Main Topic: The departure of John Bolton, the third National Security Advisor under President Donald Trump, and its implications for US foreign policy.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Support for this episode of Today Explained comes from KiwiCo. You may remember them as the people who send projects to kids of all ages to help spark creativity, tinkering, and learning about science and technology and engineering and art and math. You can try them up for free right now at KiwiCo.com slash explained.
Alex Ward
What happened to John Bolton, National Security Advisor for the White House? He's gone. Just like that. Adios, Bolton.
Sean Rameswaram
But this time, the controversy immediately landed on Fox News, where Bolton was like live texting over at, was it Fox and Friends? I'm not sure what the other shows are. It was to Brian Kilmeade.
Alex Ward
John Bolton just texted me. Oh. Just now, he's watching. Can you read it? Yeah, he said, let's be clear, I resigned. And I said, do you mind if I say that while you were talking? And he wrote, yes.
Sean Rameswaram
So John Bolton has just told me, texted me, just said I resigned. You basically have Trump saying, like, I asked for Bolton's resignation last night. The president also tweeting, quote, I disagreed strongly with many of his suggestions, as did others in the administration.
Alex Ward
You have Bolton saying, Ambassador Bolton tweeted this just moments ago. I offered to resign last night. And President Trump said, let's talk about it tomorrow. So there's that controversy. The end result is the same. John Bolton, the third national security advisor for Donald Trump, is no longer the third national security advisor for Donald Trump.
Sean Rameswaram
Do we have any idea why President Trump and his national security advisor have now parted ways? These two guys don't really agree on anything.
Alex Ward
Trump is not a dove in any way. But the one thing he does not want to do and he seems completely allergic to is being a president who starts a new war. Whether it be with Iran, with Syria, with Venezuela, whoever it may be, he will threaten it. Right. We've heard him say it constantly, but he always just seems when the moment comes to push back from that.
Sean Rameswaram
John Bolton hasn't found a conflict. He doesn't want to start a war. Like he's written openly even before he joined the administration about bombing North Korea, Iran.
Alex Ward
And so while they both, I would say, have hawkish tendencies, they both like speaking tough and using American power abroad. They seem to have a pretty big separation when it comes to go to war or not.
Sean Rameswaram
He has strong views on things, but that's OK. I actually tempered John, which is pretty amazing, isn't it?
Alex Ward
OK, so that's been their relationship since the jump. But this is coming, what, just a few days after this totally bungled Camp David summit where President Trump was supposed to host the leaders of Afghanistan and the Taliban.
Sean Rameswaram
Does that have something to do with this, too?
Alex Ward
It definitely could. Bolton had been sidelined from major meetings leading up to that planned summit that never really materialized. Because he didn't want to do it? Because Bolton doesn't want to make a deal with the Taliban.
Sean Rameswaram
In fact, one of the secrets we kind of heard over time was that it was a purposeful decision to keep Bolton out of that process. It basically so wouldn't leak.
Alex Ward
Like you could imagine Bolton is a D.C. insider through and through. He knows how to play this game. And so there was a concern that if this had leaked to Bolton, that there was going to be a Taliban-Afghan-U.S. meeting at Camp David, that that definitely would have leaked to the press and that may have scuttled it.
Sean Rameswaram
So the fact that it didn't, right, we kind of heard about it through Trump's tweet, it showed that the National Security Advisor, the president's main aid when it comes to dealing with national security and foreign policy affairs, was left out of a massive national security and foreign policy issue.
Alex Ward
If this was a bad match from day one, why did these two people elect to work with each other?
Sean Rameswaram
I think from Trump's end, it was that John Bolton is a respected GOP national security figure. He's been around forever. He's basically served in every Republican administration going back to Reagan, if I recall.
Alex Ward
And on top of that, he spoke tough on Fox News and Trump liked that about him.
Sean Rameswaram
The Obama era for American foreign policy is clearly over.
Alex Ward
I thought the strike ordered by the president was very measured, very precise.
Sean Rameswaram
He would defend some of Trump's policies, some of his more hawkish tendencies. And so you had someone who, at least on the hawkish end, matched with Trump minus that war part.
Alex Ward
Yeah. On Bolton end that job was by far the highest he would ever get to government. I mean for those that don't know the National Security Advisor position is an insanely important and powerful position. I mean it is equivalent in a sense to Secretary of State and Secretary of Defense.
Sean Rameswaram
Not necessarily saying that they are equivalent, right? National Security Advisor is not Senate confirmed.
Alex Ward
But the point is that like, this is the person who runs the day-to-day foreign policy for the president, main advisor in the presidency or every day, coordinates National Security Policy across the sprawling government.
Sean Rameswaram
And I think he knew that he and Trump matched temperamentally, I think. They did not match in terms of going the full extent on some issues.
Alex Ward
So despite being at loggerheads with the president the entire time, was he able to get anything done?
Sean Rameswaram
Oh, yeah. I mean, despite, you know, having trouble pushing on some of the big ticket items that he wanted to work on, he definitely did a lot of things kind of outside of Trump's view that, you know, led him to live his best life.
Alex Ward
Like what?
Sean Rameswaram
Three things come to mind especially.
Alex Ward
The first is he, even before joining the Trump administration, was strongly against arms control, meaning like, you know, deals to reduce the number of nuclear weapons and missiles and stuff.
Sean Rameswaram
Like the INF with Russia? Like the INF with Russia.
Alex Ward
That's gone. It looks like New START, another important U.S.-Russia deal, maybe out the window.
Sean Rameswaram
And I reported at the time when Bolton went over to Moscow to negotiate with Putin and others that like he was carrying a, hey, can we work out a deal message?
Alex Ward
But that internally and telling aides like he just did not at all want to do that. He wanted those deals done or gone rather.
Sean Rameswaram
And now they're gone.
Alex Ward
What else?
Sean Rameswaram
Two is he like totally dismantled any adherence the U.S. really had to international law and the U.N.
Alex Ward
Like the Human Rights Council, you know, is an important body for many reasons that many that I should say people find controversial.
Sean Rameswaram
But like the U.S. stopped adhering to that. U.N. defunding. The International Criminal Court wanted to look into the conduct of U.S. troops in Afghanistan.
Alex Ward
Bolton basically bullied them to not doing so and even like revoked the visa of one of their counselors.
Sean Rameswaram
And the third thing?
Alex Ward
He's not the only one responsible for this, but he was a major driving force in the American pressure campaign against Latin America. Specifically Cuba, Nicaragua, and of course Venezuela.
Sean Rameswaram
Bolton kind of used these issues to say like it is America's job to push back against autocratic socialist regimes or communist regimes.
Alex Ward
And he even said like the Monroe Doctrine is back like with the Trump administration. So the U.S. would have complete control in a sense or complete power over the Western Hemisphere.
Sean Rameswaram
And in fact, there's some reporting out there that like Bolton and others sold, in the case of Venezuela, the Maduro's ouster. Like it would be so much easier.
Alex Ward
And since it's taken so long, Trump has completely lost interest. But Bolton didn't. And so despite the fact that he may not have completed all the things he would have liked to have done, he didn't convince Trump to do all the things he would have wanted him to do.
Sean Rameswaram
In the end, Bolton accomplished a lot in his short time there.
Alex Ward
This isn't the first time he's been asked to leave an administration, right? But wasn't his exit from the George W. Bush administration sort of similar?
Sean Rameswaram
It wasn't by tweet.
Alex Ward
Bolton has rubbed people the wrong way in the past. He was the U.N. ambassador for George W. Bush. He left in part because, you know, he didn't really like the U.N.
Sean Rameswaram
He went there basically to trash the U.N. He had once famously said, like, you could lop off a lot of the top rows of the U.N. and it would still be fine.
Alex Ward
And so where Bolton has gone, Bolton has just been himself. And he's never really molded himself into an administration. He's been an ideologue forever. He's had a lot of opinions about arms control, Iran, Latin America, communism, socialism.
Sean Rameswaram
Like he's just been constantly sort of single-minded about many of these things. And he's just pursued those objectives wherever he was.
Alex Ward
In this case with Donald Trump, he had a president who had strong views on foreign policy but didn't really deal with the day-to-day issues, didn't really follow through, wasn't – is not a task manager, is not a – you know, thorough person.
Sean Rameswaram
And so Bolton had a lot of room to pursue a lot of his objectives.
Alex Ward
Is this sort of the end of his political career? Does he have to just go back to being a Fox News talking head now?
Sean Rameswaram
That's the belief, is that this is it for John Bolton. And it's part of the reason, again, why he took the Trump job. It's because that's the highest he'll ever go.
Alex Ward
The chance that he'll ever be Senate confirmed seems impossible because Democrats hate him and a lot of Republicans hate him too.
Sean Rameswaram
But we have not heard the last of John Bolton.
Alex Ward
This guy is going to be commenting constantly. He'll be writing op-eds. He'll be on TV.
Sean Rameswaram
Unlike Mattis who wants to stay quiet Bolton I very sure is going to be extremely loud.
Alex Ward
And I think maybe the first real insight we may get to how Trump is as president may come from John Bolton.
Sean Rameswaram
John Bolton was President Trump's third national security advisor.
Alex Ward
Is the revolving door starting to hurt our national security? That's in a minute.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, so I mentioned this a couple weeks ago, but now it's September, so it feels much more real. Halloween is coming. It's just a month and some away.
Alex Ward
I was talking to my neighbor this weekend. He's already got Halloween costume ideas for his kids.
Sean Rameswaram
KiwiCo has costume ideas for your kids but they'll actually go one step further and help your kids make their own costumes.
Alex Ward
Your kid can be a KiwiCo unicorn, a KiwiCo dinosaur, a KiwiCo UFO, very timely with all the Area 51 stuff going on right now.
Sean Rameswaram
If the kid in your life isn't into dressing up, KiwiCo has other Halloween ideas. You can make a Pac-Man inspired glowing ghost and they have a glow in the dark flower project that looks kind of creepy and then best of all, a spider launcher.
Alex Ward
Guys, KiwiCo's got all sorts of fun for kids of all ages, and you can try it out right now for free at KiwiCo.com.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, Alex, National Security Advisor, hugely important job. The Trump administration has had three in not even as many years yet.
Alex Ward
But what does this mean for the nation's foreign policy? Here's what I think it means, and I don't know if you might see this as a good or bad thing. But Donald Trump is firmly in control of his foreign policy. Period.
Sean Rameswaram
What do you mean?
Alex Ward
Let me put it this way. If you were worried that John Bolton was going to lead Trump into wars with Iran and North Korea and elsewhere, he didn't lead Trump into wars with Iran and North Korea and elsewhere.
Sean Rameswaram
He did help increase the pressure on these countries, on North Korea, on Iran, on Venezuela.
Alex Ward
You may remember that we are backing effectively a coup attempt against Maduro. That's part of Bolton's policy.
Sean Rameswaram
But if we also look at sort of the grand picture here, Trump's foreign policy did not change with Bolton in the White House.
Alex Ward
And so regardless, I think, of who Trump picks to replace Bolton, like there will be more continuity than change.
Sean Rameswaram
Let's dig into some of these major conflicts that are still unresolved. I mean, where are we with North Korea now that Bolton's gone?
Alex Ward
Well, let's recall that part of the reason, not fully, but part of the reason that the U.S. and North Korea do not have a deal is because of John Bolton.
Sean Rameswaram
Pretty soon after Bolton joined the administration, he went on a Sunday news show and he said that.
Alex Ward
Will President Trump insist that Kim give up, ship out all of his nuclear weapons, all of his nuclear fuel, all of his ballistic missiles before the U.S. makes any concessions?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, I think that's what denuclearization means.
Alex Ward
And we have very much in mind the Libya model from 2003, 2004.
Sean Rameswaram
Well, North Korea is not like that. They saw what happened to Gaddafi after he gave up his nuclear weapons.
Alex Ward
And I don't think Kim Jong-un wants that fate.
Sean Rameswaram
So you could give Bolton marks for making it harder for the U.S. and North Korea to sign a deal, but he did not succeed in getting Trump to abandon that diplomatic process.
Alex Ward
What about Iran?
Sean Rameswaram
So Bolton joined in April 2018, and then in May 2018, the U.S. left the Iran nuclear deal.
Alex Ward
And that was something that Bolton wanted ripped up, and Trump did too.
Sean Rameswaram
So they were simpatico on that.
Alex Ward
But where I think Bolton definitely would have pushed Trump is, hey, maybe if we bomb certain parts of their nuclear program, maybe if we use more force, this might be another way to get Iran to that negotiating table that you want.
Sean Rameswaram
Trump was like, I just want them to do a better deal. I don't want them to have nuclear weapons ever. I don't want them to support terrorists ever. I don't want them to test missiles ever.
Alex Ward
And Bolton supported all of that, but also supported regime change. And it doesn't seem like Trump did.
Sean Rameswaram
So the basic sort of tagline for Bolton is like he and Trump aligned on a lot but he always wanted to go further than Trump.
Alex Ward
And that's where I think they where I think Bolton rubbed Trump the wrong way.
Sean Rameswaram
And Afghanistan Bolton is incredibly skeptical of doing any sort of deal with America adversaries right Whether it be Iran, whether it be Maduro, whether it be North Korea or whether it be, in this case, the Taliban.
Alex Ward
And so the notion that Trump was not only going to sign a peace deal with the Taliban that had recently been killing American troops and has just been increasing its attacks, to bring them to Camp David, right? kind of a sacred ground, not only for American foreign policy, but just the presidency in general, so close to September 11th.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm sure Bolton hated that.
Alex Ward
And in fact, he hated the peace process the entire time.
Sean Rameswaram
The president of the National Iranian American Council released a statement today congratulating President Trump on Bolton's departure, saying it may become the best decision of his presidency and noting that, quote, the single move dramatically reduces the chances of a new catastrophic war in the Middle East.
Alex Ward
Bolton's always been hawkish. He's always been skeptical of the UN. Did like the international order breathe some kind of sigh of relief today?
Sean Rameswaram
I think to a certain extent. But I think you can look at this two ways.
Alex Ward
Way one is the most hawkish person ever to be in Trump's orbit is gone and left before convincing the president to launch a catastrophic war.
Sean Rameswaram
Which war was that again? That's North Korea? And Iran. OK.
Alex Ward
And another way to look at it is that one of the most able people that Trump has had in his administration, arguably the most able, the most D.C. savvy, the most knowledgeable about a lot of these issues.
Sean Rameswaram
You may disagree with his views, but he's very knowledgeable about a lot of these issues.
Alex Ward
He's gone. And Trump is instead going to replace someone who would at least challenge Trump's instincts with someone who's more likely to be sycophantic and someone who's more likely to just agree with him.
Sean Rameswaram
And so you now are going to have kind of more Trump in your foreign policy.
Alex Ward
Now, you may think that's better than not having Bolton there, and I think that's a fair take.
Sean Rameswaram
But you need to know that Bolton has tons of relationships with people around the world.
Alex Ward
He is liked by a lot of people around the world. He's an able D.C. insider.
Sean Rameswaram
That's a loss for this administration that is still somewhat devoid of experience.
Alex Ward
And is that the way to survive in this administration? At this point, I suppose it's worth asking.
Sean Rameswaram
How do you remain in this administration if you have views that oppose President Trump's?
Alex Ward
I think the absolute blueprint is Mike Pompeo. Mike Pompeo has been with Trump since day one, first as CIA director, now secretary of state.
Sean Rameswaram
And what he's done, especially since taking the top diplomat job, is just side with Trump on everything.
Alex Ward
He may offer some thoughts behind closed doors. But at the end of the day, like in public, a staunch defender of Trump, a staunch defender of his policies.
Sean Rameswaram
What Trump likes is the spectacle of I am the leader and I have these guys defending me at all times.
Alex Ward
And Bolton did that to a certain extent, but he was also more equivocal. He was also certain times saying like, look, you know my views, but I'm the national security advisor, not the national security decider.
Sean Rameswaram
And so that's how it was a way he would kind of always be like, all right, media, you know where I'm at on this. You know Trump and I disagree on this. But I give my advice and Trump does what he wants.
Alex Ward
Alex Ward writes about national security here at Vox. You can hear him on the Worldly podcast every Thursday.
Sean Rameswaram
He's one of the co-hosts of that joint. And I bet this week they might just talk a little bit more about John Bolton.
Alex Ward
I'm Sean Rameswaram. This is Today Explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks to KiwiCo for supporting this episode of Today Explained.
Alex Ward
One last reminder that KiwiCo would like to give all of our listeners here at Today Explained a chance to try their fun, engaging projects about science and technology and engineering and arts and math out for free.
Sean Rameswaram
And you can take them up on that offer at KiwiCo.com slash explained right now.