Podcast Episode Summary:
The podcast episode discusses the complex relationship between media mogul Rupert Murdoch and his children, particularly his eldest son Lachlan and his second son James. The episode explores how Rupert Murdoch's media empire, which includes Fox News, has been a significant player in shaping American politics and culture. The hosts, Sean Ramos and guests David Folkenflick and Oliver Darcy, delve into the history of the Murdoch family and their struggles for control of the media empire.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Murdoch has built a media empire that leads all the way to the White House. But nothing lasts forever. And at age 94, he finally has an official successor.
This episode was produced by Peter Balonon-Rosen and Denise Guerra, edited by Jolie Myers, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, engineered by Patrick Boyd and Adriene Lilly, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram.
Rupert Murdoch with his son Lachlan. Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images.
Listen to Today, Explained ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members. Transcript at vox.com/today-explained-podcast.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Discussion begins
Did you watch Succession on HBO? I loved that show. I would tell friends to watch it, but a lot of them would say, I tried, but I hated all the characters.
Pause
The funny thing about that, of course, is that Succession is loosely based on a real family. The kids fighting over who gets control of daddy's empire. Those are the Murdoch children, the older Murdoch children.
Pause
The unyielding mercurial patriarch who built an empire that none of his children truly deserve. That's Rupert Murdoch, of course. You'll remember Rupert from our show yesterday. We talked about his humble rise from Australian media to global media mogul.
Pause
On Today Explained from Vox, the chickens come home to roost. Or the children come home to fight over Fox. Or Rupert realizes he can't quite control the monsters he's made. Let's go with D, all of the above.
Pause
Support for the show today comes from Anthropic, the team behind Clawed. Today's news moves fast, but the most important stories deserve deeper thinking. Whether you're trying to understand the implications of a policy change or connecting dots across breaking stories, Clawed, your new AI collaborator, can help you go beyond the headlines.
Pause
Clawed doesn't just summarize the news. It helps you explore the context, analyze the patterns, and think through what it all means together. Try Clawed for free at clawed.ai slash today explained.
Pause
Support for this show comes from strawberry.me. Be honest. Are you happy with your job? Or are you stuck in one you've outgrown? Or never wanted in the first place?
Pause
Sure, you can probably list the reasons for staying. But are they actually just excuses for not leaving? Let a career coach from strawberry.me help you get unstuck. Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Pause
Oliver Darcy
A media analyst quoted earlier this year in the New York Times, quote, Rupert has his mojo back. Well, we have a lot of experience in producing newspapers and a lot of feeling about where they fit in the society, they do undoubtedly still carry a lot of influence.
Pause
I think probably not as much influence as politicians. Rupert is in a class by himself. He's an amazing guy. He's an amazing guy.
Pause
The one thing Murdoch has always wanted and never gotten was a bat phone in the White House, similar to what he has at 10 Downing Street, similar to what he typically had in Canberra in the prime minister's office in Australia.
Pause
He wanted a bat phone, and with Donald Trump, he got it. His relationship with Murdoch Media starts certainly years and years before he ever runs for president.
Pause
Donald Trump's obviously a creature of New York and has a long history planting stories with the New York Post. A source for a lot of their gossip reporting and often a source for their gossip about himself.
Pause
Because he's a bit of a gossip magnate himself. Marla boasts to her pals about Donald, quote, best sex I've ever had. Trump himself was the source for that.
Pause
And he was a fixture on Fox and Friends. I'm Donald Trump and you're watching Fox and Friends. And if you turn the channel, you're fired.
Pause
He used to have that weekly segment where he would call in and opine on everything under the sun. Donald, are you going to be doing that anytime soon? Well, I'm not so sure.
Pause
It doesn't look too good to me. I was talking about going shirtless. Well, shirtless I love, right? Shirtless I love. All right, let's talk about gaspers.
Pause
Can we move on now? Ben Rupert just has kind of an amused contempt for it. He thinks this is not a serious person.
Pause
My name is Oliver Darcy. I'm the founder and lead author of Status, which is a nightly newsletter covering the media industry.
Pause
My name is Dave Folkenflick. I'm the media correspondent for NPR News. I'm also relevant to this conversation, the author of Murdoch's World, The Last of the Old Media Empires.
Pause
Dave Folkenflick
As Donald Trump became a more serious candidate in the 2016 election, you certainly saw Rupert Murdoch's media empire start to scrutinize him more seriously.
Pause
Fox being Fox gets the first Republican debate, August of 2015. Megyn Kelly, who was an anchor at Fox News at the time, she asks Donald Trump about some of his previous statements.
Pause
You've called women you don't like fat pigs, dogs, slobs, and disgusting animals. Donald Trump does not like it.
Pause
Honestly, Megyn, if you don't like it, I'm sorry. I've been very nice to you, although I could probably maybe not be based on the way you have treated me, but I wouldn't do that.
Pause
He makes this debate about his debate with this woman, person representing the news industry, even though it's Fox, a friendly outlet.
Pause
And it changes the nature of the debate. Donald Trump retaliates against Fox News, and it leads to this conflict between Rupert Murdoch and Donald Trump.
Pause
You know, you could see there was blood coming out of her eyes, blood coming out of her wherever. Rupert Murdoch likes being in Trump's good graces because it's good for ratings, it's good for business, it's good for his bottom line.
Pause
And Donald Trump likes to be in the good graces of Fox because it's his most powerful megaphone. And he knows that a lot of people watch that channel.
Pause
A lot of his base watches that channel. And it's much better for Fox News to be in his corner than to be scrutinizing his actions.
Pause
Ultimately, they move past it. Rupert Murdoch and Donald Trump, they both realize that a symbiotic relationship is best for both of them.
Pause
Basically, Trump lit their ratings on fire. Trump is amazing television. So they are running pretty much everything he says live because they're so desperate not to miss anything he has to say or that people will turn elsewhere to wait for him.
Pause
But I'm sure Murdoch never thought Donald Trump would actually succeed in winning out in that GOP primary field and then becoming president.
Pause
Then he runs to the front of the line and pretends he was leading the parade all along. That's what Rupert Murdoch does.
Pause
The president of the United States, my friend Donald J. Trump. Rupert Murdoch speaks with the president several times a week.
Pause
Fox News and Donald Trump's first term unquestionably becomes a propaganda mouthpiece for Donald Trump. Trump policies are working for African Americans and the results are now beginning to come in 20 year old NAFTA deal It would not be renegotiated right now if not for Donald Trump
Pause
And they also know that he not a fascist he not a racist he not a bigot I think you almost see something that you have never seen in American politics, which is there is a channel on the air that is 100% committed to pumping propaganda on behalf of the president out to the masses in a way that's just unprecedented.
Pause
So Trump is delighted that Murdoch is sucking up to him. Largely speaking, these two are in tandem about messaging up until election night in 2020.
Pause
The Fox News decision desk is calling Arizona for Joe Biden. That is a big get for the Biden campaign. Are you 100 percent sure of that call and when you made it and why did you make it?
Pause
Absolutely. We made it after basically a half hour of debating, is it time yet? And that sets Donald Trump totally off.
Pause
This was a blow because he's being repudiated and declared to having lost, having lost, not just by a television station publicly, but by the one he expects to be in his quarter.
Pause
In real time, Donald Trump and his camp are calling Fox News, calling the Murdochs, demanding that they retract the call. And Fox News stands firm.
Pause
Trump starts attacking Fox and starts pointing people to watch Newsmax and even farther right, OAN.
Pause
And he's saying, you know, Fox is betraying you and betraying me. Fox is moving more and more to the losing wrong side in covering the Dems.
Pause
They got dumped from the Democrats' boring debates, and they just want in. They forgot the people. Millions of viewers bleed away. They just disappear.
Pause
And panic just consumes the top executives, the top talent. They are watching their ratings collapse, and they are wondering how they can turn this around.
Pause
And what you see is Fox News immediately do its best to win back its audience by putting its opinion talking heads, the people like Sean Hannity, Laura Ingram, out front and center.
Pause
They don't really seem to care about the risks of fraud and those possibilities. Some completely deny that fraud even exists.
Pause
And by the way, they are once again lying to you, the American people. I love these legal challenges because we have to get to the bottom of all this and expose fraud where it occurred.
Pause
And simultaneously, they soften their coverage immensely on Donald Trump. Well, they don't like the truth. Well, what can you do?
Pause
I talked about a rigged election, which it was 100% rigged. I mean, look at what happened in Wisconsin. As of tonight, tens of millions of Americans suspect this election was stolen from them.
Pause
That means we now live in a country where a large percentage of our population no longer believes that our democracy is real.
Pause
You know, Murdoch is clearly aware of what's going on, has no illusions about whether Biden won. You know, Fox's line that they settle on is, hey, the president of the United States is saying that there's fraud. It's newsworthy. It's inherently newsworthy.
Pause
He's the most newsworthy person in the country and the planet, and he's making claims about our constitutional system and the electoral process. We have to air that and we have to acknowledge that in our reporting.
Pause
And some of the personalities like Maria Bartiromo really embrace these conspiracy theories. And at the time, behind the scenes, top executives allowed them to take hold on their airwaves.
Pause
Sydney, we talked about the Dominion software. I know that there were voting irregularities. Tell me about that.
Pause
Let's put it mildly. Dominion Voting is now suing Fox for defamation over the cable channels, what they describe as bogus allegations of voter fraud in the 2020 election.
Pause
Court records unsealed Monday showed that Fox Corporation Chairman Rupert Murdoch acknowledged under oath that some Fox News hosts endorsed false claims that the 2020 U.S. presidential election was stolen from former President Donald Trump.
Pause
On the eve of trial, right before the trial starts, right before Rupert Murdoch has to testify in open court, they settle for $787.5 million.
Pause
OK, so Fox News went hard on election denialism, the big lie. They had to pay out a ton of money, almost $800 million for doing so. They fired Tucker Carlson.
Pause
It feels like a turning point for the network. But now Trump's president again, and he's littered his cabinet with Fox News talking heads.
Pause
Oh, he loves him something about people who appeared on TV, and he loves him when they look the part. These are central casting. If I'm doing a movie, I pick you, General.
Pause
In terms of his relationship with Rupert Murdoch, it has been at once very strong and strained.
Pause
You know, cutting the Murdochs in seemingly to ownership of TikTok, giving them an entree into social and new media for this legacy media company of Fox Corp.
Pause
You know, Trump is also suing Murdoch directly. You know, he sued The Wall Street Journal and Rupert himself for 10 billion bucks for their reporting that he had sent a letter two decades ago to Jeffrey Epstein for his birthday that was, you know, fairly sexually suggestive.
Pause
Donald Trump, in many ways, is an outgrowth of the media environment that Rupert Murdoch shepherded into reality, right? He is someone who just took it to the nth degree that no one else had been willing to go before.
Pause
But Rupert Murdoch should know that he is the one that created the structure that allowed Donald Trump to become who he is.
Pause
In Rupert Murdoch, he does not like Donald Trump's antics. Rupert Murdoch is not someone who is going to be a MAGA stan.
Pause
But Rupert Murdoch is also a very conservative man. And so he wants to make sure that his media empire, his conservative right-wing media empire that he has spent his entire lifetime building does not slip away into his liberal sons or liberal children's hands.
Pause
You know, at 94 years old, he's certainly thinking about his legacy and how to secure it.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Rupert Murdoch presents Succession on Today Explained momentarily From Pushkin Industries, I'm Jonathan Goldstein, and Heavyweight is back.
Pause
The new season is bigger than ever. Bigger hopes? I keep waiting for this moment when he says, Mom, I get it. I'm sorry. Bigger dreams. Tom Hanks wants to meet with you. This is a real chance. And bigger heartbreaks. I thought it would be my movie moment.
Pause
And maybe he would even whisper in my ear, I've always been in love with you. Check out new episodes of Heavyweight on Apple Podcasts.
Pause
What makes for a happy life? In 1938, scientists at Harvard started tracking the well-being of over 250 young people to figure that out. Now, almost 90 years later, the results are in.
Pause
There was learning. People who learned and read and read and read and liked to learn. They were much happier as they got older. People who were really good at managing their feelings.
Pause
But there was one thing that stood above all the rest. I'm Henry Blodgett, and this week on Solutions, I talk to bestselling author Arthur Brooks about the science of happiness.
Pause
Follow Solutions with Henry Blodgett for more wherever you get your podcasts.
Pause
Hey, Alex Heath here, founder of Sources.News and a contributor at The Verge. And I'm Ellis Hamburger, tech reporter turned industry insider, working closely with today's hottest AI startups.
Pause
We're excited to announce the launch of our new show, Access, with the Vox Media Podcast Network. Access is the tech industry's inside conversation with Silicon Valley's most influential leaders.
Pause
From the tech titans of today to tomorrow's most visionary builders. It's a show made by insiders for everyone who wants a glimpse into the future.
Pause
In our first episode, Alex interviewed Mark Zuckerberg about Meta's latest smart glasses, the AI race, and what's next for the social media giant.
Pause
I mean, didn't you just tell Trump you were going to spend like $600 billion? I did. Yeah, through 2028, which is... That's a lot of money. It is.
Pause
And if we end up misspending a couple of hundred billion dollars, I think that that is going to be very unfortunate, obviously. But what I'd say is I actually think the risk is higher on the other side.
Pause
You can find the AccessPod now on YouTube, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Pause
Where does the drama between Rupert Murdoch's white children begin? I think the best way to say this is that it becomes clear to Rupert that if he should die, there is a very decent chance that the more liberal children might take control of his media empire.
Pause
And if that were to happen, he fears that they would destroy it by moderating the news outlets, particularly Fox News. And he does not like this idea.
Pause
He said it's important that our properties remain conservative for the betterment of the country, but also for the financial fortunes of our holdings.
Pause
So James Murdoch initially was seen as the successor to Rupert Murdoch. Second son James, who had been a very good broadcast executive and satellite TV executive.
Pause
So he elevates James, and James by and large does really well until the tabloid hacking scandal. James Murdoch, who just a few years ago was very much at the center of the phone hacking scandal in Britain.
Pause
In response, Rupert Murdoch shut his beloved News of the World newspaper. He even got a pie in the face by a protester when he and son James were hauled before a parliamentary committee investigating phone hacking.
Pause
Rupert brings Lachlan back. The eldest boy. I'm the eldest boy! And says, come on, I need you by my side.
Pause
Lachlan had basically taken off for Australia in the early 2000s because he thought his dad wasn't sticking up enough for him, that he wasn't protecting him when Roger Ailes and other top executives were kind of sticking at him repeatedly behind his back.
Pause
And Murdoch said, hey, if you can't swim in the deep end, then you don't deserve to run the company.
Pause
Lachlan Murdoch does come back. And he then basically puts Lachlan and James in power together, setting them against each other in the most uneasy, publicly uneasy partnership you could imagine.
Pause
All right, media mogul Rupert Murdoch is preparing to step down as chief executive of 21st Century Fox, leaving his youngest son, James, to take over.
Pause
Lachlan Murdoch, the other son of Rupert Murdoch, will move from Sydney to Los Angeles, where he'll become executive chairman.
Pause
James and Lachlan Murdoch are expected to run the company as partners, even though James has the CEO title.
Pause
Murdoch really pitted James and Lachlan against each other from the outset. And that's kind of brutal. That was not necessary.
Pause
They are first and foremost competitors. And this just over the next decade just sours the point where, you know, James speaks out against what the News Corp newspapers are doing on climate change, on immigration.
Pause
On particularly January 6th and the 2020 elections. He walks away from the companies. James Murdoch, the son of media mogul Rupert Murdoch, has resigned from the board of News Corp.
Pause
He cited disagreements over editorial content at the company, which was founded by his conservative father. When he resigned from the News Corporation board, he blasted Fox.
Pause
My resignation is due to disagreements over certain editorial content published by the company's news outlets and certain other strategic decisions. Sincerely, James R. Murdoch.
Pause
He's accused the media empire of misinformation and of poisoning the public discourse, and he has not been shy about it.
Pause
As I've said in the past, and on the record, there's plenty of stuff on Fox News that I disagree with. Do you think there's ever a future in which you would go back to Fox News?
Pause
And I don't think so. I think they're off doing their own thing there. And so Lachlan Murdoch becomes chief executive officer of Fox Corporation, which is obviously the parent company to Fox News, and also News Corporation, which is the publishing arm that owns outlets like the Wall Street Journal and New York Post
Pause
And it becomes clear that he is going to be Rupert preferred son his chosen son In part because Lachlan is more cast in his image in part because Lachlan shares his ideological outlook
Pause
But there is this family trust where each of the siblings has an equal vote. The trust designed 25 years ago put the conglomerate which owns fox news the wall street journal the new york post and several international outlets in the hands of all of murdoch's four oldest children murdoch explaining this decision in a 2006 interview if i go under a bus tomorrow yeah um it'll be the four of them i have to decide uh which of the ones should lead them
Pause
The Murdoch Family Trust is an asset protection trust that holds the voting shares of Fox Corporation and News Corporation.
Pause
The reason that there was this trust was that when he was with his second wife, Anna Torv Murdoch, and left her, she was seemingly entitled to half of what he owned.
Pause
But she asked for a lot less than that. She said, but in exchange, I want you to ensure that their three children and one daughter from his first marriage be treated equally in the trust and have equal voting shares.
Pause
And they will have to work out together how to lead. And that way, nobody's screwed over. And so Murdoch says, fine, I will do this. It'll be an irrevocable trust.
Pause
And then he comes up through a couple years ago and says, I want to revoke it. Time and again, he has done this where what he promises, what he writes down, he doesn't live up to.
Pause
Murdoch tries to effectively oust his children from the trust. And this court case plays out and ultimately Rupert Murdoch does not win.
Pause
And the children are going to stay as members of the trust. But he was effectively able to buy the children out in a $3.3 billion deal.
Pause
Rupert did not want James coming back with his sisters or even one of his two sisters in a four-person boat and causing a stalemate as to what the direction of the company would be and causing a crack-up of it.
Pause
Rupert wanted his legacy cemented. And so the kids each got $1.1 billion. In exchange for rewriting the trust that will see them seed control and see Rupert Murdoch be able to get what he wants, which is Lachlan Murdoch on the throne in his death.
Pause
Rupert Murdoch, he doesn't know how to show love very well, aside from paying them off when they're upset.
Pause
James doesn't speak to his father or his brother anymore. James Murdoch in particular has effectively been outcast from the family.
Pause
There is a sort of winner-take-all mentality there. His two daughters, older daughters, decided to do this in part because they didn't want this clash and this resentment to define their last interactions with their father before his death.
Pause
I think Lachlan certainly from an ideological perspective will maintain his father's vision for Fox News and some of these other right-wing outlets, which is to be a counter in their eyes to what they would call the liberal mainstream media.
Pause
And he wants to take this company further to the right. Lachlan is not Rupert. Lachlan is not the political animal. He's not got the same sensibilities and inclinations.
Pause
He may not be quite as ruthless. Regardless of what you think about Rupert Murdoch, he is a strong businessman. And the question is whether Lachlan Murdoch can continue to make the business moves that is going to see Fox News and some of these other outlets live long into the future.
Pause
To me, there's like a human tragedy to this. Like Rupert Murdoch never set his children up to sustain each other. To love each other. To support each other. To take pride in each other.
Pause
He pitted them against each other. And I think that tells you in some ways something fundamental about who he is.
Pause
And I think you can see that in some ways in his publications and in the kinds of ways in which they frame stories, that the things are always sort of competition and confrontation and collision.
Pause
And he took us back to an age where news organizations were more nakedly partisan and more interested in the exercise of the power of their owners than a news report that could be accepted by all sides.
Pause
Rupert Murdoch's legacy will be leaving behind a world in which shared reality no longer exists and where a large portion, at least of the United States, believes in debunked conspiracy theories, believes in lies, has been trained to hate the other side.
Pause
These are the narratives that Rupert Murdoch's empire have helped promote for years and years to a very large audience.
Pause
When you see Donald Trump up at the White House podium behaving, frankly, like a madman trying to control speech, acting like an autocrat wannabe, that is a direct result of the way Rupert Murdoch treated him, but also the media reality that Rupert Murdoch gave birth to.
Pause
It's Rupert's world and we just live in it.
Pause
Thanks to David Folkenflick from NPR.org and Oliver Darcy from Status.News.
Pause
Thanks to Peter Balinon-Rosen for making our show today with Denise Guerra.
Pause
Thanks to Jolie Myers for editing with help on facts from Laura Bullard.
Pause
Thanks to Patrick Boyd and Adrian Lilly for mixing.
Pause
And thank you for listening. I'm Sean Rameswaram from this is Today Explained from Vox.
Pause
You can become a Vox member at vox.com slash members.
Pause
Easy enough. To further entice you, there's a deal right now in our membership. You can support shows like this one we brought you today for 30% less than what you would usually pay.
Pause
Plus, you won't have to listen to ads anymore. Easy enough. Vox.com slash members to join. The Wanderth