Main Topic: The official start of the impeachment inquiry against President Donald Trump, with the House of Representatives voting 232-196 to authorize the inquiry.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sound of a news broadcast
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
It's a big day in Washington, D.C. It's Halloween. The Nationals won the World Series for the first time ever. Go Expos. And a World Series Game 7 winning Curly W is in the books. and the impeachment inquiry is official.
Sound of a news broadcast continues in the background
On this vote, the yeas are 232. The nays are 196. The resolution is adopted without objection. The motion to reconsider is laid upon the table.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Madam Speaker, I rise in strong support of House Resolution 660. I rise in strong support, but I do not take any pleasure in the events that have made this process necessary.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
I think the gentleman, Madam Speaker, trying to put a ribbon on a sham process doesn't make it any less of a sham.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Andrew Prokop, Politics Vox, what does this mean? It is now official and maybe already was official, but now it's like extra official. What does that mean?
Andrew Prokop
Well, so today was the first full vote taken by the House of Representatives related to the impeachment inquiry of President Donald Trump. And it's not a vote about impeaching Trump. It was a procedural vote on how the impeachment inquiry will work going forward.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Now, this is basically a political move to sort of ratify and get the full House vote behind what Democrats were already doing. And it was pretty much a party line vote.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
What does the actual resolution say? So the resolution was about procedures. It was about how things are going to work going forward.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And over the past month, the action in the impeachment inquiry has been in Representative Adam Schiff's House Intelligence Committee. They have been holding closed-door depositions of various Trump administration officials related to the scandal over whether Trump pressured the Ukrainian government to investigate his political opponents, including Joe Biden.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Now, this seems to be a signal that we are moving from the closed door phase of this to an open setting where there will be public hearings aired on television, witnesses being questioned by members of Congress that we can all at long last watch.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Did the House have to have this vote today? Why did they do it today? Why is this happening right now?
They did not have to hold this vote. There's no requirement in House rules or in the Constitution that an impeachment inquiry start with a vote of the full House.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And it's not clear entirely why they are holding this vote now. But the fact that they have not held this vote yet has been one of the major Republican talking points used to criticize the impeachment inquiry for weeks now.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Nancy Pelosi needs to have a fair process, a vote on the floor to actually authorize this impeachment inquiry with a standard set of rules and due process.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
This is an attempt to dress it up a little bit, to try and give it the sheen of legitimacy, and I just don't think that's going to sell.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And it didn't seem like a particularly sincere argument because none of them are going to now say, all right, now it's legitimate that they've held this vote. They'll just move on to new process-based complaints in large part because they're uncomfortable defending President Trump on the merits of this scandal.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Well, the fact that Democrats may have been pressured into doing this by Republicans makes it sound sort of unremarkable. But there's like an official impeachment inquiry happening against the president. That's a pretty big deal, right?
Sound of a news broadcast returns
You know, on the substance, this vote doesn't change very much. Democrats were conducting this impeachment inquiry before it and they will be conducting it after it. And it wasn't strictly necessary.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Still, though, an impeachment of a president is a very rare thing and it is a milestone that will be remembered by history that this is the first full vote of the House of Representatives related to the topic of whether Trump will be impeached even though that final full vote on impeachment is still probably weeks or more likely months down the road.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
So what comes next? Some like televised hearings?
So Schiff is going to bring back some of the witnesses that have testified behind closed doors and he will also get new witnesses if he can.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
And then at the end of this phase it no specific timeline but whenever they decide they done the Intelligence Committee and Schiff will write a report on their findings and recommendations
That report is then where the Judiciary Committee comes in. They will review the report and will probably draft articles of impeachment related to the findings of that report and they will vote on whether to approve those articles of impeachment.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And if they are approved, then they will go before the full house and that is the vote to impeach Donald Trump in the house. If any article of impeachment passes, Trump is impeached. And then we move to the Senate, which will hold a trial on whether he should be removed from office.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Why call witnesses who have already testified? So the move now really is to make more of a public case about why Democrats think Trump did something very wrong here and deserves impeachment.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
They've gotten all of this information behind closed doors. That was the kind of fact-gathering phase away from TV cameras, you know, stunts and people mugging for the cameras.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And now they're ready. They think they are on a good position and they understand the basic facts of this scandal. And now they're ready to kind of air those facts more in public and get some big TV events to capture voters' attention.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
And while we're on witness testimony, there was some witness testimony this week. Anything significant?
There were several witnesses that came in to do their closed-door depositions this week. And the most significant one that we know of so far was Alexander Vindman.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
He is a staffer for the National Security Council, and he is also a lieutenant colonel in the U.S. Army. And Vindman was the top Ukraine expert on the NSC staff, and he was in the mix and in the thick of all of this.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Today, the White House's top Ukraine expert told impeachment investigators that he and others on the National Security Council repeatedly raised concerns about the president's push for investigations into the Bidens and 2016 election interference.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
And he gave an opening statement, which has been released publicly, that was quite critical of what Trump did here in demanding these investigations into the Bidens.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
And Vindman says that he reported his concerns internally twice during this process.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Why was Vindman's testimony a big deal? So Vindman added new detail to events and episodes we had previously heard about in this whole saga. And he also revealed some new concerning episodes that we had not yet heard about.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
First of all, Vindman was on the famous phone call between Trump and the Ukrainian president. And that's interesting because he is actually the first official who was actually on the line during the call who Democrats have heard testimony from.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
He says, quote, I was concerned by the call. I did not think it was proper to demand that a foreign government investigate a U.S. citizen. And I was worried about the investigation, the implications for the U.S. government support of Ukraine.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
I realized that if Ukraine pursued an investigation into the Bidens and Burisma, it would likely be interpreted as a partisan play, which would undoubtedly result in Ukraine losing the bipartisan support it has thus far maintained. This would all undermine U.S. national security.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
That's what Vindman chose to reveal in his opening statement. Since his testimony, other details have leaked out that he apparently said behind closed doors.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman, the first witness with firsthand knowledge of that call to testify, reportedly told investigators the crucial phrases were left out of the White House transcript of the call.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
He said that he wanted to make certain changes to the transcript of the phone call afterward that he believed would more accurately reflect what was said.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Like before the whistleblower even made his report? Yes. Vindman tried to add those details to the reconstructed White House transcript of the call, but according to the Times, his edits were not included. And it's not clear why.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Vindman also describes more about how the document summarizing the call was locked down afterward, that after he was telling the NSC's lawyer, John Eisenberg, about all these concerns, that the response was to try to prevent many other government officials from being able to see what happened here and have access to this transcript by moving it to a more secure system.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
You know it looks like he will be a tough witness to discredit He corroborated a lot of what was said so far and raised new concerning allegations as well
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Behind closed doors the deposition grew heated lawmakers shouting at each other Democrats are accusing Republicans of asking questions in an effort to determine the whistleblower's identity.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Do people think that Vindman himself could be the whistleblower? He testified he was not the whistleblower and he doesn't match the reported background where he, whistleblower is a CIA officer.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Does he still work at the White House? Yes, he is still detailed to the NSC staff, but he is an active duty army officer.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
So, you know, the NSC staff is just a temporary assignment for him.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
How much credibility does that give him that he's an active duty member of the military, that he's in the White House? Well, you might think that it would give him sterling credentials.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
He doesn't have a partisan background at all. He was wounded in Iraq by a roadside bomb. He got a Purple Heart. And so, you know, he's a decorated veteran.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
But it didn't take long until some of Trump's defenders were viciously attacking him, calling attention to his background, which is that when he was three years old, his mother died and his father and grandmother fled Ukraine or the Soviet Union at the time and got to America.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Most people would interpret this as an inspiring story of the American dream that he rose to become a decorated military veteran and a top staffer in the White House's National Security Council.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
But Trump's defenders have used this to make insinuations and innuendos about, you know, is he really loyal to the United States or is he loyal to Ukraine?
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Because Colonel Vindeman emigrated from Ukraine along with his family when he was a child and is fluent in Ukrainian and Russian, Ukrainian officials sought advice from him about how to deal with Mr. Giuliani, though they typically communicated in English.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Now, wait a second, John. Isn't that kind of an interesting angle on this story? I find that astounding. And some people might call that espionage.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
It was pretty ugly stuff. And there were some Republicans who pushed back against it.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Representative Liz Cheney of Wyoming, daughter of the former vice president, Dick Cheney, spoke out and said that. Questioning the patriotism, questioning the dedication to country of people like Mr. Vindman and others who have testified.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
It is shameful to question their patriotism, their love of this nation, and we should not be involved in that process.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Senator Mitt Romney said the same thing.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
How does the president feel about someone who works in his White House testifying in such an incriminating way against him? Has he weighed in?
Sound of a news broadcast returns
The line Trump has taken is basically, I don't know him. I don't know those gentlemen. That's the approach Mariah Carey takes when everyone asks her about Jennifer Lopez. The Mariah Carey defense. I don't know her.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
The president tweeted this. Supposedly, according to the corrupt media, the Ukraine call concerned today's never Trump or witness. Was he on the same call that I was? Can't be possible. Please ask him to read the transcript of the call. Witch hunt.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Trump has also been relying on this talking point lately that the call is actually OK. And if you just read the call summary document released by the White House, which he keeps calling the transcript, then it'll be totally fine.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
And it's a bit weird because when that document was released, it was widely viewed as terribly damning for the president. But he is now just attempted to, I guess, just assert. I made a call. The call was perfect. There was no quid pro quo. There was nothing. Nothing to see here. Move along. Look at this. I did nothing wrong.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And when, in fact, a lot of people think that it shows he did quite a lot wrong.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Vindman testified on Tuesday. Today, a cat named Tim Morrison testified. Who's he?
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Morrison is another National Security Council staffer, and he was the top staffer handling Russian and European issues. And he is actually leaving the NSC. Word just broke Wednesday night about that.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And so in his testimony, his opening statement is now out. And he doesn't really go out of his way to make President Trump look bad. But he did confirm some pretty ugly underlying facts that other more hostile witnesses have laid out.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Most specifically, he confirmed that Ukraine was in fact told in September that if they wanted to get their military aid, they needed to investigate Burisma, the natural gas company that Hunter Biden sat on the board of.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
And Tim Morrison is a Bolton guy, right?
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Yeah. Is Bolton going to testify So on Wednesday night the House Democrats sent a request to Bolton to testify They asked him to show up next week
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
And Bolton lawyer quickly responded by saying that he would only show up if he was subpoenaed However, there is a lawsuit going on right now by an aide who is close to Bolton and in fact using the same lawyer as him.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
This aide has sued both the House and the Trump administration and is basically asking a federal judge to tell him what to do. Should he testify, as the House says, or should he not, as the Trump administration says?
Sound of a news broadcast continues
So Bolton may be waiting for this case to resolve itself before testifying or not testifying.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
It's interesting because, you know, he's a hardcore conservative. He's mad at Trump, but he also supports like executive power. He doesn't like Democrats. So I don't know which way.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Well, irrespective of whether or not Bolton testifies, is the fact that you've got military personnel saying that this transcript is incomplete and what transpired was actually far more incriminating, the fact that this has now become official, is that going to sway any Republicans?
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And does it even matter? This is going to happen, right? It definitely looks like the House is going to impeach Trump at this point.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
The factual picture is bad enough as it is that the votes already seem to be there. So definitely bet on Trump being impeached at this point.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
But the question of the Senate is a tougher one. It takes two-thirds to remove Trump from office. The Republicans have a majority in the Senate as it is. So that means you need 20 Senate Republicans to vote to remove Trump from office.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
And right now we're not seeing anything close to that. Mitt Romney is still the only senator who is kind of openly defying the White House here and saying there's some very concerning stuff.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
All the others are trying to continue to dodge this in part because they say there are going to be jurors eventually.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Jurors? Yeah. That's their official role. The House is the prosecutor in impeachment and the Senate is essentially a jury.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
So senators consider themselves jurors and a lot of the Republican senators have used this as a convenient excuse to avoid talking about this scandal in any way whatsoever.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Well, I look forward to having you back to talk about the jurors, Andrew. Happy Halloween.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
The Senate has a lot of rural jurors. Ah, the rural juror. That is something. That's a 30 Rock reference.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
The show is over, but the fun is ready to begin.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Our guest today was senior correspondent Andrew Prokop.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Today Explained is hosted by Sean Rameswaram.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Our executive producer is Irene No Spooky.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
The show is produced by Wichid McCarthy, Amina Al-Skari, Noam Hassanfear, and Halima Shah!
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Our engineer is Efim the Scream Shapiro.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
We also had help this week from Jared Poltergeist and Matt Frasica. I mean, Frightsico.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Fact-checking by Olivia Hextrom.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
And our music is composed by the quite mundane Breakmaster Cylinder.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Today, Explained is produced in association with Witcher.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
And we are part of the Fox Media Podcast Network.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Mwahahahaha.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Did you hear that Edward Snowden recently sat down with Joe Rogan for like a three-hour marathon interview?
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
Did you hear that and go like, damn, I would really like to listen to that interview, but I really don't like Joe Rogan?
Sound of a news broadcast returns
I have incredible news for you. If so, Kara Swisher of Recode just did a marathon interview with Edward Snowden.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Snowden. The two discuss everything from what it's like living in Russia to his views on the relationship between United States tech companies and the U.S. government, what he thinks about the whistleblower complaint that just launched the entire impeachment inquiry against President Donald Trump and how it compares to his own experience as a whistleblower.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
They talk about so many things. And as per usual, Kara Swisher does not hold back.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
This episode, Snowden, Swisher, it drops in the Recode Decode feed tomorrow, Friday, November 1st.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
If you're not subscribed to Recode Decode, now is the time.
Sound of a news broadcast fades out
You'll get a nice little alert, maybe a little notification tomorrow when this episode goes live.
Sound of a news broadcast returns
Find it on Apple Podcasts, find it on Spotify, find it on Stitcher, find it wherever you don't listen to the Joe Rogan experience.
Sound of a news broadcast continues
Host (Sean Rameswaram):