Main Topic: The podcast episode "Blame Capitalism" explores the concept of capitalism, its evolution, and its impact on society. The host, Noelle King, delves into the criticisms of capitalism and the reasons why people are increasingly angry with the system.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noelle King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King.
Discussion begins
We cannot separate capitalism from racism. Market capitalism is not a religion. You'd have to be a fool to worship it. I am so sick of living in a capitalist society. Everyone's talking about capitalism. And they all seem like they're mad. They say that they hate it. And they contest and debate it. But they all agree it's bad.
Music plays
Every Friday for the next four weeks, a new Today Explained series, Blame Capitalism. On Today Explained, we will listen to their complaints to find out what is going on.
Music continues
Everything comes with a price, even peace of mind. The Today Explained.
Music ends
And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at ServiceNow.com.
Music plays briefly
Support for the show comes from Charles Schwab. At Schwab, how you invest is your choice, not theirs. That's why when it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices. You can invest and trade on your own. Plus, get advice and more comprehensive wealth solutions to help meet your unique needs. With award-winning service, low costs, and transparent advice, you can manage your wealth your way at Schwab. Visit schwab.com to learn more.
Music ends
Modern capitalism emerged about 250, 300 years ago. Our economic system shapes everything. How we get to live, what we get to want, who we get to be. But I think we're at a turning point because many of us aren't happy with how we get to live and what we get to want. On the other hand, most of the people in power still think this is the best system we've got. What is it? How do we get here? Why do we blame it? Can we change it? Should we try? Everyone's asking those questions.
Discussion continues
Senator Bernie Sanders wrote a book this year, It's Okay to be Angry About Capitalism.
Music plays briefly
Used to be people started a small business. You started a small business. You have a business. Today, in sector after sector, you have fewer and fewer multi-billion dollar corporations controlling that sector.
Music ends
Over the summer, I interviewed Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy, who has clawed his way to a real competition by attacking woke capitalism.
Music plays briefly
A small group of business elites get to decide how we settle questions on climate change to racial justice instead. And I reject that vision.
Music ends
My friend Max left me a message shrieking that I had to go see the new Indiana Jones movie. You stole it. Then you stole it. Then I stole it. It's called capitalism.
Music plays briefly
So many people are throwing this word around. Just another day living under late capitalism.
Music ends
I first noticed it in 2017. I'd been covering economics for four years for Marketplace and then for Planet Money. And I never once used the word capitalism on air. Business, yes. Housing, yes. Energy, sure. Markets, always.
Music plays briefly
It's a half day today for markets in the U.S. and for some European indices.
Music ends
But then that summer, my friend Brittany Luce hosted this very zeitgeisty live podcast taping. And something went down while she and her guests were talking about Jay-Z's new record.
Music plays briefly
There is an album that came out recently. Yes. Oh, God. That is basically lipstick alley on wax. I'm talking about 444.
Music ends
OK. All right. So Vincent Cunningham, a writer for The New Yorker, started talking about the economic message that some writers saw in that album.
Discussion continues
I could have bought a place in Dumbo before it was Dumbo for like two million. Greg Tate just had a piece in The Village Voice about 444. He's pretty, like, okay about it, but he talks about it in terms of, like, a Black economic nationalism and talks about him in terms of Garvey and in terms of Booker T.
Music plays briefly
And I didn't agree with it from Booker T, and I don't agree with it from Jay-Z. I don't think that capitalism is the answer for Black people.
Music ends
So, bad for the Blacks. I don't think capitalism is the answer for Black people.
Discussion continues
Thomas Edison's light bulb went on in my brain and illuminated something that had been skittering around the edges. Economics reporters like me weren't talking about capitalism, but the culture was.
Music plays briefly
Now, I am a lot, and days later, I exuberantly reported this observation to my colleagues. They were skeptical. One of them said something like, knocking capitalism is just what college kids do.
Music ends
My excitement dampened. I couldn't square it. I mean, my colleague was right about college kids, but these weren't college kids. These were smart, young culture critics.
Discussion continues
except the culture critics were in the zeitgeist and my colleague was somewhere else. He was in the firmament. It was the thing we all love to hate. It was a generational divide because there is one thing that young people don't have, memories of capitalism's biggest triumph.
Music plays briefly
I've now reached the western side of Checkpoint Charlie where there are a huge number of people here. 1989. The first East German has come across now. He's been raised aloft.
Music ends
I was alive when the Berlin Wall fell. I was eight years old and sitting in the back of my mom's Oldsmobile. She was letting the engine run so that it wouldn't stall out in the cold. And the man on the radio, who was always so calm, was yelling.
Discussion continues
One man's just come through, raised his arms in the air and declared, I've made it, I've made it.
Music plays briefly
I leaned in from the backseat, put down my chapter book, and took leave of linear time for a split second as I decided, someday I'm going to be the man yelling on the radio.
Music ends
Now, at that exact moment, another man who would someday yell on the radio was a lieutenant in the U.S. Navy in Norfolk, Virginia.
Discussion continues
And I was in the ready room of my squadron when all of this started happening. And I remember where I was. I was having a conversation with Victor, God, what's his last name? Anyway, a buddy of mine then, 30 years ago.
Music plays briefly
And we said, everything's going to change now. everything's going to change.
Music ends
You know that voice. That's Kai Rizdahl. From American Public Media, this is Marketplace.
Music plays briefly
Host of the most popular economics show on NPR stations. And Kai's also a veteran of the Cold War.
Music ends
You know, I had been on missions up around the North Cape in Norway flying against Soviet bombers in 1986 1987.
Discussion continues
And that was what we knew. And communism was the ever threat. A threat because very real atrocities had happened under communism. See Joseph Stalin's Soviet Union.
Music plays briefly
And communist leaders wanted theirs to be the only economic system in the world. Now, capitalists wanted the same thing.
Music ends
And the way the West saw it, capitalism had to beat communism. It was an existential fight. And it did. The Berlin Wall came down. Capitalism won.
Discussion continues
Throughout the 90s and the early 2000s, there were certainly critiques of capitalism. But envisioning a world without it? No. Capitalism was the system we had, and experts and economists were all very confident that it was the best system.
Music plays briefly
And then... Lehman Brothers is going bankrupt. The financial crisis hit.
Music ends
And financial markets from Asia to Europe are doing their utmost to prevent Monday from turning from dark to black.
Discussion continues
I remember the day that the TARP, the Troubled Assets Relief Program, failed in the House for the first time.
Music plays briefly
Wall Street watched Washington with shock and fear. Nobody could believe it.
Music ends
As the bailout package went down on Capitol Hill, the Dow went down like a sub.
Discussion continues
You know, Henry Paulson and Ben Bernanke had gone up to the Hill and said, please, please, please, please, please, we need this money.
Music plays briefly
Right. Paulson said, I need a bazooka. I don't want to have to use it, but I need a bazooka.
Music ends
And that was this $700 billion package that was going to get the economy through the collapse of the financial system, the near collapse of the financial system.
Discussion continues
And I remember TARP failing and the Dow dropping 777 points in minutes.
Music plays briefly
And then, honestly, it became a long slog. It became a long slog because you got through Bear Stearns. You got through Lehman Brothers. You got through the March 2009 lows in the stock market.
Music ends
And then that long, slow recovery where jobs weren't coming back and people were still struggling and the real estate market was still challenged and people didn't have work.
Discussion continues
Not for me and journalism, but for people out there.
Music plays briefly
More than 500 people applying for a shot at 50 slots at a local iron workers union. Many of these people have been camped out for days, hoping for the promise of a steady job with health care.
Music ends
Do you think that's why instead of people blaming the banks and the bankers and the people who really got us into trouble, that they decided some percentage of them decided to blame the whole system?
Discussion continues
Yeah, the blame did get spread to the entire system, how we run this economy. But I think also, and this is not to be discounted, especially as we find ourselves in the political moment we find ourselves in today, I think people got equally angry at capitalism and equally angry at the politics of American capitalism.
Music plays briefly
Because what you had was the government coming in and saving the big banks and giving them tens of billions of dollars.
Music ends
And CEOs mostly, right, did okay. A couple of big bank CEOs, you know, got canned, but mostly the people on Wall Street survived and the system endured.
Discussion continues
I think the challenge is that the average person in Des Moines, Iowa looks at what happened and looks at the bailouts while he or she is still, you know, bailouts were 2008, 2009.
Music plays briefly
Let's fast forward to 2013, 2014. This person is still having trouble making rent, is still working two jobs, trying to get the kids to school on time, has a clunker of a car or the combine on the farm, needs a repair or whatever it is.
Music ends
And they saw these tens of billions of dollars. And that justifiably got people angry, really angry.
Discussion continues
And then it just got worse. Hella degrees, student debt, garbage job. Work your ass off, never going to buy a house. Mom's got a pension. Good for her. You're going to work forever. Oh, mom doesn't? Well, you're responsible for her now, too. Babies someday? Nah, they cost too much. GDP growth? Absolutely. Love it. Trash the planet on our way there, though.
Music plays briefly
Oh, and the guys with the money, Elon, Zuckerberg, Bezos, they do not pay taxes. It can drive you crazy if you let it. Or you can just have fun, mock it, meme it.
Music ends
Over the summer, Serena Toros wrote a think piece for Vox. It's called How Frog and Toad Became Queer, Anti-Capitalist, Cottagecore Icons.
Music plays briefly
Frog and Toad are these two characters from this children's book series from the 70s. Toad! Toad! The sun is shining! The snow is melting! Wake up! Oh, I am not here.
Music ends
I feel like they inhabit this sort of like anti-work sentimentality where their lives are structured around taking care of each other, doing the sorts of activities that don't rely on generating income, that don't rely on market forces.
Discussion continues
Come on, we'll skip through the meadows and run through the woods and swim in the river. In the evenings, we will sit right here and count all the stars.
Music plays briefly
I was an early teenager when the 2008 Great Recession happened. And I feel like I really started to question how things worked and why they worked.
Music ends
And, you know, it kind of was a moment I realized, like, maybe money is fake, you know, and that the free market is not something that is free, that there are regulations to it, external regulations to it that could change people's lives.
Discussion continues
So all the things that I've been struggling with are things that could very easily be taken care of by, you know, stronger government intervention.
Music plays briefly
And so to me, I was like, oh, that's capitalism. So, you know, it's a very easy scapegoat to blame. Blame capitalism. Or maybe fix it?
Music ends
Well, you can't do that until you can define it, understand it. And that's what we're doing from here on out. Stay tuned.
Music plays briefly
Support for today's show comes from Adio. What is Adio? Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Music ends
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model. According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up. And within seconds, you will have your email and calendars synced.
Discussion continues
You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data. And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Music plays briefly
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile Replicate Modal and so much more You can go to adio slash todayexplained to get 15 off your first year That A dot com slash today explained
Music ends
Support for this show comes from Macy's. It's almost fall and that means it's time to cycle your wardrobe to the cold setting. Because while everyone loves a breezy summer outfit, let's be real. Layering is even more fun.
Music plays briefly
That's why Macy's Fall Fashion Guide has everything you need to piece together the perfect look for you. It's your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
Music ends
Add a statement shoe to your collection, like the calf-hair loafers from Steve Madden. Or tap into your romantic side with flowy dresses from Cece and sheer pieces from INC.
Discussion continues
You can even throw in some textural layers for contrast, like a faux fur bomber jacket from Karl Lagerfeld Paris.
Music plays briefly
Whether your old favorite sweater or coat is on its last threads, or you're just craving a new vibe to switch things up, Macy's has got you covered this season.
Music ends
Find the perfect layering pieces for you by exploring the Macy's Fall Fashion Style Guide. Shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
Music plays briefly
It's Today Explained. We're back. I'm Noelle King.
Discussion continues
In the autumn of 2021, I'd been thinking about capitalism and our discontent for four years. And I came across a story in The New Yorker about an economist named Wendy Carlin.
Music plays briefly
Wendy had earned this rare and coveted profile by writing a new economics textbook. She told The New Yorker, somewhat slyly, that she wanted to teach economics as if the last 30 years had happened.
Music ends
Wendy Carlin has a doctorate in economics. She's a CBE, Commander of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire, for her contributions in economics.
Discussion continues
Wendy Carlin is super-duper smart. But when the financial crisis happened, Wendy had no idea how to explain it. To her undergraduates, no less.
Music plays briefly
I was in the classroom, literally in the classroom, with hundreds of students. And they were asking about why was there a crisis. Economics was happening in the real world, in a really big way.
Music ends
They felt embarrassed when they went home and their family asked them to explain about the crisis and they really had nothing to say. It didn't relate at all to what they were learning in their economics classroom.
Discussion continues
And like many, many other economics professors around the world, I was pretty hopeless at giving them a good answer.
Music plays briefly
Okay, so economics as a profession isn't keeping up with the real world. You wrote a textbook. Give me the textbook definition of capitalism.
Music ends
Wendy Carlin
Capitalism is an economic system, so it's a set of rules of the game, and it has three defining characteristics. So one is private property. The second is markets. And the third is a particular kind of firm, a capitalist firm.
Discussion continues
And the capitalist firm is one that employs workers for wages with the intention of producing goods and services for sale on markets. There's private ownership of the production means, so that's where the private property comes in. And the objective of the firm is to be able to sell its output of goods and services above the cost of production, making profits.
Music plays briefly
So it has the intention of making profits. The definition that you gave me, is that largely agreed upon by people in your profession? If I were to ask another economist, would they tell me something similar?
Music ends
They might. They might not have ever thought about it. How is that possible? Economics, like many sciences and other forms of academic inquiry, is very specialized. and people work in a particular area.
Discussion continues
So they might work on the economics of migration or of competition policy or of macroeconomics. There's not really a sense of the study of the whole system. And so they might feel a little uncomfortable if you ask them to define capitalism.
Music plays briefly
Economists get uncomfortable defining capitalism should you ever feel inadequate.
Music ends
And Wendy says, we don't even actually know who first used the word. It's a good question, actually. I don't know the answer to that question. But we know who first and best wrote about its emergence.
Discussion continues
Adam Smith was a philosopher who was born in Scotland 300 years ago. Like Wendy, he was very smart. He was kind of some sort of genius who went to university at the age of 14, I think.
Music plays briefly
He studied first in his native Scotland, then he went on to Oxford like Wendy. He had a bit of a sickly constitution. He didn't think much of Oxford and wrote to his mother asking for her to send some socks or stockings because he was cold.
Music ends
He became a philosopher, wrote a book called The Theory of Moral Sentiments in 1759, moved to France, became a tutor. Get a job, long hair.
Discussion continues
While he was there, he started writing The Wealth of Nations. It took him 10 years to finish. A decade? Really?
Music plays briefly
Smith was describing what he saw around him. It sounds simple, and shockingly, it really sort of is. There was private property, there were firms, and those firms wanted to make profits, and there wasn't a king or a czar or a president, God forbid, making all of this happen.
Music ends
It was as if an occult hand, an invisible hand, were guiding everything. The invisible hand is a phrase that was introduced by Adam Smith, and he was pointing out that in order for a butcher or a baker or a candlestick maker to make an income, he had to produce something that somebody wanted to buy.
Discussion continues
And therefore in the process of promoting his own interests and looking to his own profit, he ended up serving the interests of his customers.
Music plays briefly
Was what Adam Smith was describing a natural process? No, I don't think you can describe it as natural. It's a particular form of economic organization.
Music ends
It's a totally fascinating one. So it has very special characteristics, but it's not a kind of natural thing. It's also not something that in some sense had to be. It wasn't predetermined.
Discussion continues
Adam Smith writes Wealth of Nations in 1776, also that year, a little country is born.
Music plays briefly
Can you get us into the recent present? So global capitalism got going in England in the 18th century. If we jump into the 20th century, then we start to see firms owned in the United States introducing new technology.
Music ends
Ladies, are you tired of room temperature food just strewn about all over your kitchen, expiring as soon as you get home from the store? Are your children constantly complaining about contracting salmonella? Well, it sounds like you need General Electric's newest invention, the refrigerator.
Discussion continues
Taking advantage of economies of scale so a growing market a large domestic market and a lot of innovations were coming from America in the 1920s.
Music plays briefly
And then what's so striking is that that gets kind of snuffed out by the Depression. It was panicked. 16 and a half million shares of stock sold in a single day.
Music ends
A macroeconomic failure, a failure of the organisation of the economy as a whole and of the way it's being managed by the government.
Discussion continues
The United States was particularly hit by lots and lots of banking failures. New lines appear on American streets, depositors swarming to snatch out what savings they have left before it's too late.
Music plays briefly
And it had failures of farms, failures in agriculture, failures of firms. And that's when mass unemployment emerged in the United States.
Music ends
A report from Detroit says men are sitting in the parks all day long, out of work, muttering to themselves. During the Depression, everything had failed. The banks, the farms, the firms.
Discussion continues
It was not enough to laissez-et-faire. The invisible hand was elsewhere, and something needed to intervene. That something was the government.
Music plays briefly
Now, having lived through COVID, when a lot of us were getting government stimmy checks, this is old hat. But at the time, it was revolutionary.
Music ends
And the gentleman who introduced this revolutionary idea was one John Maynard Keynes. As events have turned out, change has been forced on us, under circumstances extraordinarily fortunate and favorable.
Discussion continues
His idea was that if it failed, capitalism sometimes needed the government's very visible hand. You know, with the idea that the state has an obligation to support people who are unemployed, for example, that the state has an obligation to intervene to ensure that the economy doesn't fall into the grips of persistent weak aggregate demand and high unemployment.
Music plays briefly
And then that capitalism is one that produces rather extraordinary results. That's the period during which there was the fastest capital accumulation.
Music ends
In other words, the fastest growth of machinery and equipment of the capital stock in the United States and in the other high-income countries.
Discussion continues
And it was an extraordinary epoch because those benefits of growth were shared. You could say that sharing prosperity shifted the balance of power away from the owners, away from capitalists or away from profits, if you like, towards workers.
Music plays briefly
The share of wages went up. This was a period when unions were quite strong, so they were able to get wage increases to enable them to share that prosperity, including right down to workers who only had high school education.
Music ends
Is there a word for that time? If we were to trace it from Adam Smith's invisible hand to Keynesianism, oh, now there's some government hand, you're saying in the 1960s something kind of explodes.
Discussion continues
What is the capitalism of that period? So the 1950s and 60s is often referred to as the golden age of capitalism. So two decades of golden age, or sometimes it's called the glorious three decades, so you can sort of count it in different ways.
Music plays briefly
But it's the golden age. Now, for every American golden age, there's a college class telling us it didn't really happen that way, or there's a Florida high school history textbook insisting that it did.
Music ends
The historical fact is that the golden age of capitalism was wonderful for the people it included, but it often excluded women, Black people, Hispanics, gay people, among others.
Discussion continues
And those groups of people knew this. And then they, along with the sweep of history, conspired to change it. And when it all shook out, capitalism was changed forever.
Music plays briefly
In July of 1964, on a hot summer night, some residents of Rochester, New York, threw a block party. A young man got drunk, and when the police tried to arrest him, he got disorderly.
Music ends
Bystanders took issue with the degree of force the police were using, and no one exactly knows who threw the first brick. As you can see now, we're in front of a public safety building where the members of the state police brought in here to relieve Rochester police officers at the scene of the rioting.
Discussion continues
After that, black residents of Rochester started to organize against police force and then against so much else. The golden age of capitalism passing them by. No, no more.
Music plays briefly
They demanded the city's most prominent employer, Eastman Kodak, the camera company, start hiring Black people. At the time, it didn't hire many.
Music ends
The activists wanted to push this big corporation to actually just do what was fair. But part of that meant engaging with the burgeoning civil rights movement.
Discussion continues
Now, during that time period, many activists, many ordinary Americans went out in the streets to protest. The activists from Rochester took their fight out of the streets and to Kodak's annual shareholder meeting in New Jersey.
Music plays briefly
They staged a protest outside. They humiliated this big company. Kodak backed down. It promised to start a job training program for Black residents of its home city, Rochester.
Music ends
A corporation had just been forced to, and agreed to, take a position on civil rights. It was the 60s. Those were the times.
Discussion continues
This was the start. Two men were living this history. One was an economist, and the other was an activist. One man thought the purpose of a corporation like Kodak was to make money and nothing more.
Music plays briefly
The other man insisted that corporations had to do better by the people and the communities where they worked and by the planet.
Music ends
One of those men, one of those points of view, would win decisively. And that, and he, I will argue, is why we're all so angry today.
Discussion continues
Noelle King
That's coming up on the next episode of Blame Capitalism. Today's episode was produced by Miles Bryan. We had original music and skits by the great John Ahrens.
Music plays briefly
Our editor is the equally great Matthew Collette. And we had additional editing from Jolie Myers and Miranda Kennedy.
Music ends
Laura Bullard is our fact checker. Our engineers are David Herman and Patrick Boyd. Special thanks to writer Max Bernstein.
Music plays briefly
Be like Max. If you see capitalism out in the wild, call us, DM us, text us, tweet us, X us.
Music ends
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained.