The main topic of this podcast episode is gut health, specifically how to achieve a healthy gut and address common issues such as bloating, constipation, and IBS. The guest expert is Dr. Robin Chutkin, a renowned gastroenterologist with 30 years of medical experience.
Key points from the episode include:
Takeaways from the episode include:
Overall, this podcast episode provides a comprehensive overview of gut health and offers practical tips and advice for achieving a healthy gut.
Two-thirds of people have a stomach or gut issue. Do you want to know exactly what to do to feel better?
In today’s episode, you’re getting an appointment with one of the most renowned GI doctors in the world.
She is here today with her step-by-step protocol to help you reset your gut health, beat the bloat, and find more energy today.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan, MD is a renowned gastroenterologist. For two decades, her integrative clinic, Digestive Center for Wellness, has helped patients to help them uncover the root cause of GI disorders. She’s worked at Georgetown Hospital for 27 years and has a deep wealth of knowledge and experience.
She is going to inform you of the simple things that you can do starting today to:
- Have a healthier gut
- Beat the bloat
- Settle your IBS
- And address constipation once and for all
You’ll get her nutritional plan to heal stomach problems and optimize your gut for mental and physical health… and you’ll even learn exactly WHAT your poo should look like (and when you should go to the doctor).
This is THE master class on your gut health, and it’s filled with compelling, tactical, and easy to understand science.
For more resources, including links to Dr. Robynne Chutkan’s research, website, and social media click here for the podcast episode page.
If you liked this research-packed episode, you’ll love this episode with Dr. Mark Hyman: Reset Your Health in 10 Days: Advice From a Renowned MD
Connect with Mel:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Mel Robbins
Hey, it's your friend Mel, and welcome to the Mel Robbins podcast. The other day, I read this crazy piece of research. Did you know that two-thirds of people have a gut issue? And you want to know the age group that is the most affected? This one really surprised me. 18 to 44-year-olds. Yep, it's not your grandparents. It's 18 to 44 year olds, 73% of people in that age range have a gut issue.
So if you're feeling bloated or you're constipated or you have IBS or you're constantly popping the Tums and you wish that you could do something about it, or maybe somebody that you love has one of these issues, well, I have booked you and me an appointment with the number one gut health medical doctor. I think she's absolutely amazing. I'm talking 30 years of medical experience, and she's here to just set the record straight with the medical facts.
She's going to say, throw out your supplements and the probiotics, because there are simple things that you can do. In fact, you should do starting today to have a healthier gut, to beat the bloat, settle your IBS, and address constipation once and for all, which you will also learn may be caused by a very surprising issue in your childhood. And you're also going to learn the extraordinary role that your gut health plays in your immunity, energy, mental health, estrogen production, and so much more. This is a master class on your gut health, and absolutely everyone that you know needs to hear it.
Hey, it's your buddy, Mel. I am so glad you're here with me today. It is such an honor to be able to spend some time with you today. And I want to acknowledge you for choosing to listen to something that can help you create a better life. I think it is so awesome that you're taking time for yourself and I love spending that time with you. If you are a brand new listener, welcome to the Mel Robbins podcast family. I'm Mel Robbins. I'm on a mission to inspire and empower you with tools and the expert resources that you deserve so that you can create a better life.
And I am thrilled to introduce you to a remarkable human being. Her name is Dr. Robin Chutkin. She is a renowned gastroenterologist who is the founder of the Digestive Center for Wellness, which is an integrative gastroenterology practice where for 20 years, Dr. Robin has been working with patients to help them uncover the root cause of GI disorders. She's been on the faculty of Georgetown Hospital for 27 years. Dr. Robin received her bachelor degree from Yale, her medical degree and residency at Columbia, where she was the chief resident, which basically means she was the top doc in her residency at medical school. And then she did a GI fellowship at Mount Sinai Hospital.
Dr. Robin has also authored dozens of academic journal articles and book chapters, and she lectures frequently on the microbiome and gut health throughout the United States and Europe. She's also the host of the Gut Bliss podcast, the author of four bestselling books, The Antiviral Gut, Gut Bliss, The Microbiome Solution, and The Gut Bloat Cure. And you're going to love her. And so will everyone in your family. So please, if you got a friend or a loved one who's been complaining nonstop about their stomach issues, this is a must share. So let's jump in and please help me welcome Dr. Robin.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I'm so excited to be here. Thank you so much for having me.
Mel Robbins
We're going to go all things gut, not just the obvious things, but we're going to talk about gut brain, gut immune, how the gut is your engine for your entire body. It drives all the processes.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
And I think we're going to really give people a new way of looking at the gut and how powerful it is.
Mel Robbins
Absolutely. And what I also love about your work is you take all this science and distill it down into simple things that I can do. You listening are going to be able to walk out of here and know exactly what to do to take care of your health, to make your gut better. And you're going to understand why this matters so much.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I'm so glad to be here.
Mel Robbins
So Dr. Robin, it does seem like everybody I know has a gut issue, like the bloating and the IBS. I mean, are you finding that in your clinical practice? Gut issues seem like they're on the rise.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
They're absolutely on the rise. And as a gastroenterologist, I've always seen a lot of gut issues. But if we look nationally, there was a study done last year by MDVIP, and they found that two thirds of Americans suffer from gut issues. The highest number is in the 18 to 44 age group. Why? 73%. I think a lot of it has to do with the food that they're eating. They're eating more ultra processed foods. They're busy. They're on the go. I think there's a lot of stress and that has a profound impact on the gut. And I think they're also more aware, which is good, right? It's good to be aware that this isn't functioning properly, but that's the highest percentage.
And what they found, the American Gastroenterological Association did a survey and they found that 40% of Americans, and this is across the board, said that they had GI issues to the point where it was interfering with socializing, with running errands, with exercising, with having sex, with libido.
Mel Robbins
Wow.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
And to me, the really frightening part of all of this is the AGA launched a campaign called Trust Your Gut Around This. One in three Americans do not feel comfortable talking to their doctor about gut issues and will only raise it if the doctor asks. It's like, don't ask, don't tell. Because of embarrassment. And honestly, Mel, this was a reason when I read this last year, I was like, oh, no, I've got to do something about this. I want people to be a medical detective. You turn around and take a look at that poo. You tell me what it looks like. If you need to poke around in it with a stick, understand why do you have gas? Why are you bloated? Why are you backed up? We have to educate people about this, how this works. And the education that I see out there is mostly the biohacking. Take this supplement. Do this crazy diet. That's not fixing things for people. The more that we have, I think the sicker people are. So what we really need is we need people to understand how this stuff works.
Mel Robbins
For the person who's listening, who is in the two thirds, who are experiencing a gut issue, they'd love somebody who is. What is available to them if they truly take to heart everything that you are about to share today, Dr. Robin?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Not only is it possible for you to feel better in your gut, because your gut is your engine, it's possible for you to feel better in your whole body, for you to have a clearer mind and less brain fog, for you to feel less fatigued, for your immune system to work better so that you're not overreacting to things with food allergies or you're not underreacting to things where you can't clear infection. So the gut is a thing that unites all these different organs. And that's the thing that makes me so optimistic, because unlike when you think about genetic diseases, you sort of get what you get. You're dealt a bad genetic hand. But our gut is changing all the time.
When we think about our gut microbiome, which I know we're going to talk a lot about, we know from a study that was published in the journal Nature in 2014, they put people on a heavy, high animal protein, high fat, Atkins type diet, and then they rested them for a week and they put them on a diet that was more plant focused. And they found that within 30 hours of the food hitting the gut, things changed dramatically. The bacterial composition changed. The genetic composition changed in terms of the genes that were turned on and off. And the great thing here is you don't have to be a vegan. You don't even have to be a vegetarian. You just have to eat more plants. You have to do some basics.
And in fact, the American Gut Project study from 2019 that asked the question, what do you have to do to have a super healthy microbiome? They found that the label was completely unimportant. Carnivore, omnivore, vegan, pescatarian, lacto-ovo. It was simply the number of different plant foods people ate with 30 or more different plant foods a week being the magic number. So you can have your porterhouse or whatever it is that you're going to have. I mean, all my vegan friends will be very upset. But from a health point of view, there are reasons to consider eating less animal protein in terms of the ethics and climate change, etc. But from a health point of view, you can definitely tolerate a little animal protein on the plate. You can tolerate a lot of things on the plate if you are crowding it out with enough of the healthy stuff with some plants and some water and some movement and some of these basic things.
Mel Robbins
You just said 30 plants. So are you saying 30 different types of plants or are there 30 like ones that are better than others? Like as the gut doctor, what should we do?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
30 different plants per week. And when I say plants, you get credit for fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, herbs, spices, beans, whole grains, all of them.
Mel Robbins
Oh, well, if we include spices and nuts and grains like that, absolutely, you could get 30 different things. Because I would imagine the variety, like is the variety also important?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
The variety is important because they all contain different things. When we think of these phytochemicals. So eating the rainbow is always a good way to do it. So you get different things from the oranges and you get the lycopene from the reds and you get something else from the green. And so eating a variety, eating seasonally is another great way to do that because you're not in the same sort of peas, carrots, broccoli, heavy rotation for 365 days. And it doesn't have to be a lot either. You're getting enough from a little handful of berries is plenty. You don't have to eat a whole quart of stuff.
Mel Robbins
So as the gut expert, Dr. Robin, what do you eat in a day? You walk us through like breakfast, lunch and dinner.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Absolutely. I like to start off with a green smoothie in the morning. Collards, kale, spinach, celery, parsley, mint, a little bit of fruit, usually green apple, lots of lemon. I like to use unsweetened coconut water for the base. So when I drink that, it's like a liquid salad in the morning. I feel so good when I have that. So I usually have that in the morning. If I'm still hungry, I'll usually have something high-ish protein, maybe a little bit of smoked salmon, some eggs, or maybe a sweet potato and kale hash. I love that too.
Mel Robbins
And then what do you do for lunch?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Lunch is usually soup.
Mel Robbins
Soup?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
A big soup person.
Mel Robbins
Yeah. Okay.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
And there are a bunch that I make. My husband makes really good soup too. So it's usually split peas or lentils. Sometimes it's just a broth. I do a really basic soup that's leeks, onion, garlic, and scallion sauteed. And then I just blend it up with some broth. Delicious. Sometimes a little curry powder, depending on how I'm feeling. But that's all the good stringy, high inulin fiber that's really good for your gut microbes. So some kind of soup, sometimes it's a heartier soup.
And then dinner is usually protein, starch, veg plus salad. My husband's mostly vegan, not all the time, special occasions, he might eat some meat. So he's usually not doing animal, he's almost never doing the animal protein. He's usually doing lentils, brown rice, sauteed collards and salad. And I'll have all of that, but I may have a little piece of fish or some broiled shrimp or something. But it's lots of legumes. It's lots of beans and greens, basically. And then some whole grains. Love brown rice. Eat it probably most days. Love squash, sweet potato, yams, yucca, all of that stuff.
Mel Robbins
No wonder you're glowing. You're like, it sounds absolutely amazing. So do you need to take a probiotic? You need to eat an apple over taking a probiotic.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Yeah, this idea. And I will say for the record, there is dark chocolate happening every day for me.
Mel Robbins
Oh, thank God.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Tons of fruit and lots of dark chocolate.
Mel Robbins
Okay.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
And I have been known to eat a bag of Doritos on a road trip. It has happened.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Well, I knew I liked you. But let's talk probiotics because they are everywhere. Everybody seems to be on one. And as the gut doctor, what's your opinion about it?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
My opinion on probiotics is like multivitamins. Do we have clear and compelling evidence that a multivitamin does anything for the average person? We don't. What we know from some studies is that people who take vitamins also have healthy habits. So vitamin takers tend to be exercisers and clean eaters and meditators, etc. But we don't have evidence outside of that, that the vitamin itself in a healthy person. So it may help, it can't hurt.
Even something like a probiotic, if you're taking multiple different species, those bacteria, assuming that there are actually live bacteria in the probiotic because there's very little regulation, a lot of times the bacteria are dead. But let's say there are, let's say the product does contain what it says it contains, these live bacteria are potentially competing for resources with other bacterial species, even the native ones in your gut that are actually working and trying to do their thing. And now they're like, oh, wait, there's not enough of whatever resources we need to eat. And so you can be altering your microbial composition for the worse by taking a probiotic.
Mel Robbins
Oh, God. Now, well, I feel like I'm in the camp of everything you just said. It can't hurt. And so I'll just keep taking all these things and my body will just pee out whatever I don't need. So that's one mistake I'm clearly making. Second mistake that I'm making is I'm taking the probiotic and then I'm taking a different probiotic. And then I'm also eating the yogurt and the kimchi. And I'm just making this gigantic sort of bacteria salad.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
But eat the kimchi for sure. I mean, we have great data on fermented foods. And a lot of this is from the Sonoburn Lab at Stanford. So kimchi and sauerkraut are this powerhouse combination of pre, pro and postbiotics. And there's really compelling data that eating even a tablespoon of sauerkraut a day can provide multiple different species, important metabolites. So this is ultimately sort of medicinal food.
Mel Robbins
Wow.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Things like the sauerkraut and kimchi. So by all means, keep doing that.
Mel Robbins
Dr. Robin, what's the difference between a prebiotic and a probiotic?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
A prebiotic is food for the bacteria. So that's typically healthy, fibrous foods. Probiotics refer to the actual bacteria themselves. Not just the one you're taking as a supplement, but the ones in your gut. So probiotics are bacteria and prebiotics are the food that bacteria eat.
Mel Robbins
Got it. And I want to try to bring in a visual. So if you've ever made bread and you have that sort of, you're starting it and you've got the yeast and you then feed the yeast with the flour and it starts to bubble, the prebiotic thing is sort of like feeding the yeast and now it's like, oh, I'm really hungry and I'm getting going.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Okay, got it.
Mel Robbins
And the probiotics, the actual other forms of bacteria that you eat.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Correct.
Mel Robbins
Got it. So what are the foods that you need to eat to have both the prebiotic piece and the probiotic piece?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
For prebiotic, which are the foods to feed the bacteria, think high fiber and think stringy fiber like asparagus and celery. And also things like oats, dandelion greens. These are all great foods, fibrous foods to feed your bacteria. For probiotic foods, think about fermented. They also contain prebiotic with a fiber, but think about fermented foods because those are producing bacteria during the fermentation process.
And I do want to say it's not that a probiotic is a total waste of time. In my practice, where I treat really sick patients with Crohn's and ulcerative colitis, there are probiotics on the market that have the FDA label as a medicinal food. This is a medical food for the treatment of inflammatory bowel disease, etc. There are products that have over 100 different scientific studies behind them showing that they work for these particular conditions. But that's different, right? That's like the B12 for the Crohn's patient. That's not the average person. The data that the average person gets a lot of health benefit or really any health benefit from taking a probiotic is a little murkier.
And my concern is always that people are going to say, oh, I don't need to change my diet or really pay attention to that because I'm taking the probiotic. I mean, you're actually eating the kimchi and doing all the other stuff, which is fantastic. And I'm popping the probiotic. And I think you're probably OK, but you don't need it. But I do want to caution people. If you're taking these high dose probiotics, are you potentially using up resources that your native bacteria need? And how would you know? Like, would you be bloated even though you're taking a probiotic? How would you know that it's backfiring?
You really don't. You really don't. There's not a test we can do for that. But what I want people to remember is that when you take a probiotic product, those bacteria may be living half an hour. Typically under an hour. In order to get meaningful colonization and repopulation of the gut, you have to feed them. And so the food is ultimately more important because the truth is, it's not that you don't have any healthy bacteria in your gut. The population is low. How do you get, well, population may be low. Say you've taken a lot of antibiotics or you've had a crummy diet. How do you manipulate the microbiome and get those healthy species to grow? By feeding them, not by bringing in more species that are basically going to hang around 20 minutes and then you're going to poop them out.
So it's really this whole idea of repopulation and recolonization. And we do that by feeding what's already there. And that has been shown, and that's the American Gut Project study with the 30 different plants. When they ask the question, what is the most effective way, what is the most important thing to do to have a healthy microbiome? And this is a study done in over 10,000 people, 40 different countries. So really meaningful data. And the most effective thing was to get 30 different sources of plant-based foods in your diet once a week.
Mel Robbins
Yes, throughout the week.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Wow.
Mel Robbins
So it's still really diet. I mean, if you look at an apple that's grown organically and even better biodynamically.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
What's biodynamically?
Mel Robbins
Biodynamically is when you have the animals fertilizing the soil. Also like from a local farm.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Exactly. Local farm. I love it. Yes, that is.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Exactly.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Local because it's going to be more nutrient and microbe rich because it's not traveling 3,000 miles on a plane and barely a lot of chemicals in order to keep the thing. So an apple, you can get millions of microbes from eating an apple grown locally.
Mel Robbins
So Dr. Robin, I'm just imagining that the person listening is sitting here next to me and we have come to you because we feel bloated or we're struggling with IBS or constipation or whatever. And so it is just kind of a classic gut issue. What are the three small habits that you would like us to start implementing into our day-to-day life that are the best things that we could do that will build a healthy, beautiful kind of gut microbiome and get our gut system working correctly?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
There are tons of things to do, but if I had to distill it down to three, I would say it's hydration, it's movement, and it's fiber. And the movement, it's smooth muscle. It's not skeletal muscle, so it's not under voluntary control. But we know that movement creates nitric oxide, and nitric oxide is part of what keeps the heart healthy and keeps the gut healthy. And so the movement stimulates peristalsis. Peristalsis, if you don't have things moving through in a timely fashion, not only do you have symptoms like bloating and constipation, but you also have stasis of those intestinal contents and you have bacterial overgrowth because things aren't moving through.
So the movement is really important. And I found that since pandemic, so many of us are so sedentary. I know that I'm not at the hospital a few days a week anymore, back and forth where I'm probably walking four or five miles every day. I'm sitting a lot more. And I think we've seen a huge effect of that, of the effect of being sedentary on the gut. So we need to stimulate gut peristalsis. The people we see with the worst GI problems are people in nursing homes. And it's not because they're elderly, it's because they're not moving. So movement is really key.
Hydration, I can't say it enough times. Plumbing, we've got to unclog those pipes. And then the fiber, because the fiber feeds our gut microbes so they can ferment that fiber, create all the healthy metabolites. And it doesn't have to be some enormous kale salad. It can literally be grab a carrot as you're walking out the door and chomp on it. Throw an apple in your car, eat some nuts, something basic, ideally something unprocessed, right?
Mel Robbins
I love how accessible this is because based on everything that you are teaching us, your body is naturally designed to work in the correct way. It is plumbing. It's trying its best. And so if you get all different kinds of plant-based fibrous foods in, the research says try 30 different types of spices and foods, and if you simply walk more, you're saying that three things that we can do will help over time create a healthy gut.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Tremendous benefits. Tremendous. You know the water thing is like a drug when you really start to. And I was one of those people who for years walked around sort of dehydrated. I drank a lot if I was at heated vinyasa flow yoga or running. But other than that, I was like, oh, I can't be getting up. I'm seeing patients. I don't want to get up every five minutes and have to pee. And then I started measuring and drinking 100 ounces of water. I noticed a tremendous difference. I already have pretty good poos, I have to say. I'll show you some pictures later, Mel. But these, I mean, just dramatic improvement and they perk up like how briskly they come out because things are lubricated.
Mel Robbins
You know, I never thought I would say to a GI doc, I could listen to you all day. But I could. And there are so many people in my life, Dr. Robin, that need this information. And so I want to take a quick pause so we can hear a word from our sponsors. They bring you Dr. Robin at zero cost. So let's give them a little love. But you know who else I want you to give a little love to? The people in your life that need this life-changing information. Those friends that are complaining about their stomach, the people that have all kinds of issues, send them this episode. It could really change their health and change their life. Alrighty, don't go anywhere. We will be waiting for you after a short break with more from Dr. Robin.
Advertisement Break
Welcome back, it's your friend Mel and you and I are here with the incredible Dr. Robin Chutkin and we're learning all about gut health. I really do want to dig into having you help us understand specific gut issues like bloating and IBS and some of the things that people really struggle with. But before we go there, I would love for you to explain to us why should we care about a healthy gut? And what I'm trying to ask is, what is it impacting when your gut is healthy and when it's not? You said earlier that there's a big connection between your immune system and your gut health, which I didn't know. And so if you could just elevate this issue for us at the highest level, like why beyond our plumbing working, does your gut health mean total health?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
The gut immune connection is probably the most important connection for the gut and other organs. You have the gut lining and on one side, you have the trillions of microbes in your gut, your microbiome. And on the other side, you have the immune cells. And that gut lining is only one cell thick. It's a razor blade separating your gut microbiome from the immune processes. And it's a hand-in-glove relationship. They're working together. Literally, the microbes are like the lookouts. And they're like, oh, something problematic coming along. They trigger the immune system. In some cases, they actually kick on the lining of the gut. They push on it to trigger the immune processes. It's a physical interaction sometimes. But they signal the immune cells on the other side to say, oh, whoa, something big. Here comes Ebola or SARS-CoV-2. You guys need to get ready, mount an immune response, start making antibodies, T-cells mobilize.
Mel Robbins
Let me just make sure I'm understanding why this matters. Because based on what you're consuming through your mouth that gets processed through this 30-foot tube, your gut is extracting intelligence that mobilizes other parts of your body to help you outside of this tube?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Yeah, absolutely. Your gut microbiome directs your immune system.
Mel Robbins
It does?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It literally trains it. And this is why we see there's a fascinating theory called a hygiene hypothesis. And it was developed by David Straughan. He was an epidemiologist in Britain in the 1950s. He did a study of over 17,000 children from birth to adulthood. So a long period of time to figure out why they were seeing these high rates of autoimmune diseases in England and sort of post-industrial London. And he found that kids who were exposed to more germs, who were living in large households, where cousins and siblings were always sneezing and coughing on them, they were immunized because their immune system had been trained at an early age how to differentiate between friend and foe and whether to mount an immune response or not, how high an immune response. Kids who are super clean, who were never sick, they had higher rates of autoimmune disease later on.
And Mel, if we look at a map of the world today, we still see the effects of the hygiene hypothesis. We still see high rates of autoimmune disease in countries where there are higher levels of sanitation. There's more washing, there's more chlorination, there are more chemicals, there are fewer microbes. Compared to less developed countries where people have close contact with animals, they have close contact to the soil, they're growing their own food. So the immune system needs exposure to microbes early on in order to train it so it can set it at just the right level.
What we're seeing now in more developed countries like the United States is we're seeing an overactive immune system, which is manifest as autoimmune disease. One in four Americans, many people have multiple. Or allergies, food allergies. Everybody's got an allergy. Why? Why do we have a food allergy? Because of an overreactive immune system. And why do we have an overreactive immune system? Because of what's going on in our gut. There is a very direct correlation.
Mel Robbins
Can I, let me see if I can explain this to myself. So you're basically saying that when your gut is out of whack and it's getting all kinds of mixed signals because your microbiome and the gut health isn't intact, it's actually not able to either break things down or read what's coming in correctly. And then that means it is not able to signal in an efficient and effective way to your immune system that either we got to go into battle or everything is okay. And so because our guts are out of whack, we're not getting the hydration, we're not moving, we're not taking care of ourselves and eating the fibrous foods. This is causing our immune systems to go haywire.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Absolutely. And this is so fascinating. And I actually read somewhere, I don't know if this is true, that 80% of people that, at least in the United States, that have an autoimmune disorder are women.
Mel Robbins
Yes. Why does this impact women so much? And Gabor Mate talks about this and other folks.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
We think it may have something to do with the effect of the female hormones, estrogen, progesterone, et cetera, and the interaction with the gut. And also because some of these genetic predisposers for autoimmune disease are sex-linked. They're tied to the X chromosome. So a couple of different reasons. I also worry about the personal care products, the cosmetics, the other things that women tend to use more of that are getting absorbed into the body and how those might be affecting women. Because you think about it, you put makeup on at 10 o'clock in the morning, at 10 o'clock at night, it's like, where's the makeup? It's all gone. Where's it gone? It's got absorbed into our body.
And again, I'm not saying that makeup causes autoimmune disease, let's be clear. But we put a lot of things on our skin. And after our GI tract, our skin is our next biggest digestive organ. Our skin literally digests the things we're putting on it. And so we have to also think, what are we putting on our hair, our skin, et cetera, that could be getting absorbed into our body that could potentially be triggering an immune response. So that's just one of several theories. And like most diseases, like cancer, like dementia, it's not one cause.
Mel Robbins
Right.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's multiple different factors.
Mel Robbins
But is there research or do you see in your clinical practice, if you are doing these interventions that anybody can do, drink more water, move your body, eat more fibrous foods in your diet, when you can start to get your microbiome and your gut health and your plumbing working as it should, do you see an impact on an autoimmune disorder?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Most of what I do in my practice now is helping people with complex autoimmune disorders like Crohn's and ulcerative colitis get off immune suppressing drugs. And do you know how we do it, Mel?
Most of what I do in my practice now is helping people with complex autoimmune disorders like Crohn's and ulcerative colitis get off immune suppressing drugs. And do you know how we do it, Mel?
Mel Robbins
How?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
We do it with diet and lifestyle. If you had told me 27 years ago when I finished my GI fellowship that I would be treating complex autoimmune diseases with food, I would have laughed at you. I would have said, "Ha ha, that's hocus pocus craziness." But now when I think about it, I think about my colleagues saying to me, "Does that stuff really work?" And I'm like, "Are you asking me, as a fellow gastroenterologist, if what you put into your gut affects what's going on in your gut? And you're asking me if that's how it works?" I mean, of course that's how it works. What we put into our gut profoundly impacts what's going on in our gut. And what's going on in our gut profoundly impacts what's going on in the rest of the body.
It is very contrary to the prevailing wisdom of all the biologics and the immunosuppressants you see advertised on television. That's a gazillion dollar industry. But I will tell you, Mel, we have published data on this. We have a success rate of about 79% getting patients off of these biologic treatments. Now, I will tell you, it doesn't work in everyone. And it's a cherry-picked population because people are coming to see me, fancy GI doc, they've got to travel out, whatever, come and see me. And they're motivated. But the intervention is what anybody could do. The intervention is what anybody could do. It's drink more water. It's move your body. The intervention is not any special diet you have to go and buy or products.
I mean, we sometimes do use this very high potency probiotic, the one I mentioned that has the indication as a medical food for IBD. We'll often use that in conjunction, but it's always a dietary change. And I'll tell you the diet that I put patients on. What is the diet? It's similar to what I eat. It's a green smoothie in the morning. And I tell them, if you do nothing else, do this green smoothie. Get in your three leafy greens, a little celery, the parsley and mint are for me just for flavor, fruit, ice, little lemon for taste. Get that in in the morning. I usually start people on about 12 ounces and then I work them up to 40 ounces of this green smoothie. It's all just stuff you buy at the supermarket.
I always felt like I was sort of alone out there in the wilderness saying, "Eat food, real food. It will make a difference." So green smoothie in the morning. And I tell people, look, if you're still hungry, have some eggs, make an omelet, definitely have something else for sure. Then for lunch, it's usually something based around plants. I'll encourage my patients, I'll say, get a salad that's usually easy for people to get. And if you want some animal protein, go for it, but make sure it's a big salad and ideally put some chickpeas in there, some hummus on the side. So lots of plants. Then for dinner, if you are an animal protein eater, your protein, your starch, your two veg plus salad. And that's it. There's a formula. Sensible eating.
It's also getting people to cut down or ideally eliminate the ultra processed foods, the packaged foods with all the emulsifiers. In my neck of the woods for autoimmune diseases in the GI tract, we see that the emulsifiers, the soy lecithin, carrageenan, those things are particularly bad for the gut. And we think it's not so much the microbiome, but it's the gut lining, that they compromise the gut lining in some way.
Mel Robbins
What are some other parts of your overall health that are driven by gut health that might surprise someone to know?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Your estrogen levels. I did not learn this in medical school. When I found this out a decade or so ago, I was mesmerized by something called the estrobolome. The estrobolome refers to a collection of bacteria in your gut that metabolize estrogen. When the estrogen is made primarily in the ovaries and a little bit in the adrenal glands, it travels through the bloodstream to all the different parts of the body that have estrogen receptors. That's not just the uterus, that's also heart tissue, different parts of our brain, et cetera. Then the estrogen that's not used gets transported, it gets into the bile, and it gets excreted into the gut and it gets recycled through the gut.
There are certain bacteria in the gut that help to recycle that. Some of it gets excreted out and some of it gets reabsorbed back through the lining into the bloodstream. If the estrobolome is disrupted, you get higher levels of reabsorption than you should. And you end up with a situation called estrogen dominance, where you have too much estrogen on board. That is associated with a lot of conditions: fibroids, endometriosis, a lot of the menopausal symptoms we think of. Again, this isn't the only reason for sure, but most people don't realize that the gut plays a huge role in estrogen metabolism.
Mel Robbins
So if you've been taking antibiotics nonstop for whatever they may have been prescribed for decades...
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Exactly. Not just, "I had a strep throat, I took antibiotics," but somebody put you on antibiotics for your skin, told you have a chronic inflammatory condition, maybe rosacea, take these antibiotics. Or because you're getting frequent urinary tract infections, take the antibiotics every time you have sex. That could add up depending on who you are. So many of the patients I see, and so many women in particular, are put on these suppressive antibiotics, not to treat an actual infection, but to treat inflammation or to prevent an infection. That ends up being ruinous to your gut bacteria, and that ends up affecting your estrogen metabolism and throwing your estrogen levels off balance.
I really, particularly for my menopausal women and particularly because I'm menopausal myself, really focus on a gut-centric approach to that. You've got to have a healthy gut if you want to go through menopause successfully. There have been some really interesting articles. Dr. Neal Barnard at the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, they're very much a plant-based organization. They published a study that looked at a plant-based diet for vasomotor symptoms and menopause, for hot flashes. It was way more effective than hormone replacement.
Mel Robbins
Wow.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
The thing that I find in my patient population is it doesn't have to be a completely plant-based diet. Now, Neal and his colleagues who are wonderful people would tell you that it should be, but we live in the real world and not everybody's going to become a vegan to control their hot flashes. Just eating more plants and having a plant-based dinner, having your last meal before you go to bed be primarily plants, can help dramatically.
Mel Robbins
If I want to induce a hot flash, I don't have them anymore, but if I want to induce one, I have a porterhouse steak and some red wine at night.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I was just going to say the same thing. Up all night.
Mel Robbins
I was just going to say the same thing.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Because digestion is such an active process. Particularly digesting animal protein that's high in fat, high in protein, requires a lot of blood flow, a lot of enzymatic activity that leads to a lot of dilation and flushing. And of course, alcohol is going to vasodilate you too.
Mel Robbins
I think you just inspired me to make a major change, especially during the weeks that I have a really big workload or I'm traveling for work. I've got to get up in the morning, give a big keynote in front of thousands of people. I always think, "Oh, I should have a steak tonight. I should have a piece of fish tonight. I should have a big protein thing to carry me through." What I'm gathering from you is I would be way better off if I heavy loaded on the leafy greens and the vegetables and a lot of water at night, because it would allow my gut to just flush itself.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Rest and digest. Yes.
Mel Robbins
Yeah.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Think about it. The protein can be sating and it can carry you through, but think about having a high protein breakfast the day before. Have an omelet the day before or have more protein at lunch. Then for dinner, really lighten it up early. Light soup and salad.
Mel Robbins
Perfect. I love this because so many of the experts that have come on, because you've been talking to a lot of people about hormones and menopause and for women in particular, how you age well so that you have energy and you're strong and you're vibrant as you age. So much of the message is about resistance training and lots and lots and lots of protein. I think really trying to get the big protein in the morning and at lunch is the way to go. I'm learning so much. Can you explain the connection between the gut and the brain to the person listening?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
The gut-brain connection is another fascinating one. I think gut-immune and gut-brain right now. We have a whole separate nervous system in our gut called the enteric nervous system. It's many, many millions of nerve cells. In fact, we have about seven times the number of nerve cells in our gut that we have in our spinal cord. Not as much as we have in our central nervous system, clearly. But the gut is a very innervated organ.
Mel Robbins
Innervated? Lots of nerve cells?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Lots of nerve cells. It also communicates directly with the brain via the vagus nerve, the 10th cranial nerve, messages going back and forth. The gut is also where most of the neurotransmitters are produced. Serotonin, the feel-good hormone, dopamine, several others. Most of them are produced in the gut. They're co-manufactured by bacteria.
Mel Robbins
I think that is a surprise to most people because you hear the word serotonin and you think brain. But you're here to tell us, Dr. Robynne, no, no, no, no, no. Your gut health is critical because the serotonin that you need, most of it is manufactured in a healthy gut.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
In a healthy gut. So what we see is that with a disrupted gut, we see abnormalities in mood, in cognition, in memory. And conversely, because it's bidirectional, it's gut affecting brain and brain affecting gut. We see the brain influence on gut motility, enzyme secretion, and absorption of nutrients. You've got to have it in balance. And it's not either or. It's not either you take an SSRI or you eat healthily. It's both. Particularly for young people, the idea that you can take a young person who's struggling with mental health issues, and they can be eating Cheetos and cheeseburgers while you're medicating them, and you're not paying attention to what they're eating, is magical thinking. We have to pay attention to that for brain health also.
Mel Robbins
Is there a scientific link between depression and anxiety and gut health?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
There are. And like a lot of these conditions, it's multifactorial. But I'll give you just a basic example. There's a bacteria called Campylobacter jejuni, which is a common cause of foodborne illnesses. Sometimes people will get it with traveler's diarrhea when they're out of town. In mice, if you inject a large inoculum of Campylobacter jejuni, you induce anxiety in mice. What's a human correlate for that? Post-infectious irritable bowel syndrome, which is what we refer to when somebody has a change in bowel habits that's happening after an infection, often after an infection like Campylobacter jejuni.
Post-infectious irritable bowel syndrome doesn't just affect your bowel habits where now the bowel habits are irregular, maybe they're looser, they're more frequent. It also frequently involves changes in mood. People will say they're more anxious. "I went to the Caribbean, I got traveler's diarrhea. I was in Mexico, I got Montezuma's revenge. I came back and my bowel habits haven't been the same, but I also find I'm more anxious. My mood seems to have changed." We think a lot of that is mediated through the change in the microbiome.
Mel Robbins
Wow. Let's talk about IBS because I have a number of friends and family members that are struggling with it. What should somebody do if they think they have IBS? What are the steps I would take before you go running for some sort of drug?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Number one is you have to figure out what is causing it. I like to think in terms of general categories. Is it something mechanical? If you're a woman, when was your last ultrasound? Do you have a big fibroid? Could there be endometriosis? Do you have an anteverted uterus or a prolapsed bladder or something that's pressing on it? What is the anatomical, mechanical thing going on that could be causing symptoms?
Medicine cabinet is a big one. And it's not just prescription drugs, but it's also over-the-counter and supplements. You need to look at the side effects.
Mel Robbins
And what am I looking for?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
All of them. You're looking for things that have GI side effects: nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, constipation.
Mel Robbins
Isn't that every medication?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's a lot. But I'll tell you, when they list side effects, they list the most common ones first. It's like ingredients at a food label. The most common ingredient is listed at the top.
Mel Robbins
And by common, you mean this is the side effect we see the most?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Exactly. If you see nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, constipation, diarrhea in the top five, and you are having some of those symptoms, that's something worth checking out. Again, not advocating that you take a drug holiday on your own, but talk to the prescriber. Here's the thing. Your psychiatrist might be prescribing a drug for you for anxiety, and the drug may be helping your anxiety, but it may be causing a whole different problem in the GI tract. I have to remind people that just because something is helpful doesn't mean it's a good idea. I tell people all the time, if you're tired and I gave you some cocaine, it would pep you right up. But does that mean cocaine is a good idea for treating fatigue?
In my practice, I spend so much time trying to undo what I like to call "medical misadventure," where a very well-meaning physician prescribes something for his or her neck of the woods: a kidney problem, a psychiatric problem, a lung problem. It's going great for that problem, but it's messing up my organ now. We're very siloed in medicine. The nephrologist is the kidneys and the pulmonologist is the lungs and everybody's just sort of focused on their thing. Because the medicine cabinet is such a problem, the GI tract, and as you said, Mel, don't all these drugs have GI side effects? Many of them do because you ingest them. They potentially affect the pH of the gut. They potentially affect the gut lining and they potentially affect the gut microbiome. Then those things affect the immune system, et cetera. It becomes a sort of whack-a-mole. You whack one problem here, your high blood pressure, fantastic. Blood pressure is controlled. Now we have a problem over here. So we whack that with another medicine. It's polypharmacy.
When I see people, the first thing I want to figure out is, "Is this a side effect I'm treating?" Because it often is. Is their constipation or their bloating a side effect of a medication they're taking? The sometimes challenging thing is people don't want to hear that. They want the magic potion. "Give me the magic supplement probiotic that's going to make this go away." So I have people bring their medications, their over-the-counter, the supplements, everything, and I lay them all out on the table. The people in my office always laugh because I always have my rubbish bin right next door because they're like, "Oh, this is going to fill up." And I'm like, "Okay, this one, what's this one for?" To be clear, I would never tell somebody to stop a prescription medication that I didn't prescribe. I tell them, "This one you've got to talk to your prescriber about." I divide it up. Usually by the time I'm done, it's a pretty small group that's left.
Mel Robbins
What is the first thing that you're like, "No, no Advil, no aspirin, no this"? The thing that people take all the time?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
You got it. The non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.
Mel Robbins
What is that?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Advil, Anacin, Aleve, ibuprofen. When we look at the emergency visits for gastrointestinal bleeding, number one cause.
Mel Robbins
Too much ibuprofen?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Too much ibuprofen. People don't realize that over-indexing on this stuff can cause fatal gastrointestinal bleeding. There was not a weekend on call when we were not in the intensive care unit with our scopes trying to stop dramatic, near fatal gastrointestinal bleeding. These drugs can be potentially really dangerous. You have to be careful with them.
Mel Robbins
I'm assuming that if this is the detective work you're doing, it's still the same three things that you would recommend in terms of movement and water and diet to overcompensate.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
But you can't fill a bathtub with the stopper out. If you're trying to improve gut health, fill the bathtub, you have to make sure that it's stopped up, that you're not draining all the good stuff you're doing out. I like this concept of personalized medicine, but personalized medicine not in the sense of all these wonky tests and supplements, but personalized medicine in terms of sitting down and really figuring out what are the things that you're dealing with and what is background noise? What is a platform on which your symptoms or illness live? Is that platform the standard American diet? You only eat a broccoli floret once a week as your only vegetable? Is it massive amounts of antibiotics in childhood, as was the case with my daughter? Is it really sedentary and no time outside? You've got to look at that platform, see what you can change, and then start to add on. You don't just start adding on all the medication without really thinking about the other medication. How are these four other medications you may be taking for high blood pressure or something else, how are they affecting the gut?
Mel Robbins
As I'm listening to you, I'm not only thinking about myself and the person listening, but I've got at least five people that I have to send this episode to right now. Let's take a quick break so we can hear a word from our sponsors. While you're listening to the sponsors, share this episode with your friends and with your family. Anybody that's been complaining about stomach or gut issues, they need Dr. Robynne in their life. Send them this episode and don't go anywhere because we'll be waiting for you after a short break. Stay with us.
Break
Welcome back, it's your friend Mel Robbins and you and I are here with the incredible Dr. Robynne Chutkan, and you and I are learning absolutely everything related to gut health and more importantly, how to make it better. Dr. Robynne, here's where I want to go next. One thing that I want to talk about with you today is poop. What should we be looking for? What's healthy, what's not?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
My favorite thing to talk about. And Mel, I am so curious about your poop. If you are willing to share, I know I'm not the only one who wants to know. What are Mel Robbins' bowel habits like?
Mel Robbins
Well, I'm the kind of person, you ask the question, I'm going to tell you. I'm happy to talk about my poop.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I have a feeling that you have wonderful poos because you have this glow. You seem really healthy.
Mel Robbins
Do you really want to know?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Yes, I really want to know.
Mel Robbins
I am a once a day person.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Excellent.
Mel Robbins
I typically go in the morning and I have one of those little stools, a squatty potty. If I can't find a stool, like if I'm at a hotel, I pull the little garbage can over and stick my feet up. I think it's healthy. I don't even know what healthy poop is. I just know that when it comes out kind of in one shape, perfect, and it's somewhat soft and held together, and there's not a lot of strange objects in it, that that's probably healthy. If I have a situation where I'm not doing well and I'm super stressed, I might go a day without pooping, but typically never more than a day or two. When that happens, it looks like Malted Milk Balls, and I know I'm in trouble and I'm not healthy. How am I doing, doc?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Stool nirvana, baby.
Mel Robbins
Is that what it is?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
You got it. Stool nirvana. You hit all the marks. Daily, good color, formed. It also sounds like you feel good when it comes out. There's that feeling of, "Yeah, I emptied, I detoxed. I'm good to go."
Mel Robbins
I'm pretty efficient. I don't spend a lot of time in there. I can get in, I can get out. But that does beg the question, how often should you be going?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
How often do you eat? Do you eat every day?
Mel Robbins
Of course. At least once a day.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
You should be eliminating once a day. This idea, we have this textbook definition that it's three or more bowel movements a week is normal. But if you're going under three, you're constipated. It's a very arbitrary number. When we think about constipation, we're usually thinking about things like consistency. Is the stool hard or is it soft? How much is coming out? But it should absolutely be a daily thing because that's what it is. It's elimination. It's eliminating dead blood cells, bacteria, toxins, undigested food particles. That stuff is not supposed to be gumming up your colon, just sitting there.
Mel Robbins
Everybody that does not go number two once a day just leaned in and thought, "Oh gosh, what do I do?" If you're somebody that is not going once a day, that doesn't have a satisfying experience with this or kind of reliable, what are the first couple steps that you want somebody to do?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I think the first thing, again, is recognizing that this should be daily. That being said, if you skip a day here and there, your traveling schedule is a little bit different, that's nothing to worry about. But how can we help people go every day? I want people to consider a couple things: what they're putting in, how they're stimulating the gut, and that's primarily with movement, and what they might be doing that's slowing things down, the gut motility.
What you're putting in, you want to make sure you're putting in enough fiber. You want to make sure you're putting enough water, liquid. It's plumbing. The GI tract is pipes. In fact, a plumber was at my house one day fixing something and I was standing over him and he kept looking at me and he was like, "Are you checking what I'm doing?" I'm like, "No, no, no. We're just in the same business. You just make a lot more money than I do. I'm just looking at what you're doing here." But it's plumbing. It's one long pipe from north to south, about 30 feet long, and things get clogged along the way. What do you do when your pipe is clogged? Thin liquids, lots of water.
