Main Topic: The Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) movement, led by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and its potential impact on the US healthcare system.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noel King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noel King.
Discussion of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and his confirmation hearings
Health and Human Services Secretary nominee Robert Floride Kennedy Jr. went before the Senate today in fiery confirmation hearings.
Did you say Lyme disease is a highly likely militarily engineered bioweapon? I probably did say that.
Kennedy makes two big arguments about our health, and the first is deeply divisive. He is skeptical of vaccines.
Well, I do believe that autism does come from vaccines. Science disagrees.
The second argument is something that a lot of Americans, regardless of their politics, have concluded. He says our food system is serving us garbage and that garbage is making us sick.
Coming up on Today Explained, a confidant of Kennedy's, in fact, the man who helped facilitate his introduction to Donald Trump, on what the Make America Healthy Again movement wants.
Support for the show from ServiceNow
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform.
Callie Means is an informal advisor to RFK who went viral on Twitter about two years ago with this explosive claim.
Callie Means
I had worked as a consultant for Coca-Cola, and he said that he'd witnessed Coke give millions of dollars to various groups to ensure that sugar taxes failed and that soda was included in food stamp funding.
Noel King
The NAACP took millions of dollars from Coca-Cola to say that we should maintain Coca-Cola on food stamps, which is just an absolutely insane public policy because that's literally poisoning lower-income kids with a supplemental nutrition assistance program.
Callie Means
Kali went on to co-author a book with his sister, Dr. Casey Means, called Good Energy, and he founded a company called TrueMed.
Noel King
Today, he maintains deep skepticism of big food and big pharma, and he contends that these industries have economic incentives not to make Americans well, but to keep us sick.
Callie Means
In hindsight, what I saw is that the health care system is working to propagate a system where more Americans are sick and to perform interventions on those Americans, not to cure any disease, but manage it.
Noel King
And that's 95% of our medical spending. 95% of our medical spending is management of chronic disease.
Callie Means
So examples of that are in this invisible hand at work where I don't even think people realize what they're doing is working for Coca-Cola, funding millions of dollars to the American Diabetes Association.
Noel King
I saw that. So why is Coca-Cola funding the American Diabetes Association? And why would the American Diabetes Association be accepting money from Coca-Cola when we have a diabetes crisis among children, when it's liquid diabetes, it's high sugar drinks?
Callie Means
So there's actually this interplay between our food system, our ultra-processed food system that's getting people addicted, that's getting people sick, and then a healthcare system that stands silent.
Noel King
On the pharmaceutical side, it's the rigging of institutions. The pharmaceutical industry is the lifeblood of academic research and the NIH and the federal bureaucracies just by definition are a revolving door, an orgy of corruption between industry and government.
Callie Means
I mean 11 of the 12 past FDA directors literally left the FDA and the next day walked into a pharmaceutical office.
Noel King
I had a list of Stanford and Harvard professors that we were going to funnel money to. You know, these aren't, you know, apparent corruption. It's rank corruption.
Callie Means
And I saw that.
Noel King
Kelly, what do you hear as the main pushback against you? What do your critics argue?
Kelly
Well, they resort to ad hominem attacks. If you really stay on these unimpeachable messages, I think they're pretty hard to disagree with.
Noel King
It's a demonstrable fact that our scientific and healthcare agencies are co-opted.
Kelly
75% of the FDA department that oversees drug approvals is funded by the pharmaceutical industry itself.
Noel King
NIH bureaucrats are able to take royalties from drugs, which they did during COVID.
Kelly
It's also impossible to argue with the fact that we're the sickest country in the developed world and there's a true chronic disease crisis among children.
Noel King
That's pretty hard to argue with.
Kelly
So what happens is the healthcare industry is the largest and fastest growing industry in the country.
Noel King
It's the most powerful industry in the country.
Kelly
The pharmaceutical industry is the biggest funder of politicians themselves, scientific research, regulatory agencies, the media itself.
Noel King
So they control a lot of our institutions just by definition.
Kelly
I've seen some of the ad hominem attacks. I've also seen another line of criticism about you and what you have to say, which is that there's this claim.
Noel King
I mean, Well, you've made it, right? There's a claim that there's almost a conspiracy at play here that involves big food companies, pharmaceutical companies, medical schools.
Kelly
It goes all the way to the top levels of government.
Noel King
I wonder if you can explain that aspect of your message. Why does everything, because you know that many people will be turned off by kind of what they view as conspiratorial thinking.
Kelly
Might it make sense to temper this a little bit? Do you think part of the problem is – like, you know, it sounds a bit nutty, someone might say, right?
Noel King
What sounds nutty that I said?
Kelly
The idea that everybody is in league to keep Americans sick.
Noel King
I didn't say that. I didn't say that. I completely dispute the premise of your question.
Kelly
I said that the pharmaceutical industry makes money when people are sick and loses money when they're healthy.
Noel King
That's not a conspiracy. That's a demonstrable statement of economic fact.
Kelly
And hospitals make money from fee Many friends from Harvard Business School of mine work at hospitals and their job is dependent on filling the beds
Noel King
That not a conspiracy I going to push just a little bit further on this Kelly because there are statements of fact that you are making Yes And they will pass a fact check It the idea that pharmaceutical companies want to keep us sick I didn say that.
Kelly
Companies want to keep us. I didn't say that. I said their economic incentives.
Noel King
Well, the economic incentive is the want.
Kelly
I mean, it's America. It's a capitalist society. No, I didn't talk about their motivations.
Noel King
What are their motivations?
Kelly
This is the largest industry in the country is healthcare. A pharmaceutical executive gets fired if there's not growth.
Noel King
Growth of pharmaceutical, the pharmaceutical industry presupposes and necessitates more sick people.
Kelly
You're saying there is an economic incentive. Somebody gets fired unless the company grows.
Noel King
The company requires more sick patients to grow.
Kelly
That's an indisputable fact.
Noel King
I think that many people would agree with you that when there is money involved, the incentives to grow, to grow the company can lead to perverse outcomes like a lot of sick Americans.
Kelly
You are the founder of a company that sells, among other things, supplements, fitness classes, fitness equipment.
Noel King
I was on this morning. You have some good sales. You personally have an economic incentive in this too.
Kelly
And I wonder, is there any part of you that thinks maybe I should just be the guy that says the thing but not try to make money off it?
Noel King
Well, that's inaccurate. My company facilitates third-party medical interventions to recommend whether exercise, supplementation, food in some cases is a medically appropriate intervention.
Kelly
And you're not making any profit?
Noel King
No, no. Hold on. Excuse me. Excuse me. No, I don't think we should expect nobody to make money.
Kelly
I think everyone's financial conflicts should be highly exposed.
Noel King
My company makes money when a third-party provider recommends efficacious treatments of root cause non-pharmaceutical interventions.
Kelly
My company will make money when more people are exercising and more people are eating broccoli.
Noel King
And I am absolutely fine that being exposed and that being scrutinized of whether I'm in the pocket of big exercise and big broccoli.
President Trump appointed a seed oil lobbyist to be chief of staff of the USDA.
Kelly
He fought Obama-era rules to cut ultra-processed foods from school lunch.
Noel King
He made RFK eat a Big Mac for a photo op.
Kelly
In the 2024 election, President Trump overwhelmingly won in America's farm-dependent counties.
Noel King
Those are areas where there is a lot of farming.
Kelly
And so you would assume the president has to really take care not to alienate big ag.
Noel King
Do you think President Trump really is genuinely invested in the Maha movement?
Kelly
Well, he didn't have to appoint Bobby Kennedy. He didn't have to say at every single rally that he was going to have Bobby Kennedy go wild on health.
Noel King
So President Trump said this. He doesn't think a lot about health policy.
Kelly
But what he does think a lot about is corruption and taking on the swamp and taking on corporate cronyism.
Noel King
And I think he's really seen in Bobby Kennedy how the forces that profit from sick children are a great example of what the foundation of President Trump's candidacy is about, which is corruption holding us down.
Kelly
So, yes, I don't think there's any cabinet secretary that there's more demonstrated history with and bonding with during the campaign than Bobby Kennedy.
Noel King
There is an area here that is deeply divisive, and it will come up again and again, we can predict, in Mr. Kennedy's hearing.
Kelly
And that is his views on vaccines.
Noel King
So he has said before that he believes autism comes from vaccines.
Kelly
He runs a nonprofit, Children's Health Defense, that consistently cast doubt on vaccines, on the schedule on which they're administered, on the ingredients in them, on whether they protect or actually cause chronic illnesses.
Noel King
Do Mr. Kennedy's positions on vaccines concern you at all?
Kelly
What Bobby Kennedy has consistently said about vaccines during the campaign is that they should be studied like any other pharmaceutical product.
Noel King
Blanket trust of pharmaceutical companies is not a good idea either.
Kelly
And continued scientific research on interventions we're providing to the American people, whether that be pharmaceuticals or the other billion prescriptions we're writing in America a year.
Noel King
I don't think anyone disagrees with that.
Kelly
And even what you mentioned about the children's health defense, you didn't say that they're attacking all vaccines in general.
Noel King
You said they're questioning the pharmaceutical schedule.
Kelly
They're questioning specific ingredients.
Noel King
I mean, I don't know. We should be scrutinizing each formulation and whether that's safe and which the safest this vaccine is.
Kelly
I mean, that's a good thing to do.
Noel King
We, you know, we have demonstrably different schedules than other countries.
Kelly
Like, you know, continued research and refining of that is, seems like a reasonable thing to do.
Noel King
So I think there's a lot of, frankly, pharma money and bad money making that the key issue, even though he's talking about much wider things.
You know, our parents are old enough to remember polio.
Kelly
We're in the millennial generation and polio feels like it was a million years ago.
Noel King
It really wasn't.
Kelly
Americans broadly are susceptible to conspiratorial thinking.
Noel King
One of the concerns that I know you don't like the word conspiratorial, but let me offer you the concern as I've heard it articulated.
Kelly
Americans are going to decide they don't trust vaccines broadly.
Noel King
They are not going to vaccinate their children.
Kelly
And that will return us to a generation and a time that most people just don't want to go back to.
Noel King
I think you just painted an extremely pessimistic and nihilistic view of the American people.
Kelly
What an unfounded statement to say that they're prone to conspiracy thinking.
Noel King
That's kind of a dismissive statement, honestly.
Kelly
I myself am prone to it. Like, I am happy to say I'm—
Noel King
Well, maybe that's being rational. Maybe that's being prone to questioning things.
Kelly
Listen, this is what President Trump and Bobby talked about during the campaign, and I strongly believe.
Noel King
The American people are rational. The American people don't want their kids to be sick.
Kelly
I really commend and respect, you know, the media hearkening back and their concern for polio, right, and polio coming back.
Noel King
But I would push you. If you or anyone else is concerned about childhood health, which is the real issue here, we should be concerned about what's happening right now.
Kelly
We have a chronic disease crisis. We have a truly societally destabilizing event happening.
Noel King
Yes, I agree. We should keep polio at bay.
Kelly
But, like, that's not even on the top 10 list.
Noel King
Let me ask you a last question.
Kelly
If Mr Kennedy is confirmed MAHA the Make America Healthy Again movement is very close to being inside the system maybe even in a couple of years being the system
Noel King
And some people might say well that's when the work gets really hard, right? It's easier to be an outsider than it is to be an insider.
Kelly
Do you have any thoughts on that, on what it might be like for this, at the moment, outsider movement to operate on the inside?
Noel King
Do you think it'll be tough?
Kelly
What the promise of Maha is, is Bobby, a reform-minded person, I would say a magnetic, incredible leader, is putting a stake in the ground that we need to move to a more preventative model and a more chronic disease reversal-focused model of health.
Noel King
That's his stake.
Kelly
And I had a really profound conversation with the dean of a med school recently, and he was honest.
Noel King
And he said, listen, everyone in the faculty lounge thinks Bob, he's a whack job.
Kelly
And, you know, if you steer NIH funding to more preventative outcomes, and, you know, that's kind of where the NIH is going, they're going to kick and scream and complain and say that's, you know, stupid.
Noel King
But they're going to write grants for what the NIH is saying they want.
Kelly
And if you can win and keep this kind of vibe and this movement towards that more preventative pull, in four years, in six years, Bobby will be gone.
Noel King
But if that preventative direction that the health incentives go towards stays that way, in six years, it'll be the norm.
Kelly
In six years, it won't be about Bobby being crazy.
Noel King
It'll just be like, this is how things are done.
Kelly
And that's the stakes right now is we're trying to – we've lost our way a bit.
Noel King
Our health incentives are too focused on waiting for people to get sick and then managing those conditions.
Kelly
I would argue profiting from those conditions.
Noel King
What we're trying to do is get conflicts of interest out of the system and steer the sizable incentives that the government creates towards a more preventative future that asks how can we actually prevent and reverse these diseases.
Kelly
That's the fight right now.
Noel King
And we just have to continue to win that argument.
Kelly
You know, at the highest level, these are unimpeachable ideas that most Americans agree with.
Noel King
It's not going to be total shock and awe.
Kelly
We're not going to be able to change everything at once.
Noel King
But we really have changed the country if we can accomplish that momentum shift to that world.
Kali Means. The book is Good Energy. The company is TrueMed.
Kelly
Thank you so much for taking the time for us today.
Noel King
We really appreciate it.
Kelly
Thank you.
Noel King
Before we go, you heard Kali say that the healthcare industry is the biggest in America.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
I think overall, Callie is correct that most Americans would agree on those issues. They're concerned about chronic disease, access to healthy food for kids.
Noel King
Kids, you know, there's a lot of questions about why our rates of diet-related diseases have continued to climb.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
Diabetes, obesity, these diseases are not just costly for the healthcare system, but they really affect people's lives.
Noel King
So there is deep concern.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
I think where we get into some division is what to do about that and what the government's role is.
Noel King
And that's, I think, where the rubber is really going to meet the road here.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
So, Maha first became, I think, an actual term that was entering, like, the fray, if you will, in August, when RFK Jr. had dropped out of the presidential race.
Noel King
And he endorsed Donald Trump, which surprised a lot of people.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
If I'm given the chance to fix the chronic disease crisis and reform our food production, I promise that within two years, we will watch chronic disease burden lift dramatically.
Noel King
We will make Americans healthy again.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
And in this alliance, Trump then adopted some of the platform around food.
Noel King
So you then started hearing then-candidate Trump saying, like, I want to get the toxins out of food.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
You know, I want to make America healthy again.
Noel King
Millions and millions of Americans who want clean air clean water and a healthy nation have concerns about toxins in our environment and pesticides in our food
Halina Bademiller-Evich
This immediately perked my ears up because I've been covering these issues for a long time, and generally you would hear those arguments being made on the left.
Noel King
And Democrats, you know, here in Washington weren't getting much traction on them, but those are the folks who were raising those arguments.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
So then when I heard Trump raising those issues, I immediately thought something is happening here that is fundamentally different.
Noel King
There is some political realignment that is happening.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
You know, up until even a couple months ago, I couldn't remember ever hearing a Republican talk about food additives on Capitol Hill.
Noel King
And as of September, we were seeing senators like openly and publicly saying, you know, FDA needs to look at red dye three or whatever the issue was.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
And that was just a real turn of events.
Noel King
We got to help, you know, get our kids healthy, chronic disease, viruses.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
And RFK Jr. is the guy to do that.
Noel King
Let's say that RFK is confirmed and he is the new leader.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
He is the new head of the Department of Health and Human Services.
Noel King
What does he want to do to that agency? What has he said?
Halina Bademiller-Evich
We're waiting to hear details, but I think in general he has talked about, you know, getting conflicts of interest out of health care decisions and also food decisions.
Noel King
So I focus on food.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
One of the big issues has been the dietary guidelines for Americans, which is the official nutrition advice from the government.
Noel King
RFK has taken issue with a lot of the experts that advise the government on that process, saying they have too many conflicts of interest with the food industry and sometimes pharma.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
He wants to really reform that process.
Noel King
We don't know exactly how, but HHS and USDA work together on those guidelines, and they're actually set to come out in 2025.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
So he could have a lot of influence over what those guidelines say.
Noel King
For example, the advisory committee that just wrapped up told the government that there wasn't enough evidence to essentially recommend that Americans consume less ultra-processed foods.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
Kennedy himself has been extremely critical of ultra-processed foods.
Noel King
So that's one area where perhaps, you know, the guidelines would say something about ultra-processed foods.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
He also wants to reorient NIH research to look more at root causes, more at holistic interventions, so not as much focused on pharma and sort of traditional medical interventions.
Noel King
Food additives, cracking down potentially on food additives, although I have a lot of questions about whether or not the Trump administration is really going to regulate, which is what you would have to do to crack down on food additives.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
RFK's also made a lot of claims about completely changing the food system on the USDA side, which he will not have purview over, but he's talked about changing farm subsidies, cleaning up school meals, so actually banning processed foods from school meals, just really upending that multi-billion dollar program.
Noel King
How challenging will it be to make reforms within the food system?
Halina Bademiller-Evich
So it really depends on the issue.
Noel King
If you're talking about something like totally changing how we subsidize food in this country, that would require Congress.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
You would have to write a farm bill that's going to reform the system.
Noel King
And a lot of that falls over at USDA, which RFK would not have jurisdiction over.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
That is Brooke Rollins, who's been nominated for that position, and she's much more of, I think, a status quo pick.
Noel King
So that would be one area where it would be very difficult.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
I would say exceedingly unlikely that that's going to happen.
Noel King
But on some of the issues that would fall under FDA, you could really bring down the hammer on food additives if that were the priority.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
They could speed up all these post-market reviews, which means they take a really hard look at a lot of the chemicals that are already in the food supply.
Noel King
They could really close this loophole, which allows a lot of substances on the market without pre-market approval.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
And so there are some policy changes that could happen there, but it would require going through a regulatory process, you know, allowing those bureaucratic wheels to turn.
Noel King
But again, on each of these, it's like pushing a boulder uphill.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
And so I would not bet that in five to 10 years we're going to see that reality.
Noel King
But I think that would be the ideal that they would be pushing for.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
We'll see, again, the extent to which Republicans in this administration are going to be, you know, using the federal government to push that vision forward.
Noel King
It's in some ways a radical departure from where we are now.
Halina Bademiller-Evich of the Food Fix newsletter.
Halina Bademiller-Evich
Miles Bryan produced today's show, Jolie Myers edited.
Noel King
Andrea Kristen's daughter and Rob Byers engineered.
And Laura Bullard is our fact checker.
I'm Noelle King.
It's Today Explained.
Thank you.
End of show
Halina Bademiller-Evich
Find your flavor at senoritadrinks.com. Use code VOX20 for 20% off. Must be 21+. This product may cause intoxication. This product has not been evaluated or approved by the FDA. This product may contain up to 0.3% THC.
Noel King
Thank you.
End of show