Main Topic: The Supreme Court's decision on the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which affects the lives of hundreds of thousands of undocumented immigrants who came to the United States as children.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Short pause
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com
Short pause
Ian Millhiser, you cover the Supreme Court for Vox. We spoke on Monday about a historic LGBTQ decision, and I ended the interview by saying, Ian, I hope the next time there's a major decision from SCOTUS, the construction will be done. Is the construction done outside your apartment?
Ian Millhiser
Yeah, the good news is that whatever my neighbors are doing, they seem to have finished. God bless.
Sean Rameswaram
OK, so let's talk about yet another historic decision from the Supreme Court. Is it historic? I don't know. It seems like a big deal. It is a very big deal in terms of the human impact. But I mean, frankly, I think the Supreme Court had no business hearing the case.
Ian Millhiser
The holding of today's decision is that the Trump administration's decision to end the DACA program, a program that protects several hundred thousand undocumented immigrants who came to the United States as children, that that rescission of that program is invalid because of a paperwork error.
Sean Rameswaram
Oh. Because the Trump administration did not file the right kind of memo when they decided to end the program.
Ian Millhiser
So the Supreme Court just said, hey, you guys didn't dot your I's and cross your T's? Pretty much. I mean, what they said is that whenever an executive branch agency wants to implement a new policy, even if it's a policy that they're allowed to do, they have to explain their decision why. And they have to provide a pretty full explanation of why they did what they did.
Sean Rameswaram
And the Supreme Court just looked at the memo that the Trump administration wrote explaining why it wanted to get rid of DACA and said this isn't good enough. You didn't explain why you're going to take nearly 700,000 people and you're going to suddenly make them subject to deportation. You didn't explain why all these people who have relied on the fact that they have DACA status, who have gotten married, who have gotten jobs, who have gotten degrees, all these people who are paying potentially billions of dollars in taxes, you did not adequately explain why you're going to take this away.
Ian Millhiser
And I will note, because this is very important, this doesn't mean that DACA is safe. If the Trump administration does its homework properly the next time, they can still get rid of DACA. But for the meantime, DACA stands basically because of incompetence, because the Trump administration didn't do what it needed to do to explain its decision.
Sean Rameswaram
And beyond that, this still wasn't a unanimous decision. This wasn't 9-zip. This was 5-4. So clearly there's more here to unpack. So let's unpack, starting with just winding back a little bit. So DACA is the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program that started under the Obama administration. What happens when Trump comes to office?
Ian Millhiser
So a lot of this goes back to 2016. In 2016, the Supreme Court heard a case involving a program called DAPA and then an expansion of the DACA program, which were efforts by President Obama to allow a larger group of undocumented immigrants to live in the country and to continue to work here.
Sean Rameswaram
This was after Scalia's death. So the Supreme Court had only eight members and the court split evenly. And we're pretty sure it was along party lines with all of the Republicans saying that it had to fall and all the Democrats saying that DAPA could stay.
Ian Millhiser
And so a lot of people feared that now that there's a Republican majority on the Supreme Court there would be five votes to say that DACA which is very similar to DAPA also had to fall. What wound up happening instead is at least the majority just didn't go there. The majority relied entirely on this extraordinarily narrow ground that well the Trump administration didn't file the right paperwork.
Sean Rameswaram
So if they want to get rid of DACA they have to go back and file the correct paperwork.
Ian Millhiser
The thing that stood out at oral argument is that Roberts, who is the George W. Bush appointee who crossed over to vote with his liberal colleagues in this case, at oral arguments, he seemed really concerned that DACA might be illegal. He seemed to think that it would give the president too much power if the president had the power to create the DACA program in the first place.
Sean Rameswaram
And so I think there was legitimate fears that Roberts was going to go the other way and potentially that he might strike down DACA altogether forever.
Ian Millhiser
Joe Biden can't bring it back forever. And what happened instead, of course, is that Roberts didn't do it. He decided to see the case narrowly. And so this question of whether DACA is legal in the first place still remains an open question that has not been resolved by the Supreme Court.
Sean Rameswaram
What about the dissenters here? I'm guessing what Kavanaugh, Gorsuch, Alito and Thomas. Why were they not concerned that this wasn't the right paperwork, that the I's weren't dotted and the T's weren't crossed?
Ian Millhiser
So there were several different dissents. The primary dissent was written by Justice Thomas. And Thomas basically said this has always been illegal. DACA couldn't exist in the first place. So it's an absurdity to say that Trump couldn't get rid of a program that has always been illegal.
Sean Rameswaram
Kavanaugh wrote a separate dissent where he took, I guess, a more moderate view.
Ian Millhiser
What Kavanaugh said is, look, the fact that basically he said the fact that we would strike this down over a paperwork error is silly. So, you know, he seemed to think that there weren't strong reasons why the administration should have to provide the full explanation that the majority demanded.
Sean Rameswaram
Alito had like a one-page dissent where he said it's bad that this case has been pending for a long time and it started with a single district court handing down a decision.
Ian Millhiser
And that, you know, basically it's bad that while this case was in limbo, the Trump administration wasn't able to do anything.
Sean Rameswaram
Where does this leave dreamers for the time being, the people who this program was created for? The answer is it leads them in a pretty precarious place.
Ian Millhiser
So again, the holding of the Supreme Court today was that the Trump administration didn't file the right paperwork and they could potentially file the right paperwork tomorrow. And if they do file the right paperwork tomorrow, it's likely that the court's going to say, yeah, that's fine.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, the court said explicitly that Trump does have the power to get rid of DACA if he wants to. He just has to do it the right way.
Ian Millhiser
Now, if the Trump administration decides that it wants to take a second crack at getting rid of DACA, it's likely there's going to be another round of litigation. There could be new injunctions from lower courts, and those injunctions could potentially push this until past the election.
Sean Rameswaram
And so maybe it becomes moot if Donald Trump is no longer president in a year.
Ian Millhiser
But for as long as Donald Trump is president of the United States, he can try to get rid of DACA and there's a good chance he'll succeed.
Sean Rameswaram
And even if he doesn't try to get rid of DACA, again, the question of whether DACA was legal in the first place, the question of whether President Obama had the power to create DACA has not been resolved by the Supreme Court.
Ian Millhiser
So there is still a danger that the Supreme Court will turn around and strike down DACA because they say that DACA itself is illegal.
Sean Rameswaram
So what's the president said about this? If this all comes down to Donald Trump right now, has he weighed in on the decision from the Supreme Court?
Ian Millhiser
He sent out a tweet where he said that he doesn't think that the Supreme Court likes him very much.
Sean Rameswaram
And like, I actually think he's on to something. I mean, I don't think it's that the justices personally dislike Donald Trump is the explanation for this.
Ian Millhiser
But I think that Chief Justice Roberts, I think what sets him aside from the other four Republican appointees on the court is that Roberts cares about procedural regularity. He believes that things need to be done in a certain way.
Sean Rameswaram
And we saw this last term in the census case and we saw it again this term in the DACA case that when the administration is incompetent and it doesn't follow the proper paperwork requirements it doesn't provide a proper explanation for what it's doing Roberts is willing to say because you didn't follow the procedural rules correctly we're not going to let you do what you tried to do.
Ian Millhiser
What comes next for the dreamers after a quick break?
Sean Rameswaram
I'm Sean Rameswaram for him. This is Today Explained.
Theme music fades in
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards. These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars. But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head. Not anymore, says Built Rewards.
Short pause
Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Bilt, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more.
Short pause
Your home isn't just where you sleep. It's your community. And Bilt wants you to go out and do things in the community. You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Bilt members every month.
Short pause
When you're ready to travel, they say Bilt points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining Bilt.com slash Explained.
Short pause
That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash Explained.
Short pause
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to.
Short pause
Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one.
Short pause
You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Theme music fades out
Nicole Norea, you cover immigration for Vox. When President Obama created the DACA program in 2012. He said that it wasn't a permanent fix. What is the permanent fix here?
Nicole Norea
So for the better part of almost two decades now, lawmakers have been trying to get the DREAM Act passed, and that would offer permanent protections to DREAMers, offering them a path to citizenship for the most part.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's been sort of the subject of contentious legislative debate for years, but never really mustered enough support to pass.
Nicole Norea
It was part of a big legislative package in 2013. It was supposed to be a massive immigration reform bill, but that failed in Congress.
Sean Rameswaram
And even though public support remains really strong for the DACA program and for Dreamers, it just hasn't been able to get passed in Congress.
Nicole Norea
How strong is public support for DACA, for Dreamers? It's pretty overwhelming among all different sections of voters.
Sean Rameswaram
Even almost 70 percent of Trump voters support DREAMers and don't want them to be deported.
Nicole Norea
But unfortunately, Republicans often want to use DREAMers as a bargaining chip to kind of beef up border security and enact some restrictionist immigration agendas.
Sean Rameswaram
So whenever the DREAM Act has sort of come up in Congress, they've always attempted to sort of tack on funding for President Trump's border wall, for example, leaving the negotiations kind of stalled.
Nicole Norea
I mean, the president is currently beefing up border security and reducing drastically immigration into the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
Has that neutralized the issue of DREAMers at all? It doesn't seem to because I guess Republicans know that Democrats really want these protections for DACA recipients.
Nicole Norea
And it is one of the few issues on which there is some sort of bipartisan consensus. So they know that now controlling the Senate, they can sort of use these dreamers as a bargaining chip to enact broader restrictions on immigration just because this proposal is so widely popular.
Sean Rameswaram
As Ian sort of explained in the first half of the show, President Trump now has a very clear idea of how exactly he can get the Supreme Court to rule in his favor on DACA. Do we have any idea if he'll pursue that? Do we know what exactly he's been up to on immigration lately and what that might suggest for what he might do now that we have this decision from the Supreme Court?
Nicole Norea
So Trump just tweeted this morning actually that he is asking for a legal solution on DACA not a political one And because the Supreme Court is quote unquote not willing to give him one he now wants to start the process all over again.
Sean Rameswaram
It's very unclear what that means, whether he might be considering issuing an executive order or having the Department of Homeland Security put out a memo or even going through the rulemaking process to terminate DACA.
Nicole Norea
But the thing is, that process could take a long time and possibly extend far beyond the presidential election or the inauguration in January 2020.
Sean Rameswaram
But the president hasn't concluded that maybe it's time to actually pass legislation to get the DREAM Act codified into the law.
Nicole Norea
I mean, I think he's sort of left that up to Senate Republicans And Mitch McConnell has said that he doesn't want to bring any legislation to the floor.
Sean Rameswaram
There are circumstances under which I and others would be happy to support that. But we need to do more than that. You know, there's some genuine fixes on the legal immigration side and on the illegal immigration side that need to be addressed.
Nicole Norea
He's sitting on right now what's called the Dream and Promise Act. And that was a House Democrat led proposal.
Sean Rameswaram
And that was passed now almost a year ago. and he has said he doesn't want to bring it to a vote.
Nicole Norea
So at this point, it's stalled in the Senate and the ball is kind of in Mitch McConnell's court.
Sean Rameswaram
And just more concretely, if you're a dreamer in the United States right now and you run into ICE somewhere, are you protected or are you in some place of legal limbo where you could get deported?
Nicole Norea
No, ICE can't deport DACA recipients now because they do have legal status.
Sean Rameswaram
If Trump is eventually able to go forward with ending the program, that means that their legal status would expire or terminate.
Nicole Norea
And then, only then, would they be potentially eligible for deportation. And the Trump administration has made clear that if that's the case, they do intend to deport DACA recipients.
Sean Rameswaram
It's not even clear, though, how the Trump administration could carry out that agenda just because immigration enforcement resources are already overstrained.
Nicole Norea
Trump is already enacting restrictions on the border and beefing up border security in a way that's really monopolizing their resources.
Sean Rameswaram
So this is a threat that the Trump administration has made. But even if it comes to pass that DACA is eliminated, it's not clear how just at least in practice they would be able to carry out deportations on a mass scale.
Nicole Norea
What about all the people who are applying for DACA, people who are trying to become dreamers? So it's still an open question what happens to all these people who would qualify for the DACA program.
Sean Rameswaram
There's almost 66,000 of them who have been waiting to apply since 2017 when new applications to the program were shut down amid litigation.
Nicole Norea
So it's likely, or at least some legal experts are saying, that they should be able to apply for those protections now.
Sean Rameswaram
And the Attorney General of California, Xavier Becerra, has said that he intends to fight for that.
Nicole Norea
So hopefully the program will become open to new applications and those people who were previously shut out will be able to get protection.
Sean Rameswaram
It feels like at this point, like, limbo might be the only setting that the dreamers know. Where does this decision today leave them exactly? Is it exactly where they were yesterday?
Nicole Norea
It definitely is cost to celebrate. And I know a lot of dreamers are floored and surprised by this decision.
Sean Rameswaram
It definitely gives them some assurance, at least for the immediate moment, that they will maintain their legal status, that they won't lose their jobs because their work authorization is tied to their legal status, and that they will be able to remain in this country that is, for many of them, the only country they've ever known for the immediate future.
Nicole Norea
But they know that this isn't a permanent fix and that Trump can still move forward with ending the program, especially if he gets reelected.
Sean Rameswaram
So that's why they're really pushing for permanent protections enshrined in law through the Dream and Promise Act or some other Dream Act adjacent legislation that would give them a path to citizenship.
Nicole Norea
Nicole, thanks so much for your time. Appreciate it.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks.
Theme music fades in
I'm Sean Rameswaram for Today Explained.