Podcast Episode Summary:
The podcast episode, "Life in the Barricades," explores the story of 15-year-old Ty Larson and his 12-year-old sister Bryn Lee, who have been barricaded in their bedroom since last December. They are refusing to leave due to a court order that requires them to reunite with their father, whom they claim abused them. The court has been trying to put them through reunification therapy, which the kids believe is an attempt to force them to forgive their father and move forward with a relationship.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noel King
Life in the barricades, it's hard. I'll say that it's hard not seeing people and not leaving. 15-year-old Ty Larson updates his TikTok followers every day from inside of his bedroom. The room is full of teenage boy stuff, computer, guitar, board games. Also, his little sister, 12-year-old Bryn Lee. Bryn Lee's doing good. She is sleeping. She sleeps nonstop. It's a way to cope. If you learn about psychology, that's a big one.
Hannah Dreyfus
Ty and Brinley have been barricaded inside of that bedroom since last December. They're refusing to leave it because a judge says they must reunite with their father, and they say their father abused them. Now, the judge believes the kids are victims of parental alienation, that Ty and Brinley's mom has poisoned them against their father.
Noel King
Coming up on Today Explained, what the story of these two children exposes about family courts.
Support for the show
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform.
Hannah Dreyfus
Having a night out with your friends is awesome. Dealing with hangovers sucks. Meet Senorita, the THC-infused margarita that lets you skip the booze but keep the vibe. Made with real fruit, organic agave, and Himalayan pink salt, every sip is like a mini getaway. No fillers, no hangovers, just full flavor and a better buzz.
Noel King
Having a night out with your friends is awesome. Dealing with hangovers sucks. Meet Senorita, the THC-infused margarita that lets you skip the booze but keep the vibe.
Hannah Dreyfus
Made with real fruit, organic agave, and Himalayan pink salt, every sip is like a mini getaway. No fillers, no hangovers, just full flavor and a better buzz.
Noel King
Find your flavor at senoritadrinks.com. Use code VOX20 for 20% off. Must be 21 and over.
Hannah Dreyfus
This product may cause intoxication. This product has not been evaluated or approved by the FDA. This product may contain up to 0.3% THC.
Noel King
It's today explained I'm noelle king hannah dreyfus is an abrams reporting fellow for propublica hannah investigates abuses of power in many places including in family court and that's how she ended up looking into the story of these two kids ty and brinley here's hannah
Hannah Dreyfus
I was on TikTok, I saw a video of Ty Larson. Hey guys, I got a story I need to tell you guys about my life. He's a 15-year-old living in Utah, and he was on a live stream and talking to his TikTok followers about why he and his sister, Bryn Lee, had decided to barricade themselves in their bedroom for, at that point, a number of weeks.
Noel King
I'm so afraid I haven't even left my room. I wait till it's dead silent and I know I'm safe to leave and hurry go to the bathroom. And for food, we get food delivered to our door right here and I wait until everybody leaves and then I'll get it.
Hannah Dreyfus
So what Ty is telling his TikTok followers is that he's barricaded inside this bedroom because there's a court judge who has ordered him into the custody of his biological father, despite the fact that he and his younger sister have both made claims that the father sexually and emotionally abused them.
Noel King
The court has been trying to put us through reunification, and reunification really only works for really young kids. It never works for teenagers like me.
Hannah Dreyfus
Ty and Brindley's mom, Jessica, and their father were married when they were younger. They got divorced and until about 2018, Ty and Brinley were in part-time custody with their father and mother.
Noel King
I was abused by my father physically, sexually, and emotionally. This all started when I was about three years old and went till I was about 10. For my little sister, she was three to seven.
Hannah Dreyfus
And the mom, not knowing what to do, brought them to the Department of Children and Family Services in Utah, which investigates claims of abuse, to try and involve authorities in the situation and to figure out what was going on.
Noel King
The investigators interviewed them forensically, which means they interviewed them to understand more about their disclosures, and they concluded that the children were credible and that the abuse that they were describing, there was a very high likelihood that it did take place.
Hannah Dreyfus
In the DCSF paperwork, they described the abuse as chronic and severe, meaning that it wasn't just a one-off, but that this is a pattern of behavior that they feared was taking place towards the children multiple times.
Noel King
The courts signed what's called a child protective order, which is akin to a restraining order, that prevented the father from being in contact with his kids.
Hannah Dreyfus
So at that point, they paused visitation with their dad for some time.
Noel King
So the two kids report abuse. Utah authorities confirm the abuse. They say the kids' allegations are supported.
Hannah Dreyfus
How does that then lead to these two children barricading themselves in a room after being ordered to see their father?
Noel King
There was initially a case opened, a criminal case, to see if the father would or could be prosecuted for these crimes.
Hannah Dreyfus
For a criminal conviction, you have a very high standard of evidence beyond a reasonable doubt, which is very difficult to come by, especially in a case of sexual abuse.
Noel King
And because the district attorney decided that there wasn't necessarily enough evidence to convict the father, the district attorney put the case on hold.
Hannah Dreyfus
And so the father was no longer facing criminal allegations that he had sexually abused his kids.
Noel King
At that point, the father decided that he wanted to have visitation with his kids.
Hannah Dreyfus
And so he petitioned the court to continue having custody rights with his children.
Noel King
And the court decided that reunification therapy was the best way to go about this.
Hannah Dreyfus
This is a type of therapy that the court will sometimes order when children are resistant or refusing to see their parent.
Noel King
For a variety of reasons. Sometimes kids are resisting or refusing to see a parent because they think the parent abused them or the parent did in fact abuse them.
Hannah Dreyfus
So in Ty and Brindley's case, they were encouraged by a mental health professional to forgive their father and to move forward and put what happened in the past behind them and continue a relationship with him going forward
Noel King
When the kids continued to be resistant to being in their father's custody, the father stepped up his efforts to take back custody of the kids.
Hannah Dreyfus
And that's where we get into the claims of parental alienation.
Noel King
What does parental alienation mean?
Hannah Dreyfus
So parental alienation is the concept that one parent can alienate a child's affections for the other parent, meaning one parent actually can cause a child, usually in the context of a custody dispute, to not want to have anything to do with the other parent.
Noel King
Okay, so the dad is making an explosive claim. I didn't do anything to my kids. Their mother has poisoned them against me.
Hannah Dreyfus
I'm thinking, if I'm the judge, I look at this and I say, well, the kids' claims of abuse were found to have been supported.
Noel King
What ends up happening?
Hannah Dreyfus
What they did next is they appointed on the recommendation of the father's attorney, a mental health professional. She's a social worker in Utah. Her name is Michelle Jones, and she is a major public advocate for this concept of parental alienation.
Noel King
It's a steady stream of negative messaging to the child that everything that other parent does is bad, wrong, stupid, contemptible, and an indication that the parent doesn't love the child.
Hannah Dreyfus
Sadly, many mental health and legal professionals are untrained.
Noel King
But even when a judge sees it, they don't know what to do about it.
Hannah Dreyfus
When they would try and tell Ms. Jones that they had been abused by their father, and that is why they did not want to return to his custody, she would basically say, what happened in the past? We should leave in the past. Let's ignore the fact that that may or may not have happened.
Noel King
And encouraged the children to disregard their previous experiences in order to move forward and forge a new relationship with their father.
Hannah Dreyfus
And what Michelle Jones told the court in no uncertain terms after meeting with these kids on various occasions, that they were in fact not victims of their father for sexual assaulting them, but that they are victims of their mother for psychologically manipulating them to believe that they've been abused.
Noel King
And Michelle Jones encouraged the court to force the kids back into full custody of their father.
Hannah Dreyfus
I see. Okay. And what happened then?
Noel King
It began to be a standoff between the kids and the court.
Hannah Dreyfus
The kids continued to tell their truth, which is that our father abused us. This was investigated by state authorities and found to be the case.
Noel King
And now all of a sudden a court judge is choosing to ignore that and to force us back into the full custody of our father.
Hannah Dreyfus
The family court judge in this case wrote, you kids are not in control. You do not get to control who your parents are. You do not get to control who you see.
Noel King
The court is telling you that you have to go back into custody of your father for your own good and you better listen or there are going to be extreme consequences.
Hannah Dreyfus
The court actually ordered late last year that the kids attend what's called a reunification camp.
Noel King
This is actually an out-of-state facility where the kids would be forced to participate in intensive therapy with their father.
Hannah Dreyfus
And they wouldn't be able to bring any devices with them, no phones, no any sort of methods of contact with the outside world.
Noel King
And they also would be prohibited from contacting their mom not only for the week when they were participating in this intensive reunification therapy but also for 90 days after they returned from this program and were entered into the full custody of their father.
Hannah Dreyfus
Now the very strange thing about this case is that if you look closely at the court orders the judge the family court judge who ordered that these kids return into the custody of their father did not give the father total unrestricted custody.
Noel King
In fact, the court judge said that the father would not be able to spend overnights or unsupervised parenting time with his children.
Hannah Dreyfus
So clearly the court had some reservations about giving the father completely unfettered access to his children.
Noel King
However, they still believed the children needed to be removed from their mother's custody because of the psychological harm that the father said she was imposing on the kids.
Hannah Dreyfus
Hannah, tell me about the judge in this case, Derek Pullen.
Noel King
How did he make his decision?
Hannah Dreyfus
He's a well-respected judge in Utah.
Noel King
So the judge said, look, I'm relying on this mental health professional who says she knows a lot about this condition.
Hannah Dreyfus
I'm a judge. I'm not a mental health professional. I'm going to rely on what Ms. Jones is telling me is going on here.
Noel King
Which is that the kids weren't actually abused, or we don't know if they were sexually abused, but what we do see is that they're being psychologically abused by mom.
Hannah Dreyfus
Okay, and what does mom say during all of this?
Noel King
What has her response been?
Hannah Dreyfus
The way she describes it to me is she's watched this narrative develop around her, and she has almost no control to fight it.
Noel King
Anything that she does in response is wrong.
Hannah Dreyfus
If she tries to say that her kids are entitled to tell their truth, then she's criticized for continuing to psychologically manipulate them.
Noel King
If she doesn't say anything, she's accused of being a negligent mom.
Hannah Dreyfus
There's sort of a catch-22 here where just her existence is a crime because she is somehow encouraging her kids to continue doing this.
Noel King
And by even bringing them food up in their barricaded room. She is encouraging them to continue to reject the father and the court is holding her in contempt for this.
Hannah Dreyfus
What has been happening to these two kids? What have their lives been like in that bedroom?
Noel King
They are terrified of leaving their room because they know that they are under a court order to go into the custody of their father, that police have been authorized to use reasonable force to take them there.
Hannah Dreyfus
And then if their mom tries to protect them in any way, she will be held in contempt of court and face jail time.
Noel King
They are live streaming around the clock.
Hannah Dreyfus
I wanted to also give a mini update. I still in this room still barricaded still haven't left I still over live on Twitch
Noel King
So please go over there and watch me
Hannah Dreyfus
Just say hi
Noel King
Ty told me that the reason that they decided to turn to TikTok is because if the public is watching, then maybe they have some protection against what they believe is a terrible injustice that's going on.
Hannah Dreyfus
And that public outrage will consider the courts to reconsider what they're asking them to do.
Noel King
The school has accommodated their situation and they are taking some online school.
Hannah Dreyfus
And the question of what happens next is truly unknown.
Noel King
I have infrequently worked on a story that's developing in real time in this way, where I myself, the reporter on the case, don't know what's going to happen next.
Hannah Dreyfus
I do think that the public pressure of all of this being under scrutiny now online and beyond has perhaps given the children more of a voice in this case than many other kids who face similar situations in family court.
Noel King
Ahead, Hannah Dreyfuss comes back with the surprising story of where this concept of parental alienation came from.
Hannah Dreyfus
Support for today's show comes from Adio. What is Adio?
Noel King
Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Hannah Dreyfus
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Noel King
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up, and within seconds you will have your email and calendars synced.
Hannah Dreyfus
You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Noel King
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Hannah Dreyfus
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal, and so much more.
Noel King
You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
Hannah Dreyfus
That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Noel King
This message is brought to you by Apple Card.
Hannah Dreyfus
Each Apple product, like the iPhone, is thoughtfully designed by skilled designers.
Noel King
The titanium Apple Card is no different.
Hannah Dreyfus
It's laser-etched, has no numbers, and it earns you daily cash on everything you buy, including 3% back on everything at Apple.
Noel King
Apply for Apple Card on your iPhone in minutes.
Hannah Dreyfus
Subject to credit approval, Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch.
Noel King
Terms and more at AppleCard.com.
Hannah Dreyfus
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King.
Noel King
Earlier in the episode, Hannah Dreyfuss, a reporter with ProPublica, told us the story of Ty and Brinley Larson, two siblings in Utah who have locked themselves in a bedroom after being forced to reunite with a father that they say abused them.
Hannah Dreyfus
Now, a judge made that decision after a court-appointed therapist said the kids were victims of something called parental alienation.
Noel King
Hannah, what is the history of this term?
Hannah Dreyfus
So the term parental alienation syndrome originated with a psychiatrist named Dr. Richard Gardner.
Noel King
He practiced in courts in the U.S. in the 80s and 90s.
Hannah Dreyfus
Now, the interesting thing about Gardner is that he was hired as a court expert to defend mainly fathers who were accused of sexually abusing their kids.
Noel King
So he came up with a theory, parental alienation syndrome, a mental health disorder in which the mom has brainwashed the kids to falsely believe that they had experienced this abuse.
Hannah Dreyfus
The treatment, number one, has to be to take the child, remove the child from the indoctrinator.
Noel King
You can see the child seven days a week. I don't care how skillful you are as a therapist. If the child is turned back to the home of the indoctrinator, your therapy is a waste of time.
Hannah Dreyfus
And so the theory took off as a way to defend fathers from accusations of molesting their children.
Noel King
Is this an official term that psychologists use that is in the DSM?
Hannah Dreyfus
Courts seem to recognize it, but what is it exactly?
Noel King
It's a supposed mental health disorder that is not recognized by major psychological bodies like the American Psychiatric Association or the American Psychological Association.
Hannah Dreyfus
It's not listed in any official code, and it's not a diagnosis that any professional can give to an individual.
Noel King
It is a dynamic that lawyers and some psychologists say exists within the context of high conflict divorces, where you see kids being manipulated by one parent in order to resist contact with the other parent.
Hannah Dreyfus
So Richard Gardner coins the term in the 1980s.
Noel King
And then what's the reaction to it?
Hannah Dreyfus
So the reaction has shifted and changed over time.
Noel King
Defenders of the theory sort of dropped the term syndrome, and that's why I refer to it now more broadly as parental alienation.
Hannah Dreyfus
Michelle Jones, in the case of Ty and Bryn Lee, told me that she diagnoses parental alienation among her patients as easily as she could diagnose strep throat.
Noel King
But others say that, no, this is not a diagnosable theory.
Hannah Dreyfus
This is a family systems problem, meaning that it's a dynamic issue.
Noel King
Doesn't exist within one person's own mental health or inside someone's mind, but that it is a dynamic that comes up when there is a high-conflict divorce situation.
Hannah Dreyfus
One of the most pernicious ways that a parent might manipulate a child to reject another parent is to cause them to believe that they had been abused when the actual abuse had not taken place.
Noel King
According to modern-day alienation experts, if there is legitimate reason to believe that a child has been abused, that alienation cannot be the explanation for why a child does not want to be with the parent.
Hannah Dreyfus
However, what you're seeing is that there are reunification therapists lawyers and court experts who continue to take on and defend cases in which abuse has been substantiated.
Noel King
If there is no certainty around the term parental alienation if it's so disputed why are courts still making rulings as if there is certainty about it?
Hannah Dreyfus
I'm going to quote Dr. David Corwin, and he is the immediate past president of APSAC, an organization that defends against abuse of children.
Noel King
And what Dr. Corwin told me is that people understand that in a messy divorce, somebody might make false claims about the other parent and that people will say not nice things about the other parent to try and perhaps gain a custody advantage.
Hannah Dreyfus
However, the difference here is that the concept that a child could actually be manipulated to believe and disclose abuse is wildly unscientifically supported.
Noel King
Meaning, the reason that the courts continue to be compelled by this theory is because it's very difficult and uncomfortable to believe that a parent would have sexually abused a child.
Hannah Dreyfus
Even though we have statistics that there are a huge number of children who are sexually abused, and most commonly by family members or close relatives.
Noel King
How common is it for claims of parental alienation to be used in custody cases?
Hannah Dreyfus
How often does this go on?
Noel King
ProPublica is actually collecting information on this now.
Hannah Dreyfus
It's not easy to collect data on this issue because many court cases are sealed, especially when they have to do with minors.
Noel King
But what is important to keep in mind is that there are a lot of divorces taking place in the U.S. at any given time.
Hannah Dreyfus
A relatively small percentage of them fall into the category of high-conflict divorces, which are divorces that continue to go through legislation over the course of frequently years.
Noel King
So we don't have specific numbers at this point.
Hannah Dreyfus
Who else benefits from this type of ruling?
Noel King
You mentioned that Ty and Brindley had been forced to go through a reunification program with their dad.
Hannah Dreyfus
Tell me about those.
Noel King
There are relatively few number of these that exist in the U.S., but these are programs that take place in various different locations frequently.
Hannah Dreyfus
I mean, actually almost exclusively not disclosed to participants beforehand.
Noel King
And they are brought there frequently from the backhouse of courtrooms.
Hannah Dreyfus
They are brought into the total authority of parental alienation experts who will give them intensive treatment to help cure them of all the psychological programming that they say they have gone through.
Noel King
I actually think my job is kind of easy.
Hannah Dreyfus
The hard part is getting the court to realize that their rejection is counterintuitive, meaning that the children really don't mean it when they say they don't want to ever see a parent again.
Noel King
Family reunification programs cost a pretty penny.
Hannah Dreyfus
I'm actually in the process of getting receipts myself, but I have heard in the realm of $30,000 for a week of intensive reunification therapy and the follow-up treatment.
Noel King
This is big business.
Hannah Dreyfus
It is big business, yeah.
Noel King
What does this story tell us about how children in this country are protected or not protected by court systems from abuse?
Hannah Dreyfus
I think what this story tells us about the way that family courts handle abuse is that children largely in this country are not given the opportunity to tell family courts who they want to live with and why they want to live with that specific person or parent or caregiver.
Noel King
Even my own guardian ad litem slash my own attorney hasn't even been standing up for me in court.
Hannah Dreyfus
So you see delegated in family courts the responsibility of speaking for kids given over to a third party instead of the ability for kids and teenagers even teenagers 16 years old them not having that chance to speak for themselves and address a court directly about what they want.
Noel King
I'm now almost 16 and I've been through this court case for almost five years now.
Hannah Dreyfus
I've been interviewed by DCFS thousands of times, it feels like.
Noel King
Cops, police officers, anything, I've been interviewed by them.
Hannah Dreyfus
In the case of Ty and Bryn Lee, Ty has been desperate to communicate exactly why he does not want custody with his father.
Noel King
My own word does not matter and they don't believe my truth.
Hannah Dreyfus
So he has to resort to talking about his situation on social media.
Noel King
I think what this story tells us is that while America thinks of itself as a pretty advanced country when it comes to awareness about child sexual abuse and laws protecting victims of domestic violence, the courts so frequently go out of their way to silence children who are claiming that they were sexually abused.
Hannah Dreyfus
I have been approached by hundreds of parents and kids who said the courts have completely disregarded their stories and their truths.
Noel King
Today's episode was produced by Siona Petros and edited by Amina El-Sadi.
Hannah Dreyfus
It was engineered by Patrick Boyd and fact-checked by Laura Bullard.
Noel King
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.
Hannah Dreyfus
has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express.
Noel King
You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects.
Hannah Dreyfus
That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe.
Noel King
Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more.
Hannah Dreyfus
Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content.
Noel King
Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Hannah Dreyfus: