Main Topic: The Brett Kavanaugh Supreme Court confirmation hearings, specifically the opening day, where Democrats used a collective force to oppose the nomination, and Republicans pushed back with claims of normalcy and hypocrisy.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Sarah Cliff
Hi, I'm Sarah Cliff, a reporter on maternity leave from Vox.
Sean Rameswaram
Sarah, you've been on maternity leave from Vox, where you usually report. Yes. And you're holding a baby named Max. Yes, this is my baby.
Sarah Cliff
It'd be weird if it was someone else's. It's so weird. But we're not here to talk about babies. No, we're not.
Sean Rameswaram
We're here to talk about Quip electric toothbrushes. Yeah, babies don't have teeth. Yeah. But I have a Quip electric toothbrush. That you got at getquip.com slash explained? I did.
Sarah Cliff
Perfect. So Dahlia Lithwick, you report on the Supreme Court for Slate. You host the Amicus podcast. We were all watching, following along today, and I kept seeing people who report on the Supreme Court saying they'd never seen anything like this before.
Dahlia Lithwick
Yeah, we actually at Slate had an under over on how many interruptions, how many protesters would get dragged out of the room. And I said, oh, you know, the usual is like three or four. And we hit that in the first two minutes.
Sean Rameswaram
Do not vote on him. No, she was not warned. Don't take away my health care. The amount of shouting over the chair. We cannot possibly move forward, Mr. Chairman.
Dahlia Lithwick
I extend a very warm welcome to Judge Cavanaugh to his wife, Ashley. And I think actually, interestingly, today was the first day that I really saw the Democrats kind of coordinating. It looked as though they really had thought through as a collective how they were going to oppose this.
Sarah Cliff
And that also felt really different. But no, I guess this is my sixth Supreme Court confirmation hearing, and I've never seen anything like this morning.
Sean Rameswaram
So in addition to a massive amount of protests that continued throughout the day in the hearing, you saw Democrats speaking over Senator Grassley, who was running the hearings. What were they saying and why were they interrupting him and why did they open with such a strong sort of collective force?
Dahlia Lithwick
Well, I think, you know, it was ostensibly about the documents. They got a massive document dump last night at five o'clock. I think at one point the claim was made. They literally would have had to be able to read 7000 pages an hour in order to get through all of it.
Sarah Cliff
No one could prepare and review 42,000 documents in one evening. We know that no matter how much coffee you drink.
Dahlia Lithwick
What are in these documents? I mean, the Democrats spent so much of the morning demanding an extension, an adjournment so they could learn what was in these documents.
Sarah Cliff
Do we know? We don't know what is in all the documents. Some of them are literally being vetted right now.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think that Senator Durbin said that huge volumes of them are from the time that Kavanaugh served as staff secretary in the Bush administration. And that means that he was summarizing documents.
Sarah Cliff
And there is a question about whether that was just ministerial. You know, it doesn't matter because he was just like a guy pushing papers across the president's desk or if he was deeply engaged in policy conversations and we'd want to know about it.
Dahlia Lithwick
And I think the claim about documents is a way of saying, look, we have never, ever had a nominee with such a voluminous record that is largely being kept hidden to the extent it's being vetted.
Sarah Cliff
It's being vetted by Bill Burke, a Republican lawyer who actually represents some of the folks who work for the president and who worked for Kavanaugh at some point.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think the argument is it just feels like the fix is in. And if you want us to reasonably assess the nominee, let us see his record.
Sarah Cliff
And I think that, you know, embedded in that complaint, there are a lot of other complaints about this is a rushed process.
Dahlia Lithwick
And this is somebody who has written extensively about presidential power and issues that inflect directly on Donald Trump and his legitimacy and whether probes into Donald Trump can go forward.
Sarah Cliff
And I think all of that got framed as a complaint about the process. Senator Blumenthal at one point said that there will always be a taint. There will always be an asterisk after your name.
Dahlia Lithwick
Appointed by a president named as an unindicted co-conspirator after the vast majority of documents relating to the most instructive period of his life were concealed. The question will always be why.
Sean Rameswaram
We had this conversation a year ago, you may remember, around Neil Gorsuch, and I think there was a similar claim.
Dahlia Lithwick
Again, the argument was at the time, look, you blocked Merrick Garland, Then you picked someone and then rushed it through, and there is forever going to be a taint because this looks like a stolen seat.
Sarah Cliff
So some of that rhetoric is familiar. I do think that this time we didn't have some of the weirdness that we had around the Gorsuch hearings where we heard a lot of the Democrats saying, this whole process is tainted, this sucks, but let's go ahead and do it anyway.
