Main Topic: The Golden State Killer case and the controversy surrounding the use of DNA evidence in law enforcement.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Upbeat music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Isra Elmati, hi, how are you? Welcome to Today Explained. Thank you so much, Sean. Friend of the show? Yes, I am. Colleague here at Vox Media? Yes, indeed.
Isra Elmati
I hear you might have a mattress problem. You know, so far I actually, I've had this mattress for 16 years. 16 years? I bought it 16 years ago at Mattress Firm, actually.
Sean Rameswaram
Wait, wait, wait, I want to hear all about it. MattressFirm.com slash podcast. The code podcast10 gets you 10% off. We'll do the rest later. Okay.
Isra Elmati
Sometimes when you want to catch a criminal, you have to catch his great-great-great-grandparent first. That's how police in California finally track down the guy they think is the Golden State Killer. After four decades.
Sean Rameswaram
My detectives arrested James Joseph D'Angelo, 72 years old, living in Citrus Heights. I can tell you that although it was DNA, ultimately, that led us down the right road, there were a lot of places that road could have led.
Isra Elmati
Since the arrest was made last week, a lot of people have taken issue with some of the tactics police used. Cops took DNA people submitted to genealogy sites to track down relatives and instead used it to track down a murderer.
Sean Rameswaram
We're going to tell you the story in two parts, Golden State Killer and DNA Controversy. The first part has a lot of grisly details and audio from the killer and one of his victims, too. So if you'd rather not hear that kind of thing, skip ahead to the second half of today's show. It starts around minute 10. Okay, here we go.
Asia Romano
In 1974, a man who would go on to terrorize most of California began a series of regular break-ins where he would essentially go through people's houses and rifle through their things and take small mementos from their houses. He became known as the Visalia Ransacker.
Sean Rameswaram
What came next started in 1976. A suspect who would go on to become known as the East Area Rapist began assaulting people in their homes. He was incredibly detailed. He would spend weeks and even months scoping out his victims' neighborhoods, even detailing things like the drainage systems nearby, places that he could escape.
Asia Romano
While he was doing this, he would also call his victims. Sometimes he would just breathe heavily into the phone. Sometimes he would tell them exactly what he wanted to do to them. Sometimes he would say, I'm going to kill you. I'm going to kill you. I'm going to kill you.
Sean Rameswaram
48 Hours did a documentary on the Golden State Killer, and they talked to Larry Crompton, who was a detective for the county sheriff's department. He would go in the house when the people weren't there and set that house up. And he would leave a window unlocked or a door unlocked so that he could go in.
Asia Romano
He would come for you even if you weren't home alone. If you were with a partner, he would bind you both, usually with shoelaces. He would blindfold the victims. And after tying them, he would take a towel and tear it up and use that for a blindfold.
Sean Rameswaram
Blindfolded, gagged, hands tied, legs tied, and then, you know, pulled me up like this because I was on my stomach and put me back in bed and said, if you move, I'm going to kill you.
Asia Romano
He would cut off your circulation and he would leave your partner there while he assaulted you. During the assault, he would frequently cry. He would often pretend to have met the victim at a previous event based on photos that he gathered from around the house.
Sean Rameswaram
So if you left up a photo of yourself attending prom, during the middle of his assault, he might say, I met you at the prom and I wanted you then. And then he would leave without a trace. And he did this over and over and over and over and over for almost a decade.
Asia Romano
Between 1974 and 1986 the suspect committed 12 murders that we know of at least 50 sexual assaults and at least 100 break and robberies He became known as the Visalia Ransacker the East Area Rapist the original Night Stalker and the Diamond Knot Killer among other nicknames
Sean Rameswaram
It wasn't until 2011 when DNA evidence taken from an original Night Stalker crime scene and an East Area Rapist crime scene were positively matched, and police were able to confirm that the killer and the rapist were one and the same. And it wasn't until 2013 that all of these different names and all of these different crimes in all of these different parts of California became unified under one new name, the Golden State Killer.
Asia Romano
Law enforcement, spearheaded by the Sacramento District Attorney's Office, began to use ancestry websites that have compiled public DNA profiles based on people who've submitted their own DNA samples to the websites. They began looking at one website in particular called GEDmatch to see if they could pair the East Area Rapist and a DNA sample that they had from one of the original Night Stalker cases to an existing DNA profile on one of these websites.
Sean Rameswaram
And they looked and they looked and they looked. And then on Thursday, April 19th, 2018, they thought they found a guy. His name is Joseph James DeAngelo and he had been living in Citrus Heights, which is one of the areas where multiple attacks of the East Area Rapist took place in the 70s. He'd been living there the entire time.
Asia Romano
Police immediately put him under surveillance and by Friday, they had obtained a discarded DNA sample. Joseph James D'Angelo had probably thrown something out in the trash. Could have been a straw, a drink, cotton swab, anything. And law enforcement surveilling the house collected it. And they had a match.
Sean Rameswaram
Joseph James D'Angelo had lived in Sacramento for most of his life. He had gone to school in the area between 1973 and 1979, when the most active period of his crimes took place. Joseph James D'Angelo worked as a police officer. In 1979, he was, in fact, fired from his police officer position because he was caught shoplifting dog repellent and a hammer.
Asia Romano
You might ask, why would anyone want to shoplift something like a hammer, a dog repellent? Well, if you're going to use it for something very specific, you don't want that receipt to be in your record. When he was arrested for shoplifting in 1979, he faced trial. but immediately pled no contest.
Sean Rameswaram
You might say that he was eager to let that incident die quickly before authorities could look further. Joseph Giangelo also served in the Navy in Vietnam, which added fuel to the longstanding belief that he had had some sort of military training and that he had had some sort of Marine training to tie the intricate knots that he tied.
Asia Romano
Recently, one of his daughters moved into the house along with a granddaughter. Authorities have said that family members are cooperating with police and that family members had no idea their father and grandfather was the Golden State Killer.
Sean Rameswaram
DNA evidence isn't 1,000% accurate, but in this case, we have very specific reasons for believing that all of these cases are connected. We have DNA matches in several of the original Night Stalker cases. And we also have DNA evidence in multiple instances of the East Area Rapist cases. Those DNA samples have been matched together.
Asia Romano
And because they have multiple DNA samples obtained from multiple cases, it's very, very, very unlikely that police have targeted the wrong person.
Sean Rameswaram
Cops in California would have never caught the Golden State Killer without DNA evidence. But the way they use DNA might set this really problematic precedent.
Isra Elmati
That's in a beat. This is Today Explained. Isra, you have been to a mattress firm and actually bought a mattress there? Yes. You are a rare breed. My parents did, to be fair, as I was 12. You were 12? I was 12 years old.
Sean Rameswaram
Do you remember the experience? I do. I do remember it really distinctly because we bought a new house I was sleeping on a twin mattress for 12 years We went to the mattress firm which was ginormous It was in Texas So it was extra big Okay And my expectation was getting a full bed And then my dad took me over to the Queens area and I lost my mind.
Isra Elmati
And the mattress firm guy, you know, he would just like talk to me directly. Did he seem like an expert? Definitely. I thought some like foamy crap was what I wanted. You know, some like weird soft stuff. A water bed, like what a 12-year-old would want? Exactly.
Sean Rameswaram
They're like, we don't have those here. They deal in the real over there. And he knew. That's why I've had the same mattress for 16 years. And it's still comfortable. Wait, this doesn't sound like a mattress problem anymore.
Isra Elmati
I know. I'm Sean Ramas for him. This is Today Explained.
Steve Mercer
We can easily be happy that a serial crime has been solved. But the way the Golden State Killer was caught has been keeping me up at night.
Sean Rameswaram
It is alarming for many people who find out that DNA that they have shared for one purpose is being used for an entirely different purpose. The cops started with some Golden State Killer DNA. And then they tested that DNA to develop this much larger profile, this ancestry profile, that looks at about 700,000 places on the human genome and has a lot more information in it.
Steve Mercer
They ran this DNA through a genealogy site. An open source genealogy site called GED. So law enforcement had to create some user account. They got this way distant relative. Then they created this massive family tree. And one branch leads to Joseph James D'Angelo in Citrus Heights right outside Sacramento.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, got some notification of a potential relative, went and put this person under surveillance, and then collected what's called abandoned DNA. And evidently it was a perfect match, and on the strength of that match has charged him.
Steve Mercer
It all sounds like really good detective work. But ownership of DNA is a tricky thing. If you submit a sample to Ancestry.com because you want to investigate your family ancestry, you know, if you look through their terms and conditions, they will tell you you own your DNA.
Sean Rameswaram
Well, that sounds very reassuring. Steve Mercer has been litigating at the intersection of DNA and civil liberties for 20 years. He teaches law at the University of the District of Columbia, and he says we're all at risk of another Facebook Cambridge Analytica type situation where your data gets shared without your approval.
Steve Mercer
Except this time, it's the most personal data you've got. You're allowing them to use your genetic information to develop products and services that they may sell, either themselves directly or in collaboration with research partners. The future of companies like 23andMe, Ancestry.com, is not in the testing business. It's in the DNA brokerage business.
Sean Rameswaram
What they have created are applications that entice people to send in their DNA sample. Now these private companies have over 12 million DNA samples. That is a very rich resource in unlocking the human genome that big pharma companies want to have to be able to study large data sets of DNA so that traits, for example, can be identified.
Steve Mercer
Identified, new medications created, or new ways to identify someone with mental illness, or perhaps their sexual orientation, or substance abuse. What happens if the data of a private company that contains genetic information is hacked? You could certainly envision a situation where a politician has his 23andMe account hacked, And then it's revealed that this person has traits for impulsivity or substance abuse or mental health disorder.
Sean Rameswaram
We're walking into this blind. But you can bet companies like Google are very much aware of the value of DNA. It's no surprise that you see these insider connections between a company like Google and Ancestry.
Steve Mercer
Think about the history with Google. with the assurances 10 15 years ago that we just here to help you we just here to help you search the internet to the point now where it very clear that its purpose is to hoard information about you so they can better target ads at you. I mean, that's just a hint at what it's going to be like if your DNA propensities are known.
Sean Rameswaram
You'll get targeted ads for mental health services. You'll get targeted ads for anxiety-related conditions. And it's the opening up of the Pandora's box. And we're walking into that by allowing private companies and, frankly, law enforcement to develop and maintain unregulated databanks of our most profoundly intimate information.
Steve Mercer
How is law enforcement using DNA a game changer? How is that potentially worse than, like, getting creepy targeted ads based on my DNA?
Sean Rameswaram
DNA testing has become so fast and so sensitive that when a crime occurs, let's say it's a bank robbery and the getaway car was rented from Hertz and the swab patrol goes out and they swab the door handles and the steering wheel and the gear shift and the headrest.
Steve Mercer
Let's say that you had rented that car for a day or two and you had returned it. And after that, it had been used in this bank heist. Okay. You can quickly become a target if your DNA is found on that car seat.
Sean Rameswaram
And although you may not be a convicted offender or arrestee whose DNA is in a regulated data bank, Maybe your brother or sister at Christmastime had sent off their DNA to an ancestry website. Now suddenly your name pops up on a list.
Steve Mercer
The unintended consequence of having this regulated databank system is that it invites law enforcement to both create and maintain quasi-private public databanks and also to allow law enforcement to go off to these public data banks that are in the hands of private companies without any oversight, without any safeguards, without any reporting requirements is just inviting a world where genetic surveillance of everyone has become a reality.
Sean Rameswaram
If you could scream something from a mountaintop, Steve, what would it be?
Steve Mercer
Wake up. Don't let the camel put its nose in the tent.
Sean Rameswaram
What does that mean?
Steve Mercer
If you let the camel put its nose in the tent, then very soon the whole body's going to be in the tent. Incremental changes over time aren't noticed that are putting us in peril.
Sean Rameswaram
It's easy to celebrate that a cold case involving a serial wrongdoer has been solved. But you shouldn't have to worry when you submit your DNA to an ancestry site that without any oversight, law enforcement will examine it to investigate a crime.
Steve Mercer
What if the crime that is being investigated is trespass or shoplifting or property crimes? And familial searching is already being used in some areas for precisely that type of crime.
Sean Rameswaram
If we're creating rules around these handful of cherry-picked successes that allow for free reign of law enforcement over DNA, we're setting ourselves up for some real peril.
Steve Mercer
Steve Mercer teaches at the David A. Clark School of Law in D.C.
Sean Rameswaram
One more thing before we go. At midnight, these new steel tariffs the Trump administration proposed were supposed to go into effect. Instead, the White House delayed them for another 30 days.
Steve Mercer
For all the details on the tariffs and why they won't make the United States too popular in Canada, Mexico, and Europe, check out our March 6th episode, What's the Deal with Steel? You can find a link to it in today's episode description.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm Sean Ramos from This is Today Explained.
Isra Elmati
Do you love your mattress?
Sean Rameswaram
I do like my mattress, but I need to change my mattress. Why? Tell me about the problem.
Isra Elmati
I don't know if it's just society is pressuring me to get rid of it. They say stuff about like dead skin cells or something along those lines. That's a problem.
Sean Rameswaram
I read a lot of things online about how you should switch it up. How often? Between, you know, five to ten years. Okay. For various reasons. So I've long passed that. So probably in the next, you know, a few months or so, I'll be looking into changing my mattress.
Isra Elmati
All right. Well, you know, you should go to mattressroom.com slash podcast and use the coupon code podcast10 to get 10% off before May 8th. I definitely will.