Main Topic: President Biden's upcoming trip to Saudi Arabia and its implications on the country's relationship with the kingdom, as well as the ongoing lawsuit by 9/11 families against Saudi Arabia.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noel King.
Jonathan Geyer
Hi, Noel.
Noel King
Jonathan Geyer is a senior foreign policy writer at Vox covering Joe Biden and the world. Jonathan, what's going on with this trip? Biden and his administration are just doing everything they can to lower oil prices.
Jonathan Geyer
Biden and his administration are just doing everything they can to lower oil prices. The turmoil of Russia's war on Ukraine has obviously contributed to prices. Saudi Arabia is kind of caught between in this geopolitics and surprisingly hasn't really overtly sided with the U.S., kind of playing both sides.
Noel King
So it's not totally clear what Joe Biden can get out of this visit. But I think everyone watching is going to interpret it as him trying to go there to lower oil prices. The problem is, if oil prices don't get that much lower in response to this trip, it's not going to look like a very successful use of presidential power.
Jonathan Geyer
Can you just lay out what Saudi Arabia can do with regard to oil prices? I mean, the United States produces a lot of oil itself. It produces a lot of natural gas. What exactly can Saudi Arabia do for the United States that the U.S. can't do for itself?
Noel King
The narrative that the U.S. has become energy independent has been a little bit overblown. I mean, prices are still determined by this international market. And what MBS and the Saudi government can do is increase production a couple million barrels a day. It's not a whole lot, but it might be enough with other factors and other efforts to help lower prices a little bit.
Jonathan Geyer
The bigger issue here, though, has to do with refineries. There's just not enough oil refineries right now due to a whole load of reasons. Building a refinery is a multibillion-dollar investment. It may take a decade. We haven't had a refinery built in the United States since the 1970s.
Noel King
Let's talk about how Joe Biden has talked about Saudi Arabia in the past. Looking at what Biden has said as vice president, as presidential candidate, you get the sense he's very conflicted about Saudi Arabia. He's very critical of them, called them a pariah on the campaign trail.
Jonathan Geyer
And I would make it very clear we were not going to, in fact, sell more weapons to them. We were going to, in fact, make them pay the price and make them, in fact, the pariah that they are. This was largely because Mohammed bin Salman, the crown prince, had ordered the assassination of a U.S. resident, Jamal Khashoggi, Washington Post columnist.
Music transitions to a new segment
Noel King
So earlier I said that most Americans are interested in Saudi Arabia for one reason, gas prices. But there is another group of Americans who are fixated on the kingdom. Brett Eagleson is one of them.
Brett Eagleson
I lost my father in 9-11 when I was 15 years old. He was just a great human being. He was a great leader, had an amazing sense of humor. I don't think I ever met anyone that didn't like him. And, you know, he died a hero that day.
Noel King
When news broke that 15 out of the 19 hijackers on 9-11 were Saudi, it didn't quite register in Brett's teenage mind. For the initial years after 9-11, you know, I was focused on doing everything that a normal kid should be doing. I was in high school, more concerned about putting one foot in front of the other and studying hard so I can get into a college and, you know, all the things that a teenage boy would be interested in, sports, friends, girls, family.
Brett Eagleson
So I sort of tried to block out as much as I could about 9-11 and just sort of try to keep with the family and keep distracted and just put my head down and finish high school.
Noel King
Brett grew up. It wasn't until then that I really started to look back on what did happen that day and what do we know and what does our government know. I think I always had questions about how 19 individuals with no knowledge of English, no money, no flood experience, how 19 of these people could have banded together and pulled off the most devastating and consequential attack in the U.S. history.
Brett Eagleson
How did that happen without any help from anyone? Two investigations were going on separately. The FBI was conducting a rather secretive investigation into the Saudi government's role. And the legal teams representing the 9-11 victims' families were also investigating.
Noel King
They planned to sue Saudi Arabia. But because they were civilians, they had to rely on what information was public. At the time, there were documents that were publicly available still. I mean, I'll even source right to the 9-11 Commission report where they say that they found significant evidence that Saudi Arabia was sponsoring this sort of radical form of Islam called Wahhabism all over the world.
Brett Eagleson
There were a lot of mentions of Saudi Arabia within the 9-11 Commission report. So they say all the evidence that they have, they say everything that they find, but they didn't go far enough and say that the institution of Saudi Arabia sponsored 9-11.
Noel King
The families reach a conclusion. The Saudi government was definitely involved. They've done their own research. Similarly, the FBI reaches a conclusion. The Saudi government was involved.
Brett Eagleson
And at that point, your recourse is to sue the government of Saudi Arabia. But U.S. law doesn't allow you to sue the government of Saudi Arabia because of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act.
Noel King
This is a law that says basically you can't sue most countries except if a country is on the state sponsors of terrorism list. and Saudi Arabia is not.
Brett Eagleson
So then the only thing you can do, I assume, is get that law changed. We had to pass a law called the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act.
Noel King
Congress has done something today that they have never done to you before. You vetoed a bill that would have allowed 9-11 families to sue Saudi Arabia. They today overrode your veto.
