Main Topic: The 2018 Brazilian presidential election, which is taking place in a tumultuous time for the country.
Participants: Sarah Maslin, The Economist's Brazil correspondent, and Sean Ramos from Today Explained.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
It's still pretty much a brand new month, the month of October, and every month Audible members get one credit for any audiobook they choose, plus two Audible originals from a changing selection that they can't get anywhere else. You can start a 30-day trial and your first audiobook is free at audible.com slash todayexplained or when you text todayexplained to 500-500.
Brazil's got a presidential election coming up on Sunday. It's the usual drill. There's a first round. If no one gets more than 50 percent of the votes, there's a second round later this month. Whoever wins gets to lead the country for the next four years. But here's where things get interesting. One leading candidate campaigned from a hospital bed and another campaigned from jail.
This has been a dramatic and tumultuous election in Brazil for a number of reasons. Sarah Maslin is The Economist's Brazil correspondent.
Sarah Maslin
Brazil's in a really tough place right now. It has gone through the deepest and longest economic recession in its history. And voters are extremely frustrated because of that. And also a series of interlocking corruption scandals known as the Lava Jato or car wash operation.
What many believe to be the biggest corruption scandal ever anywhere in the world. This bribery and money laundering scheme spread throughout Latin America, but the epicenter is in Brazil and it has already cost that country billions of dollars. Basically tarred nearly all of the major political parties. And given the sense that politics here is just extremely rotten.
Starting in 2014, prosecutors revealed kickbacks between politicians from nearly all of the major parties and private companies whereby bribes or campaign donations from those companies would then lead to government contracts or laws that were good for their businesses. And it's just an absolutely massive thing.
Even to this day, there's sort of more cases coming out on a pretty regular basis related to the car wash scandal, which is where it all began, in a car wash that was used to launder money. It all began in the capital city of Brasilia in the most mundane of places, a gas station that had once housed a car wash.
In what came to be known as Operation Car Wash, the police tapped the phones of a money transfer business housed there, and in 2012, they heard the voice of Alberto Youssef, an infamous money launderer, the New York Times reported. Anyone linked to him immediately came under suspicion.
The effect that it has had on Brazilians is a real sort of sense that corruption is the basis of the entire political system, And they blame the economic recession and crisis on corruption, which isn't quite right. Because, you know, to be honest, the recession also has a lot to do with legal distortions where companies were given subsidies and there was irresponsible budget management and lending.
But, you know, a lot of Brazilians, they're struggling to buy everything they need at the supermarket. And to them, you know, the corruption is the explanation for why the economy is struggling. And that sort of comes as a surprise, right, because Brazil was doing really well there for a minute?
So Brazil had a really exciting rise in the early 2000s where their economy was doing well. While the U.S. economy is slumping, the economies of some nations are booming, among them Brazil's. And it began to take sort of a leadership role on the international stage.
So for a lot of Brazilians, it feels like a pretty deep fall to where they are now. And, you know, there's hope that someone will be able to bring the country back to that kind of prosperity. You know, but before that, there's just some pretty serious problems to fix.
So who are the candidates who are offering to fix it? Who are the frontrunners? The two leaders in the polls are a far-right candidate named Jair Bolsonaro and a leftist candidate named Fernando Haddad. And they couldn't be more different.
Bolsonaro is an outsider. He has promised to shake things up and rid the country of corruption. And then the other candidate, Haddad, is the representative of a party that many Brazilians see as responsible for all of the corruption. And then other Brazilians see as responsible for the prosperity.
So I would say the principal factor of this election is you know stark polarization and a real divide in the vision for what Brazil is going to look like in the future. And each of their campaigns has sort of been wild in totally different ways right?
Well this election has had some crazy twists and turns. First of all, until just a few weeks ago, Haddad wasn't even the candidate for the Workers' Party. They were running with the ex-president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, very popular politician, but actually in jail.
The Supreme Court narrowly voted against his petition to remain free while he appeals a 12-year corruption conviction. This means Brazil's most popular politician and the frontrunner for October's presidential election must go to jail.
Which eventually meant that he was barred and Haddadu was swapped in. He's been in jail since April. But his party, knowing that he was just such a popular politician, kept him as a candidate until the bitter end.
And his candidacy was eventually struck down by the Supreme Court. But they were running campaign ads showing Lula with Haddadji. And then sort of in the background, Haddad's actual vice presidential candidate. And these ads say things like, Haddadji is Lula and Lula a Haddadji.
Almost trying to suggest to voters that they're voting for Haddad, but really it's going to be Lula who's running the show. Wow, so there's no subtlety there. Not at all.
So who is Haddad and how is he faring as sort of the stand-in for Lula? So Haddad is extremely enigmatic. We all want to know who Haddad is.
You're feeling the pain that I'm feeling. We have to tell the people that we are feeling that same pain, but that it's not time to go back home with our heads down. It's time to take to the streets with our heads high up to win this election. And we will win it for Lula, for the Workers' Party, for the Community Party, for all social movements, and for Brazil.
He was a minister under Lula and then the mayor of Sao Paulo. People who work with him said that he was a responsible leader and effective and a good negotiator, all kind of qualities that you want in a leader.
However, he comes from this party that has kind of refused to come to terms with its participation in these massive corruption scandals, which sort of leads to this question of how much Haddad will be able to strike his own path if he's elected or how much he'd just be sort of a puppet of the workers party.
So on the left, you have this candidate who's currently in jail slash his replacement stand-in. How are things going on the right? I wish I could tell you that things were calm on the right, but it has been crazy there as well.
Bolsonaro is this far-right congressman but hasn't gotten that much play in the public eye until the past couple of years when he's managed to cast himself as this outsider, traditional values, iron-fist approach to crime and has skyrocketed to the forefront of this race, casting himself as the guy who can come in and fix things here.
That has gotten him a ton of support, especially among younger male, higher educated voters. But it's also gotten him some real pushback. And even a month ago at a campaign rally, while he was being carried on the shoulders of his supporters, he was stabbed.
A shocking moment caught on camera. A leading presidential candidate in Brazil stabbed during a campaign rally. Cell phone video from various angles captured him clutching his abdomen in pain. His supporters rushed him into a waiting ambulance amid panic and confusion.
Bolsonaro's son posted a photo of his dad in the hospital saying the stabbing injured his liver, lung and intestine. We don't really know what the motivations were. It seems the person who attacked him may have had sort of mental health problems.
Sean Rameswaram
How does not only getting stabbed, but then fulfilling the rest of your campaign from a hospital bed affect people's vision of whether you're going to be healthy enough to run a country?
Sarah Maslin
Well, you know, it actually seems to have had the opposite effect. After Bolsonaro was stabbed, you sort of started to see this real crystallization of his polling numbers. Being stabbed meant that he was all over the media, and it also made it difficult for the other candidates to attack him.
Sean Rameswaram
What is it about Bolsonaro that is engaging younger voters and especially younger male voters?
Sarah Maslin
Right. So, I mean, you see sort of different voters who like Bolsonaro for different reasons. But with Bolsonaro, you've got both this nostalgia for a time when Brazil had more, quote, traditional values.
So you do have some older voters in that sense. But I think the younger voters, it just real frustration and being fed up. These are voters who kind of came of age when Brazil was doing well and the economy was soaring.
And The Economist had a cover of the famous Christ statue in Rio de Janeiro taking off like a rocket. But then the corruption scandal came and the recession. And it was almost as if all of that was sort of fake and all of that was a lie.
And underneath it all, the politicians were sort of helping themselves to the government coffers. And I think for young, educated Brazilians who have been following this rise and fall, there's a real kind of sense of betrayal and of, you know, wanting someone who doesn't look at all like any of the other politicians.
And for some of them, that is Mr. Bolsonaro. What about him looks so different from the sort of norm in Brazil? I mean, part of it is just his rhetoric. And he doesn't worry about political correctness. He says offensive things.
He has cast himself as, you know, someone who's very different and uniquely capable to shake things up. But I think, I mean, there's also this kind of darker element. You know, he's spoken about the 1964 military coup as, you know, a necessary thing for Brazil that was sort of the only solution to what he kind of considers this communist terrorist threat at the time.
Sean Rameswaram
Sarah, how old is democracy in Brazil?
Sarah Maslin
Brazil sort of had throughout the 20th century back and forth between democratic rule and military rule. But most recently, there was a dictatorship that started in the 1960s and lasted until the 1980s.
Brazil's military dictatorship committed crimes against humanity, So says the country's National Truth Commission. It says there's proof that more than 400 people were killed or disappeared between 1964 and 85, but the real figure is undoubtedly higher.
Sean Rameswaram
Democracy came back with the 1988 constitution, so it's pretty young. Yeah, and fragile it sounds like.
Sarah Maslin
Yeah, and I don't think anyone would have said that until very recently. The institutions in Brazil have proved themselves pretty successful. The biggest example of that being that the judiciary over the past few years has really gone after politicians and revealed these corruption scandals and attempted to hold people accountable for it.
Sean Rameswaram
Between the late 80s and now have there been glory days for Brazilian democracy?
Sarah Maslin
I think that if I were a correspondent here during you know during the time when Brazil was you know was leading up kind of world initiatives on climate change and on poverty and the economy was doing well, and business was flocking to Brazil, which is not so much of a distant memory, that was just sort of less than a decade ago, I would have said absolutely, democracy is thriving.
But, you know, but what we didn't really know was that that whole time, there was this sort of massive corruption happening just beneath the surface. And so, you know, it's hard to say.
Sean Rameswaram
I think it's not as simple as sort of it's either democratic or it isn't. But, you know, I think that the corruption scandal and now this kind of, you know, this specter of a candidate who has expressed support for something other than democracy and has really seen people sort of react positively to that shows that the democracy is young and that it still got a long way to go.
Sarah Maslin
So how did it get to this point where this far-right candidate can make appeals to a military dictatorship and, you know, lead the polls?
Sean Rameswaram
I think what you have to remember is that, you know, in Brazil, as sort of everywhere else, people vote on emotion and on fear. You know, if you ask Brazilians to sort of, you know, Whether they want to live under military dictatorship, I think all of them would absolutely say no.
Sarah Maslin
But if you ask how to get out of this crisis or what the solution is, they want change and they want something different. And the current round of politicians have proved themselves to be mostly interested in their own preservation, not in any sort of reform that would help Brazil become a more prosperous and a more equal and more fair country.
Sean Rameswaram
I think that most who will vote for Bolsonaro will do so because they think that he can solve this problem without resorting to some sort of a military solution.
Sarah Maslin
Absolutely. You saw this kind of real fear of Mr. Bolsonaro and what he might mean for Brazilian democracy this past weekend when hundreds of thousands of Brazilians in, you know, in cities throughout the whole country took to the streets.
Sean Rameswaram
People shouted, Bolsonaro, you can cry. Women will take you down. Waving banners with the hashtag Eli now, which means not him, and slogans about, you know, accusing him of being a fascist or an extremist.
Sarah Maslin
They chanted, Bolsonaro, you fascist, women will put you in line. Or sort of a torture because of his associations with the dictatorship.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a fear that his kind of flirtations with past moments of undemocratic rule would make him more likely in the case of a kind of chaotic situation or when crime and the economy aren't shaping up to take some sort of a dramatic action.
Sarah Maslin
And Brazilians are certainly scared of that as well. And that's sort of the source of this huge outcry and social movement against his candidacy.
Sean Rameswaram
I do have to say, though, that there's fear of Haddad as well. Some people believe, especially people who are more kind of economically conservative, they believe that Haddad would be a real risk of, you know, they compare him to Venezuela.
Sarah Maslin
They say kind of Brazil could become a socialist country. And I think a lot of Brazilians are trying to decide not necessarily which one of these two they kind of feel the most represented by, but rather which one is, in their opinion, sort of a bigger danger or a bigger threat.
Sean Rameswaram
And is that just par for the course in Brazilian presidential politics? I mean, this is an election where, you know, for most of the election, you had one leading candidate campaigning from jail and another one, you know, ending up campaigning from a hospital bed.
Sarah Maslin
So, you know, it's pretty crazy. That said, I have to say Brazilians seem to kind of accept that. And, you know, they remind me that last time in the 2014 election, one of the leading candidates died in a helicopter crash.
Sean Rameswaram
Sarah Maslin writes about Brazil for The Economist. I'm Sean Rameswaram from This is Today Explained.
When you get your books at Audible, they're yours to keep. You can go back and re-listen anytime, even if you cancel your membership. And if you don't like your audiobook, you can exchange it, no questions asked. Plus, there's a 30-day trial, and your first audiobook is free when you go to audible.com slash todayexplained or text todayexplained to 500500.
It's a special day today. Is it? It's your birthday. Oh, man, you're right. I heard. It's also Mean Girls Day. That's true. And I'm wearing pink. You are. I'm not, but I don't own anything. On Wednesdays, we wear pink. I'm doing this thing with these Audible ads where every day I read a different summary of a book that you can find on Audible. Because your first book is free.
And I was thinking since it's your birthday today, you could read the summary of a book of your choice. Oh, yeah. I got one. Great, great, great. What is it? As Seattle is ravaged by a string of mysterious killings and a malicious vampire continues her quest for revenge, Bella once again finds herself surrounded by danger.
In the midst of it all, she is forced to choose between her love for Edward and her friendship with Jacob, knowing that her decision has the potential to ignite the ageless struggle between vampire and werewolf.
With her graduation quickly approaching, Bella has one more decision to make, life or death, but which is which? And you can find out when you go to audible.com slash todayexplained or text todayexplained to 500500.
Sarah, how old is democracy in Brazil?
Sarah Maslin
Brazil sort of had throughout the 20th century back and forth between democratic rule and military rule. But most recently, there was a dictatorship that started in the 1960s and lasted until the 1980s.
Brazil's military dictatorship committed crimes against humanity, So says the country's National Truth Commission. It says there's proof that more than 400 people were killed or disappeared between 1964 and 85, but the real figure is undoubtedly higher.
Sean Rameswaram
Democracy came back with the 1988 constitution, so it's pretty young. Yeah, and fragile it sounds like.
Sarah Maslin
Yeah, and I don't think anyone would have said that until very recently. The institutions in Brazil have proved themselves pretty successful. The biggest example of that being that the judiciary over the past few years has really gone after politicians and revealed these corruption scandals and attempted to hold people accountable for it.
Sean Rameswaram
Between the late 80s and now have there been glory days for Brazilian democracy?
Sarah Maslin
I think that if I were a correspondent here during you know during the time when Brazil was you know was leading up kind of world initiatives on climate change and on poverty and the economy was doing well, and business was flocking to Brazil, which is not so much of a distant memory, that was just sort of less than a decade ago, I would have said absolutely, democracy is thriving.
But, you know, but what we didn't really know was that that whole time, there was this sort of massive corruption happening just beneath the surface. And so, you know, it's hard to say.
Sean Rameswaram
I think it's not as simple as sort of it's either democratic or it isn't. But, you know, I think that the corruption scandal and now this kind of, you know, this specter of a candidate who has expressed support for something other than democracy and has really seen people sort of react positively to that shows that the democracy is young and that it still got a long way to go.
Sarah Maslin
So how did it get to this point where this far-right candidate can make appeals to a military dictatorship and, you know, lead the polls?
Sean Rameswaram
I think what you have to remember is that, you know, in Brazil, as sort of everywhere else, people vote on emotion and on fear. You know, if you ask Brazilians to sort of, you know, Whether they want to live under military dictatorship, I think all of them would absolutely say no.
Sarah Maslin
But if you ask how to get out of this crisis or what the solution is, they want change and they want something different. And the current round of politicians have proved themselves to be mostly interested in their own preservation, not in any sort of reform that would help Brazil become a more prosperous and a more equal and more fair country.
Sean Rameswaram
I think that most who will vote for Bolsonaro will do so because they think that he can solve this problem without resorting to some sort of a military solution.
Sarah Maslin
Absolutely. You saw this kind of real fear of Mr. Bolsonaro and what he might mean for Brazilian democracy this past weekend when hundreds of thousands of Brazilians in, you know, in cities throughout the whole country took to the streets.
Sean Rameswaram
People shouted, Bolsonaro, you can cry. Women will take you down. Waving banners with the hashtag Eli now, which means not him, and slogans about, you know, accusing him of being a fascist or an extremist.
Sarah Maslin
They chanted, Bolsonaro, you fascist, women will put you in line. Or sort of a torture because of his associations with the dictatorship.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a fear that his kind of flirtations with past moments of undemocratic rule would make him more likely in the case of a kind of chaotic situation or when crime and the economy aren't shaping up to take some sort of a dramatic action.
Sarah Maslin
And Brazilians are certainly scared of that as well. And that's sort of the source of this huge outcry and social movement against his candidacy.
Sean Rameswaram
I do have to say, though, that there's fear of Haddad as well. Some people believe, especially people who are more kind of economically conservative, they believe that Haddad would be a real risk of, you know, they compare him to Venezuela.
Sarah Maslin
They say kind of Brazil could become a socialist country. And I think a lot of Brazilians are trying to decide not necessarily which one of these two they kind of feel the most represented by, but rather which one is, in their opinion, sort of a bigger danger or a bigger threat.
Sean Rameswaram
And is that just par for the course in Brazilian presidential politics? I mean, this is an election where, you know, for most of the election, you had one leading candidate campaigning from jail and another one, you know, ending up campaigning from a hospital bed.
Sarah Maslin
So, you know, it's pretty crazy. That said, I have to say Brazilians seem to kind of accept that. And, you know, they remind me that last time in the 2014 election, one of the leading candidates died in a helicopter crash.
Sean Rameswaram
Sarah Maslin writes about Brazil for The Economist. I'm Sean Rameswaram from This is Today Explained.
When you get your books at Audible, they're yours to keep. You can go back and re-listen anytime, even if you cancel your membership. And if you don't like your audiobook, you can exchange it, no questions asked. Plus, there's a 30-day trial, and your first audiobook is free when you go to audible.com slash todayexplained or text todayexplained to 500500.