Main Topic: The 2018 Mexican presidential election and the implications of Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador's victory.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Johnny Harris, the last time we spoke, you were in Hong Kong checking out some epic views of the harbor, yeah?
Johnny Harris
Yeah, that was amazing. And you had your getquip.com slash explained purchased toothbrush, and you were on the cusp of like this huge personal breakthrough of brushing your teeth two times a day. Yeah, big toothbrush revolution for me, for sure.
Sean Rameswaram
Have things gone well since?
Johnny Harris
Yeah, well, Hong Kong was amazing, and I'm back now editing the Borders videos that we'll be publishing in a couple weeks. Excellent. I'm a little bit downtrodden because something happened with my quip while I was in Hong Kong. Yeah.
Sean Rameswaram
Oh, no. I'm actually kind of embarrassed to come out and say it, but yeah, something pretty bad happened with my quip.
Mexico just had its biggest election ever. Not just because of the stakes or the gravity of this moment for Mexico. It was literally the biggest. Well over 3,000 seats were up for grabs this time, including the throne, the presidency.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
But that particular race? Not exactly suspenseful. As a race, it was boring because the leading candidate was so far ahead that, you know, the most interesting part in that regard was the fight for the second place, which in a presidential system like Mexico, it's pretty much irrelevant.
Sean Rameswaram
Carlos Bravo Regidor is a professor at the Center for Research and Teaching in Economics. It's in Mexico City. Yet, if we think about the election, not in terms of the horse race, but actually in terms of the field where the horses were running, that's when things got interesting, to put it mildly.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
We had, you know, one episode where Mexico's Justice Department intervened directly in the race to try to damage one of the candidates, Ricardo Anaya, from the center-right coalition. He had a momentum, he was growing. And then the Justice Department, without an actual legal file to back it up, accused him of being involved in a money laundering scheme back in the day.
Sean Rameswaram
This was huge. It was all over the media. And it really damaged his chances. Then we had, you know, another issue, which was violence against politicians. In Mexico, running for office can be very dangerous. A bit over 110 politicians were murdered during the campaign.
This surveillance video shows Mexican congressional candidate Fernando Puro posing for a selfie with a supporter after a campaign debate last Friday when a man walks up from behind, raises a gun, and fires point-blank at the back of his head.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
This is how organized crime votes, in a way. They decide who gets in the ballot and who doesn't. And even when people are on the ballot, if they don't like them, well, they threaten them and sometimes they kill them.
Sean Rameswaram
And the last thing, I think, related to the field of the race was the prevalence of fake news and disinformation. Researchers say that they have found a host of Facebook pages that are attacking the leftist frontrunner, Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Okay. I mean, Mexico was a bit in the vanguard of this. There were bot farms in Mexico before there were bot farms in Russia. In addition, there have also been tons of fake news stories circulating. Some say that the pope has criticized the leftist, Andres Manuel López Obrador, and others falsely claim that Ricardo Anaya, the number two candidate, has endorsed Donald Trump's plan of building the wall.
Sean Rameswaram
This was just like out of control. How did Mexicans feel at this point about the incumbent president, Peña Nieto?
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Well, his popularity is incredibly low. Right now it's around 20 percent. And in many ways, this election became a referendum on Peña Nieto and his party, the PRI. And the results were brutal. The party that won almost 40% in the latest presidential election got around 15%. Oh, wow.
Sean Rameswaram
And I mean, this party lost all gubernatorial races at stake this time around. The Mexican people are sending a message to the PRI and Peña Nieto, and the message is, we can't wait for you guys to leave.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And why were people so disappointed with his party and his leadership? Well, I think it was two things. On the one hand, his government, you know, was full of corruption scandals since the second year.
Sean Rameswaram
Though he campaigned and had an early record as a reformer, corruption scandals and public outcry have sparked a political crisis for the Mexican leader.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And these were nonstop corruption scandals. Every week we would hear about a scheme to launder money, a scheme, you know, to deviate resources. And this going up the ladder until, you know, it reached the very president himself.
Sean Rameswaram
And then there the issue of violence of course I mean I think the most known episode of this administration was the 43 of Ayotzinapa the students that disappeared
Carlos Bravo Regidor
For more than three months now we followed the terrible mystery of what happened to 43 college students who disappeared in Mexico Tonight, there are troubling new questions about what the government in Mexico City may have known when those young people vanished.
Sean Rameswaram
And then we ended up knowing that the police have turned them to a narco, to an organized crime gang, and they killed them and they disappeared them.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And, you know, the amount of violence in this administration has, you know, reached record levels. Poverty is still an issue. Inequality is still an issue. Economic growth is very mediocre.
Sean Rameswaram
So, who won this presidential election yesterday?
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Andres Manuel López Obrador won by a landslide. He is the first president in the history of Mexican democracy to get over 50 percent of the vote.
Sean Rameswaram
To remind our American listeners, Mexico is a presidential democracy with a multi-party system. So in contrast with the U.S. that only has two parties and where, you know, most of the time one candidate would get almost automatically over 50 percent.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
This is López Obrador's third time around. He was candidate for president in 2006 and in 2012. He lost both elections. He didn't recognize his defeat.
Sean Rameswaram
Leftist Mexican presidential candidate Andrés Manuel López Obrador is calling for Mexico's electoral tribunal to cancel the results of the July 1st election, claiming they were not free and authentic as the Constitution requires.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Not only did he refuse to accept the results, He held a gigantic alternative inauguration ceremony in Mexico City, in which he was sworn in with a fake sash and declared himself the legitimate president of Mexico.
Sean Rameswaram
So he became, you know, very famous as a sort of a sore loser. OK. And this time around, he really cleaned the clock of his adversaries. And not only in the presidential election, but also in the gubernatorial races. And in Congress, his party has the largest legislative contingent, both on the Senate and the lower chamber.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
None of the other parties had a strong showing. So there's, on the one hand, a new hegemony of López Obrador's party. And on the other hand, a very fragmented opposition.
Sean Rameswaram
What was López Obrador's platform? What was he running on and what connected with the Mexican people?
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Well, this is interesting because this points us towards the typical question of why did he win this time around? Yeah. Lopez Obrador has always been a man of the left. He's very concerned with social policy, with the poor, with the underserved, with the forgotten, the marginalized.
Sean Rameswaram
Number two, he always relies on popular mobilization. You know, he's a street politician, which in Mexico has become like a sort of a rare thing.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And López Obrador is also a nationalist. I would say even a populist in some of his stances. He has always been a man of the left. But in this electoral cycle, apparently there was a learning process within López Obradorismo.
Sean Rameswaram
In the other elections, he openly identified himself as a man of the left. And this time around, he didn't. He adopted a much more moderate and conciliatory tone.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
He toned down, you know, some of his proposals. He's a leftist candidate, for instance, who openly said that he would not raise taxes.
Sean Rameswaram
So it seems that López Obrador this time finally, you know, made his peace with the fact that Mexican voters are a lot more conservative than he had thought previously.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
So he found this formula for, you know, still being a man of the left, but becoming a sort of conservative left.
Sean Rameswaram
Progressives have this idea that we need to change society, you know, and conservatives are much more traditional. They don't really want to change who we are.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
So López Obrador is a man of the left because he's very critical, you know, of neoliberalism, of market economy. but he is conservative because he doesn't want Mexicans to become something different.
Sean Rameswaram
He has played the card of the outsider. He speaks like an outsider sometimes. He even looks like an outsider. But, you know, truth be said, he has never been a true outsider.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
He was a man of the system for a couple of decades, and then he became, you know, a man of the opposition, but of the institutional, official opposition.
Sean Rameswaram
So he has found this very effective and successful formula where he is the outsider from within.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador played the outsider card and won in Mexico even if he really wasn't an outsider.
Sean Rameswaram
So how he going to get along with the actual outsider the ultimate outsider his neighbor to the north? That's in a minute on Today Explained.
Johnny, before we go, I mean, is there a chance that the reason you lost your quip is because it is so well designed, that it's so smooth and compact and felt that it just slipped out of something or, you know, like?
Johnny Harris
That's a pretty good theory that the design is just too sleek, just too sleek. And it just, it just slipped through the cracks.
Sean Rameswaram
Although they, they remedy this because it comes in this carrying case, this capsule. That's I think you're supposed to put it in there while you're traveling.
Johnny Harris
I didn't do that. Oh, yeah. And it just, it just slipped through the cracks.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry for your loss.
Johnny Harris
It's okay. At least I can get a discount on a new one. If I, if I so decide get quip.com, slash explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Isn't that great? That gives me a little bit of solace here for sure.
Not that they're disposable or anything, Johnny. You're supposed to hold on to them.
Johnny Harris
I'll keep that in mind for the next one.
Sean Rameswaram
So, Carlos, you mentioned there was a lot of violence in this campaign, that violence was one of the biggest issues on the minds of Mexican voters.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
What can López Obrador do about violence in Mexico? What does he pledge to do and what can he actually do?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, López Obrador was very successful in portraying himself as an alternative. You know, for around 12 years, we've had governments of different parties, but that have stuck with the same vision regarding violence, focused on putting people in jail, of mobilizing the army, of mobilizing the police.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And the thing with this is that violence levels have gone up and the punitive strategy is not working. There's no peace for the families of the more than 30,000 Mexicans who were murdered last year and the equal number who are still missing, records that are expected to be surpassed this year.
Sean Rameswaram
So López Obrador became, during this campaign, like a very vocal critic of the punitive consensus. And instead of focusing on, you know, putting more people in jail, he proposed to focus on the social roots of violence and of crime.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
This is, of course, a very lefty vision. What he's saying is that, you know, a lot of people joined drug trafficking gangs or organized crime because they've become their only vehicle of social mobility.
Sean Rameswaram
There are regions of the country that are very poor, where people have, you know, very few years of schooling, very few opportunities, marginalized.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And according to López Obrador, what we need to do, you know, is to strengthen our social policy, really make a dent on poverty, reduce inequality, and then, you know, with that, open up avenues of social mobility that do not, you know, push people, so to speak, to the ranks of organized crime.
Sean Rameswaram
For instance, poor peasants in the mountains of Guerrero, a state in the south, you know, that cultivate poppy. They're incredibly poor, incredibly isolated.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
What Lopez Obrador is saying is these people don't belong in jail. This sounds smart, but the thing is a policy like this is going to take a long time, you know, to deliver its fruits.
Sean Rameswaram
And in the meantime, you still have to deal with the fact that there are armed, dangerous, very aggressive gangs around the country.
I wonder how else you resonated for Mexican voters. You know, Mexico has one of the biggest wealth gaps in the West. Did he say anything about that since he does have sort of this populist bent?
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Yes, in a way López Obrador is an old-fashioned politician and he speaks more about poverty than about inequality.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, he's not an ideologue. He is a man of slogans and of formulas, so to speak.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And one of his most known formulas is Por el bien de todos, primero los pobres. We'll listen to everyone, we'll respect everyone, but our priority is the poor. for the good of everyone, the poor first.
Sean Rameswaram
And, you know, Mexico's economy has been growing at very mediocre rates. Democracy was supposed to bring prosperity, and it really hasn't, to the degree at least, that people expected.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
So López Obrador, I think that's another one of the issues where his message really has resonated you know with Mexican voters
Sean Rameswaram
Mexico is in a way one of the biggest issues in the United States right now Our border with Mexico the president immigration policies I wonder, how much did the United States factor into the Mexican election?
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Well, this is such an important question. I've read so much about this in the American press. And I can tell you confidently that the U.S. was not really an issue in this election.
Sean Rameswaram
Mexico has many and very pressing domestic problems, corruption and impunity, violence, poverty and inequality. To put it somehow, we were not really that into you guys this time around.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
And the way the United States press seemed to be portraying López Obrador was, you know, he's Mexico's version of Trump. He's a reaction to Trump.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, was there any truth to that? OK, so there's this idea. I've seen it float around that López Obrador is Mexico's answer to Donald Trump.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
I can tell you quite confidently, and to put it in very polite terms, that that's fucking bullshit.
Sean Rameswaram
Lopez Obrador has been around since way before Trump was even in the political radar.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
He was Major of Mexico City, which is a very important post, from 2000 to 2005. He was a presidential frontrunner in 2006 and 2012.
Sean Rameswaram
So his win might coincide with Trump's ascendancy, yes, but, you know, López Obrador's popularity comes from way, way before Donald Trump was even around.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Now, regarding the comparisons, López Obrador is not anti-American in the way that Donald Trump is indeed anti-Mexican.
Sean Rameswaram
López Obrador is also not a nativist or even a xenophobe. He has never said things that would be comparable on any scale or by any degree with Trump's anti-immigrant or anti-Muslim rhetoric.
It seems like a lot of this will hinge on relationships. Peña Nieto and Trump had a pretty contentious one.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
Do you think the election of López Obrador is a chance for Mexico and the U.S. to hit reset?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, I think López Obrador is a lot more nationalistic than Peña Nieto. But at the same time, nobody wants the Mexican president to enter into a fight with the American president.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
So he might just trying to contain the worst impulses of Donald Trump. But I don't think he's going to try to develop a relationship with him.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, this is something that we Mexicans have come to learn. When Donald Trump speaks about Mexico, he's not really speaking about actually existing Mexico or Mexicans.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
He's talking about this country that exists in his electoral basis minds, you know, that is a threat that is taking advantage of the U.S., that is flooding, you know, America with immigrants.
Sean Rameswaram
That country really doesn't exist. The migration rate has gone down to a point where now the balance between the U.S. and Mexico is negative.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
More people are crossing the border each year towards the south than towards the north.
Sean Rameswaram
If you're concerned about a presidential election disruptive for the Mexico-U.S. relationship, you don't need to look at the 2018 Mexican presidential election.
Carlos Bravo Regidor
You need to look at the American presidential election in 2016.
Sean Rameswaram
And whatever effect Lopez Obrador election has in U.S.-Mexico relations is anecdotal at best compared with the effect that Donald Trump's election already has.
Carlos Bravo Regidor teaches at the Center for Economic Research and Teaching in Mexico City.
I'm Sean Rameswaram. This is Today Explained.