Main Topic: The 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre and its Legacy
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Jamil Smith
I'm Vox Senior Correspondent Jamil Smith, sitting in for Sean Rameswaram. Back in 1921, if you were Black and lived in Tulsa's Greenwood District, you pretty much never needed to leave. You would find hotels, beauty salons, barbershops, movie theaters, dance halls, pool halls, grocery stores, restaurants, haberdasheries, clothing stores, shoe shine shops, jazz clubs, and a number of service providers, including doctors, lawyers, accountants, and dentists.
Hannibal Johnson
That's Hannibal Johnson. He's an author, attorney, and he serves on the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre Centennial Commission.
Jamil Smith
Now, Greenwood was one of many communities throughout the former Oklahoma Territory that was founded after the U.S. government and others parceled out former indigenous tribal lands to formerly enslaved Black people. That ability to own land set the foundation for Greenwood to become one of the most prosperous Black communities in the United States until Memorial Day of 1921.
Hannibal Johnson
The incident happened on Monday, May 30th, 1921, which happened to be Memorial Day. Dick Rowland was at work shining shoes. He needed to use the restroom. Tulsa was a highly segregated city. He knew that his options were limited. He knew of a restroom in a downtown building called the Drexel Building on an upper floor. He walked over to the Drexel Building, entered the building, boarded the elevator. Something happened on the elevator. We'll never know exactly what it was, but it apparently caused the elevator to jerk or to lurch. Dick Rowland bumped into or perhaps brushed up against Sarah Page. She overreacted, began to scream. The elevator landed in the lobby. Dick Rowland, frightened, ran from the elevator. Sarah Page, distraught, exited the elevator, and she was comforted by a clerk from Renberg's, a locally owned store. She told him of being assaulted in the elevator. He was concerned and he called the police.
Jamil Smith
She would later recant, retract that original version of the story, refuse to cooperate with prosecutors after they arrested Dick Rowland for the attempted assault. The next day, May 31st, 1921, the Tulsa Tribune ran a story entitled, NAB Negro for Attacking Girl in an Elevator. It was a false narrative of an attempted rape in broad daylight in a public building in downtown Tulsa.
Hannibal Johnson
A large white mob, mostly white men gathered on the lawn of the courthouse. And there were rumors among the white mob that they were going to attempt to overpower law enforcement and lynch Dick Rowland. Eventually, a group of several dozen Black men marched down to the courthouse, intent on protecting Dick Rowland from what they thought would be a certain death by lynching.
Jamil Smith
As they approached, words were exchanged between the much larger white group, which numbered ultimately in the thousands, and the smaller Black group, several dozen men. A white man tried to take a Black man's gun. The gun discharged. And in the words of one of the survivors of the massacre, all hell broke loose after that.
Hannibal Johnson
So the violence lasted roughly 16 hours. And Black men put up a vigorous, robust defense initially, but it was short-lived because they were outnumbered, outgunned, overmatched. The teeming white mobs spilled over into the Greenwood community, the Black community, Black Wall Street, destroying everything in sight, burning, shooting, looting.
Jamil Smith
Many of the men in the white mob had been deputized by local law enforcement. They prevented the Tulsa Fire Department from putting out the fires that raged. Airplanes flew overhead, officially, on reconnaissance missions. But according to a number of eyewitnesses and survivors, the planes either strafed the community with bullets and or dropped some sort of incendiary devices on the community.
Hannibal Johnson
When the dust settled, most people who have looked at this believe somewhere between 100 and 300 people, most of them Black, were killed. Hundreds more were injured. At least 1,250 homes in the Black community were destroyed, as were scores of businesses and other commercial establishments. Property damage conservatively estimated at the time was $1.5 to $2 million. Again, that's a lowball estimate, but even that translates to well over $25 million today.
Jamil Smith
Many Black folks spent days living in internment centers throughout the city, very much like people of Japanese ancestry were interned during World War II.
Hannibal Johnson
The real narrative here, though, is that of the indomitable human spirit because even as the embers from the massacre still smoldered, the Black community began to rebuild and rebuilt sufficiently by 1925 to host the national meeting of the National Negro Business League, which is Booker T. Washington's Black Chamber of Commerce.
Jamil Smith
By the early to mid-1940s, there were well over 200 documented Black-owned and operated businesses back in the Greenwood District.
Hannibal Johnson
So this is the story of the human spirit. What happened to the Black community in Tulsa, this pogrom? I mean, it's not something I learned about in school. Same goes for a lot of Americans.
Jamil Smith
Can you tell us how you first learned about this and how you view the silencing of this particular tragedy?
Hannibal Johnson
I would say first that we don't do a good job here in America, more generally, in talking about hard history, history that's not pretty. We tend to want to sanitize history and marginalize the history of people of color, let's just be honest. And Tulsa is no exception.
Jamil Smith
There are a number of psychological dynamics that really feed into that tendency to silence or erase this history. And Tulsa specifically, think about 1921, what was Tulsa doing? Tulsa was on an upward trajectory toward becoming the self-described oil capital of the world.
Hannibal Johnson
So the leaders of Tulsa, these were white men, didn't want this stain on Tulsa's reputation. They were trying to position Tulsa as a cosmopolitan city. So they wanted to create a pristine reputation for the community. So not talking about this, pretending it never happened, was part of that desire.
Jamil Smith
There was also, in 1921, after the massacre, shame in sectors of the white community. Shame that they had allowed this to happen here in Tulsa, a city that they took great pride in.
Hannibal Johnson
In the Black community, there was post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, and fear associated with the event. Fear that the event could recur if they would step outside their place.
Jamil Smith
When you talk to some of the survivors, many of the survivors were living 20 years ago. There was a commission that studied these events and interviewed survivors between 1997 and 2001.
Hannibal Johnson
I was here then. I had the privilege of meeting some of the survivors who had really vivid memories of the event.
Jamil Smith
The real narrative here, though, is that of the indomitable human spirit because even as the embers from the massacre still smoldered, the Black community began to rebuild and rebuilt sufficiently by 1925 to host the national meeting of the National Negro Business League, which is Booker T. Washington's Black Chamber of Commerce.
Hannibal Johnson
By the early to mid-1940s, there were well over 200 documented Black-owned and operated businesses back in the Greenwood District.
Jamil Smith
So this is the story of the human spirit. What happened to the Black community in Tulsa, this pogrom? I mean, it's not something I learned about in school. Same goes for a lot of Americans.
Hannibal Johnson
I think it was the release of the report by the Riot Commission in 2001. It's not I don't think it's recent events. I mean, there's renewed attention. More people are learning about the history.
Jamil Smith
But there was a great deal of attention given to that report, international attention to the report in 2001. And that's when curriculum began to change, when public discourse began to include this, when people in Tulsa began to talk about how do we repair the damage that remains from the massacre?
Hannibal Johnson
What is the legacy of the massacre? These types of questions.
Jamil Smith
So recent events obviously have broadened the acknowledgement of these events. And popular culture, the Watchmen and Lovecraft Country, their use of this history as part of their narrative arc has been important because it's a gateway for people to begin to learn about the actual history.
Hannibal Johnson
You're going to go with Heck and Lydia and they're going to get you someplace safe. How are you doing, Joe? We're going to be right behind you. Okay.
Jamil Smith
And the fact, of course, the 100th anniversary of the massacre has drawn incredible media attention. It's yet another opportunity for us to leverage this history to create positive change in the community and uplift what was once a destroyed community, physically destroyed, the Greenwood District, Black Wall Street.
Hannibal Johnson
In Oklahoma, we also have there's the House Bill 1775 that bans teachers from teaching certain concepts of race and racism. And of course, there are similar efforts by lawmakers in Republican-led states across the country trying to keep people from... I mean, we use the term critical race theory, but really the heart of it is that they're trying to get people to stop thinking critically and learning about how this country's past influenced the present.
Jamil Smith
As you mentioned, is the effect of these laws more to really just completely erase the history or to intimidate people from even thinking critically about it?
Hannibal Johnson
Both. The Oklahoma law, House Bill 1775, it's mainly problematic because it's ambiguous. Because teachers it's not clear that teachers will be able to discern what's permitted and what's proscribed. And because of that uncertainty, it's likely that the law is going to have a chilling effect on teachers. They're going to not teach things that they think might be problematic, whether they're told they can or not.
Jamil Smith
They're still going to have some doubt as long as the law is on the books. And if they do teach things that they think might be problematic, that they there's a substantial risk that they will teach it on such a superficial level that it won't be meaningful and won't be won't be an honest, vigorous, robust discussion. That's the problem with this legislation.
Hannibal Johnson
We've been talking about the ways that in which the history of Tulsa in this event were suppressed. Why do you think it's important to remember this history? Is remembering the history enough? It's necessary but not sufficient.
Jamil Smith
So, and why is remembering the history important?
Hannibal Johnson
Ask people in the Jewish community why remembering the Holocaust is important. It's no different. It's no different. I think the universal point of all this is that we must recognize our shared humanity. We must recognize our shared humanity. We ignore that imperative at our own peril.
Jamil Smith
So if we recognized our shared humanity, The Holocaust would not have happened. If we recognized our shared humanity, The 1921 Tulsa race massacre would not have happened. If we recognized our shared humanity, there wouldn't have been lynching in the United States. All these things are connected and they're connected by the way that we relate one to another and the dignity and respect we accord one another.
Hannibal Johnson
And it is hoped that through teaching this history and teaching the causative factors that bleed into this history, we avoid future missteps. There's certainly no guarantee that we will, but that's the hope.