I tell people my rule of thumb: half your body weight in ounces of water as a minimum. That's just plain water. We don't need electrolytes in it. We don't need flavoring. Those things often are irritating to the gut. Just plain water, half your body weight in ounces of water as a minimum. That makes a tremendous difference. I can probably solve 50% of the constipation I see in my office just by getting people to hydrate.
Mel Robbins
Wow. And by the way, great for your skin and everything else. So takeaway number one is thinking about your gut system as a 30-foot long plumbing system. It starts with your throat, moves all through your body, and right out the chute at the bottom. Half of your body weight is what you should be hydrating with just plain water every day. As a medical doctor specializing in this, 50% of constipation issues can be solved by simply hydrating?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's a generalization, but 50% of the people I see in my office who are bloated and constipated and things are sluggish, when I get them to really start hydrating, things perk right up. I also want to point out that the female plumbing system is very different from the male plumbing system.
Mel Robbins
Oh, how?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
That's because of three main reasons. If you have had a colonoscopy, if you're 45 or over, you should have had a colonoscopy. You may have been told, particularly if you're a woman, that you have either a redundant colon or a tortuous colon or a twisted colon. The reason that's more common in women is because of anatomical differences.
Number one, we have a longer digestive tract. Our colons on average are about three to five inches longer.
Mel Robbins
Three to five inches? If you think five inches, that's like from your rear end to your belly button.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Exactly. It is a lot. That extra length creates more looping and twisting. Things are more likely to get stuck. That's one of the main reasons women tend to be so much more bloated and constipated. The reason why is to allow for more fluid absorption during pregnancy. The colon does two things: it gets the products of digestion from north to south, and it also reabsorbs water from the inside, from the stool, through the lining of the colon into the bloodstream. The reason women have a slightly longer colon is so that when we are pregnant, we can reabsorb more water through the colon to maintain the amniotic fluid.
Mel Robbins
Let me see if I can extract that so that those of us without your amazing medical knowledge and degrees understand this, because I think that's fascinating. Did you just say that one of the things that your colon is doing is when the waste is moving through your colon, the colon is actually removing water and moisture from the waste matter and recycling that water through your body so that as a woman, you can make the amniotic fluid? You can do other things that are part of the reproductive cycle?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
One hundred percent. If you were to go up into a colonoscopy as somebody is having a bowel movement, which I don't recommend, we like to have the colon cleaned out when we're doing that, what you would see is that when the stool hits the top of the colon, it's liquid.
Mel Robbins
What?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's liquid and it's green. It's bilious fluid. As it moves through the five to seven feet of colon at the end, the fluid gets reabsorbed so that what comes out at the end is a beautiful Mel Robbins stool nirvana, chocolatey brown, gorgeous.
Mel Robbins
We need to make some T-shirts for you that say, "I have great poops."
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Oh my God.
Mel Robbins
I don't know if I want people looking in the toilet and going, "That looks like Mel Robbins right there."
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Smiling right back at you. So at the end, you get this chocolatey brown thing. How do you turn liquid green at the top of the colon to solid brown at the bottom? The colon reabsorbs the fluid and all the bacteria that are primarily in the colon. You have bacteria throughout your whole GI tract, but they're concentrated at the bottom. The bacteria get dumped in, the dead bacteria and the dead red blood cells, and that turns it brown. That process happens in the colon. The absorption of nutrients, the vitamin A, D, E, and K, the iron, all that stuff gets absorbed upstream in your small intestine. The function of the colon: transport the products, reabsorb water, ferment the products of digestion with all the gut bacteria so that you end up with a chocolatey brown stool.
Mel Robbins
This is fascinating.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Isn't it? Poo is so fascinating. The longer colon is just reason number one. Reason number two why we're more bloated and constipated is that we have a deeper, wider pelvis. The female pelvis is called a gynecoid pelvis. The male pelvis is an android pelvis. What that means is that our colon falls deeper down into the pelvis where it has to compete for space. What else is in the pelvis? Your uterus, your fallopian tubes, your ovaries, your bladder. That's a lot of hardware. In men, they just have a prostate gland that's about the size of a walnut. There's much more room. If you look at two skeletons side by side, male and female, you can tell the female. The pelvis is like wings and the male is straight. Again, what's the reason? Childbearing, so that we can accommodate a whole human being down there. That's reason number two. These are both anatomical reasons: longer colon, deeper, wider pelvis.
Reason number three: we have lower testosterone levels.
Mel Robbins
What does that mean?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Testosterone does a lot of things. It's not that we don't have any, but we have less. One of the things testosterone does is it makes the muscles in the body stronger, more rigid. Men have a tighter abdominal wall because they have more testosterone. Even a man with a big beer belly, he'll complain about having a beer belly, but he won't complain about being bloated because underneath his beer belly is a nice, tight Spanx. We've got a stretched out Spanx because of the lower testosterone levels. These three things really conspire to bloat and constipate us.
If you look at the medical literature, you'll see all these articles about why colonoscopy is harder in women. It takes longer. We require more sedation. That's true. But it's not because we have a lower pain threshold. It's because we have all these anatomical things that are there for a reason. They're not a design flaw, but they also conspire to make us more backed up.
Mel Robbins
Can we talk a little bit about constipation?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I love talking about constipation.
Mel Robbins
Why do you love talking about constipation?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Constipation is so satisfying because there's so many different things that cause it. And often people are dealing with two or three things. And when people feel better, it's like, they're so happy.
Mel Robbins
[Laughs]
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
And the other reason I love treating constipation—sorry to interrupt—is because bloating is constipation's fellow traveler. So when people are constipated, they're almost always bloated because they're just plugged. When you relieve the constipation, you de-bloat them and they're thrilled.
The other thing is, a lot of people who are bloated don't even realize they're constipated. You can have a bowel movement every single day and still be constipated. You can have two bowel movements a day and be constipated if you are having something called incomplete evacuation, tenesmus.
Mel Robbins
Tenesmus.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Tenesmus is like the new insomnia. Think about it. When we think about insomnia, we think, "Okay, I have trouble falling asleep." But most people who have insomnia don't have trouble falling asleep. They go to sleep fine, but they wake up and they can't go back to sleep. I go right to sleep and I pop awake and I start ruminating and I can't go back to sleep.
Well, constipation—tenesmus—is kind of like that. It's not that you're not going. You're having a bowel movement, but it's incomplete. You can tell that your colon isn't empty. You've got that feeling like, "Oh, I still got something on the launch pad."
Mel Robbins
Yeah.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
And often it's a smeary wipe. When you wipe and there's still a lot of stool on it, that's because there's stool still in the rectum that hasn't come out. You don't have that good clean wipe where it's like, "Oh, look, nothing on the toilet paper." That's part of stool nirvana—a clean wipe.
Mel Robbins
So you said that there were lots of different causes and lots of different things you can do. Can you walk us through the things that cause constipation that might surprise people?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's very similar to the IBS classification. So, mechanical: Do you have a voluptuous venous colon? Do you have fibroids? Have you had surgery and you have scar tissue? Do you have a prolapsed bladder or rectum? So what's going on mechanically?
Medicine cabinet—I think I beat that horse to death.
And then hormones: Do you have potentially undiagnosed hypothyroidism? Are you in early menopause and now you're more constipated because of that? Remember, perimenopause starts like 10 years before you stop having your period. So could it be a hormonal problem?
Could it be a physiological motility problem? Motility is very tied to the composition of the gut bacteria. Believe it or not, antibiotics that you took 10 years ago and affected your microbiome can now be causing your gut to slow down or go too fast and not function properly.
Mel Robbins
I have somebody that I love that is chronically constipated. They'll go four or five days, and that is consistently what their experience is. What do you think the reasons are? Have you done any sleuthing?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I have. And it's a very healthy person. Exercises all the time. Has a very clean diet. Does not take a lot of medication. Young.
Mel Robbins
And I personally think it is an issue with the muscles—like somehow training yourself to clench when you should be releasing.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's a huge category. I'm so glad you brought it up because I had overlooked that when we were talking about it.
Mel Robbins
So can you describe what this means? Because I think for people that also have shy bowel...
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
The medical terms are things like anismus. Some of these are pelvic floor issues. I know you've had pelvic floor people on. But it is tightening when you should be releasing. What we're talking about here isn't really a pelvic floor issue. It is a muscular issue. And it's exactly what you said.
Shy bowel—the technical term is parkopresis. It's also called psychogenic fecal retention. It's classified as a psychiatric problem. But there are some really important physiological things that make me think it's misclassified as a psychiatric problem.
Mel Robbins
So could somebody have constipation and you actually have shy bowel? Like you get in there and you're so constipated and you're like, "Why can't I get it out?" And as you're stressing and tensing, you're actually in this almost traumatic response to pooping because you're so stressed about being constipated. Is this a thing?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
It's the immediate stress, but more so, it is what happened before. People who tend to hold their poo in. You have to have a bowel movement, but there's not a good bathroom or you don't have time. You're at the airport and you're worried that your flight's going to board without you. Or you're at school and the bathroom's gross and there's space between the door and people can see and hear and smell.
One of the most important things for bowel hygiene is to not have stalls. Even people like me—I am the least shy about bowel movements. I don't want to have a bowel movement in public, but I don't care. I'll be in the stall talking to you.
Mel Robbins
[Laughs]
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
That's not really normal. Most people do not want to be in a bathroom with four stalls having a bowel movement talking to somebody on the other side of the door. Having a bathroom where you have a toilet and a door that closes—not stalls—is hugely helpful for good bowel habits.
You have these two muscles. You have the internal sphincter, which is under involuntary control. It's clenched tight to prevent leakage. And then you have the external sphincter, which is under voluntary control. That's the one that you open or close depending on whether you're trying to push stool in or out.
When the rectum fills with stool, the internal sphincter relaxes to let the stool out. That's when your external sphincter is supposed to push it out. But if you decide, "Oh, I don't like the look of this bathroom. I'm at a train station. I'm going to wait," you're clenching when you should be releasing. That completely confuses the sphincters.
Mel Robbins
So you can train yourself to hold it in and not realize you're doing that?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
A hundred percent. That creates something called reverse peristalsis, where the stool is going back up in the wrong direction instead of coming out. If you do that often enough—and this often happens in children, it's more common in girls because we tend to be a little bit more fastidious about where we use a bathroom—it means that when you actually want to have a bowel movement, you can't. The sphincter is confused. The internal sphincter relaxes, but now the external sphincter is clenching.
My best advice for people: if you have tried everything for your constipation—the fiber, the water, the exercise, all these things—and nothing is working, consider some of these mind-body practices. Whether it's cognitive behavioral therapy or internal biofeedback, which is a kind of physical therapy. Find a biofeedback practitioner. It could make a huge difference.
One clue is on the rectal exam. I'll say, "Oh yeah, this person definitely has anismus." Another clue is when somebody says, "I've done all of these things, and not only is it not working, it's making me more bloated." The sphincter at the very bottom is tight. All the fiber and water and everything is backed up right at the back door, but the door won't open.
Mel Robbins
So what is the difference? How do you know if you're bloated versus you're just gaining weight?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
That's a really challenging and sometimes uncomfortable conversation to have with people. But a really useful way to know is to take a tape measure and measure right around your waist—generally just around your belly button—in the morning and at night, every day for about a week. If there is a lot of variation in that number, that's likely bloat. Bloating ebbs and flows. It's usually gas, but it can also be liquid and solid.
If it is belly fat, that number typically won't vary by more than an inch. Sometimes people come in with an apple shape—skinny legs, big belly—and they think they're bloated. On exam, I can also tell because fat feels different. When you auscultate and percuss and listen, I can tell fat from gas.
But if somebody's out there and they're not at the doctor, measuring the waist and seeing if it ebbs and flows is helpful. People send me pictures. Typically it's flat to fat from morning to night. They're flat in the morning and then they send me pictures at the end of the day and they're super bloated.
Mel Robbins
What are some surprising foods that cause bloat that we might not know cause bloat?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Yogurt.
Mel Robbins
Yogurt?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Yogurt. Because somewhere between 60 and 70 percent of the world's population is lactose intolerant. Some people know it because they have really smelly gas and it's immediate. But many of us lose our ability to digest dairy over time because we're not baby cows. We're not really designed to be drinking this.
The lactase enzyme is along the brush border in the small intestine. If you have an acute infection, that can knock it off and you lose it. And just as we age over time, people might have tolerated dairy really well, and now they're not. Their dairy would mostly be cheese and yogurt—things that don't have as much lactose. They're not drinking big cups of milk.
Dairy is one that a lot of people think of as a health food. It's a fermented food. But so often people are not tolerating the dairy. They're having all this yogurt every day. It's a convenient, quick, portable, delicious source of protein. Many of my patients will have some form of dairy—either yogurt or cottage cheese—trying to get their protein up every day. We get rid of that, things improve a lot.
Mel Robbins
Are there some surprising everyday non-food things that can cause you to be bloated?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Yes. One of the things to remember with bloating—we think about the GI tract and elimination and stool and liquid and gas—but it's also our lymphatic system. Our lymphatic system is like a fluid that bathes our cells and it has to drain. Exercise is what stimulates lymphatic flow.
If you're sitting for a long time, you may notice your feet swell. Why do your feet swell? Because the venous flow—the veins are occluded because you're sitting and there's pressure on the veins, and the lymphatics don't move as much. Moving around, exercise—really important for lymphatic flow, really important for de-bloating.
Then there's things like salt in the food, alcohol. Alcohol is a big one because it irritates the gut. That can lead to inflammation, fluid retention. It also dehydrates us, and that causes fluid to shift and puffiness. But exercise is another big one for bloating.
Mel Robbins
When somebody comes and sees you, Dr. Robynne, and they're just really, really bloated and it's not a big serious issue—it is something that they're experiencing—is there like a step-by-step protocol where you're like, "Do this and do this and you should be feeling relief in a matter of days"?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I love putting people on a liquid diet for a couple of days and using some magnesium citrate. Now, I want to say with the magnesium citrate in the liquid—the bottle—you've got to make sure there's no kidney disease and other things going on. But let's say this is a typical healthy person. They went on vacation. They oversported themselves, in the words of my mother-in-law. They ate a little too much. They drank a little too much.
Most of us come back from vacation feeling a little constipated. Why is that? Because we've just been like, "Woo hoo!" And also if we've crossed time zones, we often feel jet lag in our gut. It slows down. Also because our GI tract is a creature of habit. Now you're in a strange bathroom somewhere. Our bowels get a little shy when we're traveling.
My favorite thing in that situation is to put them on two days of a clear liquid diet—broth and tea and green juice, as opposed to a smoothie. Do that for a couple of days and a little bit of liquid magnesium citrate at night. Not too much. We don't want to blast things.
Mel Robbins
Like a teaspoon?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
No, no, no. The typical bottle of magnesium citrate is about a soda bottle. So maybe a quarter of that.
Mel Robbins
A quarter of it.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
A quarter of that. So like a cup of the liquid magnesium citrate. Make sure if you haven't taken that, that you know where the bathroom is. For some people, it will work overnight. For some people, it could work in a couple hours.
I like that because the stimulant laxatives that have senna—those are really hard on the colon. The colon can become dependent. Some of them have an impact on the microbiome that isn't great.
The liquid diet is a great way to sort of reset, to decompress. Most of the time when your colon is uncomfortable, stop eating. Liquids work great. You see with animals in the wild when they're sick, they stop eating. You won't see a dog who picked up a parasite chowing down on their food. That's often how we know they're sick. They're not eating.
What we call NPO—nothing per oram, nothing by mouth. It doesn't have to be that extreme. But going to liquids and eating less to allow whatever it is to come out. That could be true even for something that's infectious. If you have a mild case of infectious diarrhea—a foodborne illness—and your GI tract is trying to expel that, you're having diarrhea and vomiting, it's trying to eliminate it—don't go adding a whole bunch of food on top of that. If your GI tract wants to empty, let it empty. Get it all out and then start again. So that's my favorite thing—just to do a little mini cleanse.
Mel Robbins
How does stress impact our gut?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Stress has a huge impact on our GI tract. We talked about the gut-brain connection and the neurotransmitters. But stress triggers our sympathetic nervous system—that's our fight or flight. Parasympathetic nervous system is our chill out, rest and digest.
If you think about having to get away from the tiger that's chasing you, you need the blood flow to go to your brain and the large muscles in your body—your quadriceps, your hamstrings—so that you can run and get away from danger. Digestion itself is a very active process. It takes a lot of enzymatic activity, a lot of blood flow. So when you are stressed, all the resources are diverted away from your GI tract.
Stress can really impact digestion negatively. It will affect the way the digestive enzymes are secreted. It can decrease acid secretion. It can decrease other digestive enzyme secretion. But we know stress can also increase the population of unhealthy microbes.
There was a famous experiment done in college students. It found that during finals, certain more pathogenic bacteria could increase a thousandfold in an hour. Just start multiplying and multiplying. And you think about when college students are stressed—they're not sleeping, they're not eating well, they're over-caffeinated, and now their microbiome is out of whack. Stress has a really profound impact.
Mel Robbins
The question comes up a lot with people who have irritable bowel syndrome—particularly folks where there hasn't been one or two more specific causes found—and they want to know, "Is stress causing this?"
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
What I find in the GI tract is stress isn't usually the entire reason, but it can be a really major contributing factor.
Mel Robbins
What are symptoms that indicate that there may be something more serious going on with your gut, Dr. Robynne?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Red flags in the GI tract are really important. Those would include things like blood in the stool, weight loss, vomiting, abdominal pain—not like a little discomfort, but like, "Oh, that really hurt." Unrelenting nausea. Those are the things where I would say get to a gastroenterologist, and quickly.
Mel Robbins
Dr. Robynne, you have this 10-day plan for a better gut and you call it the Gut Bliss Method. Will you walk us through it?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I call it the Gut Bliss Method. It consists of removing, replacing, and restoring.
The first part is to remove foods, practices, and medications that are potentially harmful to your diet. That would be things like ultra-processed foods, alcohol, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and excessive antibiotics. For practices, it may be something as simple as not taking enough time to have a bowel movement. Removing those things.
The idea behind that is like the bathtub. If you're going to fill the bathtub, you've got to make sure the stopper is in. You don't want to be trying to fill a bathtub with the stopper out because you're eating foods and taking medications that are still causing a problem. So that's your remove.
Replace is trying to add in those extra healthy bacteria—not through a probiotic primarily, but through exposure to nature, through fermented foods. The powerhouse combination of pre-, pro-, and postbiotics. Those sorts of really healthy high-fiber and fermented foods to replace the gut bacteria.
Then restore is how do you restore overall health? A lot of that focuses on mind-body practices, on getting outside, on getting quiet, reducing stress. And of course, hydration is a big part of it.
It's simple. It's stuff that anybody can do. It's not expensive. You need access to some good food and you need to actually eat it. But what I find, whether I'm seeing a patient who has complicated Crohn's disease or somebody who's just a little bloated, it is incredible how much of a difference these basic principles make.
I came up with them over a couple of decades of practice. Not to say that some of the fancier things don't play a role also. But what I find the majority of the time, it's really getting people to pay attention to these foundational things that they can do. These are not things that require a gastroenterologist. You may need to go to the gastroenterologist for the evaluation for sure, particularly if you have alarm symptoms. But these are things that anybody can build into their everyday routine.
I know it doesn't sound super sexy. Where's the fancy magical food and supplement? But believe me when I tell you, Mel, I have done thousands of colonoscopies, seen thousands of patients in the 30-plus years since I graduated from medical school. These are the things that make a difference. The beautiful thing is you can see a difference quickly. You may not be able to reverse your autoimmune disease quickly if that's part of the goal. But in terms of that tangible return on investment that your gut is going to give you—when you sit down and you have that stool nirvana for the first time and you're like, "Damn, is this what it's supposed to feel like?"—I just detoxed in the most profound way.
Mel Robbins
I freaking love you. I feel so smart. And I literally want to go to the bathroom now and just enjoy having a poo.
Mel laughs
I would love, Dr. Robynne, for you to talk directly to the person listening. You have been so generous and have poured into us. There was so much that you taught us, that you equipped us to be able to do. If there was one thing that you really want them to remember, that they walk away and that they implement today, what would that be?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Eat more plants. Eat more plants. You don't have to be vegan or vegetarian or any of it. But plant fiber is the most important food for our gut microbiome. It doesn't mean there aren't other things that aren't helpful. It doesn't mean the other stuff you're eating is bad. But we have to feed our microbiome. We have to nourish and nurture it. We do that with plant fiber. Whether it's just a carrot stick as you're going out the door, an apple that you throw in your bag, or it's a more complicated lentil bowl—eat more plants.
Mel Robbins
You know, Dr. Robynne, I often remind everyone that some of the best people that you will meet, you haven't met yet. And I just love you. I feel like you literally walked into my life and we are going to be lifelong friends.
And for the record, you were already super smart before I walked in here. You already knew so much stuff. People need to understand how their body works. We're kind of alienated from our body, and we're really alienated from our gut. We don't even want to look in the toilet. I'm like, how can you not look in the toilet? It's like tea leaves. It's telling you something. This is really important evidence and feedback. You can't just flush it and ignore it.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
We do that because we still have this sort of Victorian sensibility about cleanliness and stool—it's dirty. So really understanding how this stuff works. For me, helping people to understand—and this is really the focus of the last book, *The Antiviral Gut*—that yes, our gut is a digestive organ and digestion is really important. But our gut is also a defensive organ.
Stomach acid isn't just there to digest food. It also kills pathogens. Our gut lining literally protects us from pathogens so that bacteria and viruses can't penetrate and get into our bloodstream and travel to the rest of our body. Our stool eliminates not just waste matter, but toxins. There's a huge defensive element to our gut. If we want to stay healthy, we've got to keep these defenses going. We've got to protect these defenses and understand them.
I'm so grateful to have a chance to come on and explain all this stuff.
Mel Robbins
I'm so grateful that you're here. The person that was listening to us didn't just feel smarter. They felt seen. They now understand themselves. And more importantly, you know what to do and you know why this can work and why it matters. That means somebody is going to try it.
The simplicity of it is also something that I really love because let's face it, we're all busy. If you can't fit it into your already crazy busy life, you're not doing it. If you can't remember it when you stop listening to the two of us, you're not going to be able to do it. If you can't share it with your friend who has irritable bowel syndrome or your son or daughter or your husband who has a problem with constipation, if you can't remember what to tell them and why it matters, you're not going to be able to help them.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Absolutely.
Mel Robbins
I so appreciate spending this time with you. I would sit next to you in a public bathroom with open stalls and chit-chat all day. So thank you. What are your parting words?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I want people to remember that when they have these symptoms in the GI tract—bloating, constipation, heartburn—so often these are not illnesses that are just falling out of the sky. This is your gut trying to communicate with you. It is "knock, knock."
In the case of heartburn, why did you have that porterhouse steak at 11 o'clock last night and the two glasses of red wine? You should have had that at one o'clock. Had a salad at night. It is your GI tract giving you feedback. Why is it giving you feedback? To keep you alive, to keep you healthy, to protect you, to try and prevent you from doing it again.
But what do we do? We don't listen. We just block acid and keep on going. Now, there are, of course, alarm signs—blood, severe pain, and so on. But most of the common symptoms—indigestion, constipation, the bloat—these things are your GI tract saying "knock, knock" and trying to communicate with you.
My whole goal is to translate this stuff, to basically teach people gut language. Let me tell you what your GI tract is saying and how you can respond. Once people do that, they don't need me. And that's the goal. I'm superfluous. I'll just see you at the farmer's market.
Mel Robbins
Hey, what's up?
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Or in a public bathroom.
Mel Robbins
Exactly. "Is that you, Dr. Robynne?"
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
You should not—if somebody is continuing to come and see me year after year after year, aside from chronic autoimmune diseases—it means I'm failing. I'm not doing my job. If I was seeing you for constipation 10 years ago and you're still constipated, you should fire me. I needed to have given you the tools. I needed to have translated for you so that you now speak "gut ease" and you understand and you know exactly what to do.
Mel Robbins
Dr. Robynne, thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And thank you for tuning in and for sharing this. I know you're going to share this with so many people in your life. Didn't you freaking love her?
And for the record, I would be next to you in a public bathroom stall talking off my whatever with you because I love you. I believe in you. What I'm so excited about is you now have world-class medical facts and understanding from literally the number one expert on this. So you can empower yourself from the inside out to activate the natural intelligence of your body. You now know all the health implications and how positive it is. So go do it.
Share this episode, please. And I can't wait to see you again soon. And three, two, one, action.
End of episode
Outtakes
I love it when she says that. I already feel like you're my new best friend.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
I already feel like you're my new best friend. A hundred percent.
Mel Robbins
Okay. Because we're going to talk for like five fucking hours.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Sympathetic, fight or flight. Parasympathetic, rest and digest. Yes.
Mel Robbins
Oh, wow. Starting today that will help you.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Oh my God.
Mel Robbins
Sorry.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Oh shit.
Mel Robbins
Okay. I got to go back up. I didn't realize that was in. Okay. So hold on. You're fucking amazing.
Dr. Robynne Chutkan
Oh my God. You guys.
Mel Robbins
Wow.
Legal disclaimer
Oh, and one more thing. And no, this is not a blooper. This is the legal language. You know, what the lawyers write and what I need to read to you. This podcast is presented solely for educational and entertainment purposes. I'm just your friend. I am not a licensed therapist. And this podcast is not intended as a substitute for the advice of a physician, professional coach, psychotherapist, or other qualified professional. Got it? Good. I'll see you in the next episode.
End of transcript