Main Topic: The Oregon Senate Republicans have fled the state to avoid voting on a sweeping climate change bill, known as the cap-and-trade bill. This bill aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and is a priority for the Democratic governor and legislature.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Information:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Noel King
And I'm Noel King.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, we're talking about a landmark cap-and-trade bill in Oregon that's on life support after Republicans fled the state to avoid voting on it. Lauren Dick, you cover politics for Oregon Public Broadcasting. Lauren, thanks for joining us.
Lauren Dick
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
So, what exactly is happening in the Oregon state capitol right now?
Lauren Dick
The Oregon Senate Republicans have actually fled the state and are apparently in Idaho or Montana or other states in order to avoid a vote on a pretty sweeping climate change bill. It's a cap-and-trade bill.
Noel King
That's a big deal. Can you walk us through what this bill does?
Lauren Dick
Yeah, so the bill has long been a big Democratic priority. Republicans have voiced concerns about it for a long time. They felt like negotiations were not going well. So rather than vote on it, they have fled the state.
Sean Rameswaram
Wow. Republicans on the run. How did this happen?
Lauren Dick
Well, this has been a big Democratic priority for a long time. A lot of Democrats campaigned on getting this done. Then they had the supermajority in both chambers, so they thought, you know, it was definitely going to happen. Future generations will judge us not on the fact of global climate change, but what we've done to tackle it.
Noel King
And what's the stakes here? What happens if this bill doesn't pass?
Lauren Dick
Well, the bill made it to the House floor earlier this month. And then as it moved through the Senate, got closer to the Senate floor, negotiations broke down over there and the Republicans fled for Idaho.
Sean Rameswaram
What's the plan with fleeing the state? I mean, that can't really be like a long-term plan, can it?
Lauren Dick
I mean, I think the idea is that they are outside of the Oregon State Troopers jurisdiction. So they can't be as easily compelled to come back to the state Senate.
Noel King
Has anyone heard from these Republicans since they left town last week?
Lauren Dick
Yes, they are talking. One Senate Republican sent me a photo of a sunset over a lake from his cabin in Idaho. Just to show that, you know, they're in no hurry.
Sean Rameswaram
That's... quite a move. And what's the reaction from the governor?
Lauren Dick
Oregon's Democratic Governor Kate Brown has authorized Oregon State police troopers to search for those now missing Republicans and bring them back.
Noel King
That's interesting. Lauren, can you walk us through the chronology of how this happened?
Lauren Dick
This has been a big Democratic priority for a long time. A lot of Democrats campaigned on getting this done. Then they had the supermajority in both chambers, so they thought, you know, it was definitely going to happen. Future generations will judge us not on the fact of global climate change, but what we've done to tackle it.
Sean Rameswaram
And what's the state of play now?
Lauren Dick
The bill made it to the House floor earlier this month. And then as it moved through the Senate, got closer to the Senate floor, negotiations broke down over there and the Republicans fled for Idaho.
Noel King
And what's the impact on Oregonians?
Lauren Dick
Oregonians are very split, like the state in general. We have a real urban-rural divide here. There are a lot of rural Oregonians who are supporting this. Protesters gathered outside the state capitol again Sunday, opposing a sweeping cap-and-trade bill while supporting Senate Republicans on day four of the walkout.
Sean Rameswaram
That's a lot of tension. Lauren, thanks for walking us through this.
Lauren Dick
Thanks for having me.
Short pause
Sean Rameswaram
Umair Irfan, you write about energy and the environment here at Vox. Umair, thanks for joining us.
Umair Irfan
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
So, let's talk about the cap-and-trade bill. How would it work?
Umair Irfan
It would set effectively the second statewide cap on greenhouse gas emissions in the country set in law. Ever. The first was just last week, which was New York.
Noel King
That's a big deal. Can you explain how it works?
Umair Irfan
In a system like this, essentially we set a cap, a finite amount of greenhouse gas emissions that are allowed to be emitted. Now, if you exceed that cap, you have to buy a credit.
Sean Rameswaram
So, it's like a market-based system?
Umair Irfan
Yeah, it's a market-based way of controlling pollution. And that should kind of hint at the fact that this is something supported by free marketers, people like Republicans.
Noel King
And what's the goal here?
Umair Irfan
The idea is that over time, those credits are going to get more and more expensive. And so you can only buy your way out of the problem for so long. Eventually, you're going to have to make meaningful reductions in greenhouse gases.
Sean Rameswaram
That makes sense. And how important is this tool in the fight against climate change?
Umair Irfan
A lot of economists would say that one of the primary things, the sine qua non of fighting climate change is pricing greenhouse gas emissions. We have to create some sort of disincentive financially to pumping out carbon dioxide into the air.
Noel King
And what about the politics of this? Is this something that's supported by most people in Oregon?
Umair Irfan
It's been fairly high. I mean, remember, Democrats won the last election. Some of them campaigned on this issue and they won super majorities.
Sean Rameswaram
And what about the impact on Oregon's economy?
Umair Irfan
The bill, as structured, has a lot of carve-outs to try to mitigate the impact on individuals, specifically low-income people, to make sure that their electricity rates or heating rates don't go up too much.
Noel King
And what about the future of this policy? Will we see more states adopt cap-and-trade?
Umair Irfan
Yeah, I mean, Oregon is kind of an interesting case because, you know, it's not New York and California. New York and California are very big states with large populations and huge economies. Oregon ranks 27th in population. It's 38th in greenhouse gas emissions.
Sean Rameswaram
And what about Texas? Will we see them adopt something like this?
Umair Irfan
Texas does have a lot of momentum. They are the largest wind energy producer in the United States. But they also have a very large oil and gas sector, and they're pressing hard on both of those levers at the same time.
Noel King
And what about the federal government? Will we see them adopt something like this?
Umair Irfan
At the federal level, there's some momentum that's building. We've seen this happen with other policies as well where the federal policy kind of outpaces what happens at the states.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks, Umair.
Umair Irfan
Thanks for having me.
Short pause
Sean Rameswaram
The Skimm wants to help you be prepared for the debates. They've got all the candidates' resumes and their priorities for 2020 in one place. That place is theskimm.com slash debate. But guess what? Just a little twist. There's two Ms in Skimm. S-K-I-M-M dot com slash debate.
Noel King
And if you want to learn more about the Democratic debates, you can check out theskimm.com slash debate.
Sean Rameswaram
That's it for today's show. Thanks for listening.
Noel King
And thanks to The Skimm for supporting the show today.
Sean Rameswaram
Today Explained is a production of Vox. Our producer is [producer's name].
Noel King
And our editor is [editor's name].
Sean Rameswaram
If you want to support the show, you can subscribe to Vox on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Noel King
And if you have any feedback, you can email us at [email address].
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks again for listening.
Noel King
And we'll see you tomorrow.
Theme music starts playing