Jamil Smith
Hannibal Johnson is the author of Black Wall Street 100, an American city grapples with its historical racial trauma.
Announcer voice
Announcer
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Jamil Smith
Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and, of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
Announcer voice
Announcer
From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look. Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
Jamil Smith
Congressman Hank Johnson, representing Georgia's 4th District, introduced the Tulsa Greenwood Massacre Claims Accountability Act, legislation that would give the victims and their descendants another shot at restitution.
Hank Johnson
The surviving residents at Greenwood couldn't get back the lives they'd lost, but they tried to get compensation for all the property and businesses that had been destroyed. They filed insurance claims and lawsuits against the city, but very few people were ever paid.
Jamil Smith
In fact, this massacre was investigated early on by a state grand jury, which concluded that it was a race riot, and the race riot was precipitated by the Black people whose community got burned.
Hank Johnson
And so based on that finding, all of the claims that were filed by the Greenwood victims, they were denied any kind of insurance coverage and, of course, any kind of compensation for what had happened to them.
Jamil Smith
Why do we need legislation as a remedy to this problem?
Hank Johnson
Under the law, a case can be time-barred because one waited too long in order to assert the claim. And so it's a technical defense that's available to every defendant who gets sued. And so we have to have a law that would waive that statute of limitations, period. Not for any reason other than the fact that the delay was induced by fraud.
Jamil Smith
And it was not at the fault of the plaintiffs that they could not assert their claims in a timely manner. It was because of state action. So we need to undo that state action. And also give these claimants an opportunity to claim damage under law that did not exist at the time.
Hank Johnson
And of course, this legislation opens the federal courthouse doors, not the state courthouse, but the federal courthouse doors for litigation by these claimants.
Jamil Smith
Right. I think that's an important distinction that you make here is that you're not guaranteeing any kind of reparation here. You're just simply opening up the available avenues. People can pursue this accountability through the courts.
Hank Johnson
That's exactly right. This legislation is not about an award of reparation. It's about opening the courthouse doors so that the claimants can go into court and in accordance with the law, assert their claims for damages.
Jamil Smith
And the damages that flow from what happened 100 years ago can be quantified. And so the personal property, the real estate, the lives of the people themselves who were killed, the descendants of those who were killed have causes of action to assert for the value of the life of those who were killed.
Hank Johnson
And then when you start talking about the generational wealth, these descendants could have benefited through generational wealth transfer, which did not happen as a result of everything going up in smoke and being denied compensation at the outset.
Jamil Smith
So for all of these years, you can quantify the effects of the loss, and they would be, in my opinion, substantial.
Hank Johnson
Is there support in Congress for your bill, in particular amongst Republicans in the House and in the Senate?
Jamil Smith
I don't think we have any Republican co-sponsors in the House. And we're still working on a leader in the Senate to sponsor this legislation there. But momentum is building in the House.
Hank Johnson
Every day we get more and more co-sponsors.
Jamil Smith
Congressman, you held a hearing on this legislation a couple weeks ago, and you heard the testimony, as we all did, from three centenarians who shared their remembrances of surviving the Tulsa massacre.
Hank Johnson
Yeah, their testimony was poignant. Mr. Van— You're talking about the veteran? Yes. He actually got choked up during his testimony a hundred years later. And he is still visibly affected by what happened to him.
Jamil Smith
We aren't just black and white pictures on a screen. We are flesh and blood. I was there when it happened. I'm still here.
Hank Johnson
That's right. And the ladies who testified reminded me of the elderly people in my family that I have known, my grandmothers, you know, my aunts, and how they used to sit on the back porch and talk about things. But then when we came around, the young people, they would shush up and stop talking and they never let us know what they were talking about. But we found out later what had happened.
Jamil Smith
The night of the massacre, I was awakened by my family. My parents and five siblings were there. I was told we had to leave and that was it. I will never forget the violence of the white mob when we left our home.
Hank Johnson
I still see black men being shot, black bodies lying in the street. I still smell smoke and sea fire. I still see black businesses being burned. I still hear airplanes flying overhead. I hear the screams. I have lived through the massacre every day. Our country may forget this history, but I cannot.
Jamil Smith
You know, it was really a strong sense of appreciation for what these folks have been through, what they have endured and what they have accomplished in their time on this earth.
Hank Johnson
And for them to be able to appear before Congress in a hearing that was televised to the nation. And I felt, you know, it was deeply motivating for me and I'm sure for my colleagues who were there with me.
Jamil Smith
Thank you very much, Congressman. I appreciate your time and I appreciate your work on the behalf of these survivors.
Hank Johnson
Yes, sir. You have a great day and thank you for allowing me to be on today.
Jamil Smith
Filling in for Sean Rameswaram, I'm Jamil Smith. It's Today Explained.