Main Topic: The Supreme Court's recent ruling in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo case, which temporarily blocked restrictions on religious services in New York state during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Upbeat music fades out
Halima Shah
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com. It's Today Explained. I'm Halima Shah, sitting in for Sean Ramoswaram.
Music transitions to a gentle background hum
This morning, the Supreme Court had a brief unsigned order for California judges. It basically said to reconsider pandemic restrictions on the number of people who can gather inside a house of worship. The order comes on the heels of a formal decision from around Thanksgiving. And it's one religious conservatives are likely thankful for because the decision basically says COVID restrictions on religious gatherings violate religious liberty.
Ian Millhiser
So this case, it's called Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo. And it dealt with the restrictions that New York state put on various institutions in order to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.
Halima Shah
New York State, in areas where there is already either a significant outbreak or the potential for a very significant outbreak, there were very rigid caps on the number of people who could be in a house of worship at any given time. This is about mass gatherings. This is about mass gatherings. And one of the prime places of mass gatherings are houses of worship. And so especially in faith traditions where people gather and sing, that is potentially a very dangerous activity.
Ian Millhiser
You know, you could have a room full of people who are expelling COVID out into the air and then everyone else in the congregation is breathing that in. And so New York felt it was important to prevent COVID from being spread in that way.
Halima Shah
The Supreme Court said no. Breaking news overnight. The Supreme Court has ruled against Governor Cuomo and has temporarily blocked restrictions of religious services in New York state. The two-word description is religious liberty. They felt that the houses of worship, the congregation's rights to be able to gather people together, at least be able to gather more people together at one time than New York wanted, was more important than the state's interest in preventing the spread of the coronavirus.
Ian Millhiser
So how did the vote on this ultimately shake out? So it was five to four. And one thing that's significant is that one of the four, one of the justices in dissent was Chief Justice John Roberts, who up until when Justice Ginsburg passed was had been the swing vote on the Supreme Court.
Halima Shah
Roberts is very conservative. But Roberts's view was that basically the court should defer to public health officials. And so his attitude was, look, I don't want to be responsible for spreading COVID-19. So if the state public health officials say this is what we need to do to prevent the spread of a deadly disease, Roberts was inclined to defer.
Ian Millhiser
And Roberts would typically vote for with the four liberals to say that the court should defer to public health officials. The problem is that there aren't four liberals anymore. There are now three liberals and the foremost conservative justices who were there before Justice Ginsburg's death, Plus Amy Coney Barrett, that adds up to a majority. And so Roberts is now irrelevant. And there are now five votes to say that there are much broader religious liberty protections under the Constitution, even in cases where the stakes are that if you allow people to gather in places of worship, that people could get COVID and die.
Halima Shah
So how did the other five justify this? Because we should note that even though the Diocese of Brooklyn felt like these rules were unfair, Pope Francis doesn't agree. He has actually criticized groups for not following COVID-19 restrictions.
Ian Millhiser
The general rule is that you can't discriminate against religion. And so, you know, if the state had said that movie theaters get treated better than churches or, you know, some other institution that has auditorium like sitting gets treated better than houses of worship, that would have been unconstitutional. But what the court did in this case is they basically broadened the concept of what counts as discrimination.
Halima Shah
So the issue wasn't that similarly situated businesses were treated differently than houses of worship. The issue was that any business is treated differently. So you know grocery stores in New York state for example could let more than 10 people in Acupuncture facilities is an example that the court gave in its opinion They can have more than 10 people And since any secular business was treated differently than houses of worship the Supreme Court reasoned that this is now unconstitutional
Ian Millhiser
Now I mean there a number of problems with that reasoning but I mean the most basic one is that people don't normally gather in acupuncture facilities and get together in large groups and sing. You never know, Ian. You never know. I mean, you know, maybe people go to their liquor stores and they like speak in tongues or something. I don't know.
Halima Shah
But like it wasn't irrational to say that places of worship are similar to movie theaters and lecture halls and things like that and not similar to, say, a grocery store. And so we can treat movie theaters, churches, mosques, synagogues, all of these things that are similar one way, and we can treat acupuncture facilities and garages and grocery stores a different way.
Ian Millhiser
That was the way that things used to work. But now the new rule is that if you want a religious exemption from some sort of legal obligation and you can point to any secular entity that is treated better than you are as a religious entity, then you are very likely to win your case.
Halima Shah
So this particular case really influenced the way that we think about religious liberty now and quite possibly for the next few decades. Before this point, what was the major case that really decided how we looked at religious liberty?
Ian Millhiser
Let me go into a bit of history here. In the 1960s, the Supreme Court handed down a case called Sherbert. Petitioner or appellant rather versus Charles B. Werner et al. as members of South Carolina Employment Security Commission and Spartan Mills.
Halima Shah
And Sherbert was really the first important case that said that there are some cases where we recognize that people of faith should not be burdened by the law.
Ian Millhiser
The question presented in essence is whether a Seventh-day Adventist observing the Saturday Sabbath from Friday evening at sundown to Saturday evening at sundown may be required to work on Saturday under penalty of loss of unemployment compensation.
Halima Shah
And Sherbert and the Sherbert line of cases said, no, no, the government can't do that. The government can't make Saturday Sabbatarians work on the day that they consider to be holy.
Ian Millhiser
The problems arise when someone with a religious objection to the law is seeking an objection that hurts someone else. So, you know, if I want Saturday off and I say, look, I'll work Sunday instead, I'm not hurting anyone. Like, it's fine. Like, I can work Sunday and like everyone will be fine.
Halima Shah
But let's say, I mean, to take some recent cases, I don't want my employees to have birth control. And so I refuse to follow a federal regulation that requires me to provide them birth control coverage and their health insurance.
Ian Millhiser
That was the Hobby Lobby case. In a major ruling today, the Supreme Court said that some employers cannot be forced to cover birth control in their health plans if that violates their religious beliefs.
Halima Shah
Contraceptive coverage had been mandated for employers under Obamacare. Let's say that I don't want my business to serve gay people or trans people or some other marginalized group.
Ian Millhiser
These are cases where if I get the religious exemption that I want, I am hurting someone else. I'm taking away someone else's rights. And so the line that the Supreme Court had drawn for many, many years is it basically said, I get my religious objection unless I'm going to hurt a third party and then I don't get my religious objection.
Halima Shah
Hobby Lobby changed that. Hobby Lobby was really the first case to say that a religious objector can claim an exemption from the law that does harm to a third party. And that was an earthquake.
Ian Millhiser
What makes this latest case, the Roman Catholic diocese case significant, is it basically just expands the universe of what counts as a violation that then gives someone a religious exemption.
Halima Shah
So the law used to be, at least when we were talking about state law. So so long as the law applied equally to secular people and religious people alike, then it was fine. You didn't get an exemption from a state law.
Ian Millhiser
The Roman Catholic diocese case doesn't explicitly overrule that rule, but it changes the definition of discrimination. So now, again, it's considered to be discrimination if you can show any example of any secular entity that is treated differently than you are, possibly for any reason.
Halima Shah
And so what's going to happen now, I think, is we're just going to see a lot of cases where people who have religious objections to following a particular law demand an exemption from the court. They get it. And they get it even if the exemption that they are seeking hurts someone else.
Ian Millhiser
Coming up after the break, I tell us why not all religious liberty lawsuits are created equal.
Halima Shah
Support for today show comes from Adio What is Adio Adio is an AI customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies They say it extremely powerful adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Ian Millhiser
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up, and within seconds you will have your email and calendars synced. You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Halima Shah
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Ian Millhiser
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal, and so much more. You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year. That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Halima Shah
So, Ian, what do these cases say about where the court and I guess America now stand on the issue of religious liberty?
Ian Millhiser
So I think the broader picture here is that before Hobby Lobby, I think the court understood, I mean, for lack of a better way to put it, that like we live in a society like we live in a pluralistic society. We live in a society with people with many different faiths.
Halima Shah
And the only way to make that work is for us to all have common obligations to another. And we decide what our common obligations are through the democratic process.
Ian Millhiser
So, you know, it is not in the Constitution, for example, that private businesses can't discriminate against LGBT people. But if the legislature passes a law saying that that's illegal, the legislature is allowed to do that. And we all then have a common obligation not to discriminate.
Halima Shah
And if you don't like that common obligation, you're not powerless. You can vote for different lawmakers who will repeal that law. You can lobby the lawmakers that we have. You can lobby the executive branch and say, hey, we should change the rule.
Ian Millhiser
But what you can't do is say, I'm just going to go to the court. I'm going to claim that I don't want to follow this obligation and I'm just going to be relieved of it, even if it means that other people get hurt.
Halima Shah
Now, I think the court is putting the thumb on the scale for people with certain kinds of religious objections. But even if the Supreme Court made this decision with the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn in mind, can't other religious groups still use this decision to their benefit?
Ian Millhiser
Couldn't a mosque or temple in New York now defy social gathering rules?
Halima Shah
My best guess is that the Supreme Court's going to apply this pretty universally to various houses of worship that want to defy these rules.
Ian Millhiser
Shortly after the Roman Catholic decision came down, there was a case called Agudith Israel, which was basically the same case. It just involved an Orthodox synagogue rather than a Roman Catholic church.
Halima Shah
And the Supreme Court applied the same rules to the Jewish sect that they applied to the Christian sect. So, so far, at least they seem to be applying this rule fairly.
Ian Millhiser
That said, there are disturbing signs that this Supreme Court has been less friendly to religious liberty claims brought by Muslims than they have to religious liberty claims brought by Christians.
Halima Shah
Two cases that concern me there. One is Trump v. Hawaii, the so-called Muslim ban case where the Supreme Court ignored a bunch of fairly virulent anti-Islamic statements from President Trump to uphold one of his policies.
Ian Millhiser
And then the other is a case called Dun v. Ray, where the Supreme Court engaged in really blatant religious discrimination. They said that there was a state where if you were going to be executed and you were Christian, you were allowed to have a Christian pastor present. But if you were Muslim, you were not allowed to have a Muslim imam present during your execution.
Halima Shah
So I do think that the Supreme Court has shown a disturbing ability to engage in some amount of discrimination, but I don't want to exaggerate the extent of that.
Ian Millhiser
I mean, the court has in the past ruled in favor of Muslims bringing religious liberty claims. Oddly enough, there's a lot of cases involving beards because there are Muslim men who believe they have a religious obligation to wear a beard.
Halima Shah
And so when the government has tried to prevent cops from growing beards or when they have tried to prevent prisoners from growing beards, the justice has sometimes stepped in and said, no, they can grow the beard.
Ian Millhiser
So they don't always rule against Muslims, but they do rule against Muslims and in ways that I think should suggest that the court is not applying its rules in a completely even-handed way.
Halima Shah
So what's next for the court then? Are there other religious liberty cases that they're going to hear soon that could take the Hobby Lobby and Roman Catholic diocese decision further?
Ian Millhiser
So the case that I'm watching very closely right now is a case that they recently heard oral arguments. In case number 19123, Fulton versus City of Philadelphia.
Halima Shah
Fulton is an unusual case in that it involves a government contractor contracted with the city of Philadelphia to help Philadelphia identify potential foster families to place foster children with
Ian Millhiser
And the head of Catholic Social Services testified that certifying a home of a same couple would be in violation of that religious belief that a home study is essentially a validation of the relationships in the home.
Halima Shah
What makes Fulton new and different and, you know, my opinion, potentially worrisome is that Fulton is a case about a government contractor that was engaged in government services on behalf of the government and wanted to be able to continue to have a government contract without complying with one of the terms of that contract, which says that they weren't allowed to discriminate.
Ian Millhiser
And historically, the Supreme Court has said that government contractors are different. When the government is hiring people to do work on behalf of the government, it has much more leeway to make demands of its own contractors than it does just tell some random private business what to do.
Halima Shah
So like Fulton, I think, and I think that the city of Philadelphia is likely to lose the Fulton case. It would be a significant escalation, I think, in the religion wars because it would mean that the government could potentially have to engage in discrimination.
Ian Millhiser
We're not just talking about a conservative bench expanding what religious liberty means here. We're also talking about the nation's highest court basically deciding whether or not a state government can implement a public health rule during a pandemic.
Halima Shah
Did this decision just demonstrate how hard it's going to be for Democrats to implement any kind of top-down regulation in the next term? I mean, certainly whenever religion is implicated.
Ian Millhiser
Now, I mean, I don't want to exaggerate the holding of the Roman Catholic diocese case. Like, it is a case about religion. It's not a freestanding objection to preventing the spread of COVID-19.
Halima Shah
We're seeing a lot of lawsuits. I mean, I think there's two or three cases pending for the Supreme Court right now where other religious entities are seeking exemptions from COVID-19 regulations.
Ian Millhiser
You know, you could imagine a case where there's a private business owner who manages to frame their objection to covid-19 regulations as a religious objection. You know, you could imagine a hypothetical plaintiff who says my faith requires me to not wear a mask. And so I have a constitutional right to not wear one.
Halima Shah
And like you might see cases like that. I think the open question, though, is what happens when religion isn't implicated. And we've seen it some lower courts. You know, the Wisconsin Supreme Court, for example, which has historically been very right wing, struck down the governor and the state health director's ability to close bars and to, like, put in place a lot of restrictions to prevent the spread of COVID.
Ian Millhiser
I could see, based on what the Supreme Court has done up to this point, that they could say that the president or the Biden administration's powers are very limited and they have to get Congress to put in place any regulation.
Halima Shah
I could see this Supreme Court, based on some of their federalism decisions, saying that the federal government is very limited in what it can do to prevent COVID-19, but states potentially have more power.
Ian Millhiser
So, like, I think that there are a lot of limits that this Supreme Court could potentially impose on the Biden administration and the federal government generally's ability to deal with COVID.
Halima Shah
But at this point, I mean, I'd really just have to speculate as to what those restrictions are going to be.
Ian Millhiser
Now we have three liberals plus Roberts on the left and we have a block of five very, very conservative justices. justices. And I hesitate to predict everything that they're going to do because there hasn't been a five justice block that is as far to the right as the five justice majority that we have now is.
Halima Shah
I mean, you'd have to go back to the 30s to find a Supreme Court that's as conservative as this one. And, you know, until I see more decisions from them and I just get more information about what they're going to do, it's hard to predict what they're going to do.
Ian Millhiser
And I think, you know, that makes things very difficult for the Biden administration.
Halima Shah
Ian Millhiser is a senior correspondent at Vox. He writes about the Supreme Court and the Constitution. I'm Halima Shah, sitting in for Sean Ramosfaram, who will be back on Monday. It's Today Explained.
Music transitions to a gentle background hum
And Adobe quality templates make it easy to create pro-looking flyers, social posts, presentations, and more. You don't have to be a designer to edit campaigns, resize ads, and translate content. Anyone can in a click. And collaboration tools put feedback right where you need it. See how you can turn your team into a content machine with Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.