Main Topic: The 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act and its impact on immigration policy in the United States.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram here with David Leonhardt. He's a senior writer at the New York Times, but more recently, the author of Ours Was The Shining Future, The Story of the American Dream.
David Leonhardt
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
We were more interested in David's writing specifically on immigration because it really helped us wrap our heads around an issue that just feels relentlessly intractable. Immigration's complex. Because a lot of the claims you hear about immigration's economic effects, I think, are overblown.
David Leonhardt
I think you often hear complaints from opponents of more immigration saying that immigration is economically ruinous, that it's the worst thing or one of the worst things happening to Americans who live here now. I think that's wrong. And then on the other side, you hear people argue saying that basically immigration is a free lunch, that it has no economic cost whatsoever for native workers and for workers who are already here as immigrants. To me, that's wrong as well.
Sean Rameswaram
He says a lot of our issues with this issue actually trace back to the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965. But before we get to that landmark law, we wanted to ask about what things looked like before it was passed.
David Leonhardt
In the 1920s, the United States passed an extremely restrictive immigration policy. And frankly, the accurate way to describe it is a restrictionist and racist immigration policy. It essentially allotted nearly all immigration slots to just a few countries in Western Europe, like England. It kept out nearly all people from Asia, nearly all people from Africa. It kept out nearly all people from Eastern and Southern Europe.
Sean Rameswaram
And the decades from the 1920s through the 1960s were really one of the most restrictionist times for American immigration policy in our history, if not the most restrictionist.
David Leonhardt
And I think it's important to think about that in two different ways. Not only did immigration policy restrict it to just a very few countries, but the levels were very low. So it's not like the United States was admitting huge numbers of Europeans and keeping out everyone else. The United States was actually admitting very small numbers of people overall.
Sean Rameswaram
And then within that number, it tended to be a quite racist system.
David Leonhardt
But both halves of that are important. So when does someone decide that they ought to change that?
Sean Rameswaram
Sometimes John F. Kennedy gets too much credit for things during his presidency. And you look at polls and people say he's one of the most successful presidents ever, and then you look at his legislative record and he actually didn't do that much. Happy birthday, Mr. President. Happy birthday to you.
David Leonhardt
But I think immigration is one of these areas where John F. Kennedy legitimately deserves credit for putting it onto the national agenda. We are the descendants of 40 million people who left other countries, other familiar scenes, to come here to the United States to build a new life, to make a new opportunity for themselves and their children. I think it is not a burden, but a privilege.
Sean Rameswaram
And John F. Kennedy basically becomes one of the early politicians who realizes, you know what, actually, one, our system is unfair, and two, we now have enough descendants of immigrants from the really high immigration levels of the late 19th and early 20th century that it might actually be politically popular, particularly in a diverse state like Massachusetts, which had a lot of Portuguese and Irish immigrants, if I came out for a different kind of system.
David Leonhardt
And so he does, both as a senator and then as president. And he really doesn't move the legislation at all while he is president, but it then becomes part of this great batch of legislation that LBJ picks up after JFK's assassination and pushes.
Sean Rameswaram
No words are sad enough to express our sense of loss. No words are strong enough to express our determination to continue the forward thrust of America that he began.
David Leonhardt
He basically pushes a version of JFK's immigration plan. It was called the Immigration and Nationality Act, although colloquially at the time it was also known as the Heart Seller Act, after two people who helped write it.
Sean Rameswaram
And he is helped by the fact that there are two Kennedys who are still very much active in politics at the time.
David Leonhardt
By the time the bill is going up for a vote in 1965, Ted Kennedy is a 33-year-old senator, the youngest member of the Senate, and Robert Kennedy is elected senator from New York.
Sean Rameswaram
This generation did not create most of the conditions and the convictions which have led us to this day. But this generation has a responsibility to resolve them.
David Leonhardt
And so they, among others, really start pushing this bill. And what it sets out to do is get rid of this old racist system. It gets rid of the system that basically says you have to be from England or a small number of other Western European countries to come here.
Sean Rameswaram
And they instead say, we're going to create a system that is open to the whole world and that treats people from different countries equally.
David Leonhardt
And by the way, stops barring people with disabilities, which the old system also did, which was a personal issue for the Kennedys, in part because their sister had disabilities.
