Main Topic: Nancy Pelosi's visit to Taiwan and its implications for US-China relations.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi landed in Taiwan earlier today. All right, I believe we are seeing Nancy Pelosi coming down. I was just deboarded the plane after arriving in Taiwan. Remember, this is the highest level visit by a U.S. official in 25 years, coming at a very sensitive time. China does not want her to be there. China's foreign minister today said U.S. politicians who play with fire will come to no good end. The U.S. called that saber rattling, but it should be noted the White House didn't want her there either. So what is Nancy Pelosi doing in Taiwan? What is she not doing in Taiwan?
Pause
I don't expect her to, like, stand on a Taiwanese beach and stare across the street with, like, her arms folded and go like, Mm, China, we're here. But I do sort of expect her to make as many, again, small, deep Democratic statements and show her support as possible, because that ultimately is what this trip feels like it's about.
Pause
That's coming up on Today Explained. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com. Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and, of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts. From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look. Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com. It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King. Alex Ward, longtime friend of the show, national security reporter for Politico. Why are so many people losing it over Nancy Pelosi being in Taiwan?
Alex Ward
Because of the escalation that it portends. It isn't necessarily for a visit. It's more what could happen afterward. So you're seeing already escalation between China, where they're sending planes to the middle of the Taiwan Strait that separates Taiwanese island from mainland China. You're seeing ships sail near that sort of border. The leader of China, Xi Jinping, say, hey, don't play with fire here.
Pause
And this comes amid a pretty tense moment, not already between the U.S. and China, But as the U.S. is trying to get China to stop helping or to not help, I should say, Russia in his war against Ukraine. And so having Nancy Pelosi be there, which would make her the first speaker to be there since 1997, there's no way around that. So then why is she there? What's the official reason she's given if all of this is stressing everyone out?
Well, the thing is, she hasn't even given an official reason. When her office provided an itinerary of her visit, it didn't include Taiwan. I mentioned Singapore, I mentioned South Korea, I mentioned Japan. There's no real reason why she's going. The unofficial reason, the best thing we can surmise from our own reporting and from others is that she's fearful she will not be the speaker by this fall. And she has had a decades long stance of pretty much China hawkery and standing up for human rights in China.
Pause
She was in Tiananmen Square shortly thereafter, the famous tank and the tank man moment, saying that the U.S. stands for people of China, that the U.S. stands for human rights. The three members of Congress had been optimistic about their human rights mission to China until they themselves went to Tiananmen Square. Democrats Nancy Pelosi from California and Ben Jones from Georgia and Republican John Miller of Washington staged their personal Tiananmen remembrance in front of the international media in a square fold of Chinese tourists and security personnel.
Pause
And so maybe this is sort of a bit of legacy burnership. Maybe this is, you know, in her final days, she went to Taiwan, stood up for its democracy, gave the middle finger to Chinese leader Xi Jinping and showed herself to be the true champion of democracy worldwide, not just in the U.S., that she fancies herself to be.
Pause
Noel King
Let's put all of this in some context. What is the United States' official policy toward Taiwan? It is that we do not recognize its independence. We haven't done so since 1979, when Jimmy Carter officially made the U.S. recognize mainland China, with Beijing as its capital and Taiwan as a separate political entity, basically a breakaway state.
Alex Ward
The United States of America and the People's Republic of China have agreed to recognize each other and to establish diplomatic relations as of January the 1st, 1979. Within this context, the people of the United States will maintain cultural, commercial, and other unofficial relations with the people of Taiwan. However, it does recognize its ability to defend itself from, you know, would-be invaders, which of course would be China, and we have sold billions of weapons and missiles and planes and all other kinds of things to Taiwan to help it defend itself and create what some analysts would call a porcupine, quote unquote, which is an island so full of missiles, so full of weapons that it would basically prick China if it tried to take the island by force.
Pause
What is China's policy toward Taiwan? And I mean both its official policy and also the way it behaves toward Taiwan. The official policy is that there is, you know, one China. And by the way, I should say that the U.S. believes in that too. that is the one-China policy. Taiwan is a separate entity. Beijing believes that Taipei is not its own capital, that it belongs to China. And so the sort of official policy is that eventually there will be the reification of the island. And so it's been decades in which, you know, sort of a democratic Taiwan has built up, basically off the shores of a very communist China.
