Main Topic: The shift in Silicon Valley's values and support towards Donald Trump's reelection campaign, particularly with the emergence of a new faction led by Elon Musk.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
Coming up on Today Explained, Elon Musk interviewed Donald Trump on X, formerly known as Twitter spaces, last night.
Short pause
From Trump, there was nothing much new. Immigration, crime, inflation, that catty semi-defense of President Biden. And say what you want. This was a coup. This was a coup of a president of the United States. He didn't want to leave and they said we can do it the nice way or we can do it the hard way. They just took him out back behind the shed and basically shot him.
Short pause
No, it's actually Elon that's undergone an evolution. I've not been very political before. I supported Obama. I stood in line for six hours to shake Obama's hand when he was running for president. And so it's not like I'm like some sort of dyed-in-the-wool long-term Republican. I'm actually...
Short pause
Both campaigns want Silicon Valley's support and money. Now, historically, it's gone to the Democrats. But this year, Musk is at the vanguard of a shift in the Valley's values. And some tech titans are Trump-curious.
Short pause
Well, I want to thank you. And, you know, I actually always did think of you as somewhat left. I must say that. So it's even more of an honor to have your endorsement. I know how strong you feel about it.
Short pause
Support for this show comes from Strawberry.me. Be honest. Are you happy with your job? Or are you stuck in one you've outgrown? Or never wanted in the first place? Sure, you can probably list the reasons for staying. But are they actually just excuses for not leaving? Let a career coach from Strawberry.me help you get unstuck. Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Short pause
Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts. From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look. Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
Short pause
Explained. 2024 Explained. Emily Glazer is with us. She's a reporter at the Wall Street Journal. Hilariously, what I do changes a lot each day. I write about people in power and those that have great influence and wealth. And so a lot of that has been about Elon Musk in recent years. But I've also kind of thought about how the money world applies to politics a lot. It's something I wrote about in 2020 and is super relevant these days, too.
Short pause
Emily Glazer
Silicon Valley is going to pour money into this election, as you've reported. The question is, who will it go to? Let's start with the Dems and Kamala Harris. So let's go back in time a little bit. Kamala Harris brings this home court advantage in a way to California and Silicon Valley. Two middle class kids. One, a daughter of Oakland, California. Her ties really began during the time she spent mingling with San Francisco's tech community when she was San Francisco district attorney, and that was between 2004 and 2010.
Short pause
So when she became the presumptive Democratic nominee, you better believe that people, you know, got off their seats and the money began pouring in for her and the very vocal endorsements. So we've got folks like LinkedIn co-founder Reid Hoffman. Within minutes of Biden exiting the race, he was all in on Kamala.
Short pause
Well, I was already a great supporter of the Biden-Harris ticket. I'm continuing those efforts and redoubling them. I'd already maxed out to Biden-Harris. Am I allowed to put in more money to Harris?
Short pause
Ron Conway, who is like the venture capitalist, many people follow his view on politics. He endorsed Harris, you know, right away. And we've seen that even travel through to recent days where this group, you know, VCs for Kamala, raised $150,000 on a Zoom fundraiser.
Short pause
So it goes from the top, top, top wealthy people to others working in the industry. You mention, of course, Kamala Harris has very deep roots in the Bay Area. If we were to look specifically about how those local connections are turning out to help her or might turn out to help her, what are we looking at here?
Short pause
Well, Kamala Harris, you know, she lives now when she's not in Washington, D.C. She lives in Los Angeles with her husband, Doug Emhoff. And she just has a number of people that have been very longtime supporters of hers. I talked to several donors that have backed her, you know, when she was attorney general of California.
Short pause
I believe in that old adage, so goes California, goes the rest of the country. So in that way, you know, we have Silicon Valley. We have produced great things that have changed the way that America lives. Of course, she was senator of California. So she's just spent decades of her political career in California.
Short pause
It doesn't mean that all of those people agree with every single policy she has. And in fact, I think, you know, she isn't necessarily this like super pro-business candidate. But there are a lot of people that have interacted with her over the years. I was chatting with a CEO of a cloud company the other day that is very vocally, you know, pro-Kamala.
Short pause
And even they said, oh, you know, we had a fundraiser for her like a decade ago before her senator days. So I think you can't really wipe away someone's history or roots or time spent in a state. And that undoubtedly would help them if, you know, they've got a bunch of supporters and it's a left-leaning area to begin with.
Short pause
She has a brother-in-law who works for Uber but has taken some time to work for the campaign, right? Yes, Tony West. And so Tony West used to work in the Department of Justice So you know he does have government experience as well He is the husband of Kamala sister Maya He is taking time off to advise on the campaign
Short pause
There's always questions around having family members, you know, advise with the campaign and what that could mean if she should win the White House. So I think there's a little bit of like ruffled feathers around that. And also Uber, you know, as a major tech company, has gone through a lot of litigation.
