Podcast Episode Summary
Main Topic: Menopause and Hormones
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
In this episode, double-board certified Dr. Amy Shah is here to explain the science of hormones, how they impact a woman's body, and more importantly, what you can do about it.
If you’re tired of PMS, bloating, mood swings, hot flashes, the belly "bread basket," or the brain fog of menopause... grab your pen and get ready to take notes.
Dr. Amy, a medical doctor trained at Harvard, Cornell, and Columbia, is an immunologist and leading expert in women’s hormonal health and nutrition.
She is here to explain it all in a way that you can understand and apply to your life.
Today, Dr. Amy Shah reveals:
I can’t wait for you to learn from Dr. Amy. You are going to feel so empowered!
And please share this with all the women you care about in your life: your mothers, sisters, daughters, wives, and girlfriends, because we all deserve to know what the heck is going on and how to feel better in our bodies.
Xo, Mel
PS: For all of our readers who are men, do NOT stop reading. You have to live with us, so this will help you too. (And will make you wonderful when you forward it to all the women in your life). Plus this research and advice on hacking hormones is just downright fascinating!
In this episode, you’ll learn:
02:27: Why the hell do I always feel so tired?
04:52: What happens in our bodies during PMS and menopause?
09:10: Best metaphor to help you understand what’s going on in your body.
11:37: How to optimize your health in every phase of hormone change.
15:02: When in your cycle you should train and eat like an athlete.
17:03: What is really happening with your hormones during pregnancy?
21:09: Where the heck did this muffin top come from?
27:32: The top 5 health questions for Dr. Shah and her answers.
30:02: Did you know that PMS is a mini-menopause?
34:06: Why sleeping in a cold, dark room will help you lose weight.
38:42: Top 3 tricks that regulate your cravings.
40:01: Why anxiety increases during PMS.
46:48: What you need to know about hormone replacement therapy.
56:12: Power nap or meditate at THIS time for best results.
59:01: Why it’s way past time we start talking about women’s health.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Mel Robbins
Hey, it's your friend Mel, and welcome to the Mel Robbins podcast.
All right, I have been wanting to do this episode for such a long time. What are we talking about today? The big M and the big H. What is that? Menopause and hormones. And no, do not touch that off button. Everybody needs to hear this. Hormone changes in women affects half of the population. Today is a conversation for all of us.
If you are in the stage and the age where you feel bitchy and itchy and dry and hot and your hormones are all out of whack, or if you're living with somebody who is going through that, everybody needs to hear this. I'm embarrassed to tell you. I know jack shit about menopause and hormone fluctuation in women and in girls. And there is so much misinformation flying around the internet. I thought I have to have a conversation about this with you and a medical doctor, somebody who understands this.
We are going to cover everything from PMS to hormones in women to what to expect when menopause hits. We're not going to be getting our menopause tips on TikTok, people. We're talking to a doctor about what is going on in our bodies. And the thing that everybody that I know is bitching about my age, which is the bread basket that develops in the middle. That's what we're doing today.
And who have I asked to guide us through the land of menopause and hormones in women? None other than Dr. Amy Shaw. That's right, she is back. She did her training in nutrition from Cornell. She did a residency at Harvard. She got a fellowship in Columbia. She is an expert on hormones. Dr. Amy Shaw is back by popular demand. Dr. Amy, welcome back.
Dr. Amy Shaw
What an honor. Thanks, Mel.
Mel Robbins
You're welcome. So I loved your book. *I'm So Effing Tired*. Title's fantastic, by the way, because I do feel effing tired. And it's a proven plan to beat burnout, boost your energy, and reclaim your life. And what I really wanted to talk about, because when I hear the word tired, I think about two things. How everybody I know feels burnt out. And I want to talk about adrenal fatigue, but I also want to talk about menopause. The big M.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The big M.
Mel Robbins
The big M. I'm going to be double nickels, 55 this year. I am in the thick of it. What the fuck is going on with our hormones and our bodies? And why isn't there more information? I mean, it affects half of the population for crying out loud. So where do you want to start, Dr. Amy?
Dr. Amy Shaw
I think the menopause conversation needs to be had much more commonly and much more openly. Most women go through this time of life and they have no idea why their anxiety level has increased, why their energy has decreased, why they feel like there's a brain fog. People will present with ear itching, body itching.
Mel Robbins
Wait, that is something that's... That's part of menopause? It is? Yes. That explains. [Laughs] Did you just see me as we were walking up? I was itching my back as if like I had just been bitten by a mosquito. Why does your body? I'm going to hijack this conversation so fast. So keep going with the weird ass symptoms.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yeah, I think the biggest symptoms that people feel is the brain fog that happens with menopause. And the mood changes, the hot flashes, and then the sudden change in temperature. Like what is happening? Why are we feeling like this? We don't have the conversation enough. And so everybody's kind of feeling like they're going crazy.
Mel Robbins
Yes.
Dr. Amy Shaw
And one of the biggest complaints, and I know that we'll touch on this, is the increase of fat around the middle.
Mel Robbins
Yes. So brain fog, fatigue, the increase in fat, especially around the middle. And all of these weird symptoms all have to do with your changing hormones.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Okay. You're going to have to break this down for us because the conversations that I'm having with my girlfriends, it's all about this metamorphosis. I feel totally out of control. The last time I felt like this in my own body was when I was going through puberty and I started to get, you know, first you get those like knots or whatever they're called, bumps or whatever they are. And then you get the boobs. I didn't feel that way about pregnancy when my body was changing because I was so excited about it. And because there is so much written and that you can read about pregnancy and it's so celebrated that you kind of know what to expect, even though when it's your first time, it feels so foreign. But this feels so out of control.
Mel Robbins
And I also am glad that you're here because I know it's also a really frustrating time for the people who know and love us because it's not just the hot flashes. I have hot flashes in my mood. Like I will swing from happy to bitchy, like a kitchen door swinging. And so should we start with understanding what's going on?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yeah. Well, first of all, let's just understand the fact that we don't talk about it enough. In the medical sense, we talk about it all the time with our friends and colleagues. I mean, your conversations with your friends and my conversations with my friends match. It's menopause, menopause, menopause all the time, right? Because we're all trying to figure out what's going on with our bodies. We're trying to help each other because we don't have enough guidance. It's not like pregnancy where you can say what to expect when you're expecting on day 22.
Mel Robbins
Yes. So I guess we should start with what the fuck is going on.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Exactly. And the problem is, is that in our lifetime, I was in school when they actually mandated that women be included in medical studies.
Mel Robbins
Wait, what? Women were excluded from all medical studies because our fluctuating hormones or the fact that we could be pregnant during a time of a trial. And so every medication, every intervention, every surgery, everything was done only on men.
Well, I knew that about the ADHD studies in the late 70s and why ADHD has been misdiagnosed at profound levels for women because they only study boys. I had no idea that all of the medical studies related to the effect of anything.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Anything.
Mel Robbins
Why are people not talking about this?
Dr. Amy Shaw
I know. How do we even know then whether or not the side effects of something are going to impact us versus the way they impact dudes? In fact, what they were just doing is they would just prescribe a smaller dose to women. Sort of like a golf tee that's closer to the green. It's like they didn't know anything about the biology of women, but they just said, well, let's just give them a little less. They're just smaller, you know, than men. And thinking that medications are going to affect us the same way as they would have in men. And that's why women are the forgotten gender when it comes to health care.
Mel Robbins
Wow. So what year was this in medical school?
Dr. Amy Shaw
I think it's the 80s where they had to mandate that women be included in all studies.
Mel Robbins
Wow. Yeah. And then on top of that, what they weren't doing and they still don't do is they weren't seeing the impact on hormones. All right. Now you're forced to include women, but you're not actually seeing what the impact is on our hormones, if any. Maybe there's no impact, but why not look at what's happening when you're taking medication X? What's happening to the estrogen, progesterone, testosterone? There's no data.
I can't believe that they're not looking at the impact on hormone levels. That's kind of scary, honestly.
Dr. Amy Shaw
It's a shame. In fact, when I was a young mom, my kids were one and three, and I was out of the postpartum range, and but I felt so out of control. Like I felt burned out but then I couldn't sleep, my hair was falling out, but my thyroid levels were fine. And I was so confused about my hormones, so I thought maybe I just didn't pay attention to that part of medical school. So I went to the hormone experts, so-called OBGYNs, my colleagues who were specialized in women's health or brains, and they said to me, "Oh, we didn't learn about that either. We learn about pregnancy, puberty, and then all you learn about menopause is that it just shuts off and that's basically all we know."
And so I said to myself, well, that's really sad because at least half of the population is women. And if doctors, if they don't even know what's going on, then how are women going to know what's going on?
Mel Robbins
Can you explain what a hormone is?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yeah, that's a great question. Hormones is a chemical messenger.
Mel Robbins
So what do you want us to know in terms of hormones? The 101.
Dr. Amy Shaw
All right, let me tell you. It's like the best analogy is like two sisters. Okay. Okay. Estrogen is super smart. She's super social. She is outgoing. She can be a little bit risk taker. She can be a little bit out of control.
Mel Robbins
Got it.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Then you have the sister, the progesterone sister. She's very calm, level-headed. She knows when the other one's like kind of going off the rails. She's the one that kind of keeps you at home. No, study, stay at home. Let's just chill. She's the one that keeps you calm.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Okay.
Dr. Amy Shaw
So when we're going through menopause, we are getting less estrogen and less progesterone. So you're starting to feel like you're not as sharp. You're not taking as many risks. You're not as social. Your level of estrogen is going down. You might not have the energy levels. You might not feel like doing the things you used to do. Your activity level might go down just without even realizing it, you're just sitting more. As progesterone goes down, you start to get more anxious. You start to feel like you can't sleep. And you start to feel like your life is out of control.
Mel Robbins
Wow. And so what you're noticing-
Is this also why I'm waking up in the middle of the night?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes.
Mel Robbins
The drop in estrogen and progesterone is why I'm not sleeping through the night?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes.
Mel Robbins
I thought it was because I had to go to the bathroom, but it's probably because of the hormones?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes.
Mel Robbins
Dr. Amy, I cannot thank you enough for explaining this to us. Let's hit pause real quick so we can hear a word from our sponsors, because they're allowing us to bring this to everybody at zero cost. And don't you go anywhere. We've got so much more to cover when we come back.
Ad Break
Welcome back. I'm Mel Robbins. I'm here with Dr. Amy Shaw. You know what we're talking about? The big H, people. Hormones. So Dr. Amy, talk to us about women's hormones throughout her lifetime. What do we need to do to optimize our life throughout every one of these stages that women go through from puberty to menopause?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yeah, that's a great question. So women start their hormonal cycles at puberty. Women often aren't even taught what their cycle is and what to expect and how to manage it. Because you just go through life thinking it's just an annoying period, but you don't really learn anything more about it.
Mel Robbins
It's so true. It is annoying. And you don't know a lot about it.
Dr. Amy Shaw
So the first day of your period is a very momentous day. It's the start of your 28-day cycle. And the reason why I think it's important for us to understand is that you're starting, basically, when you shed the lining of your uterus, that's your period, you're starting over. So now, from day one of your period all the way till day 14, you get a rise in your hormones. If you don't get pregnant, then you're going to get a fall in the hormones.
Mel Robbins
Get a fall in what hormones?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Estrogen rises throughout the first part of the cycle and progesterone actually rises too. Testosterone has a little spike closer to ovulation. So day 14. But the interesting part is that at the latter half of your cycle, if you are not pregnant, so most months, you're going to be experiencing a fall in your hormones. And I think it's really important for women to realize that you can train and eat and fast and live differently throughout those different changes of your hormones to match what's happening.
Mel Robbins
What does that mean?
Dr. Amy Shaw
So from day one through day 14, when your estrogen and progesterone levels are getting higher and climbing, especially towards that day 14, you're going to feel more energetic. You're going to be more stress resilient. You're going to be able to do more workouts. So I always talk about that time is like train like an athlete, eat like an athlete, eat more, train more. Energy levels are good. Stress levels are good. This is a time to try out intermittent fasting or no food two to three hours before bed.
So day 21 through 28. So it's called the late luteal phase when your hormones are really dipping down there. The kind of mini menopause column. That's when you pull back on the very stressful activities. You pull back on eating lots of like maybe you're eating a lot more treats or sugar or carbohydrates in the first half of cycle. That's when you want to pull back a little bit. You want to realize that your body is less stress resilient. This is not the time to take on all the projects and to be skimping on sleep and to be working out excessively and to be adding the intermittent fasting for the first time.
You don't want to be testing your stress resiliency at this time, if possible, because according to your own cycle, this is the time that you're going to be least stress resilient, also going to be more insulin resistant, come down on the sugar and the carbohydrate level, start to eat more fiber and protein to keep yourself fuller. And so when you understand that, you're like, oh, well, that makes sense. I naturally don't feel like doing my high intensity workouts the final week of my period.
So from the time you hit puberty to the time you go into menopause, you have these monthly cycles. It's imperative for us to learn them and to learn how to optimize them.
Mel Robbins
Wow, this is so interesting. You know, if we were all clued into this, how to optimize your energy or your focus during certain stages of your cycle, and if we knew what really worked for our bodies from a younger age, by the time we get to menopause, we wouldn't have to have the discussions that we're having today. It's kind of lame that as a 54-year-old woman, I'm still going, what the fuck is going on with my body?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Exactly. The problem is the world is a man's world, at least a medical research world, because that what we researched. Because we don't have enough research on this topic. We don't have 10 women studies where we look at their cycles and we look at menopause. I mean, we need that. We need that data. So we can say, hey, if you are trying to optimize your muscle mass, you should be training hard in the middle of your cycle. Like, where are those studies? Where is the data? So we have a toolbox.
Mel Robbins
So a woman goes through puberty, she gets her menstrual cycle. And then what happens when somebody gets pregnant? What happens to the hormones then?
Dr. Amy Shaw
So basically what happens is if at ovulation, the egg gets fertilized, the hormones stay high. They don't drop to let the lining shed. So as the hormones stay high, you get obviously HCG. People know this because this is the one hormone that actually rises during early pregnancy. That's what you check when you pee on a stick is the HCG levels are in the blood. The body knows that you're pregnant and has released HCG because there's been an implantation. So you don't get the whole last part of your cycle that you usually do. There's no late luteal phase. There's no PMS. Your hormone levels stay high for the duration of the pregnancy. And then when you have the baby, it can take a few months actually to normalize. There's some fluctuations, but then you'll go back to having kind of that approximately 28 day to 32 day cycle.
Mel Robbins
And then there's perimenopause. I guess this is like the warmup for menopause. I mean, what happens there?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Perimenopause is your estrogen and progesterone are getting low, like a tube of toothpaste. When you kind of get to the end of the toothpaste, sometimes you press on it and you just get a splatter. And sometimes you just press on it and you get a full squeeze of toothpaste. And sometimes you press on it and you get nothing. And so that's what's happening during perimenopause. Some months you're getting a good dose of estrogen and progesterone. You're almost feeling like you're normal. And other months you have a low level and you're getting all these symptoms. And some months you're feeling absolutely terrible because your hormone levels are super low. And so you can have a lot of fluctuations during this time. That's perimenopause.
One of the things that people talk about is hot flashes. And the reason why hot flashes happen is one of the roles of your hormones is to tell your hypothalamus, your temperature center, what to do, like how to regulate your temperature. So that month, if you just get a splatter of estrogen or you get none, you get dysregulation of that central thermostat. And so now you're hot, you're sweating, and you get these peaks and valleys of temperature. And so that's how I would describe perimenopause. And that can happen for multiple years. And that's why there's treatment now. Like there's things you can do. Hormone replacement therapy is really good for that kind of hot flash, temperature dysregulation. That seems to help.
And so you have all that. And then you hit menopause. And menopause, the definition is no menstrual periods. So no ovulations for 12 months. And so full year goes by. You don't have fluctuations anymore. You're just at low levels. The fluctuations of the hormones are wreaking havoc on our brain and our body. But about five to 10 years, you seem to have a reprieve of the symptoms. So you're no longer getting the hot flashes. You're no longer having some of the menopausal symptoms.
Mel Robbins
So menopause is defined by having no menstrual period for 12 months. But the drop in estrogen and progesterone that we're talking about here happens up to 10 years before menopause.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Wow. So, you know, what's interesting is that I started to see a big spike in sort of fogginess and feeling like something wrong, probably like in my, I'd say early to mid forties.
Mel Robbins
Yes. That's very typical. So it can be as early as 35 for people who are going through menopause a little bit early, but usually in your 40s, especially your mid 40s is when people really start to see, oh, you know, that exercise that I was doing is not working to control my weight anymore.
Well, everybody that I know is talking about the fact that their body shape has changed. Yes. That there is this thickening in the middle. My sister-in-law, who I love, keeps referring to her body as a Twinkie, just like a Twinkie with legs. I'm like, Will you shut up? Stop. And I'll get flack for saying this because I'm a lean, athletic build kind of person, but all my pants fit very differently now. It's as if I have like those inner tubes that you sit in a pool. It's like I've put one from the belly button around the back. It's like all of a sudden it's filled out. So my pants don't fit anymore. I could not do more crunches. I couldn't eat healthier if I tried. I am already getting eight or nine hours of sleep. For God's sakes, I've cut back on the alcohol. I smoke a little weed here and there. That's not putting on the shit in the middle. I don't even get the munchies when I smoke weed. Why is this happening? This is happening. It doesn't seem fair.
Dr. Amy Shaw
I know. It's because our estrogen levels, as they start to drop, our body is looking for more hormonally active cells. So the fat that you accumulate in your middle-
Mel Robbins
It produces estrogen.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Okay, wait a minute. Fat produces estrogen. What do you mean fat produces estrogen?
Mel Robbins
Fat cells. You didn't say that the estrogen sister was a fat sister. You just said that she was the one that was the party girl. Okay, so fat cells. I was talking about that estrogen and progesterone that are primarily coming from our ovaries prior to menopause, premenopause.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Okay, but as you get into menopause, you start to get a very big dip in your estrogen.
Mel Robbins
Oh, that's true because you're not going to be producing children anymore. So does the estrogen and progesterone supplies that are part of the reproductive system start to drop?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes. And then as your estrogen progesterone gets lower, your body starts to do things to try to compensate for it. So it's looking for fat.
Mel Robbins
Yes. Do we also get flabbier around the arms? I'm like, where did these wings come from?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes. That's because estrogen, the other thing it does.
Mel Robbins
What?
Dr. Amy Shaw
It helps us keep our muscle mass. So when you decreased your estrogen over the years.
Mel Robbins
So I'm not going crazy. I literally have been looking at my arms and saying to myself, something is wrong with my arms. I realize they're toned, but they used to be a lot toner. I don't know if that's the right word, but they're like flappy now. And I'm like, what is that?
Dr. Amy Shaw
One to 3% of muscle mass. Yes. Per decade, you'd say up to 3%. But as you go into menopause, it goes faster. Meaning that you're losing muscle at high rates. If you're not also weight training, eating the protein. So there, the one therapy I can tell you right away for your arms.
Mel Robbins
Tell me.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Is to start to do more weight training, start to build muscle in the places, not only that it was, but that you can build more muscle on. So this is the best time to pick up some weights.
Mel Robbins
Oh, I have a, I've used the tonal machine at home. I'm doing the things.
Dr. Amy Shaw
More things than you used to. That's the key.
Mel Robbins
That's not fair. So what I'll tell you is that what we found is that when people start to go into perimenopause and their estrogen drops, their activity level drops a little bit and they don't even notice it. So you may be gaining some fat cells, not only because of the estrogen drop saying to your body it needs more estrogen from fat cells, it's because your body is not as active as it used to be. And it's very subtle and you might not even notice it until you say, oh, you know, I used to naturally just get up and walk and used to get 10,000 steps.
Dr. Amy Shaw
And one of the other things you can do as someone, if we're talking to our friends, we're talking to the audience, increase your activity level, your baseline activity, even if you don't want to.
Mel Robbins
I see shit on TikTok about gotta whiff weights, gotta eat more protein. Is that what you're talking about with activity level? So what do we need to switch up? Because the other thing that I was talking with a friend about is she's like, I'm on that Peloton like every day, Mel. And I am not seeing any results whatsoever. And it's not Peloton's fault. Something is going on with my body.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes, it is. And she's not crazy. That's the biggest thing is I feel so bad because my mom, when she was going through menopause, felt like she was going crazy. She's had anxiety. She couldn't sleep at night. She was gaining weight. And she was like, I feel like I'm literally going crazy.
Mel Robbins
Yeah. The sad thing is, is that it happens to all, everybody.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yep. Humans are one of the only animals on the planet that go through menopause, by the way.
Mel Robbins
Really? Most animals reproduce till they die. Well, thank God we don't. I mean, that would be absolutely awful. So the fact that we live past our reproductive years is pretty unique.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Huh. Dr. Amy, I love listening to you. You just have this incredible knack for taking all this science-y, complicated stuff and distilling it down into something I can actually understand. Let's take a quick break, and we'll be right back with Dr. Amy.
Ad Break
Mel Robbins
Welcome back. I'm Mel Robbins and we're talking to Dr. Amy Shaw about menopause, PMS, hormones, all the men. I can just hear them running off into the distance. Do not go anywhere. This is an important conversation for all of us. So Dr. Amy, what are the top five things that people complain to you about when they come see you for help with nutrition and hormones and how do you attack fixing them?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Okay. So number one is definitely the weight gain. The weight gain is very frustrating because if you're an active person, we're already living in a world that's working against us. The default is that we are going to be in the categories of medically overweight or obese. 73% of Americans are there now.
Mel Robbins
Wow.
Dr. Amy Shaw
It's going to be at 85% before we know it, right? Most of us are already metabolically challenged. We're already fighting against this battle. Then we got to deal with the estrogen going down, which makes you less active, less energetic and losing your muscle mass. So now you have more fat and it's making your mood a little bit lower, right? The therapies that I recommend, a lot of them have to do with things to counteract the changes in the lowering of estrogen.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Like what?
Dr. Amy Shaw
So walking more. So what I tell women is like our cortisol levels can be really high when we're doing high intensity exercise. So it's better to have a baseline of walking and you can do bouts of HIIT if you want, but really having more activity. It's called NEAT, non-exercise activity thermogenesis. NEAT activity is actually a bigger driver of our weight.
Mel Robbins
What is that last word? What is thermogenesis? That's a big word.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Non-exercise activity thermogenesis. Thermogenesis is metabolism.
Mel Robbins
Okay. So what is a non-exercise?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Walking is non-exercise? Walking. So if you're not walking for exercise, wear a watch or you wear a pedometer, you park farther, you take the stairs, you take your dog for a walk, all the stuff that you don't count as exercise, that's non-exercise activity. Thermogenesis, that has to go up. If you're in perimenopause and you want to fight the weight gain, that's where it starts.
Mel Robbins
And so the reason why running or HIIT classes aren't the greatest thing for women in this category is because it spikes your cortisol?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes.
Mel Robbins
And what does that have to do with estrogen?
Dr. Amy Shaw
The other thing that happens when your estrogen is going down is you're less stress resilient. So I'll give an example for women who even aren't in menopause or perimenopause. The week before your period, you're just less stress resilient. You can't handle the things that you usually can handle.
Mel Robbins
Yes.
Dr. Amy Shaw
So your mini PMS is happening for a few years now.
Mel Robbins
So is PMS a mini menopause?
Dr. Amy Shaw
It's a drop in your estrogen and progesterone in the middle of your normal cycle.
Mel Robbins
Yes. No shit. I didn't know that.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Right. That's when your body is like, oh, she didn't get pregnant. The egg didn't get fertilized. We got to shed this lining. They drop the hormones. So you get to basically the lowest level of estrogen and progesterone. And then you shed your lining, which is your period. And then you start all over again.
Mel Robbins
Wow. So will the things that you're saying that help for somebody in peri or menopause itself also help with PMS symptoms?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes.
Mel Robbins
That is a revelation.
Dr. Amy Shaw
It is. For me too, I thought to myself, wow, the same things that we are doing to improve our nutrition during our cycle.
Mel Robbins
Yes. We just expand on that.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The late luteal phase, which is that PMS phase of the cycle is what's happening.
Mel Robbins
I was going to say, I think it's sexier to say, I'm in my late luteal phase. The late luteal phase. Luteal phase. But you're talking, that's a period. Okay, sorry. That's the week before your period. That's PMS.
Dr. Amy Shaw
One surprising thing that people have to understand is that hormone replacement therapy does not help with the weight gain part. The weight gain part is not an indication to go get hormones.
Mel Robbins
Okay.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The things that I told you about, more NEAT activity, more weight training.
Mel Robbins
Right.
Dr. Amy Shaw
That's going to help the weight loss.
Mel Robbins
Okay. What else do we need to do for the weight loss? Because I know everybody's leaning in. Yes. Because I thought if you get the patch or the bioidenticals, your body will snap back into the way it's supposed to. And that's what's so frustrating for women.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The hot flashes definitely get better, right? Like that's one of the indications for hormonal therapy. People will have pain with sex or have dryness. That definitely, HRT definitely helps with that.
Mel Robbins
Okay.
Dr. Amy Shaw
But the weight gain portion is not so easy to address just with hormones because there's multiple things going on. Like you're less active, you're losing more muscle mass, your sleep is dysregulated. So then your appetite, your cravings, your hunger, your appetite are all increased because you're not sleeping well.
Mel Robbins
Yeah.
Dr. Amy Shaw
That can just be solved by adding hormones. I think about adding hormones like putting gas in your car. So you can add gas to your car, but if there is a traffic jam, you're not going anywhere. So our hormones are like a complicated web of highways that are backed up. And it doesn't matter how much gas you pump into the car, it's not going to go anywhere. So the ways to unclog that traffic, to keep that traffic moving, is the sleep, the exercise, the weight training, the food choices. The more you can improve your sleep, the better that weight loss part will become because your hunger hormones are really dysregulated when you don't sleep. And so you want to have a good night's sleep, but often you can't sleep because your hormones are disrupted. So it's like the cycle. So one of the things I tell people is really, really try your best to improve your sleep hygiene. If you haven't started a routine to improve your sleep hygiene, start it now in perimenopause.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Now tell us your top three things for a better night's sleep.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Top three things for a better night's sleep. Cold room.
Mel Robbins
Okay.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Your body temperature has to drop by one degree to fall asleep.
Mel Robbins
So how do you get that done fastest?
Dr. Amy Shaw
You could take a shower, you can cool down the room. You want to cool your core body temperature. That's how you'll fall asleep.
Mel Robbins
Love that.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Pitch black. If you can't control the curtains and the light, then wear a face mask or eye mask. The few studies that we have, one is on menopausal women. Even if you have an ambient light in the room, like a light coming through the window, it will stop weight loss if you're on a weight loss plan. Circadian rhythm disruption, especially during that time, seems to really mess up the hormones in that sense. So you want to have a pitch black room.
And then the third thing is you want a nightly routine. So you want to prepare your brain and your body for sleep because your body loves routines. Our bodies are built on rhythms and cycles. If every night you go to sleep at 9 PM, then at 8:45, you start to turn off all the lights, you put away your phone, you start to brush your teeth—you're cluing in your body that it's time for sleep. Keeping that same time and routine is essential for good sleep. People will sleep one day at nine o'clock and the next day at 11, and they're massively disrupting their sleep cycles. There's some data now that shows that it's maybe more important to stay on the same bedtime than even the total number of hours slept.
Mel Robbins
Wow. Are there certain foods that we should be eating more of or less of to help with the menopause symptoms and hormone regulation? And for everybody's benefit, I just want to remind everybody, this is your second appearance. We did a huge show on hunger and craving and the neuroscience and biology of it. That will be linked in the show notes along with both of your books. But if you had to bottom line it for people who are really wanting to use food to regulate hormones, what are the top recommendations?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Remember that I likened it to PMS in the sense that you're less stress resilient. What I mean is that the things that spike your cortisol are now more impactful and at a lower threshold. Caffeine, alcohol, sugar.
Mel Robbins
Shit, are we not going to have fun now too? People say to me, "I always drank this much caffeine and I always ate this much sugar."
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes.
Mel Robbins
Or had a glass of wine or did whatever. What the hell is going on?
Dr. Amy Shaw
That's because now your hormones have changed and your metabolism has changed. You're also less insulin sensitive. You've heard the term insulin resistance.
Mel Robbins
Yes. What does that mean?
Dr. Amy Shaw
That happens during menopause. Insulin resistance means that when the sugar is trying to get into your cells, the insulin has to open the door to let the sugar in. That's insulin.
Mel Robbins
So what does it mean when you're insulin resistant?
Dr. Amy Shaw
The door is shut. You don't hear it as easily. You're knocking louder and louder to try to get in. The insulin is like, "Dude, we just let sugar in. We're not going to let more sugar in." And the body's like, "No, but I need to get it out of the bloodstream." And the insulin is like, "No, but the cell is packed. It can't take any more sugar." While they're having these fights, that's called insulin resistance. When insulin resistance happens, the body gets signals to store fat, to say, "Let's get this sugar out of here because it's not going into the cell. So we got to put it somewhere." So not only do you have a higher risk of getting type 2 diabetes because your sugar level is high all the time, you also have more signaling to store fat.
Mel Robbins
Oh, man.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Insulin resistance is something that we can control by saying, "Well, if the cells are so full of sugar and they can't let any more sugar in, you better eat some vegetables. You better just cut some of that sugar out." And add in some things that help you lower the blood sugar in your body, which is fiber. Add more fiber so that your blood sugar can be regulated. Move more, like we said. Add in weight training. Sleep more. And remember the water that we talked about in the other episode—our thirst centers are often mixed with our hunger centers, the signals can be mixed. So you want to hydrate enough so that you are not eating mindlessly. The trick there, for those of you who have not heard the other episode, is when you feel your appetite coming on, in order to determine whether or not you just have a mindless craving, you can say, "Would I like a bowl of vegetables right now?" If the answer is no, that means you're not actually hungry.
Mel Robbins
Another trick is drink a glass of water. That typically can satiate that appetite that flares up. Why is there an increase in anxiety during PMS and menopause?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Remember that sister, the progesterone sister?
Mel Robbins
Yes.
Dr. Amy Shaw
She was a calming one. She was the one who was keeping you chillaxed and careful. When progesterone goes down, you don't have that chillaxer anymore. You don't have someone to keep you calm. That sister that was saying, "Calm down. It's okay, Mel. You'll be fine." Your progesterone levels are lower. All of a sudden you are anxious about everything. The things that never made you anxious before are making you anxious. And the sleep—you wake up in the middle of the night and you're like, "Oh my God, I can't believe X, Y, and Z happened," and it starts a whole anxiety spiral. A lot of women during menopause have crippling anxiety.
Mel Robbins
Does hormone replacement therapy tend to help with anxiety?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes. Progesterone replacement.
Mel Robbins
Gotcha. I'm not sure I would know how to explain what a hormone is and what it does.
Dr. Amy Shaw
There's so much confusion about hormones. A hormone is a chemical messenger. In my analogy of the highway, it's the car. It travels from your brain or from your ovaries to wherever it needs to go. It can go to the muscle. It can go to the heart. So it's a traveling message. Our bodies cannot function without hormones. People get so annoyed with hormones, but you cannot function without your hormones. Even cortisol. Cortisol is a good hormone. It has to be balanced.
Mel Robbins
So what is the estrogen? Oh, I'm getting this now. So the fun party sister. The social one.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The social one is driving one car. When she arrives, it's time to party.
Mel Robbins
The progesterone sister is driving another car. When she arrives, party's over.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes. And she calms everybody down. Like, "Let's just chillax now, guys. Let's tone it down."
Mel Robbins
Is insulin a hormone?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Insulin is a hormone.
Mel Robbins
Really? So when insulin gets in the car, what is insulin telling you?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Insulin is telling you, "Open the door to let the glucose in." It's a storage signal. Our body sends insulin out to say, "Hey, we need to store a little more glucose here because there's glucose coming in." So it's a messenger. People think, "Oh, thyroid hormone is just about weight." No, it's controlling weight, temperature, heart rate—it's controlling a million things. It's not just going to one destination.
Mel Robbins
Wow.
Dr. Amy Shaw
You can't just replace hormones and think that it's going to have one effect. For example, we see people getting high, high doses of thyroid hormone. I say to people that more is not always better. It's not just doing one thing. It's doing five different things. One of the things it's doing is going to the heart. If you send too much thyroid hormone to the heart, you're going to have all kinds of problems, including arrhythmias, heart palpitations. People taking too high doses of thyroid hormone will often have heart problems. It's like playing with fire.
Mel Robbins
Wow. So they're just kind of driving in the wrong directions or they're not arriving where they used to arrive. And that's what's making the changes. So the hormones are the root cause of PMS and menopause. For some of the symptoms, hormone replacement therapy will alleviate symptoms. But for other things like the fat redistribution or losing muscle tone, you're going to have to make lifestyle changes.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The other hormone that we didn't talk about, but that's really important even in women, is testosterone.
Mel Robbins
Really?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Testosterone is actually in higher levels—like four times the level of estrogen or progesterone. It's high.
Mel Robbins
In women?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes. We always think about testosterone as a male hormone. Of course, males have much higher levels of testosterone than women, but our testosterone is also high compared to our other hormones. Testosterone is the sister that doesn't live as close to the other sisters, but testosterone is the leader. It's the muscular, the aggressive, the leader sister. We get a spike of testosterone at ovulation. If you know your cycle, roughly a week after your period is when your testosterone levels are peaking. That's when you want to build the most muscle. That's when your libido will be the highest. Your confidence levels will be similar to the other gender. People who take too much testosterone, for example, when they're taking a replacement and they go overboard, they'll be angry, aggressive, and maybe even engage in risk-taking behavior. Testosterone can be good in small amounts, especially for women during perimenopause and during the cycle if you're lower than you need to be. But of course, you don't want to overdo it, and people overdo it all the time.
Mel Robbins
How do you figure out what to take? There's so much misinformation out there. What are the big myths?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Big example. The one thing that all doctors can agree about is that those pellets that people get are no good.
Mel Robbins
I don't know what the hell a pellet is. I've just heard about this. What the hell are pellets?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Pellets are testosterone releasing—extended release testosterone that they implant under the skin. It's supposed to release testosterone. You keep this in there for months, and you get it replaced. What's happening is that you can't adjust the levels. Most of these pellets are giving you super therapeutic levels. Hormones are not something that you just want to add, because they're doing a lot of other things besides maybe the one thing that you're targeting. Why would you use an implantable testosterone that can't be titrated, that usually releases too much? The answer is that you can charge for testosterone pellets.
When you do testosterone like a cream or an ingestible, it's not money in the pocket of the practitioner. I said this on social media once and people went crazy because they said, "I love my testosterone pellets." I said, "Great, but make sure your levels are at the level that you want them and not way high." I bet you that a lot of people who are taking testosterone pellets are at super therapeutic levels. We've seen so many negative side effects from those levels. Hormone replacement can be so amazing, but go to the right person, choose the right dosing. Even if you do pellets, choose what's right for you, but make sure you're not getting levels that are too high for your body.
Mel Robbins
I am so glad you said this because another amazing person who uses pellets herself was so excited about them that I'm like, "I got to get me some pellets. I got to go get in there and get the pellets. I got testosterone. Chris Robbins, get ready because the libido is coming back." But I'm glad that you gave us the reason why, so that you can make a choice for yourself. Is it true that women of different races experience menopause differently?
Dr. Amy Shaw
Yes. The problem again, Mel, is that not only are we not educating our doctors or the population about menopause, we don't even know the differences between different backgrounds, different races, different ethnicities. Because they're not studying it. We're just at the basic levels of finding out that women present differently with heart attacks than men. Women will be shamed for symptoms that are actually real because they just think, "Oh, she's a complainer."
Mel Robbins
The other thing that I have really not appreciated is that there is an acknowledgement that you get foggier. There's an acknowledgement that you will start to feel flabbier and start gaining weight in places that you've never had it before. But there's no "what to do." It's sort of this, "Oh, well, yeah, me too," or "Yep, that'll happen. Everything will kind of go back to where it should be when you're 60 or you're 10 years into this." I am sorry, I'm not settling for that. That's one of the reasons I wanted you on. I think it'd be really helpful if you could walk us through the day of what you would recommend for anyone to either better manage PMS or have a better routine that aligns with your recommendations and the science out there to help us both regulate our hormones and do the proactive steps to feel better during these very normal changes.
Dr. Amy Shaw
That's a great question. I'll start by saying that we live in a society that has a problem with women getting older. We've basically been told that if you don't fit into the societal ideals of young, fertile women, that you're no longer worthy, you're no longer beautiful, you're no longer wanted, you're no longer smart and motivated. I think that's one of the biggest challenges that we are going to have to face in this next generation—feeling good even into our 40s and 50s. If we do the things that we're going to talk about, this could last till our 70s. We can look younger and feel younger. We already know that our biological age is completely different—20 years different than our chronological age.
Mel Robbins
So you're really just 35 right now. Thank you, which is why I'm pissed off that I have a dry vagina and I sweat at night and I feel like somebody's grandmother.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Exactly. So here's how we move through the day. You wake up, hopefully without an alarm. This is really important because we talked about sleep and how it helps with appetite regulation. We as a society shit on sleep and don't allow ourselves to sleep. Go camping, go somewhere where there's no ambient light and no distractions from social media, and see what time you sleep and wake up. I bet you you're not a night owl like you thought. You're going to get an adequate night of sleep. You're going to go get that sunlight in the morning. Circadian biology—the light that you get in the morning tells every cell in your body that it's morning.
The benefit of that is that our hormones need that input. If our hormones don't get input from our brains and our bodies that, "Hey, it's time to release cortisol now"—cortisol is high first thing in the morning—then it causes hormonal dysregulation. That's how people say, "Oh, I feel so tired all day" or "adrenal fatigue, I feel so burned out." It's not that the adrenals are burned out. There's no such thing as adrenal burnout. It's this hormonal highway that we're talking about getting clogged. It's not just adrenals. It's coming from the thyroid. It's coming from the brain. It's the whole traffic jam happening because of all the other things—the lifestyle, the age-related hormone changes.
You want to retune those clocks. Those clocks can get damaged if you misalign them so many times, like if you never get outside or you spend hours and hours inside during the daytime.
Mel Robbins
What I love about this—I think I'm just going to keep with the analogy because the visuals really helped me put it all together. It's almost as if the circadian rhythm and the sunlight in the morning is like the remote starter to your car. It's keeping those roads open and clean so you can know, "Okay, it's time to drive. Everything's opened up."
Dr. Amy Shaw
You get the circadian rhythm. If you start to damage those cars, you get these things called senescent cells. It's a very scientific word, but basically it means your cells become zombie cells. They no longer can work. The car doesn't work, but the emissions from the car are inflammatory signals and aging and all the things that come with aging. These cars that are broken down are sending off these inflammatory signals to your whole body. That's the process of aging. We need to clean those cars up and get them out of there if they're not working. Senescent cells are the big area of anti-aging that we're trying to understand—how do we clear those out faster? How do we not break down? Working out in the morning has been shown in studies to be the best time to stay with the routine. People are compliant with exercise when it happens in the morning.
Mel Robbins
It's common sense because your day doesn't hijack your energy and your time. I see it over and over again, especially in women, because we are doing everything for everyone. Our mental load starts from the morning. If you don't get that workout in, there's a big chance that you're not going to make time for it later because the kid needs a ride, your husband needs you to be home, the meeting came up, somebody needs you to be somewhere. So get it done in the morning if possible.
Dr. Amy Shaw
Great. There's a second peak time late afternoon. Late afternoon is a better time to build muscle. So if you're doing two mini workouts, you could just split it up. And then high protein. Protein is one of the biggest things that doesn't happen with women in perimenopause. Women think that you're trying to be skinny. When they start to see themselves gaining some middle section weight, they often cut down even more. You're in this very tight calorie restriction. What you really need to do is eat more protein, more fiber, more real foods, and less of that ultra processed crap. So having a high protein breakfast, a dopamine booster breakfast, high fiber. We talked about that a lot in the other episode. Then you want to do your biggest concentrated tasks of the day early in the day so that you don't spike your cortisol.
Mel Robbins
Boom, I'm getting this. I am getting this.
Dr. Amy Shaw
If you're someone who can do a meditation or a nap, the best time to do it is when your cortisol is naturally low—like 1 to 4 PM. When your cortisol dips, it's a great time to either do a power nap, 20 minutes, do a meditation, do something calming. Remember, when your progesterone is dropping, you're likely more anxious, you're overwhelmed. It's a nice break from the day when you can do something that's very centering—prayer, whatever it is.
Mel Robbins
I've heard what I think is probably a myth. That if you just ride it out, just like three years, Mel, ride out the hot flashes, the dryness, the bitchiness, all this stuff, the brain fog. And in three years, you'll just snap right back. Is that true?
Dr. Amy Shaw
What happens is that your body just starts to get used to it. You're operating at a level that's just stable. There's no squeezing of the toothpaste. There's nothing there. Your body starts to accommodate. It's not that it's snapping back, but that the symptoms seem to go away. A lot of the symptoms that were really troublesome during perimenopause. It's often the time where people feel a little reprieved. But remember that disease risk goes way up after menopause. Our hormones protect us from heart disease and all of the diseases of aging. Once you hit menopause, you start to have an increased risk of all of those inflammatory diseases.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Wow. Yet another thing to look forward to. Is there anything more that we should know about the increased risk of inflammatory diseases?
Dr. Amy Shaw
One of the big criticisms of hormone replacement therapy was that it would cause cancer. But now we know that it's the opposite—hormones actually protect us from a lot of these diseases, especially heart disease. For women, it can actually be protective. In the right population of women, like very close to the start of menopause or perimenopause, the earlier you start it, the better risk protection you get from hormone replacement therapy.
Mel Robbins
What is the biggest myth around menopause?
Dr. Amy Shaw
My biggest pet peeve about menopause is the fact that women feel shame around it and they can't have conversations with their doctors. They often feel like they're marginalized and they're not listened to by their provider when they say, "I don't feel right. I feel tired, but I feel anxious. My sleep is off." They often get a prescription and no explanation about what's happening. I know countless women who've just come home with anti-anxiety medications and no one explained to them that there's a lot going on in your body that could explain why you're feeling this anxiety at this time. There are things that you can do. Not to say there's anything wrong with medications. There's a great need for medications, but there's also a big need for education around menopause.
Mel Robbins
I agree. There is a huge need for education, not only around menopause, but also around women's hormonal health and cycles in general. I consider myself to be a very well-educated person. I'm intellectually curious. I read all the time. And I have flunked this topic. When I've gone to my doctor or to my OB-GYN, it feels like people are like, "Yeah, well, it's going to last till you're 60. You can do hormones or whatever. You're going to have to tolerate the weight gain." I hate that.
Dr. Amy Shaw
The term is medical gaslighting—where women just feel like they're not listened to and their complaints are just dismissed. I think that's something we really need to work on as a society, because age 40, age 50, age 60 is now very different than it was even just 20 years ago. Women are doing things in their 40s, 50s, and 60s that women did not do. We got to change the conversation. It's not that, "Oh, you're just worried. You're just stressed. You're just getting old," and dismissing their concerns. These people are running companies. They're leading countries. We need to have conversations about what they could be doing to optimize themselves at that level, not just saying, "Oh, well, you're just getting old."
Mel Robbins
So what would you advise any of us who feel like we are just not getting the answers from the doctors that we're seeing? Do you just change your doctor? What do you do?
Dr. Amy Shaw
In this day and age, we have enough physicians that are interested, educated, and can be an advocate for you that you should go seek that out. We're changing the conversation not only within ourselves, but in the medical community—saying, "Hey, listen, if a woman comes to you with these complaints, don't just write it off as separate things. Think about where she is in her cycles. Where is she with her hormones?" There's this big myth that in order to be considered in menopause or perimenopause, you must get your hormone levels checked because that's what you hear on the internet. Menopause is not a diagnosis of hormone levels. It is a diagnosis of symptomology. The definition has nothing to do with the level of hormones. A lot of people spend thousands and thousands of dollars trying to get testing to figure out what their hormone levels are, but that's not necessarily the first place you need to go.
Mel Robbins
When do you get your hormone levels tested?
Dr. Amy Shaw
If you're getting replacement therapy and you're trying to troubleshoot something. But the diagnosis of menopause is not made through a lab test.
Mel Robbins
Well, that's one thing that we learned today—that the diagnosis of menopause is made after you have gone an entire year without menstruating. There's a lot of misinformation. There's a lack of research and there's a lack of interest, to be honest. All of those things make menopause an area that is mismanaged. If you look on the internet and you look for supplements around PMS or menopause or hormones, it's a wild, wild west. Clearly, people are looking to alternative practitioners and online therapies for their hormonal concerns. But when you see what's out there, it is very scary. That's a clear sign that women are looking for answers. We need to have more information. Even the basic things like we talked about here—this should be basic education for all women.
Dr. Amy Shaw, I'm having you back to talk about circadian rhythm. I'm having you back to talk about the rhythm of the day. You are a freaking rock star. The book is *I'm So F-ing Tired*, but we ain't so F-ing tired no more because Dr. Amy has given us simple things backed by profound science that you learned today that will help you take control of your hormone health so that you can live a much better life. Thank you, thank you, thank you. I cannot wait to have you back.
Dr. Amy Shaw
I'm so honored to be here and I would love to.
Mel Robbins
So before we go, I just want to remind you that I love you. I believe in you and I believe in your ability to create a better life. All right. Talk to you in a few days.
Sound of a brief, muffled exchange
What is that last word? Thermogenesis? Non-activity? Non-electric? I can't keep up with what is thermogenesis? You're in fucking menopause, so your mind is going. There we go. Yeah, we'll talk about that later. Do you want to say which hormones? It is? Okay, well then I would say what hormones. Yeah, we'll definitely keep it in what hormones. I think that Diet Coke and the outside put a little life in sinus-infected Mel Robbins here.
Pause
Oh, and one more thing. And no, this is not a blooper. This is the legal language. What the lawyers write and what I need to read to you. This podcast is presented solely for educational and entertainment purposes. I'm just your friend. I am not a licensed therapist. This podcast is not intended as a substitute for the advice of a physician, professional coach, psychotherapist, or other qualified professional. Got it? Good. I'll see you in the next episode.