Main Topic: The Sad Beige Influencer Lawsuit
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noelle King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King with Mia Sato. Mia writes about tech companies for The Verge. She broke the story of the sad beige influencer lawsuit and she begins with the accuser, Sydney Gifford.
Mia Sato
Sydney Gifford is 24. She lives outside of Minneapolis, Minnesota, and she is incredibly successful at this job. She has hundreds of thousands of followers on Instagram and TikTok. She makes videos that get millions of views, tons of people commenting, saving, presumably buying things from her clips.
Noelle King
And this is how she makes a living. This is pretty much her only job. And she's specifically an Amazon influencer because she told me that she really doesn't do other brand deals that much. She just has this partnership with Amazon.
Mia Sato
I get literally all my clothes from one place. And it's Amazon. I stopped at Skims this weekend, then immediately placed an Amazon order so we can really compare. Oh my goodness. You're telling me I spent how much on Skims? Amazon has just gotten really good at this.
Noelle King
She's part of their influencer program where every time you make a purchase from one of her special links with sort of tracking information in an affiliate link, every time you make a purchase from her links, she earns a little bit of money back.
Mia Sato
So many good deals right now, y'all. Even more on my Prime Day page. So many more things are on sale. I could go on forever. I have a whole list on my storefront of Wardrobe Essential deals that you absolutely need, but those are my favorite.
Noelle King
And now think about scaling that to like millions and millions of viewers who are looking for whatever, you know, crap to buy. And it's a pretty, pretty sweet job.
Mia Sato
And what does Sydney Gifford say that the other woman is copying? Sydney says that Alyssa is copying her vibe, basically. That's what it really boils down to, her vibe, her look, her feel, aesthetic.
Noelle King
And there are a couple different prongs of the sort of copying allegations. One is Sydney says that Alyssa has copied what her videos and photos look like, the aesthetic, the sort of look and feel, the pacing, maybe the editing.
Mia Sato
You've copied my videos. You keep making the same videos that I just made a few days ago or a few weeks ago. So that's one thing. The other thing is you keep promoting the same Amazon stuff as I do. Oh if you're not getting all your bags on amazon you need to see this let's talk about all of my favorite fallbacks from amazon i do own one bottega bag and the way that all of these feel and look are so comparable inspired by bottega for a fraction of the price even the hardware has a good weight to it like i would expect with the designer bag i adore the shape of this bag and all of the gold hardware i found some of the best woven bags on amazon this year you know me you know how much i love a woven leather bag the additional allegation is that not only did you copy what my content looks like. You copied what I look like. You changed your appearance and people are getting us confused.
Noelle King
Oh my God. Okay. Wow. All right. So this is more dramatic than even I had realized. What is the aesthetic that Sidney Gifford is saying the other woman copied?
Mia Sato
Okay. So imagine a house that is black, white, cream, beige only. You look around, there is literally not a single thing in your sight that is a color other than that. Everything is like this. Everything is smooth, clean, sort of it almost feels like a dream, like a cloud.
Noelle King
These are both of their homes. I went to both of their houses. And I visited Alyssa first and I was struck by the neighborhood that she lived in because it was all like tan. Then I stepped into her home and it was silent and completely white. Just everything was beige and cream and white and a little bit of black.
Mia Sato
And it is this aesthetic that has come to be known online as quote-unquote clean girl. You know those girls that always look clean? Their skin is always glowing, their lips are always glossed, and they never, ever look like they're wearing too much makeup?
Noelle King
You may not be them, but here's how to get their look. Clean girls have these beautiful, long, sort of smooth hair. I have never been able to dry and style my long and thick hair so fast and easily, especially with only one tool. Sometimes it's down, sometimes it's in a tight bun, slicked back bun.
Mia Sato
They wear gold jewelry. There's some of my Amazon bracelets that I absolutely swear by. They're so gorgeous, lightweight, and I just love the way they sparkle. This is my current necklace stack. I never take these off.
Noelle King
They wear also beige cream white black clothing they wear chunky sweaters or oversized sweatsuits They have beautifully manicured nails This is the sort of vision of luxury that a lot of people look up to right now.
Mia Sato
Okay, so lest our listeners think there are no stakes here, these women are actually making money from their presentation on video, the aesthetic that surrounds them. Like this is actually what they do for work. Yeah. And it pays for their life.
Noelle King
And what Sidney's claim is that the copying wasn't just like annoying, which maybe a lot of people would feel that's where it ends. It also cut into her earnings. She says that she didn't sell as many Amazon products as Alyssa was copying her, allegedly. She says that she didn't, you know, gain the same amount of followers that she would have because perhaps they were following Alyssa instead.
Mia Sato
And the sort of claim about, you know, you copied what I look like, that feeds into that where Sidney claims that because Alyssa copied how she looks, people were getting the two women confused. People were thinking that Alyssa was Sidney and then perhaps buying things from her links instead of Sidney's links.
Noelle King
Does that make sense? Yes, it does. And now you have made me wonder whether or not they know each other in real life.
Mia Sato
So that's the crazy thing they do. They have met each other. Sydney used to live in Austin, where Alyssa currently resides. And in 2022 and 2023, the two women, along with a third influencer friend of Sydney's, all met up in person twice.
Noelle King
And the meetings were kind of supposed to be like, how can we support each other? How can we support our businesses? You know, we work in the same field. We make the same kind of videos. So maybe we can just be friends or be friendly.
Mia Sato
Cool. And after the second meetup, Alyssa told me that she felt kind of excluded from the other women, like they were maybe making passive aggressive comments to her. One thing she says was they were quizzing me on my strategies on social media.
Noelle King
And Alyssa ends up blocking Sydney on social media. Now, Sydney was surprised and kind of confused by this because she thought the outings had been great, right? She thought everyone was on good terms. Everyone was friendly.
Mia Sato
But she kind of, you know, took a moment and wasn't too offended by the blocking because, as she told me, living your life online is not easy. Sometimes you compare yourself to other people and it can be mentally draining.
Noelle King
So she was like, you know what, whatever, I'm just going to keep doing my job. And something like 10 months after the blocking followers of Sydney's started to come to her and say hey there's a woman who's making content just like yours and I actually thought she was you until I looked at the name and that woman was Alyssa.
Mia Sato
This person that she had met a few times and had had this encounter with okay so it's at this point that Sydney decides I'm gonna sue and what is the content of her lawsuit?
Noelle King
So first, Sydney takes all of her social media posts and registers them with the copyright office, which is a pretty rare thing for influencers to do. It's not really a normal thing.
Mia Sato
So now she has all of her posts. She can start sending cease and desist letters to Alyssa. She hires an attorney and says, basically, you know, your content is infringing on my copyright. Like, you need to stop this.
Noelle King
And this goes on for a little bit before the actual suit is filed. That happened last spring. And the suit has a lot of different things in it.
Mia Sato
There's obviously what we just talked about, the claim that you making similar videos and photos, though not identical, similar content is infringing on my copyright. That's a novel claim.
Noelle King
What does Alyssa say in response to this? Is she taking it seriously?
Mia Sato
Absolutely. I think she was shocked when she learned she was being sued. She denies ever copying Sydney. She says, I didn't even think about this person until I had started getting these cease and desist. I was not copying her.
Noelle King
On the claim that they look alike, I should note that Sydney is a white Hispanic woman and Alyssa is a black Latina woman. And so Alyssa's legal response to this claim is, well, we don't look alike. We are two different races and nobody could confuse us.
Mia Sato
So there's a whole different, you know, Alyssa basically is saying like everything that I'm doing is totally legal and fine. And moreover, this is just the way that influencer content looks. This is the genre of clean girl. These are sort of the tropes of that genre.
Noelle King
And a lot of people online, I mean, I've seen these videos of them and of others. A lot of people online are basic. It's an aesthetic, right? An aesthetic can't just be one person doing it, because if it is, then it's not an aesthetic. It's like, oh, that girl's got good style. But nowadays, everybody online is copying everybody else, whether it's like using someone's dance or their song or their clip or their meme.
Mia Sato
And then other people are just going to use it and repeat it and mess with it a little bit around the edges. How big could the implications be here if Sydney were to win?
Noelle King
So if Sydney were to win, it would be a pretty significant expansion of copyright law. Because suddenly, it's not just about these images being identical. It's that you ripped off the vibe, the feel of my photos and videos.
Mia Sato
The reason the story was so interesting to me is that it's actually like truly unclear to me what is happening here, what the truth is. I don't know. And I have gone through the process of reporting and writing it, I've sort of landed in different places.
Noelle King
But one thing I keep coming back to is that it's really hard right now in our media ecosystem to understand how we are implicitly being influenced by algorithms that we don't understand, that we don't have insight into.
Mia Sato
Who's to say that Alyssa wasn't just pushed towards this content because this is the type of content that she sees on her feed all the time and that is what she's emulating.
Noelle King
So there's a lot of interesting questions around really like the artistic nature of influencer content and also how algorithms mediate all of the things that we post on the Internet.
Theme music starts playing
That was The Verge's Mia Sato. Coming up everybody getting a lawyer so we are too.
Theme music continues
Alex Roberts
I'm following it pretty closely because it is right up my alley, to be honest with you. So I've written about influencer marketing and I teach courses on trademark and entertainment law and intellectual property law. So this is all my jam.
Noelle King
So Sydney Gifford is suing Alyssa Sheel, claiming that Ms. Sheel is copying her. And this lawsuit is real and it is progressing?
Alex Roberts
It is. So Gifford brought this lawsuit in April of 2024. So her causes of action in the complaint include copyright infringement, trade dress infringement, unfair competition, interference with contract, misappropriation of right of publicity, and more.
Noelle King
To many experts, I think these claims seemed like overreach with very little chance of success. But Scheil moved to dismiss six of those eight causes of action. And kind of surprisingly, a magistrate judge in November declined to dismiss four of those challenged claims.
Alex Roberts
And then in December, the supervising district judge adopted the magistrate's report and recommendations. So that doesn't mean Gifford wins on those claims, but it means the judges believed that she adequately pled them. So at this stage, they can't be ruled out and the case can go forward.
Noelle King
Are you surprised by that?
Alex Roberts
I am surprised by that. Okay, tell me why. There's a lot out there, a lot that content creators are making, particularly when it comes to Amazon recommendations, particularly when it comes to this kind of clean girl aesthetic and this sad beige, you know, certain tones and colors that people are using.
Noelle King
A lot of it is really similar. Here's your step-by-step guide becoming an elegant, classy, clean girl. The first thing I want you to do is pick a signature fragrance. This is one of my favorite products for achieving the clean girl makeup routine. It's this Rare Beauty Eye Brightener. It's amazing, and it replaces all my concealers.
Alex Roberts
I was just looking at the amended complaint. And she talks about like her way of relating to her followers and her tone of voice. I mean, that's not usually what trade dress law protects.
Noelle King
And then lastly, misappropriation of right of publicity. I mean, that's usually like when a company takes a celebrity's name or photo and uses it in an ad without their consent. There you have a strong claim for right of publicity. But here she's saying essentially, you copied my look, you dressed like me You did your hair and makeup like me You paired similar earrings with a similar outfit and white cowboy boots and that a use of my image or my persona
Alex Roberts
So that seems a little outside of what the law protects but these cases are unpredictable.
Noelle King
Okay, the cases are unpredictable. We think we know where this will land. Like the smart money says, Sidney Gifford can't win. But if she does win, what could this change?
Alex Roberts
It doesn't change what's actually copyrightable, right? Photos and videos are protectable. Longer text captions may be copyrightable, but short phrases are not. Curated lists can sometimes qualify for thin copyright protection.
Noelle King
So a court would really need to find sufficient similarity here for infringement. If they do, I think the chilling effects are really tremendous. I think it leads to concerns by other content creators that they might be accused of copying somebody's content just because they're kind of following the same viral trend or creating similar categories of content.
Alex Roberts
They might be accused of impersonating somebody's look just because they make similar choices in the way that they style their outfits.
Noelle King
So when we talk about chilling effects, what we mean is speech is chilled. People are afraid to create new works, to do different forms of expression that might lead to claims of infringement.
Alex Roberts
Right. Like imagine being scared to wear beige. I mean, listen, I don't love beige, but I've learned many women do. Imagine being afraid to get on camera and show your beige house because somebody might sue you for it because your house looks too much like her house. This is crazy making.
Noelle King
So I think one difference between this case and some really high-profile copyright cases that we hear about, like in music, when you think about, you know, Blurred Lines and Katy Perry and Led Zeppelin or, you know, a case that Nike brings or something like that, typically those are defendants who are more well-resourced.
Alex Roberts
They have a legal team. They have a label behind them. They have the ability to kind of put up a really robust defense and make their best argument.
Noelle King
And when we're thinking about content creators at this level, we're usually thinking about somebody who's doing this as a side hustle or who's kind of trying to eke out a living, get some endorsements, get some paid promotions for their content, pull together a community, get some attention from followers.
Alex Roberts
But they are unlikely to have the kind of resources that will let them fight back, that will enable them to say, this is actually non-infringing or it's a fair use or what you're claiming as trade dress is completely functional and unprotectable.
Noelle King
So they're more likely to back down, they're more likely to settle, and frankly, they're much more susceptible to bullying.
Alex Roberts
So what we see in the IP context is when you have some cases setting out precedent that liability might exist, people get really aggressive with their cease and desist letters.
Noelle King
So they say, you know, this other influencer was just found or maybe found liable for copycat posts. And the same thing's going to happen to you. We're going to sue you next if you don't completely abandon this category of posts that you're making or cancel your account or whatever the demands are.
Alex Roberts
I wonder whether or not the platforms bear any blame for these creators looking and sounding and talking alike and having the same vibe.
Noelle King
Because if they're pushing stuff at you via an algorithm and you're seeing one person do it, you're seeing two people do it, you're seeing three people do it, you become the fifth or the sixth or the 10th.
Alex Roberts
Like, has anyone ever looked at, okay, the platforms are serving me a lot of sad beige content and therefore they are responsible for me thinking, huh, sad beige, that's the way to do it?
Noelle King
I think there's a philosophical question in there and there's maybe also a legal liability question in there, right?
Alex Roberts
So making creators fight to be seen and followed, that doesn't imply any liability for copyright infringement.
Noelle King
And all creators in all genres, in all kinds of industries, have to compete for eyeballs and profits. Low barriers to entry in this field probably means there's a lot more competition, right?
Alex Roberts
It's a lot easier to post an Instagram post than it is to make a movie.
Noelle King
If we're thinking about the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, a DMCA analysis might ask whether Gifford filed takedown requests with these various platforms.
Alex Roberts
She's got a copyright management information claim, which argues that by creating similar posts without crediting Gifford's account, in essence removing Gifford's username from the works, Shile violates the DMCA.
Noelle King
If she actually succeeds on that claim, which, again, seems a stretch, I wonder whether that might affect how platforms choose to structure things.
Alex Roberts
Like, could they decide they want to require or apply watermarks or something like that?
Noelle King
And likewise, if a court agreed with Gifford that Shiles' followers infringed Gifford's works when they viewed or downloaded or screencapped Shiles' posts, that might have implications for platforms and potentially platform liability for infringement.
Alex Roberts
If the parties settle or if Gifford prevails on some of her claims, really any of her claims, then we might begin to see more cases like this or see content creators lawyering up and sending cease and desist letters threatening similar suits.
Theme music continues
Noelle King
Alex Roberts, she's a professor of media and law at Northeastern.
Hady Mawajdeh
I'm Hady Mawajdeh, the producer of today's show.
Amina Al-Sadi
I'm Amina Al-Sadi, the editor.
Laura Bullard
I'm Laura Bullard, the senior researcher.
Andrea Kristinsdottir
I'm Andrea Kristinsdottir, the engineer.
Rob Byers
I'm Rob Byers, the engineer.
Noelle King
Today Explained is made by Victoria Chamberlain, Avishai Artsy, Miranda Kennedy, Patrick Boyd, Peter Balanon-Rosen, Miles Bryan, Amanda Llewellyn, and Travis Larchuk.
Today, Sean and I and the rest of the team are saying goodbye to Halima Shah, producer, reporter, fill-in host, and full-time woman of mystery.
Halima Shah
Hoc toi, girl.
Noelle King
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.