Main Topic: The recent presidential election in Turkey, where incumbent President Recep Tayyip Erdogan won 49.4% of the vote, forcing him into a runoff with opposition challenger Kemal Kilicdaroglu.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noelle King
You will recall that around the time Donald Trump won the presidency in the United States, we started worrying about authoritarian leaders. Turkey's president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, was one of them. He'd followed a similar playbook to Trump's, appealed to a conservative base, largely religious, that felt left out, juiced the economy, and slowly chip away at things like the free press and free speech. And as it did in the U.S., it worked. Erdogan has been very popular among many of his countrymen and countrywomen.
Music fades out
But Turks voted in a presidential election over the weekend, and for the first time in a long time, some cracks started to show. Erdogan lost half the population in a Democratic vote, and he's been forced into a runoff with a challenger.
Music fades in
Coming up on Today Explained, how a bad economy and a very bad earthquake backed an authoritarian leader into a corner.
Music fades out
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most.
Music fades out
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Music fades out
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Music fades out
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King with Humeyra Pamuk. She's a correspondent for Reuters who covers foreign policy.
Humeyra Pamuk
This was indeed a historic election in Turkey. And in the first round, which took place on Sunday, we have seen incumbent president Recep Tayyip Erdogan to garner 49.4 percent of the vote. We do not doubt that the choice of our nation, which gave the majority in the parliament to our alliance, will be in favor of trust and stability.
Noelle King
His rival opposition challenger, Kemal Kalishtaroulu, got around 45 percent of the vote. Kilis Darulu tells them to work for a brighter future. His logo is a heart symbol. Which means that now this race is going to go to a runoff that is going to take place on May the 28th. It's quite the nail-biting, nerve-wracking competition so far.
Why is it so nerve-wracking and nail-biting? Is it just the closeness of the numbers or is it what's at stake here?
Humeyra Pamuk
It is because of what's at stake. This is a historic election for Turkey, and The Economist has declared this as one of the most important elections of 2023. It really is, because Turkey is a major regional power that sits in a geographically unique and valuable place. That geographical advantage allows it to be very instrumental in diplomatic theaters that have global importance.
Noelle King
After months of global grain shortage, negotiators in Turkey say that they have reached a deal to resume grain exports from Ukraine. And Ukraine war is the most recent and best example. Turkey is also a NATO ally and an EU-aspirant country.
Humeyra Pamuk
Why is the election so close? There is a severe economic crisis. At this market, shoppers told us they can only afford to buy a fraction of the groceries they used to. I'm 80 years old and I've never seen such high prices.
Noelle King
Turkish lira has depreciated a great deal. The economy is clearly mismanaged. And there was also only three months ago a devastating earthquake in the southeast that killed 50,000 people. A magnitude 7.8 captured on security cameras, bringing down buildings in an instant.
Humeyra Pamuk
So you can ask the question, why is Tayyip Erdogan able to get nearly half the votes when there are so many reasons that work against him? But Erdogan has the advantages of an incumbent. He represents stability to many people, even though his policies have been the reason why the economy is so bad.
Noelle King
And he's a really skillful politician, and he has made sure that he exploits all of these advantages fully.
Humeyra Pamuk
One of the things that the West is particularly concerned about in Turkey is democracy. So I was looking at a chart a couple of days ago that suggests when Recep Tayyip Erdogan became prime minister in 2003, Turkey became less democratic.
Noelle King
And it continued to become less democratic more and more until today. And by some measures, Turkey is barely a democracy at this point.
Humeyra Pamuk
What happened? What did Erdogan do? In the initial years of Erdogan, a lot of people in the West actually did see him as a model for the rest of the Middle East, as a model democracy. There are a lot of articles in New York Times archives calling him the Muslim Democrat.
Noelle King
For a couple of years, he has actually done reforms to improve liberties and rights and freedoms of women. But that was only for a couple of years. And I think it safe to say that since 2010 we have seen a backsliding in the Turkish democracy.
Humeyra Pamuk
The rights of certain groups of people, Kurds, secularists, these were curtailed. We are looking at journalists being jailed. In Turkey, four journalists and a writer have been charged with being involved in a plot to overthrow the government. All of the men have been fiercely critical of the administration in their writing.
Noelle King
They're accused of membership of a terrorist group and inciting hatred. President Erdogan and his lawyers have filed thousands of criminal complaints against citizens accusing them of insulting the president.
Humeyra Pamuk
And some of these accusations, some of these charges were based on tweets, something a citizen has said in a television broadcast. They have also made new legislation that would allow them to possibly censor what you can say on the internet.
Noelle King
Few could have predicted the scene about to unfold on the floor of the Turkish parliament. Burak Erbay was protesting against a bill that's meant to stamp out this information. But opponents say it'll become another tool to stifle dissent.
Humeyra Pamuk
They have also been in touch with Twitter, trying to restrict some of the accounts. You know, I don't want to hear about Elon Musk talking about free speech ever again. He's literally bowing down to a dictatorship.
Noelle King
So when you look at the big picture, we have seen a democratic backsliding. We have seen a curtailing of human rights, freedoms, definitely the freedom of the press. And that has caused a lot of concern in the West.
Humeyra Pamuk
Despite all of this, Recep Tayyip Erdogan got about half of the vote in this election over the weekend. The people who voted for Erdogan, why don't they mind that Turkey is becoming less democratic? What is Erdogan doing for them?
Noelle King
I think in emerging countries like Turkey, things like human rights, press freedom, they always take a backseat when your primary problem is the economy. Erdogan emerged as the leader of conservative, pious Turks, whose voices had been suppressed in the 1970s.
Humeyra Pamuk
Turkey has had multiple military coups, and it had been for years ran by these army generals who weren't very tolerant of any Islamist tendency. One of the things that happened during the soft coup was the headscarf ban really becoming more entrenched, filtering down into more regulations and banning the headscarf almost completely from public institutions, including universities.
Noelle King
So those groups who have felt long oppressed thought that Erdogan was the leader who represented them. And he did come from humble roots, even though today he does live in a palace in Ankara. And he managed to connect with those people in a way that no other politician was able to.
Humeyra Pamuk
And again, in his initial days, and to a certain extent to date, let's say within the first decade, he has helped pull working class out of poverty. He has made health services much more accessible, build bridges, schools. He really did improve living conditions for millions of Turks.
Noelle King
But again, within his first decade, all of those things have really helped him to create and maintain a really tight and solidified voter base that at the moment is not really paying attention to anything else that's happening because their identity connection with him is really, really strong.
Humeyra Pamuk
OK, he's popular with his base. His base is about half the country. The other half of the country went out this weekend and voted for someone else. Why might Erdogan lose this election? What are his weaknesses?
Noelle King
I think the economy was thought to be the biggest weakness because it was the economy which kept Erdogan in power for so many years. As we said, there were things that wasn't going well, human rights, freedoms, democratic backsliding, judicial independence, rule of law.
Humeyra Pamuk
Turkey has had problems and Turkey has seen its track record basically deteriorate in all of those aspects. But the economic problems have been piling up for several years. Poverty is a real thing. And the second big thing is, again, the devastating earthquake. 50,000 people have been killed. Tens of thousands, if not millions of homes have been destroyed.
Noelle King
And this devastating impact has a lot to do with how Erdogan's government has worked with construction companies and lacks enforcement of safety standards. The results of the first round show us that his base was not very responsive to the economic problems.
Humeyra Pamuk
The conservative people are well aware of the economic problems. They are suffering through that. The people whose homes were destroyed in the devastating earthquake that happened in February, They are well aware that the hardships that they're going through. But the key thing here is they don't see Erdogan as the culprit of this.
Noelle King
I will sacrifice myself for him. This natural disaster was a test from God. Erdogan did what he could and people should be thankful. I am even though I living in a tent.
Humeyra Pamuk
For the earthquake they think it was a natural disaster that came from God And in the end Erdogan is still the best placed person to pull them out of this
Noelle King
When it comes to the economy, Erdogan has been extremely successful in exploiting the post-truth environment. At every instance, he has managed to find another culprit to blame. Every single time people talked about how the economic conditions were bad. He blamed foreign powers. He blamed a so-called interest rate lobby. He blamed the West. He blamed Biden just a day before the election.
Humeyra Pamuk
And when he ran out of people to blame, he said the price of the onion is so expensive because the grocery store owners are artificially keeping it high. So do you see what's happening here?
Noelle King
Yes. He's got a narrative, and it is strongly resonating with millions of people.
Humeyra Pamuk
Coming up, who is the man now posing such a threat to Recep Tayyip Erdogan's power?
Music fades in
Noelle King
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Music fades out
So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Humeyra Pamuk
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft, up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Noelle King
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at chime.com slash explained. That's chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress.
Humeyra Pamuk
Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank NA or Stride Bank NA. Members FDIC. Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs. Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023.
Noelle King
Every day, millions of customers engage with AI agents like me. We resolve queries fast. We work 24-7 and we're helpful, knowledgeable, and empathetic. We're built to be the voice of the brands we serve.
Humeyra Pamuk
Sierra is the platform for building better, more human customer experiences with AI. No hold music, no generic answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Noelle King
It's Today Explained. Humera Pamuk is a correspondent with Reuters. She covers foreign policy. Humera, tell me about the challenger here, Kamal Kilijderalu.
Humeyra Pamuk
So, Kalij Darul was born in the eastern province of Tunceli in Turkey. He's an Alevi, a minority group that follows the faith, drawing on Shiite, Muslim, Sufi, and Anatolian folk traditions. I am Alevi. I'm a sincere Muslim who was raised with the faith of the Prophet Muhammad and Ali.
Noelle King
Before entering politics, he worked in the finance ministry. He then chaired Turkey's social insurance institution. He was a former civil servant. He became a lawmaker in 2002, the year when Erdogan actually came to power. And he rose to prominence as the anti-graft campaigner.
Humeyra Pamuk
And in his campaign for this election, making right the corrupt ways, ending corruption, ending graft, bringing back rule of law was a big part of his rhetoric. We are not going to leave the fate of the Turkish Republic in the hands of one person. And no one will accept the words of just one person.
Noelle King
I've met him in person. He's very mild-mannered, quite different from Erdogan. They call him Turkiyye's Gandhi. Kilic Darulu's colleagues say he's soft-spoken like Mahatma Gandhi and to a certain degree even looks like him. Admittedly, he does lack the charisma that Erdogan has and has helped him convince millions of voters.
Humeyra Pamuk
But he comes across as a very decent, simple and straightforward man. So if Erdogan is this populist conservative who is beloved by people like Donald Trump, where is Khalidjadirulu politically? What does he represent?
Noelle King
It's not super straightforward because, as I said, he's trying to put together a very inclusive platform. He leads the Secular Republican People's Party, or CHP, and also the National Alliance, a group of parties also known as the Table of Six.
Humeyra Pamuk
And that brings together a lot of Turkey's different voices. He is partnering up with an Islamist party, which involves some members who were once in Erdogan's movement. His party is in an informal alliance with the country's Kurds. And of course, he's got the votes of secular CHP.
Noelle King
CHP was established by Modern Turkey founder Mustafa Kemal Atat and CHP has traditionally attracted secular Kemalist voters So to put him in the political spectrum by definition I guess he left because CHP traditionally has been But as mentioned, he is in an alliance with an Islamist party.
Humeyra Pamuk
He's in an alliance with a nationalist party. I think it's fair to say he is trying to put together a very inclusive platform, hoping to appeal to as many Turks as possible. Kamal Kilic Darulu, who focuses on kitchen table issues from his kitchen table. This is the real agenda of the people.
Noelle King
As they all know that when I come to power, there will be democracy. And your purchasing power will increase.
Humeyra Pamuk
OK, so you've got a religious conservative in Erdogan versus a guy who's like, no, we're going to need a broader coalition. And he kind of gathers everyone into the fold. This is Khalid Juralu. Am I reading that right? Is there kind of a culture war within the election?
Noelle King
You are spot on. There are culture wars. And we have seen the electorate vote in line with the cultural war fault lines in this election.
Humeyra Pamuk
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan last weekend branded his opponent pro-LGBT, a supporter of terrorism and a drunkard. That is why, for some, the result has been really surprising, because we have not seen the electorate punish Erdogan because of the state of the economy.
Noelle King
Instead, they felt that they still identify with him and that this connection over identity somehow is far more important reason for them to vote for him than to hold him accountable for the economic mismanagement that has led to their own hardship.
Humeyra Pamuk
I see. So at this point, how likely or unlikely is it that Erdogan loses this election? It's well established that this was one of the most unfair campaign periods because of Erdogan's, you know, outsized advantage when it comes to having resources, when it comes to having airtime on TV, the visibility of opposition candidates.
Noelle King
So you can flip that question and say, against all the odds, there was this incredible resilience and passion to go out, rally behind the opposition, campaign with him on behalf of him, and exercise this one democratic right that many citizens are left with.
Humeyra Pamuk
So you can say 45% against all those odds is pretty remarkable. I'm thinking of that democracy chart and how under, with Erdogan in power, it's ticked down, down, down, down. Every year, Turkey's a bit less democratic.
Noelle King
If Erdogan wins, and many analysts think that he will, what would that say about where Turkey is headed? I don't see any reasons or any signals why Erdogan would suddenly change his course.
Humeyra Pamuk
If he ends up winning, it is going to be a stamp of approval from the people who voted for him that what he has been doing all these years is right and that they like it and that they should continue with it.
Noelle King
Of course, he really needs to find the solution to the deteriorating economic situation because it's really, really unsustainable. Whether or not he takes steps to improve Turkey's human rights track record, press freedoms, freedom of expression, I think we have seen enough to say that he doesn't tend to do those things organically or just on his own, but that if there is enough pressure from the West, that perhaps he might.
Humeyra Pamuk
But we don't see really from the Western countries such a pressure towards Turkey. Turkey is too important for them in other national security priorities. For example, when it comes to Turkey's relations with the United States, Washington considers Ankara as a valuable NATO ally and an important player when it comes to Ukraine war.
Noelle King
Are we going to see President Biden put pressure on President Erdogan so that he would improve his country's human rights track record to the extent that their cooperation perhaps on Ukraine war or overall bilateral relation is going to be put at risk? He's not going to do that.
Humeyra Pamuk
We have not seen Biden administration prioritize human rights advocacy. So it's hard to imagine that Erdogan would change course if he secures the second round, because it's just going to be a stamp of approval from his people that he's doing everything right.
Noelle King
Humaira Pamuk of Reuters.
Music fades in
Today's show was produced by Halima Shah and edited by Amin El-Sadi. It was engineered by Michael Raphael and it was fact-checked by Laura Bullard. I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.