Podcast Episode Summary:
The podcast episode, "John Bolton: Trump's National Security Advisor," discusses the appointment of John Bolton as the new National Security Advisor to President Trump. The episode delves into Bolton's background, his hawkish views on foreign policy, and his potential impact on the administration's foreign policy.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Zack Beauchamp
And I'm Zack Beauchamp. Today, we're talking about John Bolton, the new National Security Advisor.
Sean Rameswaram
President Trump announced Bolton's appointment just as the White House prepares for historic talks with North Korea.
Zack Beauchamp
That's right. And just last month, Bolton called for pre-emptive strikes on North Korea.
Sean Rameswaram
In 2015, he endorsed war with Iran. So, let's start with the basics. What exactly does the National Security Advisor do?
Zack Beauchamp
The National Security Advisor is basically the curator of what the president sees and hears on foreign policy. Their job is to sort through all the information and policy recommendations that they're getting from everybody else, give the president an assessment of what the advisor thinks, and also an honest summary of what all the different things are, and then ultimately present a set of recommendations to the president.
Sean Rameswaram
This person is the principal filter in the way that the president understands the world. And this is a position that does not require a Senate confirmation of any kind?
Zack Beauchamp
That's right. Because it's not a technical cabinet position like a secretary. You don't have to go through the Senate confirmation process.
Sean Rameswaram
No one's going to ask questions of, say, the nominee, John Bolton. No, there's no nominee whatsoever. They've already announced the timetable for Bolton taking over McMaster's position. And when is it?
Zack Beauchamp
April 9th.
Sean Rameswaram
April 9th. Very soon. So what does it mean that our new National Security Advisor will be John Bolton?
Zack Beauchamp
Oh, boy. John Bolton. He is maybe the most hawkish man in America. He loves war. He doesn't put it like that. But whenever there's a problem, you can count on John Bolton proposing war as a solution for it.
Sean Rameswaram
He said the solution to Iran's nuclear program is that we should bomb Iran. Just as Israel twice before has struck nuclear weapons programs in the hands of hostile states.
Zack Beauchamp
I'm afraid, given the circumstances, that's the only real option open to us now.
Sean Rameswaram
He was a big supporter of the Iraq war. He still thinks the Iraq war was a good idea.
Zack Beauchamp
He has said the solution to North Korea's nuclear program is, you guessed it, bomb North Korea.
Sean Rameswaram
Anybody who thinks that more diplomacy with North Korea or sanctions is just giving North Korea more time to increase its nuclear arsenal, increase its ballistic missile capability, increase the accuracy of its guidance systems, and put us, South Korea, and Japan in more jeopardy.
Zack Beauchamp
The basic setup is John Bolton sees a rogue state and he thinks the solution to it is found in a bomber bay.
Sean Rameswaram
What is his story? Where does he come from? Is he related to Michael?
Zack Beauchamp
I'd like a more musical national security advisor. Yeah, me too.
Sean Rameswaram
So John Bolton has been like a fixture in D.C. for a really long time in Republican politics.
Zack Beauchamp
He's been an attorney and a consultant. He really first came to prominence in the George W. Bush administration.
Sean Rameswaram
Bush hired him to be the undersecretary of state for arms control, basically managing U.S. diplomacy surrounding weapons of mass destruction and other general weapons. weapons proliferation issues.
Zack Beauchamp
And this is before 9-11 or after 9-11?
Sean Rameswaram
This is before 9-11.
Zack Beauchamp
Okay. After 9-11, that became a really important job. I imagine.
Sean Rameswaram
Bolton played a major role in the run-up to the Iraq war.
Zack Beauchamp
Bolton played a role in helping politicize intelligence on issues of weapons of mass destruction.
Sean Rameswaram
So, for example, he once decided he wanted to give a speech alleging that Cuba had a biological weapons program.
Zack Beauchamp
This was not true. A State Department intelligence analyst objected and was like, you can't have this language in your speech, it's not true.
Sean Rameswaram
And so Bolton calls this guy into his office. He screams at the guy, calls for the guy's boss, talks to the boss for a while, refers to the analyst derisively as a munchkin for some reason, maybe he was short, and then says that the guy should be transferred to another department.
Zack Beauchamp
Now the boss stood up for his subordinate. And so Bolton didn't get what he wanted here.
Sean Rameswaram
But what he did do is help create a climate of fear among intelligence analysts not just in the State Department but across the different bureaucracies about dissenting from the administration line on WMD.
