Main Topic: The NATO summit in Vilnius, Lithuania, and the debate over Ukraine's potential membership in the alliance.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Overall, the episode highlights the complexities and challenges of the NATO summit and the ongoing conflict in Ukraine, as well as the controversy surrounding the provision of cluster munitions to Ukraine.
Noel King
In a photo taken a few hours ago at the NATO summit in Vilnius, Lithuania, leaders of the Western world stand together on a stage. Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, is not in that picture. He'd really like to be, but NATO has not invited Ukraine to join yet.
Sound of a plane flying by
Zelensky's on his way to the summit anyway. He tweeted today that it is unprecedented and absurd that Ukraine hasn't been given a timeline for when it may be able to join NATO. And he ended saying this, uncertainty is weakness, and I will openly discuss this at the summit.
Sound of a crowd
Even without the vow of verbal confrontation, all eyes were going to be on Zelensky. Russia's invasion of his country is forcing the NATO alliance over the next two days to confront how far it's going to go to help Ukraine. Some things, immediate membership, are off the table. Others, including a catastrophically dangerous weapon, are suddenly in play.
Sound of a car driving by
That's all ahead on Today Explained. Optimously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Sound of a commercial
Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and, of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
Sound of a commercial
From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look. Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com. It's Today Explained.
Sound of a crowd
Felicia Schwartz is the U.S. foreign affairs and defense correspondent for the Financial Times, and I reached her in Lithuania. I am in Vilnius here to cover the NATO summit this week.
Felicia Schwartz
Well, it's very sleepy right now because it seems like they've closed off a lot of the roads ahead of Biden's arrival. I am seeing lots of Ukrainian, NATO, and Lithuanian flags. Saw some posters with a big middle finger to Putin and the F-bomb.
Noel King
[laughs] I am guessing this is a family show, so I won't curse. But there's a lot of pro-Ukrainian sentiment here.
Felicia Schwartz
The 31 members of NATO meet once a year to discuss policy priorities, spending commitments. Typically, it's not anything that's very exciting, but... But of course, you know, since Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, these summits have taken on a different tone because we've got war in Europe for the first time this century.
Noel King
So this year, there are two big questions hovering over this meeting. One is, what kind of language will the alliance offer to Ukraine on membership, which is its aspiration, and Ukraine sees as a critical need to deter and defend against Russia?
Felicia Schwartz
And then separately, but relatedly, what will be the fate of Sweden's bid to enter the alliance? The fate of Sweden's bid to enter the alliance became clearer after we talked to Felicia yesterday. Turkey, which had been standing in the way, backed down at the last minute, which all but ensures Sweden's entrance into NATO.
Noel King
And so the focus again turns back to Ukraine. I think there's quite a big debate among the allies. No one is saying that Ukraine will join this week. It's generally NATO's policy that a country with an active conflict wouldn't join.
Felicia Schwartz
So the debate is really more about what kind of language, assurances, guarantees, pathway is one word that some want to use and others don't. But what can the alliance offer to Ukraine in a nod to its aspirations for membership?
Noel King
And the reason that a country at war generally can't join NATO is because if it did, all of the members of NATO would have to go to war alongside it.
Felicia Schwartz
Yeah, pretty much. Article 5 of the NATO charter stipulates that all of the members will come to the defense of each other if one is invaded. So the second you would admit a country at war like Ukraine into the alliance, that would sort of automatically draw in all 31 other countries into this conflict.
Noel King
And President Biden all along has been very clear that, you know, the number one goal for the U.S. is not to draw the U.S. and NATO by extension into war with Russia. We will not fight a war against Russia and Ukraine.
Felicia Schwartz
Direct confrontation between NATO and Russia is World War III. Something we must strive to prevent.
Noel King
Ukraine has wanted to be part of NATO for a long time, even before this war started. So it's not just about getting allies who can help us fight. Why does Ukraine want to be in NATO so badly?
Felicia Schwartz
Well, basically, Ukraine, when it gave up its nuclear weapons as part of the fall of the Soviet Union, there was a Budapest memorandum where basically the U.S. and other allies agreed to protect Ukraine's security.
Noel King
But without nuclear weapons, they feel like they've had no deterrent from Russia.
Felicia Schwartz
The U.S., the U.K., and Russia were at the heart of these talks, convincing Ukraine to return the nukes to Russia. And in 1994, those four countries signed what is now known as the Budapest Memorandum.
Noel King
They promised that none of those nations would use force or threats against Ukraine, and they promised to respect their sovereignty and existing borders.
Felicia Schwartz
So joining NATO means you know coming under the cover of the nuclear umbrella of the U and its allies.
Noel King
They point to what happened in 2014 when Russia invaded Crimea and of course the full invasion in 2022 that you know just empty promises from the U and other powers are not enough to fend off Russia.
Felicia Schwartz
And Russian President Vladimir Putin has made it very clear that he doesn't think that Ukraine is a real country.
Noel King
I think that the best kind of analysis from the U.S. intelligence services and allied intelligence services is that Putin saw real opportunity to take advantage of what he saw as a weak landscape to go in.
Felicia Schwartz
And he didn't think that the world would put up too much of a fuss, that he could wait the world out.
Noel King
And so for Ukraine, they really feel like the kind of joint protection of this massive alliance is all that will really fend Putin off and Russia off, whoever controls Russia.
Felicia Schwartz
We understand that while the war is ongoing, we can't become a member of NATO. However, we need to be sure that after the war, we will become a member. That's the signal we want to get, that after the war, Ukraine will become a NATO member.
Noel King
Let's take us back again before the war, because obviously right now there is a very good reason why NATO member states would not want to let Ukraine in. Nobody wants to join Ukraine in this war.
Felicia Schwartz
So NATO has an open-door policy, which means if all the members consent, then any country can join.
Noel King
I think that when the U.S. and its allies picked up on the fact that Russia was going to invade, the U.S. and others tried to enter talks with Russia, trying to allay some of Russia's fears about Ukraine's NATO aspirations.
Felicia Schwartz
So this has been always a red line to Russia that the West has understood.
Noel King
And while there are plenty who want to see Ukraine and NATO eventually, there was some openness to talking about this.
Felicia Schwartz
But also putting that aside, there are, when I talk to American and European officials about this, and NATO officials, they say there are, and Biden actually said this in a CNN interview pretty strongly that he gave over the weekend, there are democratic and good governance standards and things that need to happen before any country could enter NATO.
Noel King
And I think there's a feeling that Ukraine is not yet there. NATO is a process that takes some time to meet all the qualifications, and from democratization to a whole range of other issues.
Felicia Schwartz
He basically said when he was asked over the weekends about does he want to see Ukraine join NATO, he pointed to basically reforms that any country in Ukraine in particular would need to make to enter the alliance.
Noel King
This is basically instituting good governance, making sure that it's a democracy that operates in accordance with kind of international standards.
Felicia Schwartz
But basically the subtext there is that the U.S. and its allies don't want to let in another like Orban or Erdogan or Turkey or Hungary that plays spoiler in the alliance.
Noel King
And that isn't really a democracy that's functioning well.
Felicia Schwartz
So basically, they want to see Ukraine make some reforms, which Ukraine is certainly like working on doing and says they're committed to doing.
Noel King
We are now a country that is respected, a country that is really fighting for human values, for human rights, for freedom, for democracy.
Felicia Schwartz
And everyone has already understood that it is exactly such a country.
Noel King
But I think for the U.S. and for its partners, it's hard to talk about NATO membership for a country where it's really very uncertain at this point when the war will end and what that end will look like and who will be in power.
Felicia Schwartz
Certainly Zelensky has a lot of support and he's a heroic and iconic figure who is really beloved by the West.
Noel King
But I think that there is also Biden and his partners and those in government and those that he talks to, like, understand that it's going to be probably a long road to admit a country that's under the current circumstances.
Felicia Schwartz
How likely is it, Felicia, that Ukraine will be admitted to NATO?
Noel King
I guess it depends on the time horizon. If your question is, how likely is it will Ukraine be admitted this week?
Felicia Schwartz
I would say the chance is zero.
Noel King
How likely is it that Ukraine will be admitted ever?
Felicia Schwartz
I think it's not impossible. I think it will take some time. I think what we are covering this week and looking to see is what kind of agreement can the 31 members of NATO come to on some sort of language that is satisfying for Ukraine's future aspirations, but also gets at these concerns that countries like the U.S. and Germany and others have about, on the one hand, not letting in any member that's not ready, but also not creating any sort of glide path that might create Article 5 requirements for the alliance that they're not really interested in pursuing.
Noel King
I cover the U.S., so I'm thinking about their view, but that's not the only view and the alliance.
Felicia Schwartz
I think what we will see and what we've been reporting on is Biden and also Macron and others have talked about these Israeli-style security commitments for Ukraine.
Noel King
The United States would be ready to provide while the process was going on, and it's going to take a while, while that process was going on to provide security a la the security we provide for you, for Israel, providing the weaponry, the need, the capacity to defend themselves if there is an agreement if there is a ceasefire, if there is a peace agreement.
Felicia Schwartz
I think we will see that the U.S. and its allies are working on pledging some sort of commitment for Ukraine to at least maintain like sufficient military capabilities to deter and defend against Russia for the long term.
Noel King
There'll probably be a bunch of bilateral pledges of different dollar amounts and longer term commitments that signal to Putin and to Russia and to anyone who has doubts that the West is here for the long haul and they're committed to making sure that Ukraine has what it needs to defend itself.
One of the ways in which the U is making sure Ukraine has what it needs to defend itself is by sending a type of weapon called a cluster munition or a cluster bomb.
Sound of a commercial
The U.S. just agreed to this about a week ago, and it has horrified even some countries that are allies of both the U.S. and Ukraine.
Matthew Akins
One of the ways in which the U is making sure Ukraine has what it needs to defend itself is by sending a type of weapon called a cluster munition or a cluster bomb.
Noel King
The U.S. just agreed to this about a week ago, and it has horrified even some countries that are allies of both the U.S. and Ukraine.
Matthew Akins
I'm Matthew Akins, and I'm a contributing writer at The New York Times Magazine and a fellow at Taip Media Center.
Noel King
And I'm the author of a book called The Naked Don't Fear the Water, an underground journey with Afghan refugees.
Matthew Akins
Matthew Akins covers conflict, and in the course of his coverage of conflict, he's reported from Yemen on exactly what cluster munitions do, not just to combatants on a battlefield, but also to civilians.
Noel King
So a cluster munition is basically a container, a casing, and it contains dozens or more than 100 little bombs inside of it.
Matthew Akins
And so this is either dropped from a plane or fired from an artillery gun, and it bursts open in the air and then spreads this rain of explosives over a wide area below.
Noel King
So if you were targeted by one of these, you'd basically have explosives raining down on you.
Matthew Akins
How long have cluster bombs been used on the battlefield?
Noel King
Well, they were used in World War II.
Matthew Akins
They've been used in many conflicts since then. The U.S. used them during the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq.
Noel King
And although that was the last time the U.S. military used them, weapons that the U.S. has made and transferred to allies have been used on the battlefield since then.
Matthew Akins
Why did the U.S. stop using them?
Noel King
Well, these weapons are very controversial.
Matthew Akins
And the reason is that these little bombs that rain from them don't always explode. They lie in the ground and they almost become like landmines.
Noel King
And as a result, they can quite easily injure or kill civilians, sometimes for years or even decades after the conflict has ended.
Matthew Akins
Cluster bombs have gained a reputation for killing and injuring civilians, especially children who come across the smaller explosives or bomblets that fail to initially detonate after being dropped.
Noel King
Because there's so many of these little bomblets, as they're called, within a cluster bomb, inevitably some of them are going to go off, even if you have a low failure rate.
Matthew Akins
So at one point, the failure rate was about 20 percent, then it was 6 percent. But we understand now, according to the U.S., it's 2 percent, but we don't know the evidence for that.
Noel King
So because of the danger they pose to innocent people, these weapons are very controversial, and a lot of countries have banned them outright.
Matthew Akins
You have 123 countries that have signed up to this convention against cluster bombs, but the U.S. is not among them.
Noel King
So the U.S. reserves the right to use them, though they don't currently, which again is controversial because a lot of people think these weapons should not be used.
Matthew Akins
And it's a bad example for the U.S. not to be part of this treaty.
Noel King
And in this case, they're now transferring these weapons to Ukraine.
Matthew Akins
When you were reporting in Yemen, tell me what you saw and who you talked to.
Noel King
I went to Yemen in 2015 when the country was being bombed by the Saudi-led coalition.
Matthew Akins
And we went to northern Yemen, which had been basically declared a military free fire zone by the Saudis.
Noel King
So we're here in Sa'dah City, which is the capital of Sa'dah governorate in northern Yemen.
Matthew Akins
It's the stronghold of Ansarullah, better known as the Houthis.
Noel King
And it's been a scene of intense border warfare between Ansarullah and Saudi Arabia.
Matthew Akins
And we documented these U.S.-made cluster bombs being used against civilian targets.
Noel King
Saudi Arabia declared the entire governor to be a military zone, and that anything inside of it, you know, including almost a million people who lived here, was now a valid military target.
Matthew Akins
Because cluster bombs, they hit a wide area, they're also likely to harm civilians who are in the area, so they're not very easy to target, they're not really precision weapons in that sense.
Noel King
So this is the site of a strike on a gas station.
Matthew Akins
So what happened was in the afternoon a bomb hit this gas station.
Noel King
And there were obviously a bunch of cars and people queued up for gasoline
Matthew Akins
They say that 19 people were killed but only 8 of them were recognizable because their bodies had been so badly burned
Noel King
And so we saw schools and mosques villages gas stations targeted and witnessed you know firsthand the toll of these
Matthew Akins
We saw people, children coming in missing limbs, dead.
Noel King
There were 51 people killed, 37 of them, according to a list that they showed me, were women and children.
Matthew Akins
What happened was that there was a strike on one of these houses here in the afternoon, and then as people were gathering to try to rescue and dig people out of the rubble, more bombs or rockets came in and killed the rescuers, and then they were basically afraid to go in and dig people out.
Noel King
So these are devastatingly effective weapons.
Matthew Akins
That's why Ukraine wants them, that's why the U.S. wants to give it to them, but they can cause enormous harm to civilians.
Noel King
There are civilians still living here, but they're mostly shepherds who have flocks to tend.
Matthew Akins
And there's a Saudi jet in the sky right now that we can hear circling around.
Noel King
So there's airstrikes ongoing right now.
Matthew Akins
When the United States is asked, why are you sending these to Ukraine? You, the U.S., haven't used them in 20 years.
Noel King
When you use them in Afghanistan, there was a huge outcry.
Matthew Akins
100-plus countries have banned them.
Noel King
What does the U.S. say?
Matthew Akins
Well, the U.S. says that Ukraine is running out of artillery shells.
Noel King
So the cluster munitions that are being sent are actually artillery.
Matthew Akins
And the West isn't producing artillery shells as fast as the Ukrainians are using them.
Noel King
This is a war relating to munitions.
Matthew Akins
And they're running out of that ammunition.
Noel King
And we're low on it.
Matthew Akins
So there is a need in this battle, which is very much a battle that's using artillery on both sides, for more arms.
Noel King
And that's why the U.S. says that they need to transfer this weaponry.
Matthew Akins
We recognize that cluster munitions create a risk of civilian harm from unexploded ordnance.
Noel King
This is why we've deferred the decision for as long as we could.
Matthew Akins
But there is also a massive risk of civilian harm if Russian troops and tanks roll over Ukrainian positions and take more Ukrainian territory and subjugate more Ukrainian civilians because Ukraine does not have enough artillery.
Noel King
That is intolerable to us.
Matthew Akins
Have they been used before in Russia's war in Ukraine?
Noel King
Yes, both sides have been using cluster munitions against each other.
Matthew Akins
These are Soviet-era cluster munitions, and it's been in use on both sides, but this will be the first time that the U.S. is actually providing them.
Noel King
Russia has been using cluster munitions since the start of this war to attack Ukraine.
Matthew Akins
Russia has been using cluster munitions with high dud or failure rates of between 30 and 40 percent.
Noel King
In this environment, Ukraine has been requesting cluster munitions in order to defend its own sovereign territory.
Matthew Akins
I'm sure there are good reasons for why the Ukrainians want them, why they're going to be useful on the battlefield.
Noel King
The real question is, is this worth it? Is it worth using such a controversial weapon that so many countries have banned, that we know will kill civilians for years or maybe even decades in the future, because they lie there like landmines?
Matthew Akins
Is that worth it?
Noel King
I mean, one of Ukraine's most important weapons is the moral high ground in this war.
Matthew Akins
And the question is really whether this is worth it.
Noel King
What's been the world's response?
Matthew Akins
It varies.
Noel King
You know, most of Ukraine's allies who are also providing weapons have been fairly circumspect about not criticizing the United States.
Matthew Akins
But it puts them in an awkward position because countries like the UK, Canada, Germany, they've all banned cluster bombs.
Noel King
They've all signed on to this treaty against them.
Matthew Akins
The UK, Germany, Canada, New Zealand, they've all come out against this decision, all saying that they don't believe these weapons should be used.
Noel King
British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, he has said that Britain does not endorse this.
Matthew Akins
He's one of 123 countries to ban their use.
Noel King
The Spanish defence minister has come out even further.
Matthew Akins
She's said yes to the legitimate defence of Ukraine, no to cluster munitions.
Noel King
It doesn't look good that the US is providing a weapon that its allies have considered to be morally reprehensible.
Matthew Akins
But I think what I hear you saying is other countries can't stop Ukraine or Russia from using these.
Noel King
No, they can't. This is basically a bilateral transfer from the U.S. to Ukraine.
Matthew Akins
So short of withdrawing support or reacting in some other way, then there's nothing these other countries can do.
Noel King
Ukraine has provided written assurances that it is going to use these in a very careful way that is aimed at minimizing any risk to civilians.
Matthew Akins
And by the way, Ukraine, the democratically elected government of Ukraine, has every incentive to minimize risk to civilians because it's their citizens.
Noel King
It's Ukrainians who they are trying to protect and defend.
Matthew Akins
Matthew Akins is a reporter and author of the book The Naked Don't Fear the Water, An Underground Journey with Afghan Refugees.
Noel King
Today's show was produced by Avishay Artsy and edited by Matt Collette.
Matthew Akins
It was fact-checked by Laura Bullard with help from Amanda Lewellyn and Hady Mawajdeh.
Noel King
Patrick Boyd is our engineer.
Matthew Akins
The rest of the team includes Halima Shah, Siona Petros, Miles Bryan, Victoria Chamberlain, John Ahrens, Michael Raphael, and my co-host Sean Ramos-Furr.
Noel King
Our supervising producer is Amina El-Sadi.
Matthew Akins
Our EP is Miranda Kennedy.
Noel King
Our music comes from Breakmaster Cylinder and Noam Hassenfeld.
Matthew Akins
I am Noelle King, and Today Explained is distributed to public radio stations across the United States by WNYC and is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Noel King
Thank you.