Pause
And so the goal is, you know, perhaps economic integration, perhaps a change in Taiwan's politics, or just given enough time, there will be a reunification. The thing that worries a lot of people, and a lot of people here in the US especially, is that China may grow impatient, and especially with the authoritarian leader in Xi Jinping, and especially with other internal politics, dictators have politics too. We always seem to forget that.
Pause
There are people that might consider Xi weak for allowing the US to still defend Taiwan So this is sort of leading to and concerns that China gearing up for an invasion of Taiwan not imminently not anytime soon but soon enough The Chinese timeline, let's say, and I'm making this up, is like 20 years from now. Well, the American timeline and, of course, the Taiwanese timeline is never, never do that. OK, so Nancy Pelosi's visit is making a lot of people tense. Did she get approval for this trip from President Biden?
No, the opposite. Well, actually, not even the opposite. Biden didn't call her as far as we know and say, please don't go. What Pelosi heard was a lot of anger through the media about what U.S. officials were thinking. White House officials, oh, why would we start another fight when we've got the Russia-Ukraine thing going on and we don't want China to actually start helping Russia in that fight?
Pause
But what's been interesting, the administration stance has changed and changed in the sense that they're like, look, you know, if she's going to go, we're going to defend her. It's her right to go. You know, we're never going to list, you know, kowtow to what a Chinese leader is saying. You know, if she wants to go, we will not be intimidated. And this was said from the White House podium.
Pause
Put simply, there is no reason for Beijing to turn a potential visit consistent with longstanding U.S. policy into some sort of crisis or conflict or use it as a pretext to increase aggressive military activity in or around the Taiwan Strait. President Biden didn't want her to go. What about her Republican colleagues, many of whom share her hawkishness on China? What do they think about this?
They're delighted uh it's a you know big deal uh and then look let's not you know sure go this like it is a massive deal that she's going because what it shows is that it's you know the highest ranking democrat in decades to show up in taiwan and it's the highest ranking american to show up in you know since 1997 in taiwan and republicans like it because there has been sort of a shift in republican thinking on taiwan and i should say among some democrats as well but mostly republicans they don't like that the U.S. has what's called a strategic ambiguity stance towards Taiwan, which basically means that if China were to invade Taiwan, the U.S. is not going to signal what it's going to do, whether it's going to defend Taiwan or whether it's not.
Pause
You know, Republicans have told me, they've been very open about this, you know, we should get rid of this. Get it done. We will defend Taiwan is what they want. Like, why make it ambiguous? And that's not what Pelosi is going to Taiwan to say, as far as we know. But it does sort of show a level of closeness and integration that could lead eventually down the line to like, you know, why wouldn't we defend Taiwan? Are you willing to get involved militarily to defend Taiwan if it comes to that? Yes. You are? That's a commitment we made. And I should note, President Joe Biden has three times said the U.S. would defend Taiwan in case of an invasion, although his team has always walked it back.
Pause
Today, they insisted our policy has not changed and that the president is simply committed to provide Taiwan with the military means to defend itself, as he has in Ukraine. You know, it's sort of this fascinating moment where, you know, especially former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo was like, hey. She should absolutely go. And then you've had the former Defense Secretary Mark Esper, also for Trump, who was just there, basically to say, you know, the one China policy has outlived its usefulness. I think if the speaker wants to go, she should go.
Pause
So she's, again, not going there to back a Republican stance, but it's interesting that Republicans are backing her trip and Democrats are the ones who are sort of mostly worried about it. But I also want to reiterate, you know, Pelosi has bucked the Democratic Party for years on China. And mostly she's been a fierce advocate for small d democratic norms in that country for human rights. And that, you know, those issues have become increasingly problematic as Xi Jinping's leadership continues.
Pause
You know, the crackdown on Hong Kong, the detention, the forcible detention of Uyghurs in Xinjiang and his consolidation of power to the point that he could be leader for life. So, you know, her going to Taiwan in a moment when there's fear that eventually there could be an invasion. It's unsurprising that she feels that way and is doing this and that Republicans are backing her because she has been sort of on her hawkish stance for China more, I would say, on where Republicans have longer been than where Democrats are.
Pause
Noel King
Alex, do you think Taiwanese leaders feel that they're running a risk with this visit or are they happy to have Nancy Pelosi there, even though it's drawn a lot of it's drawn a lot of attention from China? I mean, a bit of both. I mean, I've talked to some Taiwanese officials and they are saying, look, you know, we're worried about what this means. There's no illusions that China is just going to sit this one out, right? They're expecting maybe missiles to be shot in the Taiwan Strait, near Taiwan itself. More planes, more ships near the island, perhaps some cyber attack or something. There's tons of possibilities.
Pause
So they're a bit fearful, right? It's not like this will just move on by. And of course, it's not like a war is going to break out because of this visit. But the chance of miscalculation rises and that doesn't make anyone feel good. But the other part of it is like, yeah, hell yeah, we're happy to have Nancy Pelosi here because it shows how close America and Taiwan are now. You know, how much the U.S. really does seem to care about the plight of Taiwan and sort of all those other things.
Pause
And it's sort of interesting because, you know, at the inauguration, Taiwan's lead representative, not ambassador, but lead representative to the U.S. showed up there, which was the first time in a while. And then in early 2021, the U.S. ambassador to Palau went to Taiwan, being the first U.S. envoy to be there since, you know, the U.S. changes policy in 1979. So there's been sort of a closer relationship now. And Pelosi going there is just basically the icing on the cake.
Pause
As Speaker Pelosi's plane landed in Taiwan, the Washington Post published an op-ed she'd written called Why I'm Leading a Congressional Delegation to Taiwan. Quote, In the face of the Chinese Communist Party's accelerating aggression, our congressional delegation's visit should be seen as an unequivocal statement that America stands with Taiwan, our democratic partner, as it defends itself and its freedom.
Pause
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards. These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars But with your rent frequently you just pay month after month You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head Not anymore says Built Rewards Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more.
Pause
Your home isn't just where you sleep. It's your community. And Built wants you to go out and do things in the community. You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Bilt members every month. When you're ready to travel, they say Bilt points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining Bilt.com slash Explained. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash Explained.
Pause
Let's be honest. Are you happy with your job? Like, really happy? The unfortunate fact is that a huge number of people can't say yes to that. Far too many of us are stuck in a job we've outgrown, or one we never wanted in the first place. But still, we stick it out, and we give reasons like, what if the next move is even worse? I've already put years into this place, And maybe the most common one, isn't everyone kind of miserable at work? But there's a difference between reasons for staying and excuses for not leaving. It's time to get unstuck. It's time for Strawberry.me. They match you with a certified career coach who helps you go from where you are to where you actually want to be.
Pause
Your coach helps you get clear on your goals, create a plan, build your confidence, and keeps you accountable along the way. So don't leave your career to chance. Take action and own your future with a professional coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer. That's strawberry.me slash unstuck.
Pause
Today Explained, we're back with Alex Ward. He's a national security reporter for Politico. Alex, what is China saying about Pelosi's visit to the U.S.? What is Xi Jinping saying to his own people? What is he DMing to Taiwan's leaders? What do we know for certain about how China feels here?
Alex Ward
So they're unhappy, right? So what they're planning, again, is some sort of increased aggression in the sense of missile strikes into the water, airplane incursion, ships, etc. But what they've been saying is like, look, in a call that we're told lasted more than two hours, Xi warned President Biden, those who play with fire will perish by it. It is hope that the U.S. will be clear eyed about this. And he says that a lot. It's a pretty abocative phrase, but Chinese state run media commentators have basically been threatening and right.
Pause
They take their cues from the leader and from the government like they would consider shooting down Pelosi's play. There's no real risk of that. Sorry, I should say no real risk. It's like 0.0001%. That would be a calamitous moment. But there is fear in the White House and elsewhere from what the Chinese are saying, that this is going to lead to short-term, perhaps medium-term escalation. And that's something no one can really afford at the moment, especially with the Russia-Ukraine thing going on.
Pause
So what China is basically saying is, you should have stopped her from going, Joe Biden. And the fact that you didn't is a signal to us that you really are trying to escalate this moment. Because, look, it's a Democratic Speaker of the House under a Democratic president. And, you know, whether or not we know that it's kind of hard for Biden to tell Pelosi what to do, that doesn't translate well elsewhere in the world. They go, OK, well, obviously, this is a signal, even a wink, wink signal.
Pause
So a very unhappy China about this event. What do China's threats about Taiwan actually mean? What has happened in the recent past that we might worry about? Well, I think we should first know that even though they might be sending signals to the U.S., it's mostly for domestic audience, right? We've got to remember where Xi Jinping is here. And I try to always emphasize dictators have politics, too.
Pause
So Xi Jinping has a party congress this fall, the 20th Communist Party Congress, in which he is both trying to finalize his forever rule and trying to get past some of his own policy preferences. And there are parts of that Communist Party that do not want him to lead for life and do also consider him weak. And how weak does this make Xi Jinping look if Nancy Pelosi lands in Taiwan, you know, weeks, months before that party conference? It is unsurprising then that Xi and his apparatus is putting out tons of messages, signaling strength, signaling they would shoot down the plane, you know, showing that they would do more military stuff.
Pause
If Speaker Pelosi visits Taiwan, said the Chinese foreign affairs spokesman, it would grossly interfere in China's internal affairs. Being quite, you know, boisterous about this visit. He warned the Chinese military would never sit idly by. And again, part of this is just sort of what happens in China, right? When something goes wrong, you show your strength, you roar a bit. But of course, the problem, everyone knows that China doesn't want at the moment of war with Taiwan because it doesn't feel like it's ready.
Pause
And it would basically shift the entire narrative of what China is trying to do, which is a quote unquote peaceful rise and could jeopardize its perhaps ultimate goal of being the world's top power, right, if it effectively launches World War III. So it is for the U.S., you know, in hopes of like, why not try to stop Pelosi from going? Especially if you do, you could make the Biden administration look weak. So that's a win-win.
Pause
But it is also mostly for the domestic audience of like, she is unhappy and he will respond strongly if this happens. So it's a bit of a dual game here. Why did Nancy Pelosi's plane go out of its way to avoid the South China Sea? Is this like polite symbolism? China wouldn't really shoot down Speaker Pelosi's plane, would it? Probably not. But like, why take the risk?
Pause
I think of it this way. I know it's not a perfect parallel, but like, but I've flown to Korea a lot. You know, we used to go over Russia, doesn't now. But there was always a moment when you came down over the Arctic through Russia. And the fastest way would be to go over North Korean airspace. The plane avoids it. You go around North Korea and then you land at the airport. Part of it of course is you know North Korea granted access to Korean Airlines So you know why take the risk Why go anywhere near that airspace So again not a perfect parallel but you know why even take that risk in South China Sea And or you trying to do a subtle signal that like hey I going to visit Taiwan I'm not here to be provocative towards you, China.
Pause
If China and Taiwan were to go to war, what would that look like? Basically, what you're looking at is, you know, China is going to look to obliterate Taiwan with just a barrage of missiles, even before any troops show. There are just so many missiles already pointed at Taiwan right on the other side of the strait. You know, you would take out large parts of Taipei, a lot of its own missile systems. And you also want to do that because it's a pretty treacherous, you know, 110 or so mile trip across the strait. And Taiwan has a lot of its missiles and advanced airplanes on its own.
Pause
So if you're China, you're basically trying to just sort of mow the grass, let's say, before you even set foot on Taiwanese beaches. And Taiwan is fortified in speeches already, but there are some of them that can be landed on. And so what most people have sort of come out to in terms of war games is China would very likely win. Of course, a lot depends on whether or not the US and Japan and other countries get involved, but even so, likely China would win, but not necessarily the victory we're all thinking about. They would probably take the northern part of the island. Taipei would probably still be in Taiwan's hands, But then you have a currently already dangerous situation made way more dangerous and way more fraught by having China right on the Taiwanese capital's doorstep and probably always threatening even more.
Pause
And that gives China even greater leverage over this issue, but frankly, global politics. Alex, would the U.S. get involved if China and Taiwan went to war? What do we know about this? The U.S. has a policy of strategic ambiguity. So we do not say whether or not we will defend Taiwan. even though we've given billions of dollars for Taiwan to defend itself. Like, that's basically our policy. You, Taiwan, defend yourself. We'll help you do so. But, you know, whether or not we will come to your defense will leave strategically ambiguous.
Pause
Now, President Joe Biden three times has said the U.S. will come and defend Taiwan. And each time his staff has walked back his comments saying the policy hasn't changed. He himself has said that. But, you know, when you on three occasions and you're the president kind of go, yes, it is our policy to defend Taiwan, that ups the ante. It's almost, you know, de facto changes the policy. You know, whether a future president sort of continues that or follows a strategic ambiguity since 1979, we don't know. It does feel right. It does feel like, you know, if it was 50-50 before, it's like 55-45 now that the U.S. would do so.
Pause
In which case, we're talking about really a massive conflict here, which would also bring in Japan, probably South Korea, other U.S. allies and who knows what else. It would be as close to World War III, if not World War III, than you'd ever see. What, Alex, is a war between China and Taiwan most likely to start over? Well, anything that could spark a miscalculation and lead to a mistrust between the U.S., Taiwan and China and Pelosi's visit isn't like the perfect thing for that. But it's darn close because it feels like, right, if you're in Beijing right now, you're going, again, you know, the second in line to the presidency, you know, after the president and the vice president themselves, it's a speaker of the House of the same party as the president going to Taiwan to basically go democracy, small d, you know, is good. Human rights is good. We stand by Taiwan.
Pause
Then you have Chinese military exercises in response to that because of Xi Jinping's own political needs. you know, he's got to act tough, which will then lead to some sort of perhaps stronger response from Taiwan and the US. And who knows, this could spiral out of control. That's sort of been the big issue here is that something small-ish causes a series of miscalculations and escalations that eventually leads to someone doing something very stupid and starts a war.
Pause
Again, I wouldn't say Pelosi's visit is it. We have precedent, right? Former Speaker Newt Gingrich was there in 1997. Tons of American lawmakers have gone to Taiwan. This isn't new. But the fact that China is responding so, you know, angrily to this could lead them to do something dumb, which leads Taiwan and the U.S. to do something dumb. And then everyone just sort of dumbs upwards into a war.
Pause
There has always been an inescapable tension at the heart of U.S. policy towards Taiwan. We recognize one China. China is the country with which we have relations. but we're still helping to defend this island that China wants to reintegrate to defend its it was always going to be a band-aid over an irreconcilable problem and so the reason it becomes such an issue is because you know it's a tinderbox right it's so fraught with danger it's there's so many potential pathways to miscalculation that the last thing you want to do was just sort of like the match. Pelosi going there isn't necessarily the match, right? But it is like her basically lifting, you know, taking the matchbook out of her pocket and going, hmm? So there's a reason everyone's sort of angry about this.
Pause
And especially with the time that we're in, like, do you really want to even risk a second bigger fight? Not that it's likely, but do you even want to risk it? And the problem with Pelosi's visit is that it does risk that unnecessarily.
Pause
Noel King
Today's show was produced by John Ahrens and Miles Bryan. It was edited by Matthew Collette and fact-checked by Laura Bullard, Tori Dominguez, and Amanda Llewellyn. The rest of the team includes Halima Shah, Hadi Mawagdi, Victoria Chamberlain, Avishai Artsy, and my co-host Sean Ramosferm. Our supervising producer is Amina El-Sadi. Thank you for the music, Breakmaster Cylinder and Noam Hassenfeld. We're distributed on public radio stations by WNYC. And here's a thought. If you like the show, rate us and review us on Apple Podcasts. If you don't like the show, Sean, what's your Gmail address? We'll get back to you. I'm Noelle King. Today Explained is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.