Main Topic: The SWIFT system, a messaging service used by banks to facilitate international payments, and its role in the recent sanctions imposed on Russia.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noelle King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
A few weeks ago on the show, we talked to the historian Nicholas Mulder. He wrote a book about the history of economic sanctions and whether or not they work. And his answer was not so much, although the U.S. keeps trying.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
In most cases, I think it's clear that if the goal of those sanctions was behavioral change, only a very small amount of them have worked or they've worked only a little bit, but not actually fully.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
But if the U.S. and Europe don't want to get involved in a ground or air or sea war with Russia, hitting its financial sector is one of the only options.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
On February 26, the U.S., Canada, and European allies announced they had committed to kicking some Russian banks out of SWIFT.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
On today's show, we explain what SWIFT is.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies.
Discussion continues with Noelle King speaking
To explain what SWIFT is, we called Emily Peck, a markets reporter for Axios.
Emily Peck
It stands for the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication, but it just goes by SWIFT.
Who came up with that name?
I'm not sure exactly who came up with that name, but it is a cooperative of financial organizations all based in Belgium.
This dates back to the 1970s. Swift was founded to take over from a now very outdated technology.
So in times of non-invasion, in times of non-war, what does Swift do?
Okay, so this has been really an interesting journey for me, Noelle, because I'm not a longtime Swift expert by any means, like many of us just getting up to speed during this crisis.
And you might have seen already Swift described as a messaging service used by banks.
And that is correct. You can think of Swift as the backbone of the financial services sector.
About half of all high-value payments across borders go through Swift.
It links more than 11,000 banks in 200-plus countries.
But what I think people might not understand and what kind of does take a while to grok is that when you're moving money around the world, the message is everything, right?
It's not like someone's like mailing cash or checks to another bank or financial institution.
You tell a bank or you yourself wanna move money. So you send a message.
You say, I'm moving $100 to Noelle and sending it to her bank in this place.
And here is the bank number.
And that message is really what is so important.
And without a system that lets all the different banks and institutions easily send these messages to each other, it becomes very difficult to transfer money between countries.
And that is what SWIFT is doing is transferring money between countries, bank to bank.
And this is a thing that I don't think I understood until you just said it.
SWIFT is a messaging service, but SWIFT is not the thing sending me $100.
It's the thing sending the message that says, I, Emily, am sending Noelle $100.
Exactly. Yes.
Someone described it to me like an ATM.
You go to the ATM and you deposit your $100 in there.
And like, that's what matters.
No little man is inside the ATM machine like holding on to my money or anything like that.
It's the message is everything.
And you know, the banks will settle up.
They kind of like net out the money.
You know what I mean?
Because they're sending money back and forth all the time.
This is a worldwide financial messaging system.
Russia is part of the world.
Russia is using SWIFT.
And then Russia invades Ukraine.
And what happens between Russia and SWIFT?
Well, at first, nothing.
Nothing happens at all.
SWIFT keeps being SWIFTY.
Russian banks and companies and people still use it to send their money.
But then there starts to be this kind of outcry.
There are major things they've not done.
No block on Russia's energy market and no move to block Russia from a system called SWIFT, an interbanking messaging platform that enables global payments.
The U.S. and the EU and other Western allies start talking about sanctions and you start hearing like they want to possibly cut Russia off from SWIFT.
And then a big announcement about sanctions comes out last week.
Putin chose this war, and now he and his country will bear the consequences.
The U.S. and EU, they cut off Russian banks' access to the United States financial system, but they do not cut off SWIFT.
The sanctions that we have proposed on all their banks have equal consequence, maybe more consequence than SWIFT, number one.
Number two it is always an option but right now that not the position that the rest of Europe wishes to take
Everybody at this point after Russia invades Ukraine the West is really upset
They're looking for things they can do to punish Russia.
And it would seem like cutting Russian banks off from SWIFT would be a really easy way to, like, knock them for a loop.
Why doesn't that happen?
Well, it doesn't happen right away because I think it's seen as, like, someone described it to me as the ultimate sanction.
Oh.
It's considered like a very big deal for, I guess, for a couple of reasons.
One, Swift likes to say it's not political.
It tries to be more of a neutral mechanism.
And once you start monkeying with neutral mechanisms and using them as political weapons, you change the nature of the service.
Second, the sanctions they initially took against the Russian banks, cutting them off from the U.S. financial system, asset freezes, things like that.
The argument was this is going to be a bigger deal than the SWIFT cutoff.
SWIFT cutoff is symbolic, but these bank sanctions are going to be a bigger deal.
So initially that's why SWIFT was left out.
But then, the Ukrainian minister of foreign affairs, as we say in these times, he took to Twitter and he tweeted the next day, you must ban Russia from SWIFT and kick it out of everywhere.
We demand and we need immediate steps to impose a full financial isolation of Russia from all civilized systems, applying to all Russian banks, including its central bank.
And this idea that you must ban Russia from SWIFT really took off.
And I guess it went viral in as much as a wonky financial transaction messaging service based in Belgium can go viral.
It did.
And so then what happened was the U.S., the EU said, you know what?
I will now propose to EU leaders the following measures.
First, we commit to ensuring that a certain number of Russian banks are removed from SWIFT.
We learned seven Russian banks were going to be banned from SWIFT.
That hasn't gone into effect yet.
And they left out the biggest Russian bank, Spurbank.
They also left out a bank that's partly owned by Russian gas giant Gazprom from the Swift ban.
And the reason those two giants were left out is because one thing that the US and the EU and everyone has been concerned about in levying these sanctions has been Russia's oil and gas sector.
Russia supplies around a third of Europe's gas.
And the latest figures show imports have actually increased since its invasion of Ukraine.
People want the oil and gas from Russia to keep flowing to Europe.
And there was concern that if these big players were cut out of SWIFT, it would be harder to sell the oil and gas.
There's this notion of self-inflicted punishment, right?
I mean, cutting Russian oil and gas from Europe would be pretty devastating for Europe.
Prices are already shooting up higher for oil and gas, and nothing's really changed.
Just the idea that these markets could be disrupted has sent prices soaring.
If it actually happens and the oil and gas is shut off, that would be devastating for Germany, for Italy, for all these economies.
And I think there is not an appetite for that.
Once a bank is cut off from SWIFT, who notices it first?
Is it like some guy or gal in front of a terminal saying, oh, where'd my money go?
Where are my messages?
Like, how is this realized, IRL?
The seven banks have been notified.
I think they have 10 days to sort of get ready.
So it's not like some guy at a bank is going to all of a sudden not be able to access it.
The people who might be surprised would be people living in Russia.
Because you could go on a service like Wise, where it lets you transfer money internationally.
And so you could use a service, could be anyone, to send money to your relatives.
And people in Russia want to get their money out of the country.
So they might log on to an app or something to try and do that, and they won't be able to.
So like so many of these complicated how-do-we-punish-people questions, this is one of those things that may end up punishing ordinary Russian people rather than like Vladimir Putin and his cronies who all have wealth stashed in houses and yachts and bank accounts elsewhere.
I think about this all the time.
I think everyone's thinking about this.
We've seen already pictures of Russian people waiting on ATM lines and things like that.
All these sanctions are going to weigh heavily on the Russian people.
And while it might be hard for them to get their money out of Russia, big money always finds a way.
The U.S. and its allies are going after wealthy oligarchs and such, but just like you said, they have money stashed all around the world in all kinds of places and all kinds of assets, and it's going to be hard to find them all.
Noelle King
Support for today's show comes from Adio.
Emily Peck
What is Adio?
Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up.
And within seconds, you will have your email and calendars synced.
You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
And they say you can build AI automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters building your company
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile Replicate Modal and so much more
You can go to atio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Noelle King
Why shop at Burlington?
Emily Peck
Maybe it's the deals that are new each time you drop by.
Maybe it's the brand names you'll be shocked Burlington has in store.
Or maybe it's the quality of the items, the amazing selection, and the newest trends.
If you like to save but also like to stay in style, Burlington is your answer.
And the question you'll be asking yourself is, why go anywhere else?
Burlington. Deals. Brands. Wow.
Noelle King
We're back with Emily Peck.
Emily Peck
She's a markets reporter with Axios.
And she's part of a team there that's putting together a new podcast called How It Happened, Putin's Invasion.
SWIFT, the cooperative of financial organizations that allows banks to send messages to each other, tries to stay out of geopolitics, which makes sense.
It wants to be a system for the world, and it can only do that if the whole world participates.
But when Russia invaded Ukraine, Canada, the U.S., and European allies instructed SWIFT to cut Russia off, and it did partially, by tossing off seven Russian banks.
It was a noteworthy move, but it's not the first time in recent history that this has happened.
The example everyone points to is Iran getting cut off from SWIFT, which happened back in 2012.
The European Union imposed the new sanctions to put pressure on Iran to suspend its program of uranium enrichment.
Western countries believe the program is designed to create nuclear weapons.
It was pretty devastating for the country.
It's Iran's bank customers who will feel the immediate effects.
When they find they're unable to make simple international banking transactions.
And then in the lead-up to negotiating the nuclear deal with Iran that the Obama administration put together, they rolled back those sanctions as like a sweetener to make the deal happen.
Happy crowds turned out to cheer the Iranian negotiators as they arrived back in Tehran.
Young people, especially, who hope the deal will bring jobs and revive the economy.
And when you say it was devastating for Iran, in what way?
What did that look like?
They weren't able to send money to buy things.
It was hard for the people who live in Iran, but the country itself was able to kind of find a way through it.
It wasn't pretty, but as with so many things, it's the regular people who get hurt the most.
March 1st, 2022, St. Petersburg, Russia.
We just arrived here.
It's like the only ATM in the entire city that's available.
We got screamed at by the guards telling us that there's no money in the ATM whether we should leave immediately.
Noelle King
Today Explained did an episode about how Russia has its own version of NATO called the CSTO, the Collective Security Treaty Organization.
Emily Peck
I think Russia would like to see it as Russia's NATO.
NATO definitely doesn't view it as that.
Right now, aside from Russia, it has five other members, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan in Central Asia, Armenia, Belarus, and of course, Kazakhstan.
And this made me wonder, in all honesty, as I've been hearing about SWIFT, is there a Russian version of SWIFT?
Yeah.
Russia has developed its own financial messaging system, but it doesn't have very many financial institutions.
SWIFT has more than 11,000.
Russia has, according to Bloomberg's reporting, fewer than 400, and very few are international.
So Russia has a version of SWIFT, but the point of a messaging system is to be in touch with as many institutions as possible.
That's how you get money around the world.
And if it's only in touch with 400 other financial institutions, it's a version of SWIFT, but it's kind of like a bootleg version of SWIFT.
I've been thinking about it like a social network.
It's only as good as the amount of people who show up to it every day.
So, like, remember when President Donald Trump got kicked off Twitter and tried to go to other platforms?
He's trying to start his own thing now.
It's like, okay. You have to have critical mass for a messaging network or any kind of network to actually work.
I imagine that world powers that are in difficult diplomatic relationships with the West look at SWIFT and think, hmm, there's this tool that the U.S. and the EU have that can really put our citizens in a difficult place financially, which no government wants because that tends to be one of the ways that governments get overthrown.
So I'm wondering in particular about China, right?
Obviously vying with the United States for the position of leading world power.
Does China have a version of SWIFT?
Yes, China has a messaging service also.
China's cross-border interbank payment system, otherwise known as SIPs, has been striving to become a highway for the Chinese yuan.
But just like Russia, it's mostly connected to other Chinese financial institutions.
It's not anywhere near where SWIFT is in terms of global connections.
And the other problem is China's currency is just not used that much.
The global currency is the dollar.
Yeah. Most payments in the world are in dollars.
China has a messaging service. It's not very international.
But, I mean, I think you are right to ask that question.
And I think SWIFT doesn't want to be used politically because if people start to view it as a political tool, then it makes it less desirable.
If some world powers see SWIFT as this system that might kick them out, surely at some point China and Russia and other countries that are not allied with the United States and with the West are going to sit down together and say, we're going to do our own version of this and we're going to make it big and we're going to make it work.
And the West can do its thing and we'll do our thing.
And then we have chaos.
Right.
And definitely people are worried about that.
But right now I not because of the power of the dollar compared to the power of the yuan.
Obviously the ruble is not very powerful at this moment.
It just not comparable
I don't think anyone wants a currency issued by an autocracy to be the one that rules them all.
I mean, China manages its economy very closely.
We saw, I think it was last year, they decided that their big public companies were getting too big and they stopped IPOs from happening.
I don't think anyone would want to rely on the yuan as like the global currency of choice.
You have to transact in dollars. You have to transact in euros.
SWIFT is how you do that.
We now have seven banks in Russia cut off.
And we have people in Russia who are going to suffer because of it.
And we have Russia surely looking for a solution.
I know that people keep bringing up cryptocurrency and the possibility.
People keep bringing up the specter of cryptocurrency and whether Russia might be able to use cryptocurrencies to get around these institutional banking systems that, in this case, have kicked them off partially.
I don't think you need to worry about that very much because crypto needs on-ramps and, more importantly, crypto needs off-ramps.
So you can put your money into crypto, you can buy the crypto, you can buy the Bitcoin, but you have to then convert it back into something, right?
I can't take my Bitcoin to the store yet, mostly, and buy stuff.
So when you off-ramp the Bitcoin, that's where you're going to touch financial institutions that are subject to all these sanctions and you're hit a dead end.
If Russia continues this aggressive posture, if it keeps on with the war in Ukraine, if Vladimir Putin won't back down, do you think there is a world in which the folks at SWIFT, people in the EU and the U.S. get together and say, we are going to kick those two big Russian banks off?
They're done.
Or is that just not going to happen because of the, as you said earlier, you're punishing them, but you're actually punishing yourself dilemma?
I don't want to make any predictions right now because the swiftness, if you'll pardon my word choice.
The swiftness of the EU and the U.S. to levy these sanctions, how quickly they did it and how severe they've been and how they keep adding on more to the pile, I wouldn't rule it out.
Ever since the days of globalization, and I'm thinking about like the early 90s, we have heard many smart people say there are no more borders. There's just capital.
And capital flows through countries and through systems, through the mechanism of messaging systems like SWIFT.
Is the disconnection of Russian banks from SWIFT proof of anything about the way we talk about globalization and the free flow of money?
Yes.
I mean, since the 90s, there's really been huge efforts to bring Russia into the global financial system.
Even when it was a bad actor, you know, even after Crimea, I mean, there were sanctions, but Russia was still a part of the global financial system.
Its wealthiest citizens have assets, like we said, all over the world.
The reason we're able to do sanctions right now to cut Russia out of SWIFT, etc., is because it was part of that big river of capital flowing through the world.
It was a player, so that gives us leverage to punish them, essentially.
By coming into the fold of capitalism, Russia opened itself up to this.
It opened itself up to the potential that it would be punished in this way.
Yeah, exactly.
And actually, since sanctions were levied back in 2014 after Russia invaded Crimea, it's been trying to kind of reduce its exposure to these kind of sanctions.
It's tried to build up currency reserves in currencies that are not the dollar.
It has a big pile of gold.
So it's tried to make itself less vulnerable to being a part of the global financial system.
But even for all that, it was still quite vulnerable to the global financial system.
Do you think this moment in history where Russia is facing these unprecedented economic sanctions and is deciding it's going to have to find different ways to do business and different ways to protect itself.
It wants to deintegrate from the global economy.
Do you think that could be a trend going forward?
That other countries decide we don't want to be part of the global economic system because it makes us vulnerable?
I do think that could be a trend going forward.
I think a slow-moving trend, but a lot of smart financial columnists and observers and so on have been talking about this a lot the past week or two.
Like, in these sanctions and this economic warfare, we've seen the U.S. and its allies engage in using the dollar as a weapon and demonstrating just how strong that weapon can be.
At the same time, maybe that's the apex for the dollar.
Maybe now that show of strength leads Russia and countries like Russia to push harder to create something else.
Noelle King
Today's show was produced by Miles Bryan, edited by Matthew Collette, engineered by Afim Shapiro, and fact-checked by Laura Bullard.
Emily Peck
The rest of the team includes Halima Shah, Will Reed, Hadi Mawagdi, and Victoria Chamberlain.
Our supervising producer is Amina El-Sadi.
Vox's VP of audio is Liz Kelly Nelson.
We use music by Brickmaster Cylinder and Noam Hassenfeld.
I'm Noelle King.
Today Explained is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Thank you.