Main Topic: The impact of artificial intelligence (AI) on the internet and copyright law, specifically the case of Anthropic's AI tool, Claude, and its use of copyrighted works without permission.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram, and I'm here with Jason Kebler, tech reporter and co-founder of 404 Media.
Jason Kebler
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, we're talking about the latest development in the world of artificial intelligence. AI is scraping the internet, and it's causing a big problem for authors, artists, and musicians. We're going to dive into the details of a recent lawsuit and what it means for the future of the internet.
Jason Kebler
That's right. I'm very interested in this topic, both as a journalist who covers AI and as someone who has a direct financial interest in it.
Sean Rameswaram
So, let's start with the lawsuit. There was a decision in a case against Anthropic, which makes the AI tool called Claude. What happened in this case?
Jason Kebler
Well, three authors sued Anthropic, claiming that they built a multi-billion dollar business by misusing copyrighted works and pirated writings without permission and without paying the authors for their work.
Sean Rameswaram
And what was the outcome of the lawsuit?
Jason Kebler
The judge essentially handed down a split decision, saying that yes, this is fair use to use these authors' work this way, but also it wasn't totally fair how you got this stuff because it was pirated.
Sean Rameswaram
So, what does that mean? Does everyone go home unhappy or was this like a huge win for Anthropic?
Jason Kebler
I don't think it's a huge win for anyone yet. And I think that the people who are saying this is a slam dunk for Anthropic, which many people in the AI world are saying it's a huge win for Anthropic, I think they're wrong.
Sean Rameswaram
What do you mean?
Jason Kebler
Well, the judge determined essentially that it was not copyright infringement to train Claude on copyrighted material that was legally obtained. But then they also downloaded books from this website called LibGen, which is a piracy website that has millions of books on it. And the judge said that obtaining the books in this way was pretty much like cut and dry copyright infringement.
Sean Rameswaram
And what does this mean for the future of AI and the internet?
Jason Kebler
I think the piracy aspect of this is really important. And we've seen in the past, like, if you are a 13-year-old kid who's pirating Metallica songs on Napster, like, you can be liable for hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of damage. And in this case, you have 7 million books.
Sean Rameswaram
That's a lot of books. And what about the companies that are training on these copyrighted works? Do they have a plan to make money off of this?
Jason Kebler
Obviously, they want to make money. Has anyone asked what their long-term plan is?
Sean Rameswaram
So, let's talk about the impact of AI on the internet. John Herman is a tech columnist at New York Magazine. John, welcome to the show.
John Herman
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
So, John, you've written about how AI has broken the internet as we know it. Can you explain what you mean by that?
John Herman
Well, I think what's happening is that AI is consuming the internet in a way that's making it less useful for humans. Google, for example, is becoming more and more AI-centric, and that's making it harder for people to find what they're looking for.
Sean Rameswaram
And what about the impact on media companies? How are they being affected by this shift?
John Herman
Well, media companies are struggling to adapt to the new reality of the internet. They're trying to find new ways to make money, but it's not easy.
Sean Rameswaram
And what about the future of the internet? Do you think we're heading towards a world where AI is the dominant force, and humans are just along for the ride?
John Herman
I think that's a possibility. I think we're heading towards a world where AI is the dominant force, and humans are just trying to keep up.
Sean Rameswaram
That's a scary thought. Thanks for joining us, John.
John Herman
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's it for today's show. Thanks for listening.
End of episode
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Jason Kebler
Yeah, I mean, I think that the piracy aspect of this is really important. And we've seen in the past, like, if you are a 13-year-old kid who's pirating Metallica songs on Napster, like, you can be liable for hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of damage.
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Upwork. If you run a business, you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time.
Jason Kebler
And I think that the people who are saying this is a slam dunk for Anthropic, which many people in the AI world are saying it's a huge win for Anthropic, I think they're wrong.
