Main Topic: The Case Against Masks in Schools and the CDC's Communication Failures
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Supporting Organizations:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
I'm Sean Rameswaram from Today Explained. And I'm sure you've noticed that we've reached the point in this pandemic where ideas that used to seem unscientific or fringy are now being discussed more seriously or even accepted by the large majority of us. That lab leak theory, that was a total conspiracy until maybe not. Those cloth masks will do the trick until maybe not. Schools should remain closed. Well, probably not. Or maybe even kids shouldn't wear masks at school anymore.
For two years, having kids learn masked, not really seeing their teachers' faces or their friends' faces, this is likely not going to be a no-cost intervention. You know, we're seeing some anecdotal evidence start to pop up that masks are exacerbating speech delays. It's harder for language acquisition. It impedes social emotional skills and facial recognition. They're obviously harder to communicate in.
This is Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson. She's an infectious disease scientist based in Maryland. If this is a layer that we can eliminate because it's not backed up by robust data, we should. We shouldn't have to wait for the data to be collected about the harms to eliminate this if it's simply just not backed up by data that it's significantly reducing spread.
It's worth noting here that almost half the country isn't waiting. They've gone ahead and lifted school mask mandates if they ever had them to begin with. And those places with unmasked kids, they got just as much COVID as places with kids wearing masks.
Dr. Smelkinson recently joined forces with a few fellow doctors to make an argument directed at all those places that still have mask mandates in schools, the blue states. They wrote the case against masks at schools for The Atlantic, and we asked her to make the case on the show today.
We started with the data. This year, nearly half of school districts don't have mask mandates. So we're actually able to make these comparisons between districts with and without masking. And controlling for things like community transmission and vaccination rates and demographics. And again, we're seeing very little difference in case rates in schools between schools that have masking and those that have optional policies.
There were a couple of other CDC studies this year that were conducted in the early fall. Everyone 12 and up had eligibility for vaccines. And they actually did show that masking did reduce spread. But these studies were very heavily flawed. They didn't control for vaccination rates. And when these studies were conducted, breakthroughs were very rare, unlike now.
But, you know, back when these studies were conducted, controlling for vaccination rates when looking at cases was a huge confounder because areas with higher vaccination rates had less spread everywhere, including schools. And those areas also tended to have more mask mandates. So it wasn't really fair to conclude that it was masks reducing spread in school when it was much more likely that it was lower rates of transmission in the communities with higher vaccination rates.
Okay. For example, one of the studies, almost all of the schools that were mask optional were in the district with lower vaccination rates. So it was much more likely that it was that causing the increase in spread in those schools.
I see. Areas that had mask mandates usually had other measures in place, especially in the beginning of the pandemic, you know, areas that implemented mask mandates earlier typically had more business closures, limits on gatherings, more, you know, cautious behavior, and just, you know, tighter lockdowns. And so it may have been these other things that were driving case rates down and not specifically masking.
But at this point in the pandemic, we're two years in, We really need robust evidence that these interventions are working and that they outweigh the harms. And mask mandates at school at this point, especially with children now eligible for vaccination, it just doesn't meet the standard.
So you would argue that there is no clear evidence that shows that masking in schools at this point in the pandemic is making a big enough difference for the CDC's current guidelines?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
I would say that if there is a benefit at this point, it's not outweighing any potential harms. There's some countries that never mask students. Several countries in Scandinavia never mask students or teachers. And there's many more countries that follow the WHO, which only masks kids under 12 very sparingly, and they don't mask kids under five.
Sean Rameswaram
And I just want to say that in the UK, they typically don't mask kids under 12. So this is really just at the secondary level. The CDC, in contrast, they don't make any distinctions. They just say everyone two and up in schools has to mask all the time.
And what would you say to someone out there who's maybe got an immunocompromised grandmother at home and they're scared that if their kids go to school unmasked, they might bring home COVID and get grandma sick?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
We have to look at the data. And if the masks haven't really been that effective, then this is going to happen anyway with our current policies.
Sean Rameswaram
There have been calls for some people to use better high-quality masks. And I don't think that this is reasonable to mandate this for kids. There's not really data that they're going to work much better in a school setting, particularly how our kids wear masks. They're generally less comfortable. They do have to be tightly fitted.
