Main Topic: The episode discusses the topic of inflation, specifically why economists and forecasters, including Dylan Matthews, got it wrong in predicting that inflation would be transitory.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
It's Today Explained. I'm Noel King. For months, my colleague Dylan Matthews, a senior correspondent at Vox, was of a particular opinion about inflation. He said, and many economists said, do not worry.
Dylan Matthews
I was not alone in that prediction. And I've done a lot of thinking recently about why I got that wrong and why other people might have gotten it wrong and how we got into the current situation where inflation really is something to worry about.
Noel King
It's 8.5 percent. It's high. It's getting to a level we haven't seen since the 1970s, early 1980s, when inflation became sort of the defining issue in American politics and really caused a great deal of damage. And so we're very much not out of the danger zone.
Support for Today Explained from Adio
Coming up, what economists and Dylan got wrong about inflation and how we might get out of the danger zone.
Support for Today Explained from Macy's
Dylan Matthews, senior correspondent at Vox, last year to you, it seemed like inflation would be transitory. There would be an end to it.
Dylan Matthews
Yeah. In 2021, there was kind of a sense by me and some other people that inflation was happening in a few goods, but not everything. It seemed like cars were getting a lot more expensive. It seemed like gas and food were getting more expensive. And my general attitude was, you know, this isn't great, but this too shall pass.
Noel King
And it just kept not passing. And worse, kept spreading to areas other than gas and cars and food into places where you wouldn't expect some of the shortages we were seeing to necessarily be driving prices up.
Dylan Matthews
To your credit, you weren't the only person who doubted that inflation would get this bad or last for this long, were you?
Noel King
No. So when I was predicting inflation under 3% for 2022, I based that very explicitly on both the Federal Reserve, who are basing this on literally hundreds of economists who work for the Federal Reserve system trying to predict these things, they were all suggesting that inflation would cool throughout 2022.
Dylan Matthews
The survey of professional forecasters, which is a very useful survey of economists who specialize in doing this kind of forecast, had even lower predictions for inflation in 2022. So there was a really persistent error. And it wasn't an error among everyone. Some people who were publicly projecting high inflation. and I think deserve a bit of a victory lap include Larry Summers, the widely hated in some quarters, beloved in some quarters, former Treasury secretary.
Noel King
So there is a kind of scaffolding or framework behind why you and many, many, many other very smart people thought that inflation wasn't going to be a big deal. Tell me about where this kind of framework begins.
Dylan Matthews
Sure. So you kind of have to understand the history of how economists have thought about inflation. The most basic framework for understanding it is something called the Phillips curve.
Support for Today Explained from Built Rewards
Noel King
In Econ 101, you might learn that one definition of inflation is too much money chasing too few goods. Simple, right? You want to take care not to flood an economy with too much money.
Dylan Matthews
But then the U.S. government floods the economy with a lot of money. About $5 trillion is one estimate that I've heard. About $1.8 trillion in unemployment and stimulus checks and other things to individuals, about $1.7 trillion to businesses, over $700 billion in state and local aid.
Noel King
Just a lot, a lot, a lot of money. And that resulted in total spending, not just sort of matching where it was before the pandemic, which I think would have been the goal, but kind of exceeding it.
Dylan Matthews
So the floodgates open, $5 trillion comes pouring into the American economy. Inflation does start to go up. Everybody does notice it. But you didn't think it would turn out to be a big deal. Why?
Noel King
I had a few philosophies on this. One was, you know, it's better to err on the side of too much than too little. And I think that gets at some of what we talked about, about the 2008 crisis, where we did too little and a lot of people suffered.
Dylan Matthews
And I think some of it was also a sense that it would settle down. We might have gotten into a situation where there was more money than there was stuff to buy with it. But that would ease. People would go back to work after they got vaccinated.
Noel King
The virus would kind of die down and stop sort of slowing the economy on its own by making people sick and making it harder to do stuff. And after all the money was dispersed by the federal government, people would spend it and then get back to normal and it wouldn't keep going.
Dylan Matthews
A lot of those assumptions turned out to be wrong. People were pretty prudent with the government's money, and so they've been spending it very gradually.
Noel King
And that's definitely what, like, my personal finance teacher in high school would have told me to do. But it has made sort of the resulting inflation a lot more durable than it otherwise would have been.
Dylan Matthews
Prices surging more than they have in 30 years, and there doesn't seem to be an end in sight. The price of a pound of bacon rising more than a dollar, a dozen eggs up 21 percent and a sirloin steak up a whopping $2 a pound.
Noel King
A lot of people are wondering, when is this going to end? It's also meant that price increases in some areas aren't offset by decreases in other areas.
Dylan Matthews
Normally when you have like a huge increase in gas prices people spend less money on other stuff because they only have so much cash. And so they have to offset price increases in one area by spending less on other stuff.
Noel King
That typically means that the other stuff sees its prices fall. And so you don't get overall inflation. You just get a change in relative prices between types of things.
Dylan Matthews
You didn't see that this time in part because people had lots of money in their checking and savings accounts because the government had been so generous. And so you just sort of get a broad overall inflation.
Noel King
We needed a strong fiscal response. We just did a lot of it. And a lot of it was not particularly well targeted.
Dylan Matthews
I think in retrospect, by far, the most wasteful part of the whole package was the hundreds of billions of dollars sent to state and local governments.
Noel King
There was kind of an assumption the state and local governments were going to see their tax receipts plummet and they would need all this federal help. And they really didn't.
Dylan Matthews
The economy recovered fast. They had a big surge in their tax receipts. And then they got this enormous handout from the federal government.
Noel King
And it would be one thing if they spent that sort of prudently improving services and whatnot. They'd spend it on tax cuts.
Dylan Matthews
And so sometimes when people hear, you know, we spend too much on stimulus, they hear like, oh, you wanted to take my check away. That's not necessarily what I mean.
Noel King
I mean that like maybe Texas shouldn't have gotten billions of dollars to like cut taxes. and that maybe that was somewhat inflationary.
Dylan Matthews
Again, it was an attitude of it's better to err on the side of doing too much than doing too little. And that still might have been the case, but we definitely erred on the side of doing too much.
Noel King
People are seeing that inflation has gone up by 8 plus percent. Is it fair to assume that your average employee going in to negotiate a salary is going to ask their employer for more money or the person who's already employed is going to go to their boss and say, hey, you know, my paycheck is shrinking here.
Dylan Matthews
Yeah, so this is a dynamic that's sometimes called a wage price spiral. And the idea being that when inflation is going up and people are seeing their wages adjusted for inflation go down, they'll demand higher wages and they'll get them.
Noel King
I'm skeptical of it basically because employers have a lot of power. So one example I often use is hospitals.
Dylan Matthews
I grew up in a small town in New Hampshire. There were basically like two hospitals nearby. And if you were a nurse, you kind of had to work for one of them.
Noel King
And it was pretty easy for them to not poach each other's people in such a way that people could say, you know, if you don't give me a raise, I'm going to go to this other hospital.
Dylan Matthews
And a lot of markets are like that. There are only a few employers who could theoretically hire you, and that reduces your bargaining power and reduces your pay.
Noel King
So I think that has meant that workers can't exploit this inflation to get wage increases as much as they might want to or might be fair.
Dylan Matthews
Since last February, the average hourly wages have increased by more than 5 percent. Historically, that is a considerable increase. But with the cost of goods at its highest level in 40 years, it's posing a threat to the nation's economic recovery.
Noel King
All right. So we have trillions of dollars floating around the economy from the stimmy. We also have a tight labor market. What does it take now? What will it take now to bring inflation down?
Dylan Matthews
So I think there are a few key policies to pursue here. And one thing that I think some economists on the left have been emphasizing that I agree is very important is just increasing productive capacity for some things where we have shortages, building more semiconductor factories, building more robust supply chains, expanding renewable energy so that gas prices are less important for people.
Noel King
That's all great. That's all part of a long-term approach to inflation management. In a more short-term thing, you've got to get the virus under control.
Dylan Matthews
And that's a tough public health challenge. People seem sick of masks, and we seem to maybe be reaching an upper limit on how much we can vaccinate people, given sort of the number of people who are skeptical of vaccines for very bad reasons.
Noel King
But there are still some people who aren't working because of fear of the virus. And the more you get the virus under control, the more you can get those people working and expand what we're able to do with our economy.
Dylan Matthews
But I think the ugly truth is the Fed needs to use and has started using its lever of trying to tamp down spending to get it to match what the economy is actually capable of doing.
Noel King
Federal Reserve raising interest rates to a new range of 0.25 to 0.5 percent. And that's ugly and it's causing some concentrated pain.
Dylan Matthews
But we're at a point where it's clear that we're not going to expand our ability to make stuff for that supply to reach the level of demands we're at now.
Noel King
We're not able to do that in a very short-term way. What we are able to do is constrain demand a little bit to get it to better match up with what the economy is overall able to do.
Dylan Matthews
That's a conclusion I reach with some great regret. Interest rate hikes are a little like chemotherapy. They cause a lot of pain in the now, and they're blunt, and they hurt healthy cells. But they might be better than the alternative and prevent future pain.
Support for Today Explained from Schwab
Noel King
Dylan Matthews is a senior correspondent at Vox. Today's show was produced by Will Reed, edited by Matthew Collette, engineered by Paul Mounsey, and fact-checked by Laura Bullard.
Support for Today Explained from Bilt
And also, Amina El-Sadi, Matthew Collette, myself, and Will Reed, as Laura is sick today. The rest of our team includes Halima Shah, Hari Moagdi, Miles Bryan, Victoria Chamberlain, and my co-host, Sean Ramos-Furr.
Dylan Matthews
Special thanks this week to Sophie Lalonde.
Noel King
Our supervising producer is Amina El-Sadi. Vox's VP of audio is Liz Kelly Nelson. We use music by Breakmaster Cylinder and Noam Hassenfeld. I'm Noelle King. Today Explained is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Thank you.
Theme music fades in