Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode, hosted by Sean, explores the topic of Antifa, a decentralized movement that opposes fascism and far-right ideologies. The conversation is facilitated by Zach Beecham, a Vox senior correspondent, who appears as a mental projection in Sean's brain.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from the FIFA World Cup, of all things. The FIFA World Cup 26 is coming to North America next summer. It is the ultimate celebration of sports and culture. You can get closer to the beautiful game with a hospitality package, closer to the action, the best seats, the best suites, closer to match day and that world-class food and that world-class entertainment, closer to the experience of a lifetime. Book a hospitality package at fifaworldcup.com slash hospitality. And listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Pause
Oof, long day today. Let me sit down and relax and watch some television. When the president said that he was designating Antifa as a terrorist organization, the question...
Pause
With looters ransacking businesses and torching cars and buildings, President Trump has vowed to take action and designate Antifa as a terrorist organization. What I do know is that Antifa fits the very definition of domestic terrorism.
Pause
Hmm. I wonder if this all is just an Antifa plot.
Pause
No, Sean, absolutely not. No.
Pause
Whoa, who is that? Who is that? Whose voice is that?
Pause
It is your friend, Zach Beecham, a Vox senior correspondent and host of the Worldly Podcast. You know all of this, which is why you're hallucinating me in your head so I can explain Antifa to you.
Pause
Zach Beecham
That's correct. The memory of the before times is so strong, so imprinted in your brain, that when you're confused about something, I come back to help explain to you why you're confused and you don't really understand it.
Pause
Then I show back up, and bam, explanations. Perfect. This is like when they give you a blazer after you host five episodes of Saturday Night Live.
Pause
You sound kind of weird, though.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Can we just like have you sound normal?
Pause
It's your brain. I can just join you on the couch if you want.
Pause
Nice. Let me mute the TV for a second here.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Good morning. So help me work through this Antifa business. The president is right now blaming Antifa for the vandalism and for turning the peaceful protests against police brutality less peaceful. Like it's all on Antifa in his eyes. Is that right?
Pause
That is correct. It's possible they've done some of it. It's plausible that they've done some of it, but there's no hard evidence to suggest that that's actually what's happening.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
What even is Antifa again? Do they have a website or a newsletter that I can read?
Pause
Zach Beecham
No, they don't. And understanding what Antifa is requires going back to the 1930s.
Pause
Because that's where the idea came from. So the very first iteration of what we now call Antifa was a German organization called Anti-Fascist Action.
Pause
I'm pronouncing it in an English accent because I'm going to butcher the German, or at least your mental projection would, Sean.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Nine. This is just a testament to your mental limitations.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Aww.
Pause
Zach Beecham
This organization was designed to be a street-level counterpart to the Nazi organizations that were dominating street brawls at the time in late Weimar Germany.
Pause
And they became an inspiration afterwards to a variety of different other groups who wanted to oppose the rise of fascism and far-right movements in the West.
Pause
The basic idea was that if you had been able to more aggressively confront the Nazis on the street and to use force to prevent them from showing up in public, maybe they wouldn't have been able to rise as powerfully and prominently in German politics in the 1930s as they did.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Where else? So you saw this a lot in the particular growth of it, starting in Europe and in the UK in the 70s and 80s.
Pause
Zach Beecham
So Germany and the UK, I'd say, would be the key places where this started.
Pause
And it started and centered around the punk movement.
Pause
The punk movement?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, yeah, yeah, the punk music movement.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Like anarchy in the UK?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Exactly like that. Exactly like the Sex Pistols.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Because I want to be anarchy.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Now don't mind.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Antifa is designed essentially, as one scholar I read put it, as a kind of anarchist alternative to the police to get out the fascists.
Pause
Right? So you're at a punk show and you need to get rid of neo-Nazis. You don't want them there. You think they endanger the people who are participating. You think they're spreading bad ideas in your left-wing spaces. And you don't want to call the cops because you hate the cops.
Pause
And so what do you do? You have these group of individuals who are willing to beat up the neo-Nazis or forcibly throw them out.