Dahlia Lithwick
At least this morning we saw what looked like the beginning of maybe we just walk out of the room I don't know Maybe we just adjourn Maybe we postpone
Sarah Cliff
And so I think it looked a little bit more as though there was a concerted message that said this is so tainted that we won't participate.
Dahlia Lithwick
But then as we saw, Democrats participated. Yeah, then they just went along as business as usual.
Sean Rameswaram
So what happened once the dust settled?
Dahlia Lithwick
Well, I think once the initial sort of back and forth of, I think, Senator Blumenthal and Senator Harris and Senator Klobuchar, a bunch of the Democrats really were calling for postponement or adjournment.
Sarah Cliff
Mr. Chairman, if we cannot be recognized, I move to adjourn. The American people. Mr. Chairman, I move to adjourn. Directly from Judge Kevin Law. Mr. Chairman, I move to adjourn.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think there was a micro battle about whether that could happen if you're not in an executive session.
Sarah Cliff
Grassley essentially overruled them. And then, as you said, they went on to the merits.
Dahlia Lithwick
And really, the whole day went to opening statements. It was clear that Grassley was like, I mean it when I say you only have 10 minutes and then they would go on for, you know, 25. Endless opening statements.
Sarah Cliff
Oh, my gosh. Yeah, it was really, I think Cory Booker was like doing some kind of, at some point, performance art. I mean, it was really, really a lengthy statement, but I think it goes to, and I would say this, in my view, is one of the themes of the day, is that Democrats, one way or another, are trying to say this isn't normal.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think that was Senator Klobuchar's whole theme. It was Dick Durbin's theme. None of this is normal.
Sarah Cliff
And whether you say it's not normal because Donald Trump has selected the person who's going to someday sit in judgment about issues that have to do with his presidency or with obstruction claims and campaign finance claims, or whether it's not normal because Anthony Kennedy is being replaced with a pretty credible right wing, probably to the right of Justice Alito jurist.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think the claim on the Democrat side of the room was like nothing about this process is normal. And interestingly, the kind of in the call and response, what you heard from Republicans was this is totally normal.
Sarah Cliff
It didn't bother anybody for Clinton to nominate Breyer while he was under investigation. We actually did it.
Dahlia Lithwick
And I think in a weird way, the fact that the Bob Woodward excerpts explode into the middle of this allows you to make your own determination of how normal this whole thing really is.
Sarah Cliff
It was interesting from the Republicans you had like Jeff Flake come out and just talk about how much he appreciated that Brett Kavanaugh likes sports for what seemed like 10 minutes.
Dahlia Lithwick
We both played football back in the day. I'm sure you're looking forward to this weekend, not just when these hearings are concluded, but when the Redskins and Cardinals play on Sunday.
Sarah Cliff
I learned that you've run the Boston Marathon twice. I wonder if the ABA took that into account when they gave you a favorable rating.
Dahlia Lithwick
I'm not sure what that says about your soundness of mind myself.
Sarah Cliff
But then Lindsey Graham spent almost all of his time, I feel like, talking about Democratic hypocrisy.
Dahlia Lithwick
The whole argument is you can be a conservative Republican president, but you got to nominate a liberal to be fair to the country. That's absurd.
Sarah Cliff
Where do you think Ruth Bader Ginsburg came from? She was a general counsel with ACLU. Wonderful person.
Dahlia Lithwick
What groups do y'all use to pick from? This is shaping up to be the hypocrisy hearing.
Sarah Cliff
Didn't mention anything about Merrick Garland, whose shadow still feels like it looms in these confirmation hearings.
Dahlia Lithwick
Do you think it does? Is some of this about how the Republicans stole an Obama nomination?
Sarah Cliff
Yeah, I think it does affect very much this question of this is just about power. This is just about politics.
Dahlia Lithwick
And if you really listened, one of the things that echoed throughout was this conversation about how much is this just about raw power? How much is this about Senate Republicans just getting to do what they want, screw the rules and the norms because that's what they do?
Sarah Cliff
And a kind of pushback from Republicans saying, no, this is about dignity and civility and this deliberative body.
Dahlia Lithwick
So it's a really it's a kind of invisible thread that goes through it. You're quite right.
Sarah Cliff
But it's also, I think, the source of just great unexpressed frustration on the Democrat side and great unexpressed kind of exaltation on the Republican side that in the end, this kind of is just about power.
Sean Rameswaram
Dahlia, the Kavanaugh hearings are supposed to go until Friday, and I want to know if we're actually going to learn anything about this man, but I'm going to do it after a quick break.
Sarah Cliff
So Sarah Cliff Vox reporter maternity leave you have your baby Max here. He's wonderful looking. It's pretty cute. You decided while on maternity leave to get a new electric toothbrush a Quip electric toothbrush at getquip slash explain.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, so I was having some toothbrush drama, which is not a thing I thought would ever happen in my life.
Sarah Cliff
So I had a different electric toothbrush and I don't know what happened to it, but it just started turning itself on like it was possessed at like two in the morning.
Sean Rameswaram
It would start vibrating and sounding like someone. Oh, sorry, Max is getting a little, he's upset remembering this.
Sarah Cliff
Because he was waking him up at 2 a.m. too. He was waking him up too, and he's a baby.
Sean Rameswaram
So anyways, it would go off at like 2 in the morning and just start vibrating.
Sarah Cliff
And, you know, I was already getting woken up by him like three times a night. I did not need a toothbrush that was also going to wake me up.
Sean Rameswaram
Right on. So you went to the thing.
Sarah Cliff
So the next morning I went on getquip.com and slash explain.
Sean Rameswaram
Slash explain. Some free refills. Some free refills. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Sarah Cliff
And while he was probably doing this, I ordered a toothbrush.
Sean Rameswaram
Mr. Chairman, Senator Feinstein, members of the committee I look forward to the rest of the hearing And to answering your questions I am an optimist I live on the sunrise side of the mountain Not the sunset side of the mountain I see the day that is coming Not the day that is gone
Sarah Cliff
Is there a chance that we actually learn anything About this Trump nominee this week?
Dahlia Lithwick
You know, it's a good question. I think this morning there was so much furious speechifying, it's hard to imagine that Kavanaugh's going to get a word in edgewise.
Sarah Cliff
That said, I will say that Senator Blumenthal, Senator Whitehouse, Booker, Harris, Senator Hirono are really good and deft cross-examiners.
Dahlia Lithwick
And I think they laid out the markers of the kinds of things they're going to ask about.
Sarah Cliff
I think there will be, whether Judge Kavanaugh chooses to answer. I think there will be in the coming days, a pretty exhaustive conversation about his ideas about presidential power, his ideas about campaign finance law, his ideas about speech.
Dahlia Lithwick
Certainly there will be, I think, at least an attempt to probe his views on abortion and whether Roe is, quote, settled law.
Sarah Cliff
So I think there will be deft attempts to pin him down.
Dahlia Lithwick
And And I think what you heard from the Republican side today was 200 versions of he's not going to answer.
Sarah Cliff
And is there a chance that the Democrats get to find out some of what they're not seeing in these documents by just talking to the man himself?
Dahlia Lithwick
Well, that was interesting. It was one of the things that Grassley kept promising in his attempt to mollify Democrats.
Sarah Cliff
He kept saying, you know, OK, maybe you didn't get the documents, but you can certainly ask him the questions.
Dahlia Lithwick
And then intriguingly, within moments of asserting that, he also said, but he doesn't have to answer anything because of the so-called Ginsburg rule.
Sarah Cliff
And so I think there's a little bit of a pincer happening here where you don't provide the documents and then you say he also doesn't have to answer.
Dahlia Lithwick
And I think that was very, very much set up today.
Sean Rameswaram
The Ginsburg rule so-called for how Ruth Bader Ginsburg's hearings went?
Dahlia Lithwick
Yeah, I think that there was, and it's not entirely fair, there's a story told that Ginsburg said she would give no hints and no tips about how she would vote in future cases.
Sarah Cliff
But then she went on to talk about abortion and her views of abortion law at great length.
Dahlia Lithwick
That rule has been more or less distorted to mean nobody should have to talk about any case that could conceivably come before them.
Sarah Cliff
In fairness, I think that John Roberts answered pretty thoroughly.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think that Sam Alito answered pretty thoroughly. But the trend has become to offer up less and less information about anything that could conceivably appear before you as a justice.
Sarah Cliff
And ultimately, what Kavanaugh says or doesn't say won't really matter towards his confirmation on the Supreme Court, correct?
Dahlia Lithwick
It doesn't look that way, I think, to the extent that all eyes were on Susan Collins and the hope that the voters of Maine could push her to really use Roe v. Wade as a litmus test.
Sarah Cliff
She seems to have signaled that she's fine with where Kavanaugh says he is on reversing Roe.
Dahlia Lithwick
And the whole sort of mystical formula of saying, you know, something is, quote, settled precedent or is good law doesn't even tell you that much about how someone would rule.
Sarah Cliff
So it's such a rabbit hole to try to say that that is the single handed determinant of one senator's vote.
Dahlia Lithwick
And I think she pretty ably suggested that she can tell the voters at home that she is sanguine about the fact that there will be good law and she not really in play
Sean Rameswaram
I wonder you know looking at this super contentious morning of hearings followed by sort of what we used to seeing but there was lingering tension throughout the day.
Dahlia Lithwick
I mean, Cory Booker opened up his statement with this huge preamble. Mr. Chairman, Chairman Grassley, I hope you do not think earlier this morning that in any way I was questioning your integrity or your decency.
Sarah Cliff
I was appealing to it earlier before.
Dahlia Lithwick
Do you think something changed today? Might something that happened in that room have implications in the midterms or have implications the next time there's a Supreme Court nominee or a hearing?
Sarah Cliff
Are these things just going to get more contentious to the point where we don't discover anything about these people in them anymore?
Dahlia Lithwick
What I see today is a real fracture of we talked about norms, we talked about civility, we talked about the Senate for a long time as being the saucer that slowly cools off the hotheads in the House.
Sarah Cliff
And today, I think the gloves are off.
Dahlia Lithwick
Today is the most partisan in terms of imputing bad faith on both sides, senators on both sides saying, you know, on the one hand, a lot of Republicans saying, oh, you know, Democrats are all just running for president.
Sarah Cliff
They want their soundbite on TV.
Dahlia Lithwick
Democrats saying that. Sorry about that. Are you busy today, Dahlia?
Sean Rameswaram
I'm sorry that it keeps beeping. It's okay.
Dahlia Lithwick
Yeah, you're saying Democrats. Democrats sort of imputing really bad faith on the part of Republicans in the Senate, suggesting that, you know, the White House is deliberately obstructing that Senator Grassley is deliberately hiding documents.
Sarah Cliff
I cannot think of a time that I've seen that level of presumptions of just really bad faith that are openly stated.
Dahlia Lithwick
And maybe the most interesting, it was perplexing, but Ben Sasse, Senator Sasse, talking about, you know, the Congress doesn't do its job and then everything gets, you know, foisted over to the Supreme Court.
Sarah Cliff
It's predictable that every confirmation hearing now is going to be overblown, politicized circus.
Dahlia Lithwick
And it's because we've accepted a new theory about how our three branches of government should work and in particular how the judiciary should work.
Sarah Cliff
Kind of the level of almost self-abnegating, of self-blame, of, you know, man, people really, really hate us that undercurted a lot of the discussion today.
Dahlia Lithwick
I thought that was really interesting. You know, it almost seems as though both sides know that they've passed some kind of brink and that public confidence is so lacking.
Sarah Cliff
And people in the galleries are screaming and getting hauled out. And it just has this feeling of, you know, all this time we wanted to pretend that the Senate was different and that it was decorous and that these relationships really will carry the day.
Dahlia Lithwick
I think that's why you saw Senator Booker importuning Senator Grassley not to be mad.
Sarah Cliff
But there's a sense in which something really cracked. and I think that's only going to get worse in the coming days.
Sean Rameswaram
Dahlia Lithwick is the host of the Amicus podcast from Slate where she also covers the Supreme Court.
Sarah Cliff
I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Sean Rameswaram
This is Today Explained.
Sarah Cliff
You know what's cool about the quip is that you can take the battery out because it's a regular battery. Yes. So if it ever went crazy and was possessed, instead of like performing an exorcism in the sock drawer, you could just take the battery out and it would be quiet.
Dahlia Lithwick
Yeah, that would have been a nice feature. It didn't exist.
Sarah Cliff
I haven't had to do it yet because my quip has not gone crazy yet.
Sean Rameswaram
Kara Swisher, you're here all week talking about your podcast in the Vox Media Podcast Network, the Recode Decode podcast. I am.
Kara Swisher
I'm here in D.C. with you. It's been around for a minute, but how should we introduce it to Today Explain listeners who might not have heard it before?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, we should say it's in-depth interviews with key players in tech, media, and politics. That's our little thing.
Kara Swisher
Beautiful. And then we do actually interview key players in tech, media, and politics.
Sean Rameswaram
So who's a key player we should hear about?
Kara Swisher
So this week I talked to Amakan Delrahim. He is at the Justice Department. He's the Assistant Attorney General.
Sean Rameswaram
And he's the one who tried to block the AT&T-Time Warner merger and has lost and is appealing.
Kara Swisher
And he talked about that a lot, more than he probably should have. But there he did.
Sean Rameswaram
And he talked about sort of the attacks that he got because people thought he was carrying water for President Trump.
Kara Swisher
Who hates CNN. He talked about where antitrust was going. You know, he'll have a lot of say about where if, say, Google bought something big or Facebook did and stuff like that.
Sean Rameswaram
So he's a really interesting and engaging lawyer for a lawyer.
Kara Swisher
Wonderful. Okay. And people can find Recode Decode wherever they find their podcasts?
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, indeed.