Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the whistleblower complaint against President Trump and the challenges faced by whistleblowers in the United States.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Discussion continues with Sean talking to his mom
My mom just told me that you got a new KiwiCo crate, and other people can do the same if they go to kiwico.com slash explained, where they can learn more about KiwiCo's projects for kids of all ages and try them out for free.
Desmond
It's a trebuchet.
Sean Rameswaram
What's a trebuchet for the kids at home who don't know?
Desmond
It's like an ancient catapult type thing.
Sean Rameswaram
Oh my gosh, you got a catapult in the mail? I guess. They said it was very dangerous. Cool. So, like, what are the materials you're building this trebuchet out of? Like some wood, string, and foam.
Desmond
Great. And once it's built, what will you launch out of it?
Sean Rameswaram
A ping pong ball. Cool. Have you sought out any targets for your trebuchet and ping pong ball at this point?
Desmond
No, I do have some boxes I could knock over, though.
Sean Rameswaram
You think your parents are on board with you knocking over the boxes?
Desmond
Yeah, it's one of my boxes, so I'm sure they'll be fine.
Sean Rameswaram
You're very considerate, Desmond. Thanks.
Allison, you just wrote a book about whistleblowers. Is that for real?
Allison Stanger
That is for real, Sean. It's for real. Yeah. Imagine if the book about whistleblowing you've been working on forever published the day Nancy Pelosi announced she was opening up an impeachment inquiry into President Trump based on a whistleblower report. It's only because it was delayed by about two years. So the fact that I took so long to do it has has been a positive thing.
Sean Rameswaram
If that happened to you, you would be Professor Alison Stanger, author of Whistleblowers, Honesty in America from Washington to Trump.
Allison Stanger
I've actually been working on it for seven years, if you can believe that. It's sort of sad. It went through five full manuscript iterations, had to cut hundreds of pages. It was really kind of the book manuscript from hell. But am I allowed to say that on a podcast?
Sean Rameswaram
You could say fucking hell. I'm not going to do that.
Allison Stanger
Whistle blowing is really about as American as apple pie. We passed the world's first whistleblower protection law in 1778. And that is a response to a man by the name of Essek Hopkins.
Sean Rameswaram
Hopkins was the first commodore of the U.S. Navy. And he was removed from his post for torturing British prisoners of war.
Allison Stanger
There were 10 sailors on Hopkins' ship that filed the complaint. Two of the 10, there were two men by the name of Marvin and Shaw, had the misfortune of being Rhode Islanders, which meant Hopkins was a Rhode Islander. He could retaliate against them. So he had them immediately thrown in jail for libel.
Sean Rameswaram
But Congress intervened not only with the Whistler-Borough Protection Law, but they also paid Marvin and Shaw's legal fees. They legislated that all the records should be made available to the public.
Allison Stanger
Without those records being made public, we would have never known about this incident. So even in these early stages of the republic, Congress had a sense that we need to have some sort of safety measure for people to report abuses of power?
Sean Rameswaram
It's interesting to read the original language, which really conveys the sense that you have an obligation, if you're a public servant, to report wrongdoing whenever you see it.
Allison Stanger
I can even read you a passage from the law that conveys that. It's kind of in the stilted English of the time, but I think it's really easy. It says that it is the duty of all persons in the service of the United States, as well as all other inhabitants thereof, to give the earliest information to Congress or any other proper authority of any misconduct, frauds, or misdemeanors committed by any officers or persons in the service of these states.
Sean Rameswaram
So that's basically saying if you see it as an American, you're obligated to report it.
Allison Stanger
The obvious one is Daniel Ellsberg. Mr. Pentagon Papers. Yeah, Daniel Ellsberg revealed an administration that was lying to the American people about how the Vietnam War was going.
Sean Rameswaram
I can no longer cooperate in concealing this information from the American public. And obviously, when the American people are kept in the dark, democracy cannot function properly.
Allison Stanger
You have to keep some secrets for national security purposes. I don't mean to downplay the difficulty of navigating that potential tension. But obviously, if the American people can't see what their government is doing, self-government becomes impossible.
Sean Rameswaram
And that one, like Watergate, which came shortly thereafter, involves a whistleblower going to the press, which makes them different from the current situation.
Allison Stanger
The similarity between Watergate and the current situation is the implication of the attorney general. The attorney general of the United States is supposed to enforce impartial justice. And in both the Watergate situation and the current situation, the attorney general is really a partisan serving the president rather than the cause of the rule of law.
Sean Rameswaram
So that's one thing that's similar between the Watergate situation and impeachment and this current situation. but pales in comparison to the rhetoric and vitriol and the complete misunderstanding of the president's role as somehow serving the Trump brand rather than the U.S. Constitution.
Allison Stanger
I don't think you see that in the Watergate years. In fact, part of what went on in Watergate is things were kept secret and when they were exposed, they were so embarrassing and shameful that Nixon resigned.
Sean Rameswaram
What you have in the current situation is a president who shameless
Allison Stanger
The lawyer representing this whistleblower in this current situation is worried about the whistleblower safety
Sean Rameswaram
What the worst thing that ever happened to an American whistleblower that we know of?
Allison Stanger
There's all sorts of examples. Maybe the best one is Bunny Greenhouse. Her life wasn't destroyed because she's too strong a person, but she's someone who blew the whistle on waste fraud and abuse in Halliburton contracts under the Bush administration.
Sean Rameswaram
And she was a Department of Defense principal for reviewing contracting. She exposed what she thought was an immense conflict of interest. She was retaliated against. She lost her job. She was actually injured in her office because someone set up a booby trap to intimidate her.
Allison Stanger
What? What was the booby trap?
Sean Rameswaram
I feel like I got to ask. Some kind of tripwire in her office that she tripped over is how I understand it.
Allison Stanger
Oh, my God. Yeah, but I mean there's all sorts of other examples of this kind of retaliation.
Sean Rameswaram
Some of you don't even hear about because the standard pattern really in the intelligence community is for these complaints never to see the light of day.
Allison Stanger
In part simply because the intelligence community is based on secrecy. They have to keep secrets and legitimately so to keep our country safe. So the very idea of revealing secrets is anathema to that culture.
Sean Rameswaram
So the standard pattern you would see is that the complaint would get squelched rather than being turned over to Congress.
Allison Stanger
In this instance, by some miracle, it happened. Edward Snowden, for example, at the time everybody said he should have complained up through the official chain about what he saw at the NSA.
Sean Rameswaram
That's problematic because if he had complained to the NSA inspector general, we probably would have never known about his revelations because the man in charge of the NSA inspector general at the time of the Snowden leaks, his name is George Lard, and he was removed from his position in 2016 for, guess what, whistleblower retaliation.
Allison Stanger
Hmm. Getting back to this whistleblower. In the acting DNI's testimony last week, he called this current whistleblower situation unique and unprecedented over and over.
Sean Rameswaram
I am not familiar with any prior instances where a whistleblower complaint touched on such complicated and sensitive issues, including executive privilege.
Allison Stanger
I believe that this matter is unprecedented. How else is this totally unprecedented than what's come before it?
Sean Rameswaram
It's just unprecedented on every conceivable dimension. The whistleblower complaint indicates a cover-up of both a national security threat and a threat to democracy from within.
Allison Stanger
The national security threat is the shadow foreign policy that the White House was running with Ukraine using the president's personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, also the attorney general, William Barr, And now it seems even Secretary of State Pompeo was in on the phone call.
Sean Rameswaram
What's distinctive about that is that shadow foreign policy is in direct opposition to the official foreign policy of the United States as administered by the State Department and for which funds are appropriated by Congress.
Allison Stanger
That military aid had to be approved by Congress. So that's a national security threat. How can our allies and our enemies know what to expect from the United States when it speaks with two mouths, secretly and publicly?
Sean Rameswaram
Then there's the threat from the democracy from within, which is really straightforward. The president's celebration of the solicitation of foreign electoral interference. It's not hard to understand why that's not okay.
Allison Stanger
Obviously, Americans should elect our leaders, not foreigners. So the intelligence community whistleblower is rightfully reporting this, but it's just part of a pattern of behavior that the intelligence community has noticed since Trump's election.
Sean Rameswaram
James Comey's firing being another example of a member of the intelligence community blowing the whistle on Donald Trump, not through official channels, but by leaking his memos to the press.
Allison Stanger
Thinking about this current situation we're in, we have the president trying to out the whistleblower and tracing that back to the very first instance of whistleblowing you talked about, this Commodore jailing his whistleblowers.
Sean Rameswaram
It just feels a little like America wants to have it both ways. We're proud of our long history of whistleblower protections, but we also have a history of blasting these brave people who speak truth to power.
Allison Stanger
That's a great observation, Sean, because that is exactly the pattern that I write about in whistleblowers. I call it the paradox of whistleblowing in America.
Sean Rameswaram
On the one hand, Americans celebrate whistleblowers. We think they're heroes. On the other hand, when time marches on and media attention focuses elsewhere, they pay a price, as I've already mentioned.
Allison Stanger
So whistleblowing in America is not done lightly for these reasons. and it is really something once this current crisis is passed that we could do better in legislating protection, say in the national security realm.
Sean Rameswaram
There's all sorts of things we could do. We could also legislate interpretations of the Emoluments Clause so that it makes sense in the 21st century.
Allison Stanger
But this distinctively American idea sometimes there's a gap between the ideal and the reality.
Sean Rameswaram
Alison Stanger is the author of Whistleblowers and a professor of international politics and economics at Middlebury College in Vermont.
I'm Sean Ramos from This Is Today Explained from Washington, D.C. Thank you.
End of podcast