Main Topic: The World Health Organization's (WHO) efforts to promote breastfeeding and the United States' attempts to undermine these efforts.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Hey, hey, hey. Amazing. It's like you expect me to call you to tell you that Uber is adding a bunch of new features that are designed to take the stress out of your pickup and that you can find out all of the ways Uber is moving forward and see the improvements they're making to their app at uber.com slash moving forward.
Sound effects: Uber ad music plays
Yeah, it's almost as if we've done this before. I'm no scientist, but I can guarantee you none of us would be here if it weren't for breastfeeding. Like, even if you weren't personally breastfed, all of your ancestors were.
Julia Belluz
Let's just get this out of the way. Breast milk is good. Yeah, this is like the gold standard for babies. And there's massive consensus on this among medical organizations and the scientific community. And only in the last hundred years have we seen this massive evolutionary shift to most babies being fed baby formula instead.
Sean Rameswaram
This evolutionary shift to baby formula strangely became a thing the entire world was talking about for a second this week. And it all goes back to a meeting in Geneva. It happened this past May. A new report says U.S. delegates to the World Health Organization pushed to scrap a resolution meant to encourage breastfeeding in underdeveloped countries.
Julia Belluz
Julia Beluz writes about health for Vox, and she's going to take us there. So where this all starts, every year the World Health Organization, which is the UN's global health agency, ministers, heads of state, civil society, they all gather in May for this meeting called the World Health Assembly. And it takes place in this beautiful setting on a lake in Geneva.
Sean Rameswaram
There are peacocks roaming around the grounds of the European headquarters, which kind of looks like an old European palace. And over the course of several days, delegates from the WHO's 194 member countries bring forward resolutions about global health.
Julia Belluz
So we're basically talking about a forum of the WHO where all the countries of the world come together to set global health policy. And that means they're talking about everything from pandemic preparedness to antimicrobial resistance, maternal and child health.
Sean Rameswaram
Together, we can create a world in which all people can lead healthy and productive lives, regardless of who they are or where they live. And in that context, this year, what seemed like a pretty innocuous resolution about breastfeeding came forward, and it was supposed to be put out by Ecuador's delegates.
Julia Belluz
And the resolution just called on countries to protect and promote breastfeeding. It asked policymakers to restrict misleading marketing of baby formula, which is something we know has undermined breastfeeding and often caused moms to switch to formula when they don't need it.
Sean Rameswaram
And it let countries know that the WHO had put out new documents about breastfeeding in emergencies and hospitals, so it was pretty non-controversial, and health advocates who were at the meeting told me they thought it would pass with no issue.
Julia Belluz
But before Ecuador could put the resolution forward, Trump officials started meddling. So Andrew Jacobs at the New York Times broke a story this weekend about how the Trump administration sought to water down the language in the resolution.
Sean Rameswaram
And when they didn't get their way, they started to bully other countries, threatening Ecuador with trade sanctions and withdrawing aid. And this caused Ecuador to back off.
Julia Belluz
And it kind of put health advocates who work on maternal and child health in this scramble to try to find another country who would put this resolution forward. And no one wanted to piss off the U.S. basically.
Sean Rameswaram
One person who was at the meetings told me that in the negotiating rooms it was really America against the rest of the world and countries like Bangladesh and other low- and middle-income countries were speaking out against the bullying tactics the U.S. delegation was reportedly using.
Julia Belluz
And European countries that often align themselves with the U.S. around issues of infant feeding, they were also turned off by America's behavior. And then in this weird geopolitical twist, Russia took on breastfeeding, so they ended up bringing the resolution forward.
Sean Rameswaram
The U.S. pushed back with a counter-resolution, and that failed, but only after two days of debate. And so the Russian resolution ended up passing with most of the original pro-breastfeeding language intact.
Julia Belluz
This happened back in May, right? Yes. Why are we just finding out about it now?
Sean Rameswaram
I think many of us miss this, basically, because I noticed that there were people who were at this meeting, including breastfeeding advocates and maternal and child health advocates, who were tweeting about what was going on.
Julia Belluz
And the World Health Assembly doesn't always maybe get as much coverage as it deserves. And I think many of us, quite frankly, miss the story.
Sean Rameswaram
So has the United States acknowledged this since?
Julia Belluz
So, yeah. So the story broke on Sunday and Trump responded to it on Monday through his favorite medium, Twitter, and he called it fake news.
Sean Rameswaram
And he said he not anti but he wants moms to be able to choose an access baby formula if they need it
Julia Belluz
And that kind of been the line out of HHS and the administration that they not anti but they believe that women should have the right to access and choose baby formula if they want or need it.
Sean Rameswaram
A spokesperson for HHS Health Human Services basically denied that any threats regarding trade were made.
Julia Belluz
And yeah, they're kind of out there denying the story. Who's to be believed? That's the question.
Sean Rameswaram
I think I'd side with fake news on this one. I'd side with fake news, New York Times, and other people who I've since spoken to who were at the meeting and said, this is not only characteristic of how this administration was acting at the World Health Assembly, but in other meetings on breastfeeding.
Julia Belluz
It seems like common sense and an obvious question, but what are the health benefits of breast milk?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, so breast milk is basically this perfectly calibrated food for the baby. It's rich in vitamins and minerals. It has antibodies that boost a baby's immune system and get it working.
Julia Belluz
The strongest evidence is that breastfeeding helps protect against a range of illnesses. So ear, throat, and sinus infections, pneumonia and diarrhea, which are really common killers of infants worldwide.
Sean Rameswaram
It's a little bit more controversial, but there's quite strong evidence linking babies who are breastfed to a higher IQ later.
Julia Belluz
Wow. Lower rates of chronic disease like obesity and diabetes. And yeah, the best estimate on, you know, how many lives would be saved if breastfeeding were near universal comes from the Lancet.
Sean Rameswaram
And they suggest it's about 820,000 lives. So we're talking about something that's essentially inoculating babies against death and disease.
Julia Belluz
Now, lest we be sounding to team breast milk here, where's formula come from? What's the story of formula? How does it enter the scene?
Sean Rameswaram
So formula starts to emerge in the late 1800s, and from a medical standpoint, it's viewed as something that can be used when babies can't get breast milk, or a woman can't breastfeed or chooses not to, or they have an infection that might be transmitted to their baby through breast milk.
Julia Belluz
In that case, then formula is a good option. And part of the rise in popularity for formula comes from aggressive marketing on the part of industry, but it also syncs up with women entering the labor force.
Sean Rameswaram
In just a minute, the time the aggressive marketing of formula killed millions of babies. This is Today Explained.
Julia Belluz
in 1978 a united states senate investigation under senator edward kennedy's chairmanship was called to look into the marketing practices of the baby mug industry nestle was one of the key witnesses
Sound effects: Senate investigation clip plays
would you agree with me that your product should not be used where there is impure water yes or no uh we give all the instructions just just answer
Sound effects: Nestle representative clip plays
What would you, what is your position?
Sound effects: Nestle representative clip plays
Of course not, but we cannot cope with that.
Sean Rameswaram
May I make a reference to... You can't have that responsibility? No, no.
Julia Belluz
In the 70s, it came to light that baby formula makers were sending out sales representatives dressed as nurses in sub-Saharan Africa, and they were pushing formula.
Sean Rameswaram
They were suggesting not only that it was equivalent to breast milk, but that it might even be better for babies. And women in these places don't have access to fantastic clean water and great sanitation systems, so they were mixing the baby formula with contaminated water.
Julia Belluz
And it's believed that millions of babies died as a result from drinking these formulas instead of their mother's milk.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's why, you know, we still talk about these things at meetings like the World Health Assembly. It's to prevent these types of tragedies from happening again.
Julia Belluz
Do we have any idea how much of the world is breastfeeding versus using formula?
Sean Rameswaram
Globally, 40% of babies are exclusively breastfed for the first six months of life. So that means 60% are getting something else or they're, you know, having formula and breast milk or in some countries they're using tea or porridge or other things to supplement breast milk.
Julia Belluz
So it's pretty wild, again, to think about that massive evolutionary shift from all babies getting milk from women to babies getting milk from powder and bottles and other things.
Sean Rameswaram
What makes a happy mom? A happy baby. And a happy feeding. So, if introducing infant formula, start happy and see why no other formula is like good start probiotic.
Julia Belluz
And surely some of this must be happening because formula companies have pushed their product really hard on people, right?
Sean Rameswaram
That's absolutely true. So there's definitely sociological changes like people having higher incomes, women entering the workforce, urbanization.
Julia Belluz
But there's this very aggressive marketing on the part of industry to push this idea that there's an equivalence between breast milk and formula.
Sean Rameswaram
So they created this idea which absolutely isn't true, and we're only learning about all the ways breast milk is far superior to formula.
Julia Belluz
I wonder how this sort of becomes a more political issue. How is the United States going before this international body in 2018 and advocating formula against breastfeeding.
Sean Rameswaram
Health advocates and other officials who have been in on some of these negotiations say this is really about basically big baby formula and the dairy industry shaping maternal and infant health policies.
Julia Belluz
That's the thing, big formula. Big baby formula is a huge industry, yeah. It's projected to be valued at $70 billion by next year.
Sean Rameswaram
And the number one product in baby formula is dairy. And so countries that have these big formula companies that have big dairy industries tend to be on side with policies that are more supportive of baby formula.
Julia Belluz
And which of those countries? It's not just the United States? It's not just the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
So European countries tend to be in line with the U.S. So France, Switzerland, the Netherlands, they're home to some of the world's biggest formula makers.
Julia Belluz
And which of the companies we're talking about? Are they familiar names?
Sean Rameswaram
Absolutely. So we're talking about Nestle in Switzerland, Denon in France. There's Friesland Campina, which is a Dutch company.
Julia Belluz
Mead Johnson, a U.S. company that's now U.K. owned. And then there are these two big U.S. giants, Abbott Laboratories and Heinz.
Sean Rameswaram
So these six companies have half the world's share of the baby formula market. And yeah, this is a really big business.
Julia Belluz
One of these companies, Abbott Labs, which makes formulas, spent nearly $800,000 in lobbying just this year alone.
Sean Rameswaram
So thinking about these companies that have been around for a while, this United States approach to supporting big formula must go back before Donald Trump got into office.
Julia Belluz
Yeah, so there's a long history here, and it's definitely important to remember that it way predates the current president.
Sean Rameswaram
So in 1981, the World Health Assembly in Geneva, remember the Peacocks and the Lakes, when Reagan was president, the WHO launched the International Code of Marketing of Breast Milk Substitutes.
Julia Belluz
It's known as the code, and basically it talks about how companies shouldn't put bold health and nutrition claims on labels, that they shouldn't aggressively market their products, since, again, breastfeeding is seen as the gold standard, and so they shouldn't be pushing their products on women.
Sean Rameswaram
They shouldn be doing something that still happens in a lot of places today giving out free samples in maternity wards sending women home with advertising and formula kits
Julia Belluz
Many studies have shown that when women access those products they tend to stop breastfeeding exclusively sooner than women who don't have access to formula.
Sean Rameswaram
So countries have used this code to set laws and prevent formula companies from directly targeting moms and doctors.
Julia Belluz
And when the code passed in 1981, 118 countries voted to support it and the U.S. was the sole descending vote.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, the U.S. is one of the few countries that has none of these formula marketing laws to enforce the code, basically.
Julia Belluz
So big formulas basically getting pushback everywhere in the world except here in the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
Are they finding workarounds?
Julia Belluz
I think the next big thing that we're going to be hearing about, there's this fast-growing category of baby formula called follow-up formulas that are targeted at older babies, so babies six months and older.
Sean Rameswaram
Since their very first days, your baby starts to write their future. Inspired by 40 years of breast milk research, our experts created our range of optimal follow-on milks.
Julia Belluz
And essentially it's a category that was created by the baby formula industry to get around all the regulation that's been put in place for the infant formulas.
Sean Rameswaram
And they are pushing to have these products be seen as foods instead of breast milk substitutes, which means they wouldn't have to curtail their marketing practices.
Julia Belluz
And it's hard to tell the difference. They look almost identical to the infant products.
Sean Rameswaram
And so I think that's a very active debate, how we should treat these products, how we should regulate them.
Julia Belluz
It's something the U.S. is reportedly involved in. Again, I've been told that they're siding with Big Baby Formula on this one as well.
Sean Rameswaram
Is there a difference between how the United States advocates formula in these global forums and how the United States promotes formula or breastfeeding in the United States?
Julia Belluz
In the U.S., the FDA regulates our food, including InfimFormula, and they have some extra provisions and oversight in place since it's this vulnerable population that's getting the formula.
Sean Rameswaram
But I think it's important to acknowledge that the U.S. has better rates of breastfeeding than many other high-income countries.
Julia Belluz
So in most high-income countries, less than 20% of infants are breastfed at one year, and the U.S., the number is 27%, and it's been rising in recent years.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's in part because women are more aware of the benefits of breastfeeding over formula.
Julia Belluz
But it's also because we've put in place policies at the national level through Obamacare that have supported breastfeeding.
Sean Rameswaram
So lactation consultants and breast pumps are now essential health benefits. They're now covered by insurance companies.
Julia Belluz
Through Obamacare, workplaces also have to make safe places for women to breastfeed or pump at work.
Sean Rameswaram
So we are doing better nationally, although obviously this administration has been trying to tear away Obamacare.
Julia Belluz
So what happens with those provisions remains to be seen.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, and coupled with that, how does it look for the United States to roll into this World Health Organization meeting in Geneva in May and be advocating big formula and bullying countries like Ecuador into doing the same?
Julia Belluz
Yeah, it doesn't look very good for the U.S. It sends a pretty important signal that we're not moving in the direction we should be around breastfeeding and doing, you know, everything we can to save babies' lives and increase the number of women who feel they can breastfeed instead of relying on baby formula.
Sean Rameswaram
Places that give me hope are countries like Brazil. They have bans on formula marketing. They have paid maternity leave.
Julia Belluz
And they're seeing their breastfeeding rates go up. And so that suggests that, you know, when you have a policy environment that supports women and that focuses on this issue, you can have success.
Sean Rameswaram
Julia Blues reports on health for Vox. I'm Sean Ramos from This is Today Explained.
Julia Belluz
The show's executive producer is Irene Noguchi. Bridget McCarthy is our editor.
Sean Rameswaram
Noam Hassenfeld produces. Luke Vanderplug produces.
Julia Belluz
and Efim Shapiro engineers.
Sean Rameswaram
Catherine Wheeler and Bree Sealy are spending their summers with us and the Sunny Breakmaster Cylinder is making music for us.
Julia Belluz
Today Explained is produced in association with Stitcher and we are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Sean Rameswaram
Side note and pro tip, dog had an eye infection once. Put breast milk in the dog's eye, cleared up in an hour.
Julia Belluz
Some say it's not possible, I watched it with my own too. Milk of the Gods, just saying.
Sean Rameswaram
Thank you.
Julia Belluz
Thank you.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks for listening to Today Explained.
Julia Belluz
And if you want to support the show, you can go to vox.com/todayexplained and become a member.
Sean Rameswaram
We'll be back tomorrow with another episode of Today Explained.
Julia Belluz
And don't forget to follow us on Twitter @todayexplained.
Sean Rameswaram
And on Facebook @todayexplained.
Julia Belluz
Thanks for listening.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks for listening.
Julia Belluz
Bye.
Sean Rameswaram
Bye.
Sound effects: Today Explained theme music plays