So it's not really appropriate to mandate this. But for those high-risk individuals that want the heightened protection or live with someone that is high-risk, they can wear a higher quality mask that fits tightly to the face. They can learn how to fit tested and make sure it's tight. And that's where this idea of one-way masking comes in, where you can wear a mask and be protected without having to rely on everyone else taking the same level of precautions.
In your article in The Atlantic, The Case Against Masks in Schools, you don't really spend too much time focused on the politics at hand here. But I mean it impossible to ignore that basically what you saying is that all of those red state politicians and all of those you know vigilant and in some cases even borderline violent anti-maskers were kind of right about something here.
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
When you're a scientist or public health official, you have to evolve your stance. My stance has even evolved. And in the beginning, it made sense to support masks. We didn't have vaccines. We had to really do whatever it took to limit spread.
Sean Rameswaram
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
I'm Sean Rameswaram from Today Explained. And I'm sure you've noticed that we've reached the point in this pandemic where ideas that used to seem unscientific or fringy are now being discussed more seriously or even accepted by the large majority of us.
That lab leak theory, that was a total conspiracy until maybe not. Those cloth masks will do the trick until maybe not. Schools should remain closed. Well, probably not. Or maybe even kids shouldn't wear masks at school anymore.
For two years, having kids learn masked, not really seeing their teachers' faces or their friends' faces, this is likely not going to be a no-cost intervention. You know, we're seeing some anecdotal evidence start to pop up that masks are exacerbating speech delays. It's harder for language acquisition. It impedes social emotional skills and facial recognition. They're obviously harder to communicate in.
This is Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson. She's an infectious disease scientist based in Maryland. If this is a layer that we can eliminate because it's not backed up by robust data, we should. We shouldn't have to wait for the data to be collected about the harms to eliminate this if it's simply just not backed up by data that it's significantly reducing spread.
It's worth noting here that almost half the country isn't waiting. They've gone ahead and lifted school mask mandates if they ever had them to begin with. And those places with unmasked kids, they got just as much COVID as places with kids wearing masks.
Dr. Smelkinson recently joined forces with a few fellow doctors to make an argument directed at all those places that still have mask mandates in schools, the blue states. They wrote the case against masks at schools for The Atlantic, and we asked her to make the case on the show today.
We started with the data. This year, nearly half of school districts don't have mask mandates. So we're actually able to make these comparisons between districts with and without masking. And controlling for things like community transmission and vaccination rates and demographics. And again, we're seeing very little difference in case rates in schools between schools that have masking and those that have optional policies.
There were a couple of other CDC studies this year that were conducted in the early fall. Everyone 12 and up had eligibility for vaccines. And they actually did show that masking did reduce spread. But these studies were very heavily flawed. They didn't control for vaccination rates. And when these studies were conducted, breakthroughs were very rare, unlike now.
But, you know, back when these studies were conducted, controlling for vaccination rates when looking at cases was a huge confounder because areas with higher vaccination rates had less spread everywhere, including schools. And those areas also tended to have more mask mandates. So it wasn't really fair to conclude that it was masks reducing spread in school when it was much more likely that it was lower rates of transmission in the communities with higher vaccination rates.
Okay. For example, one of the studies, almost all of the schools that were mask optional were in the district with lower vaccination rates. So it was much more likely that it was that causing the increase in spread in those schools.
I see. Areas that had mask mandates usually had other measures in place, especially in the beginning of the pandemic, you know, areas that implemented mask mandates earlier typically had more business closures, limits on gatherings, more, you know, cautious behavior, and just, you know, tighter lockdowns. And so it may have been these other things that were driving case rates down and not specifically masking.
But at this point in the pandemic, we're two years in, We really need robust evidence that these interventions are working and that they outweigh the harms. And mask mandates at school at this point, especially with children now eligible for vaccination, it just doesn't meet the standard.
So you would argue that there is no clear evidence that shows that masking in schools at this point in the pandemic is making a big enough difference for the CDC's current guidelines?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
I would say that if there is a benefit at this point, it's not outweighing any potential harms. There's some countries that never mask students. Several countries in Scandinavia never mask students or teachers. And there's many more countries that follow the WHO, which only masks kids under 12 very sparingly, and they don't mask kids under five.
Sean Rameswaram
And I just want to say that in the UK, they typically don't mask kids under 12. So this is really just at the secondary level. The CDC, in contrast, they don't make any distinctions. They just say everyone two and up in schools has to mask all the time.
And what would you say to someone out there who's maybe got an immunocompromised grandmother at home and they're scared that if their kids go to school unmasked, they might bring home COVID and get grandma sick?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
We have to look at the data. And if the masks haven't really been that effective, then this is going to happen anyway with our current policies.
Sean Rameswaram
There have been calls for some people to use better high-quality masks. And I don't think that this is reasonable to mandate this for kids. There's not really data that they're going to work much better in a school setting, particularly how our kids wear masks. They're generally less comfortable. They do have to be tightly fitted.
So it's not really appropriate to mandate this. But for those high-risk individuals that want the heightened protection or live with someone that is high-risk, they can wear a higher quality mask that fits tightly to the face. They can learn how to fit tested and make sure it's tight. And that's where this idea of one-way masking comes in, where you can wear a mask and be protected without having to rely on everyone else taking the same level of precautions.
In your article in The Atlantic, The Case Against Masks in Schools, you don't really spend too much time focused on the politics at hand here. But I mean it impossible to ignore that basically what you saying is that all of those red state politicians and all of those you know vigilant and in some cases even borderline violent anti-maskers were kind of right about something here.
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
When you're a scientist or public health official, you have to evolve your stance. My stance has even evolved. And in the beginning, it made sense to support masks. We didn't have vaccines. We had to really do whatever it took to limit spread.
Sean Rameswaram
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
I'm Sean Rameswaram from Today Explained. And I'm sure you've noticed that we've reached the point in this pandemic where ideas that used to seem unscientific or fringy are now being discussed more seriously or even accepted by the large majority of us.
That lab leak theory, that was a total conspiracy until maybe not. Those cloth masks will do the trick until maybe not. Schools should remain closed. Well, probably not. Or maybe even kids shouldn't wear masks at school anymore.
For two years, having kids learn masked, not really seeing their teachers' faces or their friends' faces, this is likely not going to be a no-cost intervention. You know, we're seeing some anecdotal evidence start to pop up that masks are exacerbating speech delays. It's harder for language acquisition. It impedes social emotional skills and facial recognition. They're obviously harder to communicate in.
This is Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson. She's an infectious disease scientist based in Maryland. If this is a layer that we can eliminate because it's not backed up by robust data, we should. We shouldn't have to wait for the data to be collected about the harms to eliminate this if it's simply just not backed up by data that it's significantly reducing spread.
It's worth noting here that almost half the country isn't waiting. They've gone ahead and lifted school mask mandates if they ever had them to begin with. And those places with unmasked kids, they got just as much COVID as places with kids wearing masks.
Dr. Smelkinson recently joined forces with a few fellow doctors to make an argument directed at all those places that still have mask mandates in schools, the blue states. They wrote the case against masks at schools for The Atlantic, and we asked her to make the case on the show today.
We started with the data. This year, nearly half of school districts don't have mask mandates. So we're actually able to make these comparisons between districts with and without masking. And controlling for things like community transmission and vaccination rates and demographics. And again, we're seeing very little difference in case rates in schools between schools that have masking and those that have optional policies.
There were a couple of other CDC studies this year that were conducted in the early fall. Everyone 12 and up had eligibility for vaccines. And they actually did show that masking did reduce spread. But these studies were very heavily flawed. They didn't control for vaccination rates. And when these studies were conducted, breakthroughs were very rare, unlike now.
But, you know, back when these studies were conducted, controlling for vaccination rates when looking at cases was a huge confounder because areas with higher vaccination rates had less spread everywhere, including schools. And those areas also tended to have more mask mandates. So it wasn't really fair to conclude that it was masks reducing spread in school when it was much more likely that it was lower rates of transmission in the communities with higher vaccination rates.
Okay. For example, one of the studies, almost all of the schools that were mask optional were in the district with lower vaccination rates. So it was much more likely that it was that causing the increase in spread in those schools.
I see. Areas that had mask mandates usually had other measures in place, especially in the beginning of the pandemic, you know, areas that implemented mask mandates earlier typically had more business closures, limits on gatherings, more, you know, cautious behavior, and just, you know, tighter lockdowns. And so it may have been these other things that were driving case rates down and not specifically masking.
But at this point in the pandemic, we're two years in, We really need robust evidence that these interventions are working and that they outweigh the harms. And mask mandates at school at this point, especially with children now eligible for vaccination, it just doesn't meet the standard.
So you would argue that there is no clear evidence that shows that masking in schools at this point in the pandemic is making a big enough difference for the CDC's current guidelines?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
I would say that if there is a benefit at this point, it's not outweighing any potential harms. There's some countries that never mask students. Several countries in Scandinavia never mask students or teachers. And there's many more countries that follow the WHO, which only masks kids under 12 very sparingly, and they don't mask kids under five.
Sean Rameswaram
And I just want to say that in the UK, they typically don't mask kids under 12. So this is really just at the secondary level. The CDC, in contrast, they don't make any distinctions. They just say everyone two and up in schools has to mask all the time.
And what would you say to someone out there who's maybe got an immunocompromised grandmother at home and they're scared that if their kids go to school unmasked, they might bring home COVID and get grandma sick?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
We have to look at the data. And if the masks haven't really been that effective, then this is going to happen anyway with our current policies.
Sean Rameswaram
There have been calls for some people to use better high-quality masks. And I don't think that this is reasonable to mandate this for kids. There's not really data that they're going to work much better in a school setting, particularly how our kids wear masks. They're generally less comfortable. They do have to be tightly fitted.
So it's not really appropriate to mandate this. But for those high-risk individuals that want the heightened protection or live with someone that is high-risk, they can wear a higher quality mask that fits tightly to the face. They can learn how to fit tested and make sure it's tight. And that's where this idea of one-way masking comes in, where you can wear a mask and be protected without having to rely on everyone else taking the same level of precautions.
In your article in The Atlantic, The Case Against Masks in Schools, you don't really spend too much time focused on the politics at hand here. But I mean it impossible to ignore that basically what you saying is that all of those red state politicians and all of those you know vigilant and in some cases even borderline violent anti-maskers were kind of right about something here.
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
When you're a scientist or public health official, you have to evolve your stance. My stance has even evolved. And in the beginning, it made sense to support masks. We didn't have vaccines. We had to really do whatever it took to limit spread.
Sean Rameswaram
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
I'm Sean Rameswaram from Today Explained. And I'm sure you've noticed that we've reached the point in this pandemic where ideas that used to seem unscientific or fringy are now being discussed more seriously or even accepted by the large majority of us.
That lab leak theory, that was a total conspiracy until maybe not. Those cloth masks will do the trick until maybe not. Schools should remain closed. Well, probably not. Or maybe even kids shouldn't wear masks at school anymore.
For two years, having kids learn masked, not really seeing their teachers' faces or their friends' faces, this is likely not going to be a no-cost intervention. You know, we're seeing some anecdotal evidence start to pop up that masks are exacerbating speech delays. It's harder for language acquisition. It impedes social emotional skills and facial recognition. They're obviously harder to communicate in.
This is Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson. She's an infectious disease scientist based in Maryland. If this is a layer that we can eliminate because it's not backed up by robust data, we should. We shouldn't have to wait for the data to be collected about the harms to eliminate this if it's simply just not backed up by data that it's significantly reducing spread.
It's worth noting here that almost half the country isn't waiting. They've gone ahead and lifted school mask mandates if they ever had them to begin with. And those places with unmasked kids, they got just as much COVID as places with kids wearing masks.
Dr. Smelkinson recently joined forces with a few fellow doctors to make an argument directed at all those places that still have mask mandates in schools, the blue states. They wrote the case against masks at schools for The Atlantic, and we asked her to make the case on the show today.
We started with the data. This year, nearly half of school districts don't have mask mandates. So we're actually able to make these comparisons between districts with and without masking. And controlling for things like community transmission and vaccination rates and demographics. And again, we're seeing very little difference in case rates in schools between schools that have masking and those that have optional policies.
There were a couple of other CDC studies this year that were conducted in the early fall. Everyone 12 and up had eligibility for vaccines. And they actually did show that masking did reduce spread. But these studies were very heavily flawed. They didn't control for vaccination rates. And when these studies were conducted, breakthroughs were very rare, unlike now.
But, you know, back when these studies were conducted, controlling for vaccination rates when looking at cases was a huge confounder because areas with higher vaccination rates had less spread everywhere, including schools. And those areas also tended to have more mask mandates. So it wasn't really fair to conclude that it was masks reducing spread in school when it was much more likely that it was lower rates of transmission in the communities with higher vaccination rates.
Okay. For example, one of the studies, almost all of the schools that were mask optional were in the district with lower vaccination rates. So it was much more likely that it was that causing the increase in spread in those schools.
I see. Areas that had mask mandates usually had other measures in place, especially in the beginning of the pandemic, you know, areas that implemented mask mandates earlier typically had more business closures, limits on gatherings, more, you know, cautious behavior, and just, you know, tighter lockdowns. And so it may have been these other things that were driving case rates down and not specifically masking.
But at this point in the pandemic, we're two years in, We really need robust evidence that these interventions are working and that they outweigh the harms. And mask mandates at school at this point, especially with children now eligible for vaccination, it just doesn't meet the standard.
So you would argue that there is no clear evidence that shows that masking in schools at this point in the pandemic is making a big enough difference for the CDC's current guidelines?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
I would say that if there is a benefit at this point, it's not outweighing any potential harms. There's some countries that never mask students. Several countries in Scandinavia never mask students or teachers. And there's many more countries that follow the WHO, which only masks kids under 12 very sparingly, and they don't mask kids under five.
Sean Rameswaram
And I just want to say that in the UK, they typically don't mask kids under 12. So this is really just at the secondary level. The CDC, in contrast, they don't make any distinctions. They just say everyone two and up in schools has to mask all the time.
And what would you say to someone out there who's maybe got an immunocompromised grandmother at home and they're scared that if their kids go to school unmasked, they might bring home COVID and get grandma sick?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
We have to look at the data. And if the masks haven't really been that effective, then this is going to happen anyway with our current policies.
Sean Rameswaram
There have been calls for some people to use better high-quality masks. And I don't think that this is reasonable to mandate this for kids. There's not really data that they're going to work much better in a school setting, particularly how our kids wear masks. They're generally less comfortable. They do have to be tightly fitted.
So it's not really appropriate to mandate this. But for those high-risk individuals that want the heightened protection or live with someone that is high-risk, they can wear a higher quality mask that fits tightly to the face. They can learn how to fit tested and make sure it's tight. And that's where this idea of one-way masking comes in, where you can wear a mask and be protected without having to rely on everyone else taking the same level of precautions.
In your article in The Atlantic, The Case Against Masks in Schools, you don't really spend too much time focused on the politics at hand here. But I mean it impossible to ignore that basically what you saying is that all of those red state politicians and all of those you know vigilant and in some cases even borderline violent anti-maskers were kind of right about something here.
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
When you're a scientist or public health official, you have to evolve your stance. My stance has even evolved. And in the beginning, it made sense to support masks. We didn't have vaccines. We had to really do whatever it took to limit spread.
Sean Rameswaram
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
I'm Sean Rameswaram from Today Explained. And I'm sure you've noticed that we've reached the point in this pandemic where ideas that used to seem unscientific or fringy are now being discussed more seriously or even accepted by the large majority of us.
That lab leak theory, that was a total conspiracy until maybe not. Those cloth masks will do the trick until maybe not. Schools should remain closed. Well, probably not. Or maybe even kids shouldn't wear masks at school anymore.
For two years, having kids learn masked, not really seeing their teachers' faces or their friends' faces, this is likely not going to be a no-cost intervention. You know, we're seeing some anecdotal evidence start to pop up that masks are exacerbating speech delays. It's harder for language acquisition. It impedes social emotional skills and facial recognition. They're obviously harder to communicate in.
This is Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson. She's an infectious disease scientist based in Maryland. If this is a layer that we can eliminate because it's not backed up by robust data, we should. We shouldn't have to wait for the data to be collected about the harms to eliminate this if it's simply just not backed up by data that it's significantly reducing spread.
It's worth noting here that almost half the country isn't waiting. They've gone ahead and lifted school mask mandates if they ever had them to begin with. And those places with unmasked kids, they got just as much COVID as places with kids wearing masks.
Dr. Smelkinson recently joined forces with a few fellow doctors to make an argument directed at all those places that still have mask mandates in schools, the blue states. They wrote the case against masks at schools for The Atlantic, and we asked her to make the case on the show today.
We started with the data. This year, nearly half of school districts don't have mask mandates. So we're actually able to make these comparisons between districts with and without masking. And controlling for things like community transmission and vaccination rates and demographics. And again, we're seeing very little difference in case rates in schools between schools that have masking and those that have optional policies.
There were a couple of other CDC studies this year that were conducted in the early fall. Everyone 12 and up had eligibility for vaccines. And they actually did show that masking did reduce spread. But these studies were very heavily flawed. They didn't control for vaccination rates. And when these studies were conducted, breakthroughs were very rare, unlike now.
But, you know, back when these studies were conducted, controlling for vaccination rates when looking at cases was a huge confounder because areas with higher vaccination rates had less spread everywhere, including schools. And those areas also tended to have more mask mandates. So it wasn't really fair to conclude that it was masks reducing spread in school when it was much more likely that it was lower rates of transmission in the communities with higher vaccination rates.
Okay. For example, one of the studies, almost all of the schools that were mask optional were in the district with lower vaccination rates. So it was much more likely that it was that causing the increase in spread in those schools.
I see. Areas that had mask mandates usually had other measures in place, especially in the beginning of the pandemic, you know, areas that implemented mask mandates earlier typically had more business closures, limits on gatherings, more, you know, cautious behavior, and just, you know, tighter lockdowns. And so it may have been these other things that were driving case rates down and not specifically masking.
But at this point in the pandemic, we're two years in, We really need robust evidence that these interventions are working and that they outweigh the harms. And mask mandates at school at this point, especially with children now eligible for vaccination, it just doesn't meet the standard.
So you would argue that there is no clear evidence that shows that masking in schools at this point in the pandemic is making a big enough difference for the CDC's current guidelines?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
I would say that if there is a benefit at this point, it's not outweighing any potential harms. There's some countries that never mask students. Several countries in Scandinavia never mask students or teachers. And there's many more countries that follow the WHO, which only masks kids under 12 very sparingly, and they don't mask kids under five.
Sean Rameswaram
And I just want to say that in the UK, they typically don't mask kids under 12. So this is really just at the secondary level. The CDC, in contrast, they don't make any distinctions. They just say everyone two and up in schools has to mask all the time.
And what would you say to someone out there who's maybe got an immunocompromised grandmother at home and they're scared that if their kids go to school unmasked, they might bring home COVID and get grandma sick?
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
We have to look at the data. And if the masks haven't really been that effective, then this is going to happen anyway with our current policies.
Sean Rameswaram
There have been calls for some people to use better high-quality masks. And I don't think that this is reasonable to mandate this for kids. There's not really data that they're going to work much better in a school setting, particularly how our kids wear masks. They're generally less comfortable. They do have to be tightly fitted.
So it's not really appropriate to mandate this. But for those high-risk individuals that want the heightened protection or live with someone that is high-risk, they can wear a higher quality mask that fits tightly to the face. They can learn how to fit tested and make sure it's tight. And that's where this idea of one-way masking comes in, where you can wear a mask and be protected without having to rely on everyone else taking the same level of precautions.
In your article in The Atlantic, The Case Against Masks in Schools, you don't really spend too much time focused on the politics at hand here. But I mean it impossible to ignore that basically what you saying is that all of those red state politicians and all of those you know vigilant and in some cases even borderline violent anti-maskers were kind of right about something here.
Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson
When you're a scientist or public health official, you have to evolve your stance. My stance has even evolved. And in the beginning, it made sense to support masks. We didn't have vaccines. We had to really do whatever it took to limit spread.
Sean Rameswaram
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
I'm Sean Rameswaram from Today Explained. And I'm sure you've noticed that we've reached the point in this pandemic where ideas that used to seem unscientific or fringy are now being discussed more seriously or even accepted by the large majority of us.
That lab leak theory, that was a total conspiracy until maybe not. Those cloth masks will do the trick until maybe not. Schools should remain closed. Well, probably not. Or maybe even kids shouldn't wear masks at school anymore.
For two years, having kids learn masked, not really seeing their teachers' faces or their friends' faces, this is likely not going to be a no-cost intervention. You know, we're seeing some anecdotal evidence start to pop up that masks are exacerbating speech delays. It's harder for language acquisition. It impedes social emotional skills and facial recognition. They're obviously harder to communicate in.
This is Dr. Marjorie Smelkinson. She's an infectious disease scientist based in Maryland. If this is a layer that we can eliminate because it's not backed up by robust data, we should. We shouldn't have to wait for the data to be collected about the harms to eliminate this if it's simply just not backed up by data that it's significantly reducing spread.
It's worth noting here that almost half the country isn't waiting. They've gone ahead and lifted school mask mandates if they ever had them to begin with. And those places with unmasked kids, they got just as much COVID as places with kids wearing masks.
Dr. Smelkinson recently joined forces with a few fellow doctors to make an argument directed at all those places that still have mask mandates in schools, the blue states. They wrote the case against masks at schools for The Atlantic, and we asked her to make the case on the show today.
We