Sean Rameswaram
And they say, we're going to create a new system that's much fairer. A nation that was built by the immigrants of all lands can ask those who now seek admission, what can you do for our country? But we should not be asking, in what country were you born?
David Leonhardt
It's viewed as part of the great civil rights push of the 60s. In fact, the civil rights bill that had passed before specifically banned discrimination on the basis of national origin.
Sean Rameswaram
And so when you look at a civil rights bill that bans discrimination on the basis of national origin in this country, it felt deeply hypocritical to have an immigration system that was still based entirely on national origin.
David Leonhardt
Now, LBJ and the Kennedy brothers and the other people who are pushing this bill make two promises. One, they say we're going to get rid of this old unfair system and we're going to open it up to the whole world.
Sean Rameswaram
And two, they say we are not going to significantly increase the level of immigration.
David Leonhardt
So they say we are changing the who comes. We are not changing the how many people come in any significant way.
Sean Rameswaram
And maybe the clearest statement of this comes from Edward Kennedy, Teddy Kennedy, who is the Bill's main shepherd in the Senate.
David Leonhardt
And he said that he welcomed legitimate criticism of the bill, but the notion that it would lead to a large increase in immigration, he said, was so false that it didn't deserve a place in the political debate.
Sean Rameswaram
The charges I have mentioned are highly emotional, irrational, and with little foundation. In fact, they are out of line with the obligations of responsible citizenship. They breed hate of our heritage and fear of a vitality which helped to build America.
David Leonhardt
So Teddy Kennedy is saying, I'm open to legitimate criticisms. How much criticism was there?
Sean Rameswaram
There was a lot. And this is one of these other ways in which this is such a fraught issue, right?
David Leonhardt
I think a lot of times when we're looking at politics, particularly in our polarized country today, we want to think of there are good people and bad people. There are right people and wrong people.
Sean Rameswaram
Now, Americans have very different views about who's right and who's wrong, but we tend to view it through this almost binary lens.
David Leonhardt
What's so tricky about this old immigration debate is that many of the people who were raising criticisms were Southern segregationists.
Sean Rameswaram
And they said all kinds of horrible and racist and false things about what would happen if the United States opened up its immigration system to people from Southern and Eastern Europe, or even more so to people from Africa and from Asia.
David Leonhardt
That part of their criticism was really quite vile.
Sean Rameswaram
The people of Ethiopia have the same right to come to the United States under this bill as the people of England, the people of France, the people of Germany, the people of Holland.
David Leonhardt
With all due respect to Ethiopia, I don't know of any contributions that Ethiopia has made to the making of America.
Sean Rameswaram
They also said that the supporters of the bill were wrong when they claimed that it would not lead to any increase in the levels of immigration.
David Leonhardt
This bill that we will sign today is not a revolutionary bill. It does not affect the lives of millions. It will not reshape the structure of our daily lives or really add importantly to either our wealth or our power.
Sean Rameswaram
When LBJ is signing the bill, he specifically says that this is not going to lead to millions of people coming.
David Leonhardt
Yet it is still one of the most important acts of this Congress and of this administration. Or it does repair a very deep and painful flaw in the fabric of American justice.
Sean Rameswaram
It corrects a cruel and enduring wrong in the conduct of the American nation.
David Leonhardt
And this is where things get tricky. The supporters of the bill repeatedly promised that it was changing only the who comes. It's changing the mix of who comes to make it more fair. It was not changing the levels.
Sean Rameswaram
The supporters were completely wrong about that. They were wrong almost immediately.
David Leonhardt
And the opponents of the bill who said this is going to lead to immigration soaring and reaching above a million, they were entirely correct about that.
Sean Rameswaram
And so you go back and you look at this and half of what the supporters are arguing looks really good historically. The US should not have a racist immigration system that makes decisions based on where people are coming from.
David Leonhardt
And half of what they argue was just wrong. In fact, they sold this bill to the American people on a basis that ended up being false.
Sean Rameswaram
They said this will not increase the level of immigration in this country.
David Leonhardt
It did almost immediately. There's a front page story in the New York Times about it within a couple years, and immigration just continues to rise after that.
Sean Rameswaram
What this 1965 law did to the politics of immigration, when we're back on Today Explained.
Supporter announcement
Welcome back to Today Explained. We're still with David Leonhardt of the New York Times.
David Leonhardt
When we left off, I was telling you that the enemies of the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act ended up being kind of right in that it led to a massive influx of immigration in the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
How do LBJ, RFK, Teddy, and their allies get it so wrong?
David Leonhardt
I think there are a couple answers to that question. I don't think they were lying. I've looked at the historical records on this. Others have as well. There's no evidence in their private correspondence that they secretly thought it would lead to a big immigration increase and were hiding that from the public.
Sean Rameswaram
They still deserve criticism, I think, for so strongly promising something that turned out to be false.
David Leonhardt
And I think they engaged in motivated reasoning. I think they were so eager to rewrite immigration law for very good reasons.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, it is a monumental civil rights achievement to change the country's laws so that they aren't making decisions based on what countries people are coming from.
David Leonhardt
But they were so eager to do that that they basically brushed off any criticism of the bill, including much more legitimate criticisms.
Sean Rameswaram
And the key thing here is that the bill had a whole bunch of categories that didn't count toward entry into this country.
David Leonhardt
They were called, in the jargon of the time, non-quota entries. These non-quota entries ended up basically overwhelming the system.
Sean Rameswaram
And many of them were family members.
David Leonhardt
And so, if an immigrant was already here, that immigrant's parents and children and spouse didn't count toward the quota.
Sean Rameswaram
And so what was the effect of, say, one individual's wife and kids and parents coming and not being counted in this cap?
David Leonhardt
What did that mean for the country over the decades? I mean, it means that basically instead of having immigration at the levels that the bill's authors promised, which was roughly constant, maybe a small increase, you see immigration surge almost immediately.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, as a share of the U.S. population, the 1965 immigration law leads to a wave of immigration that resembles the huge wave of the late 19th and early 20th century.
David Leonhardt
And because the country was bigger in the 70s and 80s and decades since then, it may well be the largest single wave of immigration in terms of number of people to a single country in human history.
Sean Rameswaram
And of course, the question we have to ask here, and I'm sure the answer is very complicated, is, is that wave good or bad for the country?
David Leonhardt
I think for the immigrants themselves, the answer is overwhelmingly that it has been good.
Sean Rameswaram
There is an important piece of research, a book called Streets of Gold by two economists who have studied this question in more depth, really, than anyone else using big data records from census and from immigration forums and elsewhere.
David Leonhardt
And what they show is that the trajectory of the post-1965 immigrants looks remarkably similar to the trajectory of the Russian and Italian and Irish immigrants from the late 19th and early 20th century.
Sean Rameswaram
Obviously, it's a big country. There are exceptions. There are immigrants who still struggle.
David Leonhardt
And most immigrants themselves, if they arrive here poor, remain poor for their lives.
Sean Rameswaram
But their children do extremely well.
David Leonhardt
And the upward mobility of recent generations of immigrants looks very similar and deeply encouraging.
Sean Rameswaram
These recent immigrants tend to be from Latin America and Asia, not exclusively, but mostly.
David Leonhardt
And they're doing very well by many, many measures.
Sean Rameswaram
So a great deal for those arriving to this country, at least their kids.
David Leonhardt
What about for those who are already here? That answer is more complicated.
Sean Rameswaram
I do think there have been modestly negative economic effects for most American workers of the big increase in immigration.
David Leonhardt
And I know this is a point that many people on the political left take issue with, and frankly, some people on the political right as well.
Sean Rameswaram
It practically verboten You not allowed to talk about that.
David Leonhardt
Yes, but I think both logic and the empirical research point to the idea that there have been modest costs.
Sean Rameswaram
So the empirical research there is a huge study done by the National Academy of Sciences. It's hundreds of pages.
David Leonhardt
There is one table that summarizes all the relevant studies of the effect of immigration on the wages of people who are already in the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
You just scan down that chart and there are a lot more negative numbers than zeros or positive numbers.
David Leonhardt
And that's the empirical research.
Sean Rameswaram
I think logic, though, points to the same thing. If you have many more workers competing for the same job, the company can pay those workers less.
David Leonhardt
Now, I don't think that's the main reason why we've had huge increase in economic inequality.
Sean Rameswaram
I think the decline of labor unions. I think trade policy. I think tax policy. I think all those things are more important.
David Leonhardt
But I think it's a real mistake when relatively affluent Americans say to working class Americans, oh, no, you're wrong.
Sean Rameswaram
Immigration has had no costs, because I think there's just a wealth of evidence that it has had some economic costs.
David Leonhardt
And that's even before what we've we talk about what it has done to the political atmosphere in our country.
Sean Rameswaram
So to me, the politics of immigration are a microcosm of the shift of the Democratic Party.
David Leonhardt
And the Democratic Party has increasingly become a party of college graduates.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's increasingly become a party of professionals and more affluent people.
David Leonhardt
I think part of what's happened is that many Democrats have come to view immigration as a human rights issue.
Sean Rameswaram
And they have focused overwhelmingly on the effect that it has on the immigrants who are coming.
David Leonhardt
And I understand that. When doing that, though, it's part of the Democratic Party's shift away from the values and the interests of working class people in this country.
Sean Rameswaram
If you look at polling, working class people tend to be more communitarian than college graduates.
David Leonhardt
They tend to be more likely to say that they are patriotic.
Sean Rameswaram
They are more likely to say they believe the United States is the best country in the world.
David Leonhardt
They also tend to be in favor of lower levels of immigration.
Sean Rameswaram
And we basically have this situation in which I think the huge surge in immigration, which started in the 1960s on the basis of false promises from the people who passed the law that it wouldn't happen.
David Leonhardt
This huge surge in immigration, I think, has been one of the factors that has caused working class people to look at the Democratic Party and say, that party doesn't represent me.
Sean Rameswaram
And do you see the Democratic Party's approach to immigration in 2023 as monolithic?
David Leonhardt
I don't see it as monolithic, but I do see it as afraid to talk about immigration enforcement in a way that has little precedence in our history.
Sean Rameswaram
So even Joe Biden, who really tries to cast himself as more of a working class or middle class Democrat who has had an immigration policy that is more moderate and more restrictive than many parts of the Democratic Party.
David Leonhardt
Matt Iglesias, the old Vox writer, pointed this out in Substack, which is Biden actually has just announced that he wants to do a bunch of things to try to reduce undocumented immigration.
Sean Rameswaram
And instead of saying, that's because I believe we shouldn't have high levels of undocumented in immigration.
David Leonhardt
Biden has said, I had no choice. The law forces me to do that.
Sean Rameswaram
The border wall, the money was appropriated for the border wall.
David Leonhardt
I tried to get them to reappropriate, to redirect that money. They didn't. They wouldn't.
Sean Rameswaram
And in the meantime, there's nothing under the law other than they have to use the money for what was appropriated.
David Leonhardt
I can't stop that.
Sean Rameswaram
That's an odd thing. Biden there seems to be talking to a group of professional progressive policy people who are quite far left rather than talking to swing voters, multiracial swing voters who polling suggests are quite concerned by the chaos in our immigration system and the fact that basically if people arrive here now, they can often stay for years as long as they set foot in this country, regardless of what American law actually says about how the system works.
David Leonhardt
It sounds like this 1965 law, by your estimation, had the best of intentions, but it sounds like it also might be the reason, if you put all the racism and xenophobia aside, that the argument, make America great again, can be very compelling to some people.
Sean Rameswaram
Is that fair?
David Leonhardt
I think it is fair. And I would add, I would do yes and, as they say in improv comedy.
Sean Rameswaram
I would say it was the start of a way in which immigration was an important contributor to that.
David Leonhardt
I don't want to put it all on that law, but the law is the start of an era.
Sean Rameswaram
The law, as I've already said, is a great civil rights achievement.
David Leonhardt
It's also fundamentally a failure of democracy.
Sean Rameswaram
If people sell a bill to the American people by making repeated promises that it won't do something, and then it goes ahead and does exactly the thing that the law's authors promised it wouldn't do, that does breed cynicism.
David Leonhardt
Just as an immigration system in which laws don't seem to matter that much breeds cynicism.
Sean Rameswaram
And I really do think we have ended up with a system in which people feel like this just isn't really working that well.
David Leonhardt
And how could it be that as a country, we just can't have a policy that does what it says it does?
Sean Rameswaram
David Leonhardt, to read more about this 1965 Immigration Act, the modern American economy, the American dream, check out his new book. It's called Ours Was the Shining Future.
David Leonhardt
Find it wherever you find your books.
Sean Rameswaram
This episode of Today Explained was produced by Amanda Llewellyn, edited by Matthew Collette, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, and mixed by David Herman.
David Leonhardt
Goodbye for now.
Sean Rameswaram
Goodbye for now.