Main Topic: The episode discusses the Black Lives Matter protests in small towns, specifically in Bethel, Ohio, and how they were met with counter-protests and violence.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies. A powerful data structure adapts to your business model, syncs in all your contacts in minutes, and enriches your business with actionable data. Adio says it also allows you to create those email sequences, those real-time reports, those powerful automations, which they claim can help you build what matters most, your company. You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year. That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique, fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give first perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
We've done a lot of shows about the Black Lives Matter protests that swept the nation after the police killing of George Floyd. We've talked about how the police responded to protesters in major cities, the protests about the responses to the initial protests in those cities. We've talked about how governments are reforming police in those cities. But one thing we haven't really touched on is how this works in small towns. Small towns where there maybe aren't that many Black people, but that are still grappling with systemic racism. Towns like Bethel, Ohio.
Bethel is a town that's about a 45-minute drive from Cincinnati, Ohio. I think in some places people would think of it as like an excerpt, But from what everyone has told me, it does not feel like that. It feels like a rural place. This is Anne Helen Peterson. She's a culture reporter for BuzzFeed, where she wrote about one fateful protest in Bethel.
Anne Helen Peterson
So the town proper is 2,700-ish people. But then, you know, outside of the small village line, there are more people who consider themselves residents of Bethel. And there's the Village Proper, which is downtown area that has been there since the early 19th century. It has a bunch of churches. People say, like, there's about a church per person. But a lot of other things have been pretty hollowed out. Like, there used to be a normal grocery store, and now it's a discount grocery store that doesn't have good produce, that sort of thing. And there's, like, a bunch of gun shops and pawn shops.
In early June, this substitute high school teacher, Alicia Gee, was seeing that there were protests organized in small towns all around her. One thing she said to me was like, if Hazard Kentucky can ever protest, then we can ever protest. But she was very deliberate about thinking through what kind of gathering that they wanted to have. They wanted it to be a demonstration and solidarity of Black Lives Matter. They wanted to think of it as being a big tent to invite people who were all along the spectrum of, you know, defund the police to, you know, I just, I support working towards equality.
They wanted to go beyond just the handful of people that she already knew would be interested from her personal circle. So she decided to post it on the Facebook page that has kind of become a de facto community page since the local news has pretty much evaporated. And she was pretty scared about what would happen. She waited until later at night and then like posted some information about it and then went to bed and woke up in the morning. And there were just a ton of messages and comments about like, we don't need that here. like how dare you bring that here and a lot of it i think it's less to do with what the message of the protest was going to be and more to do with what people had seen largely on fox news about what these protests were which were violent conflagrations this is just one of hundreds of businesses that were looted vandalized or set ablaze over the past week the left psychotic so-called solution now to all the violence and all the anarchy and all the lawlessness and all the looting and all the arson and violence is, let's get rid of the police.
And so people, perhaps logically, given the information that they had consumed, thought that to have a Black Lives Matter protest meant to destroy your small town. So they were saying, you know, do not bring this here. And they also, there's a lot of assumptions that like, if you do ever protest, you have to import protesters or pay them. All of this is happening on Facebook. So one of the people who gets really mad about the threat of a protest is a guy named Lonnie Mead, who has also grown up in Bethel, went to high school with some of the people that were showing up to protest. And he started doing Facebook Live broadcasts asking people to show up to protect the town on Sunday. Sunday at 3 o'clock, they're supposed to be bringing Black Lives Matter. I want to tell you right now I hope everybody that feels like me I hope we outnumber those people 1 to 1 and not let that shit happen here in our little town of Bethel
On the actual day of the protest June 14th you have a couple dozen protesters who have shown up thinking that it going to be just a really docile maybe even boring event where they stand on the corner hold up their signs for an hour and, you know, maybe some people honk their horns at them or even throw a soda, but nothing really happens. And then what they actually encountered when people arrived in the downtown area of the village were hundreds and hundreds of bikers. You're in the wrong town. Hey, get this on your phone. This ain't Seattle. This ain't Seattle. We're not in a democratic state here. We don't put up with this shit. All lives matter here. This is a motherfucking Republican state. So you have, you know, just standing with signs on one side, a couple dozen people. And then you have hundreds of bikers yelling racial slurs, yelling, like, you know, all sorts of nasty things, telling them to go home, ripping up signs on the other.
Why are you shaking for it? Nervous? A lot of bikers had guns that they were carrying pretty openly, like AR-15s, large guns, handguns. But other people just brought bats, right? Like, someone brought a bag full of bats. There was anger that, you know, these protesters, they decided to stand their ground. They were like, we are just standing here with our signs. We're not going to leave. You're going to get your ass beat, dumbass! You're going to get your head cracked! It's really, really difficult to watch. I think especially anyone who grew up in a small town because it's just so easy to imagine that happening in your small town. It's just a dark, dark energy.
There's been a lot of criticism about how the police handled the situation because they essentially did not diffuse it in any meaningful way. But I honestly think the police were incredibly overwhelmed because they were there expecting, again, you know, a couple dozen people standing on the corner holding signs. And what ended up happening was so much bigger. But they did not intervene or arrest people who were tearing up signs. Sir, I just got punched in the back of the head. You know, even the man who came and sucker punched. This guy in the back of the skull, like, did not arrest this guy. The police were standing right there and watched it, and you can see that on tape. And I think, too, though, that when that happened, that was kind of like the point when the protesters were like, we've been here an hour, it's time to go home. People realized, like, it could have gotten a lot darker at that moment.
Can you paint a picture of what these protesters looked like? I mean, you hear a lot of racial slurs in the videos, but you don't really see any black people. It's a whole lot of white people, right? That's one of the things that you have to understand. You know, in a lot of these small towns, they've worked hard to center people of color in the community and let them lead and say, like, what matters to them, what the protests should look like, that sort of thing. But there's also a lot of places, and I think Bethel is one of them, where there just aren't a lot of people of color. There actually was a woman who is Black who was recording, and she was not there to be part of the protest, I think because she knew she would get menaced. So she actually was on the other side with the counter protesters, and so people started yelling the N-word at her. A lot of people said afterwards that the few people of color in the community who maybe would have shown up didn't really feel safe. Like they knew that maybe it wouldn't be the best place to be. And, you know, it turns out they were right.
I mean, considering small towns like Bethel are very white and only have a handful of people in their police force to begin with, why is it important to focus on what's happening in these small towns and what their protesters are saying? Well, I think one thing that a lot of people have told me that makes this time feel different is that, you know, it's not just Black people who are saying Black Lives Matter in the streets, right? It is a whole lot of white people who are also saying, you know, this is something, this is an idea that I agree with. I think that showing how national the movement is, that it's not a city thing, it's not a coastal thing, it's not a thing that is limited to Black people or a certain class of people, that is incredibly important to show just how widespread and popular, for lack of a better word, this movement is.
How comparable is what happened in Bethel on Sunday, June 14th to what have happened in other small towns across the country as they've tried to organize around this movement? In some ways, incredibly unique in terms of, like, exactly how many counter-protesters showed up and the confrontation between them. But at the same time, I think that it could have happened in many, many, many different towns. It could have easily happened in my hometown in Lewiston, Idaho, where 1 people showed up to protest But the protest was in a park along the river and all of the protectors were downtown If they had been in the same space it could have easily exploded
Sean Rameswaram
After the break, I'll speak to someone who's been trying to bring people together to better understand Black Lives Matter in Bethel. I'm Sean Ramos-Vurham. It's Today Explained.
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards. These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars. But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head. Not anymore, says Built Rewards. Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more. Your home isn't just where you sleep. It's your community. And Built wants you to go out and do things in the community. You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members every month. When you're ready to travel, they say Built points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining Built.com slash Explained. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash Explained.
Rachel Lamb
[background noise] Oh, that's definitely a background noise. Hold on. Is that your dog? Yeah, he's coughing. Hold on. Why don't we just have you start by saying, you know, your name and where you are and who your canine friend is and all that stuff?
Sure, absolutely. My name is Rachel Lamb. I am in Cincinnati, well, the outskirts of Cincinnati, Ohio. And my dog of eight years, he just turned eight, is named Freedom. My daughter of 12 years is named Liberty. So I have a theme going there. Thanks for letting us know.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, so, I mean, how close are you to Bethel?
Rachel Lamb
Claremont County is kind of an inner working of a bunch of small towns. And Bethel is actually right in between Batavia, where I live now, and New Richmond, where I grew up and went to high school. We intermingle a lot. But, you know, we all pretty much know each other and have events together. And Bethel is just kind of a part of my life and always has been.
Sean Rameswaram
As someone whose whole life is sort of centered around this town, what is your impression of why the protest in Bethel on June 14th went so poorly?
Rachel Lamb
Some of the comments that seem to be happening, not just from places like Bethel and New Richmond and Batavia here in Claremont County, but from rural America all over the place, you see this attitude of, oh, you better not bring the protests or the looting and the rioting to our town. We'll be ready for you. And that kind of became the country bumpkin mantra. Because small town America is not familiar with the language of protests, just because they don't happen there as often as they do in the big cities, they're not used to them. The two words, riot and protest, got conflated in people's heads.
So what did you do? I had planned a barbecue-style sit-down in the park. Like I said, the language of protests, they don't understand. But the language that they do understand is barbecues in the park, community events. You at least have to have coffee and donuts. And that is what we definitely had.
Wait a second, at a barbecue is coffee and donuts? Yeah, yeah. Well, it was day two. It was it was morning. It wasn't really it wasn't an evening time dinner. When we say the word barbecue, that basically just means get together, eat some food. So we got a bunch of donuts from the donut place in Bethel. We had hot coffee. We had snacks and we had water. And we had invited anyone who wanted to come. Our idea was that we were just going to sit down and kind of hear why people felt the way they did. There always some thought process to how this person got to saying all lives matter when people say black lives matter Why is that so important to you And then we explain why Black Lives Matter is so important to us
The only problem was that Bethel was still in a very raw state because of everything that happened. And I think everyone looked very kind of skeptically on our luring them in with donuts. They thought that it was just going to be another yelling with bullhorns across the street. So what it ended up turning into is a bunch of Black Lives Matter allies talking about how we can have conversations in our family units, in our friend units, at our jobs, if we hear or see racist things happening, to encourage people to start standing up, to start calling out that uncle or grandpa or friend that occasionally says racial slurs.
So I think that particular protest on June 14th in Bethel, as almost anyone who sees the video would agree, was sort of exceptional and perhaps got out of hand because of a lot of misinterpretation of what people were coming to Bethel to do that day.
Sean Rameswaram
I wonder, as someone who sort of initiated the conversations thereafter, what do you think is key to helping people think about what's going on right now in the country in a new way? And not having sort of these hangups about what they think Black Lives Matter might be about from, you know, I don't know, watching Fox News and hearing a lot of talk about Antifa.
Rachel Lamb
Here's the thing about small towns. One of the things that I heard so many times over and over again is, you're not from our town. Get out. You're not part of our community. Get out. And when someone said to them, hey, I've lived here 20 years. I'm absolutely a part of this town. The way the tension and the anger just melts away is probably surprising to people, but the small town talking to small town idea, that's what is going to work. It's a simple and obvious solution, but for some reason not used as often as it should be.
We've been taught for so many years, if you want to keep your friends, if you want to keep your family, don't talk about, I think it's politics, religion, or money, right? We've been bred to avoid difficult conversations. Have you had personal experience fostering progress by talking and listening to your own family, to your own neighbors in these small towns in Ohio?
Absolutely. In my own family unit, my aunt and uncle are very conservative socially. The first time that my partner was a black man, I had to have a lot of difficult conversations with a lot of my family members that did not believe in interracial dating. The one that really surprised me the most was my grandma. My grandma and grandpa, grandpa specifically, he was a racist, you know, and I shouldn't even try to sugarcoat it. And that's the thing is that we do that too often. We sugarcoat how bad it is because we love people.
When my grandpa died, my grandma held on to a lot of those same opinions. And I remember her saying to me that my boyfriend would never be welcome in her home. And I looked at her and I said, well, that's a real shame because I love him. And I would think that you loving me and me loving him, that you would be happy for me. And I walked out on the porch for a while. And within 10 minutes, she came outside crying and said, I do love you. And I am happy for you. And I'm sorry, these old ways are hard to kick, but I'll give it my best. if you want to bring them over.
And I'm not saying that every conversation would go that easily, obviously. But when you put it out there and you stand up and you tell them that they're wrong and you tell them in a way that involves, hey, I love you, but what you said was not the right thing to say. Or in friend groups, you know? Like, hey, man, none of us say that kind of stuff. Why do you have to be like that? You know, just simple statements like that can hang in a person's brain, and it can really make a big difference in possibly changing their mind.
Sean Rameswaram
Rachel well thank you for having this conversation with me and I really appreciate your time and give our regards to freedom and liberty
Rachel Lamb
I absolutely will I appreciate you showing interest I do. I do. I do.