Main Topic: The US designation of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard as a terrorist organization and its implications for the region and the world.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Depending on when you're listening to this, I've already brushed my teeth several times since recording this message.
Pause
Today's episode of Today Explained is brought to you by Quip Electric Toothbrushes.
Pause
The Quip Electric Toothbrush starts at $25 and your first pack of refills is free at getquip.com slash explained.
Pause
A lot happened this week. Solange pulled out of Coachella. Humanity saw its first black hole. Old Town Road hit number one on the charts. Julian Assange and his beard got arrested. Dirk and Dwayne's last games, Game of Thrones, hysteria. Omar al-Bashir got ousted. Benjamin Netanyahu got re-elected.
Pause
With all of the things, who could fault you if you forgot?
Pause
President Trump did something this week that no U.S. president has ever done before.
Pause
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has announced that the U.S. is designating the Iranian Revolutionary Guard as a terror group.
Pause
We're doing it because the Iranian regime's use of terrorism as a tool of statecraft makes it fundamentally different from any other government.
Pause
The first time that we've seen the U.S. government designate part of another country's government as a terrorist organization.
Pause
This designation is a direct response to an outlaw regime and should surprise no one.
Pause
I asked Dina Esfandieri what this first means for the world.
Pause
She's the author of Triple Axis, Iran's Relations with Russia and China.
Pause
And we started with what exactly Iran's Revolutionary Guard is.
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
So the guards are a branch of the Iranian Islamic Republic government, effectively.
Pause
They were created after the 1979 revolution when Iran's army, their views were not in line with those of the new government and their people couldn't be trusted.
Pause
And so the new government created the Revolutionary Guards as a kind of parallel military organization that would uphold the views of the Islamic Republic and that would spread the revolution both inside the country and outside the country.
Pause
Is there like a comparable government entity that we might know well that helps frame what the Revolutionary Guard is?
Pause
Yeah, like in another country.
Pause
Oh, that is a good question. Honestly, I can't think of one.
Pause
It's just it's such a different organization and it's so huge.
Pause
It's got a military branch. It's got a foreign policy branch that's very active in the region in countries like Syria and Iraq.
Pause
It's got an economic branch with businesses spread throughout Iran, and it grew in strength while Iran was under sanctions because it was very difficult for smaller and medium-sized companies to operate in a sanctioned environment.
Pause
And the Revolutionary Guards were quite rich.
Pause
So anytime somebody went out of business, they would kind of sweep in and establish themselves further.
Pause
So in the economic sphere, they're huge.
Pause
And politically, they have a lot of sway, A, because they're obviously a massive organization, and B, because some of their members are quite active in Iranian politics.
Pause
In fact, the previous Iranian president, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, was a former member of the guards.
Pause
I mean, they really touch absolutely everyone, which means that it makes things a little bit difficult.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Who is actually going to get into trouble as a result of this designation?
Pause
I mean, previously, what are we talking about when we talk about a U.S. president declaring something a terrorist organization?
Pause
It's stuff like al-Qaeda and the Islamic State?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
What terrorists are is a non-state actor.
Pause
The Revolutionary Guards don't fit that pattern.
Pause
They are a state actor.
Pause
And what does it mean to declare this part of the Iranian government a terrorist organization?
Pause
What are the consequences?
Pause
So technically what it means is that all U.S. persons, and this includes businesses, that are found to either communicate with or help the guards in any way could be punished and be imprisoned under U.S. law.
Pause
Because with this terror designation, the U.S. can sanction pretty much anybody who talks to or deals with or has any business whatsoever with the IRGC.
Pause
And because they permeate so much of Iranian society, they're trying to make, I think the word they used was, they're trying to make Iran's economy radioactive.
Pause
They are trying to prevent anyone from doing business with Iran at any time.
Pause
The problem is that, effectively, this was already the case before.
Pause
So the designation doesn't have that much of an impact other than make a very big political and symbolic statement.
Pause
The impact it does have is that it raises the stakes in the region and it makes things a little bit more complicated for a future potential president that might want to engage with Iran.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
The Trump administration is entrapping future administrations into a permanent state of enmity between the United States and Iran because any movement future administrations would like to do to reduce tensions with Iran, all of those efforts will become severely hampered by this decision
Pause
This happened on Monday
Pause
How have Iran leaders responded?
Pause
The first thing that they did was Retaliated by doing the same to U forces in the region specifically mentioning U.S. Central Command and saying that the United States was a state sponsor of terror.
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Now, that doesn't necessarily have that much of an impact on Iran, but what it does do is it allows Iranian militias and militias that are affiliated to the Iranian government in the region, perhaps a little bit more wiggle room when it comes to targeting troops that are present there, should they want to do that.
Pause
Ideally, Iranians will show restraint, much like they have, I would argue, in the last couple of months, given the very tough rhetoric that's coming out of D.C.
Pause
But this does raise tensions quite a lot.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And being that this move is unprecedented, how have other countries in the region or elsewhere responded to it?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
I believe the first person to respond was Netanyahu, who actually congratulated President Trump for the move, as did some of the U.S.'s friends and allies in the Middle East region, the Gulf Arab countries, for example.
Pause
But France was the first government in Europe to come out today with a statement exactly on this issue, urging caution and calm on both sides.
Pause
The U.S.'s allies in Europe actually have struck a little bit of a different tone.
Pause
This makes it very difficult for them because they are trying to uphold the Iran nuclear deal that was signed in 2015, the deal that the U.S. walked away from last year.
Pause
And this makes it very difficult to continue engaging Iran and talking to Iran.
Pause
And the Europeans don't, unlike the United States, have an ocean separating them from the Middle East and what's going on in Iran.
Pause
So one of their number one priorities is to prevent regional instability even further in this region closer at home.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
You mentioned Israel. Israel obviously had an election this week.
Pause
Might that have had something to do with the timing?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Absolutely.
Pause
I mean, the Iranian foreign minister certainly made it seem that way when he announced on Twitter shortly after the designation that this was a gift to Netanyahu on the eve of his potential re-election.
Pause
And so many have perceived it as something that a move that is directed towards assisting Netanyahu's re-election.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Apart from the Israeli election this week, are there other reasons this move is happening now in, what, April 2019?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
The move seems to be the natural progression of Trump's announced maximum pressure campaign on Iran.
Pause
It began with President Trump's removing of the U.S. from the Iran nuclear deal and the reimposition of a series of sanctions following that since.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
This isn't just Iran, right? This is Iraq, this is Israel, this is Syria, this is so many things.
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
It increases the risk of conflict and escalation between the U.S. and Iran in the region.
Pause
And there are a number of arenas in the region where both countries have influence or are present.
Pause
Iraq is a very good example.
Pause
In fact, The Iraqi government came out earlier this week and said that this would make things very difficult for them and that they had tried to lobby the Trump administration hard in order for him not to do this because Iraqis can't afford to side just with Iran or the U.S.
Pause
They very much need both countries present within their borders and helping them with their reconstruction and rebuilding efforts.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
After the break, she tells us why.
Pause
All week I've been talking about tweets people have sent me about the Quip electric toothbrush.
Pause
But shout outs to Gchat, which is a primary mode of communication in my life with a few select friends.
Pause
And one of them had the idea over Gchat.
Pause
He said, what if you just tell people about how they are in no way brushing their teeth for anywhere close to two minutes and this toothbrush will make them do that?
Pause
I think Matthew was referring to the two minute timer.
Pause
The Quip got it pulses gently to let you know when to switch sides and quadrants.
Pause
Matthew says basically you are gross and this toothbrush will help you be less of a monster and also it's pretty.
Pause
Also, also this isn't Matthew.
Pause
This is Quip.
Pause
Lets you know That their brush runs for three months on just one battery and it has a clunky charger.
Pause
So what are you waiting for get Quip slash explained is the price point you to start at there with the Quip.
Pause
You can soup it up if you like G dot com slash explained.
Pause
Right now the Quip comes with a free first pack of refills.
Pause
Deuces
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Why exactly did Iran create the Revolutionary Guard?
Pause
What was its purpose in the outset?
Pause
The Revolutionary Guards were created right after the Iranian Revolution in 1979 because the new government didn't trust Iran's standard army that the Iranians called the Atish.
Pause
They didn't think that the army was loyal because it had been loyal to the previous ruler, the Shah of Iran.
Pause
And so as a result, they carried out a number of purges.
Pause
And ultimately, they decided to set up the Revolutionary Guards as a new entity that had an ideological leaning, that believed in the revolution, and that would be tasked with spreading the revolution both domestically and outside of Iran's borders.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Greetings to you Khomeini, they chanted, surging toward him, desperate to touch the hand or robe of the holy man, or to have something, anything, touched and blessed by him.
Pause
A new and more turbulent era for Iran had begun.
Pause
The reign of Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the man who ruled Iran through four decades, came to an end.
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
So created in 1979 by sort of the hardcore contingent of people who want to spread Iran's revolution, what is the first major test of this new group?
Pause
The test was whether their ideology was going to survive.
Pause
Iran, after the revolution, faced a lot of difficulties.
Pause
It became isolated on the international scene quite rapidly.
Pause
We have to remember that Iran under the Shah was a close ally of the U.S., had partners in Europe and South America and the rest of the Middle East.
Pause
And the Islamic Republic was left alone.
Pause
Nobody wanted to work with it anymore after the hostage crisis.
Pause
And on top of that, shortly after the revolution, the Iraqis invaded Iran and started a war.
Pause
In the frontline cities, Iranian troops hurried to engage the invaders.
Pause
Local resistance was led by Iran's revolutionary guards, who were fiercely loyal to Ayatollah Khomeini.
Pause
From their example stemmed the Iranian mood of self-sacrifice in a holy war.
Pause
And following that, it escalated pretty quickly because most of the world helped Iraq out because they were afraid of the new Islamic Republic, even though the Iraqi leadership used chemical weapons against Iran.
Pause
And after seven, eight years of war, Iran was left even more isolated with even less resources and a hell of a lot of reconstruction to do.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, so Iran has this revolution in 1979.
Pause
It creates this organization, this revolutionary guard right after that.
Pause
Then it goes into an eight-year war.
Pause
It comes out weakened.
Pause
And between, let's say, the late 80s and, you know, 30 years later now, how does this organization become so important?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Part of that actually is a result of the international pressure and the successive waves of sanctions that were imposed on Iran.
Pause
The guards had been empowered by the government.
Pause
They had a big membership and they had a lot of financial means.
Pause
And they were increasingly getting involved in the Iranian economy that was, despite difficulty, still managing to grow.
Pause
And because of their privileged position within the system, when there were contracts to be handed out in different sectors, well, ultimately, the Revolutionary Guards would more often than not get them or would find a way to enrich themselves as a result of it.
Pause
And then when the sanctions were imposed, it became even easier for them to become richer because it was harder for smaller businesses to stay afloat when the price of raw materials was increasing and inflation was quite high.
Pause
And the guards could manage that more easily because they were bigger and richer.
Pause
It's also important to note that the guards, even though they're viewed as a single giant entity in Iran, they actually aren't.
Pause
It isn't a monolith.
Pause
There are some today who are not as ideological as when the guards were first created.
Pause
It works on the basis of conscription, so there are a lot of young Iranians that join because they are given a good financial opportunity and don't necessarily believe in what the revolution says.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So the guards are interesting today because they don't look like what they did when they were first created.
Pause
I guess when we think about terrorist organizations, our minds go to these violent cells that are plotting attacks and beheading people.
Pause
But you make it sound like the Revolutionary Guard is so everyday in Iran, so quotidian.
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
It is an organization that you probably end up dealing with in some way or another on a daily, weekly, monthly basis.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Because maybe some of the groceries that you buying are coming from an entity that the Revolutionary Guard controls.
Pause
You might be leasing a space that the Revolutionary Guard owns.
Pause
You might be unhappy with the way the government is functioning.
Pause
And so you'll go out and demonstrate and you might get beaten up by somebody in the Revolutionary Guards.
Pause
So it's undeniable that as the average Iranian, you will come across this organization regularly.
Pause
And it's always going to be an Iranian man between a certain age of a certain age?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
No, no, no.
Pause
The Revolutionary Guards have a very, very wide membership.
Pause
There is an older corps that remember the revolution quite fondly.
Pause
But actually, most of them today are very young.
Pause
And they're, you know, just fresh out of school if they have been to school.
Pause
And it's just there is a lack of other opportunities for them.
Pause
And so the Revolutionary Guards is a good place to turn because you can get paid relatively well and fed and sometimes even have a roof put over your head.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So it is a good place to turn to at a time where Iran is struggling economically.
Pause
And what's the reputation of the organization within the country?
Pause
Is it revered? Is it, you know, suspect?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Well, it depends what happens and how the guards are attacked from the outside.
Pause
So the Revolutionary Guards haven't always been very popular, particularly their plainclothed militia, the Basij, who are disliked because they are the ones who come and beat people up when they're out on the streets.
Pause
But for example, when ISIS spread in Iraq and Syria and came relatively close to the Iranian border, so when there's an external threat, support for the guards increase.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
This designation that happened earlier this week, it will serve to unify Iranians around the Revolutionary Guards because ultimately the guards help to secure the country.
Pause
It's sort of reminiscent of a conversation we just had on the show about Medicare and Obamacare.
Pause
And by speaking out so forcefully against Obamacare, President Trump actually managed to make it more popular.
Pause
Is that the same situation with the Revolutionary Guard?
Pause
Might his designation on Monday of it as a terrorist organization might make it more popular domestically?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Absolutely.
Pause
It's undeniable that it's going to make the guards more popular, at least for a little while at the very least.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
The day after the designation was announced, members of the Iranian parliament who never agree on anything all showed up in Revolutionary Guards attire to show their support to the guards.
Pause
I wonder, you know, Trump bullied North Korea and it led to what looked like possible progress before everything sort of fell apart.
Pause
Could it work here?
Pause
You mean bullying Iran?
Pause
Dina Esfandieri
Yeah.
Pause
The problem is that bullying Iran is not going to work anymore.
Pause
It had somewhat of an impact prior to the nuclear deal because the policy of sanctioning Iran and isolating it was done in conjunction with trying to engage it and trying to get concessions from it.
Pause
Once the nuclear deal was signed and Iran made those concessions and implemented the nuclear deal, as has been certified now multiple times, and the U.S. still walked away from it, this basically proved Iran's Supreme Leader right when he said, you cannot trust the United States, and as such, we don't want to engage with them.
Pause
For the Supreme Leader, the exercise of dealing with the U.S. was just an effort to see whether it was worth engaging with the U.S.
Pause
He believed it wasn't, but he wanted to give his government a chance to try.
Pause
And they did.
Pause
And it worked.
Pause
And it was the U.S. that broke the deal by walking away from it.
Pause
There is no scenario today where Iran can trust that the U.S. would ever deliver or stick to another agreement after it walked away from one that was working and one that Iran was actually implementing.
Pause
I think the U.S. government is hoping to constrain Iran and to potentially change the government.
Pause
But this policy is just unifying the Iranian public around the government.
Pause
And actually, from a PR perspective, Iran is starting to look like the reasonable country, and other countries are seeing it that way.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Dina Esfandieri is a fellow with Harvard's Belfer Center at the Kennedy School and a fellow at the Century Foundation in New York.
Pause
I'm Sean Ramos from Just a Regular Fellow at Today Explained.
Pause
Thanks to Quip Electric Toothbrushes for riding with us for another week.
Pause
It's been a journey.
Pause
You can get your first Quip Electric Toothbrush for $25 at getquip.com.
Pause
It comes with a free first pack of refills.
Pause
G-E-T-Q-U-I-P dot C-O-M slash E-X-P-L-A-I-N-E-D.
Pause
Have a nice weekend.