Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the ongoing trade war between the United States and China, focusing on the reasons behind the conflict and its potential consequences.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Additional Notes:
Music plays
Sean Rameswaram
Please buy our toothbrushes. No, that's, wait, I don't think we could say that.
Pause
Oh, really? No, that's, that's. That's not what this is about? That's like, that's begging.
Pause
Oh, I can't beg. No, it's just about like letting people know.
Pause
Oh. There's an option to go to getquip.com slash explained. Please know that we have toothbrushes.
Pause
How do you start a trade war? President Trump is going heavy metal tonight. He says he will impose tough new tariffs on imported steel and aluminum.
Pause
You start with tariffs. I am taking action to impose safeguard tariffs on imported residential washing machines and all solar products.
Pause
Then you express your feelings. The Chinese are saying that they are watching and waiting to see whether or not President Trump's threat turns into action. And if it does, they say they are ready to slug it out until the bitter end.
Pause
And then, of course, there's retaliation. Monday, China slapped back pork, soybeans, and other crops in the crosshairs.
Pause
From there, things can get kind of nasty. Beijing's promising it's ready for a fight after Donald Trump threatened another round of tariffs on $100 billion worth of goods from China.
Pause
So what happens when the two biggest economies in the world stop playing nice? This is Today Explained.
Pause
Okay, first things first, the entire trade war so far is hypothetical but that doesn't mean people aren't freaking out on Friday wall street staged one of its biggest single day drops this year as investors fled U.S stocks after president trump threatened more tariffs on chinese goods
Pause
President Donald Trump is sort of obsessed with Chinese trade. When the Chinese traders come in and they want to make great trade deals and they make the best trade deals and not anymore, because we can't continue to allow China to rape our country.
Pause
And that's what they're doing. His obsession has a lot to do with the trade gap between China and the United States. It's big. Like, China exports almost 400 billion dollars more worth of stuff to the United States big.
Pause
Everything's made in China for the most part. And frankly, they're sending stuff over here and we're paying for it. And, you know, it's sort of interesting.
Pause
Very little tax, if any, paid. But that's just what's happening in plain sight.
Pause
A specific concern that has been of longstanding is that Chinese companies violate American intellectual property.
Pause
Matthew Yglesias
Matthew Iglesias writes about economic policy at Vox. He says the president's even more worked up about the stuff that China's doing behind the scenes.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So there's two or three broad categories of stuff happening here one is counterfeit goods okay so there might be something and it says it's a north face jacket or it's a patagonia jacket but really it isn't it's just something else that came out of a chinese factory it's labeled wrong
Pause
If canal street has taught me anything it's that there is nothing we have that the chinese can't just make themselves. I mean, that's where I get all my fushi from.
Pause
A second thing that happens is just pirating of intellectual property content. You go to a Chinese market, you can see DVDs of Western movies for sale, boxes of Western computer software, often for very cheap, often without appropriate copyrights being paid.
Pause
Pirated DVDs. Look at this picture. These are DVDs that often appear right on the street corners of Shanghai and Zhengzhou, sometimes even before a show or a movie's release.
Pause
One entertainment industry watcher says Chinese theft of the U.S. entertainment properties has to be stopped.
Pause
Third, and sort of probably most significantly, American companies often feel pressured to bring Chinese managers into their operation when they go to China.
Pause
It'll be a sense that if you want to sell airplanes in China, you need to produce some through a joint venture with a Chinese company. And then there can be industrial espionage in which trade secrets are sort of stolen from the American factory.
Pause
The know-how is transferred to Chinese companies. It's important because it erodes America's sort of advantage in high-end type manufacturing.
Pause
You could also say, why is it in America's interest to even worry about this, right? I mean if an American company decides that it wants to offshore production to China because they going to save money by paying people less the fact that Chinese companies might steal their trade secrets that like a reason to not do that
Pause
A good reason to keep production back at home might be that you don't want your Chinese partners to rip you off. Obviously, American companies would like to have it both ways, right?
Pause
They would like to be able to locate all their factories where it's cheap but benefit from the American government's rules and protections.
Pause
At any rate, these are the three buckets of issues, trade secret theft, counterfeit products, and just sort of straight up illicit copying.
Pause
And so is this the real reason the trade war began, all this theft of American intellectual property?
Pause
So American governments from time immemorial have wanted China to stop this or change something. Encouraging China to play by international rules, I say again, is an important step toward a safer, saner world.
Pause
The Trump administration has not laid out an incredibly clear goal. It's not like we want you to do X and then we won't do it. It's like we want you to fix this problem or else we're going to have these tariffs.
Pause
So we'll see if that actually happens. Then the Chinese said, no, no, no. If you put these tariffs on us, we're going to put tariffs on your stuff, particularly soybeans, airplanes, some kinds of pharmaceuticals and possibly certain kinds of cars.
Pause
And why those specific things? Are those our major imports into China? Well, there's a mix of sort of motives that they have.
Pause
So U.S. agricultural products, I think, are attractive to the Chinese because they think that Trump needs to pay attention politically to what it is that American farmers think.
Pause
Airplanes is potent because there are only two companies in the world that make wide-body passenger airplanes, Boeing in the U.S. and Airbus in Europe.
Pause
So if you put a 25% tax on American airplanes, we're going to lose the whole Chinese market. Nobody is going to buy a Boeing plane if it costs 25% more than a European plane.
Pause
So that would be a big dramatic sort of problem that would catch people's attention.
Pause
Then they have a lot of niche goods, things like orange juice, certain kinds of liquor and luxury goods.
Pause
And what's the latest? China is threatening like over 100 US products. And the list has all kinds of things like pipes, pork, roasted macadamia nuts.
Pause
And it's different categories of business equipment essentially that are made in China. A lot of agricultural machinery is on the list. OK.
Pause
Tools that are used in American factories to build things. And so that's what was on the initial list. Now, Trump has said he wants to come up with a bigger list, right, so that if the Chinese retaliate, that he's going to retaliate with tariffs on twice as much stuff.
Pause
What might the practical realities of this trade war be if it starts to happen?
Pause
Matthew Yglesias
Yeah, I think if we go down the road that has been laid out by the American and Chinese governments, you are going to see most people probably OK, but people who have strong ties to agriculture suffering quite a bit.
Pause
And that's not just because you're a farmer, but if in the community that you live in, the secondary industries involve providing services to agriculture.
Pause
There should be quite a significant hit simply because the price of agricultural commodities will go down. And that tends to depress, you know, the whole economy in the Midwest and in other significant swaths of the country.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Brewing talk of a trade war with China could devastate rural voters who back Trump, providing an opening for vulnerable Democrats in red states.
Pause
A lot of these things that China says they're going to do seem like they'll affect Donald Trump's base, his peeps.
Pause
Matthew Yglesias
Yeah, I mean, it seems like a big goal of targeting American agricultural products is to try to impact the Republican Party, Donald Trump's base.
Pause
They've succeeded in getting a lot of Republican senators from farm states to be very critical of him. These tariffs are a terrible idea. Tariffs always hurt us.
Pause
Ultimately, nobody ever wins a trade war. Both sides lose a trade war.
Pause
This could cost him votes in Ohio where they grow a fair amount of soy, in Florida who has a significant citrus fruit industry that might be targeted here.
Pause
And that, you know, could be perilous to the president's political standing. That's not the kind of thing that's going to swing an election.
Pause
If the Chinese do hit American agriculture, that could be a significant problem for Republicans, both because it might cost Trump votes in rural areas.
Pause
It might cost Republicans votes in rural areas in the midterms. But it also could generate infighting inside the Republican coalition.
Pause
So far, Republicans in Congress have been very supportive of Trump on a whole range of ethics issues, you know, lots of stuff relating to his conduct.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah.
Pause
If farm state Republican senators get really mad at Trump and feel like they need to do something to try to change his behavior there a lot they could do to work with Democrats on oversight investigations things like that
Pause
So that could factor into Trump thinking
Pause
Up next, the last time the United States had a real trade war, it was straight up bananas. This is Today Explained.
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
Kainaz Amaria, visuals editor here at Vox. What kind of toothbrush do you use?
Pause
I have a mechanical toothbrush. Is it a Quip?
Pause
It is not yet. Are you happy with your brush?
Pause
I believe I am happy, but I could be convinced otherwise.
Pause
Can I tell you an issue I have with my current mechanical brush?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Sure.
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
Switching to Quip. Okay, okay, yeah. Once I'm done brushing, you know, sometimes there's like toothpaste coming down, you know, like some residual watery toothpaste mix, and it kind of like gets on the ridges of the brush.
Pause
Do you have to wash your toothbrush?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, actually, now that you mention it.
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
Seriously? Why didn't I mention that?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, my toothbrush, standalone toothbrush, as much as I love it, does sort of have toothpaste. The gunk. The gunk. You get the gunk.
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
Yeah, and so I do have to rinse the actual toothbrush every time I brush my teeth.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Wouldn't it be nice if there were a toothbrush that was like sleekly designed that didn't get gunky?
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
Oh my gosh, I completely fell into this trap.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, I would love that.
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
What if it started at just $25 and came with a free pack of refills?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, I would do that.
Pause
Kainaz Amaria
Oh my gosh. You know what you should do, Kataz? You should go to getquip.com slash explain.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I sold.
Pause
When was the last time we saw a good trade war, Matthew Iglesias, host of the Weeds podcast?
Pause
Matthew Yglesias
I think you really have to look back to the banana wars of the early George W. Bush years, in which the United States and the European Union were in a vicious battle with each other for control over banana markets.
Pause
It could be a spin doctor's nightmare on either side of the Atlantic if a row about selling bananas sparks a multi-billion dollar trade war.
Pause
There eventually were tariffs on American whiskey, some kinds of French wines.
Pause
I believe there were allegations about unpasteurized soft cheeses and whether that was really a health measure or a covert trade measure.
Pause
And it got quite comical. It didn't really impact people in a concrete way, though.
Pause
China is a—this is a bigger deal.
Pause
Has there been a trade war that wasn't laughable?
Pause
Oh, yeah. The banana wars of the early 21st century were mostly funny.
Pause
Yeah. To see really large-scale trade war, right?
Pause
What people worry about, the sort of big apocalyptic scenario, is what you saw in the late 1920s and early 1930s where one country after another would put tariffs on the rest of the world to say, well, we need to protect our domestic industries.
Pause
Each country just kept putting higher and higher taxes up on foreign imports. And the end result of that was that everybody was paying more for everything.
Pause
It was just a sort of overall big negative hit to the world economy.
Pause
And it took decades of sort of careful diplomatic work to reopen the basic bounds of trade that had been disrupted by that depression era sort of trade war.
Pause
So that would be the really bad scenario.
Pause
They created an organization after that big Second World War we had to deal with this kind of thing, right?
Pause
Yes. It was originally the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. It's now the World Trade Organization. The WTO.
Pause
The WTO. WTO. The WTO now has fingers in a lot of pies, but the basic idea of the WTO is to say that these things should be governed by a big meeting of a lot of countries altogether through something resembling a legal or a diplomatic process rather than each country going off on its own, sort of firing shots.
Pause
What makes people a little queasy about what Trump is doing here and what he did earlier on the steel and aluminum is that he's going outside the boundaries of that process and invoking powers that he has under older pieces of legislation in a somewhat ad hoc way.
Pause
Is China playing by the rules with the WTO?
Pause
No. I mean they have signed commitments to crack down on intellectual property theft.
Pause
OK. Intellectual property theft continues to happen in China. Now, something they will tell you, right is like we have laws We are up to our WTO compliance We can be held responsible for the fact that some people break the law
Pause
Now Americans say back at them like look you have this authoritarian political system If you didn't want factories making counterfeit clothing, like, you could put a stop to it.
Pause
What's clearly true is that since American companies keep being willing to put factories in China, the Chinese government is not that concerned about them getting ripped off.
Pause
What would really make the Chinese worry about protecting intellectual property is if companies were saying, no, we're not going to invest here.
Pause
We're not going to use your suppliers here. We're not going to try to play in your market because we're concerned about getting ripped off.
Pause
But the attraction of China, both the size of the client base you could reach by selling things to China and the advantages to producing in China are so big that American companies keep wanting to put their facilities there even though they are at risk of loss of trade secrets, loss of control of their copyrights.
Pause
And to me, that's the fundamental issue, right?
Pause
If you don't want the Chinese to be able to steal your production methods, you have to not put your factories in China.
Pause
But companies really want to put their factories in China.
Pause
President Trump, more so than like any president in my lifetime, has really villainized China.
Pause
Yes. and is constantly complaining as far as i can tell about their dodgy trade practices and and tactics is he right um because you're saying they're constantly ripping stuff off and and plagiarizing and and falsifying and stealing like does is he is he just the first person to come out and say it in a long time
Pause
I think he's the first person to fully embrace the critical view of china that some American companies have, right?
Pause
If you talk to different American business people, you get very different views about China depending on what line of business they're in and how it is that they feel about it.
Pause
There's also, I think, real disagreement about what cheating means.
Pause
On the metal stuff, a lot of people, I talk to anyone in the American steel industry, Canadian steel industry, European steel industry, they'll all tell you, look, the real problem here is the Chinese, they're cheating.
Pause
So what are the Chinese doing with steel? Well, they're producing a ton of steel. Lots and lots and lots of steel come inside of Chinese factories.
Pause
And it's cheaper? And it's making the price of steel on the world market really low.
Pause
So foreign steel producers want them to stop doing that.
Pause
I, though, you know, I don't work in a steel factory. But I do live in a house. I work in an office building. I buy stuff that's made of metal.
Pause
To me, like, is it so bad that the Chinese are coming in here and giving us all this cheap steel so that we can have cool buildings and drive cars and stuff like that?
Pause
Is that really cheating or is that progress?
Pause
Nobody likes it when somebody else comes in and undercuts them on price. It's really easy to understand why that makes the people who compete with Chinese metal producers unhappy.
Pause
The question of what's fair and unfair, I find a little bit challenging to sort of get my mind around, right?
Pause
And I mean, the big accusation against the Chinese on the trade front over the past 20 years has been that they are providing Americans with discount manufactured goods.
Pause
And that just doesn't sound that bad fundamentally.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Matthew Iglesias is a co-founder of Vox.
Pause
I'm Sean Ramos from this is Today Explained.
Pause
You can find our show on Twitter at today underscore explained.
Pause
Just to be clear, I did not think this conversation would go this way.
Pause
Really?
Pause
Yeah. You didn't think I would sell you on this?
Pause
I thought I was fine.
Pause
Yeah. Yeah. The design is all like metal-y, and I think you could just wipe anything off right quick.
Pause
I'm a sucker for good design.
Pause
You are?
Pause
I'm a visuals editor.
Pause
You're speaking my language.
Pause
Yes.
Pause
When's your birthday?
Pause
July 4th.
Pause
That's coming up.
Pause
It is.
Pause
So maybe I can get you one for your birthday.
Pause
Do I have to wait that long?
Pause
I feel like I can just...
Pause
You can give me an early birthday gift.
Pause
Sure.
Pause
You know, my birthday just passed.
Pause
Oh, happy belated.
Pause
And maybe as a belated gift. Okay, so I'll buy you.
Pause
Did you just sucker me into buying you a toothbrush?
Pause
But I'll buy you one too.
Pause
All right. It's really reciprocal.
Pause
Let's do it.
Pause
Hey, Kynas, thanks.
Pause
Thank you, Sean.
Pause
Oh, getquip.com slash explain. That's where we have to go.
Pause
Yes.