Brett Eagleson
Well, I think it was a mistake. And what that law did is it created a loophole in the existing law. What we're saying is that no matter where the attack is planned, whether it's planned from overseas or the plan here in the United States, that a lawsuit can be brought.
Noel King
It would allow you to bring a lawsuit against a country that is not on the state sponsors of terrorism list. But you have credible evidence that that foreign sovereign killed or harmed Americans on American soil.
Brett Eagleson
With the law now changed, the families filed suit in 2017 in federal court in the Southern District of New York. But Brett and the other 9-11 families knew that they'd need access to the FBI's investigation to win their lawsuit.
Noel King
We had seen redacted versions of FBI reports. We had former FBI agents give us sworn affidavits that we were able to use publicly. We had a whole host of stuff, but we didn't, at the time, we didn't think we had enough.
Brett Eagleson
They subpoenaed the U.S. government for those files, and they won. But it took years and three U presidential administrations.
Noel King
We reached out to then Biden during his campaign trail and we asked if he would help us and we presented our case to some of his officials Biden responded with a letter written to the 9-11 family members saying that if he were elected president, he would instruct his attorney general to bring us peace and bring us closure, and to the greatest extent possible, declassify once and for all, all the government's investigative files on 9-11.
Brett Eagleson
So he gave us that campaign promise, which we were elated to have, and we all became Biden fans overnight because of that. And the family sort of gave him the benefit of the doubt.
Noel King
We wanted to give him some time to get into office. He had a whole host of problems going on at that point. It wasn't until about August of that year that we found out that President Biden was going to be making an appearance at Ground Zero to honor and mark the 20th year anniversary of 9-11.
Brett Eagleson
We had this idea. First responders, survivors, and the families of 9-11 victims are telling the president of the United States to stay away from next month's 20-year memorial events unless he fulfills a promise.
Noel King
And we were not going to let another anniversary go by with politicians saying how much 9-11 means to them and how they grieve with us and how they should never forget and how important this day is knowing that behind closed doors, they're blocking justice to the families.
Brett Eagleson
They're not doing what the families want. They're demanding that President Biden declassify evidence that they believe may show a link of the terror attacks and the Saudi Arabian government.
Noel King
So that certainly got the attention of the White House and the attention of the president. And a few days before 9-11, the president issued an executive order saying that he was directing the DOJ and the FBI and the CIA to do a declassification review of all the documents that had been produced by these government agencies and entities.
Brett Eagleson
And that the goal was to declassify and give to the 9-11 families and give to the public, to the greatest extent possible, the most amount of documents that they were able to share with us.
Noel King
We got our first document on September 11th, and it was a document that said, I'll paraphrase it a little bit, but it was an FBI document. It's called the 2016 Operation Encore Review Report.
Brett Eagleson
It's an analytical level document. And for those that are not in the intel world, what that kind of means is that it's signed off by multiple layers and multiple levels.
Noel King
So when you have a document that's called a summary document or an update to an investigation, the FBI concludes that as true.
Brett Eagleson
Brett, you and the other families, what is the status of your lawsuit now? What are you suing for and when should our listeners expect to see this go to court?
Noel King
How will this work?
Brett Eagleson
We just concluded discovery. We finished up our expert depositions, our expert reports. We have presented that all to the judge.
Noel King
We suspect that the Saudis are going to try to wiggle their way again out of the lawsuit. But it would just be incredible after everything that we've produced and after all the FBI documents that we have, it would be incredible if a judge were allowed them to dismiss their case.
Brett Eagleson
So we suspect that in the next couple of months, we'll start having some pretrial motions and we think that we'll be in court early part of next year.
Noel King
What is one concrete thing that you want to come out of this so that 10 years down the line you can say, I am satisfied. This is what I wanted. It is enough.
Brett Eagleson
I want the record to be rewritten. When I think about my daughter, she's two years old and I have a son now that's three months old. When they learn about 9-11 in school, I want the Saudi role to be front and center.
Noel King
And I'll be satisfied when the story or the narrative is changed from the fact that 19 hijackers with no knowledge of how to fly a plane were directed by Osama bin Laden from a cave 5,000 miles away were able to pull off the most devastating attack in American history.
Brett Eagleson
I'll be satisfied when that's rewritten to say that the hijackers, the 19 hijackers, had support from a Saudi support network here in the United States, which is what allowed them to be successful.
Noel King
President Biden needs to remember his campaign promises made to us. And I understand that the president needs to go to Saudi Arabia. I don't think we're mad at that point, right? We know that he has to go there.
Brett Eagleson
These are all huge, huge issues. We have gas at $5 a gallon in some parts of this country. President Biden is the head of state. You know, he is supposed to go there. In fact, you know, I encourage him to go there.
Noel King
But at the same time, when you do go there, Mr. President, you need to think about the 9-11 families and you need to think about the evidence that your own FBI has produced to you per your executive order that says 21 years ago there were bad people within that government that led to 9-11.
Theme music fades in
Today's show was produced by John Ahrens and Victoria Chamberlain. It was edited by Matthew Collette. Fact-checking on this one was a group effort. Get well soon, Laura.
Theme music continues to play