Main Topic: The podcast episode "Absolute Truth" from "Today Explained" explores the role of mitigation specialists in the US criminal justice system, specifically in death penalty cases. The episode delves into the story of James Bernard Belcher, a death row inmate who was given a new sentencing hearing after a Supreme Court decision deemed Florida's death penalty system unconstitutional.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Overall, the episode provides a nuanced and thought-provoking exploration of the US criminal justice system and the role of mitigation specialists in death penalty cases.
Theme music fades out
Noelle King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King with a quick note. Today's show is about a death row inmate, and there are some descriptions of violence throughout it, so take heed, please.
Pause
In the criminal justice system, a death sentence is not always final. There's a little-known job called mitigation specialist, and this is a person hired to look into the past of a death row inmate and see if there's some trauma that might convince a jury to be lenient, something in childhood maybe.
Pause
I mean, she found a beat cop, like an older Italian guy who described the constant violence and the way he would sort of pity the kids who were growing up there.
Pause
In Florida, a woman was assigned to dig into the past of such an inmate. He said, my cousin, he's a model tragedy in Black American life. This is what those neighborhoods did to people. This is what Rikers and sending people to prison too young does to them. And it's a tragedy.
Pause
Ahead her story, could what she found in this guilty man's past get him off of death row? Absolute truth.
Pause
As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp.
Pause
The one is not me, guys. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com. That's BetterHelp.com.
Pause
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit Sierra.ai to learn more.
Pause
It's Today Explained. Maurice Shema, reporter with The Marshall Project. Tell me about James Bernard Belcher.
Maurice Shema
James Bernard Belcher committed a atrocious murder in 1996 where he got into the apartment of a young woman named Jennifer Embry in Jacksonville, Florida, and she was then found the next day raped and drowned and strangled.
Pause
And at the time, there was no DNA to match anyone. But over time, they found DNA on some of the evidence that eventually matched James Bernard Belcher, who at this point was already in prison for a different crime.
Pause
So the prosecutors say, look, this guy has gone after women in the past. He's committed sexual crimes. He's robbed women on the street. And the jury says, yeah, this is a dangerous guy. And they sentence him to death.
Pause
The jury is actually out for only 16 minutes at his original trial before he's sent to death row. But then about 15 years pass and a Supreme Court decision comes down.
Pause
The high court ruled the entire system Florida's criminal courts use to sentence convicts to death is unconstitutional because it gives judges too much power in the decision as opposed to the jury.
Pause
Dozens and dozens of people on death around Florida are entitled to new sentencing hearings. So as of 2016, it becomes clear that Belcher is going to get a new sentencing hearing and have a new jury consider whether he's going to get the death penalty or instead get a life sentence in prison.
Pause
Okay, so he is guilty for sure. The new hearing is about what should his punishment be, life in prison or death.
Pause
How did you become aware of this guy?
I've been reporting on the death penalty for more than 10 years. And throughout that time, I had met a handful of members of this kind of secretive profession called mitigation specialists.
Pause
They are investigators who research the life stories of people who face the death penalty and then bring that information into court and use it to try to convince juries and prosecutors to choose less severe punishments.
Pause
So life in prison as opposed to the death penalty, or maybe the possibility of parole as opposed to life without parole.
Pause
And throughout conversations with these mitigation specialists, I kept coming back to this one named Sarah Baldwin, who's based in Jacksonville, Florida.
Pause
She's very open in terms of her process. And we had these conversations about her work.
Pause
And eventually I pitched her on the idea of following her along as she investigated a case to really see, you know, in the weeds, What does it look like when you investigate someone's life like this and then bring that information to a jury?
Pause
Sarah said, you know, provisionally, OK, but there were a lot of kind of ethical concerns about, you know, watching the defense basically be prepared in a case, you know, with this high stakes life and death litigation.
Pause
But over time, we had conversations with his lawyers and then I was, you know, exchanging snail mail letters with Belcher himself.
Pause
And he eventually agreed to go through this process and to let me watch Sarah at work.
Pause
I'm a pretty informed person. I read a lot of news. I cover a lot of news. I had never heard the term mitigation specialist until I read your piece.
Pause
Is this a job that is known among the court system and criminal justice reporters?
It's really just known within certain circles of the criminal justice system, especially related to the death penalty because these mitigation specialists are now a mainstay.
Pause
in capital cases. So you're going to see them more in states that have the death penalty, like Texas and Florida.
Pause
But they're increasingly well-known in kind of public defender circles.
Pause
So now if you go to, you know, the Bronx Defenders or the Brooklyn Defenders Service, you're going to have social workers on staff who are doing work sort of like mitigation specialists.
Pause
Then they go to mitigation specialist trainings.
Pause
You're starting to see an awareness grow, but they remain obscure.
Pause
And I think part of that is because it was by design
Pause
And people who defended people who committed terrible crimes, defense lawyers, public offenders, even they weren't terribly open about their work because there was this perception that the public disliked them or thought that they were, you know, basically helping criminals get off.
Pause
And mitigation specialists are sort of a more extreme version of that, where they were really seen as like kind of too close to the bad guys, quote unquote.
Pause
And so, as a result, I think they were very, kind of, reasonably shy about public attention.
Pause
And only in the last few years with you know movies like Just Mercy
Pause
If we say we committed to equal justice under law to protecting the rights of every citizen regardless of wealth race or status then we have to end this nightmare for Walter McMillan and his family
Pause
And kind of an awareness that criminal defense lawyers are in a way a certain sort of human rights advocate.
Pause
Have mitigation specialists, I think, kind of come out into the open and been a little bit more public about their work.
Pause
Who is doing the hiring? Is it the person on death row? Is it the person on death row's lawyer?
It's the person on death row's lawyer.
Pause
Now, sometimes mitigation specialists are full-time employees of a public defender office, and sometimes they're kind of freelance investigators who get hired by defense teams.
Pause
Okay, and so once a mitigation specialist is assigned, there's somebody in the county who does this job, we're going to put them on the case.
Pause
What do they do precisely?
They dig deeply into the life story of the person facing the punishment.
Pause
When you look at a crime and somebody says, how could a person do that? There's always an answer to that question.
Pause
And it's not because the person had a nice family and a nice life and just decided that they wanted to be a murderer.
Pause
There's always a reason that they became the way that they are.
Pause
What that looks like practically is going to every hospital, jail, court, you know, any kind of public record that relates to this person.
Pause
They're going to try to get it, you know, and this is going to lead to often thousands and thousands of pages.
Pause
And it was all a way of just kind of understanding, you know, what brought this person to this particular place and time.
Pause
And so the mitigation specialist, you know, they start interviewing this person, learning about the course of their life, going to the different counties and states where these records exist and getting those records.
Pause
As soon as I get the case, I meet the client and start trying to get a history and figure out what the issues are.
Pause
You have trauma, mental illness, intellectual disability, poverty.
Pause
I mean, those are all issues that are common themes in our cases, but we have to get to know our clients and decide exactly what the issues are going to be and what experts we're going to need to bring in.
Pause
Then they start doing interviews with everyone around the person.
Pause
So that can be their parents, it can be their grandparents, cousins, anyone who grew up with them.
Pause
I once heard a mitigation specialist tell me that she found an old yearbook from this person's elementary school and just started looking for other kids who had been in their elementary school class.
Pause
That seemed like a really above and beyond task to me.
Pause
But one way of describing it that I found striking was that, you know, what if your client was sexually violated as a child?
Pause
And this was a really key moment in their life that the jury should hear about because it helps understand their path to their crime.
Pause
While that sexual violation, maybe they're too ashamed to admit it.
Pause
Maybe their parents have reasons not to admit it.
Pause
And so it's only the estranged third cousin that you happen to get to on your fifth meeting with them, they say, well, you know what? I heard this thing happened when I was a kid.
Pause
And suddenly the door opens to a whole story that helps make sense of this person's path.
Pause
You only get there through just, you know, relentless shoe leather research and investigation.
Pause
Is there scientific research that ties trauma to violence later on? Like, is this grounded in science or grounded in feelings?
I'll say two things.
Pause
First of all, it is grounded in feelings because the defense attorneys would say it's not just explaining the crime and we often maybe can't explain the crime because the tools of science, the tools of sociology have not gotten us there yet, right?
Pause
So mitigation specialists are often researching any fact that can mitigate the crime and evoke mercy from the jury.
Pause
So that could be childhood trauma
Pause
It could be a brain injury or something very physical and scientific.
Pause
It could also be things that are just sort of moving, like the fact that once they got to prison, they were a mentor figure to younger prisoners, or that they were a really caring father in addition to the crime that they committed.
Pause
So anything that can evoke feelings.
Pause
So on the one hand, there's the feelings piece of it.
Pause
But what mitigation specialists practically are often doing is looking for how did trauma shape this person's path?
Pause
And there is nascent brain science that gets us there.
Pause
So we know that when somebody suffers severe trauma, especially as a child, it affects sort of their neural pathways.
Pause
And so the amygdala, the frontal lobe, the hippocampus, all the parts of the brain that affect impulse control and aggression and rage and your sort of response to fear, those can get shaped and kind of rewired through a traumatic childhood so that you are less good at impulse control.
Pause
And especially when you don't have, you know, therapy or deep brain stimulation or other kinds of interventions that can help, you see repeatedly that people kind of spiral towards riskier and deeper violence.
Pause
This woman, Sarah Baldwin, who you met, the mitigation specialist, how did she get into this line of work?
Pause
So Sarah Baldwin grew up in Florida, in Jacksonville.
Pause
She was, you know, married a few times, had kids.
Pause
She was a stay-at-home mom. She was a chef.
Pause
And then she went to social work school and fell in as an intern with criminal defense lawyers who were focused on the death penalty and specifically focused on, you know, the last minute saving people from execution.
Pause
So she was being sent out to Death Row to interview and talk to men about their pasts and use that information to then go to the governor or the public and say, we should really spare this person's life.
Pause
This was in the 1990s.
Pause
The profession had sort of developed in the 1970s and 80s and 90s.
Pause
So once Baldwin got into it, there were ways to get trained.
Pause
There were, you know, older mitigation specialists who were able to mentor her.
Pause
But then she just started taking cases and diving in and learning about the past of her clients.
Pause
How did she meet the criminal, James Belcher?
Pause
So around 2018, she had a full-time job at the public defender's office in Jacksonville, Florida.
Pause
And as I mentioned before, James Belcher was given a new sentencing hearing, and so she was assigned to his case.
Pause
She then left the office and became a freelancer, but kept on with his case.
Pause
And this led to more than a dozen meetings where she drove out to death row and interviewed him, and then slowly started interviewing his family members.
Pause
In early 2022, they set a trial date for Mr. Belcher in the fall.
Pause
And so it was really, you know, the spring and the summer that she got, you know, deeply enmeshed in the intensive work of examining his life.
Pause
Noelle King
Coming up Sarah Baldwin found a lot of trauma in his life but could it save James Belcher
Pause
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards.
Pause
These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program.
Pause
You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars.
Pause
But with your rent, frequently you just pay month after month.
Pause
You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head.
Pause
Not anymore, says Built Rewards.
Pause
Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent.
Pause
By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more.
Pause
Your home isn't just where you sleep.
Pause
It's your community and Built wants you to go out and do things in the community.
Pause
You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points.
Pause
You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios.
Pause
You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members every month.
Pause
When you're ready to travel, they say Built points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world.
Pause
You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining built.com slash explained.
Pause
That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash explained.
Pause
and soccer to culture, the climate, and more.
Pause
Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Pause
It's Today Explained.
Pause
We're back with the story of Sarah Baldwin.
Pause
She's a mitigation specialist who was given the assignment of looking into the history of a death row inmate named James Bernard Belcher.
Pause
Maurice Shema
Maurice Shema, reporter for The Marshall Project, What did Sarah Baldwin learn about her client?
Pause
So many mitigation specialists are already looking at early childhood to try to understand trauma.
Pause
And she learned from her client that his family had migrated from Jacksonville up to Brooklyn, New York, as part of the broader Great Migration of Black Americans in the 1950s and 60s.
Pause
And in New York, his mother divorced his father.
Pause
But Sarah learned that there was sort of violent conflict between the mother and father.
Pause
and it reached the point where the mother took a blade and she actually slashed the father's stomach all the way down the middle.
Pause
It sent him to the hospital for a week.
Pause
He almost died.
Pause
And the son was about 10 years old at the time.
Pause
The mother says that the father was regularly beating and choking her.
Pause
So you imagine a child who is just constantly around violence and situations of intimacy.
Pause
He is then neglected by his mother and stepfather.
Pause
And in order to have enough money to buy shoes and clothes in, you know, the public housing projects that he's living in as a teenager.
Pause
He starts to rob the coat pockets and purses of his teachers at school, you know, hanging on the rack.
Pause
And then he pretends to have a gun and, you know, mugs women on the street.
Pause
And I think this was a key discovery for Sarah Baldwin, that when he was 16 years old, he was sent to Rikers Island, you know, the notoriously violent jail in New York City.
Pause
and he was surrounded by violence there.
Pause
He described sexual assaults just constantly, that he had friends who were being sexually assaulted every day.
Pause
He never said that he was sexually assaulted, but he gets out of Rikers and New York prisons and then gets essentially no help from the state in the form of any sort of re-entry services or counseling.
Pause
Did Larry suggest that you get Bernard mental health counseling?
Pause
Yes.
Pause
And did Sister Priscilla also recommend that?
Pause
Yes.
Pause
Did you accept their recommendation?
Pause
No, I didn't.
Pause
Okay, so he has laid out a very dark and difficult childhood for Sarah Baldwin.
Pause
And then I guess it's on her to track some of these people down.
Pause
Who does she end up talking to?
Pause
All sorts of people.
Pause
Can you please introduce yourself to the jury?
Pause
My name is Wayne Lorenzo Gies.
Pause
He's Belcher's first cousin and is really this almost poignant example of who Belcher might have become if he had a very different set of circumstances and influences.
Pause
Deese had become a Wall Street banker.
Pause
He had had a bit of a career in journalism and written for The New York Times and just a very successful person.
Pause
He said that, you know, his cousin Bernard was very much like him as a child, very much a kind of protector, mentor figure.
Pause
He was viewed by me as my older brother, my beloved older brother.
Pause
He was a leader, a role model.
Pause
He taught me. He basically was my protector on many occasions.
Pause
He helped guide me.
Pause
Wayne, the cousin, got bused to a white school and then his parents put him in private school, whereas Belcher, you know, was sent to the worst schools in New York City.
Pause
The schools are horrible.
Pause
The conditions are horrible.
Pause
the attention span that the teachers give you knew to have best.
Pause
And that ends up at Rikers Island where he's not really getting schooling at all.
Pause
So she talks, of course, for hours and hours to both of the parents.
Pause
She finds many other cousins and uncles who can describe the sort of environment, the violence between the parents and the sorts of, you know, environmental violence that he was experiencing as a young child, even things that Belcher himself did not remember.
Pause
So she used all these different sources to kind of connect the dots and tell a story about his life.
Pause
And all of those dots and that story lead her to conclude what exactly?
Pause
She concludes that trauma really infected Mr. Belcher's brain at a young age and set him on a path that maybe he could have come back from, but that at every moment that he could have come back from it, there was sort of no help for him.
Pause
So his mother seemed to be checked out for many years.
Pause
He did get to go to college for some months after jail, but it didn't work out for him.
Pause
His family kind of left him behind overall.
Pause
All the cousins and aunts and uncles who had helped him once he kept stealing and committing crimes basically you know left him
Pause
We can all I think imagine the kind of wayward cousin family member that we just sort of sick of and move on from and leave on their own
Pause
And he fell further and further until he committed this crime.
Pause
And so she ultimately couldn't explain this is why he killed Jennifer Embry.
Pause
But she did kind of unearth enough of the story of his early life.
Pause
I think that you can see, like, this isn't somebody who just woke up one day with a psychopathic tendency to want to murder people.
Pause
This was somebody whose psychology, whose brain was deeply affected and broken in certain key ways, even if we can't, we don't have the scientific language to describe all of them yet, that set him on this path towards violence.
Pause
Noelle King
All right. So our mitigation specialist has done her job.
Pause
She's found a lot of stuff about this man's early life.
Pause
And then comes the sentencing.
Pause
And the stakes here are that Mr. Belcher is either going to be sentenced to death or he's going to be sentenced to life in prison.
Pause
Maurice Shema
It was one of the most profound reporting experiences I have ever had.
Pause
I spent two weeks in Jacksonville, Florida, every day from roughly nine to five, going into this courtroom and just watching this trial play out.
Pause
The first couple of days, I was watching jury selections, and you saw a real reckoning.
Pause
You saw people cry and say, I don't think I could ever, you know, I support the death penalty in theory, but I don't think I could look someone in the face and give them the death penalty.
Pause
And then you had other people who said, sure, I can give them the death penalty.
Pause
And I'll tell you right now, I don't think their childhood matters at all.
Pause
And, uh, we then witnessed, I think about five to six full days of testimony.
Pause
And you had the prosecution really try to tell a story of, you know, here's a man who has relentlessly caused pain to women.
Pause
So there were stories of him robbing women on the street as a child, and they couldn't necessarily find those women to testify, but they did find a woman who he had manipulated into giving her home address.
Pause
He then snuck into her apartment and it was a horrific sexual violation.
Pause
And the whole courtroom was, you know, you could hear a pin drop.
Pause
The jurors were just staring at this woman in horror, looking over at this elderly Black man, thinking, you know, how, like, how did this happen, right?
Pause
And the prosecution really spun that forward to say, well, this woman survived, but Jennifer Embry, the victim in this murder, did not survive that same violation, that same crime.
Pause
We also heard testimony from the family members of Jennifer Embry.
Pause
Walking into her apartment and finding her in the bathtub, deceased, is an image that I would never get out of my head.
Pause
During that moment, I felt more pain than I have ever felt in my life.
Pause
It has been 26 years, yet it feels like it was just yesterday.
Pause
You really felt for them and you really got the sense that the process offers the victim family very little beyond you know the promise of a harsher punishment like the death penalty being a kind of service to them and then you know if if they don't get it it being a kind of you know further harm to them
Pause
So they were in the courtroom the whole time watching as it transitioned from the prosecution's case to the defense's case.
Pause
A series of witnesses from Veltcher's life went up on the stand and described the horrible circumstances of his childhood.
Pause
And then you had experts on Riker's Island and on incarceration get up and talk about the effects of trauma.
Pause
You had psychologists.
Pause
And then you saw these family members really break down about the fact that they kind of abandoned this kid, right?
Pause
He needed help and they had abandoned him and they felt horrible.
Pause
I mean, his mother said, you know, everyone thought he needed therapy, but I just thought that was for crazy people.
Pause
First of all, I didn't think that, you know, that my child was crazy.
Pause
That's what I was dumb enough to think.
Pause
She's a woman in her 80s who's really now reflected back on her decisions.
Pause
So it was really, really intense.
Pause
You know, jurors were crying.
Pause
I really feel for these jurors.
Pause
like I said, these average Jacksonville people who just got swept into this story of trauma and reckoning.
Pause
The closing arguments were very dramatic.
Pause
And the defense lawyer said, look, this guy did a terrible thing.
Pause
This defense lawyer kind of reminded me of Mr. Rogers because he was saying to the jury, like, you have permission to feel the feelings that you're having, right?
Pause
We're not trying to tell you don't feel anger and rage and sadness at this crime.
Pause
We're just saying let Belcher live the rest of his life in prison as opposed to execute him, which would then create more pain for his mother, for everyone around him.
Pause
And it was very poignant.
Pause
A jury hears all of this testimony and what do they decide?
Pause
So they come into the courtroom slowly.
Pause
It felt like it took forever.
Pause
I'm sitting next to Sarah Baldwin as she's clutching Belcher's mother's hands, you know, super tightly and they're praying together.
Pause
I have never witnessed an execution, but this felt like the closest I'd ever come because it felt like this pin drop moment where the jury is going to make a decision of life or death.
Pause
But finally, they say, at least one juror finds that the mitigating factors outweigh the aggravating factors, which means that the jury has come out in favor of the mitigation, which means in favor of life.
Pause
And so he's not going to get the death penalty.
Pause
At that moment, there's this wave of relief in the courtroom.
Pause
You're hearing Earlene, the mother, say, thank you, Jesus. Thank you, Jesus. Thank you, Jesus.
Pause
And Sarah Baldwin, the investigator, leans over to her and says, you're free, Earlene, you're free.
Pause
You know, your son is not going to face execution anymore.
Pause
And then that was it.
Pause
And everyone went home and Sarah Baldwin moved on to her next case.
Pause
And all these players, you know, some of them keep in touch with each other.
Pause
But, you know, for the professionals, the mitigation specialists and the lawyers, it was like, OK, that was that case.
Pause
Now on to the next one.
Pause
Noelle King
Maurice Chema with the Marshall Project.
Pause
Today's episode was produced by Hadi Mawajdeh and edited by Jolie Myers.
Pause
It was fact-checked by Laura Bullard and Matthew Collette and engineered by Patrick Boyd and Paul Robert Mounsey.
Pause
I'm Noelle King.
Pause
It's Today Explained.
Pause
Thank you.