Main Topic: The historically tight relationship between the United States and Israel is shifting, with some American politicians questioning the future of the alliance.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Noel King
And I'm Noel King.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, we're talking about an arms deal between the United States and Israel that's drawing criticism from Democrats. It's part of a shifting tide in the American approach to the Israel-Palestine conflict.
Noel King
That's right. And we're joined by Alex Cain, a reporter who writes about Israel and Palestine for Jewish Currents, 972 Magazine, and The Intercept.
Alex Cain
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
So, let's start with this arms deal. The Biden administration approved a $735 million sale of bombs to Israel, which are being used in the current conflict. How did you guys discover this deal?
Alex Cain
I cannot reveal my sources, but I will say when news of the transmission from the State Department to Congress broke on Saturday, Sunday amongst lawmakers and staffers who work on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, there was a lot of chatter and a lot of deliberations between those parties and private conversations taking place on how to privately apply pressure on the administration.
Noel King
And what was the reaction from lawmakers and staffers?
Alex Cain
The positions amongst progressive Democrats range on what exactly they wanted to do about this deal. I think some were talking about just privately applying pressure on Tony Blinken to use the deal as leverage to call for a ceasefire. Others wanted the deal halted altogether.
Sean Rameswaram
And how did you catch wind of it?
Alex Cain
I caught wind of it through sources who relayed some of those private conversations. And by Sunday night, we had our story ready to go and confirmed by several congressional aides who work on this issue on a consistent basis, who had also given us details of those exact bombs that were going to be sold to Israel and approved by the Biden administration.
Noel King
And what kind of bombs are we talking about?
Alex Cain
These are kits that transform so-called dumb bombs into precision-guided missiles, and then guided bomb units, which are shorthand called GBU-39s, both of which are used against Palestinians.
Sean Rameswaram
Just to be clear, this deal is not a reaction to the escalating violence we're seeing. This was something that predated this violence.
Alex Cain
Yeah, and that's a really good point. Boeing applied for this license in November of 2020, according to State Department sources. And also, it's a commercial deal, we should note. But deals over a certain price tag, this one, $735 million, do require congressional approval or at least congressional review.
Noel King
And what's the reaction been from lawmakers and the public?
Alex Cain
The reactions definitely varied, and we didn't see much reaction at all from Republicans. But progressive Democrats and even, again, some lawmakers who have been staunch supporters of Israel and defenders of the Netanyahu government called for more scrutiny of this deal.
Sean Rameswaram
And what's the significance of this deal in the broader context of the Israel-Palestine conflict?
Alex Cain
I think this deal is going to increase scrutiny of deals with Israel when it comes to munition supplies going forward. It's not universal condemnation, though. I'm sure some people are fully in support of arms deals like these that have certainly predated this one.
Noel King
And how does this fit into the broader shift in the American approach to the Israel-Palestine conflict?
Alex Cain
Well, I think this shift has been developing over the past decade or so. It started with the end of the George W. Bush administration and the beginning of the Barack Obama administration. There was pretty unstinting support for Israel, but then there were a few key moments that really shifted the conversation.
Sean Rameswaram
Can you walk us through those moments?
Alex Cain
Sure. So, one of the key moments was when Israel bombed Gaza in 2008 and 2009. That was a really devastating conflict that killed over 1,400 people, mostly civilians. And it was televised 24-7, which really brought the issue to the forefront of the American consciousness.
Noel King
And how did that impact the conversation in the US?
Alex Cain
Well, it really grew the student activism movement calling for divestment from corporations that did business with the Israeli military. And that was part of the global boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement that Palestinian civil society had called for.
Sean Rameswaram
And how has the Republican Party responded to this shift in the conversation?
Alex Cain
Well, the Republican Party has actually become more pro-Israel over the past few decades. They've been influenced by white Christian evangelicals and massive donations from people like Sheldon Adelson.
Noel King
And what's the significance of this shift in the Republican Party's stance on Israel?
Alex Cain
I think it's really important because it's a shift away from the bipartisan consensus that we used to have on Israel. Now, we're seeing a partisan split between Democrats and Republicans, and even within the Democratic Party, a split between progressives and the establishment.
Sean Rameswaram
And what does this mean for the future of US policy on Israel and Palestine?
Alex Cain
I think it means that there's going to be more debate and more disagreement about US policy on Israel and Palestine. And that's healthy, because people's lives are at stake.
Noel King
Alex Cain, thanks for joining us on the show.
Alex Cain
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's it for today's show. Thanks for listening.
Noel King
If you want to learn more about the Israel-Palestine conflict and the shift in the American approach, check out our episode on the history of the conflict.
Sean Rameswaram
And if you want to support our show, you can make a financial contribution to Vox.
Noel King
Thanks for listening, and we'll see you tomorrow.
Theme music fades in