Short pause
He had some big wins around how, you know, the gig economy is paid, how their workers are, I should say, how their drivers are paid. California voters appear to have approved Proposition 22. Now, this means app-based drivers in the state will likely be able to remain as independent contractors instead of employees.
Short pause
They've had some big wins on that that I think some Democrats in the state really did not agree with Uber's opinion. They've done a lot of lobbying that has angered some people. So it's not just about threatening the drivers anymore. They're actually threatening the passengers by saying that if we have to pay our drivers a fair wage, we're going to shut down operations in all of California.
Short pause
So, you know, I think like a number of candidates, there are always people that have views on who their advisors are. And there are definitely people that are super pro-Tony West and think he's very smart. And they emphasize that he hasn't only worked at Uber as their general counsel.
Short pause
And then there are others that kind of feel like he's part of the big bad tech, you know, community that isn't always the most sympathetic or empathetic to the average worker or particularly gig workers, which is very potent and present in California.
Short pause
What is Silicon Valley like about Harris's policies? So we are waiting to find out more about exactly what her policies are. I'm actually going to start there because I think that what I have heard from CEOs, from big supporters are what they are looking for and what they're hopeful for.
Short pause
But we don't know exactly what they are just yet. And obviously this all happened very quickly. But what I think they are hopeful for is good policies on immigration so that if workers are coming over from outside of the U.S., particularly high-skill workers where especially there's a lot of engineers that tend to come from outside the U.S. and are really clutch talent for major tech companies, big and small, they're hoping to have some good policy on that.
Short pause
There is such a desire to have what I think a lot of people refer to as smart artificial intelligence regulation. I think some folks would consider that to mean light artificial intelligence regulation. Almost certainly. Especially because we've already seen regulations come down in Europe.
Short pause
Right now in the U.S., there's a White House executive order, but there really isn't too much. And that's a big, big question mark. And notably, they are hoping for a much lighter touch for antitrust regulation. Under the Biden administration, the Federal Trade Commission led by Lena Kahn and the DOJ have really had a very aggressive stance on antitrust.
Short pause
And that has blocked a number of deals from going through. And so it's not just the tech community. The business community at large is really hoping that that could change under a potential Harris administration.
Short pause
There are a lot of areas where her politics line up with Silicon Valley's politics. What are the areas that she may still need to convince the tech sector on? Taxes. You know, I think that Trump has been very vocal. And look, during his administration, he lowered the corporate tax rate.
Short pause
So a lot of business people really have enjoyed that and reaped the rewards from that. So we'll see where Harris comes in on taxes. And crypto, of course, there are so many questions about what is the future of cryptocurrency regulation.
Short pause
Under the Biden administration, the Securities and Exchange Commission led by Gary Gensler has been extremely tough on crypto regulation. So tough, in fact, that a number of people have said that they really became more anti-Biden and looking for another candidate to support because they felt crushed that their business was crushed.
Short pause
On day one, I will fire Gary Gensler. I think it's kind of clear where tech executives and loud voices in tech are frustrated. Antitrust regulation, cryptocurrency regulation and questions around AI regulation are big ones.
Short pause
And then, you know, we'll see how she rolls out policies in her platform that may be similar or different to what we're seeing now. I just don't think we should expect like a total 180 because she is the vice president right now.
Short pause
It's not like she's not in this administration. All right. So to read a lot of the news over the past week or so, one might get the misimpression that everybody loves Kamala Harris. Does everyone in Silicon Valley like Kamala Harris? No. No, they don't.
Short pause
We've seen this remarkable shift. It's not huge yet, but there are a lot of loud voices that are pro-Trump. And one in particular that has a lot of weight is Elon Musk. And that has kind of led to this much more vocal shift with some people in the tech community really going all in for Trump.
Short pause
And that is a pretty big change in what we've seen before from such a left-leaning part of the country. Emily Glazer, Wall Street Journal.
Short pause
Noel King
Coming up, we're going to talk about Elon Musk and Donald Trump and the Republicans writ large. Emily, thanks so much. Thank you.
Short pause
anywhere else. Browlington. Deals. Brands Wow Mint is still a month for premium wireless And if you've made the switch yet here are 15 reasons why you should One it a month Two seriously it a month Three, no big contracts. Four, I use it. Five, my mom uses it.
Short pause
Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 per three-month plan. $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See MintMobile.com.
Short pause
You're listening to Today Explained. All right, Emily, in the first half of the show, you told us that leading tech bro Elon Musk has found himself very compelled by Donald Trump. And Elon Musk is nothing, weirdly, if not influential. Tell me about the faction that is moving toward Trump and what is motivating them.
Short pause
Emily Glazer
So there is a group, you know, in theory led by Elon Musk, I think because he's at times the wealthiest person in the world, but a lot of his close associates are very active in this as well. And they have created a political action committee, the America PAC.
Short pause
It's relatively new, and it's not just Elon Musk who's behind it. It's tech investor Joe Lonsdale, tech investor David Sachs, Antonio Grazias, a former Tesla board member and current SpaceX board member, the investor Kenneth Howery, Sequoia Capital Partners, Sean McGuire and Doug Leone.
Short pause
Both Sequoia is a huge investor in a lot of Elon Musk's companies. So there's a lot of people that are listed on this Federal Election Commission filing for the PAC that are very close to Elon. And they've raised an enormous amount of money already, millions that have been reported.
Short pause
But the Wall Street Journal has reported, you know, an article I worked on with my colleagues, that Musk has privately said he plans to commit around $45 million a month to this super PAC. So it has some big names, but it also has some really big money too.
Short pause
I will say that Musk posted on X a meme in response to our article with the caption, fake news. And he later said on X that he had created a PAC and that funding to date has been far below that level. But we stand by our reporting. You know, that is what we had heard.
Short pause
And we're continuing to actively report on this political action committee and what kind of money is behind it. What do these folks, these men, what do they see in Donald Trump? What do they like about him?
Short pause
In many ways, I think what they like about Donald Trump is what they don't like about the Biden administration. For example, we've talked about the cryptocurrency regulation under Biden. They want much lighter regulation and are hoping that a potential Trump administration could bring them that.
Short pause
I pledge to the Bitcoin community that the day I take the oath of office, Joe Biden, Kamala Harris's anti-crypto crusade will be over. It will end. It'll be done. It'll be done.
Short pause
They want a major change in antitrust regulation. Most of them do not like Lena Kahn. If I had to defend Google, I would still say that it's still better run, even in its silly, woke way, even in a slightly troll-like, toll-collecting way, than whatever completely destructive path Lena Kahn would have for the company.
Short pause
They're also hoping for very light AI regulation since there's a lot of potential around how that is shaped in the coming years, the coming months. And some of them, this is all about social issues. Elon Musk is known for calling things kind of the woke mind virus.
Short pause
And the outcome of that mind virus is very clear if you walk around the streets of downtown San Francisco. It is the end of civilization. And I would also say for some of them, they're one issue voters. They really are pro-Israel, and they think that under a potential Trump administration, it would be much more pro-Israel than where the Biden administration is right now.
Short pause
So I would say it's a mix of a lot. But for many of these people, it does come down to business. It does come down to money, and they want lighter regulation. Donald Trump has expressed anti-big tech sentiments in the past. Has that meant anything for his relationship with Silicon Valley? Does it matter anymore?
Short pause
I think there's a lot of things that Donald Trump has said in the past that he switched on after, which, by the way, a lot of politicians do on the left and the right. These days, he is completely embracing Elon Musk's endorsement of him.
Short pause
To go back in time a little bit, Trump had the assassination attempt. It was on a Saturday night. And we and others had been reporting about the deepening ties between Musk and Trump. You know, they went from trading barbs in 2022.
Short pause
Elon is not going to buy Twitter. Nah, he's got himself a mess. You know, he said the other day, oh, I've never voted for a Republican. I said, I didn't know that. He told me he voted for me. So he's another bullshit artist, but he's not going to be buying it.
Short pause
Musk recently tweeting, I don't hate the man, but it's time for Trump to hang up his hat and sail into the sunset. And then this assassination attempt happened, and pretty soon after, Elon Musk very vocally endorsed Donald Trump on Twitter.
Short pause
And then after that, it's been like the floodgates were open, and Elon Musk has been very pro-Trump and complimentary of him since that moment. It wasn't just like the teasing and kind of flirting with the idea that Musk had done before.
Short pause
Go back in time for me a bit, and let's talk about how Musk has evolved on this. So Elon Musk, you know, he had donated to both Democrats and Republicans in the past. We did an analysis of Federal Election Commission data.
Short pause
That's where you can see where individuals are donating. And that's what we would call hard money, so where you could see it reported as opposed to soft money, which often is a little bit harder to track. Elon Musk had given to both Democrats and Republicans over the years.
Short pause
And so he gave a lot to Obama. And under the Obama administration, that was when SpaceX was really, you know, becoming a bigger and more important player in the space industry.
Short pause
On Thursday he was on hand at Cape Canaveral to greet the president and show off his Falcon 9 rocket Well congratulations This is terrific Thank you very much How the car doing It doing great actually
Short pause
I think a lot of that changed a couple of years ago where he said that he was more of a Republican and would be voting that way in the 2022 midterms And, you know, his politics more publicly had started to shift.
