Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the potential ceasefire between Israel and Gaza, and how a Donald Trump presidency may impact the situation.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noelle King
Is a ceasefire between Israel and Gaza imminent? For the past 24 hours, there's been a flurry, a snowstorm even, of news suggesting yes. It begins with an Israeli negotiating team arriving in Qatar Monday. Tuesday, a senior Palestinian negotiator tells the BBC that talks are in a, quote, decisive and final phase. Then, according to Reuters, Benjamin Netanyahu makes a plan to go to Cairo, which his office denies. And today, CBS reports that William Burns, director of the CIA, is also on his way to Qatar. As all this began on Monday, President-elect Trump gave a press conference and gave a warning. I'll be very available on January 20th, and we'll see. As you know, I gave warning that if these hostages aren't back home by that date, all hell's going to break out.
Music transitions to a new segment
Coming up on Today Explained, can this new administration deliver a ceasefire in Gaza?
Ad for ServiceNow plays
Autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Ad for Senorita drinks plays
Having a night out with your friends is awesome. Dealing with hangovers sucks. Meet Senorita, the THC-infused margarita that lets you skip the booze but keep the vibe. Made with real fruit, organic agave, and Himalayan pink salt, every sip is like a mini getaway. No fillers, no hangovers, just full flavor and a better buzz. Find your flavor at senoritadrinks.com. Use code VOX20 for 20% off. Must be 21 and over. This product may cause intoxication. This product has not been evaluated or approved by the FDA. This product may contain up to 0.3% THC.
Music transitions back to the main segment
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King. Amir Tibban is the diplomatic correspondent for Haaretz. Amir was a resident of Nachal Az, which is a kibbutz near the Gaza border that Hamas militants attacked on October 7th, after which Amir wrote the book The Gates of Gaza. Amir, start by telling us where we are with the ceasefire negotiations.
Amir Tibban
We are closer today than yesterday and closer today than two, three and four months ago. But I would still urge people not to run into any kind of conclusions that we are on the verge of ending the war, that a ceasefire will be signed tomorrow, that the hostages are coming back in 48 hours.
Noelle King
There have been many attempts over the past year to square the circle on one specific issue, which is that Hamas demands that in return for the Israeli hostages, Israel will agree to end the war in Gaza completely, officially, with international safeguards and commitments by world powers that the war will not be renewed after the last Israeli hostage comes back from Gaza. And the Netanyahu government in Israel refuses to accept this demand and says that it is willing to accept a ceasefire, temporary, even a long ceasefire of many weeks or months, but not to officially end the war. Because if Hamas stays in power, it will regroup, rearm and attack Israel again and again and again as it is vowed to do. So Hamas has got to go.
Amir Tibban
At the heart of these negotiations are the hostages. How much of a priority are these hostages for Benjamin Netanyahu?
Noelle King
The families are certainly putting a lot of pressure on him. The release of the hostages for the Israeli public is the number one priority. You see it in all the public opinion polls. This is the most important issue to an overwhelming majority of Israelis.
Amir Tibban
And the hostages, we currently have 100 of them in the hands of the enemy. Approximately half of them are considered to be alive. But it sometimes seems that if there are Israelis who are a little less committed to the issue of the hostages, they somehow happen to sit in the government. Because you do have people in this government, especially the far-right elements of it, messianic, ultra-religious members of it, who have other priorities. They want to build settlements in Gaza.
Noelle King
Netanyahu is not in that category. Netanyahu doesn't really care for settlement in Gaza on an ideological or religious level. But the problem is he needs those people in order to remain in power.
Amir Tibban
And what we're seeing right now is a momentous struggle here in Israel between the families of the hostages and many, many, many Israelis who support them, who are pushing for a deal. And those far-right elements in the government who are much less committed to a deal. And Netanyahu in between, until this point, seemingly more on the side of his coalition partners.
Noelle King
How much does Trump mean for this war?
Amir Tibban
Trump's entry into the White House will change many, many things all over the world. But it seems that on the issue of the wars in Gaza and Lebanon, it has already been causing change even before he is in the White House. And we saw it certainly on Lebanon, where there is no doubt that the Israeli decision to go into the ceasefire was impacted, at least by Trump's desire to have that war end before he becomes president.
Noelle King
And what do Israelis think about Donald Trump coming back in?
Amir Tibban
Trump is very popular in Israel. I would say much more popular than any Israeli politician at this point in time. And he enjoys support from different parts of Israeli society. Israelis look at him as a president who was very supportive of Israel during his previous term in office. And also as someone that talks a bit like an Israeli, if you want to put it that way.
Noelle King
How so?
Amir Tibban
Brash, says exactly what he thinks, not always very sensitive to what others will think about his words. And, you know, I can see him getting quite well in a group of Israelis sitting in a cafe on Friday morning and talking about whatever is happening in the world.
Noelle King
I wonder, from your perspective there, what do you hear about what Palestinians think about Trump coming back into office?
Amir Tibban
There are mixed feelings about it, because a lot of Palestinians remember Trump from the first term being very much on the side of Israel and taking a very tough stance toward the Palestinians. And the biggest achievement of his foreign policy in the first term were the Abraham Accords, which from a Palestinian perspective were an attempt to sidestep the Palestinians, to turn them into a minor issue in the regional picture, to come and say Israel can make peace with the Arab world regardless of the Palestinians.
Noelle King
And I know that there has been some contact between Trump and the leader of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas. His Lebanese in-law, Masoud Boulos, has been the contact point for that relationship. And I guess we'll have to wait and see.
Amir Tibban
It's an open question at this point.
Noelle King
Joe Biden's National Security Advisor, Jake Sullivan, has been openly talking about working with his successor, who, of course, will be a member of Donald Trump's team. He said it's been professional and serious. And we've had good discussions, constructive and substantive discussions.
Amir Tibban
Do we know whether the outgoing and incoming administrations in the U.S. are working together on this at all?
Noelle King
On the hostage issue, I know that there are some levels of cooperation because the Biden administration is still officially running this file and trying to get a deal. But they are benefiting from the Trump effect. And there is some level of coordination, and I think it's important because it increases the likelihood of a deal actually being reached.
Amir Tibban
Amir Tibban, he's the diplomatic correspondent for Haaretz. He's also the author of The Gates of Gaza.
Noelle King
Coming up, Donald's second chance.
Ad for Chime plays
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Ad for The Guardian plays
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture.
Ad for Upwork plays
Support for Today Explained comes from Upwork. If you run a business you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time. With Upwork, you can find specialized freelancers in IT, web development, AI, design, admin support, marketing, and more experts who they say are ready to help you take your business to the next level.
This is Today Explained. Stephen, go ahead, give me your full name and tell me what you do.
Stephen Cook
Stephen A. Cook. I'm a senior fellow for Middle East and Africa Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations.
Noelle King
In the first half of the show, we talked about what a Donald Trump presidency, A second one might mean for the war in Israel. Let's go back in time to 2016 to 2020. How did Trump approach Israel in his first term?
Stephen Cook
Well, Trump was a very pro-Israel president, which is saying something because most presidents actually are very pro-Israel. Under my administration, the unbreakable alliance between the United States and Israel has never been stronger. You read things, you hear things. It's never been stronger. Just remember that.
Noelle King
He moved the U.S. Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. At this moment, the American embassy stands proudly in Jerusalem. The capital, the Jewish people have established, and they've wanted the embassy for many, many years, for many decades, and frankly, through many presidents.
Stephen Cook
Something that had been a law since the late 1990s, but no president had ever acted on it. We got it done. Not only did we get it done, we also got it built at a slight cost saving.
Noelle King
He recognized Israel's sovereignty over the Golan Heights and in general sort of turned a blind eye to the worst excesses of the Israeli government when it came to settlement in the West Bank.
Stephen Cook
And let's turn to the State Department where Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is speaking right now. The establishment of Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank is not per se inconsistent with international law.
Noelle King
The world has arguably gotten more complex since Donald Trump's last term. I think so. Yeah, OK, OK. You know, we add arguably just in case. Russia, Ukraine, October 7th, every nation that was pulled in after October 7th. Do you think Trump and his foreign policy team recognize things may be more complicated this time around?
Stephen Cook
You'd like to think that they do, that they're in touch with reality. But, you know, some of the statements that Trump has made about the region would suggest that he thinks he's just going to pick up where he left off when he reluctantly left office in January 2021.
Noelle King
He's been talking about expanding the Abraham Accords to include Saudi Arabia. To cooperate as partners across the broad range of sectors, from tourism to trade and healthcare to security. That has been greatly complicated as a result of the war in the Gaza Strip.
Stephen Cook
The Saudi price for normalization has gone up steeply since the war began. And now the Saudis are demanding an actual two-state solution. The answer is a Palestinian state.
Noelle King
Do any of his appointments reflect the major changes undergone? Who's he looking at to serve under him on the Middle East and Israel?
Stephen Cook
The National Security Advisor designate Congressman Mike Waltz is someone who is a very pro-Israel personality. Senator Marco Rubio, who's been designated to be the Secretary of State, also has very strong pro-Israel credentials. And of course, his UN permanent representative is Elise Stefanik, the congresswoman from New York, who made a name for herself for being pugnaciously pro-Israel, as well as taking on elite college presidents in those famous hearings after the October 7th attacks.
Noelle King
At Harvard, does calling for the genocide of Jews violate Harvard's rules of bullying and harassment, yes or no?
Stephen Cook
It can be, depending on the context. What's the context?
Noelle King
Targeted as an individual. Targeted at an individual. It's targeted at Jewish students, Jewish individuals. Do you understand your testimony is dehumanizing them? Do you understand that dehumanization is part of anti-Semitism?
Stephen Cook
And then there is, of course, Mike Huckabee, the former governor of Arkansas, who's been named U.S. ambassador to Israel, who is a very, very pro-Israel figure. There are certain words I refuse to use. There is no such thing as a West Bank. It's Judea and Samaria. There's no such thing as a settlement. There are communities, there are neighborhoods, there are cities. There's no such thing as an occupation.
Noelle King
Mike Huckabee might as well be a settler. He doesn't recognize the Palestinian people as a nation. There's plenty of land in the world that we could find a place and say, OK, let's create a Palestinian state. He doesn't regard Israel's settlement in the West Bank as illegal.
Stephen Cook
This is an administration that is very, very pro-Israel. But of course, these people may end up just being implementers, bit players in what President Trump decides to do. And based on his first term, what he decides to do is what his gut tells him. He sees himself as a great negotiator. And I think at least on the two solution and on Iran nuclear program that self as a great negotiator and dealmaker may cause tension with an Israeli government that has other views on these two issues
Noelle King
What do we know of the truth about what Trump and Netanyahu think of each other?
Stephen Cook
Well, I read Jared Kushner's memoir of his time in the White House so that no one else had to. It was truly a dreadful read. But one of the things I learned, in fact, I think one of the only things I learned in the book, other than the fact that he's a terrible writer and can't even make his grandparents seem charming, was that Netanyahu and Trump, there was a very significant trust deficit between the two leaders.
Noelle King
Bibi responded with less than expected enthusiasm. Thrown off by the lukewarm response, Trump began to second guess his decision. As he continued his conversation with Bibi, he wondered aloud why he was taking this risk if the Israeli prime minister didn't think it was that important. Trump's voice hardened into a stern tone. Bibi, I think you are the problem.
Stephen Cook
Trump was always concerned that Netanyahu was going to double cross him. Netanyahu was always worried that Trump was going to do something that would run afoul of Israel's interests, like sit down and negotiate with the Iranians over a new nuclear deal.
Noelle King
Add to the fact that Prime Minister Netanyahu relatively quickly called President Joe Biden when his election was confirmed in November 2020. And this angered President Trump. So ever since Trump's re-election, Netanyahu has made a real effort to call Trump, placate Trump.
Stephen Cook
I want to thank President Trump for his strong statement yesterday about the need for Hamas to release the hostages, the responsibility of Hamas. And this adds another force to our continuing effort to release all the hostages. Thank you, President Trump.
Noelle King
But I still think that that trust deficit remains because Trump has a different view of things like the two-state solution and the Iran nuclear program than the Israelis do.
Stephen Cook
Now, I'm asking you this question in the context of it is Tuesday afternoon as we speak, and we're hearing, you know, a ceasefire may be near. I mean, we've got Reuters and the AP reporting it. I have no idea. When do you think we'll get a ceasefire? What's your sort of, yeah, I know. I mean, I've been listening to, you know, columnists and others tell me that a ceasefire is imminent since at least February 2024.
And what I know is that Hamas, and the person of Yahya Sinwar, who the Israelis killed a number of months ago, was not interested in a ceasefire, believing that Hamas was winning the conflict because it was a total war. And even though the Israelis were doing a lot of damage to Hamas's cadres in the Gaza Strip, Israel's international legitimacy was suffering greatly as a result of the conflict.
And for Yahya Sinwar and others within Hamas, this was one of the goals, was to undermine Israel's legitimacy in the international order. And then, of course, on the Israeli side, the settlers did not want a ceasefire. They want the quote-unquote total destruction of Hamas to clear the way for the Israelis to essentially resettle the Gaza Strip.
So there was no real incentive for a ceasefire. Things have changed significantly since then, however. The Israelis have done a tremendous amount of damage to Hezbollah, Iran's primary proxy in Lebanon. And there's now a ceasefire in Lebanon. That leaves Hamas standing alone, which Hamas now needs to make a decision. Will it save the remnants of itself by cutting a deal with the Israelis, or will it fight on believing that the continued fight will continue to damage Israel internationally and that they're going to play the long game?
Some of the indications coming from Israeli ministers and others, the Egyptians and others, is that Hamas has dropped a major sticking point, which is that they demanded that all Israeli forces leave the Gaza Strip. So that may pave the way towards a ceasefire and a hostage exchange.
Noelle King
There are a million reasons to want a ceasefire here, not least of which is the humanitarian catastrophe, which has unfolded for more than a year. But in the blunt calculus of politics, if we do get a ceasefire before Donald Trump is inaugurated, who gets the win? Trump? Biden? Will they fight over it? I mean, certainly Trump will claim it. The Biden team will also claim it. They've been working at this, you know, since the very beginning.
Stephen Cook
I would give neither of them. I would say that the credit goes to the IDF. You know, of course Donald Trump will claim it. I mean, that's why he's been posting on Truth Social and said in his first press conference that there would be hell to pay if the hostages weren't returned by the time he's inaugurated. But I think, you know, he's essentially setting it up so he takes the credit for it.
Noelle King
The man from Plainview, Stephen Cook of the Council on Foreign Relations. Thanks to him. Thanks also to Avishai Artsy and Peter Balanon-Rosen for producing today's show. Matthew Collette for editing. Patrick Boyd and Rob Byers for engineering. And Laura Bullard for checking the facts. I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you. Thank you.