Main Topic: The controversy surrounding lawmakers' ability to trade individual stocks and the bipartisan effort to ban this practice.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
Today, today, explain. A hearing tomorrow on Capitol Hill will probably command attention because, for once, Republicans and Democrats agree on something. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York thinks lawmakers should not be able to use insider information to game the stock market.
Pause
It's incredibly important that we ban the ability for members of Congress to direct trades in individual stock. Maybe unsurprising, but you know who agrees with her? Republican Matt Gaetz of Florida.
Pause
The fact that you've got populists from the widest ends of the political spectrum coming together to say, hey, look, why don't we just make a deal in this country that you're on one side or the other? You're on the lawmaking side or you participate in the stock market.
Pause
And I don't... Banning stock trades by lawmakers, possibly the one thing uniting the right and the left.
Pause
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp.
Pause
Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me. And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not.
Pause
Why don't you try betterhelp.com slash explained? Absolute truth. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise.
Pause
Find the one with BetterHelp. The one is not me, guys. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com slash explained.
Pause
That's betterhelp.com slash explained. Support for the show comes from Charles Schwab.
Pause
At Schwab, how you invest is your choice not theirs that's why when it comes to managing your wealth Schwab gives you more choices you can invest and trade on your own plus get advice and more comprehensive wealth solutions to help meet your unique needs with award-winning service low costs and transparent advice you can manage your wealth your way at Schwab visit schwab.com to learn more.
Pause
Dave Leventhal
Dave Leventhal, Deputy Washington Bureau Chief of Insider, you and your team have done a deep dive into stock trades by lawmakers. How did we get here?
Pause
We think of everything here in Washington, D.C. in terms of red and blue. And yet here is an issue where lawmakers have been bipartisan in two very important ways.
Pause
Number one, as you just noted, they have been bipartisan in their support of the notion that their fellow colleagues in Congress on Capitol Hill should not have the right to buy and sell individual stocks.
Pause
Well, I don't think members of Congress should be directly involved in trading. I think you should have to turn it over, as I have when I got into Congress, to a third party and not be able to give any direction on the buying and selling.
Pause
The flip side to that coin is that there has been bipartisanship in the violations that have taken place of a law known as the Stock Act, the Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act of 2012.
Pause
Lawmakers from both parties bought and sold stocks after receiving closed door COVID briefings before the pandemic began to rage.
Pause
Which exists to prevent financial conflicts of interest in Congress. The Stock Act makes it clear that if members of Congress use non-public information to gain an unfair advantage in the market, then they are breaking the law.
Pause
And provide transparency for the public to ensure that lawmakers are operating in the public's best interest as opposed to their own personal financial interest. That is a good and necessary thing.
Pause
What is the Stock Act, the thing that says you can't, you got to behave in certain ways? How does it work?
Pause
The Stock Act came about a little more than a decade ago when there had been some financial scandals in Congress.
Pause
Members of Congress who were accused of trading on insider information for their own personal gain so that they could basically make money off of information that they were privy to by virtue of them being a member of Congress, by them being elected to serve in power.
Pause
We know that during the health care debate, people were trading health care stocks. We know that during the financial crisis of 2008, they were getting out of the market before the rest of America really knew what was going on.
Pause
And because of that, there, in fact, was a sort of bipartisan outrage that came about, largely in part because of a report that 60 Minutes did.
Pause
While Congressman Backus was publicly trying to keep the economy from cratering, he was privately betting that it would, buying option funds that would go up in value if the market went down.
Pause
There was some other journalism around it to really show the depths of this phenomenon. So Congress decided to go ahead and pass this law, the Stock Act.
Pause
And what the Stock Act entails is that if you are a member of Congress, you can still trade stocks. But you would have to disclose, at least by congressional standards, your stock trades in a pretty rapid clip, within 30 to 45 days of making a trade, depending on the type of trade.
Pause
And what that was supposed to do is provide a great deal of transparency into the process. So, for example, if you served on a particular committee where you might be trading energy stocks, but having insider information about that, then you were supposed to disclose that in a way that would allow the public insight into your financial decision-making as a person.
Pause
Or for that matter, a spouse's financial decision-making, because it extended to members of Congress's family members, wives, husbands, dependent children.
Pause
And it also patently made illegal the notion of members of Congress engaging in insider trading. So that was basically said in the Stock Act that that was a total no-no, you can't do it, very, very clear.
Pause
And it was held by Barack Obama, president at the time, is really an elixir to the pre-existing problems. It shows that when an idea is right that we can still accomplish something on behalf of the American people and to make our government and our country stronger.
Pause
What was the punishment supposed to be if a lawmaker got caught doing insider training or if a lawmaker was not making their stock trades public in that set amount of time?
Pause
Well, I think it's important first to note that there seemed to be, at least at the moment that the Stock Act passed, a certain amount of trust that lawmakers felt like, all right, We've passed this bill. We've passed this law. And we're going to be fine now.
Pause
Everyone is going to be a professional. Everyone is going to be honorable. And we're going to go forward and not have the same types of trouble in the future that we had had in the recent past.
Pause
I mean, here's a case where a problem was identified that cut directly to the public's faith in their elected representatives. We dealt with it quickly and on a bipartisan basis in both houses of Congress.
Pause
So the penalties were not terribly onerous. So, for example, if you were late to filing that purchase of AT&T or that sale of Facebook, you might only get a fine of $200 that would be put forth by either the House or the Senate Ethics Committee.
Pause
Say you engaged in insider trading. That would be activity that would be potentially criminally prosecuted or investigated at the very least.
Pause
But what we have found with the Stock Act is that when it comes to proving insider trading by a member of Congress, it is incredibly difficult to come to that conclusion.
Pause
Members of Congress have easy alibis. They can go ahead and say, well, I am just clairvoyant. I got information from reading the news. I have not used any insider information. I'm just very good at stock trading.
Pause
Which is probably why, 10 years on, we have never had a criminal prosecution of a member of Congress under the Stock Act.
Pause
So at least the Stock Act, in this regard, has not lived up to its billing as something that was going to absolutely defend against conflicts of interest and punish members of Congress for insider trading.
Pause
Arguably, some of this stuff has taken place over the past decade, but it hasn't risen to the level where the Department of Justice has been able to say, absolutely, we are going to spend time and resources pursuing a member of Congress, and we are going to charge and indict them and go forward and try to send them to jail.
Pause
That just simply has not taken place.
Pause
Do you have a sense of how many lawmakers have violated the Stock Act in the past few years? Does anyone know?
Pause
Insider and other media organizations have found 59 members of Congress to be in violation of the Stock Act's disclosure provisions.
Pause
So we've had members of Congress who've been, in some cases, months or even years late, past the deadline that they themselves have set for themselves and their congressional colleagues.
Pause
And have done so to the tune of hundreds of thousands and even millions of dollars worth of combined trades that were late.
Pause
So what's the problem here? Well, the problem is that if the public doesn't have access to that information, the public cannot make a judgment on whether a member of Congress is engaging in a conflict of interest.
Pause
So the disclosure provisions of the Stock Act are only as good as the compliance by the members of Congress.
Pause
If members of Congress don't comply with the Stock Act's disclosure provision, it kind of becomes a house of cards that falls apart very quickly.
Pause
And at this moment in time, that's very much where we're at.
Pause
Effectively, we have one in 10 members of Congress, more than that at this juncture, engaging in illegal activity as it relates to the disclosure provisions of the Stock Act.
Pause
All right. So it's like one in 10 plus members of Congress not following the law, the law that they wrote.
Pause
What's the most egregious example you came across of a lawmaker seeming to be using inside information to buy and sell?
Pause
At the dawn of the pandemic, so we're talking February of 2020 right now, Richard Burr, senator from North Carolina, Republican, he had basically dumped about $1.6 million worth of stock in that month.
Pause
But he didn't warn the public. He didn't even disavow an op-ed he'd written just 10 days before claiming America was, quote, better prepared than ever for coronavirus.
Pause
He didn't do any of those things. Instead, what did he do? He dumped his shares in hotel stocks so he wouldn't lose money.
Pause
And then he stayed silent. And it was right before the stock market crashed. It was right before the country entered the teeth of the pandemic.
Pause
And reporting by ProPublica and other news organizations have indicated in the months since that he had not only just dumped that stock by himself that he owned, but he had also called his brother-in-law.
Pause
According to the court documents, on February 13, 2020, immediately after he spoke to Senator Burr on the phone and immediately after Senator Burr had directed his own broker to liquidate his own joint IRA portfolio, the brother-in-law appears to have directed the sale of several stocks.
Pause
This led to ultimately a federal investigation into whether Richard Burr was using inside information to make personal stock decisions.
Pause
And he wasn't the only one. Senator Dianne Feinstein of California. She has been contacted by the FBI confirming that Feinstein answered questions from the FBI about stock trades that her husband made.
Pause
Senator Kelly Loeffler. The Daily Beast found that Senator Kelly Loeffler of Georgia sold off seven figures worth of stock after a private senator's briefing on the coronavirus.
Pause
She also bought up to a quarter million dollars of stock in a company that offers teleworking software.
Pause
Senator David Perdue. Records show that Perdue didn't sell nearly that much, but he did purchase between $63,000 and $245,000 worth of stock in Pfizer.
Pause
So the pandemic really proved to be kind of a flashpoint for members of Congress and trading stocks in the sense that we saw a flurry of activity around that time.
Pause
So you can see from that that it's sort of a tapestry of permissibility, that almost anything still goes in Congress, and that even if you do something that at least at its face or in the public's eye would seem really, really bad, lawmakers aren't too terribly concerned about anything beyond just maybe having a news article or two written about them.
Pause
And you know lawmakers really don't have to care about a whole lot in terms of real hard penalties.
Pause
So we know that they're buying and selling. You got lots of data on that. Are they actually doing well, though? Are they getting rich or richer?
Pause
There have been studies and indications, some academic, won by an outfit called unusual whales that have indicated that, yes, actually they have been doing much better than, say, the S&P 500 or the Dow Jones Industrial Index.
Pause
In essence, they're beating the market. And now that's not true in every case. It's not true for every lawmaker. But it's definitely true for some to a point where it is most curious.
Pause
And that's really the crux of the concern here, that so long as it's legal for members of Congress to buy and sell individual stocks, the possibility, the specter of them using insider information is going to factor in full or in part to decisions that they make financially speaking.
Pause
Noel King
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime.
Pause
Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Pause
So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Pause
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals.
Pause
Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Pause
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained.
Pause
That's Chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress.
Pause
Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Pause
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs.
Pause
Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Time checking account required.
Pause
Support for this show comes from Macy's.
Pause
It's almost fall, and that means it's time to cycle your wardrobe to the cold setting. Because while everyone loves a breezy summer outfit, let's be real. Layering is even more fun.
Pause
That's why Macy's Fall Fashion Guide has everything you need to piece together the perfect look for you. It's your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
Pause
Add a statement shoe to your collection, like the calf-hair loafers from Steve Madden.
Pause
Or tap into your romantic side, with flowy dresses from Cece and sheer pieces from INC.
Pause
You can even throw in some textural layers for contrast, like a faux fur bomber jacket from Karl Lagerfeld Paris.
Pause
Whether your old favorite sweater or coat is on its last threads, or you're just craving a new vibe to switch things up, Macy's has got you covered this season.
Pause
Find the perfect layering pieces for you by exploring the Macy's Fall Fashion Style Guide.
Pause
Shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
Pause
Dave Leventhal
Okay, here's where we stand. We have 59 members of Congress who are making suspicious trades or who are not reporting their stock trades on time as they should be according to the law.
Pause
And the question is, how do we fix that? So what we have right now are a number of different bills and even a couple of resolutions that would address this very issue.
Pause
And I should note that back in December, Insider produced a project called Conflicted Congress.
Pause
There were more than two dozen stories, and it really shed a lot of light on the situation.
Pause
So there had been a couple of bills sponsored by Representative Abigail Spanberger, a Democrat from Virginia, for example.
Pause
It's not just enough to know what members are buying or selling. It's that they shouldn't be buying or selling.
Pause
Chuck Roy, who was her Republican co-sponsor. None of this would stop you from being able to engage in free enterprise and the free market and being able to continue to hold your investments.
Pause
All we're saying is put in a blind trust or be in broadly traded index funds.
Pause
You had Senator Mark Kelly, a Democrat of Arizona, Josh Hawley, Republican of Missouri, John Ossoff, a Democrat freshman of Georgia, getting on board with their own bills.
Pause
Democratic Senator John Ossoff just released a bill tonight that would force lawmakers to put their assets into a blind trust or pay a fine of their entire salary.
Pause
Each bill kind of had a little bit of a different take. Some want to ban members of Congress and only members of Congress from trading stocks.
Pause
Others want to extend that ban to family members.
Pause
It eludes me as a possibility that someone would say to the American people, oh, no, no, no, no. My spouse makes all his own decisions.
Pause
Ignore the fact that when a pandemic's starting, he's buying stocks and insert pharmaceutical company name.
Pause
Some have suggested that members of Congress should invest their finances in exchange-traded funds or mutual funds or government bonds, something that is going to be a lower risk and definitely tamp down any possibility that a member of Congress would be buying or selling an individual stock because they had specific knowledge about that company or about the industry in which that company operated.
Pause
So it's unclear at this point whether lawmakers are going to be able to coalesce around one particular route here.
Pause
But it is incredibly, insanely rare in this day and age for Democrats and Republicans to agree on anything.
Pause
So the fact that they are at least in principle getting behind this notion that members of Congress should not be able to engage in stock trading activity in the same way that they do right now is just simply notable in and of itself.
Pause
We just don't see this in Washington, D.C. in 2022.
Pause
But with this particular issue, we do see it.
Pause
This is why I so obsessed with this story because almost nothing is bipartisan But this is bipartisan which has actually made me wonder the lawmakers that you mentioned is there something unique to those lawmakers the ones who are proposing the changes versus the lawmakers who are saying I really like to keep my privileges
Pause
Maybe you guys could just shut up about it
Pause
The one thing that they have in common is that they are not House or Senate leaders in the Democratic Party.
Pause
The leadership of the Democrats, and of course, the Democrats control at this point in time both the House and the Senate, the leaders of the Democratic Party and the House and the Senate have been very reluctant, if not straight up resistant to changing the status quo.
Pause
When we asked Nancy Pelosi at a press conference, should lawmakers be able to engage in individual stock trading? She said, this is a free market and people, we are a free market economy, they should be able to participate in that.
Pause
And this was coming from Nancy Pelosi, who has been turned into the ultimate meme trader of Congress by folks on TikTok and Twitter and whatnot.
Pause
And would you look at that, literally clockwork. The U.S. government has an agreement to purchase a supercomputer from who else? NVIDIA. Yup, NVIDIA, the one. Yup. The one that Nancy bought back on 7-23-21 in that tweet.
Pause
The news comes out literally yesterday, like 8-24-21. She knew.
Pause
And you would have known if you followed her portfolio on Iris.
Pause
We asked Senate leadership. They were very quiet on this.
Pause
But after about a month of getting a ton of heat from both sides, the far left, the far right, and in the not so far left and the far right, you saw Democratic leadership begin to get squeezed.
Pause
And you began to see that they were in a pretty difficult situation where this issue of members of Congress and their trading of stocks was not going away.
Pause
So ultimately, Nancy Pelosi first said, well, I will let a House committee look into this issue of penalties not being doled out in the way that they should.
Pause
And then about a week later, she went a step further, which was very surprising to a lot of people who had been following this to say, I'll actually let a committee go forward and look at advancing legislation that would address this issue.
Pause
I do believe in the integrity of people in public service. I want the public to have that understanding.
Pause
We have to do this to deter something that we see as a problem, but it is a confidence issue.
Pause
And if that's what the members want to do, then that's what we will do.
Pause
When Nancy Pelosi came out so publicly in defense of the status quo, it gave an incredible amount of fuel to those who have been talking about this issue for a good long while now.
Pause
People like Senator Elizabeth Warren, people like Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who said that this should be just simply illegal.
Pause
And then it also gave Republicans of a certain stripe a great opportunity to go and beat up Nancy Pelosi, who, of course, likes to fashion herself as a very moralistic leader of the House.
Pause
So you saw plenty of Republicans go and start beating her up on this.
Pause
Well, what I'm wondering is why we're in the fourth year of Nancy Pelosi being speaker. And why is this being done now?
Pause
This should have been done on day one.
Pause
Oh, yeah. Suddenly she's a big advocate of the free market when we're talking about enriching and padding her wallet as opposed to standing with the small businesses that she's destroying with all of her crony capitalism.
Pause
And it gave other politicians opportunities to say, all right, we're going to do the right thing here. We've got an opportunity to make right. This is this is something that that should not be controversial and that we truly can be bipartisan about this.
Pause
Do you think any of these bills will become law?
Pause
I think it's possible. The fact that you do have members on both sides not only talking about it, but talking to each other, which is a small but subtle but incredibly important detail that leads Capitol Hill observers, especially that I've talked to, to believe that if anything is going to have a chance to be truly bipartisan on Capitol Hill in Congress in 2022, that this may be the thing.
Pause
And that it could actually happen sooner rather than later.
Pause
Noel King
Dave, it depends on what polls you look at, but polls show that a majority of Americans, sometimes it's 60 some odd percent, sometimes it's 70 plus percent, do not think that lawmakers should be allowed to buy and sell stocks.
Pause
And Americans hardly agree on anything in those kinds of numbers.
Pause
Do you have any reflections on why there is this one thing that we seem to agree on across partisan lines?
Pause
When you look at those polls, what's striking about them is there is hardly any statistical difference between the way that Democrats and Republicans and independents feel about this, just a handful of percentage points.
Pause
So the vast majority of Americans, regardless of where they fall on the political spectrum and how they would answer any type of other political question about, say, Donald Trump or about Nancy Pelosi or about any issue facing the country, mask mandates, abortion, you name it, they're all basically on the same page when it comes to this issue.
Pause
And members of Congress are not blind to that. They read these polls, they understand these polls, and they understand the truth from these polls, which is that if they are supporting the status quo, if they're saying, hey, there's nothing to see here, we don't have to worry about this issue, this is just a whole lot of nothing and being blown out of proportion, then they are out of step with the way that the body politic feels on this issue.
Pause
So this is definitely a policy-focused issue that has incredible political implications and it's all beginning to swirl together in a pretty tight spiral at a time when even though some Democrats would like it to go away, it doesn't appear that it's going to at least anytime soon.
Pause
Today's show was produced by Hadi Mawagdi, edited by Matthew Collette, engineered by Efim Shapiro, and Fact Checked by Laura Bullard and Tori Dominguez.
Pause
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained.