Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the complexities of the US-Mexico border and the experiences of a former Border Patrol agent, Francisco Cantu. Cantu shares his time working on the border, the culture of the agency, and the dehumanizing effects of the job.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm talking to Francisco Cantu. He's a former border patrol agent, and he mostly spent his time on the border patrolling the desert because every day people choose to risk their lives to cross it.
Francisco Cantu
Yeah, it didn't always used to be like that. What we have done since the 1990s is we've had this policy of enforcement through deterrence that has sought to build fences and heavily enforce crossing border crossing in the towns and cities, and in the sort of like flat, easy to cross parts of the border.
Sean Rameswaram
And what that has done has over time, like pushed crossings out into the most remote, dangerous, rugged parts of the border. And so, you know, like beginning in the 2000s, you start to see like hundreds of people dying in the desert every year.
Francisco Cantu
And that trend is a trend that continues. So last year, for example, the president and his administration bragged about the fact that border crossings were down to their lowest level in something like 14 years or even more.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, but what you didn't hear and didn't read about was the fact that deaths along the border actually went up from the year before. So although less people are crossing the border, that crossing is still becoming more dangerous.
Francisco Cantu
People will endure whatever version of hell you put in front of them when, you know, their family is on the other side.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm sure you encountered thousands of people in your years working as a Border Patrol agent. I'm wondering if one person sticks out as sort of an encounter you'll never forget.
Francisco Cantu
Yeah, I mean, one that really stands out to me, it was during those first weeks and months when I was, you know, allowed to like patrol out on my own. And one of the jobs that you're given as a junior agent is to just, you know, go pick people up who've been apprehended and bring them back to the station.
Sean Rameswaram
And so I was called to this village where a couple of people, you know, were knocking on people's doors, trying to get picked up. And it was a man and his wife. They had like fallen asleep in this little church.
Francisco Cantu
The woman was pregnant. Her husband sort of like really eagerly was telling me that she speaks English. And so I started talking to her in English. And it turned out she spoke perfect English with an American accent. She had grown up in Iowa. She went to high school there. She was a kindergarten teacher there.
Sean Rameswaram
And she had left Iowa when a family member died back in Mexico. And she had gone to care for them. But then when she got pregnant, she made the decision that she wanted her child to have the life that she had had, the opportunities that she had had.
Francisco Cantu
She had convinced her husband to cross, and she was telling me, it's my fault. I was the one who made the decision to cross. Her husband sort of asked me if I would kind of do them a solid. Can we skip the whole deportation thing? Can you just drive us back to the border?
Sean Rameswaram
You know, I said no, of course. I was like, this is my job. I have to take you guys in. I told them my name and I asked them for their names, like repeated their names out loud so that I would remember.
Francisco Cantu
And I sort of told them to be safe, to think about their child. And then a couple hours later, I was back on patrol, like back in the van, and I realized I had totally forgotten their names.
Sean Rameswaram
Looking back on it, you know, that stands out to me because I think that's one of the first steps in dehumanization, right? Is you forget someone's name, what makes them an individual?
Francisco Cantu
And this is what our rhetoric nationally does. When we read about migrants, we read about a wave of immigration, a tide, an uptick, as if like these individual people's lives can be plotted on a graph or something like that.
Sean Rameswaram
And that language encourages us to think of people as part of this indistinguishable mass.
Francisco Cantu
Now that you're years out of being in the border patrol, do you ever wish that you had done what her husband asked and just taken them back to the border or even just let them continue?
Sean Rameswaram
Man, I don't know. That's like, I try not to spend too much time thinking about what I could or should have done different, because I think that's already happened.
Francisco Cantu
So the question becomes, what do we do now? Do you feel like you know something now years out of this that like, oh, the easy fix to this is just this? Why don't we do this?
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, I think acknowledging the complexity and the humanity of this situation in and of itself is huge. And that's something that we have not done.
Francisco Cantu
You know, like if you live in Ohio and you've never been to the border, you've never really thought about it, and somebody's like, oh, yeah, like build a wall across this landscape that for you might as well be the ends of the earth. It's like the frontier of the nation. It's easy, right?
Sean Rameswaram
But it's not. We just had a huge conversation about immigration reform, but we didn't ever talk about the idea that there is a humanitarian crisis unfolding on our border that has been occurring over the course of many decades.
Francisco Cantu
You know, to me, that's the place to start. The place to start is saying it's unacceptable for people to lose their lives. That's the first thing that needs to be fixed.
Sean Rameswaram
Let's make sure that people stop dying on our doorstep and then we'll come up with the rest.
Francisco Cantu
I'm Francisco Cantu, and my book is called The Line Becomes River, Dispatches from the Border.
Sean Rameswaram
Before we bounce, we want to explain the gender wage gap on our show and we could use your help. If you've had an experience with unequal pay because of your gender, we want to hear your stories.
Francisco Cantu
So find a quiet place and record a short voice memo onto your phone. Send your stories to todayexplained at vox.com.
Sean Rameswaram
That is our email address, todayexplained at vox.com. Include your name, your age, where you live, and what you do. Thanks.
One last shout out to the Google Cloud Platform. Thanks for supporting our show.
Francisco Cantu
Google Cloud Platform wants to make your business work better with data. Go to g.co slash getcloudai to learn more.