Main Topic: The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and its recent policy changes, including a new rule allowing veterans to choose their doctor in clinics, whether at a VA facility or a private medical center.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Support for this episode of Today Explained comes from the Quip electric toothbrush. Over 1 million people out there have the Quip electric toothbrush, and it starts just $25 at getquip.com slash explained. Right now, when you go there, your first refill pack is free. That's G-E-T-Q-U-I-P dot com slash explained.
Pause
I bet almost anyone could guess the biggest federal agency in the United States. That's right, Bob. It's the Department of Defense. But how about the second biggest? That one's a bit tougher, maybe even surprising. It's the Department of Veterans Affairs.
Pause
But that sort of makes sense, right? The United States spends more on its military than any country in the world. Therefore, the United States should spend a ton of money taking care of its military. But how the United States takes care of its military is changing significantly.
Pause
For the past few years, there's been this effort to overhaul how the VA works. And it's become a political battle involving some really unexpected characters, like Spider-Man. But we'll get to that later.
Pause
First, the big announcement. Well, this really shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone who's been paying attention to what the president has been saying since early in the campaign. Veterans should be guaranteed the right to choose their doctor in clinics, whether at a VA facility or at a private medical center.
Pause
But what this policy, this new policy announcement does is really put that vision into practice in the biggest way that we've seen so far.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf covers the VA for ProPublica. So the VA just announced new rules for when the department will pay for veterans to see private doctors instead of using the government-run health centers that the VA is known for.
Pause
And this is significant because these new rules are much more permissive than they used to be. It looks like they're going to lead to a lot more veterans being eligible for private care, which is likely to cost the government a lot more.
Pause
So what exactly are the details of this policy change? What was the old system and what's the new?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
So the VA has been supplementing its government-run health services with buying private care, basically as long as it's been existed in some circumstances. But since 2014, that's been growing a lot.
Pause
And a lot of what was driving that was this big new program, new in 2014, that is, called CHOICE. This bill covers a lot of ground, from expanding survivor benefits and educational opportunities to improving care for veterans struggling with traumatic brain injury and for victims of sexual assault.
Pause
But today I want to focus on the ways this bill will help us ensure that veterans have access to the care that they've earned.
Pause
The rules under the CHOICE program were, if you had to wait 30 days or travel 40 miles, to get care in the VA, then the VA would pay for you to go to a private doctor.
Pause
And there were a lot of problems with the implementation of the Choice Program. It ended up being really complicated and confusing.
Pause
The contractor that they hired to do this would send veterans to doctors in different states or to the wrong kind of doctor and make all kinds of mistakes and was charging these administrative fees that were really out of line with industry standards.
Pause
So there was a pretty widespread understanding that this program wasn't working.
Pause
They thought that this 30-day, 40-mile thing was pretty arbitrary, and they wanted to replace it with something that would make more sense from a medical perspective.
Pause
So now we've got this new announcement, and instead of 30 days, they're making it 20 days for primary care and 28 days for specialty care.
Pause
Okay. And instead of 40 miles, they're making it a 30-minute drive for primary care, or a 60-minute drive for specialty care.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And that has a lot of people saying, well, hang on, that really sounds a lot like 30 days and 40 miles, just like a little bit of a different variation on that.
Pause
And that's one of the complaints that we've been hearing from lawmakers and veterans groups.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
So if the problem was that this is arbitrary, how is this any less arbitrary?
Pause
Okay, so there's a lot there, though. The VA has been ramping up its privatization over the past few years, and one of the major areas they're focusing on is when and where exactly veterans get their care.
Pause
What are the other concerns?
Pause
So there are a number of concerns. There's actually a lot of evidence that wait times are lower in the VA than in the private sector and the law is supposed to require that if the VA is sending veterans out into the private sector because they can get seen soon enough in the VA They supposed to make sure that they can actually get that care in the time that they needed in the private sector but the VA hasn't said how they really going to accomplish that
Pause
There's also a big concern about the quality, and there's a lot of research that shows that the quality of care in the VA is better than what veterans can get in their communities.
Pause
And then finally, the big question is what this is going to cost since, generally speaking, private sector care is more expensive and private sector doctors are paid by the services that they perform as opposed to being salaried like in the VA.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And what about the VA itself? If all this money is going to private companies, what does that do to the VA system?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
So that's the concern that a lot of lawmakers and veterans groups are raising is that is the administration going to cannibalize the VA's own health system in order to pay for all this private care?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And we don't really know the answer to that until we get the president's budget and we see are they planning to increase the funding to private care as well as to the VA's own care? Or are they just going to be moving that money over from the VA's health system and shifting that out to the private sector?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
How does this shake out politically? Do these changes have bipartisan support or are they divisive?
Pause
Democrats generally oppose them. They say that they're putting the VA on a path toward privatization.
Pause
And there's a lot of opposition or at least skepticism from veterans groups that really support the VA, that their members use the VA, rely on the VA, and they want to protect those benefits.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But you mentioned some of these changes started in 2014, right, when Obama was president. Who really pushed to make these changes in the first place?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
This push really started in 2014 in response to a wait time scandal at the VA hospital in Phoenix.
Pause
There were 1,700 veterans needing medical care, 1,700 that were on no waiting list at all. And what the report says, and I just want to read it very quickly. Please do.
Pause
These veterans were and continue to be at risk of being forgotten or lost.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And Republicans really seized on that to advocate for opening up the doors to sending more veterans to the private sector in response to that.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
One of the sources of that was a group called Concerned Veterans for America, which is funded by the Koch brothers.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And a key person from that group then got a job on the Trump transition and was one of the key people in the administration who was writing these new policies.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
How did taking care of veterans become a thing that was divisive, a thing that the Koch brothers threw money at?
Pause
Generally, this became a partisan issue because for small government conservatives who look at the federal government and say, this is too big, they kind of point to the VA as the epitome of bloated bureaucracy.
Pause
They want to reduce the footprint of the federal government in general.
Pause
The other reason that this became more controversial in recent years is because of the broader debate about health care.
Pause
And I think you saw a lot of liberals pointing to the VA as sort of an example of successful socialized medicine in a certain sense.
Pause
And for conservatives who are opposed to a greater role for the government in health care or opposed to the Affordable Care Act, then the stakes of what happens with the VA have some resonance in that debate.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
The Koch brothers aren't the only shadowy figures taking an interest in the VA. Spider-Man and his boss are coming up next on Today Explained.
Pause
Let's talk about toothbrushes for a moment here if we can.
Pause
The standard electric toothbrush can be kind of abrasive, can be kind of loud, can be kind of rough.
Pause
The Clip electric toothbrush has sensitive sonic vibrations, and it makes for an effective clean that's gentle on your sensitive gums.
Pause
Plus, it's got this cool fancy timer that pulses every 30 seconds to remind you when to switch sides.
Pause
And there's this whole situation with this cover that works as a stand, but it also is a mount and it slides over your bristles to pack and protect your quip when you're on the go.
Pause
The quip electric toothbrush has been sold to more than a million mouths in this world and it starts at just 25 if you go to getquip.com explained right now you get your first refill pack for free that is g explained to get the clip along with some free refills
Pause
Isaac, how exactly does Spider-Man figure into this story?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
So if you remember during the transition, there was this period where Trump was basically asking a bunch of his rich friends to do various things in the administration.
Pause
One of these guys was Ike Perlmutter, who's the chairman of Marvel Entertainment and a longtime acquaintance of Trump's and a member of his Mar-a-Lago club.
Pause
And what Perlmutter said he wanted to help with was veterans.
Pause
He then brought along a Palm Beach doctor who specializes in serving very wealthy clients and a lawyer who does not have any – well, none of them have any government experience or has served in the U.S. military or really has any experience working on veterans policy.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, I guess I get a doctor and a lawyer, but why would the head of Marvel want to help reform the VA?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
Well, he fought for Israel in the Six-Day War, so people think that he seems to have an interest in it for that reason.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But it's true that he certainly has no government experience and has no experience with the U.S. military.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
So what exactly does this trio do first?
Pause
So the first thing, and this is still during the transition, is they convene a meeting of private health care executives to talk about the future of the VA.
Pause
And two important things happen at that meeting. One is the name David Shulkin comes up, which has a lot to do with how he ended up being the first VA secretary.
Pause
And the other that happens is they put forward this idea that instead of using a software that it invented for keeping track of patient health records, that the VA should switch to a private vendor like the private industry uses and completely transform the software that the hospital systems use.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So they come up with a pick for the VA and they sort of ditch the software.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
What happens next?
Pause
Once Shulkin is the nominee, he comes down to Mar-a-Lago to meet with them, and they establish this relationship where they talk very frequently, they weigh in on what policies they like or they don't like, and what people they do or don't like for various jobs, and they really kind of act like a shadow leadership for the department.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Certainly a lot of the duly appointed and Senate-confirmed officials thought it was weird that they had to take direction from Mar-a-Lago.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
Some of the things that these three guys were asking for really had to do with their own pet interests rather than things that people who did have experience and expertise working with veterans thought were important.
Pause
So, for example, the doctor wanted the VA to work with Apple to make a new version of an app that he had made finding nearby medical services.
Pause
And the VA and Apple sort of said, well, thank you very much for the introduction. Here are all these ways where we think that we could really help veterans by having a collaboration between the VA and Apple.
Pause
And the doctor said, but I don't want you to do those things. I want you to do this app thing because that's what I said.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And another example is a promotional event around the time of Veterans Day that Ike Perlmutter, the chairman of Marvel, put in motion, which eventually involved the secretary of the VA ringing the closing bell at the New York Stock Exchange with Disney, which is Marvel's parent company.
Pause
So it's a pretty weird image of the VA secretary standing next to Spider-Man and Captain America.
Pause
Is that meant to help the VA or to help like Spider-Man and the Disney brand?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
This is a question that they posed to the VA's ethics lawyers before doing the event because they recognized that it was questionable.
Pause
And I don't know the answer that that official provided because when I got the emails through the Freedom of Information Act, that part was redacted.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Meanwhile, how does the new head of the VA feel about all of this sort of like outside influence?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
By the end, things really frayed between Shulkin and the Mar-a-Lago crowd.
Pause
They felt like he wasn't listening to them and wasn't doing what they wanted.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And after Trump fired Shulkin, the temporary guy who was in charge was in very close contact with the Mar-a-Lago crowd.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
They really got along swimmingly with him, even though he made a lot of enemies on Capitol Hill.
Pause
And then they also met with Wilkie, who became the next VA secretary, and that sort of cleared the way for Wilkie to then become the nominee.
Pause
And Wilkie, after meeting with them, he made a really interesting comment.
Pause
He said, no matter how long I am here, there is a template in place based on your efforts to move this institution out of the industrial age.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
One thing I don't get here is how nobody got upset about all this.
Pause
I mean, this Marvel executive is sort of brought in, and then all of a sudden Captain America and Spider-Man are doing a promotional event with the VA This seems shady and also like something people would notice
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
November 2017 even if you watching the closing bell of the New York Stock Exchange every day, which I really don't know why you would, but you wouldn't have known the backstory of why the VA secretary was standing next to Captain America, right?
Pause
If Ike Perlmutter wanted to run the VA, Trump could have nominated him for VA secretary.
Pause
But Ike Perlmutter is such a secretive guy that he reportedly showed up at an Iron Man movie premiere wearing a glasses and mustache disguise.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So he obviously was not going to submit to a Senate confirmation hearing.
Pause
So this whole thing was set up to not be subject to the kind of transparency that usually attaches to government service.
Pause
And so once my reporting shed that light on it and people became aware of what was going on, there was a lot of opposition to it.
Pause
So you published a big story in August 2018 about these three friends of the president who had a major influence at the VA.
Pause
What happened once you shed light on them?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
The House Democrats opened an investigation.
Pause
The Government Accountability Office is going to investigate a veterans group sued under a law from the Watergate era that says if the government is consulting outside people on policy, then they need to be transparent about that.
Pause
They need to make certain disclosures about that. And that wasn't done here.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
And that lawsuit is still pending.
Pause
But the relationship between the shadow trio and the VA is still in place?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
Well, I mean, because of the pressure that the secretary came under from lawmakers who thought this wasn't an acceptable situation, he has had to distance himself from them and cut off contact with them.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But they still had a pretty good run.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
Certainly the most significant one is going back to that new software system.
Pause
That program is off to a really rough start.
Pause
A recent progress report said that the program was, quote, yellow trending towards red.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So not really the direction that you want to be going in when you have patient safety on the line.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
You know, the other thing that they were involved in that goes back to what we were talking about earlier is they really liked the idea of having executives from private hospital systems come into the VA and make recommendations about which services the VA should provide itself versus which services the VA should outsource to private healthcare systems like the ones that those executives led, which is sort of a fox henhouse situation.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
in a lot of people's eyes.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
That idea didn't go anywhere directly, but it gives you a sense of the perspective that they're coming to this with, you know, again, being private sector people as opposed to people with any government experience and how that relates to this wider controversy of what's the right balance between the government-run healthcare system and the private sector.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
So what should people take away from this VA reform that's going on right now and how the Trump administration is handling it?
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
A lot of the sort of chaos that you're seeing coming out of the VA, people might remember around a few months ago the problem with errors in student stipends, the problems that the VA is now having with this overhaul of its electronic health records, the controversy around this new policy they just announced.
Pause
All these things stem from just the upheaval that the administration is sort of known for coming to the VA.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
But what makes the VA different from a lot of the other agencies is when we think about nominating Scott Pruitt to the EPA saying he wants to roll back environmental protections or nominating Rick Perry to the Energy Department after saying he wanted to eliminate the Energy Department.
Pause
But by contrast, after everything that Trump said about veterans, of course, he was not going to be explicit about wanting to undermine the VA.
Pause
That wouldn't make any sense.
Pause
Isaac Arnsdorf
And so what's been interesting in reporting on this is, are the solutions that he's presenting to the VA actually what veterans support and actually leading to better results for veterans?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Isaac Arnsdorf covers national politics at ProPublica.
Pause
I'm Sean Ramos from This is Today Explained.
Pause
Thanks again to the Quip Electric Toothbrush for supporting this show today.
Pause
Over 1 million people have purchased the Quip.
Pause
Not all of them went to getquip.com slash explained, I'm guessing.
Pause
But if you go there right now, your first refill pack is free.
Pause
The Quip starts at $25 at getquip.com slash explained with your first refill pack free.