Zack Beauchamp
And, you know, if you look at some of the documents there and internal conversations with Bush administration people, they'll say this helped prevent dissent from being surfaced on Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program.
Sean Rameswaram
Which was, of course, the reason why the invasion happened in the first place.
Zack Beauchamp
Bolton is unrepentant about all of this.
Sean Rameswaram
It's especially funny because Trump once tweeted that all Bush administration officials involved in the Iraq war should be discredited.
Zack Beauchamp
And here he is promoting someone who had a really important role in messing with intelligence before the war.
Sean Rameswaram
Who bears a lot of blame for the fuck up that happened.
Zack Beauchamp
This doesn't make him very popular within his department, but how does the administration feel about John Bolton?
Sean Rameswaram
Oh, they promote him.
Zack Beauchamp
President Bush intends to nominate John Bolton to be our next ambassador to the United Nations.
Sean Rameswaram
One of the most important diplomatic posts in the entire government.
Zack Beauchamp
Which is to say George W. Bush very much liked this John Bolton character.
Sean Rameswaram
Correct.
Zack Beauchamp
Okay. And Bolton's not a dumb guy.
Sean Rameswaram
I want to be clear. He really believes in war, and he is a huge asshole to a lot of the people around him.
Zack Beauchamp
But he's smart.
Sean Rameswaram
The issue is not intelligence or even competence at managing the bureaucracy, which has been the case with other Trump administration employees.
Zack Beauchamp
It's that he's sinister.
Sean Rameswaram
So Bush elevated him for whatever Bush's reasons were.
Zack Beauchamp
But the Senate was not interested. In John Bolton as ambassador to the U.N.
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, which is a Senate confirmable position.
Zack Beauchamp
OK. And the reasons why were twofold.
Sean Rameswaram
First, there was the Iraq intelligence issue, because that obviously was in the middle of the war turning into a disaster.
Zack Beauchamp
And everyone was really upset at the politicized intelligence.
Sean Rameswaram
The second issue was something I alluded to earlier, which is the way that he treats his subordinates.
Zack Beauchamp
So this incident with this intelligence analyst that he yelled at is not a one-off.
Sean Rameswaram
There's another incident from the 90s where a federal contractor named Melody Townsall tried to raise questions about something Bolden was working on at the time, a USAID project.
Zack Beauchamp
Bolton, instead of thanking her for blowing the whistle on problems with the contract, Followed her around a hotel in Moscow, screaming at her.
Sean Rameswaram
By her account, he throws stuff at her.
Zack Beauchamp
She gets so scared that she hides in her hotel room.
Sean Rameswaram
And then he slips angry notes under her hotel door after she stays there for days.
Zack Beauchamp
And have these stories been corroborated?
Sean Rameswaram
At the time, during the 2005 Senate hearing, Joe Biden was the ranking Democrat.
Zack Beauchamp
And he said there were five different people alleging multiple allegations of Bolton politicizing intelligence or mistreating subordinates.
Sean Rameswaram
Carl Ford, who was in the State Department with him, very conservative Republican, said that Bolton's M.O. was kissing up and punching down.
Zack Beauchamp
So he doesn't get confirmed to the U.N.?
Sean Rameswaram
No, and Republicans controlled the Senate at the time.
Zack Beauchamp
Okay. So this wasn't a partisan thing.
Sean Rameswaram
It was that he seemed like a guy who was unfit for high office.
Zack Beauchamp
Wow.
Sean Rameswaram
So Bush appointed him to the U.N. job as a recess appointment, basically going around Congress.
Zack Beauchamp
He could never make it through the Senate and only lasted about a year in the job.
Sean Rameswaram
Because his recess appointment ran out.
Zack Beauchamp
Yeah, and he couldn't be confirmed.
Sean Rameswaram
And he famously shows up to the UN after saying something like you could chop off the top 10 floors of the building and it wouldn't make a difference.
Zack Beauchamp
I believe that might be the exact quote.
Sean Rameswaram
Not the best opening salvo for a UN ambassador.
Zack Beauchamp
Love to have a UN ambassador who thinks the UN is bad.
Sean Rameswaram
He railed against a lot of people at the UN, but actually didn't get a lot done because he was pretty isolated in the Bush administration at that point.
Zack Beauchamp
But early on, he was winning a lot of bureaucratic battles.
Sean Rameswaram
So what's he been up to since basically losing in the George W. Bush administration?
Zack Beauchamp
Oh, he's been on Fox News pretty much the entire time.
Sean Rameswaram
Perfect, because it's a 24-7 channel.
Zack Beauchamp
Yeah, he's always there.
Sean Rameswaram
Fox News contributor John Bolton.
Zack Beauchamp
Fox News contributor.
Sean Rameswaram
Turn on Fox News, there's John Bolton.
Zack Beauchamp
You go to a conservative conference, there's John Bolton.
Sean Rameswaram
Some of these events, by the way, are quite troubling.
Zack Beauchamp
So he has really close ties to a group of radical anti-Muslim extremists.
Sean Rameswaram
Oh, no.
Zack Beauchamp
Sort of call themselves counter jihadists this again yeah this again um here at the forward to a book by pamela geller and robert spencer who are two of the most prominent anti-islam activists in the united states they part of a broad ideological movement called the counter jihad that believes that the u is being quietly infiltrated by islamic extremists and that mainstream muslim american organizations like the council on american islamic relations are secret fronts for terrorist groups engaging in something they call civilizational jihad and these people have proposed to shut down something like 80 of all mosques in the united states
Sean Rameswaram
Bolton doesn't outright espouse their views he sort of cozies up with them.
Zack Beauchamp
He sees them as kind of supporters and worthwhile thinkers.
Sean Rameswaram
You can't imagine someone who wrote a forward to an avowedly anti-Semitic book being the National Security Advisor.
Zack Beauchamp
But this is like that.
Sean Rameswaram
Except this time we've got a president who proposed a Muslim ban and watches a lot of Fox News.
Zack Beauchamp
And if you connect a couple of dots here, John Bolton all of a sudden makes a little bit of sense.
Sean Rameswaram
He sure does.
So how do we think he and Donald Trump got connected?
Zack Beauchamp
Fox News.
Sean Rameswaram
Oh.
Zack Beauchamp
It's pretty clear, yeah.
Sean Rameswaram
But is that just what we think because he watches a lot of Fox News and he's on Fox News a lot?
Zack Beauchamp
Look, Trump loves watching TV.
Sean Rameswaram
We know that Trump staffs his administration with people who he sees on TV defending him, like Larry Kudlow, the CNBC pundit, who just got appointed to a top economics post.
Zack Beauchamp
And there's like a few other ones.
Sean Rameswaram
The overall situation is one in which Trump sees people on TV, he likes that, and that's who he wants working for him in the government.
Zack Beauchamp
More with Zach Beauchamp just ahead.
Sean Rameswaram
We're going to find out how this Bolton appointment might change United States' foreign policy.
Theme music starts playing
Before that, here's this. A fresh take on a Bolton classic.
When a Trump loves a Bolton Seeing his face on Fox News He'd trade off McMaster for more hawkish views He don't need the United Nations Said he could lose ten floors Who needs the UN when you only want war?
When a Trump loves a Bolton Ignores the Iraq defeat Forgets George W. and WMDs He won't need confirmation And it don't matter that he's brash Now we're running North Korea Gotta deal with that mustache
When a Trump loves a Bolton Thank you.
Platform teams, customers, and partners about best practices from security to machine learning and more.
You can subscribe to the podcast at g.co slash gcppodcast.
This is Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Zack Beauchamp
And I'm Zack Beauchamp.
Sean Rameswaram
He hosts the Worldly Podcast at Vox.
Zack Beauchamp
This is a really, really big deal.
Sean Rameswaram
Bolton is now in charge of the White House's foreign policy.
Zack Beauchamp
He is in charge of managing it.
Sean Rameswaram
He's in charge of dealing with the cabinet secretaries.
Zack Beauchamp
He is Trump's principal lifeline to the world.
Sean Rameswaram
And he believes fundamentally that we need to go to war.
Zack Beauchamp
Multiple different wars at once.
Sean Rameswaram
Wars that could have thousands, tens of thousands, millions of casualties, potentially in the case of North Korea.
Zack Beauchamp
And he wants to put U troops in harm way because he believes the threat to the United States is so dire that there no other solution.
Sean Rameswaram
Almost every expert disagrees with him in these two cases.
Zack Beauchamp
Bolton doesn't care.
Sean Rameswaram
He believes that he's right, and it's very possible that he'll get his way.
Zack Beauchamp
Are there any forces in the Trump administration who might provide a counter-argument in scenarios where, let's say, something terrible happens, There's an attack.
Sean Rameswaram
The last bastion of hope here is Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis.
Zack Beauchamp
Not only is Mattis widely understood to be a force for restraint inside the White House, but Trump likes him.
Sean Rameswaram
I don't know if it's because he stays out of the media.
Zack Beauchamp
I don't know what the reasons are, but he is the person who has been anchoring American foreign policy in the Trump era.
Sean Rameswaram
And his job seems for the time being to be relatively safe.
Zack Beauchamp
It's interesting that you're saying that the introduction of John Bolton into this administration speaks to this increasingly hawkish cabinet, and the one person maybe holding it back is a general.
Sean Rameswaram
A general whose nickname is Mad Dog.
Zack Beauchamp
Got it.
Sean Rameswaram
So we've got General Mad Dog Mattis on one end.
Zack Beauchamp
Who's in the other camp over there with Bolton?
Sean Rameswaram
Secretary of State, well, soon to be, if he's confirmed, Mike Pompeo, is quite hawkish, is also called for bombing Iran.
Zack Beauchamp
Right. It's not clear if he thinks war with North Korea is a good idea, but he's sort of hinted at it.
Sean Rameswaram
Mike Pence, also relatively hawkish.
Zack Beauchamp
Yeah, those are sort of the top influences on foreign policy.
Sean Rameswaram
So what does it mean then for our foreign policy that the people with the president's ear are John Bolton, Mike Pompeo?
Zack Beauchamp
It means that every crisis has a higher risk of escalating than it did before.
Sean Rameswaram
Foreign policy is all about unpredictable crises coming up and having to manage them.
Zack Beauchamp
You know, Trump hasn't had a big, genuinely world-changing event like the Arab Spring that Obama had to deal with.
Sean Rameswaram
And in those situations, he will have to react based on a sort of impulse and best consensus advice.
Zack Beauchamp
We know Trump can be pushed.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a real chance that these people could persuade him towards a more militaristic reaction.
Zack Beauchamp
What about the president himself? His reluctance to go to war? His constant reminder during his campaign that he thought the Iraq war was a huge mistake.
Sean Rameswaram
Well, first of all, that was a lie.
Zack Beauchamp
Are you for invading Iraq?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, I guess so.
Zack Beauchamp
You know, I wish it was, I wish the first time it was done correctly.
Sean Rameswaram
He endorsed the Iraq war before it happened and only afterwards was like bad idea.
Zack Beauchamp
So don't let him get away with that.
Sean Rameswaram
I think also in general, this idea that Donald Trump is some kind of instinctive dove is really ridiculous.
Zack Beauchamp
He has called for all kinds of crazy uses of military force.
Sean Rameswaram
Like in Iraq, he wanted to annex Iraqi oil fields.
Zack Beauchamp
I've always said, shouldn't be there, but if we're going to get out, take the oil.
Sean Rameswaram
If we would have taken the oil, you wouldn't have ISIS.
Zack Beauchamp
Like, that's colonialism.
Sean Rameswaram
But it is really telling because it shows that his impulse is that he wants to maximize gains for the United States and doesn't care about the consequences.
Zack Beauchamp
Does that scare you?
Sean Rameswaram
I don't know.
Zack Beauchamp
I've gone back and forth in this administration between normal levels of fear about the world and, like, real panic about this particular situation.
Sean Rameswaram
Now I'm back on the real panic train.
Zack Beauchamp
The last time was when we were in like really tight tensions with North Korea.
Sean Rameswaram
And then we had good news on that front.
Zack Beauchamp
We did and thought that, you know, maybe there'd be sit down negotiations and those could be at least temporarily, you know, calm things down.
Sean Rameswaram
But now Bolton is out there being like, look, he should meet with Kim because it'll prove to be a disaster and then we can go to war.
Zack Beauchamp
Well, fuck.
Sean Rameswaram
That was the worst case scenario as a result of these talks that like they piss off Trump and he hates talking to Kim.
Zack Beauchamp
And the result is that he gets mad and wants to do something to retaliate against North Korea.
Sean Rameswaram
But like now we have someone in the White House who's actively rooting for the worst case scenario.
Zack Beauchamp
War with North Korea would kill so many people.
Sean Rameswaram
So many people.
to other smart people about all of Google's cloud technology.
Learn more and subscribe to the podcast at g.co slash gcppodcast.