Main Topic: The National Rifle Association (NRA) is facing a crisis after a tumultuous annual convention, where a power struggle between CEO Wayne LaPierre and President Oliver North came to a head. The NRA is also under investigation by the New York Attorney General for financial abuses and disclosure problems.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
There wasn't anything to watch on TV last night or to go see in the cinema this weekend, right? So everyone hung out at home and watched Hulu's all-new original series Rami, right? Right? Okay, well, if not, all new episodes of Rami are now streaming only on Hulu. You still have a chance.
Pause
In recent days leading democrats have proposed banning new guns and confiscating existing guns from law abiding citizens what they don't tell you is the bad guys aren't giving up their guns and you're not going to be giving up your guns either. The NRA that you know and love or hate wasn't always this divisive. The National Rifle Association was founded in 1871 by two guys who just wanted to promote marksmanship. One of them worked for the New York Times.
Pause
The modern-day NRA has grown out of two major changes within the organization. One was a big overhaul at an annual convention in 1977, where they shifted their focus to politics and lobbying. And the other was hiring an ad agency called Ackerman McQueen to focus on that shift shortly thereafter. What makes those two changes super interesting right now is that the NRA kind of face-planted this weekend at an annual convention because of that ad agency.
Pause
We're talking about claims of extortion, financial scandal, major power struggle between two icons of the conservative movement and one party walking out. Mark Maramont is a senior editor at the Wall Street Journal, and I asked him just how bananas this convention in Indianapolis was this weekend.
Mark Maramont
Sean, I've been covering companies and nonprofits for many years, and this was the craziest thing I have ever seen. At the heart of this shit show is the power struggle between Wayne LaPierre. Wayne LaPierre is the CEO and what they call executive vice president of the NRA, and he's been running the gun rights group for about 30 years. The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun. And he's credited with essentially helping turn the NRA from a grassroots gun safety organization many years ago into a powerful advocacy group and, of course, a political force.
Pause
So he's the inside face of the NRA. And then there's Oliver North. Oliver North is a retired Marine lieutenant colonel. Many years ago, he played a significant role in the 1980s Iran-Contra scandal. He's since become a kind of conservative darling, and he's a very high-profile figure. And about a year ago, in fact, he became the president of the NRA.
Pause
Look, all we do in the NRA is to defend freedom, but we're a convenient target when crazies go off and do things like school shootings. I guess it's worth reminding people that the NRA is a not-for-profit, and anyone who has not-for-profit experience knows that there's infighting and financial difficulties in not-for-profits. But what made this different? Well, a couple things. One is that membership was down. I think 2017 was the lowest since 2012.
Pause
And the organization, in a sort of irony, its finances became a little bit more constrained after President Trump was elected because members were a little less concerned that a potentially Democratic Clinton administration might, quote, take away their gun rights. So there's been tighter budgets at the NRA.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So what happens once this meeting begins? What happens at the convention? Oliver North, from what we have been able to gather, asked Wayne LaPierre to resign. He basically told Wayne LaPierre in a phone call to Wayne LaPierre's assistant that if he did resign, that this Ackerman McQueen ad agency was prepared to release some accusations of financial improprieties and some travel expenses abuses and a sexual harassment allegation against the top NRA officer
Pause
And North eventually told the board of those new allegations, and one of them included that Wayne LaPierre had received about $275,000 worth of free suits and other clothing from vendor. We believe the vendor was Ackerman McQueen. Obviously not too flattering to Wayne LaPierre, but LaPierre fired back instead of resigning. He fired back with a letter accusing North of blackmailing him essentially or extorting him.
Pause
The power struggle within the National Rifle Association has come to a breaking point. The group's president, Oliver North, says that he will not return for a second term in office. In a letter, the retired Marine Lieutenant General wrote that he had hoped to be renominated for a second term as president, but was, quote, informed that would not happen.
Pause
This comes two days after the CEO and the face of the NRA, Wayne LaPierre, sent a note to the organization's board. So the convention ends yesterday on Sunday. Where does that leave the organization? The New York Attorney General, Letitia James, on Friday launched an investigation into the NRA's tax-exempt status, particularly these financial abuses and disclosure problems and some political activity issues, according to a document that she sent the NRA.
Pause
So it's a pretty important and significant move, and it definitely threatens the NRA. In fact, President Trump this morning tweeted that the New York Attorney General was, quote, illegally targeting the NRA and trying to destroy it. And he called on the group to get its act together, essentially.
Pause
You know, all this is not really very good for the NRA. They may say that they're sort of moving on business as usual, but the other question is how the members react to some of these allegations. Do you as a member want to donate your hard-earned money to a group that's buying Wayne LaPierre $275,000 worth of free suits? The NRA says that the wardrobe is justified because he does a lot of TV appearances and speeches, which is probably true.
Pause
But there may be other allegations that come out. I think that things definitely have not settled down yet. In fact, they're probably just beginning. All right, so we're all up to speed on the convention this weekend. Now we're going to have to talk about the ad agency. But we're going to do it after an ad.
Pause
I'm Sean Ramos for him. This is Today Explained. There's a show out there on the Hulu. It's called Rami. It's all about the real life experiences of a first generation Muslim comedian named Rami Youssef. All of the episodes are streaming on Hulu right now. If you want a little taste of what it sounds like, I found this clip of comedian Rami Youssef talking to his parents in the show.
Pause
I don't know if it's like that Aziz show where his parents are played by his actual parents, but we can all watch it together and find out. Anyway, here's the clip.
Clip plays
No, I'm not going to go work for him. I don't care about diamonds or selling watches or whatever. I want to do something that I'm actually passionate about. Passion is a made-up idea. It's for white people.
Pause
Rami, the series explores what it's like to be caught between an Egyptian community that considers life a moral test and a millennial generation that thinks life has little to no consequences. All episodes are now streaming only on Hulu.
Pause
Mike Spies, you've been covering all these NRA developments for The Trace and The New Yorker. How did this very successful nonprofit get to this very vulnerable place?
Mike Spies
In many ways, the NRA has been very successful despite itself. It benefited greatly from this mythology that it the sort of awesomely powerful organization when in reality I don really think it is
Pause
There is a complete unawareness of the great divergence between the lives that are being lived by the average NRA member and even the average NRA staffer, and then the NRA executives and their top vendors and contractors. This movement has made them very rich. And over the last couple decades, one thing that's become sort of institutionalized at the NRA is that there is a real culture of greed and self-dealing and secrecy.
Pause
What kind of secrecy? I don't think members fully understand the NRA's current financial situation and how it got there. It's been running deficits. In 2017 alone, it had to borrow millions of dollars from its foundation. It's frozen pensions. It's laid people off.
Pause
The NRA is saying that this has happened because it's fallen into the clutches of state regulators in New York with whom they're currently engaged in a lawsuit. In reality, you know, we've got the NRA's longtime public relations firm, Ackerman McQueen. The ad agency.
Pause
Yeah. What's fascinating about it is that it's, on the one hand, it's been so important for the organization. That relationship built the modern NRA. On the other hand, it's also the leading factor in its financial demise.
Pause
So what exactly is the relationship between the NRA and this ad agency, Ackerman McQueen? It's generally really difficult to sort of decipher where the NRA ends and Ackerman McQueen begins and vice versa.
Pause
Roughly a quarter of the NRA staff is managed by former Ackerman McQueen employees. There are all these sweetheart deals for former senior NRA employees who retire. Then they become consultants. They get contracts that are worth tens of thousands of dollars a month. Plus, they get several hundred thousand dollars at the end of the year in bonuses. They also are spending several hundred thousand dollars in expenses.
Pause
And we're ultimately talking about hundreds of millions of dollars having gone out the door. I mean, in 2017 alone, the NRA paid Ackerman McQueen and its affiliates more than $40 million.
Pause
The NRA employees have, like, beater cars in the parking lot. The Ackerman staff, you know, pull up, like, with Lexuses. The fruits of this relationship are really evident.
Pause
And what exactly is the NRA getting in exchange for all that cheddar? Ackerman McQueen, among many things that it has done for the organization, is responsible for the vast majority of its messaging. So much of the time when you think that you're interacting with the NRA, you're really interacting with Ackerman McQueen.
Pause
Currently, the most prominent example of that is NRA TV. Most people are pretty familiar with people like Dana Lash. I'm a mom. And just like millions of other women, that's why I own guns. We're responsible, we're law-abiding, and we're everything that makes America strong.
Pause
What they do not know is that Dana Lash is actually paid by Ackerman McQueen, not the NRA. The videos that you've seen that circulated widely, especially after Donald Trump was elected, in which Dana Lash, you know, threatened the New York Times or talked about the clenched fist of truth.
Pause
That's all Ackerman McQueen. They use their movie stars and singers and comedy shows and award shows to repeat their narrative over and over again. The only way we stop this, the only way we save our country and our freedom is to fight this violence of lies with the clenched fist of truth. I'm the National Rifle Association of America, and I'm freedom's safest place.
Pause
Does the NRA rubber stamp these videos? Do they get circulated amongst, I don't know, executives at the NRA? Or is it just, do they just have carte blanche to make whatever kind of messaging they want?
Pause
It does operate on its own. One thing you'll hear from folks who work in the NRA's lobbying division is that they particularly have no oversight with respect to anything Ackerman McQueen does
Pause
So what often happens is Ackerman McQueen messaging specifically I should say NRA TV messaging acts at cross purposes with the NRA lobbying efforts. Like it'll step on their toes and they complain about it all the time.
Pause
After Sandy Hook, for example, when Wayne LaPierre finally came out and said, we think the solution is to put armed police officers in schools. And the response to that was that Ackerman McQueen put out a very controversial ad targeting President Obama's children. Are the president's kids more important than yours? Then why is he skeptical about putting armed security in our schools when his kids are protected by armed guards at their school?
Pause
At the same time, quietly, the NRA's federal lobbyists had been speaking with lawmakers because they assumed they were going to have to make some concessions in the wake of such a horrible and devastating event. When that ad ran, lobbyists got calls from furious lawmakers, just couldn't believe that the NRA would run that.
Pause
And were saying, if we were going to work with you in any capacity, you know, on post-Newtown legislation, it's done. So after years of provocation, this relationship is now on the fritz.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
To boot, there's this investigation from the New York Attorney General. How much worse could things get for the NRA? Things could get a lot worse for them. The IRS ultimately could take away the organization's tax-exempt status if it was justified.
Pause
What would that mean for the NRA? Well, then it would just cease to exist. Really? I'm actually telling you what the NRA said in its own words. The NRA has recently filed a lawsuit against Ackerman McQueen. And it's essentially saying Ackerman McQueen's practices have jeopardized our non-profit status, placing blame on them, not at all in itself.
Pause
And it says very directly, our nonprofit status is what allows us to exist. It's gone and we're effectively, we're gone too. Mike, I'm trying to reconcile the fact that the NRA is at once so messy, so close to broke and so powerful and influential in America. Help me out here.
Pause
Mike Spies
One part is the NRA has always had something specific going for it, which is that there's a deep history in this country that revolves around gun culture, which is real. And then the second thing is its messaging is just predicated on the idea that there is this ongoing fight between coastal elites and real Americans who are self-reliant.
Pause
They take care of themselves. They take care of their families. They hunt their own food. And they do all this with the most essential tool, which is a gun. For those who buy into it, that narrative gives their lives great meaning. I mean, it's not so different than religion.
Pause
And do these so-called real Americans care that Wayne LaPierre is buying $200,000 suits and throwing money at this greasy ad agency? Even within the gun community, if you will, there's a lot of suggestion that they're taking this very seriously, that they're not just writing it off as like a hit piece.
Pause
But if you've organized your life around something, I think no matter what, it's really hard to turn away from it. Because if that thing is the centerpiece of your life, then, you know, what are you left with? Wrestling with that, if you really wanted to, could bring on a real crisis of identity.
Pause
One way in which the NRA has sort of preempted all negative reporting and defends itself is just by continuously telling its members that it is under attack from coastal elites. And if you're already subscribing to that message, you could certainly view this reporting through that prism and you don't have to deal with it.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
One last reminder that there's only like three episodes of Game of Thrones left. One of those dragons is going to sit on the Iron Throne and then you'll have nothing to watch ever again, except for Hulu's all new original series, Rami, based on the real life experiences of Muslim American comedian Rami Youssef. Check it out. It's streaming now.