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Shopify. Running a business comes with a lot of what-ifs. But luckily, there's a simple answer to them. Shopify.
John Herman
I think what's happening is that AI is consuming the internet in a way that's making it less useful for humans.
Sean Rameswaram
Today Explained is back with John Herman now. He's a tech columnist at New York Magazine.
John Herman
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
In the first half of the show, we're talking about how this Anthropic case and judgment may or may not change the extent to which these big AI models can scrape the internet.
John Herman
Well, I think what's happening is that AI is consuming the internet in a way that's making it less useful for humans.
Sean Rameswaram
Google could not be closer to the center of like this recent AI boom. On one hand, they are a company that has really deep roots in that space.
John Herman
They published like the foundational research for what then became generative AI as we know it. They've put it in all their products.
Sean Rameswaram
If you use any Google thing, you are seeing like chatbots everywhere. Take notes with Gemini. Summarize this file. Summarize a folder.
John Herman
Google Search in particular has AI overviews at the top. There's a new AI search mode that works like a chatbot instead of a search engine.
Sean Rameswaram
Google making a rare change to its homepage, the most visited website in the world. Pushing its AI mode tool directly into the hands of its billions of users.
John Herman
With this latest move, it is changing what billions of people see when they open their browser, still the on-ramp for the entire internet. Meet AI mode.
Sean Rameswaram
Ask detailed questions for better responses. AI on Google search can provide information.
John Herman
While that was all happening, AI was also sort of accelerating this feeling of decline in the Google product, which over the years, through this back-and-forth battle between the company and search engine optimizers and companies trying to get an edge on Google and this sort of long-running dynamic had become a little spammy, a little overloaded with ads.
Sean Rameswaram
Have you noticed that Google sucks lately? I'm talking about their search. It sucks.
John Herman
Why is it so hard to find anything on Google search? Google search is terrible. It's bought and it's sold five or six links up top, all paid for. It's just garbage, pure, unadulterated garbage.
Sean Rameswaram
But I think a lot of people would agree that using Google in, say, 2023 was a kind of a degraded experience compared to 10 years prior.
John Herman
It was kind of cluttered. There was more just junk in it. There were more ads all over the interface, but also the stuff you were getting in search was a lot of low-quality, cheaply made, aggregated content, stuff that was taken from somewhere else in an effort to sell a product or just serve up some ads.
Sean Rameswaram
The arrival of generative AI tools, which enable like the creation of basically infinite passable content almost for free, really accelerated that issue.
John Herman
So on one side, you have the big ecosystem that Google guides people to that is in a sort of collapse because of this massive shock of new AI-generated content.
Sean Rameswaram
On the other side, you have Google the product becoming more and more AI-centric.
John Herman
And in the middle, you have kind of a complicated story. And honestly, for search users and regular people, kind of a strange experience.
Sean Rameswaram
Do they have a plan to make money off of this? Obviously, they want to make money.
John Herman
Has anyone asked what their long-term plan is?
Sean Rameswaram
So, there are obvious risks to throwing away this like cluttered but lucrative product and replacing it with a totally clean chatbot or whatever. That's not what they're doing.
John Herman
They are incorporating AI answers into the main search page, which they say people like quite a bit.
Sean Rameswaram
So this last quarter has been really good for them.
John Herman
It also arrived in the context of lots of like really strong data suggesting that the way people use Google search now with these AI tools means that they don't really leave it anymore.
Sean Rameswaram
They don't really click out and go to anything. An AI overview might summarize three articles, archival resource, some expert opinions.
John Herman
But the number of people that actually then click through to those opinions or to those articles is minuscule.
Sean Rameswaram
So Google's relationship to the web around it is pretty dramatically different.
John Herman
If Google's like eating up the rest of the internet, if Gemini is eating up the rest of the internet right now, and companies like ours, let's say, are no longer, you know, meeting their traffic goals, are no longer getting any traffic from Google at all, like does Gemini have like nothing to eat?
Sean Rameswaram
You know what I mean? Because everything dies?
John Herman
Who's going to be feeding Gemini all the right answers in like 10 years?
Sean Rameswaram
We're sort of like glorifying the web a bit in this conversation no matter how great and incredible it is as this as this big resource it really doesn't go that deep and the idea that it is now being sort of like trawled and and overfished and just sort of consumed like a resource by these ai companies really does i think raise the specter of like of collapse
John Herman
I do think that they could find that their products are being made worse by this dynamic and by their relationship with the web. I do think that's a real problem.
Sean Rameswaram
And you can see this in some of the deals that these companies make with publishers, including our parent company, which has a deal with OpenAI, for example.
John Herman
Remind people out there, or me, why companies like ours make deals with companies like ChatGPT.
Sean Rameswaram
The context is every media company is struggling for visitors. Even before the Google traffic really started to collapse, it was sort of unstable.
John Herman
And so in addition to like a weak advertising market, every media company is looking for any sort of additional source of revenue.
Sean Rameswaram
And if you're a media executive, OpenAI showing up and saying, here is this many millions of dollars for this many years, it looks like free money.
John Herman
Of course, if you're like producing the content or if you're even just thinking longer term about how a media company or website fits into this AI picture, you recognize that you're sort of, you know, giving access away to something that these companies are explicitly trying to automate.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, you're sort of like in an institutional sense training your replacement.
John Herman
You're listening to AI Explains today.
Sean Rameswaram
But it is a deal made not quite under duress, but something close to that.
John Herman
For people who miss that old version of the Internet, who miss going to Google, typing in a query, getting a bunch of results, clicking on a few of them, getting answers that felt credible.
Sean Rameswaram
Where do they go for that experience?
John Herman
I think there's like a funny polarized answer to this. I just did a story on Reddit, which is having a huge moment right now.
Sean Rameswaram
It's been around for 20 years. It's growing hugely.
John Herman
And part of it is just a response to, you know, social media fatigue, the sense that other communities on the web don't really exist anymore, that everything else on the web is too commercial and whatever.
Sean Rameswaram
Also, a huge part of that growth is just traffic from Google. They're having the fastest growth they've had in almost their entire existence because Google is just shoveling so many people into Reddit because everything else is not really, like, working.
John Herman
So you have that. You have a community of communities. You have something that feels kind of like it's of the old web.
Sean Rameswaram
It seems like eventually we're going to get to the point where it's like you either want to talk to one of these large language models or you just go back to, like, calling up your friend.
John Herman
I don't even know where it gets. You just walk into the street and yell, does anyone know of a good barber?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, I mean, it's like a real, the mutual suspicion about who's using AI is really pervasive, and especially online, but also in person.
John Herman
But yeah, I do think that the way that the AI training paradigm and some of the stuff that you were talking about with Anthropic, but also just the way that Google incorporates all this stuff, it really does kind of break the deal with the whole idea of the public web.
Sean Rameswaram
Like, all right, we'll all just do this stuff in public. We'll talk to each other. People will build all these businesses around this to sort of connect everything. And it'll all sort of work together and whatever.
John Herman
When you have like these massive sort of predatory companies just consuming all of that, harvesting all of that and saying, all right, we are no longer part of this arrangement. We are doing something else.
Sean Rameswaram
More people are on Discord. More people are in group chats. More people are either just purely consuming on social networks and not posting or just talking privately with their friends.
John Herman
And I do think that this fits quite well with that trend and probably accelerates it.
Sean Rameswaram
John Herman. You can read and subscribe to New York Magazine at nymag.com.
John Herman
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's it for today's show. Thanks for listening.
End of episode
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Support for Today Explained comes from Upwork. If you run a business, you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time.
Support for Today Explained comes from Shopify. Running a business comes with a lot of what-ifs. But luckily, there's a simple answer to them. Shopify.
Today Explained is a production of Vox.