Pause
So the kind of direct action that Antifa is willing to use – and they have a variety of different tactics that they do. They're not just about fighting people, but that is a key part of their ideology, what they call preemptive self-defense.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You need to beat up the Nazis before they can get in a position where they have enough power and enough adherence to beat you up.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Preemptive self-defense, is that just like – could that just be, you know, aggression?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You know, the question of whether that's justifiable in the terms that you're asking, it's actually quite complicated, right?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Because a lot of times when they would fight and engage in brawls with these people, they weren't actually being violent, that is to say the far-right movement. They were just there trying to be at the punk show or trying to talk to people about their ideas.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And so depending on how you understand the nature of these far movements you could say well they just beating up people who are talking
Pause
Zach Beecham
That seems ridiculous. That obviously just a way of getting out aggression and feeling good about it because you beating up people that you don't like.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
The other way to spin it is the more neo-Nazis there are and the more openly they can act, the more unsafe our spaces become for minorities, for Jews, for LGBT individuals.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And if we want to make this a safe and open, inclusive space for all different kinds of people. The people who want to hurt vulnerable groups, they got to go. And we got to do whatever we can to get them out.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So how does this go from a sort of anti-Nazi thing in the 1930s to a punk thing in the UK in the 80s to what we see the president constantly bashing now in 2020?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Starting around the late 2000s, 2010s, Americans started to embrace the Antifa label as just an abbreviation for anti-fascist action or anti-fascist.
Pause
And it became this kind of diffuse movement that you saw in different places around the country.
Pause
There's no central organization. There is one network that kind of tries to connect them to each other, but there's no command and control structure.
Pause
It's just a bunch of people who understand themselves to be part of this movement.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
We see ourselves as engaging in self-defense from groups who want to do our community harm, whose ideology is the ideology of genocide and mass murder.
Pause
Zach Beecham
It's unclear how many there are. There are hubs in certain places, like Portland, where they're more popular.
Pause
But on the whole, just a bunch of people who describe themselves as Antifa and were initially affiliated or involved in the punk scene, but it sort of grew beyond that.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And then you get the rise of the alt-right and Donald Trump in 2015.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And that's the key factor in transforming the way we understand Antifa socially from a totally fringe movement to something that people actually know about who aren't involved in these sort of subcultural spaces.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So this is during like the Trump campaign?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Yeah, because you started to see an active alt-right presence publicly of people like Richard Spencer, the famous quote-unquote dapper white supremacist who got these semi-friendly appearances in mainstream media and got to go on television and stuff like that.
Pause
To be white is to be a striver, a crusader, an explorer, and a conqueror. We build, we produce, we go upward. And we recognize the central lie of American race relations. We don't exploit other groups. We don't gain anything from their presence. They need us and not the other way around.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You see that, and if you're Antifa, right, again, remember that their whole idea is that you needed to stop the Nazis with force first before they could build up legitimate sources of power and become part of the political system.
Pause
Zach Beecham
So they see that, and they're like, oh my god, we've got to do something about this. And they start organizing and turning out to contest public spaces where people like Richard Spencer are showing up.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And then when Trump wins the election, so many people are scared, hurt, angry, confused, and concerned about a descent of the United States into outright fascism.
Pause
Zach Beecham
You start seeing an increase in individual interest in the Antifa movement.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And that all comes to a head in Trump's inauguration when an unidentified Antifa member punches Richard Spencer, the white supremacist, in the face.
Pause
I remember that. Was that that video that you always see? It's been slowed down and everything?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Yeah, and put over music to a lot of different things. Totally.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And you saw mainstream figures being like, this is kind of awesome. Maybe you should punch the Nazis.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And that kind of mainstream legitimacy and recognition took Antifa from something that just was totally in the fringes to something that more and more people knew about.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But the thing I wonder about is, like, is that just a guy punching a Nazi because Nazis aren't that popular? Or was it a guy who feels that he is a member of a organized group called Antifa punching a Nazi?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Man, we're getting into tricky definitional territory here, but basically the way that we should think about this is that it's kind of both.
Pause
There are a lot of people who can understand and see themselves as being Antifa, who are operating in any individual space, but who aren't formally identified as part of a movement or acting on its orders.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It doesn't really work that way. You put on a mask and you say, I'm Antifa, then you're a kind of Antifa person.
Pause
Zach Beecham
If you are somebody who's involved in your local Antifa, for example, Rose City Antifa in Portland, then you're operating within a kind of institutional structure.
Pause
But you're not going around punching Richard Spencer on orders from somebody else.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It's not like there's an Antifa commander sitting in a bunker being like, we've identified Richard Spencer. We have a go order. We have a go order.
Pause
Zach Beecham
It's not like that. It's just random people being on the street trying to act in a way that they think is consistent with their values.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Which brings us back to this idea that it's hard to define Antifa, right?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Yeah. I mean, the quote-unquote distinctive Antifa look that you sometimes see is more generally a look associated with Black Bloc anarchist demonstrators who are different, right?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You know, the sort of all-black dress, the face masks.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And that's a very particular kind of anarchist demonstration tactic that's not necessarily employed by Antifa.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So you can get into this very technical definitional thing where you've got people dressed in all black, a bandana over their face, breaking windows at a Starbucks or whatever, and people are like, that's Antifa.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And well yeah it could be Antifa but it also could be somebody who is not part of an Antifa organization sees them as such but is engaged in a similar kind of protest and demonstration that might mark them as sharing a similar ideology even if they are not technically or in terms of self an Antifa person
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It's quite complicated.
Pause
Zach Beecham
I really want to entangle this a little bit more, but I need to make a quick pit stop.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I know you're in my subconscious, but can you hang out here on the couch and I'll be right back?
Pause
Zach Beecham
No, I'm going to go with you.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It's because I'm part of your brain. Like, I know it's going to be awkward, but you're just going to have to push past it.
Pause
Zach Beecham
This is going to be fun.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, great. Let's go.
Pause
Zach Beecham
We'll be right back.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Support for today's show comes from Adio.
Pause
Zach Beecham
What is Adio?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Pause
Zach Beecham
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And within seconds, you will have your email and calendars synced.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You'll see all your relationships in a fully fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal and so much more.
Pause
Zach Beecham
You can go to attio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
That's attio.com slash todayexplained.
Pause
Zach Beecham
On everything at Apple.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Apply for Apple Card on your iPhone in minutes.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Subject to credit approval, Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Terms and more at applecard.com.
Pause
Zach Beecham
20 seconds.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Zach, are you still there?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Yep, I am.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I'm here now that your brain has been turned back on, ready to answer your questions about all the Fox News you've been watching.
Pause
Zach Beecham
President Trump is bound to take action and designate Antifa as a terrorist organization.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So they said on the news that the president's going to designate Antifa a terrorist organization. Is that a thing he can do?
Pause
Zach Beecham
No, that's stupid. Like, you can't do that.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
The reason why is the president has the power to designate foreign terrorist organizations as terrorist groups.
Pause
Zach Beecham
That's what he is legally and statutorily empowered to do.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Antifa is not a foreign terrorist organization.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Even though it started in Germany in the 1930s?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Well, because it's not an organization like that.
Pause
Zach Beecham
It's not like there's an Antifa compound in Berlin where they're sending out orders to America.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It's entirely a bunch of people here who aren't even operating under a direct order or command and control structure, which is the other problem with it.
Pause
Zach Beecham
When it's Al-Qaeda or ISIS, you can be like, well, yeah, there's an organization here that we can declare a terrorist organization.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But when it comes to Antifa, there's no structure that one could sanction like that.
Pause
Zach Beecham
It doesn't even make sense to speak of them as being any sort of unified organization called Antifa.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
There are just different Antifa branches and individuals who see themselves as participating in it.
Pause
Zach Beecham
So it's not foreign in the way that it operates because it's entirely decentralized and domestic.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
When the FBI has investigated domestic terrorism cases and organizations, they tend to apply an organized crime model.
Pause
Zach Beecham
So if you're going into a white nationalist group—
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Like the KKK?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Yeah, like the KKK or a more violent one, let's say, like the base in Atomwaffen, which are two new and recent, extremely murderous white nationalist groups.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
When the FBI looks at groups like this, they approach them like they're approaching the mafia because there isn't exactly a legal framework for purely domestic terrorist groups.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And the legal tools that one might need to deal with this kind of thing are encapsulated in the powers available for dealing with organized crime.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It's the same thing, right? You've got an organized group of people who are conspiring to commit a pattern or series of violent and dangerous actions inside the U.S.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And so even if ideologically they're different, structurally you don't need different legal powers to address them.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So there's no kind of domestic terrorist designation for that reason.
Pause
Zach Beecham
So you're saying, just to be clear here, that the president can't even designate this group a terrorist organization.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Like, that's not even within the realm of his power.
Pause
Zach Beecham
I mean, he can do whatever he wants. He can tweet, Antifa is a terrorist organization, or knowing Trump, it would be Antifa terrorist organization, 10 exclamation points.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But he can't do anything beyond that.
Pause
Zach Beecham
There's no formal legal structure that would allow him to be like, now Antifa are terrorists and the police should arrest them.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So why is he going after Antifa?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Well, that's because for the past few years, Antifa has become a kind of right-wing boogeyman.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It started with that Richard Spencer thing that we were talking about early on at Trump's inauguration, punching a very famous white nationalist.
Pause
Zach Beecham
But it really escalated after Charlottesville.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
In Charlottesville, Virginia, a white nationalist rally that descended into deadly violence and chaos.
Pause
Zach Beecham
The image is just coming in a car plowing into a crowd of demonstrators Victims thrown in the air one woman dead others critically wounded
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
During the Charlottesville protests white nationalist rally violence etc there was a pretty significant Antifa protest, because this is of course the type of event that they would go to based on the way they understand themselves.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And there, they had a very interesting role.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
On the one hand, there's footage and there are testimonies of people saying Antifa organizers and members were defending counter-protesters from violent white nationalists.
Pause
Zach Beecham
But I've also seen video of a very right-wing journalist, Andy Ngo, in Portland, who was known to hate Antifa, to try to provoke them and so on, went to a rally, and he got beat up.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I just got beat up by the crowd. No police at all. Seemingly by Antifa people.
Pause
Zach Beecham
In the middle of the street, and they stole my GoPro, and they punched me several times in my face, in my head, I'm bleeding.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Antifa hates being filmed. They don't want anyone to identify them. They want to operate anonymously.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And so they see journalists who are filming them as a threat to their anonymity and ability to function in their regular lives.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And this violence became really important ideologically for the American right.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Because it allowed you to say not that there were many fine people on both sides, but rather there are many violent people on both sides.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
That it's not just the extreme right that's become violent and dangerous in the Trump era. It's also the extreme left.
Pause
Zach Beecham
It allows you to paint a degree of equivalence between these two sides.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And so you have right-wing, you know, major legislators and politicians condemning them.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Ted Cruz today is calling for a federal investigation after protests turned violent in Portland, Oregon over the weekend.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And Ted Cruz at the time tried to introduce legislation that would count Antifa as a terrorist organization.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Now, you could do that legislatively. It's just there weren't enough votes to do it and it doesn't really make sense.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But the point is that this is not a new Trump thing. It's something that has been a major focus of Fox News and of conservative legislators for a very long time in an effort to say that the growing militancy in the United States is not at all one-sided, but rather that there's a violent left that needs to be dealt with.
Pause
It seems sort of dangerous to take this particular moment and say, oh, that's just a bunch of Antifa. Like, not only dismissive, but potentially risky?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Have we seen any manifestations of how dangerous it can be to just pin this entire thing on something called Antifa?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, you see it in the president's rhetoric to a degree, right? The way that he talks about the protests.
Pause
Zach Beecham
The violence and vandalism is being led by Antifa and other radical left-wing groups who are terrorizing the innocent, destroying jobs, hurting businesses, and burning down buildings.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
In reality, what's happening is that there are overwhelmingly peaceful protests that have violent members inside of them who do not define what's happening, and that the violent dynamics are escalated by police who use disproportionate, often entirely unjustified shows of force against protesters whose objectives they find threatening.
Pause
Zach Beecham
So it allows you to paint this as a clash between two violent factions, the police who are defending law and order and Antifa, who's trying to tear it apart, when what's actually happening is that there's a large group of people who are calling for justice, primarily, and an end to discrimination, who have some agitators inside their ranks.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And instead of being able to just deal with the agitators, you know, arrest somebody who throws a brick or something like that, the police are more justified in using broad brush tactics like firing rubber bullets indiscriminately or tear gassing in order to disperse crowds on grounds that the crowd itself is violent.
Pause
Zach Beecham
The nature of it is violent. You can't draw a straight line between calling this an Antifa demonstration and a police crackdown, but you can see how the ideology, the connection, helps legitimize what the cops are doing, even when it's quite clearly unjustifiable.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And beyond that, Zach, I mean, is this just like a straw man for the president and the right-wing media to just avoid dealing with the actual issue at hand here, which is a whole lot of Americans clamoring for racial justice right now?
Pause
Zach Beecham
Yeah, it's not even a straw man, right? It's more of a boogeyman, right? You got to put up the big monster so you can defeat it and claim victory, that you're defending the public from this.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
There was never any chance that President Donald Trump was going to say, okay, there are a bunch of black people out here protesting for racial justice. I'm going to side with the protesters.
Pause
Zach Beecham
That was just not what's going to happen. And white people, too. It's like the United Colors of angry America right now.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I thought you were going to go with angry Benetton or fiery Benetton.
Pause
Zach Beecham
I've never really known what the Benetton is.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
What's the Benetton?
Pause
Zach Beecham
It's a clothing company.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I know, but why Benetton?
Pause
Zach Beecham
What is that? Is that a place?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Well, I guess since I'm your brain, I don't really know.
Pause
Zach Beecham
This is where we fall short. As you were, brain. You need to tell a story, right, in order to justify your behaviors both to yourself and to the public.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And the story that you're telling here is that there are violent rioters who need to be put down with force.
Pause
Zach Beecham
And if you can say, well, this violence is primarily being driven by an organized group, well, that sounds a lot scarier.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And it sounds like something that, after years of the war on terrorism, in American minds justifies a more violent response.
Pause
Zach Beecham
It's a more sellable and salient narrative.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Zach, thank you for hanging out with me on my couch and helping me work through this.
Pause
Zach Beecham
I'm your captive, Sean. I can't really do anything else, but I'm happy to be here.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Jeannie, you're free.
Pause
Goodbye.
Pause
Zach Beecham
Bye, goodbye.