opportunities out there.
They're tough to transact on. They're tough to get aligned with whoever owns them. And, you know, I didn't know, and neither did Jeff, how this was going to morph. And within, you know, six months, we were sort of flat out on trying to buy an asset. And it's been sort of hair back ever since. What are the advantages to being private in a generally public, well-funded? So well-funded is the key. Nothing junior mining is well-funded, whether it's exploration. And we're not exploration guys. We look for assets that are ready to or close to being developed as mines. And when you look at that whole sphere, that whole world, there's very few projects that are ever going to be mines there's you know they explore for a while find something but it's likely never going to be large or economic enough um you know enough metal in a concentrated area to become a mine so um we look through a lot of stuff and we work for a lot of people so we see a lot of the projects that are out there that could be what we call stranded um and stranded means yeah too small for most people to pay attention to what does stranded mean could mean all those things you know a lot of people call it distressed but we're not so um enamored with the word distress we like stranded because sure the company that holds it could be distressed but that has nothing to do with the asset and the value that that we see or potentially see.
But you're right. The market, the public market tends to ignore things that don't, you know, that they can't really promote to be something massive, right? When somebody puts their money into a junior exploration project, they want to see the potential to take your 10 cent stock to $2. And that means a massive increase in the resource. We sort of come after where the resource has been somewhat defined and we think it's economic yes you know the proven probable sort of exactly and once we dig into it we have you know like i said we have a great team and we're really mining engineering focused they will see they'll look at the resource and say can we make something economic of this can we actually build a mineable plan here to extract enough of the metal or as we say we extract cash not metal we don't really care about the metal and based on how much it's going to cost us to design and permit and build and then start up, can it pay back its capital pretty fast?
And can there be enough life there to have a reserve tail that a financier in New York or London or wherever is going to be interested in? And we pride ourselves. We don't do anything without a model, an economic model being built. and we take assumptions up front that say this is going to be economic to a glorious return. And it has to really look good when we first jot out the economics because it's going to change. We're taking some assumptions in that point that we don't have all those answers to. And our people have to go back in and start to do a deeper dive on the capital and on the resource.
Historically, when you look at those economic projections, what percentage of the time are they within maybe 10% or 20% of the actual sort of return that you get? So we don't have a good sample size for what we've done because I think you need a big sample size from what I call a feasibility study. So typically we start with a preliminary economic analysis, pre-fees, and then a fees right and the fees is sort of the granddaddy to say hey this is really um reliable but from a development standpoint things change quickly things change in the north or change in africa or change wherever and it always takes more time so it's very difficult when you do a feasibility you put a construction plan together well that's a construction plan a constrained construction plan but for a company to get to the construction even it's it could cost a lot of money whether it's permitting so this is not always captured in the end result of starting construction building it and then starting up a mine and having enough working capital to get it get it to cash flow there's a whole bunch in between that so can you walk me through that i think the average listener probably has no idea and myself included what goes into extracting something from a mine so i'll start with this comment as i said before like capital allocation investment is just it's a real passion i just love it i love reviewing it looking at it under trying to understand it and i would say this that the mine site is one of the most incredible economic models that you can ever analyze and i'm not a mining engineer geologist but i have an incredible team around me that has taught me so much about this.
But I am well-versed on how the capital is going to go in, how it's going to be financed. So the economic study of a mine is incredible because the minute somebody moves, it costs money. The minute you don't hit your extracted ton rate, it costs money. So you're always trying to say, okay, the tons are X and the amount of metal that's in those tons is why. And when you're extracting it, you have costs on everything you do, drilling, blasting, everybody who's moving, hauling, and then processing. And then you also have this corporate office, the GNA. And every time something doesn't quite go right, those costs just rise.
So when we look at something, we know that's a reality until you really get a mine operating efficiently, which takes a long time, and it typically takes more capital to get really efficient. So when we look at things, we know that we're looking at extraordinarily high returns from the first view, because we know that those are going to be hampered as you dig into the devils in the details. And with our project that we bought in Northern British Columbia, we saw a massive margin in the extraction of that ore, because it It was a very, very high grade silver lead zinc. And so we knew that there would be mistakes along the way.
There would be inefficiencies along the way that we would struggle with raising all the capital that we needed. But the margin was so great that at the end of the day, there was going to be a good profit. What goes into making a decision outside of the economic factors? I mean, you're always dealing with sellers in this case who know more about the asset than you do. How do you? A lot of times we feel like we know more about the asset than the seller, or we know more about how the asset should be developed. That's what we think we're really good at. What other decisions? Many. So we have what we would call an investment criteria.
And it's become, you know, for my team, they know it. It's second nature. We know what we have to look at, the first five or six things, and then sort of thumbs up, wow, this looks good. Now, what else is there? Jurisdiction. Is it in Africa or is it at 10,000 feet on the side of a glacier in northern British Columbia? You know, so all those things. You can look at the resource and you can look at many of the technical factors that go into making money on that resource. But how do you get there? Oh, you know, the First Nations community, are they favorable to mining? Can you involve them in this project?
and then permitting you know you can't build a mine on the mountain next to Kelowna you know you know next to Okanagan Lake like the government and the community is not going to let you do that could be the best resource in the world it's not going to happen so those decisions there's political there's there's access decisions or it could be at the 66th parallel in the Arctic and that provides other challenges are going to be more costly doesn't mean it doesn't work but those all have to go into the model. And then you have to take some risk on that decision making. And there's no question that the business carries risks.
But our analysis, we feel like we can't control the risk, but we hope to understand it. And then there's no place where you don't, in any business, that you can understand all the risks. Because some risk is invisible. Otherwise, it wouldn't be a risk. You'd know about it. And so you deal with it. And things get broken and things go wrong. But, you know, we think we're pretty resilient and we'll just fix it. It's going to cost more money? Sure it is. We're going to fix it. And you build that into your thinking going along. We do. And that's basically, I don't think you can actually, you know, we always have a contingency in models, but it's about the margin.
If the margin is so good that you know that there's going to be ups and downs, and then we haven't even talked about the price of the commodity, which is out of everybody's control. And there's not one person out there that I will ever believe when they tell me what the price of a commodity is going to do. It's not knowable. And it's funny how the world is so fascinated by predicting and telling us. You know, we pay a lot of people a lot of money to tell us where gold is going or where interest. And I don't realize if anybody actually had the answer to that, they would be like a quadrillionaire.
And, you know, on a consistent basis, they would definitely not be selling that information. No, they don't need. I always said if I knew where the stock market was going or where gold was going, I'd be on a beach with my computer. I wouldn't need any of you people. Listen, this has been an amazing conversation. I want to thank you so much for taking the time to talk with me today. Awesome. Thanks, Shane. Hey, guys, this is Shane again. Just a few more things before we wrap up. You can find show notes at farnamstreetblog.com slash podcast. That's F-A-R-N-A-M-S-T-R-E-E-T-B-L-O-G dot com slash podcast.
You can also find information there on how to get a transcript. And if you'd like to receive a weekly email from me filled with all sorts of brain food, go to farnamstreetblog.com slash newsletter. This is all the good stuff I've found on the web that week that I've read and shared with close friends, books I'm reading, and so much more. Thank you for listening. Thank you.