Short pause
Yeah, so here we are at Eagle Pass, and we're going to be meeting with the sort of major officials and law enforcement responsible for the water. I would say that changed even more in the last six to 12 months.
Short pause
In March, there were reports that Elon Musk had met with Donald Trump. We know this was at Nelson Peltz's oceanfront compound in Palm Beach and that there were a number of pro-Trump supporters there.
Short pause
It was a pretty casual breakfast gathering, but Elon Musk brought one of his children and Donald Trump's younger son, Barron, was there. So it was a bit of like a family affair too.
Short pause
And from there, I felt like it was a little bit of like off to the races. And we had also reported then in May that there had been some informal conversations between Musk and Trump that Musk could have some kind of advisory role should Donald Trump get reelected.
Short pause
And we knew that they were talking and Musk would call Trump directly on his cell phone. And even though at that point Musk had publicly said he wasn't donating to either side, there was already this kind of feeling that he was becoming more and more pro-Trump and more and more anti-Biden.
Short pause
Did something happen between Elon Musk and Joe Biden? Several things happened. But we reported a few weeks ago how there really was this break in their rapport, which I think kind of catapulted Musk toward the right.
Short pause
And a lot of that is rooted in how the Biden administration and particularly Joe Biden snubbed Elon Musk when it came to electric vehicles. There was this EV gathering in August 2021.
Short pause
You know, really large car companies were there, Ford, GM, the Chrysler parent company, Stellantis. And notably absent was Tesla, even though Tesla had been producing the most electric vehicles in the United States.
Short pause
And Elon Musk was pissed. Then Biden went on to add insult to injury and publicly said that GM was leading the electric car revolution. This was in the same quarter that Tesla made 300,000 electric cars and GM made 26.
Short pause
Does that seem fair to you? The Biden team did try to smooth things over. They had advisors reach out to Elon's people. Some of these advisors even reached out to Elon himself. But it didn't really improve much from there.
Short pause
And so there's like a lot of reasons why Elon Musk has shifted away from Democrats. But with Biden in particular, I do think it goes down to the way he was treated around EVs.
Short pause
What, other than money, what is support from Elon Musk and the rest in Silicon Valley who are pro-Trump or Trump curious? What does it look like? Well, I think that part of their support, and it's grown even more, is that Trump named J.D. Vance his vice presidential pick.
Short pause
And J.D. Vance is someone that worked briefly but still worked as a venture capitalist under Peter Thiel, who for quite some time was like the only really big name in Silicon Valley who was a Republican.
Short pause
And so I think that, you know, going back to June, David Sachs co-hosted this fundraiser for Trump in San Francisco. And you've got J.D. Vance speaking, you know, unscripted at David Sachs' home there and kind of alluding to lighter AI regulation.
Short pause
He's kind of speaking and preaching to the, you know, an audience that was really just eating up everything that he was saying. And so I think that a lot of people that were already pro-Trump or already anti-Biden really cheered J.D. Vance on that VP ticket.
Short pause
So I think that's something that they're also thinking about when it comes to Donald Trump's reelection campaign as well.
Short pause
Let's close out by talking big picture. Why does a rightward shift, including some powerful people but not including everyone, why does a rightward shift in Silicon Valley matter? Does it indicate anything bigger about what's going on in tech or in the world more broadly?
Short pause
It can, but I also think we shouldn't overstate the shift. You know, there's a small number of very loud voices that are behind Trump's reelection campaign, and you can't ignore them. It's definitely there. There's definitely a movement.
Short pause
But when I've talked to different people in tech, for the people who are kind of the soldiers in the field, the engineers working day to day, who still might be like very wealthy compared to the rest of the country, I don't think that it's something where they can scream and shout from their rooftops that they support Donald Trump.
Short pause
It's kind of this still somewhat insular community in Silicon Valley. And, you know, with Kamala Harris getting this really big start, the big question that I have heard from a lot of people is what happens after Labor Day?
Short pause
There's this honeymoon phase that a lot of Democrats are in right now. There's been this massive fundraising haul for Harris. You know, a lot of excitement around the VP pick. The Democratic Convention is going to be happening soon.
Short pause
But it's going to quiet down after that. And there still is a lot of support for Donald Trump and J.D. Vance. And so it's one of those things where we're going to have to see how this all plays out in the fall.
Short pause
Noel King
Emily Glazer of The Wall Street Journal. This was great. Thanks for taking the time, Emily. Thank you.
Short pause
Today's episode was produced by Amanda Llewellyn and edited by Amina El-Sadi. It was fact-checked by Laura Bullard and engineered by Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristen's daughter.
Short pause
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained.